[HN Gopher] A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney... ___________________________________________________________________ A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes Author : rvieira Score : 220 points Date : 2021-01-18 13:42 UTC (9 hours ago) (HTM) web link (github.com) (TXT) w3m dump (github.com) | Borlands wrote: | This looks great! Lacks instructions on how to use it in the | readme, and I wonder could it be adapted for other cartoon | animations? | | A blog post on how it was built would be a great follow-up! | | Kudos to you, sir | godot wrote: | The readme doesn't mention it, but I like that it seems that | anim.py is pretty standalone so you could potentially use it not | just for Reddit comment threads, but pretty much any conversation | at all. | | Also like that it seems fairly easy to modify to use another | prosecutor as the second main character. I know who I'd use! | degurechaff wrote: | I want a danganronpa version too. | yowlingcat wrote: | My sides are splitting. This is the lighthearted use of | technology that I live for. Thanks for making my weekend, OP! And | now to find good subreddits to target... | reilly3000 wrote: | You're all right big guy! | quenix wrote: | That is amazing. | vyrotek wrote: | Fun. Reminds me of Comic Chat. | | Maybe we need a Slack app to make these images for each message? | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Comic_Chat | jcfields wrote: | I forgot all about Comic Chat. It was fun (and also the most | appropriate use of Comic Sans MS ever). | furyofantares wrote: | I believe it's the origin of Comic Sans | tomatotomato37 wrote: | There's this thing which is kinda like that | | https://aceattorneyonline.com/# | namanaggarwal wrote: | I used to get kicked out everytime I converted a group to comic | chat. Those were the days :) | RyJones wrote: | The OG Comic Chat client is available[0]; too bad Slack killed | the irc gateway. | | [0]: http://www.mermeliz.com/cchat.htm | nuodag wrote: | https://www.reddit.com/user/objection-bot | nkg wrote: | I love it | grenoire wrote: | The demo video notes that it uses Phoenix as the most-commenting, | and Edgeworth as the second (and the rest of the cast following | that); in addition, it uses a NLP to determine the tone of the | voice, and mark an _Objection!_ if it 's negative. | | Absolutely genius. | pi-victor wrote: | hilarious af. noice! | pfdietz wrote: | AA illustration of why gcc is so slow. | | https://twitter.com/i/status/1285217798642454531 | pimlottc wrote: | Note that this was created manually, it's not an example of the | bot's output. I was really impressed before I realized that :P | xwdv wrote: | Wow this is a brilliant way to mass produce tons of unique | YouTube videos and get lots of views. I wonder what the ad | revenue is like. | dukeofdoom wrote: | Actually, if there was something that turned a thread into | speech, that I could listen to while doing work around the house, | might be useful. | rebuilder wrote: | Pocket does Text to Speech, IIRC. I think I tried it on reddit | at some point. It turns out the ability to just skip comments | and not read through all the threads in their entirety is | pretty important. | Lorin wrote: | This could be done in browser via native speechSynthesis API. | Maybe there's already an extension out there. | davidscolgan wrote: | I've wondered if the AI superintelligence everyone is watching | out for is actually slowly being built from the bottom up, and | encompasses evening in the entire world. Deep Thought from | Hitchhiker's Guide is seeming more and more plausible to me. | Perhaps this bot that makes Reddit videos doesn't do anything | "useful" per se, but it is doing what a human might otherwise do, | and adds itself to Reddit as an entity that could be | indistinguishable from a person making silly videos. | | What percentage of Reddit comments are bots? I'd be curious to | know. SaaS and Lambda functions and and APIs are all like very | complicated neurons that link together to form this world wide | web of interactions. | | I've wondered if an approach to the AI alignment problem is | really to see that the entirety of all the computers in the world | are a giant brain that is continually self-improving. Phoenix | Wright bot is one neuron, like any other. And so to align the | world AI, you have to align the culture that makes the AI. And | so, basically, anything that one does to improve the culture in a | sense improves AI. | kubanczyk wrote: | > a giant brain that is continually self-improving | | ...nope, does not qualify. If it cannot manage to replicate | itself completely (as in: create another separate 'internet' | capable of further replication) it is as good as a single human | living on Mars. It's a short ride, one small mistake and | goodbye Mr. Superintelligence. (I'm not claiming humans will be | able to survive that though.) | leetcrew wrote: | maybe so, but I don't think this particular program does | anything like AI. glancing at the code, it looks like it just | pastes the full text of a reddit comment into a video template, | using a different template for each unique commenter in the | thread. it no more "does what a human might otherwise do" than | how a sorting algorithm might emulate how I sort my socks. | haolez wrote: | It uses a neural network for sentiment analysis, so it can be | classified as "using AI". | ta1234567890 wrote: | You are spot on. We are so self-centered that we think an AI | superintelligence will be something like superintelligent- | human-mind, when most likely, it will be nothing like a human | and probably completely unrecognizable to us. | | In fact, I'd argue it's already here and already taken over. | | Most of us are now enslaved by screens and the Internet, we are | addicted to them, even if we don't want to admit it. Some might | say these things are run by humans, but are humans really in | charge? Can any single person turn off the internet or prevent | everyone else from using their phones/screens for hours every | day? Is even a group of people capable of doing it? And even if | they could, would they? | | Maybe if humans went extinct, the Internet and screens would | disappear, but that just means there's a symbiotic | relationship, not that we are by any means in control. | fao_ wrote: | > Can any single person turn off the internet or prevent | everyone else from using their phones/screens for hours every | day? | | Google "ICANN" | | https://deadline.com/2020/07/internet-down-outage- | cloudflare... | | https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/25/21719396/amazon-web- | serv... | jwally wrote: | Google: "I CAN" | yissp wrote: | Apparently it's not running anymore, but | https://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditSimulator/ is sort of | apropos. It's an entirely bot-generated subreddit. You can | still read through the old posts. | danbolt wrote: | The first Ace Attorney game must have been incredible value for | Capcom's investment. The spartan, comic-like sprites and | straightforward visual novel gameplay likely fit into a smaller | ROM size. Given the charming narrative, I bet they made their ROI | pretty quickly in the first print run. | csilverman wrote: | Oh my god, this is funny. | | I'd never even heard of the game before this, but the | animation/music is hilarious just on its own. | shmerl wrote: | Check this out: | http://aaonline.fr/search.php?search&criteria[sequenceId-is]... | bombcar wrote: | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rvFk8hapDZY is the link to the | demo (missed it the first time reading the github). | dwighttk wrote: | Too bad it isn't Reddit, I'd love to see the weightlifters | arguing over how many days are in a week. | 3gg wrote: | A true cornerstone in the development of Web 3.0. | slavik81 wrote: | People also do this manually via objection.lol. One of my | favourites is "All odd numbers have an E in them" [1]. | | [1]: https://youtu.be/IFcyYnUHVBA | dharmab wrote: | "Is Lava Wet" is art. | | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sWF_8dw0zdQ | bentcorner wrote: | Also notable: "Is soup a drink?" | | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IDNuz_VFJtU | ArcMex wrote: | You can tell a Lotta Hart went into this. | mensetmanusman wrote: | This will be even more amazing when AI animation and vocals are | auto generated. | rahimnathwani wrote: | Apparently Ace Attorney is a computer game: | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ace_Attorney?wprov=sfla1 | Jommi wrote: | Its a Nintendo DS Game that has grown a cult following ever | since the first game was released. A visual novel style game. | m45t3r wrote: | Actually the original series is from Game Boy Advance, but | the GBA games were never released outside of Japan. | | Nintendo DS ports were the first one releases in the rest of | the world. | | BTW, I am a great fan of the series, really recommend it. | JohnBooty wrote: | Did you know that it's actually a rather pointed | parody/criticism of the Japanese justice system? I had no | idea myself! Perhaps I was the only one who didn't know. | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_justice_system_of_Ja | p... | | The conviction rate in Japan is over _99%_ -- going to | "trial" is essentially the same as being found guilty. | | The prosecuting attorneys have a lot of discretion over | what is prosecuted, and are effectively de facto judges. | They may decide to simply not prosecute a case if they feel | "character, age, environment, gravity of the offense, | circumstances or situation after the offense" makes it | unnecessary. | | So it's easy to imagine there might be some with quite an | ego like Edgeworth or Von Karma -- and a protagonist like | our heroic defense attorney would be quite the unusual | attorney, indeed! I loved the games even without knowing | any of that, but that really makes them all the more | poignant and funny for me. | patwolf wrote: | I recently started playing it on the Switch, and my first | thought was that I hope the Japanese court system isn't | really like this. It makes me appreciate the idea of | "innocent until proven guilty" in the US. Ace Attorney | feels much more "I don't like you, so I'm going to assume | you're guilty unless you have absolute proof that you're | not". | TheDong wrote: | Justice systems are complicated. From what I've read, | it's true that the japanese court system indeed gives | prosecutors more leeway and the trial is more of a | formality. The conviction rate of 99% (vs 70-95% in the | us, depending how you count) speaks to this. | | However, that's not all there is to it. You're still | innocent until proven guilty in Japan. | | There's also probably more in common with the japanese | justice system and the US system than different. In | practice, the majority of cases in both don't go to | trial. In japan, the prosecution will just not prosecute | any case they don't think they'll win (and have broad | leeway to do so). This results in a 99% conviction rate | because, well, there's no reason they can't just drop any | case without rock solid evidence. Even in cases where | they're confident the suspect is guilty, but they don't | think they have enough evidence, they may opt to just | drop the case. | | In the US, similarly, most cases don't go to trial. The | vast majority are also ended under prosecute discretion, | via plea bargains. Both in the US and Japan, most cases | skip the proper court system due to the prosecution | having power to do so. It's just in Japan, the | prosecution also has power to drop the case, while in the | US the prosecution can only skip the courts if they get a | plea deal, but not if the suspect keeps pleading not- | guilty. | | Japan has laws requiring evidence in addition to a | confession due to understanding that police sometimes | force confessions (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal | _justice_system_of_Jap...) | | In america it's routine for people to be convicted on | nothing other than a suspect agreeing to a plea deal even | though they didn't do it. "You can get 1 year in jail and | get back to your family if you take the plea, or you can | risk 30 years in jail if you keep saying not-guilty" | isn't at all unusual in the US system, especially since a | cop's word is often enough for a guilty sentence. | | I'd be happy to be wrong on any of he above details if | anyone has separate experience, understanding, or | sources. | | All that being said, I'd much much rather be arrested in | Japan than in the US. | marzell wrote: | I wonder if this is partly an extension of what you might | call "confirmation culture", which could be described as | a way of avoiding disgrace/humiliation. | | For instance, when applying for a promotion, I've heard | that in Japanese culture it is common to get pre-approval | from various parties beforehand so that it is ensured | before a formal/public application is made; this way, | nobody is disgraced by being turned down. Not sure how | true that is. But it could apply to the justice system in | a similar way; having a high conviction rate means the | justice system is effective, whereas trying someone and | not convicting them might make the justice system look | bad. | pacificat0r wrote: | We need that but foe hn comments | whymauri wrote: | This bot is a lot of fun! Maybe we need an HN clone? :P | meibo wrote: | That wouldn't work, the characters in ace attorney aren't that | passive aggressive ;) | brink wrote: | Well maybe some of us need to fix our attitudes a little | more. | [deleted] | xwdv wrote: | It will work better if you use downvoted comment threads. | [deleted] | Impossible wrote: | You do often win the game by being pedantic and pointing out | small issues that didn't have anything to do with the | original main testimony, so maybe parent is on to something | after all :) | sitkack wrote: | Objection! Don't do that here. | swayvil wrote: | Watched the demo. Impressive. | | It grinds that (all too common) petty drama into sausage. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2021-01-18 23:00 UTC)