[HN Gopher] Evaluating Modest SaaS Business Ideas ___________________________________________________________________ Evaluating Modest SaaS Business Ideas Author : DanHulton Score : 164 points Date : 2021-04-10 18:02 UTC (4 hours ago) (HTM) web link (greaterdanorequalto.com) (TXT) w3m dump (greaterdanorequalto.com) | 1cvmask wrote: | All seem like reasonable points. But the real test is the ability | to survive the first couple of years and get paying customers. | DanHulton wrote: | Oh absolutely. These are questions to hopefully find an idea | that lets you do that, or at least exclude ones that don't. | lpolovets wrote: | This is an excellent list. FWIW these questions overlap a lot | with questions VCs will ask if you decide to go the venture- | backed route. (Source: I'm a VC.) | | A product can still find success even if there isn't a great | answer to "is there a moat?" or "is the person who benefits also | the one who pays?" -- but the road is a lot harder. | algo_trader wrote: | What is your typical "moat perception" of a Uber-for-X SaaS | pitch. | | Yes, brand and reputation and credit card details and scale | advantages and first mover. | | But are these a "moat" or just "stickiness" factors? | lpolovets wrote: | I view those more as stickiness than as moats. They help you | retain existing customers but don't make the product more | valuable for new customers. | | Scale advantages are the exception. If the costs of your | product or service drop dramatically with scale, then you can | lower prices to a level where you still make a profit but | competitors can't compete. | | The complicated most is the logistics network. That is | definitely a moat against new entrants, but not against large | existing logistics networks like Uber or DoorDash. | figbert wrote: | > Alternatively, if you run an Internet Of Things company that | locks and unlocks doors over an API, if that API goes down, | people could be locked out of their houses during emergencies! | | Alternatively, don't develop an IoT door lock that will lock | people out of their houses if the intern accidentally fucks up in | production. | sokoloff wrote: | But how else could we make it LaaS (locks as a service) with a | monthly subscription? | senko wrote: | > Is downtime a life-or-death emergency? | | This is a big one, after you get your project off the ground. | | In my last startup, downtime of a few minutes led to torrents of | emails and customer complaints, as the service was time | sensitive. | | This was easily the most stressful part of the job. | simonbarker87 wrote: | Great list, I'm currently trying to better focus my side project | time one things that can be viable businesses so I can het back | to running my own thing again and this is getting bookmarked to | come back to for every idea. | macando wrote: | The most important part: | | _Finding a customer category that regularly spends money on the | kind of software you 're intending to build can make it | signficantly easier to actually sell them software._ | | Go to Capterra or G2 and read what actual paying customers say | about your competitors and other SaaS products. It's eye-opening. | enraged_camel wrote: | Not really. Most of those reviews are paid reviews these days, | and you can't tell the real ones from the fake ones. I know | because at my previous job the marketing team was responsible | for "encouraging" customers to leave positive reviews by | offering them various incentives and discounts. Resulting | reviews were often times the total opposite of reality. | macando wrote: | Partially true. It takes some time to learn how to spot | genuine reviews. | | However, even in the "encouraged" reviews you can still | discover what problems people solve with certain class of | tools and how much money they're ready to pay for them. | jokethrowaway wrote: | Can confirm, I did a few paid reviews (until the reward was | greater than the time spent). | | I wrote genuine thoughts on the product but given it has been | offered to me and not someone else, there is a clear | selection bias. | yoshyosh wrote: | This is a really good post, how long have you been doing this for | Dan? Look forward to seeing what you make next | DanHulton wrote: | Thanks! I've been building Nodewood in my spare time for the | past couple years, but I've been keeping my hand in the | bootstrapping community for about a decade now. I have a pretty | solid history of _not_ considering these questions before | launching something that seemed like a fun idea, so I figured I | may as well share this and see if I can help others learn from | my mistakes. =) | searchableguy wrote: | This is a good list of questions to evaluate. I am currently | struggling with finding customers for something I hacked together | to solve my personal problem. | | A discord bot which warns users when they share links to pirated | site and remove it. (I moderate a small discord server). | | I extracted the API part and put it on rapid API to see if there | is any interest because I have little idea where to look for | customers and how to talk to them. | | https://rapidapi.com/searchableland-no-piracy-team/api/pirac... | | I have also been looking for alternatives. I searched for them | before but nothing came up so I had to build a list and | heuristics myself. Maybe there isn't much of a need otherwise I | would find a product. | kayhi wrote: | How much time, money or reputation does it contribute to a | channel? | DanHulton wrote: | Yeah, if you don't find any competition, that's usually not a | great thing. The world being as big as it is, you're _probably_ | not the first person to think of this particular idea, and it's | _usually_ that there's not a market for it. | | That said, maybe this is an idea you can niche _up_ with? | Instead of just one form of moderation, could you take the | basic tech and use it to moderate a whole bunch of nasties that | admins don't want to waste time dealing with? You'll want to | make sure that the a _paying_ market exists for such tools | first, obviously, but it's a potential option. | mpoteat wrote: | Agree. A one off tool that detects pirated links seems odd to | pay for. | | Either a monolithic tool for handling moderation automation | in general seems good, or better yet a marketplace where I | can buy automation plugins for Discord in general, both for | moderation as well as other administrative or entertainment | tasks. | fbelzile wrote: | It's easy nowadays to throw up a quick slash page with some | SEO friendly pages to gauge market demand. Have an email wait | list and if it gets large, you'll conveniently have the email | of your first clients. | 1123581321 wrote: | Maybe you could get an MPAA grant to develop it further. :) | | Most problems with links on Discord are solved with a gradual | expansion of new user permissions. | luto wrote: | Does discord punish servers, which share pirated content? | cloudking wrote: | These are good questions to evaluate, as the author points out | there is no "right" way to do this. Making sure your idea solves | real customers problems that align with your personal values and | goals makes sense to me. Another tool I like to use in this phase | is the Business Model Canvas, it makes you think about the | business side, giving you a clear overview of your idea and the | avenues to turn it into a real business | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_Model_Canvas ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2021-04-10 23:00 UTC)