[HN Gopher] Flash Animations Live Forever at the Internet Archive
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Flash Animations Live Forever at the Internet Archive
        
       Author : tosh
       Score  : 166 points
       Date   : 2020-11-19 20:44 UTC (2 hours ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (blog.archive.org)
 (TXT) w3m dump (blog.archive.org)
        
       | jonah-archive wrote:
       | Really excited about this, and so happy we were able to roll it
       | out before Flash's official deprecation at the end of the year.
       | If you have old SWFs you'd like to share, these are the
       | directions for uploading them so that they'll be emulated in-
       | browser:
       | https://bluemaxima.org/flashpoint/datahub/Uploading_SWFs_for...
        
         | [deleted]
        
         | bozzcl wrote:
         | Congrats! Flash games and videos were a huge part of my
         | childhood. It's heartwarming to see people dedicated to
         | preserve such a treasure trove of the older internet.
        
         | Causality1 wrote:
         | So this is real emulation, not just transcription into a video
         | format? The vectorized and infinitely-scalable aspect of Flash
         | is preserved? That's awesome.
        
           | jonah-archive wrote:
           | Yes! See krapp's comment below -- we're using the Ruffle
           | flash emulator targeted to WASM
        
       | sarah180 wrote:
       | Not a flash in the pan after all!
        
       | mortenjorck wrote:
       | The museum-docent write-ups for the featured SWFs are the perfect
       | icing on this archival cake. I never knew there was a debate over
       | the species of onion in Leekspin!
       | 
       | A side note, and perhaps this is down to Safari's imperfect WASM
       | support, but I'm not getting any sound in Safari.
        
       | Borlands wrote:
       | Amazing work as ever from the archive! Thank you and congrats
        
       | dj_mc_merlin wrote:
       | Programming a shitty AS2 "catch the falling object" game with the
       | cheesiest story and uploading it to Newgrounds got me into
       | programming. Might never have if not for Flash.
        
         | catmanjan wrote:
         | Same here - AS2 and the flash movieclip editor had the perfect
         | learning curve for me - I wonder what the current equivalent
         | is, if any
        
           | hobby-coder-guy wrote:
           | Roblox or Minecraft maybe
        
           | k2xl wrote:
           | same here. i got into AS2 in highschool and built many flash
           | games. some people still play them and our sad it won't be
           | playable on chrome by end of the year
        
             | daveslash wrote:
             | Same here. Got into AS1 in high school, back before Adobe
             | acquired Macromedia.
        
       | Confiks wrote:
       | There's an enormous cache of historic SWFs hosted here [1] and it
       | would be awesome if the Internet Archive could archive them, so
       | they won't get lost. However, there are far too many to
       | individually add.
       | 
       | My personal favorites would be the Demented Cartoon Movie [2],
       | Weebl and Bob's transdimensional portal [3] (which is located
       | under the stairs) and of course The End of the World [4]. They
       | all load perfectly in Ruffle [5].
       | 
       | [1] https://locker.phinugamma.org/swf/
       | 
       | [2] SWF:
       | https://locker.phinugamma.org/swf/albinoblacksheep/demented%... |
       | Video: https://www.albinoblacksheep.com/flash/demented
       | 
       | [3]
       | http://www.venue.nu/infusions/the_kroax/uploads/movies/Weebl...
       | 
       | [4] SWF:
       | https://locker.phinugamma.org/swf/albinoblacksheep/end%28www... |
       | Video: https://www.albinoblacksheep.com/flash/end
       | 
       | [5] https://ruffle.rs/demo/
        
       | [deleted]
        
       | vr46 wrote:
       | OMG Internet Archive take my money now, well done, and thank you.
       | 
       | (https://archive.org/donate/ in case anyone else is feeling
       | generous)
        
         | OmarShehata wrote:
         | You should donate to the project making this possible too!
         | 
         | https://github.com/sponsors/Herschel
        
       | [deleted]
        
       | zebracanevra wrote:
       | Hopefully some collaboration can be made between swfchan and the
       | IA. swfchan claims to have 217753 flashes: http://swfchan.com/
       | (Edit: NSFW. Would recommend an adblocker before opening, at
       | least.)
       | 
       | It archives flashes (and their threads!) from /f/ and others. A
       | great historical resource.
       | 
       | The presentation of swfchan may not be for everyone, but it does
       | hold an immense amount of data.
        
         | textfiles wrote:
         | I like how you answered the question of why they're not up yet.
         | But yes, I'd like chan-like flashes to be able to live on in
         | some way.
        
         | simlevesque wrote:
         | watch out I clicked on the first link on swfchan and got a lady
         | furiously masturbating on my screen, at work.
         | 
         | > A great historical resource.
         | 
         | I wouldn't say great. It's a virus nest.
        
       | mcphage wrote:
       | While mini retro consoles are still all the rage, a retro console
       | that has a flash emulator, with a keyboard, mouse, and a vast
       | database of classic SWFs, would be awesome.
        
       | superkuh wrote:
       | What I don't understand is why google is intentionally excluding
       | .swf results from search results. Okay, fine, you don't want it
       | in Chrome that's your choice. But not indexing .swf in your
       | search engine product because you don't support it in your
       | browser product is crazy. It's going out of their way, doing more
       | work, to hurt people.
       | 
       | I guess this is just another example of being unable to count on
       | profit motivated corporations. It's a good thing the IA is trying
       | to help.
        
         | acdha wrote:
         | All major browsers have sunset support for Flash and it's moved
         | behind increasingly strict warnings over the years. Since
         | Google Search is a web application, there's not much value in
         | giving people content they can't use.
        
         | untog wrote:
         | What would Google index? Can you even decipher the contents of
         | a SWF to get keywords out of it?
        
           | siggen wrote:
           | Yes, Adobe publishes SWF specs. You can extract text, links,
           | pictures, etc. out.
        
         | captbaritone wrote:
         | They are not supported in most browsers. Most users are going
         | to have a bad experience if they load a page with Flash, and it
         | makes sense to down-rank pages that will deliver a bad
         | experience.
        
           | superkuh wrote:
           | Most file types are not supported in browsers. Only a few
           | are. A "download file" dialog is not a bad experience.
           | Treating .swf like a normal file type would both be easier
           | and better in all ways.
        
             | spijdar wrote:
             | Flash will not be supported in any of the large browsers
             | after December, limiting access to people who go out of
             | their way to use both a fork that preserves NPAPI or
             | whatever Chromium uses and manually install some version of
             | Flash.
             | 
             | I'm not aware of any search engines that index arbitrary
             | files that the browser or some ubiquitous media viewer
             | can't open. The most annoying I can think of is the
             | occasional powerpoint files I've run across on google, and
             | at least those are usually cached in a browser-friendly
             | format.
             | 
             | It'd be like indexing Adobe CS project files, and requiring
             | a subscription to Adobe to open the search result.
        
       | krapp wrote:
       | Using an open source Flash emulator written in Rust and exported
       | to Webassembly[0].
       | 
       | [0]https://ruffle.rs/
        
         | jchw wrote:
         | As a sidenote, I've taken some brief dives into Ruffle and it
         | looks very good. There's great attention to detail everywhere.
         | I hope it has a long future.
         | 
         | I've previously also taken brief dives into Lightspark and even
         | submitted a minor PR or two. Lightspark is cool, but I feel
         | Ruffle is already surpassing it in regards.
        
       | TedDoesntTalk wrote:
       | All Your Base Are Belong To Us... preserved forever:
       | 
       | https://archive.org/details/flash_allyourbase
        
         | pier25 wrote:
         | _What you say!!_
        
       | pier25 wrote:
       | The End of the World:
       | 
       | https://archive.org/details/endoftheworld_flash
        
         | echelon wrote:
         | I haven't seen this in over a decade. Everything in this
         | Internet Archive collection is bringing back so many memories.
         | 
         | Flash gave creators so much more latitude than YouTube and
         | whatever it is that Steve Jobs wanted for us. We've really lost
         | something.
         | 
         | Facebook, Platforms, ... we had so much more free-form
         | creativity back in the golden era of the web. It's a shame.
         | 
         | Flash, despite not being open source, was really amazing and
         | nothing has filled its place.
        
       | jedberg wrote:
       | I would have been disappointed if their examples didn't include
       | BadgerBadger. And they even have the original version! You can
       | tell because if you let it loop for about 5 minutes the audio and
       | video no longer match.
        
       | roca wrote:
       | What reason is there to believe that Ruffle will succeed where
       | other Flash emulators (Shumway, Swiffy, Lightspark, ...) have
       | (apparently) failed?
        
         | textfiles wrote:
         | I wouldn't say Lightspark has failed at all, they're
         | progressing nicely. Others are too.
         | 
         | I heard a rumor Shumway was abandoned as a project by Mozilla
         | because ex-Adobe engineers were steering the project and Adobe
         | issued concerns; they probably could have been worked out, but
         | you know, Mozilla. Since then, Flash has been end of life'd
         | more aggressively, so I think Shumway could return.
         | 
         | Flash files should be like music or graphic files - playable in
         | a variety of players and items. Even VLC someday, we could
         | hope.
        
       | sixstringtheory wrote:
       | Would love to see the Larry Carlson flash animations make it onto
       | here. I was able to track down the page where they used to live
       | on the wayback machine [0] (some other pages under that domain
       | would also have had some flash animations, too), but don't know
       | how to grab the actual SWFs, if it's even possible any more.
       | 
       | [0]:
       | http://web.archive.org/web/20190803102822/http://trippywonde...
        
       | Aardwolf wrote:
       | Newgrounds is also doing a good job of making many of even their
       | interactive Flash animations compatible with modern browsers,
       | which is great! I hope they'll be able to extend this to the
       | games too
        
       | sillysaurusx wrote:
       | Shoutout to Madness Combat.
       | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H1aubPfepmg
       | 
       | Kids today won't know the pain of not being able to see 50 small
       | stick figures trying to pummel each other at >15fps.
       | 
       | Also Flash was one of the best dev environments in history, in my
       | opinion. More precisely, one of the most _accessible_ , which
       | most dev environments lack.
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2020-11-19 23:00 UTC)