(DIR) Home
Crown appealing acquittal in dangerous driving crash that killed B.C.
child
(HTM) Source
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The BC Prosecution Service is appealing the not-guilty verdict for a
man charged in a tragic crash that killed a Vancouver child.
Seyed Moshfeghi Zadeh was acquitted of dangerous driving causing death
and dangerous driving causing bodily harm on April 9 after a three-day
judge-alone trial in B.C. Provincial Court.
In a notice of appeal filed May 2 in the B.C. Court of Appeal
registry, the Crown is seeking to overturn Judge Kathryn Denhoff's
decision and have convictions entered instead or to have a new trial
ordered.
2:05 Driver acquitted in Vancouver crash that killed baby
According to the court filing, the grounds for appeal are "that the
trial judge erred in law by misconstruing or misapplying the legal
principles governing whether the required mens rea had been proven for
the offences with which the defendant was charged."
Story continues below advertisement
At trial, Moshfeghi Zadeh admitted he ran a red light at a busy
downtown Vancouver intersection on July 6, 2021.
His Ford Escape collided with a McLaren before rolling and striking
Michael Hiiva and his 23-month-old daughter Ocean.
The toddler died and her father was seriously injured.
Moshfeghi Zadeh's lawyer, Robert Dick, argued the incident was a
tragic accident and that his client's failure to see the red light was
inadvertently negligent, but that there was no pattern of bad driving.
Crown prosecutor Brent Anderson said Moshfeghi Zadeh failed to notice
four separate traffic lights that had turned red more than 20 seconds
before the accused entered the intersection of Hornby and Smithe
streets during rush hour.
The judge said the Crown failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt
that Moshfeghi Zadeh's driving was a marked departure from the
standard of care expected of a reasonable person in the same
circumstances.
2:06 Trial of man accused in collision that killed toddler sees
surveillance video
Denhoff found no evidence of any prior pattern of inattentiveness and
ruled that while Moshfeghi Zadeh's momentary lapse of attention had
tragic consequences, it was not a criminal act.
Story continues below advertisement
Lawyer Kyla Lee, who is not connected to the case, said the mens rea,
or criminal intent, for dangerous driving in Canadian law is that a
person's driving is a marked departure from the standard of a
reasonably prudent driver.
"The Crown is saying that the trial judge applied too low of a
standard in determining that dangerous driving hadn't occurred," Lee
told Global News in an interview Tuesday.
"And in saying that running a red light was not a marked departure,
that was the wrong legal analysis and the trial judge placed too much
emphasis effectively on the fact that there was no pattern of bad
driving."
2:19 Understanding the 'Baby Ocean' not guilty verdict
Lee said she suspects the Crown's appeal argument will be that there
doesn't have to be a "pattern" of bad driving to amount to a marked
departure.
Story continues below advertisement
B.C. courts have, in the past, found a driver's inattention can amount
to dangerous driving.
Ken Chung struck and killed Dr. Alphonsus Hui in Vancouver in 2015
while driving 140 km/h in a 50 km/h zone.
The trial judge ruled that Chung's speeding was a "momentary lapse"
and acquitted him of dangerous driving causing death in 2018.
One year later, the B.C. Court of Appeal replaced his acquittal with a
conviction in a ruling later upheld by the Supreme Court of Canada.
Chung was sentenced to 18 months in jail in 2020.
Dick declined an interview but said the trial decision of Judge
Denhoff was well-supported in law and on the facts of the case, and
the Crown appeal will be opposed.
© 2024 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.
______________________________________________________________________
Served by Flask-Gopher/2.2.1