[HN Gopher] Feedback Welcome: I am developing an e-paper calenda... ___________________________________________________________________ Feedback Welcome: I am developing an e-paper calendar as a consumer product Author : konschubert Score : 40 points Date : 2021-02-21 19:33 UTC (3 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.invisible-computers.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.invisible-computers.com) | bombcar wrote: | It needs to support Office 365 or some sort of connector. | konschubert wrote: | Yea, for sure, that's something I'd like to have as well! | nde wrote: | Really cool idea! Style aside, I think you've developed an | interesting product with lots of appeal, especially for those | looking to be "less" connected. | | For those complaining about the style, perhaps offering a DIY kit | may be a viable alternative that allows anyone to add their own | flair. | diego_moita wrote: | Since you're announcing it at an heavy traffic like HN it is | quite likely there are already 200 companies in ShenZhen reading | your post and and planning to sell it for one tenth of what | you're asking. | dogma1138 wrote: | While Chinese can copy it easily the eInk display will kinda | guarantee that even half the price would be pushing it. | | In any case they don't need to even preemptively copy it once | you order it from a Chinese OEM they'll use the money you paid | them to make a few 1000's units more for themselves and have | them on Aliexpress before you even get the first batch shipped. | DangerousPie wrote: | I really like this idea, but I agree with others that the bezels | look a bit too large (do you need them to hide the components?) | and the price seems relatively high. | | I also thought that the calendar looked a bit grey/dull in the | image you show. Is this just about the lighting or is the display | not very high-contrast? | konschubert wrote: | > do you need them to hide the components? | | Yes for now. Though I might get them down in size as I iterate | on the hardware... | | > Is this just about the lighting or is the display not very | high-contrast? | | To be honest I'd say it's both. | briefcomment wrote: | Darker or bolder lines and text would be nice I think. | | It would be interesting if you put a little red LED on it like a | soft alarm for upcoming events. | | I would pay $35 for this, buy I'm sure others would pay more. | | Edit: Saw the 200 euro price tag, don't think I'm in the market | for this at that price. | konschubert wrote: | Thank you for your feedback, especially regarding the price. | omidh28 wrote: | With this price, Just buy a tablet and mount it. | danimal88 wrote: | I'd go for a much smaller bezel/frame. | loloquwowndueo wrote: | You want some feedback? Here is some: it's too expensive. 200EUR | for a display-only calendar? Thanks, I'll pass. | sxp wrote: | Can you post some specs about the size of the display in inches & | pixels? And does it run an open OS? | | I recently bought an M5Paper which is a 960X540, 4.7" ESP32 e-ink | display for $70. So that provides a baseline for your hardware. | okl wrote: | That price was at quantity '1' though, right? | dogma1138 wrote: | Yes but even at 10K you'll be looking at $50 per unit at | best. | | eInk displays are expensive as fuck thanks to patents. | daniel_iversen wrote: | I think your product is a great idea, good luck! Only feedback, | as others have said, the frame isn't quite my style, maybe a non- | wood or a thinner frame would be nice. And personally I'd like to | have the option to not have Saturday and Sunday on there (since | I'm imagining using this at my work desk) and the font size maybe | a little bigger/bolder for legibility. | konschubert wrote: | I can say that I fully agree on the "remove the weekend" | option. It's definitely on the list. | iamben wrote: | I love these kind of projects. But what I'd like is slightly | bigger than kindle e-ink display that shows a webpage of my | choice. And I'd like it to run off mains power. | | Then I can pretty much show what I want - so it's easy to set up | a rotating dashboard with the weather, my calendar, TFL alerts, | whatever. | | Why doesn't this exist?! | dominotw wrote: | can you open that webpage in 10 in or 13 inch eink devices ? | Plenty of them out there. I even watch youtube videos on mine. | twarge wrote: | It would be useful to show a list of the day's next events and | to-do's. Is iCloud sync even possible? | konschubert wrote: | > Is iCloud sync even possible? | | There are ways to make it work but it's not yet the way I'd | like it to be. | carbon85 wrote: | The frame fit and finish is not adequate, hire someone who is | able to cut and assemble frame miters that do not have gaps. | Offer a three wood options, Maple (light) Oak (Medium) and Walnut | (dark). | konschubert wrote: | Hi HN! | | I am trying to develop an e-paper smart display as a consumer | product. The first available layout will be a calendar. | | I'd love to have HN's input on this: Do you think it's viable? | Does it look okay? | | What would be a good selling price? | catchmeifyoucan wrote: | 200 euros is a lot. I own a remarkable tablet, and it can do a | lot more with a bigger screen | | I wouldn't be interested in spending that much since I can't | really do much other than look at my calendar. | | I'm either on the move, or in front of a computer, so I don't | see if there's a good fit for this device in my life | konschubert wrote: | I totally see your point of view regarding the price. What | price would you say is right? | | > I'm either on the move, or in front of a computer, so I | don't see if there's a good fit for this device in my life | | It's possible that the device isn't for you then, I agree. | nickweb wrote: | The price point will be a sticking point for consumers. I | understanding the pro's of this style of device with an e ink | screen, and the associated power savings and readability it | comes with, but the general public may not. This could be | better positioned towards an office environment but it would | possibly be too small to be useful to a team. | | I love the idea and the design, and I hope it works for you, | but I think it's going to be a hard sell ahead for you at that | price point. | konschubert wrote: | What price point would work better in your opinion? | kybernetikos wrote: | I know someone who needs this. | | The price seems high, but it might work as a christmas/birthday | present, and probably wouldn't ultimately stop it from being | purchased in this case. | | It would be replacing a paper calendar that shows 3 months | ahead. A nice feature would be to be able to move between views | of today, this week, 3 months. Much bigger would be nice too. | Again not having these would not stop a purchase. | | The wood bezel is pretty big. | | Most likely to stop a purchase is the ugly wire hanging from | it. If it didn't need charging often, then having it have a | powerbank (swappable?) in it would be better from my point of | view, although how often it needs to charge would be a factor. | | There was a beautiful concept epaper calendar I saw a while | back, | https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2017/3/22/15028600/m... | but I don't think it ever made it to sale, and if it had, it | would have been frighteningly expensive, but that is what I | would really like... | konschubert wrote: | That concept you're linking is what inspired me :) | | > It would be replacing a paper calendar that shows 3 months | ahead. A nice feature would be to be able to move between | views of today, this week, 3 months. | | I agree. | | > Much bigger would be nice too. | | Totally. | okl wrote: | Hi there, I have a few recommendation: | | - Add an indication of the current time and date. | | - Add a hidden button/switch to change between weekly/monthly | calendar layout. | | - Show a small popup with the pertinent information of the next | appointment. (Location &c.) | | - Where do you show entries that are scheduled for the entire | day? It would be nice to display them in an area that is | separate from the regular entries. | | - Add a button/switch to flip through the next few weeks. | | Good luck with your project, I can surely see a market for the | e-paper calendar. | konschubert wrote: | Hi, thanks for your comment. Those are good ideas. | tpetry wrote: | Something which is really missing is wifi support and the | ability to pull a custom image to display from somewhere. You | could then easily display status dashboards, calendars, | whatever someone likes. | | If you have a library for easily building these screens this | could be really interesting. | | I have seen this idea at the joan board, but they are really | expensive (attaching an ipad to the wall is cheaper) and i cant | find this feature anymore. I guess it was hidden at some | screenshot and small text somewhere. | xiaolingxiao wrote: | It's an awesome idea. The color the epaper might go better with | stainless steel, or even glass. But as it stands the | gray/black/brown combo looks a bit like an Ugly Tie, it could | work in the right room/wall, but may need some thinking on the | end of the buyer. | anotheryou wrote: | I might not be your market but I'd want: | | - a tiny version | | - with little bezel | | - at most 35eur | | - showing just todays upcoming agenda. | | - Maybe some bold and inverted display of soon to begin events. | | Than again... I could dock my phone, keep the screen on and show | some calendar app, but I don't either. | | Maybe I should :), would be possible with tasker, rfid and a | dock. | maartn wrote: | It's too officy, have a look at this one for inspiration: | https://www.instructables.com/E-Ink-Family-Calendar-Using-ES... | _Microft wrote: | Have you considered customizability of some sort? | | E.g. allowing people to extend your product, by software or by | providing necessary information to easily create 3D printed | mounts or alternate frames. Give the users a place to exchange | and host their solutions and your calendar could be a | presentation platform that others create for without requiring | you to do the work yourself. | germinalphrase wrote: | The frame size to screen feels unbalanced to me. I would reduce | the frame width and consider using a solid CNC'ed price of wood | instead of using picture frame construction. Unless you can get | those seams very tight, it looks a little cheap (which your price | point isnt). | konschubert wrote: | Yea, fair point! | | Interesting idea with the CNC'd wood - I'll look into that for | sure! | dsr_ wrote: | The frame overshadows the display. You might: | | - reduce the size of the frame | | - mount the display flush to the front of the frame | | The contrast in the photo does not look great. Perhaps use | hatching or shading instead of the solid black areas? In any | case, you'll want to be able to separate out different calendars. | | Other display modes? "Today", "Clock/Calendar", "Now and Next"? | | How do you control it? | konschubert wrote: | Thank you for the feedback. | | You're right, the display is smaller than I'd like... for sure. | | I'll also see what can be done on a black-and white display | with regards to the stark contrast. | | > Other display modes? "Today", "Clock/Calendar", "Now and | Next"? | | Yes, that's do-able, I "just" have to code it. | | > How do you control it? | | In the App. I should make that clearer on the website for sure. | m4lvin wrote: | > In the App. I should make that clearer on the website for | sure. | | I would only want this if I can use it without yet another | app. Please consider using a simple web interface etc. | mark-r wrote: | I think the idea is the display comes directly from Google | calendar and you don't have much control over it. | konschubert wrote: | Nope, it just gets the events from gcal. The layout is | whatever I make it. | cweagans wrote: | IMO, the bezel is way way way too big for how much screen space | there is. Instead of red oak, I'd suggest looking at walnut or | cherry -- something with more color and a little less texture | might help the screen to take focus. You could also look at | separating the screen from the bezel with some kind of mat board | or something (another commenter linked to an instructable that | did this). | | I'm also not super clear on the the exact use case for this. Have | you considered making it more of a portrait orientation, making | it a single day view, and maybe adding some additional | information (maybe some todos from Todoist or something?) | konschubert wrote: | The wood is actually beech, though this particular batch I got | for the prototypes had a surprising amount of texture. I am | planning to use lighter colors in future. | | Regarding your second point: I'd love to support a multitude of | layout options some day. | hertzrat wrote: | Wall calendars don't have room for enough information. A weekly | view would be nice. I would like a thinner frame and larger | screen for readability. I might worry about the inconvenience of | powering it or of entering/editing information. For the price | point, a fancier build quality would help with the "premium" feel | you probably would need: it would need to stand as a practical | art piece | konschubert wrote: | Good feedback, thank you. | throwaway69123 wrote: | Bigger screens are better. | mark-r wrote: | Too expensive for the utility it provides. A Raspberry Pi with a | simple LCD could do the job for half the price. An old obsolete | phone would work too. | zackbloom wrote: | I believe one reason people are responding negatively to the | frame is there is insufficient padding around the content before | the frame begins. I know it would be painful to not use all the | screen real estate, but I think there needs to be some spacing. | Alternatively you could surround the screen with some sort of | matting before the frame begins. | konschubert wrote: | Good idea. Also the matting. | | But I think people are right: The frame is quite big. I'd love | to get the size down. | cointreau wrote: | I actually like the heavy frame, although I see why some might | find it a bit heavy, given that the apparent goal of most screen | designers is to eliminate the bezel entirely. | | My biggest sticking point here is price. 200 euros is a no-go; | given the limited nature of the device, I wouldn't even consider | 100. 50 is the absolute max I'd pay for something like this. | | It's a very nice product, and your target audience might very | well be people who can afford an expensive desk object. I don't | think most of the folks I know could pay that, though. | konschubert wrote: | Thank you for the feedback. Getting the price down is | definitely one of my priorities. | creativenolo wrote: | Thin white frame with a white mounting could feel more | aesthetically balanced. | m4lvin wrote: | You will have to compete with much cheaper ideas like this | kindle-based dashboard https://github.com/pascalw/kindle-dash | | discussed a while ago here: | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25939042 | nom wrote: | Others will comment on the product itself, and because it looks | like you're trying to feel out the market, my questions are: | | Do you have experience developing, certifying and shipping | consumer hardware? In what countries do you want to sell it? Who | builds the hardware? How big is your first run? | konschubert wrote: | Hehe, those are really important questions you're asking. | | I'm looking at the EU and the US market. I know I need to get | CE and RoHS and a bunch of other certificates. I know this | won't be easy. | | If you know somebody who has experience with that, ideally in a | boutique/startup environment, I'd love to hear the advice they | have to give. | iamleppert wrote: | The wood bezel is kind of ugly & cheap looking. The audience for | this is likely to be tech people and users who want to show off | their calendar or manage their time with calendar invites. I | think this could do well with a more contemporary frame. You | could market it to people as a solution to forgetting meetings; | the price would have to be low enough (sub $100) to trigger | people's impulse buying. The lower the price the more likely you | will be to get a sale. | | Do a test on Facebook with different price points and see which | one produces better conversions: you don't need to actually have | the product available to buy yet. This product is mostly going to | live or die based on the marketing & pricing. | konschubert wrote: | I actually like the wood as material per se, but I still want | to improve a bit on the processing. | | I'd love to lower the price, too. I don't know yet if it's | possible. | _Microft wrote: | Besides the bezel being wide compared to the actual screen, | there is nothing else wrong with it, in my opinion. | jitl wrote: | There's no accounting for taste. I'd prefer a wood frame to | some kind of LED emissive plastic or metal | jlengrand wrote: | Interesting! I've done something _very roughly_ similar over the | past weeks | (https://twitter.com/jlengrand/status/1362319916649578499). I | would go and say that putting calendar only is probably too | static info as displayed on the website (it'll change only once a | day). | | My setup cost about 80$ total so I guess the pricing is not wild. | I do really like the cool effect of epaper personally, much more | than the typical 'use a tablet as dashboard' that has a | backlight. Good job! | jlengrand wrote: | Oh and funnily enough when I showed that on Twitter people | asked for exactly what you did so you might be up to something, | though I wonder if displayed like you do now the resolution | will be high enough ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2021-02-21 23:00 UTC)