[HN Gopher] Eric Carle has died ___________________________________________________________________ Eric Carle has died Author : divbzero Score : 271 points Date : 2021-05-27 03:25 UTC (19 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.washingtonpost.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.washingtonpost.com) | aynyc wrote: | My kids love his books. | | FYI: the broadway production of his books is very well done as | well. | afro88 wrote: | I loved The Very Hungry Caterpillar as a kid, and now read it to | my 6 month old before bed. He loves it too, smiling while playing | with the little mini pages and me poking his finger into the | holes as the caterpillar chomps through his feast. Precious | moments. | | RIP Eric Carle | _Microft wrote: | In German, it is called _Die kleine Raupe Nimmersatt_ which, | translated word-by-word, means _The small Caterpillar Never- | sated_. I always found that an especially cute name. | | How is The Very Hungry Caterpillar called in your language? Did | the translator have similar freedoms with the name? | lemming wrote: | In Spanish it's _La oruga muy hambrienta_ which is a straight | translation of the English. | Svip wrote: | The Danish title is very similar to the German and Dutch ones, | _Den sultne larve Aldrigmaet_ meaning _The hungry larva Never- | sated_. | _Microft wrote: | I just looked up Norwegian and it's _Den lille larven | Aldrimett_ there. | roywashere wrote: | Dutch: Rupsje Nooitgenoeg (Little Caterpillar Neverenough) | coccinelle wrote: | French seems to be La Chenille qui fait des trous: The | Caterpillar That Makes Holes. Very underwhelming compared to | the German or Dutch translations if you ask me! | ugh123 wrote: | The 3-book box set, along with Lonely Firefly and Busy Spider, is | still going strong with my 3 year old. | | Although I try to limit the Caterpillar book now since my son | will start demanding cake, ice cream, sausage, etc after we read | it. Makes bedtime routine really hard | pizzabearman wrote: | My mom read this book to me as a child all the time. 15/20 years | later I ran across it some how. I remembered my brain doing some | kind of "summer salt jump flip", awakening some hidden part of my | brain recognizing those plums, apples, caterpillar, etc. The | illustrations are so colorful and distinct. | nineplay wrote: | There are very few justifications for the existence of Twitter | but one is undoubtedly Eric Carle's feed. He posted new drawings | for every holiday. | | https://twitter.com/ericcarle?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcam... | jedberg wrote: | That Twitter is awesome, thanks! | | I was a little disappointed in twitter marking his "happy | Hanukkah" drawing as "sensitive content" | SirYandi wrote: | Was censored for me as well. Very strange. I'd guess it has | been reported a few times. | freepalestine wrote: | Yeah well you know Jews are literally Nazis now because | they want one country where Muslims also allowed to live | and Muslims already eradicated Jews from the rest of the | Middle East and Arabia and will kill them if they try to | emigrate, but they're the victims | | Free Palestine! /s | | The best part of this post is camping the nickname. | | Death to jihadis! | freepalestine wrote: | Judaism is tantamount to Nazism in the eyes of Twitter | afro88 wrote: | Strange, it's not marked sensitive in mine. Are twitter | personalising the labelling of tweets now? | keithnz wrote: | I'm in NZ, and not marked sensitive for me | jedberg wrote: | That would make sense but be extra funny to label a happy | Hanukkah post as sensitive for me in particular! That would | be a pretty broken algorithm. | | Unless it's per region perhaps. Are you in the USA? | sachinag wrote: | I'm in USA and not censored for me, although I'm logged in | and have view sensitive content turned on | annoyingnoob wrote: | Thank you for that link, had no idea. | hprotagonist wrote: | His books are still in steady rotation at my house. | scop wrote: | Thank you Eric Carle. | | I've greatly enjoyed reading his books to my children, especially | "The Grouchy the Ladybug" and "Papa Please Get the Moon for Me". | | In a similar vein, and for any curious readers out there, I was | recently reduced to near tears reading "The Clown of God" by | Tommie De Palo | lanstin wrote: | I cry every time at that one. | bvm wrote: | i enjoy reading to my 7 month old. she has no idea what's going | on, but she likes being cuddled, the sound of her parent's voices | and turning the pages. what i really enjoy is that she has no | idea of linear narrative, so she will turn the book to the last | page and then the first. then try to eat the book. then at some | point cry. | | the very hungry caterpillar is somewhat unique in that she | absolutely loves the illustrations, like no other book. she | really sits still and gazes agog at them, especially that picture | of the sun at the beginning. | heydenberk wrote: | Books for babies and toddlers are pretty much all the same: cute | drawings and simple sentences. On some level, they're all goofy | and inane. There's no accounting for taste to be sure, but I am | especially baffled why some of these books grow tiresome after | two read-throughs, while you are delighted to see your toddler | reach for certain books again and again. Eric Carle's books are | all in the latter camp for me. The illustrations are beautiful, | of course, but something about the stupidly simple prose and | narrative just ineffably works. I'm grateful to him. | danbolt wrote: | I've heard that a lot of children's media often looks to help | encourage pattern recognition (eg: counting the Very Hungry | Caterpillar's foods or the structure of a Blue's Clues | episode), but I don't know how true that is. | NoNotTheDuo wrote: | I've heard a corollary to this. Kids often love to watch/read | the same thing because they recognize the pattern and know | what is coming up next. This gives them comfort and a | routine. | ftio wrote: | I echo all of this, including in appreciation of Carle's work. | Despite the simple language, there's a sophistication and depth | to the best children's books that mediocre ones lack. | | My favorite to read to my little guys is _This is Not My Hat_ | by Jon Klassen, which is one of the funniest, most subtle ones | we've come across. | person22 wrote: | Adding to the recommended books: 'Bats at the Beach' by Brian | Lies. | | My kids never got tired of me reading it and I never got | tired of reading it. They loved that book. The illustrations | are extremely well done. Who would draw bats wearing | floaties? | peterstensmyr wrote: | Highly recommend "the wolf, the duck, and the mouse" which is | written by Mac Barnett and illustrated by Jon Klassen. Absurd | and funny. | citizenkeen wrote: | Sam and Dave Dig a Hole is hilarious for the kid and | absolutely terrifying for the parent. | jbrooksuk wrote: | It's so good to see Jon Klassen getting recognition on HN! | | His books are superb! Short, sweet and extremely funny :D | agentwiggles wrote: | Jon Klassen is great! Simple yet beautiful art and stories | that are fun for both the parents and the kids. I love the | final line of This Is Not My Hat, which works on two levels: | "Nobody will ever find me." | WalterBright wrote: | I enjoy Winnie the Pooh as much today as when I was 6. But for | different reasons. Today I enjoy the sly humor in it. | | It takes real talent to appeal to both young and old. The early | Spongebob cartoons were like that, Bugs Bunny, and the early | seasons of The Simpsons | bambax wrote: | My kids had a book about a wolf who made soup with a stone, | "Une soupe aux caillou". | | The wolf travels to other animals' homes; the animals are | afraid at first, but they let him in because he says he only | wants to make soup. | | He comes in, boils water in a big pot, puts his stone in. The | animals want to help with the soup, and so they suggest other | ingredients. The wolf says "well, sure, you can add that if you | want". | | They drink the soup together. Then the wolf gets up, takes his | stone back from the pot, and leaves. | | The process repeats for 8 or 10 different animals, and that's | it. | | It's a fantastic book. We must have read it hundreds of times. | wikibob wrote: | Which is in turn an adaptation of the parable of the stone | soup | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stone_Soup | bambax wrote: | Wow, thank you... did not know that... | quadrangle wrote: | I don't like this idea of grouping them all as similar. There's | a huge range of toddler-focused books, some are great, some are | awful, most are in-between. | | Brown Bear, Brown Bear from Carle himself is mediocre junk. | It's just colors and animals, and has no character, no | narrative, no arc. | | The Hungry, Hungry Caterpillar is an amazing, astounding | masterpiece. It is usually printed with a sort of dynamic | tactical approach with different page sizes, holes in the | pages, the story has a real arc, it teaches biology, it | carefully works in numbers and days of the week and the idea of | time frame... it's a true stand-out. | | Most of Carle's stuff is somewhere in the middle, though he has | a few other superb ones. | | Just like art for older audiences, there really is a range. You | could say that all movies are the same: people having conflicts | and doing stuff. On some level, they're all dramatic and | simplistic. | | It's not mere taste. What makes a great book or movie for any | age is not total relativism. | jacobolus wrote: | _Brown Bear, Brown Bear_ is an excellent book for very young | children (say, under 2 years old). It's not a deep book, but | it is not trying to be. | | It has attractive clear illustrations of one animal per page, | a simple repeating structure with only a few new words each | page, nice rhyme/meter. Its structure involves repeatedly | anticipating the next animal, which makes it easy to | memorize. | | It is a book my kids enjoyed "reading" aloud to themselves at | age ~2 before they could fully remember the content of more | complicated picture books. | | * * * | | Of course, this isn't the _only_ type of book small kids | should be listening to, and in the genre of extremely simple | picture books there is a lot of abject garbage. | chasd00 wrote: | for me, it was much easier to read books like Little Blue Truck | or Goodnight Moon night after night to my kids because they | rhyme. I could memorize the poetry and read it as my boys went | to sleep while half-asleep myself. | IggleSniggle wrote: | This one line about hubris enters my thoughts unprovoked, an | internal reproach, on occasion: | | -------- | | He _saw_ a puddle and he _tried_ to swerve-- | | Into the mud rolled the big fat truck, | | and his big important wheels got STUCK | fortylove wrote: | Even then, his heavy duty dump truck tires were stuck down | deep in muck and mire. | WJW wrote: | I'm not a native English speaker but even I can just | _hear_ the metrum in that sentence. Very cool. | croutonwagon wrote: | My wife has a masters in reading and language arts in early | childhood education. Which means shes also a LOT better at | reading to the kids than me. | | What i never realized was that a LOT of these books, Eric | Carles are in that camp, are using words chosen to teach kids | basic language skills and sentence formation. The ones that | dont really employ a lot of those learning mechanisms, seem to | be the ones that we grow tired of quickly and hit the back of | the stack.. Im sure Nostalgia is part of it too. | | Dr. Suess is similar and very heavy on sounds/aliteration. But | you would be surprised to know that many of his books actually | use very few words. Like Green Eggs and Ham is like 50 pages of | sentence after sentence but only uses like 50 words total or | something like that (i could be wrong, its one of the most | famous ones that like that). | | Honestly when I read to my young kids, i would get tired of the | same books over and over and would just kinda make up the | story. Now that my kids are learning to actually read, I dont | do that anymore. | ftio wrote: | YES -- you're nailing something that I've felt but haven't | been able to articulate. | | The worst children's books are ones that don't roll off the | tongue, that use too-complicated phraseology, that through | circumlocution challenge the rea--well, you get it. They trip | me up! | triska wrote: | This is similar to ABBA songs: Superficially, they seem very | simple, but they are quite complex internally, and when | something is repeated, then it is often repeated in a | slightly different way. | ska wrote: | > What i never realized was that a LOT of these books, | | This is part of a broader phenomenon, where most things are | more complicated than you first think when you dig into it. | This leads some people to assume work in areas they don't | understand is easy. | [deleted] | csours wrote: | I constantly assume that parts of my own job are easier | than they turn out to be. | | 'That should only take 30 minutes' - winds up taking 2 | calendar weeks. | croutonwagon wrote: | I have to typically impress in my first line support guys | that "if you don't want people to think your job is | simple, then you shouldn't assume the same of them" | | Heck I get people that think MY job is just clicking next | on installers, there are entire swaths of things we do | that others simply aren't aware of because it's | transparent to them. I even had one lady question how | much I made based on that very assumption. (She's not a | very nice person in general anyway) | garyrob wrote: | I agree. I read his books, especially that one, to each of my | kids, and still have very fond memories | meristohm wrote: | Some books I'm willing to read repeatedly: I Am A Bunny, and I | Am A Mouse, both by Ole Risom and illustrated by Richard Scarry | and John P. Miller, respectively, in a realistic style, as if | they actually made the time to observe the plants and animals; | Goodnight Moon by Margaret Wise Brown; Stack the Cats, by Susan | Ghahremani; and Bear and Wolf, by Daniel Salmieri. The latter | is my favorite so far because of this line, among others: | | "Bear and Wolf walked through the quietly falling snow, using | their eyes, and ears, and noses to take in the snowy woods." | | Bear is female, Wolf is male, and they are at home in the cold, | as we can be if we allow ourselves to acclimate. They explore | together, go they separate ways, and meet again in late spring. | navbaker wrote: | On the page in Goodnight Moon where the mouse is peeking out | from behind the bowl full of mush, our 3-year old has started | shouting at it "NO NO YOUNG MOUSE, GET AWAY FROM MY MUSH!!!" | Makes me laugh every time. | kenjackson wrote: | While Goodnight Moon is everyone's favorite, there is | something about "The Little Island" by Margaret Wise Brown | that captured me as a parent. I loved reading this story | out loud. The writing is poetic and flows off the tongue. | The story has some nuance, that to this day I'm still not | sure I fully grasp. This is my favorite book to give as a | gift to new parents. | bkandel wrote: | I love the book, but honestly who sleeps with a bowl of | oatmeal on their nightstand?! Never understood that. | thanatos519 wrote: | Who says "Goodnight nobody?" | fortylove wrote: | But what's the meaning behind "goodnight noises | everywhere"? | navbaker wrote: | I've wondered that for a while, especially combined with | the previous pages saying "goodnight stars, goodnight | air" | CyberRabbi wrote: | There should really be a black banner for this, dang? | anonu wrote: | I read The Very Hungry Caterpillar to my toddler. It really | resonates with her because of all the fun pictures of food! | | What strikes me about a lot of children's book is that they often | talk about metamorphosis - which is a strange and beautiful | concept. But we rarely encounter it in real life, other than | figuratively. | freediver wrote: | Very grateful to Eric Carle and his contribution to the world. | | Alan Kay said "People who are really serious about software | should make their own hardware.". Makes me think that people who | are really serious about writing books for children, should do | their own illustrations. | nescioquid wrote: | Though by analogy, people who are really serious about writing | books for children should _really_ make their own children, no? | jacobolus wrote: | While some excellent children's books are one-person projects, | most of my favorite children's books have separate author / | illustrator. There is no indication that they are less | "serious". You can find a large pile of terrible books with any | possible authorship structure. | | I do get the sense however that picture books are usually | better when the author and illustrator collaborate closely. | freediver wrote: | Could be as well, but as an aspiring childrens' book author, | this just made me think there may be one more skill I will | need to acquire. | rohansingh wrote: | > Books for babies and toddlers are pretty much all the same: | cute drawings and simple sentences. On some level, they're all | goofy and inane. | | If you're tired of that, I'd highly recommend Happy Dog the Happy | Dog: | | https://topatoco.com/collections/ryan-north/products/qw-happ... | | It's based on this comic: | | https://qwantz.com/index.php?comic=484 | apetresc wrote: | The one sample page it shows is: "When you grow up, your | parents may reject your sexuality". | | I don't think this is actually a book for little kids. | QuesnayJr wrote: | The ad copy says "It is not actually for children?" | syntheticnature wrote: | The Eric Carle Museum of Picture Book Art in Amherst, MA is worth | a visit: https://www.carlemuseum.org/ | rietta wrote: | He wrote or illustrated some of our daughter's favorites. It's | amazing to me just how classic these are. Something I had no idea | about until becoming a parent. RIP Sir, and thank you for being | part of our child's education. | jgon wrote: | The books have been a staple in our household as well, and I echo | other people is saying that this a loss of a true talent. One | thing I thought I'd add to the conversation is that a series of | very well done short films were made based on some of his books. | If your little ones are begging for some screen time and you're | wary of what youtube will unleash on them, I found these to be a | really fun series that keep to his unique and beautiful | aesthetic, and at least my kids loved to watch The Very Hungry | Caterpillar on the screen and then read it together afterwards, | and maybe your children will feel the same! | | The Very Hungry Caterpillar | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=75NQK-Sm1YY | | I See a Song https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pPpkaldk84Y | | Papa, Please Get The Moon for Me | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGqAw7UM6qo | | The Very Quiet Cricket | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGqAw7UM6qo | | The Mixed Up Chameleon | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FrmZeXf7ScU | | "In the light of the moon, a little egg lay on a leaf..." | strictnein wrote: | Like many others here, I spent several years of my life with his | books. "The Very Hungry Caterpillar" is obviously his best known | classic, but in our house "Dream Snow" was the most popular. | | https://www.amazon.com/Dream-Snow-Eric-Carle/dp/0399235795/ | | It's a great Christmas/Winter book. Definitely get the bigger, | hardcover version. The illustrations are great and at the end of | the story your kid will get to push a button and make some | peaceful musical notes play. | gabagool wrote: | This title should say that he died. Right now it boils down to | "Eric Carle" which does not signify a news event. | airstrike wrote: | +1. 'Eric Carle, writer and illustrator of The Very Hungry | Caterpillar, has died' is shorter than the current title so it | should work. | duxup wrote: | Mr Rogers visited him once: | | https://www.misterrogers.org/videos/eric-carle/ | robmaceachern wrote: | "The Very Hungry Caterpillar" will always have a special place in | my heart. I can't begin to describe how fond my memories are of | my two year old son reciting the words on the Saturday page for | the first time: | | "On Saturday, he ate through one piece of chocolate cake, one | ice-cream cone, one pickle, one slice of Swiss cheese, one slice | of salami, one lollipop, one piece of cherry pie, one sausage, | one cupcake, and one slice of watermelon. | | That night he had a stomach ache." | | Such a precious memory for me. Thank you Eric Carle. RIP. | philshem wrote: | TIL, the stomach-ache scene was forced by the publisher... | https://twitter.com/unfortunatalie/status/139787073540681728... | hyko wrote: | Wow. | philshem wrote: | Can no longer edit, but might be a fake parody interview from | the Paris Review. Sorry. | | https://twitter.com/buckwilson/status/1397930890446229504 | | https://twitter.com/AviTheNaftali/status/1397928222809939968 | Stratoscope wrote: | I loved Eric's books, and my daughters loved having me read the | books to them some 20 years ago. | | It's funny, as I read Eric's obituary I can hear my own voice | reading those books to my daughters so long ago. | | RIP Eric, and thank you for bringing us so many good times. | frakt0x90 wrote: | I absolutely loved that book as a kid and still remember the art | very clearly 25+ years later. Crazy how such simple things can | have such long lasting impressions. | sangd wrote: | I have this book and I have never looked him up until seeing this | post today. All of my three daughters love this book and I didn't | quite understand why as I grew up in a different culture. RIP | Eric. You've done great work for this world! | vlunkr wrote: | I didn't really understand why kids like it so much at first, | but here's what I think, in very few words it explores lots of | things: counting, days of the week, day/night cycle, lots of | foods, separating fruit from junk food, and of the lifecycle of | butterflies. Kids will find something engaging in there. | nend wrote: | Plus the holes. Kids can't seem to stop themselves from | interacting with it. | MandieD wrote: | It's the first book I remember reading in both English (as a | small child) and German (in college), and now my German-American | baby is growing up with it in both languages. | navbaker wrote: | We have a small collection of his other books that are favorites | with our 3 and 5 year old kids. "Pancakes, Pancakes", "The Tiny | Seed", and "A House for Hermit Crab" in particular are regular | reads at bedtime. | dvaun wrote: | Interesting. My oldest also loves all three of these books, | while his younger brother loves "The Very Hungry Caterpillar". | | They're great books to make funny sounds with. They're also | great for asking our kids questions about the stories. | sen wrote: | The Very Hungry Caterpillar is probably the single most important | kids book in my extended family. It was the first book I got as a | kid due to my dad loving it, and Mum sewed me a little toy which | was my favourite toy for many years. | | It the became a "thing" where it was the first book we got for | every kid born in my extended family, and now that I have my own | kids 40+ years later it was the first I got for them too. They | both know it by rote, have the toys, had the bed sheets, | everything. They're now in the early years of school and still | absolutely love the story and have the posters in their rooms | despite them being "old" for it. | | RIP Eric. You've left an amazing mark on the world. | Pxtl wrote: | What's fascinating about the Very Hungry Caterpillar was that | the "stomach ache" and nice green leaf was forced upon him by | his publisher. He wanted it to be "caterpillar eats lots of | silly things because he's hungry, becomes huge, becomes | butterfly". | | The moralizing "nice green leaf" was neither his idea nor | desired. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2021-05-27 23:00 UTC)