(DIR) Return Create A Forum - Home --------------------------------------------------------- IL2 Air Combat! (HTM) https://il2freemodding.createaforum.com --------------------------------------------------------- ***************************************************** (DIR) Return to: IL2 AC's 'Modern Military' Discussion Board' ***************************************************** #Post#: 16312-------------------------------------------------- French Foreign Legion By: Beowolff Date: March 5, 2021, 4:41 am --------------------------------------------------------- [center] (HTM) https://i.postimg.cc/C11MM6y1/d10a65ffc44d4c3a9d2caa1af4a8c7f1.jpg[/center] [center]The French Foreign Legion[/center] Ah, the Foreign Legion! Of course this dredges up old memories of myself as a kid watching those old black and white shows on TV, those old movies... of gallant and brave Legionnaires bravely marching through the burning desert always under threat of attack by brutal tribesmen just over the next sand dune! Oh how 'I' wanted to join up with them! But of course I wasn't eligible as a kid of five or six, eh? LOL! ;D (HTM) https://i.postimg.cc/PrxSTWFq/b08091164c4126245c8e4dab169563e3.jpg Those were the days of big dreams...my childhood...for stuck on a hard scrabble farm/ranch where I was expected to work like a grown man even at the tender age of four didn't leave me a whole lot of 'fun' to have. I had to 'steal' time to play and just be a kid and so such adventuresome, romantic ideas of gallant Legionnaires (and cowboys and Indians and such) always filled my head in what little spare time I had to play. Of course true life wasn't so glamorous as my daydreams/imagination would have it. The Legionnaires had it rough, very rough, especially in the early days and it's still no cakewalk today. (HTM) https://i.postimg.cc/wTMYZsXX/2ab6c170245384849152fbee370a0ed8.jpg (HTM) https://i.postimg.cc/jjr9xW7k/7fafa63028a3c35ae59f5025c4970956.jpg {Source Wiki) [font=sans-serif]Since 1831, the Legion has consisted of hundreds of thousands in active service at its peak, and suffered the aggregated loss of nearly 40,000 men[/font][sup][font=sans-serif][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Foreign_Legion#cite_note-11][color=#0645ad][11][/iurl][/font][/color][/sup][font=sans-serif]<br />in [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/France][font=sans-serif]France[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Algeria][font=sans-serif]Algeria[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morocco][font=sans-serif]Morocco[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunisia][font=sans-serif]Tunisia[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madagascar][font=sans-serif]Madagascar[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Africa][font=sans-serif]West<br />Africa[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif], [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mexico][font=sans-serif]Mexico[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italy][font=sans-serif]Italy[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crimea][font=sans-serif]Crimea[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spain][font=sans-serif]Spain[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-China][font=sans-serif]Indo-China[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norway][font=sans-serif]Norway[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syria][font=sans-serif]Syria[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chad][font=sans-serif]Chad[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zaïre][font=sans-serif]Zaïre[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lebanon][font=sans-serif]Lebanon[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_Africa][font=sans-serif]Central<br />Africa[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif], [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gabon][font=sans-serif]Gabon[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuwait][font=sans-serif]Kuwait[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rwanda][font=sans-serif]Rwanda[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Djibouti][font=sans-serif]Djibouti[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />former [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yugoslavia][font=sans-serif]Yugoslavia[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somalia][font=sans-serif]Somalia[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Congo][font=sans-serif]Republic<br />of Congo[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif], [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivory_Coast][font=sans-serif]Ivory<br />Coast[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif], [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afghanistan][font=sans-serif]Afghanistan[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mali][font=sans-serif]Mali[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />as well as others. The French Foreign Legion was primarily use d to help protect and expand the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_colonial_empire][font=sans-serif]French<br />colonial empire[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] during the 19th century. The Foreign Legion was initially stationed only in [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Algeria][font=sans-serif]Algeria[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />where it took part in the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacification_of_Algeria][font=sans-serif]pacification[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif]<br />and development of the colony. Subsequently, the Foreign Legio n was deployed in a number of conflicts, including the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Carlist_War][font=sans-serif]First<br />Carlist War[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] in 1835, the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crimean_War][font=sans-serif]Crimean<br />War[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] in 1854, the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Italian_War_of_Independence][font=sans-serif]Second<br />Italian War of Independence[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] in 1859, the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_intervention_in_Mexico][font=sans-serif]French<br />intervention in Mexico[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] in 1863, the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franco-Prussian_War][font=sans-serif]Franco-Prussian<br />War[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] in 1870, the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tonkin_Campaign][font=sans-serif]Tonkin<br />Campaign[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] and [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-French_War][font=sans-serif]Sino-French<br />War[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] in 1883, supporting growth of the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_colonial_empire][font=sans-serif]French<br />colonial empire[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] in [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-Saharan_Africa][font=sans-serif]Sub-Saharan<br />Africa[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif], the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Franco-Dahomean_War][font=sans-serif]Second<br />Franco-Dahomean War[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] in 1892, th e [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Madagascar_expedition][font=sans-serif]Second<br />Madagascar expedition[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] in 1895 a nd the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandingo_Wars][font=sans-serif]Mandingo<br />Wars[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] in 1894. In [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_I][font=sans-serif]World<br />War I[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif], the Foreign Legion fough t in many critical battles on the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Front_(World_War_I)][font=sans-serif]Western<br />Front[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif]. It played a smaller role in World War II than in World War I, though having a part in the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norwegian_Campaign][font=sans-serif]Norwegian[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syria-Lebanon_Campaign][font=sans-serif]Syrian[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif]<br />and [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_African_Campaign][font=sans-serif]North<br />African[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] campaigns. During the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Indochina_War][font=sans-serif]First<br />Indochina War[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] (1946–1954), the Foreign Legion saw its numbers swell. The Legion lost a large number of men in the (for them) catastrophic [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Dien_Bien_Phu][font=sans-serif]Battle<br />of Dien Bien Phu[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif] against forces of the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viet_Minh][font=sans-serif]Viet<br />Minh[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif]. [/font]{source quote end} So, as you can see from the above, the Legion has never had it easy... they've been thrown into combat all over the world in the hottest of hot spots, they've been marched into slaughter time and time again and for the most part (no matter the good or bad of the political situation driving them) they've performed magnificently. Go here for more historic (wiki) information: [iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Foreign_Legion]French<br />Foreign Legion - Wikipedia[/iurl] Modern Legionnaires continue that trend from what I can tell/read/hear about. Now how do 'I' feel or what do 'I' (as an adult) feel about the Legion? Well, I know they've not always been used wisely, many times they've simply been the French Government's Enforcers rather than Defenders... I get that. I also get that 'most' military forces around the world has been used similarly from time to time. (Sadly enough.) That's the way of life, I suppose. Military units may not 'be' political (well, until recently anyway) but the military has always been stuck with having to do the political whims (good or bad) of governments and politicians since time immortal. I doubt if it'll ever change. I still feel an excitement about the Foreign Legion...to this day! Ha! Their [font=Roboto, sans-serif]Esprit de Corps has always been and still is one of their main linchpins/attractions for me. Of course they've 'still' got the coolest uniforms and some darn exotic/cool looking weapons too. Too old and too fat now to be a gob-smacked 'good-looking' Legionnaire I still 'imagine' myself marching along through the desert with them though...lol! Here is a link to an official site: [iurl= (HTM) https://www.legion-etrangere.com/]LEGION ETRANGERE (legion-etrangere.com)[/iurl][/font] A map showing recent and current Legion deployments and other info: (HTM) http://foreignlegion.inf o/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/operation-barkhane-map-20 17.jpg A link to more current info on the Legion: [iurl= (HTM) http://foreignlegion.inf o/2018/03/29/foreign-legion-overseas-deployments-2018/]Foreign Legion: Overseas Deployments 2018 | French Foreign Legion Information[/iurl] These guys are superbly trained combat soldiers, certainly I respect them immensely. I (as you might have already noted) haven't always agreed with the political aspects of their deployments...yet I have and still do feel they are a powerful force (usually) for good in this world. Certainly they are no one to mess with when it comes to hot combat! Discussion on this subject is VERY welcome, as are comments and shooting the breeze conversation. Please join in and let us know your views, thoughts, opinions here. S! Beo #Post#: 16317-------------------------------------------------- Re: French Foreign Legion By: Dreamk Date: March 5, 2021, 5:10 am --------------------------------------------------------- The whole size of the Foreign Legion is less than 9000 men. Most of the French troops operating in the Sahel area are not Foreign Legion but regular French army units. The Foreign legion is made of 8 regiments (including 1 paratroop regt, 1 cavalry regt, 2 engineers regt , 2 infantry regt and 2 non-combat regt that can serve in case of need as combat support units) and a "half-brigade" (an expanded motorized infantry regt operating in support of a light armour regular French regiment to which it is integrated - roughly on the model of the panzergrenadier units. The Paratroop regiment and the 2 Infantry regiments are, together with the 3rd marine Infantry Regiment, the best troops of the French army - some say the only good troops, and in fact till the intervention in Sahel they were the only French troops with operational experience - The growing needs of troops for the French intervention there has demanded huge changes in the training of other regular French army units so as to bring them to an acceptable operational status, an objective which seems to have been reached in the last two years, that have seen a drastic increase in the professionalism of French soldiers involved in the Sahel operations - but also of their losses as they are now directly involved in active fighting. #Post#: 16318-------------------------------------------------- Re: French Foreign Legion By: Beowolff Date: March 5, 2021, 9:01 am --------------------------------------------------------- Excellent information, DK! 8) Thank you for your comment and response! 9000 men seems such a small amount for the firepower they can put out, eh! For people unfamiliar with the name Sahel, here is more info: [font=Roboto, Helvetica, sans-serif]The Sahel is the ecoclimatic and biogeographic realm of transition in Africa between the Sahara to the north and the Sudanian savanna to the south. Having a semi-arid climate, it stretches across the south-central latitudes of Northern Africa between the Atlantic Ocean and the Red Sea. Link to Wiki pages info- [iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sahel#cite_note-38]Sahel - Wikipedia[/iurl][/font] [font=Roboto, Helvetica, sans-serif] (HTM) https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c1/Camels_in_Chad.png[/font] [font=Linux Libertine, Georgia, Times, serif]Instability and violence (from wiki)[/font] [font=sans-serif]Terrorist organizations including [iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boko_Haram][color=#0645ad]Boko<br />Haram[/iurl] and [iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Qaeda_in_the_Islamic_Maghreb]Al-Qaeda<br />in the Islamic Maghreb[/iurl] (AQIM) operating in the Sahel ha ve contributed to the violence, extremism and instability of the region.[/font][/color] [font=sans-serif]The violent [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herder–farmer_conflicts_in_Nigeria][font=sans-serif]herder–farmer<br />conflicts in Nigeria[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif], [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/March_2019_attacks_against_Fulani_herders][font=sans-serif]Mali[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif],<br />[/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sudanese_nomadic_conflicts][font=sans-serif]Sudan[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif]<br />and other countries in the Sahel region have been exacerbated by climate change, land degradation, and [/font][font=sans-serif][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_growth]population<br />growth[/iurl].[/font][font=sans-serif] Droughts and food shortages have been also linked to the [/font][iurl= (HTM) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northern_Mali_conflict][font=sans-serif]Northern<br />Mali conflict[/font][/iurl][font=sans-serif].[/font] [font=Roboto, Helvetica, sans-serif]French forces there: (HTM) https://i.postimg.cc/q7nzYSkf/Frances-Operation-Barkhane-1024x765.jpg[/font] [font=Roboto, Helvetica, sans-serif] (HTM) https://i.postimg.cc/NjvMXb6p/b98c076d9b62a0ff24bb4c210b9d1b6bc4179993.jpg[/font] #Post#: 16320-------------------------------------------------- Re: French Foreign Legion By: Cashmere_Dave Date: March 5, 2021, 3:19 pm --------------------------------------------------------- From memory, there was a time in the early 1980s when they were banned from training with the French army. The Army soldiers sustained too many inuries. ;) #Post#: 16324-------------------------------------------------- Re: French Foreign Legion By: Beowolff Date: March 5, 2021, 6:31 pm --------------------------------------------------------- [quote author=Cashmere_Dave link=topic=2275.msg16320#msg16320 date=1614979144] From memory, there was a time in the early 1980s when they were banned from training with the French army. The Army soldiers sustained too many inuries. ;) [/quote] I heard that too but have no idea if it's true... anybody for sure on that or is it just people talking? 8) #Post#: 16330-------------------------------------------------- Re: French Foreign Legion By: Beowolff Date: March 6, 2021, 8:19 am --------------------------------------------------------- Looks like the old FAMAS (and newer modified versions) along with HK's are the standard rifles of the Legion. Nice weapons. I have fired a FAMAS (and thought it a grand weapon), I've not shot the HK but there's little doubt it's a quality weapon. [iurl= (HTM) http://foreignlegion.inf o/equipment/#:~:text=French Foreign Legion Weapons PA MAC 50 PA,(MAC)%2C thereafter by Manufacture d’Armes de Saint-Étienne (MAS).]Equipment | French Foreign Legion Information[/iurl] (HTM) https://i.postimg.cc/BncWMpGM/f1famas30.jpg #Post#: 16332-------------------------------------------------- Re: French Foreign Legion By: Dreamk Date: March 6, 2021, 10:46 am --------------------------------------------------------- The French army underwent a drastic change in the end-80s: they stooped being a conscription army ('people army"), the army being from now on a smaller professional army. The conscription army was fully ineffective (what can you do with masses of conscripts, staying only 12 months overall under the flag, beyond basic training) - and the combined training exercises involving both such conscripted units and professional units like the Foreign legion, resulted in a high level of accidental injuries (or worse), as could be expected - thus the ensuing logical decision to keep these units training separately. The French army of today is much more efficient for intervention in small conflicts (but of course totally unsuited to a full war situation) - implementing the model of training and logistics of the Foreign legion but also the branches integration seen in the US marines - this can bee seen on the map of the Barkane operation were armor, helicopters, engineers, logistic and infantry are integrated in a fighting force. The Air force remains the weakest point of the French army, and will apparently remain so in the coming years. #Post#: 16335-------------------------------------------------- Re: French Foreign Legion By: Beowolff Date: March 6, 2021, 10:56 am --------------------------------------------------------- Again, great information, DK... thank you. Question though, you mentioned aircraft being a weakness... what is the problem there? France has throughout the years had wonderful and sophisticated military aircraft (especially in the years AFTER WW2) so what has happened there to cause trouble? S! Beo #Post#: 16336-------------------------------------------------- Re: French Foreign Legion By: Dreamk Date: March 6, 2021, 12:50 pm --------------------------------------------------------- [font=Verdana]French air force main mission is still mainly focused on being a strategic nuclear vector - together with the aging ballistic submarines - something still more stressed after the French dismantled their land-based nuclear missile (both strategic and tactic) arm.[/font] [font=Verdana]Close air support has never been seriously developed since the sixties - the Franco-British Jaguar were a return to the failed concept of "vol rasant", once again using a badly armored plane, with an average overall weapon load (the US also implemented at this same period the "vol rasant" concept but with the A-10 which was a "flying tank") and the use of the Mirage F1 in this role were still worse. [/font] [font=Verdana]This is currently the most acute problem of the French air force - the Mirage 2000 is a quite good interceptor but not suited to close air support. And close air support is what is needed for the kind of military operations for which the modern French army is designed.[/font] [font=Verdana]Another huge problem is the logistics branch - still using the short-range short-capacity Transall, they were compelled, for the intervention in Sahel, to ask the US for support by temporary leasing them C-130 Hercules.[/font] [font=Verdana]PS. I see that I forgot the Rafale which is an issue by itself - once again, an aircraft initially designed as a pure fighter with some degree of stealth capability, it underwent a series of successive transformations over the years to become suited to a "multi-figher" role. The result is a fighter roughly equivalent to the F-18, but with a cumbersome (and expensive) maintenance. Maintenance in combat operations is are further questioned while at the looking overall very small numbers of aircraft built (overall 200 produced including 140 for France) - as compared with the over 4600 F16 produced - has the expected result of a permanent strain on replacement stocks (parts and whole aircraft). Maintenance and supply are a classic plague of the French air force: during the short intervention in Lybia, to oust Khaddafi regime (and put a hand over the oil refineries...), the French air force found it soon limited due to...the exhaustion of their stock of bombs, as these are exclusively French produced, and once again in very limited numbers. The re-entry of France in Nato as not improved the situation, as France keeps insisting on using only French designed and built equipment, instead of aligning with Nato standardization.[/font] #Post#: 16350-------------------------------------------------- Re: French Foreign Legion By: Beowolff Date: March 7, 2021, 3:47 am --------------------------------------------------------- [quote author=Dreamk link=topic=2275.msg16336#msg16336 date=1615056634][font=Verdana] The re-entry of France in Nato as not improved the situation, as France keeps insisting on using only French designed and built equipment, instead of aligning with Nato standardization.[/font] [/quote] Yes, I see your point. Perhaps it's the French "vive la différence!" that is getting in the way? :D We have our share of that here too, unfortunately. You mentioned the Rafale, which is a 'very' attractive looking aircraft. I have not studied it's actual effectiveness but from what you say it seems quite powerful and useful, in particular if it could standardize it's armament around the NATO supply chain. [img] (HTM) https://www.fliegerweb.com/data/NewsPictures/Rafale_F3R_Standard_640.jpg?c=8551[/img] Still, effective as a ground attack or not, I suppose it cannot (as you mentioned earlier) replace/take-the-place-of such dedicated ground sluggers as the US A-10 for low, pinpoint, close-in tank/troop/weapon position/etc. strike/attack. Sadly the USA continues to try and get rid of the vaunted A-10 here despite it's continued, provable value in attack/close support. The A-10 survives here... but only because there is nothing to replace it with no matter how much brainless politicians want to do away with it. ***************************************************** (DIR) Next Page