[HN Gopher] Brussels battles old prejudices as it frees unloved ... ___________________________________________________________________ Brussels battles old prejudices as it frees unloved river from its vault Author : f_allwein Score : 66 points Date : 2021-08-27 18:27 UTC (4 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.theguardian.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.theguardian.com) | marstall wrote: | In Boston, similar emotions pertain to the Charles River, which | runs through it majestically. It's currently swimmable on many | days after decades of cleanup, but finding a Bostonian who would | be comfortable taking a dip wouldn't be easy. Same situation with | the Boston Harbor | Turing_Machine wrote: | There's even a well-known song about the Charles. | | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=62XRy-jFCm8 | | London has many "vanished" rivers, the most famous of which is | the Fleet. | | In earlier times it was nice enough that a royal palace was | built on its banks, but by the Restoration it had become what | Neal Stephenson's _Baroque Cycle_ described as a "river of | shit" (the palace had been converted into a prison by then, | too). | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/River_Fleet | ClumsyPilot wrote: | 'the palace had been converted into a prison by then, too' | | So considerate! | contravariant wrote: | Well I would also be apprehensive about swimming in a river | described as "swimmable on many days". | hn_throwaway_99 wrote: | Merry Christmas! Happy New Year! Otherwise, get the f out of | the water. | schraeds wrote: | Even most beaches on the ocean have days with no swimming | flags caused by algae bloom, storm drain off, excess sewage | release in the area, etc. | whymauri wrote: | The water in the Charles feels slimey. Like it has a thin | microcoat of grossness on top. | thatcherc wrote: | I didn't grow up in Boston but spent a lot of time sailing (and | accordingly, a decent amount swimming) in the Charles River | Basin in the past several years (go Tech Sailing!). Only once | ever had a bad experience - got terribly sick for 24 hrs after | a windy windsurfing day where I was in the water more than I | was on the board. I was told this was "river fever" and it | happens from time to time! Otherwise a great body of water. | | The days the Charles is unswimmable is a few hot summer days | after rainstorms (and in the winters when it freezes up!). In | the summer the water is warm enough and the runoff after storms | brings in enough nutrients from the city that cyanobacteria | grow like crazy and create a paralysis risk. On these days the | Boston DCR does a pretty good job making sure everyone knows to | stay dry for the day. | dtgriscom wrote: | I grew up in the Boston area in the 60s, before the Charles | River was dammed to prevent Boston Harbor tides from flushing | into the Charles Basin. Driving along Storrow Drive at low tide | in summer was a malodorous experience. | | Then in the 80s, long after the dam was put in, they had | enormous air bubblers in the Charles Basin to stir up the | stagnant bottom water. Fun to sail through. | animal_spirits wrote: | Thanks for introducing me to the word "malodorous" | munk-a wrote: | I grew up in Boston and actually did some sailing on the river | as a kid - we coasted around in Sunfishes for the most part. | Unlike literally every other sailing instruction course I ever | took there was no forced capsizing tutorial to learn how to | uncapisize a Sunfish - mostly because nobody's parents would | ever sign onto a waiver that said "Oh btw, we're going to | briefly dunk your kid into the Charles". | | I love the Charles River and spent a lot of time growing up | around it in Cambridge and city-side on the Esplanade. I've got | great memories from both Pops and pop concerts in the Hatch | Shell - but yea, no where in those memories is anything about | voluntarily going into the river - avoiding even dipping a toe | into that was ingrained into us at a young age. | foobarian wrote: | Anecdata time. I am from elsewhere so I didn't have that sort | of context. I had a chance to be rowing on the Charles at | some point but forgot to bring water with me so I just drank | from the river with no ill effect. Water seemed pretty clear | and fresh. I also remember around that time there would be | periodic news praising the river cleanup success so I | probably never got to see it dirty. | munk-a wrote: | And you're saying you're currently not a Zombie? Oh vanish | the thought! | | Actually, yea, I think the river is quite clean. Especially | now that I've seen bodies of water that have an oily sheen | on them - and ones that sting if you get them on your skin. | I think I'd probably be pretty adverse to swimming in the | Charles - but I'd definitely prefer it any day over False | Creek in Vancouver. | | My biggest concern with questionable water these days is | always the bed they rest on - usually the water tends to be | pretty clear even in heavily polluted areas (though oil | floats so some forms of pollution are quite contrary to | that) - but all the really dangerous stuff tends to slowly | separate out and settle on the bottom. It's when kids get | in and kick up the muck at the bottom of one of these | rivers that I get most concerned. | | Also yea - this is pretty much all anecdotal as well. | cossatot wrote: | Some forms of environmental pollution or toxicity, like | bacteria, can result in an infection that makes you sick, | or not. Other forms, like heavy metals (common in | industrial sites), can cause serious chronic problems | through prolonged or repeated exposure, but are not | necessarily going to cause much harm from a single low-ish | dose. | selimthegrim wrote: | I capsized in the Charles one summer around 2007 or so (and | swallowed some water) with the MIT Sailing Club. I didn't | have any immediate ill effects but about 5 minutes after I | got back to the dock I was afflicted by the most painful | earsplitting headache I have ever experienced even to this | day. I curled up in a ball and thought I was dying of a | stroke. | busyant wrote: | Not sure if you've ever seen this, but former (Massachusetts) | Governor Weld staged a little publicity stunt several years | ago by jumping into the Charles: | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yiGbMmqrYrY | mgbmtl wrote: | It's worth it. Montreal and it's surrounding cities neglected the | river and canals, which supported local industry and transport, | then used to dump toxic soils from digging the subway, or dumping | untreated sewer water. After much cleanup, there are many spots | where we can swim, kayak or even surf. It has completely changed | some neighborhoods (Verdun, Saint-Henri, but also going from | Bellerive to Boucherville islands). | alamortsubite wrote: | The sewer museum mentioned in the article is excellent. Easily on | par with the Musee des egouts in Paris. I highly recommend it. | cynusx wrote: | They didn't bother cleaning it up for that long because the | stench down-river from Brussels went into a flemish area and when | they did finally succumb to pressure from the flemish side to | cleanup the stench of this river they mismanaged the effort and | the project was late and had a minor corruption scandal. | | Calling these prejudices "old" is a stretch, it's only in 2016 | they saw that fishes could survive in the river. | yvdriess wrote: | And there was a dispute a few years ago with one of the | companies that cleans the waste water that flows back into the | river. They stopped operations and the pollution wiped out the | fish all over again. | Firerouge wrote: | > They stopped operations and the pollution wiped out the | fish all over again. | | Sounds like they shouldn't be paid for any of the work that | they undid by this | lupire wrote: | You expect to work forever after getting paid once? | dylan604 wrote: | In Dallas, there's an old joke about the fish in the Trinity | River swim backwards so they don't get the water in their eyes. | | It always amazes me how there's all of the old black&white film | of industrial waste just pouring into whatever water was nearby | (river,lakes,etc). However, we know it still happens today, they | just get more sneaky about it. Again, in Dallas, a slaughter | house was found to be dumping blood and waste into the river by a | drone flying over head and the color of the water had an obvious | color change to it. | dendrite9 wrote: | Have you seen the video of the US army disposing of 10 tons | sodium by dumping it into an eastern Washington lake? | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HY7mTCMvpEM | dylan604 wrote: | Clearly, there's nothing wrong with that, just listen to the | music. If it was bad stuff happening in the film, they would | have used scary omninous music. | gus_massa wrote: | A map would be nice. More info | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covering_of_the_Senne | f_allwein wrote: | Also: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Senne_(river) | f_allwein wrote: | Similarly, the Rhine, one of the largest rivers in Germany, | recovered well after cleanup efforts in the 1980s: | https://whatsupgermany.de/father-rhines-recovery/ ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2021-08-27 23:00 UTC)