[HN Gopher] Stepping Back from Speaking ___________________________________________________________________ Stepping Back from Speaking Author : alfredbez Score : 322 points Date : 2021-06-29 15:14 UTC (7 hours ago) (HTM) web link (martinfowler.com) (TXT) w3m dump (martinfowler.com) | dom96 wrote: | Martin mentions online talks explicitly as something that he | found even harder, but the reference is to talks that are still | done live. I wonder if pre-recorded talks would alleviate some of | the stress/anxiety. | | Personally I loved the opportunity I got to pre-record a talk and | then allow the conference organisers to premiere it on | YouTube[1]. It works incredibly well and enables speakers to | answer questions live while the talk is played. I hope more | conferences adopt this. | | 1 - | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lxLL3km21Aw&list=PLxLdEZg8DR... | legerdemain wrote: | Thank you, Uncle Bob, for stating the obvious. As we enter an era | where remote, distributed work is common, normalized, and, nay, | even _the default_ , we will quickly realize that human contact | at work is unnecessary. | | That teammate tapping you on the shoulder to ask you "a quick | question"? An unnecessary distraction. A daily standup where you | take turns passing a ball around and making up a 30-second | summary of what you did yesterday? A stressful and useless waste | of time. | | Outside of companies heavy on the office politics, it should | quickly become obvious that full-remote, full-async teams are far | more effective, and sanity will finally prevail. | jrochkind1 wrote: | Martin Fowler is not "Uncle Bob". And "thank you for stating | the obvious" is usually an insult in American English. | | If you're wondering why you're getting downvoted, might be one | of those. | legerdemain wrote: | Are you... complaining about downvoting _on my behalf_? How | absurd. | jrochkind1 wrote: | Nope, wasn't complaining. | dbt00 wrote: | I think it's incorrect to assume that your preferred working | pattern (remote) is universally good for other people, even | setting aside the legitimate concerns about interruptions, | daily standups (something plenty of remote teams do), or office | politics. | | I don't like any of that latter group of things. I still work | much better in on a team that I see every day and my | productivity suffers immensely when working remotely and not | talking to other people. | | "This works for me, it should work for everyone." is an | antipattern. | goshx wrote: | What a relief. I thought he was going to announce a new | architecture/methodology and we'd have to start bracing ourselves | to convince our developers they don't need to shift to it right | away. | | Jokes aside, kudos to Mr Fowler for the decision. I'm sure we are | all going to benefit even more from his focus to writing and | things that don't make him miserable. | fossuser wrote: | I can relate to the anxiety before something like that which | often then disappears when you start. | | I feel similarly before technical interviews and it's really | unpleasant, the fear holds you back from doing things you'd | otherwise want to do. | | It's hard to evaluate sometimes or be honest with yourself if | you're making a decision based on what you want or if it's a | rationalization to avoid the fear. | | I often suspect a lot of the dismissals of technical interviews | are more about rationalizing responses to the fear. | | It makes me wonder though, does he dislike giving talks or is it | mostly the anxiety that he dislikes? They're hard to separate. I | can understand giving up on one to avoid the other. | | I think most people don't face the anxiety directly, they tend to | avoid the task and stay in their comfortable zone - I can | definitely understand why. It's cool he faced it for the amount | of time he did. | mathattack wrote: | This is true of a lot of things. It also appears in athletics. | Most competitors get very anxious. (Even Mike Tyson in his | prime!) but once you're in the zone, the anxiety goes away. | | We are all nervous in job interviews. The best ones flow once | they start. | fossuser wrote: | Yeah - I think it's a normal human experience, but there's a | spectrum of intensity. It becomes a problem when it starts | limiting you from doing what you want to do. | | Bobby Fischer was also terrified before chess matches, Elon | Musk says he's terrified of things failing all the time. I | think bravery/courage it's not so much not being afraid, but | being afraid and coming up with strategies to push through | anyway. | | For sports two tennis players come to mind too, Naomi Osaka | recently but there was another earlier (I think Mardy Fish?). | | I think different people feel the level of fear at different | intensities though - probably a mixture of genetics and | parenting. The physical symptoms are the worst part (waking | up hyperventilating, etc.) | throwawayboise wrote: | I think people who really experience no nervousness or | anxiety before doing something with a risk of failure | either don't care at all, or are just bullshitters (in the | Harry Frankfurt definition). It's likely that they are | somewhere on the sociopathic spectrum. | raegis wrote: | I understand your feelings, but I disagree. The first | time I stood in front of a classroom (~30 years ago) I | was visibly shaking from nervousness. Over the years I've | learned that everyone is human, makes mistakes, and | sometimes their minds just go blank. Nowadays the only | time I get anxiety over a presentation is when I'm not | prepared. I think of public speaking not so much as a | performance, but as an opportunity to share one or two | simple ideas with the audience. Some may receive it well, | and some not, but that's true with most interactions. | Most nice people won't fault you for trying to be | helpful. | | Oh, and by the way, I'm not a sociopath :) | sangnoir wrote: | > We are all nervous in job interviews. The best ones flow | once they start. | | I've found I'm least anxious in interviews where I don't feel | like I _need_ to get the job, e.g. at an org that 's not at | the top of my list, or when the desire to switch employers is | not urgent or desperate[1]. | | If you have the time, and the experience is not traumatic, | I'd encourage everyone to interview once a year (or once | every 2 years) even if you're happy with your current | position. At worst, you bomb out of an interview for a job | you never really wanted; at best, you can a find out that the | job is actually interesting (or pays more, or both). You may | even get a raise and keep your old job. In any of the cases, | you likely come out a little better at interviewing. | | 1. Which means you shouldn't wait until it's too late to | switch jobs. If you see any warning signs, start sending out | feelers, if you wait until you can't stand the sight of your | manager (or cubicle/corporate logo), then your job search | might feel urgent, which is not good if you're not a natural | interviewee. | mathattack wrote: | Very true. There's a fine line between having a chip on | your shoulder and desperation on your forehead. | dmoy wrote: | > It also appears in athletics | | In precision shooting, any anxiety absolutely destroys your | scores. When your heartbeat alone is enough to drop points | directly, anxiety is brutal. | | It wouldn't surprise me at all if a lot of top precision | shooters were on beta blockers. | mathattack wrote: | Every sport has it's Performance Enhancing Drugs. Even | chess and eSports. | cmckn wrote: | I too get _really_ anxious when I have to give a presentation | or do an interview. Beta blockers like propranolol have been | incredible for these moments. I don't take them every time, and | I luckily don't face these situations very often. I wouldn't | encourage anyone to dedicate their life to a career that they | need medication to survive, doesn't seem like a good trade off | to me. But if you find this to be a real negative thing in your | life, you have options besides deep breathing and power poses! | Talk to your doctor :) | fossuser wrote: | Interesting about the beta blockers - docs mostly seem pretty | clueless about this kind of thing and often suggest | benzodiazepines (lorazepam, alprazolam, etc.) or SSRIs - | neither of which I really want to take given their negative | effects. | ketzo wrote: | Yeah, seriously. A friend and I in college were talking about | how we handle our pre-presentation nerves, and I was | suggesting she should try deep breaths, counting to ten, | etc.; meanwhile, she would routinely go into full-body fight- | or-flight mode, panic attacks, barely able to speak. | | Yeah... "count to ten" is probably insufficient for that! Her | body needed more help managing her chemical response to | stress. Same thing for her -- beta blockers (propranolol too, | actually) were a _complete_ life change. | | Just to hit it on the head for anyone reading: everyone has | anxiety, it's a normal part of life. If you find yourself | _physically incapacitated_ by anxiety on a regular basis, | that 's not something everyone deals with, and you can | absolutely seek the help of a psychologist or psychiatrist! | siavosh wrote: | I wanted to only comment that I admire the bravery of the author | being so open about such personal fears like this. Many times | it's safer to not open up because there maybe little to gain and | potentially a lot to lose. | aksss wrote: | It's normal to have anxiety about public speaking. It's also | within reach of most to overcome it. I think taking meds for it | is not a good practice at all. | | It's important to distinguish the fear you may have of speaking | in front of people from the fear you may have of presenting | incorrect material. If you're giving an instructional speech | about a practice/process that's well known with zero controversy, | and which you are very familiar with, do you still have anxiety? | | That's a different breed of anxiety than when you are postulating | in front of a crowd of peers about fringe techniques that you may | harbor doubts about yourself (a new way to do a process, or a | change to the accepted standard, or a new interpretation of | history, etc). | | It's important to distinguish what's causing the anxiety because | the fix is different for these two issues. For the latter, it's | building confidence in your own preparation and learning. Do you | know what you're talking about? Could you put it on paper and | publish it and not look like a jackass? If so, carry on. | | For the former - like you just get anxiety from talking in front | of people even about material that is uncontroversial - the key | is kind of a mind trick on yourself. For me, I try to find some | aspect of the topic that I really love and enjoy, and am | fascinated by. If I can do that, my mind is focused on giving and | sharing that fascination, and all anxiety goes away. | | That said, I started speaking publicly in high school as part of | Academic Decathlon - speech competitions and the like. I remember | being anxious about doing that in the same way I would be anxious | about a school musical. As a kid, overcoming that and just doing | it is the first step to learning how to enjoy it. | | I highly recommend that parents expose their kids to this early - | school plays, speech competitions - if they have the opportunity | to do so. With most skills in life, exposure to it as a kid helps | greatly. | | As an adult, I look back on those younger days about stressing | over a two-minute speech with some amusement. Now I have zero | problem talking for 40+ minutes. It's not something I every | worked up to like reps of an exercise, it's just the relatively | simple trick of falling in love with subject matter and having | confidence that you know the material and have seen a thing or | two that gives you some authority (road mileage) on the topic. | Probably also advantageous as an adult to recognize that | EVERYBODY out there in the world is fundamentally a hack in life, | just trying to get by day-by-day, the same as you, wanting to | understand things and for people to treat them with dignity. | | Speaking is serving - think of it that way and (for me at least) | anxiety goes away. | anyfoo wrote: | For me, the dread is in the _preparation_. Once I 'm on the | proverbial stage, everything is usually good if I have prepared a | good presentation. There is definitely some pre-stage anxiety, | but I know it will go away when I actually present. | | But the preparation, I hate it so much. Sitting in front of that | empty window and trying to come up with something that makes | sense, then refactoring it multiple times. Practicing, | identifying stumbling points, fixing them... I put it off as long | as I can, but not how I put off some programming work if it's | boring, instead I put it off because of how dreadful it feels. | This is somewhat of a vicious cycle, because there's only so much | on-stage adrenaline and maybe resulting improvisation power can | do: To have a good talk, you _have_ to have a good preparation, | but if you put it off because it is so anxiety-inducing, the fear | that you are not prepared enough as a result is even more | anxiety-inducing. | throwawayboise wrote: | "I've reached the point in my life where I'm lucky enough to be | able to avoid things that make me miserable" | | I'm there. I've reached a point in my evolution as a programmer | that I have ways I like to do things. Ways that work for me. | Unfortunately they are not popular. But I'm tired of working on | stuff the way others want it done. I'm teetering on the brink of | either early retirement or contract work with a strict "my way or | the highway" approach. We'll see what happens. | [deleted] | UncleOxidant wrote: | Good for him. As someone who struggles with serious anxiety | issues I decided not to do interviewing anymore as it just became | too debilitating - days of worrying before the interview, the | feeling of dread and doom. That point in the interview when the | interviewer says "Ok, now I'm going to ask you a few technical | questions..." my heart rate would skyrocket and I'd start | sweating perfusely. It's just really difficult to shine in an | interview when you're also fighting to stay lucid, let alone | calm. It's like there are all these processes that suddenly spin | up and swamp your mental CPU. I'm retired from interviewing. | ogjunkyard wrote: | I mean this question is the most empathetic way possible, from | a curiosity-based perspective, and feel free to tell me to | shove off if you don't want to answer it. | | How do you gain employment in the event you decide you need to | leave your current place of employment? | [deleted] | UncleOxidant wrote: | I have no current place of employment. I'm fortunate to be | able to live without paid work for a long while. I'm possibly | even retired from paid work altogether and not just from | interviewing. This has happened a few years earlier than I | had thought it would. I'm definitely in the "leanfire" | category - I can be retired, but I'm going to have to be | pretty frugal. | | That said, I do occasionally get contract gigs through people | I've worked with in the past where there are no interviews | required, it's more like "Hey, we need someone to do this | project and we know you can do it because you've done similar | in the past - can you help us out?" | ogjunkyard wrote: | That's awesome to hear and I appreciate the answer! | atulatul wrote: | Very good communicator. And one of the most 'balanced' speakers. | I have seen a few people get so stuck in topics that they forget | about the bigger contexts (for example, craftsmanship, | microservices). He always looked pragmatic in his approach (for | example, tech debt). Possibly because he is not only a consultant | but works for a company that delivers things into production- and | comes up with radar). | | He can explain the overall concepts very well. You can then go | into details. (Refactoring book, UML distilled, NoSQL distilled, | etc. I even learned LMAX first from his bliki.) | | Going by blogs on his site and his signature series books, I | certainly look forward to things he will write/ contribute to. | asmos7 wrote: | There have been a lot of character assassination's on prominent | white men in the conference space by far left extremists. I | wonder how much of his anxiety can be attributed to seeing | colleagues go through that? | mttjj wrote: | Care to explain the connection between your unsubstantiated | claim and the original article? | tester756 wrote: | I think he's talking about cancel culture inside Scala | Community | | e.g | https://twitter.com/skillsmatter/status/1168944236181557254 | busterarm wrote: | I used to volunteer at a lot of conferences. Especially the | opportunities to mentor people who receive sponsored attendance | based on being from an underrepresented community. | | After seeing some heavily charged scenarios play out where it | seemed like situations were grossly misinterpreted or | expectations were wildly out of whack (none that I was party | to, just as a bystander), I no longer do any kind of conference | volunteering. I also no longer interact with anyone I don't | know _very well_ outside of large groups. | | Basically I limit my stranger-interactions to group lunches. | Out of personal caution/safety. That also eliminates the only | reasons to go to most conferences, so my schedule is a lot more | open. | slver wrote: | Unexpectedly personal, but I'm happy he's sharing this with us. | We're all human, eh? | sumnole wrote: | He's a human with superhuman writing ability. It's good he's | not stepping back from authoring. I can understand not wanting | to face situations that make you miserable all the time. | SNosTrAnDbLe wrote: | I am so glad to hear it's not just me. I have recently been doing | some meditation to help me with this. | niix wrote: | Once I figured out what was happening to me was anxiety I also | started exploring meditation. Often times I can feel the | anxiety first thing in the morning and I know I need to have a | nice mediation session to calm me down (and usually the helps | throughout my entire day). And you're definitely not alone, its | way more common than I originally thought as well. | potamic wrote: | Good on him for coming out and saying it straight. So many people | go through such discomfort and are constantly pressured by their | environment to put up with it. You're not encouraged to say no. | It is seen as unnatural. It is career limiting. I do believe the | tech industry puts an unhealthy obsession on public speaking, to | the extent that you aren't considered fit for leadership if you | can't give public talks. | mabbo wrote: | I really like Clean Code and agreed with a lot of the points it | makes. I would be lying if I said Bob Martin hasn't made me a | better programmer. And I can can empathize with what he's saying | about not liking public speaking anymore. | | Despite this, part of me wonders if the reason to pick now as to | time to stop doesn't have something to do with the criticism- | valid or otherwise- he's now receiving. Some of his Clean Code | videos have some pretty offensive stereotypes which have been | pointed out. Some of his loud political views have been | criticized. People are saying they won't share a stage with him. | | People always have reasons to quit but the precise moment they | choose to quit often tells the story of why they're really | quitting. | derekbaker783 wrote: | Isn't this referring to Fowler as opposed to Martin? | [deleted] | radicalbyte wrote: | This post is from Martin Fowler (author of Refactoring, | Patterns of Enterprise Architecture and a fantastic blog) - who | has a much better grasp of software development and who has had | a far greater positive influence on our craft than Robert C. | Martin could ever dream of. | benatkin wrote: | Don't worry - this article isn't about Uncle Bob. | jrochkind1 wrote: | > It's not always been this way. When I was a kid at school I | felt none of the fear of public speaking that others talked | about. I enjoyed being on stage, and with my loud voice and | plenty of confidence, I felt good about being there. That | continued to be true once I entered the world of work, and my | comfort on-stage did much to boost my career. But over time, this | changed. | | I am very curious about this dynamic, and why it changed. | panzagl wrote: | For many people increased anxiety in general is part of the | aging process. | throwawayboise wrote: | Young people, especially young men, tend to be fearless in | general, at least compared to older people. | johnwheeler wrote: | For me, it's somewhat ironic then that during my early software | career (20+ years ago), Fowler's lucid writing helped me through | a lot of the anxiety, insecurity and impostor syndrome I | experienced. | | His work introduced me to eXtreme Programming, UML, Refactoring | and more. Much of the agile tooling used nowadays are a | consequence of effort he and the groups he was a part of put | forth. The book Analysis Patterns is very underrated IMO and was | a breath of fresh air after futzing around with the SAMS Teach | Yourself series books that were undeservingly popular back then. | | I think of Fowler as a virtuoso when it comes to explaining | practical software matters. I haven't watched much of his talks, | but I've read most of his books and PLoP papers. | | I'm glad he's going to focus more on writing and helping others | with theirs. | mavelikara wrote: | +1 on Analysis Patterns. The notation is a little dated, but | the book is still a good read. | HeyLaughingBoy wrote: | +2 and thank you for reminding me that I have a copy of this | book. About to start a new job and it would be worthwhile to | refresh my mind on the concepts. | jjoergensen wrote: | How wonderfully liberating when people dare to be honest with | themselves and others. It's a good thing. | brianmcc wrote: | Fair play to him for coming forward and good luck, I say. | | I always assume that the people doing talks are eager to do so, | or at the very least find the adrenaline etc of the "performance" | worth it when compared to the nerves and work involved. | | I wonder if there are a lot of people in the "don't want to do | this but feel I have to" category. | | (I have no interest in public speaking, and don't make any effort | to be put in such a position) | cableshaft wrote: | There's at least one high-profile performer that had to take a | 5-year break because going on stage gave him anxiety attacks: | Bo Burnham. | | He does a good job describing the experience in this interview: | https://youtu.be/GbS-7jUBJGY | [deleted] | oh_sigh wrote: | Martin - if you're here, and would want to continue speaking were | it not for the physical problems you face - perhaps you should | give beta blockers a shot? Side effects are uncommon, risks are | low, addictive potential is low, so doctors are generally willing | to prescribe them if the patient requests it. | | It sounds like you're just experiencing stage fright. Many | professional performers get this way, and beta blockers have been | shown to help reduce the physical symptoms of stage | fright(tachycardia, sweating, etc): | https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6129674/ | | I had zero problem public speaking in school, or in casual public | speaking (ie addressing participants in a sports league I help | run), but I learned when I was 25 that I actually do have public | speaking anxiety from a professional perspective. Perhaps it is | because school/sports were low-stake activities in my mind, | whereas I know that my professional performance is directly tied | to my ability to support my family. So now I occasionally take a | beta blocker before a big presentation, and they go as smoothly | as my public speaking did back in college. | alexfromapex wrote: | I have tried beta blockers and they really just get rid of the | thumping heart sensation but you're still sweating and | terrified. I have had some good success with taking full B | complex and D vitamins before speaking though. | IsopropylMalbec wrote: | I've had success with Valerian, it is a quite mild sedative | and anti-anxiety root. It's just enough to get over the pre- | presentation anxiety and get in to the flow. | oh_sigh wrote: | Yes, if you have mental problems with public speaking, then | beta blockers will not help you. They only mitigate the | physical symptoms of stage fright. | Wistar wrote: | In the concert piano world, 5mg of Inderal (Propranolol) is a | common pre-performance dose. | | My doctor, who treated a lot of Microsoft folks, told me that | he prescribed a lot of Inderal for those who did a lot of | public speaking. | nr2x wrote: | https://youtu.be/DW5juaLAg28 | cableshaft wrote: | Sure, he could pursue that...or he could just not do the thing | that he hates in the first place, instead of putting foreign | substances (with potential risks and side effects) in his body, | so he can power through it and keep forcing it to happen. | | Not all of us have that luxury, but he seems to. | oh_sigh wrote: | From my understanding of the article, it appears that he | enjoys public speaking, but doesn't enjoy the physical side | effects of it. | hogFeast wrote: | Taking medication doesn't make the problem go away. | | I understand why people do it if their job relies on it...but | the point of taking medication is so you can expose yourself to | the fear, and then don't need the medication at all at some | point...not using it as a coping strategy. | | I have gone through something similar, unfortunately something | significantly more disruptive. And I have succeeded and failed | more than anyone over ten plus years...medication isn't | anything. Your choices are: expose yourself to the situation | and hope it goes away, or avoid it totally (and btw, both are | fine choices...I think people assume that the latter is failure | but life is complicated, sometimes it isn't possible to get | over it...choosing not to do public speaking and talk openly | about why, imo, takes some guts). | xyzelement wrote: | An interesting difference between the original post and a few | comments here is what people did about their anxiety. | | Fowler has powered through it, and although unpleasant he was | able to deliver. He says he felt no right to complain because he | understood that many people do much more objectively risky and | painful things and he was too proud a professional to quit. | | I think the above is a good insight into what success looks like. | It's not that all the right things are easy, it's that the idea | of not doing them scares you more than the pain of doing them. | | Then it seems like he finally got to a place where he knows he's | accomplished and impactful and no longer needs to do the thing he | doesn't like, which is awesome as well. The important thing is | that this happens after success, not before. | | The important thing is "to do." I think in many cases, anxiety | evaporates once you prove to yourself through experience that you | can handle the situation (it's hard to fear something you | survived a thousand times). In his case, the anxiety continued to | be painful but at least he had the intellectual strength to say | "I know this sucks but I know it's not real" and power through. | Which again, powering through - grit - is really important. | | I never had it that hard but I did have massive social anxiety. | If I had to be in a social situation, much less public speaking, | I'd dread and overthink it. And probably if I stayed an IC | engineer i would be able to continue to have this problem | forever. What happened instead is I started to do management and | recruiting and sales - all of which forced me to talk to people | one on one and in groups constantly. I didn't notice when it | happened but one day I realized that my anxiety was gone because | I had disproved its thesis. | | It was funny a few years ago at our wedding, my wife and I forgot | to prepare a speech. We realized this with a few mins to go and | my wife (who is actually very social) went into "oh shit, can you | do this cuz I can't?" mode. I quickly drafted a few points in my | head and delivered a speech I was proud of. It was amazing to | reflect on this as something I could just do, which would have | paralyzed me a few years earlier. | | The point is, do things that genuinely scare you. There's a good | chance you'll realize they are not scary. Or at least like in | Fowlers case you'll recognize that you are able to power through | and get success. | admissionsguy wrote: | I dropped out of my PhD because I could not stand the pressure of | having to do talks regularly. Even though I was pretty decent at | it (I was told my delivery was fine and clarity was superb), and | sometimes felt good ("powerful" for lack of a better word) while | on stage, I would worry for months before every presentation, | then basically get physically sick for weeks before, and take | some weeks more to recover. | | Then one poster I submitted got upgraded to a talk, which brought | me over the tipping point, and I quit. | | I keep wondering if I could have done more to desensitise myself | to it, but the anxiety was never decreasing, if anything, it was | getting worse each time. I tried therapy, medication, | Toastmasters, martial arts classes and dance lessons (which | became my hobby, incidentally), and even vocal lessons (since I | was particularly self-conscious about my voice), all to no avail. | | So now I have a co-founder to do all and any public speaking, and | I do not plan to put myself in front of a crowd ever again. But I | feel I'm missing a part of life by it. | Syzygies wrote: | Six weeks before my thesis defense, I gave a talk at MIT's | combinatorics seminar on Grobner bases. | | We came up with an abstract intended to attract computer | scientists. I was a bit naive about complexity analysis. The | computer scientists came, were quite generous and kind to me as | a graduate student who didn't know, but they were out for blood | when it came to protecting basic concepts. | | I was asked to explain algebraic geometry to complete | beginners, to set the stage for my talk. At the same time, an | algebraic geometry seminar was to meet down the hall. The | speaker was from the university that had just hired me. Two | attendees drew this ridiculous conclusion that my efforts to | computerize algebraic geometry might be the future. They | convinced the organizers to postpone the algebraic geometry | seminar so that they could attend my talk. | | 80 or so of the world's 300 experts in algebraic geometry | showed up with nothing to do for an hour. Guess what they did? | We had to move my room, so they could hear me explain algebraic | geometry to complete beginners. | | Yes I felt ill afterwards. | pyuser583 wrote: | Wow. I'm so sorry. | pbronez wrote: | Organizing an excellent event is hard. There's fundamental | uncertainty about what each presenter will say, and what the | audience needs to hear. The best you can do is try to think | of a high quality theme, get good abstracts from your | speakers, and cobble together an agenda tries to cater to | your audience. From there, it's a crap shoot. | | Don't beat yourself up. You were in a no-win scenario. | Honestly, the best option might have been to go COMPLETELY | off script. Admit to your audience that they know more than | you about the core subject. Just give that to them. Then talk | about why you find the subject interesting, and how it | relates to your work. Maybe even open it up to a Q&A with the | expectation that you'll look kinda dumb but learn a lot. | | Of course, I've stayed far away from academia, so what do I | know. | Syzygies wrote: | Yes. In the years since I've learned that it is better to | go off script. Preparation is so one can react, like a | tennis match. | | After that trial by fire, I've been comfortable before | audiences of a thousand multiple times. Once, asked how I | became the math consultant for "A Beautiful Mind", I looked | out and managed to sell "Every audience is an audience of | one". | | For anxiety, it helps to remember that public speaking is a | cultural ritual. It's not about you, you're playing a role. | | When one gives academic job talks, most professors in the | room don't understand your subject. What they can tell is | whether you listen to questions. How well you answer | questions is everyone's best gauge as to how smart you are. | If the people who know you are already on your side, the | talk itself is a Macguffin. Be truly present at each | question, consider it honestly. | enriquto wrote: | > I would worry for months before every presentation, then | basically get physically sick for weeks before, and take some | weeks more to recover. | | That was _exactly_ me. Fortunately, my PhD advisor noticed the | trend and solved it in a severe but functional way. Starting | from my second year, I was assigned to teach calculus to first- | year computer science undergrads (three groups of about 80 | students each). It was absolutely terrifying. At the beginning | I vomited, had diarrhea, anxiety, the whole pack. But since the | schedule was so intense, somehow my body got used to it. After | a couple of months, I had become desensitized to it, and | actually started enjoying it. | | It may be unusual, but my advisor coached me quite well on how | to teach, and that helped me a lot. A couple of days before my | first class, he asked me how was it going, and I told him that | it was quite bad... then he asked me casually if I had already | prepared my first class (of course, I had spent the entire | summer preparing for it!), and to remind him what was it about, | since it had been a few years since he last taught it. Then I | told him the whole contents of the first session in about 20 | minutes, even reaching for the blackboard to write a couple of | formulas. After that, I said "the way I'm going to explain all | that is...", and he cut me: "no! forget about your preparation. | The informal explanation you just gave is actually a good first | class, just repeat it a bit slowly and call it a day". I knew | he was fucking with me just to calm me down, but this actually | gave me a confidence boost. | | When I had to speak at my first somewhat major conference | venue, I had similar concerns, and he told me "remember the | first course you taught? do exactly the same thing: explain | your stuff to fellow scientists as you would do if you found | them by the coffee machine". | | > But I feel I'm missing a part of life by it. | | Surely not! If you really don't like speaking in public, it's | alright. There's plenty of other things that you are not doing, | and that are not either "a part of life". Nobody can do | everything. | avg_dev wrote: | This is a great story and I think well of your PhD advisor. | dilyevsky wrote: | Used to perform live regularly in front of audiences of up to | 100+ (piano). Never really got over it. In fact it got worse as | I got older. The only thing that ever worked for me is have | everything on muscle memory so I could basically plug my brain | off. I heard people had good experience with beta blockers | tho... | reducesuffering wrote: | Might be worth looking into a beta blocker if it's adversely | affecting your life that much. | | "Musicians, public speakers, actors, and professional dancers | have been known to use beta-blockers to avoid performance | anxiety, stage fright, and tremor during both auditions and | public performances." | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beta_blocker#Anxiety | busyant wrote: | Do you find that you give fewer/zero presentations now with | your current occupation? | | I ask because it seems like many of us still need to give | presentations even outside of academia. | | Hopefully, you're in a position where it's no longer affecting | your health. | | Also, was it the size of the audience? For example, are you | comfortable presenting to a smallish group (e.g., < 10 people)? | | In grad school, I used to memorize my talks (complete with | pauses, "ums...", "uhhs...", etc.). I did this because I was | paranoid that I would forget specific details. It took a while, | but eventually I got comfortable with making presentation | errors. I think my presentations got better as a result, too. | admissionsguy wrote: | I don't have to do any as a web development individual | contributor contractor, nor have I had to do any as part of | my own company so far. I am fairly certain I can avoid it for | the rest of my life, but do not necessarily want to avoid it. | | My anxiety scales with the audience size like it does for | most people, but in a manageable way. For me, the | overwhelming anxiety depends on how much the audience (or the | venue!) reminds my brain of my middle & high school. | | It's much less of a problem for me when the audience is | older. I had no problem presenting/interviewing in front of a | panel of PIs, for example, even got some praise for it, nor | do I find job interviews particularly stressful. Presenting | in front of other students was particularly difficult. It was | really difficult if in addition the room resembled my old | school classrooms (low ceiling, bright, particular chair | design). It didn't help that absent venue information, I | would always imagine the setting to be exactly that. | busyant wrote: | > It was really difficult if in addition the room resembled | my old school classrooms | | My opinion is uninformed here, but it seems like some kind | of therapy (e.g., cbt) might be helpful. | | Thank you for the conversation. | jakobdabo wrote: | Is it really _required_ to do talks? Does that mean that, for | example, people who can 't speak (muteness and similar | disabilities) can not become PhD? | jurassic wrote: | Public speaking is certainly expected. Accommodations might | be possible for somebody with an obvious and documented | disability like muteness, but most people just experience | different levels of anxiety which is considered "normal" and | something you have to get over. You have to realize the PhD | isn't useful on its own; it's just an entry ticket to a | community where you will be in continuous collaboration / | idea exchange for decades. Really difficult to do that | successfully if you have crippling anxiety. It's just not the | right fit for everybody. | | Full disclosure: I also quit my PhD, for different reasons. | alexfromapex wrote: | I think this goes hand-in-hand with recent research about | psychological safety at work. If you are forced to give the | talks, you don't feel psychologically safe because your | livelihood is being used as leverage to make you give talks. If, | on the other hand, they encourage you to give talks but don't | force it it's much easier to cope with and less stressful. | binaryanomaly wrote: | Do more of what makes you happy. All the best! | stadium wrote: | Appreciate the vulnerability. "Powering through" mental health | problems is so common, maybe even expected in some cultures. Your | courage to talk publicly about your personal struggles with | anxiety will surely help others to set boundaries and manage | their own struggles in healthy ways. | [deleted] | kentonv wrote: | I get this too. | | Meanwhile, I wonder: are talks even worth it? A blog post can | reach orders of magnitude more people, can be edited to | perfection in advance, and is much easier for most people to | consume (supports searching, skimming, quoting, out-of-order | reading etc.). Even the Q&A part is much better conducted on a | site like HN than live. | | It seems to me that a good blog post is strictly better than a | talk. Yet we're willing to spend way more money and effort on | talks, for some reason? | campbel wrote: | Yes! part of my speech anxiety is because the REASON to do it | is so lacking. When I feel the importance of what I'm | communicating it's almost entirely gone, but when I'm just up | there spewing them same tired shit I can't get out of my head. | adimitrov wrote: | I disagree. I prefer talks, most of the time, especially on | stuff that isn't nitty gritty technical. Do I want someone | explaining to me on stage how to install minikube and deploy a | container? Hell no. | | But take what Fowler did, namely talking about refactoring, | organizing and structuring your code - the broad strokes stuff. | I think it's a lot more enjoyable and effective to listen to a | talk (esp in person) for that, than it is to read about it. | | Humans are social creatures, and I do enjoy the human aspect of | learning from another human. Teaching is performative. I don't | get that from a text as much as from a talk. | | Of course, everyone's different, and that's why it's good it | doesn't have to be either or. | flakiness wrote: | "As I steadily get more disconnected from the day-to-day of | software development, I feel I provide my greatest value by | helping improve communication from those who have that | connection." | | I'm a big fan of his writing, including the "Refactoring" book | [1], which has changed my life. So it's a bit sad to read this | admission. But I appreciate his honesty. Wondering if this | "detached" feeling is attributed to the anxiety he has felt on | the speaking side. | | Anyway, I hope he keeps writing. It doesn't have to be a great | hit like, say "Microsevices" [2]. I believe it can be more | personal. I'd like to learn what experienced people like him | think about things happening in the software development world. | | (Probably I'll even enjoy reading about what he does on his | "indulge" time. That's what the fandom is like.) | | [1] https://www.amazon.com/Refactoring-Improving-Existing- | Addiso... | | [2] https://martinfowler.com/articles/microservices.html | nickkell wrote: | Wow, he really hid it well. I remember thinking how composed he | was and how clearly he communicated whilst watching videos of him | speak | foobarbazetc wrote: | FWIW, these are classic panic attacks. | | Usually the stressor is obvious, but sometimes it's not and it's | something you've left unresolved that your subconscious gets | caught up on from time to time. | | It might not be the talks themselves. It could be anything. | | If you've never had a panic attack before and start getting | these, it literally feels like you're going to die the first time | you get one. Then you get used to them and start adjusting. | | I went through a period of panic attacks after acquisition talks | with a giant corp fell through. I was messed up for years after | that, with random panic attacks at all times of day. | | I worked on returning myself to my previously chill demeanor and | haven't had one for many years now. | | I also stopped answering any VC/BizDev/CorpDev emails though. | lol. But mostly out of a desire to optimize my time use for | things that actually matter. | | Good luck Martin. Covid has certainly put the value of living the | life you truly want for yourself into perspective and I hope you | achieve that. | MeinBlutIstBlau wrote: | The key to anxiety issues related to speaking is not to worry | about making a mistake or a faux pas. I don't know but my whole | life, anytime anybody asked me to do something in front of others | it was never an issue. The odd thing was, the more impromptu the | easier. That's because there is absolutely no expectations by the | audience then at that point. Prepared stuff nobody cares if you | come reading off of a paper, so long as you aren't staring at it | but glance at it from time to time. | | The ultimate way to do this though is go out and try new things. | Feel vulnerable and interact with the world, and others, with a | sort of whimsy. And have fun with it. Remember that the audience | is being held hostage in the situation too! | ChrisMarshallNY wrote: | I've done a lot of public speaking. Not really keynote stuff, and | probably not to audiences more than a couple hundred, and I've | never been paid for it. | | I've not gotten particularly good at it. As I often say: "I'm | quite comfortable, speaking in public, but I'm not very good at | it. That's a really bad combination." | drkrab wrote: | Thanks for all the talks Martin | | https://youtu.be/qI_g07C_Q5I ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2021-06-29 23:00 UTC)