[HN Gopher] Launch HN: Fella (YC W20) - Tackling men's obesity u... ___________________________________________________________________ Launch HN: Fella (YC W20) - Tackling men's obesity using medication and coaching Hey HN! I'm Richie from Fella (https://www.joinfella.com), a telehealth clinic for men with obesity. Fella helps men get to a healthier weight by matching them with a board-certified obesity doctor to prescribe an FDA-approved medication, while they undertake personalized health coaching. I personally struggled with stress eating for 6 years. During that time, I was at Cambridge University, then built and sold my first company working with the UK government. It was tough, and poor eating habits as a teenager became a coping mechanism as an adult. Fella first started as a "CBT+community" product to help men battling stress eating. It resonated due to the stigma around men's eating struggles. But we realized we were only half-serving most of our customers: even when no longer stress eating, most guys weren't getting to a healthier weight. So we started researching effective, evidence-based treatments for obesity. When I say "we", I really mean my co-founder Luke. He studied medicine at Cambridge University, developing a patented AI approach to detecting cancer at a YC bio company, before moving to Microsoft Research. He parses bio papers better than me... Obesity treatment is about to radically change. This is thanks to a breakthrough medication -- NY Times called it a "game changer" in Feb 2021 [1]. The medication was approved by the FDA in June 2021 [2]. It leads to an average 15% decrease in body weight, efficacy close to bariatric surgery [3]. However, medication-assisted treatment for obesity is still stigmatized by family doctors and therefore hard to access. Moreover, only 10% of those using weight management services are men, despite men representing 50% of those with obesity. This is because almost all programs market to women, placing too much emphasis on looks and not enough on health for a male audience. Stress eating is widespread among bigger guys, but mostly ignored -- with too much focus on willpower and "eat less, move more". This needs to change. So we pivoted to the Fella you see today: a telehealth experience with a board-certified obesity doctor for FDA-approved medication, combined with personalized health coaching. We went live in Texas in July, and are soon to be live in California and New York. Fella is a 12-month program and costs $149/month, paid quarterly. We'll bring costs down over time to improve accessibility. We still have lots of difficulties ahead. The main one could be insurance reimbursement: the latest wave of medications are expensive and insurers don't like to cover them [4]. We're excited to hear your ideas, questions, concerns, feedback -- and maybe any personal stories. I'll be responding to comments all day, or feel free to shoot me an email at richie@joinfella.com. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/10/health/obesity-weight-los... [2] https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-appr... [3] https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2032183 [4] https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-07-19/weight... Author : rich-cartwright Score : 113 points Date : 2021-08-21 14:36 UTC (8 hours ago) | utunga wrote: | You went to Cambridge how hard is it to understand that some | people on the internet don't live in the US?? | | I clicked on "are you eligible?" in attempt to determine exactly | this question - but instead endured literally fifteen screens of | Jedi mind trick sales process bullshit before finally hitting the | old "What state are you in?" drop down that doesn't even give an | option outside the US. | | Why? | | I hope you do one day make this service available overseas.. But | in the meantime you've managed to really piss me off | rich-cartwright wrote: | I'm really sorry - I honestly thought we'd added that in | yesterday in prep for having more exposure via HN. Very much my | bad. | | If you still want to go down on our waitlist, please do drop me | a line on richie@joinfella.com | rich-cartwright wrote: | Hey folks, Richie here, co-founder of Fella. I'll be responding | to comments all day, or feel free to shoot me an email at | richie@joinfella.com. | | If you'd like to check out the site: https://www.joinfella.com/ | qeternity wrote: | Best intern we ever had ;) | rich-cartwright wrote: | Haha fancing seeing you here | MattGaiser wrote: | Ever think of branching into addiction? That's another place | where evidence based care is sorely lacking. | rich-cartwright wrote: | It's a possibility. There's already another YC co doing great | things in the addiction space: https://www.quitgenius.com/ | | We'll have to see. We have a long way to go in the coming years | reaching the 35 million men in the US who are fighting obesity. | dave333 wrote: | How long before there's a generic version of these drugs, | Semaglutide and Liraglutide? I assume Medicare doesn't cover | these yet. | thegypsyking wrote: | What visa are you guys on in the us? I work at big corp on l1 and | would love to be a founder but waiting for green card... | lharries wrote: | You could go the O1 route. The Peter Roberts HN posts (the | immigration attorney who does work for YC startups) has lots of | great info on this area: | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27560781 | thegypsyking wrote: | I'm aware about it in theory, but I think for people already | in us on a work visa it's a chicken and egg problem between | starting and getting the o1. I can't start anything as I can | only work for my employer, and I can't get an o1 because I | can't start anything. Looks like the founders are not | interested in answering this one. | rich-cartwright wrote: | We're actually not based in the US right now as we had to | return home for covid, and we're building a remote co. | | To be honest we sadly don't have any useful advice for US | visas: it's not a fun system. | | Only thing is it's now more possible than ever to soak up | US culture, run a US-focused company, but not be based in | the US. But that's not what you wanna hear if you've built | your life there. I'm sorry we can't be more helpful | thegypsyking wrote: | Thanks for answering! I guess it's true remote work is | taking over, good luck with everything! | ChemSpider wrote: | The catch with this "wonder drug" semaglutide is: It has to be | taken _life-long_, not just during a diet! | | So when you are 30 now, you will be on medication for the next | 40+ years. This is a long time. | | => Long term side effects are not known yet. In animal studies, | semaglutide caused thyroid tumors or thyroid cancer. It is not | known whether these effects would occur in people using regular | doses. | lharries wrote: | (Richie's co-founder here) | | > The catch with this "wonder drug" semaglutide is: It has to | be taken _life-long_, not just during a diet! | | This is why the coaching part of the program is so important. | | Whether it's taken for a while or just for the first year will | depend on the person, whether they are also diabetic and how | much weight they have to lose. It's a personalized decision | based on a conversation with their obesity doctor. | | After around 12-months on these medications the weight loss | plateaus (at an average of 15% body weight). If one stops the | medication then but hasn't made any changes to their lifestyle | they'll likely put the weight back on. But during the 12 months | of the program we will be tackling the other factors with the | coach: sleep, stress, nutrition. And so after the first year it | might well make sense to reduce the medication or stop | completely. | | It's also likely we'll continue to see new medications and | improvements with our understanding of obesity that makes being | on this particular medication for 40+ years very unlikely. | | > Long term side effects are not known yet. In animal studies, | semaglutide caused thyroid tumors or thyroid cancer. It is not | known whether these effects would occur in people using regular | doses. | | Semaglutide was FDA approved for diabetes in 2018 (3 years ago) | and in June this year for weight management. It's part of a | class of medication called GLP-1 RAs which operate in a similar | way (they all stimulate the same GLP-1 receptor). Liraglutide | is another common one that was approved by the FDA in 2010 (11 | years ago) for diabetes (by the EU in 2009) and for weight | management in 2014. So there is a 3 year of history with this | particular medication and an 11 year history for this class of | medication. | | Here's more about the history of GLP-1s and other weight loss | if you'd like: | https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2021/02/15/gl... | | It's worth noting that, as with any medication, there is a | cost-benefit trade-off. In this case it will depend on | someone's current weight, what they've tried in the past, and | the risks of other conditions e.g. heart disease, diabetes, and | their past medical history. Each person that joins Fella has an | in-depth discussion about this with an independent obesity | physician and is welcome to speak it through with their own PCP | too. | | https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2032183 | bambax wrote: | Do you plan to open in Europe at some point? | rich-cartwright wrote: | 100%. We're actually British founders so it's been a baptism of | fire learning about the nuances of US healthcare! That said, | the US is the focus for the moment, so we're not planning to | expand to Europe for quite a while. | danpalmer wrote: | What was the reason for going after the US market instead of | the UK market? | | I'm in the UK and would love to try Fella, especially if I | could get it on the NHS with a GP referral. | rich-cartwright wrote: | UK market is tricky for a few reasons. Very centralized | decision-making for healthcare funding, and the timelines | are too long for a startup to survive. Plus us Brits are | definitely more hesitant of medication approaches in | general, although that is changing. | | Both my parents, my sister and my brother-in-law work in | the NHS - so lots of interesting family conversations about | this! | f6v wrote: | > What was the reason for going after the US market instead | of the UK market? | | Might have something to do with exorbitant amount of money | in the US healthcare. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Bigger spend is definitely important. Drug approval, | decentralized decision making, consumer norms all also | important. | newsclues wrote: | Canada? | rich-cartwright wrote: | Not for the coming year. We'd love to as soon as we have | capacity! | [deleted] | Eextra953 wrote: | Great Idea!I checked out the website and it looks like it is | targeted towards older men (40+). Was there any particular | reasoning for this? I'm in my 20s and I know a lot of men my age | who are obese. Was the program developed specifically for older | men? | rich-cartwright wrote: | Really good question. In our customer dev, we tended to find | the older guys were a more motivated initial audience because | health concerns are more top of mind. Plus there's still a lot | of hesitancy & stigma around medication for obesity, but the | older guys are more ready to take that step. | | Fella works just as well for younger guys. Any more questions I | can answer? | aadvani wrote: | A lot of docs I know are prescribing GLP1s already for weight | loss, off label. When they get RCT data, get coverage, you guys | will be way ahead. Congrats, amazing concept. | aadvani wrote: | I remember reading studies of 30-36 lbs in a year, IF they | maintain diet and exercise. I see this adherence as your | competitive advantage. | rich-cartwright wrote: | 15% average body weight loss was the breakthrough study: | https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2032183 | | Important to emphasize that diet & exercise are only two | parts of broader metabolic health. Sleep also very important. | | And something our program focuses a lot on is stress eating. | Very prevalent and a big factor, but normally overlooked. | dlevine wrote: | I have done just about everything over the years to lose weight. | I tend to exercise a ton naturally, so it has been more about | eating less than exercising more. I would say that my natural | weight is slightly overweight but not obese. | | I've tried various brands of keto (Atkins/4 Hour Body), Weight | Watchers, eating slowly, cutting out sugar and wheat, juice | fasts. Everything has worked for a time, but the weight has | eventually crept back. I have really good willpower, but I've | read the research on willpower being a resource that you use up, | and definitely agree with it. | | For the past couple of months I have been on Noom. I have stuck | to it, and I'm now thinner than I have been in a long time, but | I'm a little bit skeptical that it's going to last long-term. But | I'm getting married in less than 2 months, so I only need to stay | where I am until the wedding, and then I can gain a few pounds. | reilly3000 wrote: | Hate to say it but marriage is a sure formula for men's weight | gain. | Hallucinaut wrote: | And any subsequent kids are an exponential... at least during | lockdown for me | rich-cartwright wrote: | There's a lot going on in terms of the kids angle: | increased stress, sleep deprivation, hormone changes, less | time for exercise & healthy eating. Not easy. | watwut wrote: | Is it possible that you are at healthy weight for you? Because | given lifestyle you described, it is quite possible. | criticaltinker wrote: | > I've read the research on willpower being a resource that you | use up, and definitely agree with it | | I don't enjoy subjecting you to cognitive dissonance here...but | some highly cited research shows this belief may be a self | fulfilling prophecy. | | _> Study 1 found that individual differences in lay theories | about willpower moderate ego-depletion effects: People who | viewed the capacity for self-control as not limited did not | show diminished self-control after a depleting experience._ [1] | | _> Study 2 replicated the effect, manipulating lay theories | about willpower._ [1] | | _> Study 3 addressed questions about the mechanism underlying | the effect. _ [1] | | _> Study 4, a longitudinal field study, found that theories | about willpower predict change in eating behavior, | procrastination, and self-regulated goal striving in depleting | circumstances. _ [1] | | _> Taken together, the findings suggest that reduced self- | control after a depleting task or during demanding periods may | reflect people's beliefs about the availability of willpower | rather than true resource depletion. _ [1] | | [1] Ego Depletion--Is It All in Your Head? Implicit Theories | About Willpower Affect Self-Regulation | http://icelab.psych.uw.edu.pl/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/job... | | [2] Beliefs about willpower determine the impact of glucose on | self-control | https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/110/37/14837.full.pdf | dlevine wrote: | Interesting! Thanks for sharing. | pbhjpbhj wrote: | Maybe the beliefs come from experiences of different 'types' | and the types cause the beliefs? | rich-cartwright wrote: | Interesting, reading this now. | rich-cartwright wrote: | "so I only need to stay where I am until the wedding, and then | I can gain a few pounds" - this is interesting | sergiomattei wrote: | Hi folks, congratulations on the launch. | | Are you considering expanding services for other chronic eating | disorders? For example, chronic under eating. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Interesting question. We're no longer coming at this from an ED | angle - I could & should write a whole blog about this at some | point! Quick take: tackling obesity from a wider health angle | (metabolic health, psychological health, behavioral health) is | more needed than a narrower focus. | | A impressive co focused on serious, udner-eating EDs is | https://equip.health/ if you're interested | peteretep wrote: | I had been very, very excited to start semaglutide, but about | eight weeks ago I picked up a CBT-based eating book called The | Beck Diet Solution and I've so far found it very very effective | rich-cartwright wrote: | Yep CBT (and third wave cognitive therapies in general) are | very effective against emotion-based overeating (e.g. stress | eating). Stress eating is widespread and addressing it is a | core part of our coaching. | | Important to say not everyone struggles with stress eating, | which is why our coaching program goes much broader than that. | | The metabolic medication aspect is also really helpful, which | is why we combine the two for Fella. | Smaug123 wrote: | Not to suggest anything about your personal experience, but | note that in general pretty much anyone can follow pretty much | any diet for two months and lose weight if they try. The | seriously hard bit - and the way you know you've found the | right diet for you - is if you can follow it for the third | month (and then all the months thereafter). Two months is | roughly the upper limit for the "any diet will work for anyone" | effect. | impostervt wrote: | Only available in Texas currently. When's the nationwide rollout? | Any more precise than "soon"? | rich-cartwright wrote: | It's tough with the state-by-state regulation. CA & NY are in | the coming month or two. Then the plan is the next 5-10 states | by end of Q1 2022. We'll be sprinting to go fully nationwide by | end of 2022. | newman8r wrote: | Is this just because of the prescription drug element of your | program? If there weren't any medications involved, would you | need any state certifications? | rich-cartwright wrote: | Yep exactly - the prescription drug element requires state- | by-state medicine licenses. | invokestatic wrote: | Not affiliated, but I believe with every telemedicine company, | the care providers need a medical license in each and every | state they have patients in. So it will likely be a long time | before they have "nationwide" coverage. This is why many | telemedicine startups are only in a select handful of states. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Exactly this! Got there before me. | derektlo wrote: | Hey Richie we can help with that :) https://medallion.co/ | rich-cartwright wrote: | Emailed you! | deberon wrote: | As somebody who has lost and gained weight a couple times, I can | confidently say that losing weight on it's own is hard. Really | hard. I've had far more success deliberately changing my entire | lifestyle and outlook on life. For me, it had to be a part of a | wholistic health regimen. This included therapy, healthy eating, | regular exercise, proper sleep, and a good balance of | recreational activities (it's important to have fun!). As | somebody with chronic sleep problems, it's been interesting | seeing how unhealthiness in one aspect of life (sleep in my case) | can affect other areas of my life (my weight). It's hard to | quantify this line of thinking, because in the end, all I did was | eat less and exercise more to lose the weight. That advice isn't | terribly helpful. Then again, it's very likely that "just be | healthier" is just as unhelpful ;) | | I will say, don't be too hard on yourself. My stress eating would | spiral (and still does!) when I get too hard on myself. Set small | goals and objectives (no eating after dark, be mindful of what | you put on your plate, no second helpings, etc) because | completing these always feels good. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Well written. These are all core aspects of our coaching | program to improve metabolic health: improve sleep, reduce | stress, more pleasurable activities, better food choices, | sustainable exercise routine, reasonable portion sizes. | | The "small goals" is also critical to counter all-or-nothing | thinking. We use a mix of behavioral & cognitive approaches to | try to cement the improved habits & ways of thinking. | neom wrote: | Looks like you're using a common and old Diabetes medication to | control glucose, changing the regulation of appetite? I'm curious | why this works best for men? Does it work in women? | rich-cartwright wrote: | Yep GLP-1 RAs are the gold-standard, if insurance coverage | permits (because they are expensive if you have to pay out-of- | pocket). The effect is roughly equal in men & women. The big | breakthrough was the latest GLP-1 RA called Semaglutide, FDA | approved in 2017 for diabetes and June 2021 for weight | management. The main paper for that is here if you're | interested: | | https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2032183 | criticaltinker wrote: | Interesting offering, definitely an important market. | | > So we started researching effective, evidence-based treatments | for obesity | | Fasting has a tremendous amount science supporting it [1], can | you articulate why you're pursuing the prescribed semaglutide | approach instead? | | [1] Fasting: Molecular Mechanisms and Clinical Applications | https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S155041311... | TeeMassive wrote: | I tried fasting and a pure keto diet. While they do work, I | felt miserable. This is not sustainable for people like me who | has to lose more than 100 pounds. | | Now I started losing weight by just balancing macro-nutrients; | more protein, more vegetables, less carbs as opposed to | absolutes "no" and "only" except for no sugary drinks and beer | and deserts except in social occasions. Also big emphasis on | weight lifting as opposed to cardio. Cardio helps with its own | health benefits but is very poor for muscle growth and fat loss | and should be seen as a compliment. | faichai wrote: | I felt miserable on Keto the first two times I tried it. I've | found doing fasting in the month prior helped with the | adaptation and a large part of the misery was loss of | electrolytes. | | By using electrolyte powder I only really had one or two | really miserable days this time round. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Interesting. How long have you been doing keto this time? | faichai wrote: | Only week 3, but finding it pretty great this time round, | ketones actively suppressing appetite, eating about 2 | meals a day, down about 6kg so far. I still fast a couple | of times a week, but being in ketosis already makes it | crazy easy. Have enough energy for gym, though power | slightly down. | | I hear people can hit a wall about 8 weeks in, but also | hear that could be down to over-consuming seed oils. Will | see how it goes. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Interesting to know, thanks. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Yep spot on about the sustainability. We hear this all the | time from the Fellas. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Spot on about fasting, and keto has solid evidence as well - | https://www.virtahealth.com/ are a great company focused on | this. | | The issue is we're starting to have a more nuanced | understanding of the metabolic resistance people face when they | undergo dietary changes - basically the body fights _hard_ | against you as you try to lose weight by dieting. | | So it's now industry-standard among obesity specialist doctors | to see obesity as a "metabolic disease" which, for the vast | majority of people, needs a medical approach which doesn't rely | on willpower. | criticaltinker wrote: | Thanks for your response and taking the time to answer these | questions. | | > basically the body fights _hard_ against you as you try to | lose weight by dieting | | Anecdotally I think many folks would agree. Any citations or | references you could provide on this point would be greatly | appreciated - I'm struggling to find any solid literature | with the phrase "metabolic resistance" in the context of | dietary changes. | | > So it's now industry-standard among obesity specialist | doctors to see obesity as a "metabolic disease" which, for | the vast majority of people, needs a medical approach which | doesn't rely on willpower. | | I agree that the current standard of care is largely focused | on prescription medication. Is there strong evidence | supporting the claim that the majority of people need | treatment that doesn't rely on willpower? I'm particularly | interested in the well documented association between obesity | and mental health [1], and I think Fella would be especially | compelling if a holistic approach to treatment was offered. | | [1] The High Prevalence of Poor Physical Health and Unhealthy | Lifestyle Behaviours in Individuals with Severe Mental | Illness https://www.researchgate.net/profile/David- | Scott-76/publicat... | lharries wrote: | (Richie's co-founder here) | | You're spot on with the link between mental health and | obesity and the need for a holistic approach. | | For many of the guys stress and anxiety will play a key | part in their food habits. This is something that our | coaches actively ask about and help manage if relevant. For | other guys it might be sleep [1] or it might be macro- | nutrients. The coaching will depend on the person and we | make these changes supported by their medical team. | | > Anecdotally I think many folks would agree. Any citations | or references you could provide on this point would be | greatly appreciated - I'm struggling to find any solid | literature with the phrase "metabolic resistance" in the | context of dietary changes. | | "Long-term persistence of hormonal adaptations to weight | loss" [2] and [3] are both interesting papers on this. With | the summary being that weight loss results in prolonged | changes in your hormones associated with increased appetite | and thus weight regain. This results in a strong negative | feedback cycle. | | [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28164452/ [2] | https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22029981/ [3] | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5764193/ | criticaltinker wrote: | Thank you for the excellent response and citations. I | think you and Richie are on to something here - wishing | you the best of luck. | lharries wrote: | Thank you! I enjoyed your great comments too | zadler wrote: | What's the connection between stress eating and metabolic | disease? | rich-cartwright wrote: | 1. Stress causes the adrenal glands to release a hormone | called cortisol, and cortisol increases appetite. | | 2. When stressed, we look for relief - and for a lot of | people that relief comes as food, or the act of eating | itself. | | Both of these often lead to overeating which is a cause of | metabolic disease. | jimmaswell wrote: | > basically the body fights hard against you as you try to | lose weight by dieting. | | I used to weigh 310lbs, now I'm 215lbs. All I did was count | calories to maintain a deficit and the results were | essentially the same as predicted by the math. I was a bit | hungry sometimes at first as I adjusted to it but that's | really it. Prioritizing protein and fat over carbs helps with | that. | | What ways does the body tend to fight against people? | faichai wrote: | Losing weight is essentially a stress on the body, the | response of which is to produce a lot of cortisol, which in | turn can mess with testosterone and other hormones. | | For me the caloric restriction leads to so much cortisol | that I can't really sleep properly no matter how much I try | to exhaust myself. | | Keto seems to be kinder (in week 3, of trying it for the | 3rd time, previous times unsuccessful). But too early to | say for sure. | criticaltinker wrote: | Thanks for pointing out the relationship between caloric | restriction and cortisol production. Your statements and | anecdotes seem to be well supported by the literature. | | _> Starvation caused a rise in plasma cortisol [...] but | no change in total urinary cortisol metabolites. _ [1] | | _> very low calorie diet (VLCD) did not alter plasma | cortisol and markedly reduced cortisol metabolite | excretion [...]. _ [1] | | _> Overall, caloric restriction significantly increased | serum cortisol level in 13 studies (357 total | participants). Fasting showed a very strong effect in | increasing serum cortisol, while VLCD and LCD did not | show significant increases. _ [2] | | _> The meta-regression analysis showed a negative | association between the serum cortisol level and the | duration of caloric restriction, indicating serum | cortisol is increased in the initial period of caloric | restriction but decreased to the baseline level after | several weeks. _ [2] | | [1] Influence of short-term dietary weight loss on | cortisol secretion and metabolism in obese men | https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Alexandra- | Johnstone/pub... | | [2] Systematic review and meta-analysis reveals acutely | elevated plasma cortisol following fasting but not less | severe calorie restriction https://www.tandfonline.com/do | i/abs/10.3109/10253890.2015.11... | rich-cartwright wrote: | Great links. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Anecdotally: I also used to struggle to sleep when I was | dieting. My sensation was intense hunger when I was in | bed where I couldn't stop thinking about food in the | kitchen. | bserge wrote: | Extreme hunger, like others said. I'd class it as a subset | of impulsive behavior, which is basically your primitive | brain doing it's caveman shit and not listening to _you_ , | the conscious mind. | | Apparently some people don't have this problem, which makes | me incredibly envious (or would if I could feel anything). | | It's this nagging thought of "JESUS CHRIST YOU'RE GONNA DIE | IF YOU DON'T EAT A LOT RIGHT NOW!" | | I've experienced it after hard days at work (construction), | multi hour lifting, cycling 50km. Same shit every time. | Surprisingly, unlike what my dumbass brain says, I don't | die if I eat only a little and just go to sleep. | | Counting calories didn't work btw. It actually made it | worse as my primitive brain would _know_ it 's "starving". | rich-cartwright wrote: | Said like a true Fella. I hear this _a lot_. | jjeaff wrote: | I used to be able to do that in my twenties. Now, in my | thirties, it appears I have lost that ability. Cutting my | calories seems to causey body to go into a sort of | hibernation where it becomes more efficient and conserves | more calories. | | In other words, my metabolic burn rate at rest and while | active seems to go down significantly. | zinclozenge wrote: | Unfortunately there are people like me who don't only feel | a bit hungry, when I eat at a deficit there are times where | I get so hungry my thoughts are completely consumed by the | hunger. The only way for me to successfully lose weight was | to have days where I simply eat nothing at all. | | Sounds counter-intuitive but after getting over the initial | extreme hunger I found that the hunger sensations would | diminish into a background noise, of sorts. That and the | rules are easy to follow: eat nothing. When I'd eat at a | deficit I'd frequently justify to myself that eating a | little bit more than I was planning on doing was ok because | it was only a little. And then I'd do that several times | until I felt completely satiated, defeating the purpose. | rich-cartwright wrote: | The complete fasting approach is pretty common among | Fellas I've spoken with. Lot of the guys have powerful | "all-or-nothing" traits, where it feels easier to have a | strict intense rule than a more nuanced approach. | | The issue comes when you therefore become so hungry your | body drives you to eat a lot of food all at once. But I'm | interested that you notice your hunger sensations | actually diminish over time. | speeder wrote: | I will use myself as an example: I have Hashimoto disease, | and even treated my metabolism can get so slow that I need | to eat so little that I start to have nutrient deficits, | for example one of the past dieting attempts resulted in | hair loss, brittle nails, cracking skin, because I needed | so little calories that when I consumed exactly what I | needed, I ended with a protein deficit. | | Only solution I found that worked was go for pure | weightlifting, literally train as if I was aiming to he an | Olympic champion, and even then I still ended overweight (I | am 1.75m tall, smallest weight I managed, that was then I | was training heavily and had a diet that was almost 100% | protein, was 98kg) | jimmaswell wrote: | That's interesting. That weight isn't necessarily | unhealthy if it's largely muscle from all the training. | Did you end up with a low body fat percentage despite the | weight? | mylons wrote: | i'm in a similar spot as the OP. lifting helps, but i'm | still pretty fat. 5'11" 250lbs. worksets are 355lb squat, | 225lb bench, 425lb deadlift, 175lb overhead press. it's | hard to tell i'm strong, but i'm slightly more slender at | this weight than i was before lifting. it definitely | helps with aches and pains i used to have, primarily back | pain. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Those are some tasty numbers. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Really interesting to know, thank you. | lharries wrote: | Great to hear you've had success. | | [1] is an interesting paper which gives you some hormonal | examples. Effectively when you try and lose weight your | body responds by increasing the hormones associated with | greater satiety and weight regain. And these change may | persists for a while -- this papers documenting the change | lasting past a a year. This will very by person however so | if you have something which works for you keep going. | | [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22029981/ | diskzero wrote: | I am glad to see this. I was involved in a similar startup that | became bogged down due to reasons that had nothing to do with the | validity of the approach you are taking. | | As I am sure you are aware, obesity is a complex issue and many | of the suggestions sufferers get such as eat less, exercise more, | try fasting, go keto, etc. are simply not helpful in and of | themselves. Neither is just prescribing the latest medications | without other forms of support. | | I hope your concept of telehealth, medical supervision and | personal coaching is one that will get results. Obesity is a | serious issue that is robbing society of people and potential. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Thank you very much for this. Kind message. | | What was the previous startup by the way? Always interested in | improving my knowledge of the space! | cesher wrote: | Where is Washington state in your rollout plan? 2021? 2022? | lharries wrote: | (Richie's co-founder here) We are aiming for Washington by the | end of 2021. If you'd like me to let you know when we launch | there feel free to fill in the "Am I Eligible" quiz and join | the waitlist or send an email to luke@joinfella.com and I'll | add you manually | cesher wrote: | Already filled it out, thank you! | rich-cartwright wrote: | Perfect! Working our hardest to get live in WA in the | coming quarters. | TeeMassive wrote: | Any plan for Canada? | rich-cartwright wrote: | Our focus is the US for the coming year or two. The state-by- | state expansion is tricky for telehealth companies. But we're | British founders so we recognize that this is needed in many | other countries in the coming years! | ryanSrich wrote: | Do you help people account for family lifestyles and cooking for | more than just themselves? I used to do 2-3 day fasts, but now | that I'm married with kids I find it almost impossible to do so | since I cook and prep all the meals. | | I tried low carb and keto. It works fine for me, but selling my | wife on a breakfast that consists of 6 eggs and a pound of bacon | is a hard sell. So there's always bread and pasta in the house, | which makes it harder to resist. | MagicWishMonkey wrote: | My wife is lifelong vegetarian, and I'm a big fan of keto. | We've basically adapted to a "I make food for myself, she makes | food for herself and we split responsibility for making food | for the kids" workflow and it works out pretty well. | | It helps a lot that I do the grocery shopping, I try to avoid | buying stuff that I'll be too tempted by - like regular carb | tortillas or plain tortilla chips. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Keeping food out of the house is a powerful behavioral | device. It takes away the "Ability" part from the Fogg | Behavior Model if you find that framework helpful. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Yep really good point about the family dynamics - lots of the | Fellas talk about how having teenage kids around makes the | dietary side really tough. | | How the coaching works in the program is that we dive in at the | start to really understand the 1-3 key leverage points where we | can make the most impact - then focus all our coaching time on | these. | gnicholas wrote: | It sounds like the medication is an important part of this plan. | Is it something that you anticipate someone would take | indefinitely, or only to get down to a target weight? | | Also, can you give some ELI5 background on how the medication | works in the body? | criticaltinker wrote: | _> Semaglutide, sold under the brand name Ozempic among others, | is an anti-diabetic medication used for the treatment of type 2 | diabetes and chronic weight management. _ [1] | | _> Semaglutide acts like human glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) | such that it increases insulin secretion, thereby increasing | sugar metabolism. It is distributed as a metered subcutaneous | injection in a prefilled pen or as an oral form. One of its | advantages over other antidiabetic drugs is that it has a long | duration of action, thus, only once-a-week injection is | sufficient. _ [1] | | _> Side effects including nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, | abdominal pain, and constipation may occur. In people with | heart problems, it can cause damage to the back of the eye | (retinopathy). Side effects include kidney problems, diabetic | retinopathy, allergic reactions, low blood sugar, and | pancreatitis. _ [1] | | _> Warning: Risk of Thyroid C-Cell Tumors - In rodents | semaglutide causes dose-dependent and treatment-duration- | dependent thyroid C-cell tumors at clinically relevant | exposures. It is unknown whether semaglutide causes thyroid | C-cell tumors, including medullary thyroid carcinoma (MTC), in | humans as human relevance of semaglutide-induced rodent thyroid | C-cell tumors has not been determined. _ [2] | | [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semaglutide | | [2] https://www.drugs.com/sfx/semaglutide-side-effects.html | rich-cartwright wrote: | Yep Semaglutide is the key medication. Important to emphasize | it appears to be a safe medication. | gnicholas wrote: | What is the evidence on safety? The side effects sound | potentially pretty serious, and as if the likelihood goes | up the longer you take it. If this has only been around for | a couple years, I'm not sure I'd jump on this just yet. | More details would be useful! | lharries wrote: | (Richie's co-founder here) | | Semaglutide was FDA approved for diabetes in 2018 (3 | years ago) and in June this year for weight management. | It's part of a class of medication called GLP-1 RAs which | operate in a similar way (they all stimulate the same | GLP-1 receptor). Liraglutide is another common one that | was approved by the FDA in 2010 (11 years ago) for | diabetes (by the EU in 2009) and for weight management in | 2014. So there is a 3 year of history with this | particular medication and an 11 year history for this | class of medication. | | Here's more about the history of GLP-1s and other weight | loss if you'd like: https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline | /archives/2021/02/15/gl... | | The main side effects that people seem to get are nausea | and vomiting when adjusting to the dose, this is likely | due to the slowing down of food leaving your stomach. | This is documented in the study of nearly two thousand | people which lasted for 68 weeks here [1] (where you can | also see the other side effects). | | It's worth noting that, as with any medication, there is | a cost-benefit trade-off. In this case it will depend on | someone's current weight, what they've tried in the past, | and the risks of other conditions e.g. heart disease, | diabetes, and their past medical history. Each person | that joins Fella has an in-depth discussion about this | with an independent obesity physician and is welcome to | speak it through with their own PCP too. | | https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2032183 | gnicholas wrote: | Thanks for your candor. It would be interesting to see | what positive effects can be achieved for what types of | patients at various different dosing levels. | | I'm not at a weight where I'd want to add additional | cancer risk in order to lose weight, and unfortunately | the data on this sort of incremental risk probably takes | decades to be fully realized. Perhaps I'd feel | comfortable taking a smaller dose if there were a | shorter-than-ideal track record of people taking larger | doses without much additional risk. | rich-cartwright wrote: | It's better to think of the medication as more similar to other | medications taken for chronic conditions (e.g. hypertension) | than a quick fix magic pill. | | The papers show consistent weight loss for ~52 weeks, then | plateauing off onto 68 weeks. If you suddenly stop taking the | medication, the weight creeps back on. The research therefore | suggests you can likely slowly taper off the medication after | year 1, but with medical supervision to ensure that doesn't | lead to weight gain. This is also why improved mindset & habits | are also important. | | https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2032183 | | ELI5: increases satiety, decreases appetite. | lharries wrote: | (Richie's co-founder here) | | > ELI5 for how it works in the body: | | GLP-1 RAs such as Semaglutide are increasingly looking like the | best class of medication for weight management [1] | | GLP-1 RA = Glucagon-like peptide 1 receptor agonist. | | These medications stimulates a receptor in your body which | results in a reduction in body weight and three main effects: 1 | - Slowing down gastric emptying so food stays in your stomach | for longer (this is thought to be why there is sometimes nausea | when starting the medication) 2 - Making you feel full by | working on your central nervous system 3 - Managing glucose | control (which is why it's used for people with diabetes too) | | [1] gives you a great summary of the field up to now and how it | works. | | > Is it something that you anticipate someone would take | indefinitely, or only to get down to a target weight? | | This will depend on the person, whether they are also diabetic | and how much weight they have to lose and is decided through a | conversation with their obesity doctor. After around 12-months | on these medications the weight loss plateaus (at an average of | 15% body weight). If one stops the medication then but hasn't | made any changes to their lifestyle they'll likely put the | weight back on. But during the 12 months of the program we will | be tackling the other factors with the coach: sleep, stress, | nutrition. And so after the first year it might well make sense | to reduce the medication or stop completely. | | Let me know if you have any more questions. | | [1] | https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2021/02/15/gl... | robomartin wrote: | I don't know how young you are. Great story, but, sorry, no. | Every single weight loss program claims exactly what you claim. | And they all deliver pretty much exactly the same results. My | guess is that about 10 to 20 percent of weight loss program | participants achieve sustainable life-long objectives, keep the | weight off and change their lifestyle. The rest are in a range | between utter failure and yo-yo diet programs to some short term | success, no long term behavioral modification and ultimately, a | return to their prior state or worse. | | Every single bullet point you list requires one thing that you | cannot control --nobody can: A personal decision to change. And | no pill is going to force this decision. | | Look, maybe you are well-meaning, however, what you are looking | to do here is no different from the myriad weight loss | supplements out there. I know people who made millions peddling | Garcinia Cambogia, Forskolin and other weight loss supplements on | Amazon. I know people who swear by the stuff. I would be willing | to bet that, statistically speaking the results are not very | different from almost any other purported solution. | | At the end of the day, the day weight loss isn't difficult at | all. | | In its harshest form its as simple as eating less. Even if you | eat junk, if you eat less, you lose weight. Physics. | | A more sophisticated approach is to learn and decide to eat | better. In both cases no exercise is required beyond normal | activity. | | Even a person who is confined to bedrest --no exercise at all-- | will lose weight if they consume less matter than their bodies | process into energy and excrete. My mother passed away a couple | of months ago. A couple of months before that she simply did not | want to eat very much at all. The amount of weight she lost was | incredible. | | The issue with obesity is bad food, unhealthy eating habits being | promoted from childhood and a situation where adults almost can't | escape all the things that make them sick. | | And yet, after all of that, it becomes a matter of making a | decision. And it is a very difficult decision to make for most. | To use an analogy, it takes far more effort to help someone who | becomes a drug addict than to guide them down the right path from | early childhood. That also happens to be far better for society. | | To use a business parallel: You can build the best hotel, have | the greatest and most amazing rooms, serve incredible food and | have amazing customer service. And yet, you cannot force people | to take a vacation. | | And so, all the bullet points in your argument sound fantastic. | If you go to Jenny Craig, or Weight Watchers, they pretty much | claim exactly the same things. And their road to success is paved | with the sorry bodies of the millions of people who thought they | found magic, only to end-up exactly where they started --or | worse. | | The right solution isn't a pill. Its investing time, money and | effort to change what we are doing about food and how we are | destroying our kids health by not acting with their best interest | in mind. | | That said, congratulations. With YC's backing there's probably no | doubt your startup will have a unicorn-scale exit. If there's one | market segment were the same story can be used again and again to | make billions it is the weight loss industry. So, again, | congrats. Brilliant move. | dang wrote: | Please stop posting these rants. Hounding someone like this | after you already personally attacked them is crossing into | harassment. I already asked you to stop once, and you've | responded by doing more of it, not once but twice. Seriously | not cool. | | We detached this comment from | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28258175. | robomartin wrote: | I understand. You need to protect a YC-funded startup from | criticism. No problem. I get it. Money is more important. | | Just go ahead and delete everything I have written on this | thread. That will be the easiest path. | | Lesson learned, don't be critical of YC companies. | | Got it. | dang wrote: | People criticize YC-funded startups all the time on HN. | Just look at the beating these guys took yesterday: | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28247379. | | We go out of our way to moderate threads _less_ when a YC | startup is involved (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all& | page=0&prefix=false&qu...), but your behavior in this | thread has been so egregious that I don't have a choice. | "Less" doesn't mean "zero". | mattmorley wrote: | Congratulations on the launch fella team! | | What would you say the biggest learning is you've had since | starting this journey? | rich-cartwright wrote: | Thanks Matt! | | Few things: | | 1. As we said in the post, men represent only ~10% of those | using weight management services in the US, despite | representing ~50% of those with obesity. Pretty fascinating to | reflect on the reasons why. | | 2. There are only ~5000 board-certified obesity doctors in the | US, roughly one for every 70000 Americans. | | 3. Binge Eating Disorder is the most common eating disorder, | and has above 20% clinical prevalence in those above 40 BMI. | | Maybe most importantly: the bias towards willpower and the | stigma against medical treatment for obesity (medication or | surgery) is very real, _especially_ among family doctors. This | will change over the coming decade, but it 's deeply routed. | wxnx wrote: | This is really interesting as someone who works as part of a | group who takes products similar to this to market! Thank you for | sharing. | | You mentioned the medication is as effective in women as it is in | men. While I understand men are underserved in this space and so | I respect the decision to focus on that population on that basis, | I'm curious if there are business elements to that decision as | well? Would you ever expand to serving women, given that they | seem to be a larger potential customer pool? | rich-cartwright wrote: | Sweet what's the group you're part of? Sounds interesting. | | It's obviously a great question about the focus on men, and | something we think a lot about. | | My take: the whole industry is focused on women, and there are | already cool companies taking a medication approach with | branding clearly focused on women: | https://www.joincalibrate.com/, https://joinfound.com/, | https://www.formhealth.co/ | | I'm a fan of what these folks are doing. But you speak to any | Fellas (our name for our customers!) and they _know_ those | programs aren 't aimed at them. Every week we hear something | like "I'm fed up of being the only guy in the group". | | From a business side, the bet we're taking is that if we manage | to crack the messaging/framing/branding for the male audience, | that's a great business. Plus how men think about their health | is drastically changing as concepts of masculinity change, so | the potential customer pool is growing rapidly. | | In terms of future expansion: we don't know yet. At least not | for the coming few years - there are a lot of bigger guys out | there we want to help (35 million men have obesity)! | wxnx wrote: | Thanks very much for answering! | | Sorry, if I'd had the foresight to use a throwaway I'd drop a | link to our group, but I prefer not to publicly associate my | HN account with work. We're a small team of software and data | engineers, machine learning scientists, and health policy | folks at a large research institution in Canada that take on | clients to work on stuff like this (from early stage research | to approvals to deployment). I'd be happy to reach out with | my contact info privately if you're interested, just let me | know. | | That makes sense! I wondered if it had something to do with | the group component, and I agree that the customer pool is | growing. | | Congratulations on the launch! | rich-cartwright wrote: | Sounds really interesting. Would love to hear from you: my | email is richie@joinfella.com | paulocal wrote: | How is the drug different than victoza or any of the other weight | management drugs that are currently under investigation for | causing pancreatic cancer? | lharries wrote: | (Richie's co-founder here) | | Victoza is the brand name for Liraglutide. The drug we are | primarily interested in is Semaglutide. Both Semaglutide and | Liraglutide are GLP-1 receptor agonists. | | It's worth doing your own research and consulting a doctor but | the experts I've spoken to (academics and clinicians) along | with the studies state that: "GLP-1 analogues did not increase | the risk for pancreatic cancer when compared to other | treatments" (from a Nature Scientific Reports meta-analysis | paper published in 2019) [1]. | | Here is the postmarket FDA safety information on Victoza if you | are interested: https://www.fda.gov/drugs/postmarket-drug- | safety-information... | | [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-38956-2 | paulocal wrote: | I get how when compared to other treatments for diabetes it | may not increase your risk but when we are comparing with | other treatments for weight management or just no treatment | at all, I find it hard to believe that it doesn't | significantly increase the risk for pancan. I understand it's | FDA approved but so have been all other drugs in its class | that are allegedly linked to pancreatic cancer. | robomartin wrote: | I am sorry, but this is nothing less than an abomination. Drugs, | drugs, drugs. More drugs. Let's drug everyone. Let's have | everyone popping pills for everything. Why not. And make | millions, billions, while we are at it. | | And your sob story? Do you think you are the only person in the | world who has had to deal with stress? This is ridiculous. How | about this for stress: My grandparents were genocide survivors. | They saw portions of their family killed in the most horrific | ways. And they somehow managed that and moved on. Me, personally, | I've had one pretty horrific business failure that drove me to | the edge of understanding why people take their own lives after | ending-up in the hospital twice due to stress. | | WE DO NOT NEED PILLS! | | Yes, I am yelling. | | We need action on better food quality and education. People are | filling themselves up with nothing but crap. Ketogenic diets and | balanced living work, 100% of the the time. Exercise and activity | is the magic "pill" that manages stress. | | Frankly, I am astounded that YC would fund and support something | like this. I don't care about your credentials and sob story. | This is an abomination. Yes, you are likely to make billions. | Congratulations. You are not going to fix a damn thing. All you | are going to accomplish is to get millions of people hooked on | yet another "once daily" legal drug of some sort. | | If you truly cared about helping people you would work towards | fixing what's actually wrong rather than getting millions of | people to pop pills. | | What when they stop? Huh? | | They will have developed no good habits at all. They will not | have a clue as to how to manage stress. They sure as fuck are not | going to understand that exercise is important and necessary. | They are not going to become discerning about what they eat. And | our industrialized toxic food industry isn't going to change a | thing. They will pop your pills as they suck-in a two liter drink | with insane amounts of sugar and inhale cheap carbohydrates in | their burritos, burgers, pizza, etc. | | Weight management isn't at all about eating less. It's about not | eating food that actively want to slowly kill you and, yes, | engaging in a modicum of exercise in order to deal with insulin | resistance, keep bones strong, etc. | | I've had my own battles with this. Lots of people do. Until I | finally listened to my wife (an MD). So I proposed an experiment: | I would do no exercise at all other than taking walks with her a | few evenings per week. She was pushing me to take-up a low carb | ketogenic-style diet. As an engineer, I wanted to isolate | exercise from a change in eating habits. That's what we did. And | the results were hard to ignore. It was slow going, but the fat | just came off --without having to run a marathon every day to | burn extra calories. I eat as much as I want. No restrictions | other than "don't eat garbage/sugars/simple carbs, etc.". After | dropping two pant sizes and feeling "normal" again I can now go | for the finishing touch and add exercise to this in the form of | strength training. | | The most important outcome was to reeducate myself about what and | how I should be eating. That's it. It's as simple as that. No | drug is going to do that. Ever. Unless the intent is to hook | people for their $149 per month in perpetuity. | | Sorry, to take such an aggressive tone. This is, to use the term, | deplorable. Shame on you. Invest the money educating people on | how NOT to use a drug to improve their lives. Pills isn't a long | term sustainable solution. You are bound to ruin more lives than | you save. And you are not going to do anything about improving | the quality of the food that our population consumes. | | Think of kids. Their food choices --particularly in the case of | lower education parents-- boil down to choices between different | kinds of toxic garbage. By the time they leave high school they | have already imprinted horrible habits and done damage to their | bodies. And now you show up and say "Take this pill...we will | save you". Sick. | someguydave wrote: | you could make the same argument about any modern technology | rich-cartwright wrote: | It is interesting how divisive conversations around weight | can be. For a lot of people, it represents a broader theme of | we view individualism & morality. | civilized wrote: | Congrats on having a relatively easy time losing weight, but | you're not the only person in the world, and not everyone's | body works the same as yours. Your scolding of a clinically | proven weight loss approach for not being what you did is | solipsistic and ignorant. Your approach is, like the others, | one among many that will work for some people. | beebeepka wrote: | You have a point but there is one common thing shared between | every obese person. They eat too much, or the wrong things. | That's a given and a simple fact that everyone knows but not | everyone is willing to acknowledge. | | Sure, there are medical conditions that sometimes play a | role. But how often is that the case? I actually don't know. | Maybe your company could help with that? | | Good luck. There's obviously a market for your services. | rich-cartwright wrote: | "calories in" (too much or wrong things) is for sure | important - but focusing solely on this when we're looking | for practical solutions is not the most helpful framework | for people who are fighting obesity. | robomartin wrote: | > Your scolding of a clinically proven weight loss approach | for not being what you did is solipsistic and ignorant. | | Far from ignorant. It is an absolute fact --thermodynamics-- | that no human being needs a pill to lose weight. So, stop | with the holier-than-thou come-back and think. | | This is no different from selling crap weight loss | supplements to people. Why? Because they do not need that | either. The fact that something is clinically proven means | nothing. Why? Because people don't need it. | | > Your approach is, like the others, one among many that will | work for some people. | | It isn't my approach. I only had to lose about 30 lbs. I | could have done that going back to strength training, which | was I was into before the pandemic hit. I decided to see if | there was any merit to what my wife, the MD, was telling me. | | Major "duh" moment: Of course it had merit! And of course it | can work for absolutely everyone! | | And, guess what, it does not cost $150 per month. No pills | necessary. | | The problem with obesity, particularly in the US, is | systemic. Our food is unmitigated garbage and we train our | kids to eat and crave this garbage from early childhood | times. By the time they become young adults they are well on | their way to a life of dealing with weight problems and a | straight line into diabetes and other ailments. | | You can't fix inflammation from food with pills, unless you | want to be popping them for the rest of your life and end-up | with other problems because of it. | | This is going to sound weird: I am always astounded by how | much I have learned by raising and training GSD's (German | Shepherd Dogs). Stay with me for a second. | | One of our GSD's developed a very serious problem a number of | years ago. His skin smelled horrible and he lost all hear | from his chest and belly. His coat looked dull, almost dead. | | Not knowing what was going on I sought advice from our vet. | He suggested I take him to a veterinary dermatologist. $2,500 | and bunch of shots and pills later, we went home with a plan. | Pop pills every day. Get this magical shot once a month. | | Sure enough, in about four weeks his coat was nice and shinny | again, his skin didn't smell and hair started to come back to | his chest. | | Back we went for another shot and more pills. This was | running about $600 per month. The dermatologist said he'd | have to be on this program for the rest of his life. Wow. | | I decided to reach out to a number of GSD groups and | breeders. A theme emerged from these conversations very | quickly: Change his food. He is having allergic reaction to | his food. Stop the nonsense the dermatologist is selling you. | | So, I did. I figured I could try for a couple months and, if | nothing changed, go back to the treatment. | | We went with a high quality food with twice the protein | content and far less junk carbs, etc. | | Less than a month later this dog was in what I might describe | as the best shape of his life. He looked great, was happy, | didn't have smelly skin, his coat grew back on this chest and | belly and was pretty much the picture of a healthy dog. This | was many years ago. He has been on this better-food diet | every since and looks and feels wonderful. | | We have lost sense of just how important good food is for our | bodies and minds. We accept that the garbage we buy at the | market and restaurants is normal. Well, it isn't. This is the | problem. The vet dermatologist was administering a government | approved drug to my dog. It worked. And yet that was not | really the solution, because it did not address the | underlying problem. And that's the issue I have this startup. | It isn't a solution. At all. Nobody needs this to lose | weight. | throwawayboise wrote: | GPs approach will work for almost all people, if they | actually do it. | luckylion wrote: | I've lost plenty of weight with intermittent fasting. It | totally works. My sleep schedule went crazy, no matter what | I did. My ability to focus was completely lost, as if I was | constantly overdosing on coffee. | | Yes, it works, and maybe it works easy & side-effect free | for some, but tbh I'd rather be overweight and die 10 years | earlier, than live like that. | rich-cartwright wrote: | The sustainability of approaches is what we hear most from | the Fellas. Most diets work in the short run but aren't | sustainable long-term, especially when you're already | battling against your metabolism. | civilized wrote: | [citation needed] | rich-cartwright wrote: | Eloquently written. | rose_cook wrote: | > "They sure as fuck are not going to understand that exercise | is important and necessary. They are not going to become | discerning about what they eat. They will...inhale cheap | carbohydrates in their burritos, burgers, pizza, etc" | | Who are you referring to with these wide-sweeping, derogatory | stereotypes, who are "they"? I genuinely find it shocking that | you find it appropriate to group together the millions of | people who struggle with obesity for various and legitimate | reasons as "they". | | Maybe also think about your privilege as an "engineer" with a | wife who is a doctor before offering these unneeded criticisms | on "lower educated parents". | | It's narratives like those in this post which alienate people | who are already struggling, and paint obesity as a moral | failing. You are the one with a moral failing right now. | | So I guess I'm yelling too.. | | WE DO NOT NEED TO DEMONIZE AND DEHUMANIZE MILLIONS OF PEOPLE | BASED ON THEIR SOCIOECONOMIC BACKGROUND, EDUCATION OR HEALTH. | TeeMassive wrote: | >WE DO NOT NEED PILLS! | | >Yes, I am yelling. | | If pills work then what's the problem? It seems to me that | you're making an appeal to nature | (https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/appeal-to-nature). Given all | the health problems associated with obesity from cancer to | cardiovascular problems then whatever side effects the pills | have are probably negligible in comparison. | | > Weight management isn't at all about eating less. It's about | not eating food that actively want to slowly kill you and, yes, | engaging in a modicum of exercise in order to deal with insulin | resistance, keep bones strong, etc. | | Yes nutrition and exercise are important, but even if it's | common knowledge it's obviously working like abstinence based | sexual education is working to prevent STDs and teenage | pregnancy because like we have a natural urge to sex we also | have a natural urge to eat calories and while saving energy. | | > "Take this pill...we will save you". Sick. | | A lot of pills are necessary to prolong and maintain quality of | life. What's "sick" about this? | stef25 wrote: | Assuming obesity is largely due to mental issues like stress | eating, the solution should also be a mental one. It's | basically an addition. Most people are perfectly capable of | quitting but don't because it's easier not to. | | This includes myself. I recently put on a bit of weight and I | know exactly why: second servings, having a few beers, | difficulties sticking to a diet with kids and dietary | allergies in the house, no time or too lazy for exercise. | It's all on me. | | Something that can be fixed by just putting your mind to it | shouldn't have to be treated with pills. | | For some people it will probably be the hardest thing they | ever do - I'm not downplaying this. So, for people who don't | have the willpower pills is probably the best solution. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Interesting references. | rich-cartwright wrote: | It's important you've written this. We need to have frank | conversations about obesity. It affects a lot of people and a | lot of people have very strong views on the best solution. | | I'll focus on one area of your post: "They will have developed | no good habits at all. They will not have a clue as to how to | manage stress. They sure as fuck are not going to understand | that exercise is important and necessary. They are not going to | become discerning about what they eat...They will pop your | pills as they suck-in a two liter drink with insane amounts of | sugar and inhale cheap carbohydrates in their burritos, | burgers, pizza, etc." | | I want to emphasize how wrong you are here. | | Fella is a 12-month program, with continued support for the | rest of your life after that first year. The program is focused | on: | | - building resilience to stress & other testing emotions | | - building a sustainable exercise habit which is enjoyable and | sustainable | | - building healthier eating habits which are realistic & | sustainable | | - building sleep habits which help improve metabolic health | | In terms of the medication, it's really important to listen to | obesity specialists here. They are trying to find practical | solutions to help people. It's clear that moral indignation | isn't working so far. | | These are all legitimate concerns you raise. Know that I have | researched this deeply, and genuinely believe this is the best | practical solution to help the most amount of people. | | Please let me know your thoughts. | djrogers wrote: | > It's clear that moral indignation isn't working so far. | | This is my favorite HN line in ages, kudos! | | PS - in California and signed up for the wait list. | rich-cartwright wrote: | Glad to have you! | dang wrote: | Of course obesity is an emotional topic but attacking someone | personally about it is way, way beyond the pale. | | Breaking the HN guidelines will get you banned here, regardless | of how right you are, or feel you are, about obesity and other | topics. No more of this, please. | | https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html | robomartin wrote: | Funding a company to effectively hook people on pills by | taking advantage of their vulnerability, mental state and | frustration is nothing less than profane. It's one thing to | turn people into ad-clicking drones, quite another to hook | them on drugs when they do not need them. | | You might object to my lashing out. Well, sometimes it is | important to take a strong stance. And, yes, sometimes those | promoting magical solutions are culpable and should be | scolded. | | Am I wrong? I do not think so. Nobody needs pills to lose | weight. Nobody. That is a matter of both biology and physics. | I'll defy anyone to prove otherwise. Have we become insane? | | The problem is that we have industrialized bad food choices | and have created a marketplace where it is actually difficult | to escape stuff that is bad for you. | | Just last night we were at a restaurant. A few tables over | was a family where every single member, kids included, were | twice the size of a normal and healthy person. Their table | was full of all of the wrong choices. And, on top of that, | large free-refill glasses of soft drinks. At the end of their | meal they all had cake and ice cream. Wow. | | My youngest kids just started in-person high school again. | The school has free food for every student. Its absolute | garbage. The word "junk" doesn't even begin to cover it. The | healthiest thing they have is apple juice, with nearly 40 | grams of sugar per serving. My kids pack a lunch, just a | simple sandwich them make themselves every morning. Not very | expensive at all. Not hard to make. We don't make them, the | kids do and have been doing so for years. They also drink | water. We have no soft drinks at home. The kids grew up | drinking water and have no cravings whatsoever for soft | drinks, candy, ice cream, etc. Sure, we occasionally have the | stuff at parties, but that's the exception rather than the | rule. And, no, they are not deprived. They simply do not care | for the stuff because they did not become addicted to any of | it as they grew up. | | Every family relying on the State/City/County/School district | to feed their kids is, in return, having their kids poisoned. | Worse yet, their kids are being programmed to become addicted | to food that is absolutely horrible for them. When they come | out of school they are well on their way to diabetes and | other problems. | | Pills? | | Please. | | Our kids are coming into adulthood biologically programmed | for high levels of sugar and carbohydrate consumption. It's | all they eat since they are done with breast feeding. No pill | is going to fix that level of programming. | | People who reach high levels of obesity are susceptible to | the kinds of things that are going to cause them to spend | money popping all kinds of pills every day. They are | suffering, lots of them are depressed and our government and | regulatory agencies have failed them --which is part of the | reason they got there. | | We don't need pills. The problem is systemic. Fund startups | who will deal with this and not ones that are no different | from any other yo-yo diet program by any other name. | | Does anyone really think someone is going to change life-long | habits after popping pills for a year? What is far more | likely to happen is that they will become dependent on said | pills, which is great for a revenue stream and a billion | dollar exit to a pharmaceutical giant, not so great for the | individual. | | What is beyond the pale here isn't my choice of language or | intensity, it's the ultimate significance of what this | startup represents. No different from the abomination that | bariatric surgery is. Great business. Horrible for the | individual. I know two people who nearly died after having | it. | | Who am I kidding. There's money in suffering. I'll bet it | will be a fantastic IPO one day. Maybe you should start | marketing outside schools. Just like smoking, that's your | future user base. Congratulations. | symlinkk wrote: | Very well written and I find it hard to disagree. | rich-cartwright wrote: | If you had a bigger family member who had tried everything, | what would you recommend to them? | vcg3rd wrote: | You apparently don't let people sign-up who are willing to pay | out of pocket. Shame. | rich-cartwright wrote: | This is probably a bug in our infra! We're on it now to fix. If | you email richie@joinfella.com I'll sort you. | lharries wrote: | It should be possible -- select "Uninsured" when you try and | sign up (although I realize now that we can make that clearer). | Email me at luke@joinfella.com if you have any issues | rich-cartwright wrote: | haha Luke beat me to it | ensiferum wrote: | Intermittent fasting offers a great alternative that is | completely free! The problem Fe Business perspective is of course | that there's nothing to sell. No pills no magic nutrition plan or | foods or exercise regime. And best of all...no calorie counting! | | If you're fasting and feel hungry while carrying body fat it | means your metabolism is broken. Insulins levels are high and | thus prevent the use of stored body fat for energy. It's possible | to reverse this condition but it can take time up to 6 months | approx. | | I really recommend to watch a pod cast with Dr. Benjamin Bikman. | | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TfSJFPu50_A | | It's incredible how fasting just works. I've lost 10kg of bf and | 10cm from my waistline without counting a single calorie or | feeling hungry at all over the course of 6 months. And I haven't | lost strength either and my workouts are as intense as before. | After i started fasting it took me a about 6 weeks to start | seeing visible changes. | lharries wrote: | (Richie's co-founder here) Great to hear that intermittent | fasting has been working well for you! There's also interesting | research about the longevity benefits even if you're not | looking for weight loss. | | The best approach for getting to a healthier weight will vary | by person. If you've put on a few pounds over the holidays but | are otherwise fine then Fella is not for you. We're focusing on | guys with a higher BMI (30+), they've tried everything | including intermittent fasting, keto, Weight Watchers, etc. | Normally they will have had short term results (even losing | 60lbs+) but then put the weight back on. This is often the case | for the guys that have been at a higher weight for a longer | period of time as their metabolism is in a different place. | ensiferum wrote: | I sincerely hope regardless of methods you're able to help | people and of course manage a to build a successful business | well. Best of luck. | lharries wrote: | Thank you! You too | tarr11 wrote: | I tried Noom twice. I was the only man in the support group both | times. It didn't really speak to me or work for me. | | Definitely interested in this! | rich-cartwright wrote: | We've heard this a lot.. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2021-08-21 23:00 UTC)