[HN Gopher] Show HN: Optery - See the private info data brokers ... ___________________________________________________________________ Show HN: Optery - See the private info data brokers are posting about you online Author : beyondd Score : 60 points Date : 2021-06-28 14:04 UTC (8 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.optery.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.optery.com) | shubik22 wrote: | Congrats on your product. I'm curious what lead to you all | creating this product, after you spent "years working at data | brokers." | | Perhaps this is too harsh an analogy, but how is this different | than someone who spends years working at a tobacco company and | then launches a company which sells a smoking cessation product? | As other comments here point out, even the process of opting out | of these brokers via Optery requires disclosure of personal | information and some level of trust. I can imagine the fact that | you all previously worked at data brokers make people less likely | to trust you with their personal information, rather than more. | beyondd wrote: | Hi HN, | | After many years working at data brokers such as BlueKai, Lusha, | and Oracle Data Cloud, we've spent the last few months building a | tool that provides granular visibility into the private | information posted about you online by people search sites like | TruthFinder, MyLife, Radaris, CellRevealer, Spokeo, WhitePages, | etc. | | After sign up, we provide deep links to your profile at over 100 | of these sites, as well as an Exposure Report with screenshots so | you can see exactly what these sites are posting about you. There | are typically 40 - 60 matches for each user that signs up. | | The top comment in another data privacy Show HN shared recently | illustrates the gap our tool fills: "Does it take into account | whether or not a given data broker currently has my data? Since | the deletion requests contain my personal info (for some, a fair | amount of it), I'd rather not have that sent to 500 brokers if | only 10 or 20 of them actually have me in their database." | (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27146828) | | Full disclosure, signing up is free and provides the visibility | into what data brokers are posting about you described above, but | we also have paid subscription tiers where we submit and manage | the opt outs and removals. | | If you want to skip the overview content, you can go straight to | the signup here: https://app.optery.com/signup | | (We only support U.S. residents at this time.) | qqw wrote: | Doesn't supplying all this info about myself just confirm that it | is correct, thus further putting my privacy at risk? | | > For each user, we typically turn up 2X - 5X more profile match | results than Google, or any of our competitors | | How? Is it different than manually looking up my info at each | site listed under "which data brokers are covered by each plan?" | | Not a bad idea for a business, you sell them my data then charge | me to have them delete it. I didn't know you had competitors | though, now I'm comparing your features to theirs. | beyondd wrote: | We do not sell data. We are not a data broker. | | People sign up with us to see what information data brokers are | posting about them online, and then are provided with free and | paid options to opt out and have themselves removed. | | Yes - you could manually look up your info at each site listed | under "which data brokers are covered by each plan?" - which | would take you many, many hours, or you could create an account | with Optery and have us do it for you automatically. | | The data brokers most likely already have info on you. There is | a catch22 where in order to opt out, you have to tell them who | you are. Other services use your own private email address to | submit the opt outs. We do not share your private email address | with any third party, including the data brokers we submit opt | outs to. | cdstyh wrote: | Can I know your name, address, and phone number please? | curtisblaine wrote: | US only. Please make it clear before asking for email / pwd to | sign up. | beyondd wrote: | Sorry about that. We just updated our sign up page to make this | more clear. | mdaniel wrote: | I requested that they turn on 2FA, since they themselves will | become an attack target by requesting so much PII | | That said, my experience with trying to use _any_ opt-out service | (automated or otherwise) is filled with a lot of "Oops, server | error, try again later" responses at the end of filling out a ton | of forms about oneself, so I wonder if Optery has some secret | sauce, is persistent in the face of server errors, or just is | fire-and-forget and thus follows the "spray and pray" method of | account removal | | If I paid actual money for this, I'd want some observable metric | showing that I had 166 public listings in June, followed by 66 in | July, or something of the sort. | neatze wrote: | How and why are you better then onerep.com ? | myself248 wrote: | The pricing page doesn't make it clear why it's charged monthly, | when it seems like this should be a one-time thing. What happens | if I pay for a month, get all the opt-outs, and stop paying? | | My cynicism says that an unethical service in your position could | hold my identity hostage and immediately re-publish anything as | soon as I stop paying. I'm sure you're not doing that, but | forgive me for thinking it; we're talking about an entire | industry that rests on ethics that many of us would consider | stalking and should be profoundly illegal, so the possibility of | such behavior is palpable! So, it would be good to explain or | clarify _that_ you're not holding me hostage, and lay out the | value proposition for an ongoing subscription to what feels like | a one-time event. | bythreads wrote: | US only because you're scared of gdpr? | tylerscott wrote: | It's incredible how many companies exist solely to collect (and | sell?) personal data. I was ignorant to just how wide spread bits | of my data were until I fired up Optery. It was sorta shocking to | see all the results. | altdataseller wrote: | What about ZoomInfo? Can it remove my profile from there? | troydavis wrote: | I did a version of this by Googling my name (as a phrase, with | and without middle initial) combined with city names or street | address fragments I've lived at. I then submitted removal | requests for anything I found. | | I ended up submitting about 10 requests, 7 or 8 of which were | online. | | Of course, not all data brokers have publicly indexed page, but a | lot do. | beyondd wrote: | This is great! A lot of people prefer to submit the opt outs | themselves. Our Free Basic account can be used to help people | do-it-yourself faster by helping with the discovery process. | | If you choose to sign up for Optery, next to each data broker | listing we provide the opt out link and opt out email address | to make it easy to navigate to. | | When submitting your own opt outs to these companies directly, | we highly recommend creating a disposable email address, and | Not using your primary email address, as just reaching out to | them with an email often adds you to their email lists. | gigel82 wrote: | Be very careful with any tool like this; you'll need to prove who | you are by verifying an email address and / or phone number to | your real name, which in turn will most likely "confirm" your | data with all the upstream brokers (if you pay for some extra | service you're twice a sucker with them most likely getting paid | by brokers for proving your identity and by you as well for using | the "service"). | | Note: this could be totally legit but in my personal experience, | 100% of the tools that promise to do this were in fact shady as | fuck and working with the brokers to enrich their data. | beyondd wrote: | Hi! Co-creator of Optery here. | | We do not sell data. We are not a data broker. We do not have | any financial relationship with any data broker. We are not | affiliated with any data broker. | | We are privacy enthusiasts who believe consumers should be in | full control of their data. You can learn more about our | mission, background and values here: | https://www.optery.com/about-us/ | | There are some bad actors out there unfortunately. The most | well-known is OneRep, which has an opt out and removals | business, but are owned by an ownership group that | simultaneously runs the People Search Site data broker Nuwber. | It's almost certain that they run off the same data spine, | meaning your data is co-mingled. Another one is BrandYourself, | which includes data brokers as part of its affiliate program. | So if you pay them for removals, you are indirectly paying the | data brokers. There are others that I have a strong suspicion | of, but don't know for certain, so I won't risk sharing their | names. | | But please don't lump the rest of us working hard to protect | people from data brokers into that same bucket. Along with us, | DeleteMe, PrivacyDuck, and Kanary and a few others are above- | board with no affiliation or financial relationship with any | data broker (to the best of my knowledge). Just working hard | for consumer data rights. | | The data brokers most likely already have info on you. There is | a catch22 where in order to opt out, you have to tell them who | you are. Other services use your own private email address to | submit the opt outs. We do not share your private email address | with any third party, including the data brokers we submit opt | outs to. | 123pie123 wrote: | I've no idea if you're legit or not, | | but wouldn't a bad actor say the same thing? | | why should people trust you with their information? | Hallucinaut wrote: | Hey there, good luck with the venture and look forward to an | EU/UK option. | | Just wanted to say IANAL but with putting your details out | there as a founder and being in the US, unless you've had a | lawyer check over your statements I would be very cautious | about naming companies specifically. Would recommend | anonymising it or deleting that comment if you can't edit it, | unless you've already had it checked out. | | Ethics isn't part of their business model so any statement | without hard facts backing it can get you into trouble. | johnrob wrote: | Sadly, I doubt the brokers have much concern about their data | being inaccurate! | gigel82 wrote: | I used a tool like this posted to HackerNews a couple years | back (against my better judgement, eh), and the information | on a few of the data brokers afterwards was not only not | removed but actually showed a green checkmark ("verified"). | | It's entirely possible the data brokers are simply using the | "opt out" requests as a way to validate the data, but it's | just as likely that the tool works with the brokers to | confirm information instead of actually removing it. | photoGrant wrote: | All you need to know: | | > If you purchase a paid subscription plan, as a condition to | fulfilling your subscription plan, (i) you must provide your | personally identifiable information("PII") such as full name, | birth year and home address to Optery, Inc. and (ii) Optery, Inc. | must send your PII to the data brokers and information | aggregators included in the Removal Lists. This information is | required by the data brokers and information aggregators in order | to locate your record(s) and remove you from their database(s). | We cannot control, guarantee or warranty how these third-parties | will treat your PII or what they will do with it. By purchasing | and maintaining an active paid subscription, you approve Optery, | Inc. to submit your PII to data brokers and information | aggregators for the purposes submitting opt out, suppression and | removal requests. If you do not wish to submit your PII to data | brokers and information aggregators for the purposes submitting | opt out, suppression and removal requests, then you should not | use Optery, Inc.'s Removal Services. | crummy wrote: | how exactly would it work otherwise? | orf wrote: | USA only. Not particularly clear. Seems cool though. | beyondd wrote: | Sorry about that. We just updated our sign up page to make this | more clear. | TheFreim wrote: | > After many years working at data brokers | | So you worked for years at (immoral) data harvesters but now | you're a changed man who pinky swears to not use people's data | they submit to you in a bad way? Sorry, I don't trust this | product yet. | quickthrower2 wrote: | The only way I'd trust such a service is if it's domain name | ends in .gov (or equivalent for other countries) and is free or | a nominal fee. | shrimpx wrote: | The USDS should work on stuff like this. | | https://www.usds.gov | bberenberg wrote: | I don't understand why I need to upgrade from Core to Extended to | find out if Ultimate is right for me? | beyondd wrote: | That's a great question. This is our first time sharing | publicly, and this is great feedback that we might we need to | change that. | | The intention is to tier the paid version of the product in | terms of price and value, but that may not be the best place to | do it. | | That said, as soon as you receive your Exposure Report by email | (typically within ~24 hours), it will include screen shots for | the data brokers covered by the Ultimate plan, so you will have | some visibility there for help deciding. | dgeiser13 wrote: | I signed up for an account and all I see on the dashboard is... | | "Application error: a client-side exception has occurred | (developer guidance)." ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2021-06-28 23:00 UTC)