[HN Gopher] Monitoring my home's air quality with AirGradient's ... ___________________________________________________________________ Monitoring my home's air quality with AirGradient's DIY sensor Author : geerlingguy Score : 342 points Date : 2021-09-08 14:02 UTC (8 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.jeffgeerling.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.jeffgeerling.com) | falconblock5 wrote: | Could anyone advise of the best way of getting hold of the PCB? | Looking at the air gradient webside they provide "Gerber files", | do these need to be sent to a PCB manufacturer to create? If so, | does anyone have recommendations of which to use? It is something | I would like to learn about but I am rather new to. | roflchoppa wrote: | I ordered like 5 of them the other day from JLCPCB it was like | 6 bucks shipped to my place. | | I saw this post online, I've had the pm2.5 sensor sitting | around for a long time... | | https://benjamincongdon.me/blog/2021/08/08/DIY-Air-Quality-S... | secabeen wrote: | I built one using these instructions and a ESP8266: | https://www.pieterbrinkman.com/2021/02/03/build-a-cheap-air-... | | It publishes its data via MQTT, and you can use any system that | can subscribe to a MQTT queue to process, display, etc. it. | adamjb wrote: | The last time AirGradient popped up on HN, the guy who runs it | said if you get in contact and ask nicely they might have a | spare one to send you. | tnorthcutt wrote: | Link: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27125763 | turbocon wrote: | oshpark is what we used in college https://oshpark.com/ | | $5/sq inch and you get 3 copies of your board | Afrodev wrote: | https://oshpark.com/shared_projects/M6wg5Xzs Actions > Order | Board | numpad0 wrote: | KiCad for design and JLCPCB or FusionPCB for manufacturing has | been good enough for me to go from nothing to a completed | board. Yes, gerber files are equivalent of "compiled binary" | that you send to a PCB manufacturer to be printed. | simcop2387 wrote: | I've had good experience with jlbpcb in the past, they usually | have some deals going around on youtube electronics channels | too. | Animux wrote: | There is a version from superhouse.tv with the same pms5003 | sensor: https://www.superhouse.tv/39-diy-air-quality-sensor- | part-2-d... | danans wrote: | > But after a few weeks, and after adding in a manual temperature | adjustment to compensate for that sensor's inaccuracy, the | AirGradient has been a very stable and helpful addition to my | home environment monitoring. | | When you are DIYing this sort of thing, I would think you would | need to make at least a couple of them to see if they calibrate | to the same measurement, assuming what you are after is greater | precision and control (why else would you DIY it?). Even then, | both devices could calibrate to the same very imprecise value. | | To really validate this, you would need to put it in an | controlled environment with known air pollution levels. Just | placing it outdoors when the weather report says 200AQI wouldn't | work since that's an average over a large area, not a point | measurement. | | I imagine the sensor manufacturers have done some calibration - | the article mentions a self calibration period for some, but once | everything is in the final package, I'd expect the behavior to | change. | asdff wrote: | With this data it seems like you'd be more concerned with the | relative value and its change over time anyhow rather than the | true value. | geerlingguy wrote: | I have two identical boards now, along with my TemTop portable | unit, and the CO2 is quite close (< 1% difference usually), and | PM2.5 readings are more like 5-10% different. The temperature | is the biggest outlier, but I need to figure out a better | placement for the temperature sensor to get that issue fixed. | ashtonkem wrote: | Most of the DIY solutions I've seen use pre-packaged PM | sensors, which are probably the same parts embedded in over the | counter solutions. | danans wrote: | Yes, but has the final assembly been calibrated against a | known controlled environment? | | Without that, the readings from the device become more of a | crapshoot, which is fine if there is no desire for greater | precision (i.e a just for fun project) | | Sensor manufacturers cannot calibrate for every possible | packaging configuration. | | As someone who has DIYed a lot of stuff related to indoor | climate, I tend to save my effort for the mitigation work, | and use well tested measurement tools to validate those. This | is for the same reason that one doesn't usually DIY a | multimeter before doing electrical work. | jiveturkey wrote: | yup. not entirely useless, but especially for the borderline | yellow/orange AQI you want to know the error. | | http://www.aqmd.gov/aq-spec tests and compares commercial AQM | vs lab grade instruments. It isn't quite enough to compare a | commercial unit with the same sensor, because you don't really | know the mfr calibration (if any), but this will get you a much | better idea of performance. | | i personally prefer to have a commercial sensor that has an | API, rather than DIY. | Johnny555 wrote: | Does anyone have any plans for a cheap DIY Ozone sensor? My house | came with an electronic air cleaner called an iWave: | | https://iwaveair.com/ | | It claims to not emit any Ozone, but I'd like to be able to | meaure it, and the commercial sensors tend to be expensive. | dperfect wrote: | Not sure if this is DIY enough for you, but I'm using an MQ131 | (about $20-$30 on Amazon, probably cheaper directly from China | [1]) in an air quality monitor I'm building. There's an Arduino | library for it [2], and from what I can tell so far, it does | work, though it's probably not super accurate. It's also | somewhat sensitive to environmental factors, but you can | correct for some of that with known temperature/humidity. | | [1] There are a few different kinds of MQ131 (for high and low | concentrations); you'll probably want the low concentration | one. I also removed the bare sensor from a breakout board I | purchased so I could access it directly from my custom PCB. | | [2] https://github.com/ostaquet/Arduino-MQ131-driver | Johnny555 wrote: | That's exactly what I'm looking for, looks like I can get a | $30 MQ131 with detection a range of 10PPB-2PPM [1], and a | "Good" indoor level is 0 - 54ppb [2]. It doesn't need to be | super accurate for my use case, basically I just want to turn | on the electronic filter and see if there are any detectable | levels of Ozone. | | [1] https://www.sainsmart.com/products/mq-131-gas-sensor- | ozone-m... | | [2] https://learn.kaiterra.com/en/resources/ozone-what- | levels-ar... | clipradiowallet wrote: | This doesn't answer your question - but in all seriousness you | can smell it. Even the smallest amount of ozone has a _very_ | distinct smell you will recognize. If you stand in front of | your air sanitizer and let the air pass over your face, you | should be able to smell the ozone immediately. | | If you haven't smelled it before - I would recommend going to a | retail store that sells ozone-based air sanitizers. That should | give you a whiff of the stuff for reference. You can also find | it in [some] hospitals for air sanitization. I imagine once you | smell it, you will realize you have smelled it before and maybe | not realized it was ozone that you were smelling. | s0rce wrote: | the word ozone actually comes from the Greek word for smell | (at least according to wikipedia, I don't speak Greek.) | Johnny555 wrote: | I know what Ozone smells like (I remember the old laser | printers that were also effective ozone emitters), but trust | a sensor more than my ability to smell low levels of Ozone. | | My air purifier is built into the furnace ductwork so it's | already pretty diluted air by the time it comes out of a | duct. | clipradiowallet wrote: | > My air purifier is built into the furnace ductwork | | That's neat! Do you know if the ozone is produced before or | after it reaches the blowing mechanism? I ask because if it | is produced _before_ , like right after the air intake, | that's a really great setup for keeping your ductwork mold | and mildew free. I've wanted to buy such a system but keep | holding out for things to get cheaper... in the meantime, I | use an ecoquest "FreshAir" model sitting on top of the | fridge. | Johnny555 wrote: | Well I don't know that it creates ozone at all, the | product claims that it creates purifying "ions", but no | ozone. And I don't _want_ ozone. | | The unit is installed after the filter, but before the | air is sucked into the blower. | alexfromapex wrote: | Why is this person's house 82 degrees? | reaperducer wrote: | _Why is this person's house 82 degrees?_ | | When I lived in the desert, 82deg was comfortable for me. | Generally, the humidity was below 10% (NWS reading, as most | cheap consumer sensors are not precise below 10%). But even in | monsoon season, when the humidity would spike, it was still | fine. | | I guess you get used to it. My wife never did, so when she came | home from work she'd turn the temperature down to 78deg. | dexwiz wrote: | At 42% humidity, I'm guessing they live in a subtropical | climate. Florida's? | LeifCarrotson wrote: | No, St Louis: | | https://www.weather.gov/lsx/monthTab | | It was in the upper 80s/lower 90s throughout July and August, | when this data was likely collected. And relative humidity | hit 80-90% every morning, averaging about 65% as it warmed | up. It's sticky in summer. I live in Michigan, and even with | a cool breeze from our magnificent freshwater lake, half an | hour inland it's similarly hot and humid. I kept our house at | 78 when we're home, 82 when it's just the dog, and 76 when | company comes over. I think the air conditioner keeps | humidity in the 40% range, though I'm reading this article | because I lack a hygrometer/air quality sensor and don't | really have hard numbers for that, only that humidity is | significantly less indoors than out. | | Also, he mentions that the orientation of the case causes | convection off the ESP8266 to increase the air temperature by | a couple degrees (Farenheit). | | If you're one of the Silicon Valley HN readers looking to | move to the wide open spaces and relaxed culture of the | Midwest, do be aware that climate is a big deal; coastal | California's perpetual mild climate is an aberration. | zeku wrote: | In Tennessee myself and it is only just now getting to a | temperature/humidity that is bearable to be outdoors. | | March spring hits and the pollen is crazy until June and by | then it's too hot to really be outside without tree cover | from 9am-8pm until around now. | | My area is one of the worst pollen places in the country. | You owe it to yourself before moving to look at a pollen | map as well. | dexwiz wrote: | As a Midwest native, but SF resident, I don't think I could | ever move back due to the weather. | DiabloD3 wrote: | Maine is relatively dry. My house generally stays around | 40-60% humidity year round except during the coldest parts of | the winter, independent of the outdoors in both extremes. | bombela wrote: | 82degF == 27.7degC | | https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fahrenheit | zekrioca wrote: | Why not? | mikodin wrote: | > The case is well-ventilated, and my only complaint is the | natural convection causes very-slightly-warmed air from the | WeMos D1 and CO2 sensor to pass over the temperature and | humidity sensor on the top, meaning those readings are always a | bit higher than ambient--at least in my office. | | Likely because of this. | geerlingguy wrote: | Heh, this. I keep the thermostat between 78-80degF during the | summer months (which allows the A/C to run enough to keep | humidity down below 50%), and between 68-72degF in the | winter. | [deleted] | asciimov wrote: | Here in South Texas I keep my house at 78deg during the daytime | in A/C season (that's typically March-November, plus some days | the other months). If the ceiling fan's aren't on, and the air | isn't moving around properly, it can easily get up to 82deg. | It's perfectly comfortable. (You acclimate to it) | | Understand, the average high is in the mid to upper 90's and | trying to get a home a/c to cover a 20+ temperature difference | is difficult and significantly drives up the monthly power | bill. | [deleted] | post_break wrote: | I wish there was a cheaper buy it option. I really really want to | do this but I'm worried I'll get half way and get stuck. | dhritzkiv wrote: | I'm the same. | | Plus, my living in Canada means getting all the different | components piecemeal, often from different suppliers/sellers is | a giant PITA. This is further complicated by my self-imposed | restriction to not buy from Amazon. And this is before the | headache of shipping costs (often $15 as the lowest option, | even for small parts) | | I'd love a ~$200-300CAD pre-assembled or kit option where I can | own the data, access it in a standard fashion, and optionally | choose to crowd-source it. | tzs wrote: | The WeMos D1 Mini link ends up at an AliExpress login page, not | the product page for the D1 Mini. It looks like you linked to | your order page instead. | geerlingguy wrote: | Sorry about that! This is the one I bought: | https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32651747570.html?spm=a2g0s.9... | | I've also updated the link on my site. | fuzzybassoon wrote: | Not the author, but this[1] looks to be the listing for the D1 | Mini from the LOLIN official store. | | 1: | https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32529101036.html?spm=a2g0o.s... | avodonosov wrote: | Anyone can recommend good quality inexpensive sensors? | harias wrote: | Try the one's listed here maybe: | https://newscenter.lbl.gov/2020/08/18/low-cost-home-air-qual... | asdff wrote: | Not exactly inexpensive. These are "low cost" in that they | don't cost $20,000 like the sensors used by government | agencies, but they aren't what I as a consumer think low cost | means. | numpad0 wrote: | I can recommend against one type of bad sensors. VOC sensors | paired with a temperature sensor that can generate "eCO2" value | is known bad, such as CCS811/BME280 combo board. | | Those sensors guesstimate CO2 concentration from air | temperature and changes in ambient alcohol/acetone/hydrocarbon | levels, which drifts into positive infinity and is simply do | not correlate well with actual CO2 level. | | Those sensors are dirt cheap, and can still be used as a rule | of thumb to encourage regular ventilation, but are nothing more | than that. If you want to actually see CO2 levels, avoid those. | Someone1234 wrote: | I was surprised to learn that the Airthings Wave Plus ($180~) | doesn't measure PM2.5. It is cool that it does Radon and VOCs | which this cannot do. | | This seems like it could either compete OR complement an | Airthings Wave Plus for like 35% of the cost. Since they both | offer different and overlapping data. | | I wonder what you'd need to do to get Radon and VOCs too in this | solution (essentially match and exceed the Airthings Wave Plus)? | at_a_remove wrote: | Honestly, it seems like there's a long list of things to | monitor: | | * Radon * Carbon dioxide * Carbon monoxide * Nitrogen Dioxide * | Sulfur Dioxide * Ozone * PM2.5, PM10 (any others?) * VOCs * | Temperature * Humidity * Pressure | | It is an opportunity for someone to make a "suite" sensor so | you could scatter them around the house for good average | measurements. | endymi0n wrote: | The air-q pro comes pretty close (I'm thinking of buying it), | but it's rather expensive and I haven't seen any reviews yet: | https://shop.air-q.com/air-Q-Pro-air-analyser-14-sensors | 5e92cb50239222b wrote: | Last time I looked into gas sensors (for measuring SO2 and | NO2 which reach extreme levels in my area), they were $100+ | each, depending on the gas it's measuring. | at_a_remove wrote: | I think that kind of thing could get knocked down in price | a bit with scale and inclusion in a sensor suite. | roessland wrote: | Have you looked at the View Plus (EUR300-ish)? It has PM2.5, | CO2, radon, humidity, pressure and temperature. Also I believe | it has multiple of some of the same sensors for better | accuracy. | | Way overpriced vs AliExpress but oh well. | | https://www.airthings.com/en/view-plus | abledon wrote: | This thing looks amazing, and entire first batch is sold out! | | Definitely going to pick one up when they are available. I | might save a few bucks diong the DIY route, but at the end of | the day, I would just buy 3-4 more shares of a vanguard | thing, and have to tinker/maintain a grafana dashboard, where | this thing is probably getting new apps/updates/features | monthly. | robbomacrae wrote: | "The case is well-ventilated, and my only complaint is the | natural convection causes very-slightly-warmed air from the WeMos | D1 and CO2 sensor to pass over the temperature and humidity | sensor on the top, meaning those readings are always a bit higher | than ambient--at least in my office." | | Have you considered turning it around? | geerlingguy wrote: | But then the display would not be oriented correctly ;) | | What I'm planning on doing is soldering a jumper to the board | and having the temperature sensor hang out the side of the case | a bit, towards the bottom. | lindenstark wrote: | Daniel Cuthbert did something quite similar[0], with pollution | sensor from ikea. | | [0] https://twitter.com/dcuthbert/status/1421822958604062726 | Animux wrote: | See also this: https://github.com/Hypfer/esp8266-vindriktning- | particle-sens... | Rafuino wrote: | Any suggestions for a CO2 monitor that doesn't require you to | solder? I have an Arduino and a breadboard so can hand wire | things in the meantime if needed... | karmelapple wrote: | I really like my Aranet4, although it costs a little over | US$200. No soldering though, and its been running on one | battery charge for over half a year! | BoorishBears wrote: | In theory there's no reason you can't use a breadboard jumper | kit and splice it to the cable that the sensor comes with | | But soldering has a very low cost-of-entry, and even using | solderable breadboards over solderless can make your project a | lot easier to use (no more worrying about lose connections or | capacitance issues) | Scene_Cast2 wrote: | For some context, PurpleAir also uses Plantower dust sensors. As | an alternative, there's also the Honeywell HPMA sensors (used in | Awair). | philips wrote: | It is too bad that PurpleAir doesn't do CO2 last I looked. I | really want a single device. | Scene_Cast2 wrote: | My old Awair has a Telaire T6703 CO2 sensor; the newer ones | probably have something similar. I also had a standalone | sensor at one point, they're a thing too. | | And Tindie has a slew of ready-to-order air quality stations | too. | philips wrote: | Have you had a good experience with Awair? The last time I | looked it seemed like they had no recommended way to clean | the sensors. And in my limited experience PM2.5 sensors do | need periodic cleaning to remain accurate. My air filter | has one and the manufacturer recommends a bit of alcohol | and a puff of air. | Scene_Cast2 wrote: | Their old one had an issue with the dust sensor clogging. | | The new ones use the Honeywell sensor. It has a tiny fan | on it (inaudible in a quiet room from 5 inches away); | mine ran well for a couple of years until I knocked it | off my desk. After that, the fan started rattling, so I | ordered another Honeywell sensor ($40) and replaced it | (no soldering required, just a screwdriver). That | sensor's datasheet doesn't have any cleaning | instructions, so I don't think it's a big issue. | philips wrote: | Ok thanks | personjerry wrote: | Is there a non-DIY version of this, preferably <$100? I often | have breathing difficulties and would be curious to see if | humidity, CO2, and pm2.5 are affecting me, but I don't have a | soldering kit. | outlog wrote: | think the Qingping air detector lite fits the bill - | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FVzwBGf6woo - available on | amazon or aliexpress etc. | newbamboo wrote: | Bought a monitor because aqi near me averages 50-100 during | summer, pre-fire season. | | Found my tvoc is constantly in .70-1.0 mg/m3 unless I open all | windows and run fans. Then it drops to around .6 mg/m3. I now | don't worry at all about pm2.5 levels and just keep my windows | open if the temps below 100. Buying the monitor showed me that my | migraines and other issues (brain fog) were caused by the high | voc. Opening windows even if it means breathing wildfire smoke | makes the headaches disappear. | | Anyone out there on the fence about buying a monitor, just do it. | There are worse issues than pm2.5 and smoke, both of which you | can detect with your nose. | ttesttom wrote: | Did you buy an AirGradient monitor or any brand you recommend | that is not DIY? | newbamboo wrote: | Just the 80 dollar temtop that sells on Amazon. Easy enough | to check against local purple air sensors for the particulate | readings. I did that, and they were spot on for my | neighborhood. Don't know if I trust the formaldahyde reading | but the tvoc corresponds to my physical experience very well, | and it drops to near 0 tvoc when taken outside. If there's a | catch, it's that you don't know what voc you're dealing with. | Could be something lethal like radon or something fairly | innocuous at the levels I'm seeing. Whatever it is in my | case, it causes very predictable migraine symptoms which | correspond to the voc level almost perfectly. | macNchz wrote: | After getting a (non-DIY because as much as I like hobby | electronics I have a tendency to scope creep my little projects | straight into incompletion) about a year ago, my main learnings | have been: | | - Cooking is insanely bad for the air in your house, even with an | outside-venting hood. Any sort of medium-high heat cooking will | spike the PM2.5 to multiple times that of the haziest days here | in NYC, and with the windows shut it will stay elevated for hours | after. | | - The 20" box fan + MERV furnace filter hack is super effective | for cutting down on the PM. A few days this July the wildfire | smoke from the west coast settled on NYC and we had 40-70 ug/m3 | PM2.5 outside. The box fan filter took it down to around 5 in a | matter of minutes. I didn't even bother taping the filter to the | fan. | | - My A/C system's ability to precisely hold the temperature | within fractions of a degree of the thermostat setting is | impressive. | | - With two people working from home in an old, unventilated-but- | kinda-drafty ~700 square foot apartment, the only thing that gets | the CO2 levels into "drowsy" territory (my original point of | curiosity when buying the sensor) is running the gas oven for a | while. | throwawaysea wrote: | There are better setups than the 20" box fan + MERV furnace | filter. For example check out this similar DIY design that | reduces risk of an electrical fire by making it easier for the | fan to draw air: https://encycla.com/Corsi-Rosenthal_Cube | rovr138 wrote: | From that page, | | >The EPA funded a study by Underwriters Laboratories (UL) | which tested box fans with MERV-13 filters attached, finding | them to not present a fire hazard even in extreme, modified | conditions. | | Then it links to, https://chemicalinsights.org/wp- | content/uploads/DIY-Box-Fan-... | | which says, | | >Two-Sided Obstruction | | >Figure 6 shows the time series of monitored temperatures | under extreme condition where both sides of the fans were | blocked. Despite the severe blockage of air flow, | temperatures of all five box fans peaked within the first 20 | minutes and then plateaued, remaining steady for the | remaining 7 hours. Winding temperatures had the largest | relative increase of 30 to 57 degC above ambient temperature, | with peak absolute winding temperatures remaining at or below | 80 degC. Peak temperatures on other fan parts did not exceed | 50 degC. | | > Temperatures at the power cord, guard, and switch, remained | close to ambient room temperature (+-6 degC) during all | filter test scenarios as well as during the one-sided blocked | tests. For the two-sided blocked tests, temperatures at the | power cord, guard, and switch increased initially before | plateauing to a steady temperature for the remainder of the | 7-hour test duration. All fans remained operational for the | 7-hour test duration and did not show any signs of potential | hazard or damage. | TrevorJ wrote: | The gas stove thing was surprising, but of course it makes a | ton of sense! | wintermutestwin wrote: | >The 20" box fan + MERV furnace filter hack | | Living here in the west with hyper toxic AQI for the better | part of two months now, I decided that the low CFM and leakage | of a DIY box fan are not adequate to keep up. I went with a far | more industrial solution: I went to an indoor grow shop and | bought an activated carbon filter and high CFM inline fan. Cost | $150 and is a bit noisy, but has been well worth it. | fosk wrote: | Link? | jonahhorowitz wrote: | You can buy carbon activated MERV filters. I got some from | Nordic Pure. | rtkaratekid wrote: | What sensor are you using? Just curious. | macNchz wrote: | I'm using an Awair Element, I didn't do a ton of research on | alternatives, but the app is pretty good and it "just works". | newfonewhodis wrote: | I've been thinking of getting it what are your thoughts on | longevity of it? Will it last at least a few years? I also | see in some Amazon reviews that measurements get "stuck" to | some extreme. Have you noticed that too? | tpmx wrote: | For DIY, there was a pretty good discussion on suitable | sensors in the AirGradient post from three months ago that | Jeff linked to: | | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27125060 | | tl;dr: seems like you want an NDIR sensor (https://en.wikiped | ia.org/wiki/Nondispersive_infrared_sensor). | | Some options, with digikey @1 prices: | | Senseair S8 (Sweden): $48 | | Sensirion SCD30 (Switzerland): $63 | | Amphenol Telaire T6713 (US): $96 | | If I were to buy an expensive black box iot solution, I'd at | least verify that it had an NDIR sensor. | s0rce wrote: | I'm using an SCD41 with an OLED+microcontroller (using | Sensirion's example code hacked a bit) and it seems to work | well, cheaper than the NDIR using some photoacoustic magic. | tpmx wrote: | $37 @1, but not in stock at digikey, and an 11 week lead | time. | | It's pretty tiny... I wonder if/when it will be possible | to put a high quality co2 sensor in an IP68 iPhone... | s0rce wrote: | I had purchased the dev kit sek-scd41 but its out of | stock as well. The SCD41 also does RH and T so you don't | need a separate sensor for that. | karmelapple wrote: | To add to the list of sensors: I was most curious in CO2 | levels, so I got an Aranet4: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07YY7 | BH2W/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_glt_... | | It's got an eink screen, and I haven't had to recharge it | since I got it 8 months ago. I really like it. | Robotbeat wrote: | Are there any affordable CO2 sensors that don't use outside | air for calibration of ppm? I want to know how outside air | CO2 levels change as well. Would be interesting to see day | to day changes and how big they are in absolute terms. | (Also to show people about how CO2 levels are changing | globally... without just pointing to a website of someone | else's measurements.) | Scene_Cast2 wrote: | I think the draftiness is key. In my findings, in a "modern" | house (double-paned windows, built in the last 20 years), | sleeping with the door closed will spike CO2 to 4 digits. The | other thing is that air really needs to circulate in order to | lower CO2 - opening a window in a room will not lower the | hallway CO2 unless there's at least some draft / air movement. | 5e92cb50239222b wrote: | Temperature difference helps if there's no wind. In winter | time CO2 drops from 4000+ ppm to ~450 in only a couple of | minutes after opening a single window (with inside to outside | temperature difference of 50degC or higher). In summer it | drops to ~600-700 and stays there, and even this takes hours. | crazygringo wrote: | That's what I've discovered over the past year! I live in | NYC and my CO2 levels are fine in both the winter and on | hot summer days, without even trying. | | But when it's 65-75degF outside in the spring/fall... CO2 | builds up in my apartment like _crazy_. I keep the windows | open and my bathroom fan on to try to suck fresh air in... | but even so can 't manage to really get it below 650, and | with just a window cracked it sticks around 850. | | It's really frustrating. | y4mi wrote: | 50degC difference or even higher? Damn mate, even Siberia | only gets around -34degC which is less then that of you | target the usual 18-21degC. Your winters sound terrifying. | freeopinion wrote: | Winters? I thought they were referring to this last May | or the previous August. | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Highest_temperature_recorde | d_o... | theluketowers wrote: | Saskatchewan Canada can easily reach -40degC for several | weeks during the winter. | withinrafael wrote: | Our multi-room apartment in Redmond, WA, has an always | running intake fan in the master bathroom advertised as a way | to keep air fresh. I always wonder how effective that really | is (at apartment scale) and if it's really worth the 24/7 | power draw. | hourislate wrote: | It's to keep positive pressure in your unit for safety | purposes. If there is a fire the fresh air will help keep | smoke out of your unit and as a bonus it keeps other | building odors out. Generally it is a large fan on the roof | that just sucks air down a stack pumping it into every | unit. You could put a filter over the register and filter | that air. | withinrafael wrote: | Sorry, by intake I meant it's sucking air in. That is, | air is leaving my apartment. I think you're on the right | track with the safety angle here though. Will do more | research. | zz865 wrote: | Its probably the opposite, it sucks out air. It does stop | smells from this apartment going into neighboring spaces. | asdff wrote: | Probably more for preventing mold damage from lazy tenants | I imagine. | davemp wrote: | That's why an ERV [1] is important in a modern house with | good air tightness. | | [1]: | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_recovery_ventilation | nsporillo wrote: | In a modern home, there should be supply and return vents in | every room. My home built in 1978 has 3 returns for the | entire house, one on each floor. Master bedroom has a supply, | but the return is located in the hallway. Over the years, the | recommended door cut to allow air flow has been changed | (presumably for greater privacy) - which leads to the | scenario you're describing. | | I could add the door cut back in, install return transfer | grill, or look into adding a secondary heat recovery | ventilator that acts independently of the primary HVAC | system. | geerlingguy wrote: | I know many people who put 'draft stop' devices on the | bottoms of their bedroom doors in older homes (old enough | to not have returns in each room, but new enough for | central air), not realizing they're cutting off the one bit | of circulation they need for a proper functioning central | air system! | | Or they buy new high efficiency windows and doors, and that | 'tightens up' the house, but they don't also install an HRV | (Heat Recovery Ventilator) to exchange outside air. | nsporillo wrote: | Realistically new windows and doors probably wont drop | the homes air changes per hour below the recommended | minimums, but I don't know for sure. I've gotten my | crawlspace spray foamed and I'm getting my vented attic | spray foamed to bring it into my envelope. Also getting | new windows and doors soon, but after all of that I think | enough air could leak through sill and top plates, | electrical outlets, etc. | | Having the foam crew do a blower door test for free if we | go with them, so I guess I'll see. I live in climate zone | 5a (cool, humid) so historically natural ventilation was | used via induced pressure differentials generated by | mechanical means (dryer, furnace, bathroom and kitchen | vents). When we get new furnace and water heater that | pull combustion air from outside, we're left with mostly | manual means for generating negative pressure that drives | infiltration. (But also wind, and pressure differentials | caused by temperatures in winter) | | In our case, we're definitely considering either an HRV | or ERV to supply fresh outdoor air that we control (input | and output CFM, MERV #). Our indoor air quality is poor | enough to the point where we live with the tangible | symptoms (Rhinitis), not just numbers on a sensor. | | For those with interest in these topics, I suggest | skimming a copy of one of the ASHRAE fundamentals | handbooks[1]. It reads as a textbook but has incredible | depth into the physical sciences that relate to building | science, heating, cooling, and ventilation. | | [1] https://archive.org/details/ashraehandbook2017hvacfun | damenta... | [deleted] | rootusrootus wrote: | > In a modern home, there should be supply and return vents | in every room. | | That must vary by region. I live in the PNW, and I have not | seen a recently built house with a return in each room. One | or more supply vents per room depending on size, one return | for each floor seems pretty much standard. | windexh8er wrote: | Interesting. I live in the upper midwest and remember my | first home I lived in (parents built it new in 1980) had | returns in every room. My current home is primarily | forced air and there are returns in every room with | multiples in the larger gathering spaces. Was built in | the late 90s and I think building code may require a | specific number of returns per square foot. | rootusrootus wrote: | Could be regional -- I would bet that in most cases | houses in the upper midwest have to deal with much colder | temperatures in the winter than houses in the PNW. Maybe | that influences the HVAC design. | | But I wouldn't be the least bit surprised to find that | there isn't really a specific reason, it's just "how we | do things in this area." A surprising amount of building | choices seem to be made that way. | nsporillo wrote: | The box fan and high-merv filter hack is a good idea, but | proper ventilation of filtered outdoor air is the best | solution. Not always practical, but historically buildings | breath via air infiltration due to pressure differentials, | stack effects, wind, etc - might as well bring in the air on | your own terms rather than it leak through your walls and | insulation. | Tenoke wrote: | I'm not actually sure it's always the best. My rooms face the | street and I can't tell if the air I get on that side is | actually better than just having air from the other side | +purifier. | nsporillo wrote: | Quality Energy/Heat Recovery Ventilators (which are | basically mandated by code [in some jurisdictions] in | modern construction due to air tightness requirements) | should allow you to select the filter with the MERV value | that works best for your situation. | | But to be fair, you may have a good point. Vehicle | emissions and tire wear generates particulates consider to | be ultrafine (0.1 max nanometer), which is even difficult | for HEPA filters to deal with. | macNchz wrote: | On my leafy Brooklyn street the particulate pollution outside | is well within the recommended levels nearly all the time, so | thankfully there's not really a pressing need to retrofit | modern ventilation into a 120 year old house. That is, | assuming the presence of wildfire smoke from 3000 miles away | remains a rare event, which...who knows. | jozzy-james wrote: | - Cooking is insanely bad for the air in your house, even with | an outside-venting hood. | | weeps in searing steaks with no hood at all :'( | jeffwass wrote: | If someone knows the answer to this I'd be interested to know : | | Do different PM2.5 components affect the body differently, even | for the same overall count? | | Eg, are the PM2.5 particulates from burning toast comparable in | bodily health impact to a similar PM2.5 count coming from a | heavy Diesel engine's exhaust (which I presume would have a | different particulate makeup). | pirate787 wrote: | My understanding is that PM2.5 with heavy metals or toxic | payloads is more dangerous, but both are dangerous. | goodpoint wrote: | > - Cooking is insanely bad for the air in your house | | Hold on! Not all particulates are equally harmful - and by far! | | A particulate sensor detects water vapor or particles of (non- | burnt) cooking oil that are harmless to humans. | | In the same way, it detects very dangerous (carcinogenic) | compounds from combustion engines or burning coal or wood. | | Cooking is in no way "insanely bad" (unless you are grilling | your food black or cooking on an open wood/coal fire) | macNchz wrote: | I am able to find many journal articles confirming my | observations that cooking produces significantly elevated | indoor PM2.5 levels, many of which suggest it to be harmful, | but I'm not finding anything about the relative impacts of | the different substances that make up fine/ultrafine | particles. People involved in this research seem to think it | will require more study: | | >"We know that inhaling particles, regardless of what they're | made of, is detrimental to health. Is it equally bad as | inhaling exhaust from vehicle emissions? That we don't know | that yet," [1] | | Regardless, my sensor, at least, doesn't register water vapor | as particulate. I can run an ultrasonic humidifier with | distilled water to no effect on the measured PM2.5, or with | tap water which will spike the particulates from the | dissolved minerals. | | 1) https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/feb/17/cookin | g-... | 5e92cb50239222b wrote: | It does not measure water vapor, at least not the one I'm | using (PMS5003). I always have windows tightly shut because | of the extreme pollution outside, so 100% humidity is easy to | reach simply by mopping the floors (which stay wet for hours | after). It does not change PM measurements one bit. Fry a | couple of eggs though, and PM 2.5 quickly goes over 100 | ug/m3. Burn a piece of meat just a little bit and see it rise | over 300 ug/m3. | eutectic wrote: | What about suspended water droplets? | crazygringo wrote: | The thing that sends my PM2.5 skyrocketing the most is, | interestingly, my toaster oven. Like from 50 to 1500 in the | space of 10 min. No food needed within -- just the heating | itself. | | I have no idea what the particles are though -- metal? Paint? | Carbon from burnt residue? Or just whatever the heating | element itself is made of? | | Separately, cooking with gas (oven+stove) also sends CO2 way | way up -- in my kitchen, from 500 to 1300 or so within 20 | minutes. And that's with my range hood _on_. | sneak wrote: | A lot of range hoods don't actually exhaust outside, and | just suck stovetop air over some steel wool to condense the | grease particles somewhere other than your walls. | | Not saying that's the case here, but several times I | thought the range fan was exhausting the air, only to learn | upon examination that it was just shooting it back out into | the same room. | klondike_klive wrote: | The last place I lived in - the cooker hood did exactly | this, without even the steel wool. We noticed a growing | stain on the ceiling and found out there was no outlet, | no filter, just a fan blowing the greasy air onto the | ceiling. This was a 1 bedroom apartment with one of the | ubiquitous "kitchenette"s that are fitted these days, so | that landlords don't lose a whole room to a kitchen that | exhausted commuting professionals will never use. | | Our current place has a proper kitchen, but the cooker | hood vents outside directly next to the central heating | boiler's intake. | thrashh wrote: | Dust in the toaster? | goodpoint wrote: | Carbon from burnt residue, most likely, and that could be | quite unhealthy. Clean the toaster! | crazygringo wrote: | Thing is you can't really deep-clean it... it's not | particularly dirty, I keep the bottom free of crumbs | etc., but when oil droplets from food collect against the | back surface and polymerize there, what can you do...? | | You can't exactly throw the toaster oven in the sink and | scrub the inside surfaces with steel wool and Barkeeper's | Friend under running water like you can with pots and | pans. Nor do toaster ovens have a "self-cleaning" cycle | where you try to just vaporize it all... they simply | don't get hot enough. | JoeDaDude wrote: | This is one of the selling points of induction stoves, but | you will have to balance air quality with exposure to high EM | fields. | nyghtly wrote: | You're leaving out the most important part: cooking with gas. | | "Natural gas and propane stoves can release carbon monoxide, | formaldehyde and other harmful pollutants into the air, which | can be toxic to people and pets." | | https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/resources/documents/indoor-air- | pollut... | | "Gas stoves can generate unsafe levels of indoor air | pollution" | | https://www.vox.com/energy-and- | environment/2020/5/7/21247602... | goodpoint wrote: | No, I'm responding to the statement about particulate. | Gasses are a different topic. | | Also, the dangers of open flames are well known, unlike the | ones of particulate. | tootie wrote: | Not an expert but from what I've read, gas stoves are by far | the worst. Electric (including induction) are much healthier. | karmelapple wrote: | Agreed with all these observations, especially gas oven or | stove usage! Our former third floor ~1200 sq ft condo would | spike CO2 up well over 1400 ppm when we'd run it, and almost | instantly. | | Even just with two people working from home, much of the space | would quickly get up to 800 or 900 ppm. I'd usually open | windows as I saw it creeping up, which would quickly reduce CO2 | to under 600, and then it would slowly creep up over the day. | Someone1234 wrote: | > I didn't even bother taping the filter to the fan. | | I found bungee cord with J hooks works really well. As you | correctly point out, you don't _need_ to secure it at all, but | it is annoying to tap the box fan and have the filter fall | over. | lisper wrote: | That seems odd to me. I've never tried this, but it seems to | me that you have to put the filter on the intake side of the | fan, other the fan would just blow it off. And on the intake | side, would not the pressure differential hold it in place? | wholinator2 wrote: | I feel like you could place it on either side of the fan as | long as air is directed to go through it. My personal | intuition is filter then fan but I don't see a reason it | couldn't go the other way. I wonder why most devices place | it on the intake though. Maybe to prevent dust from getting | inside a device, but even then it'd only protect the fan | from dust. Hmmm... | r00fus wrote: | When the air is good outside, I typically run our whole-house | fan pulling in outside air while I'm baking or making dinner - | didn't consciously decide on it, but it just seemed to feel | better to do those together. | | Now I really need to investigate more details - like does | induction cooking (vs. gas) improve the quality? What about the | type of food (ie, cooking vegetarian vs. grilling sausages)? | beenBoutIT wrote: | Investigate fume hoods and implement a good one with enough | make-up air to take everything coming off of your range out | of your kitchen. Air quality's negatively impacted by heating | pots/pans/etc. and their contents up and less about how | they're being heated. With the exception of h2o just about | everything you cook has a negative impact on the air quality | and the pans themselves are doing all sorts of interesting | things to the air when they get hot. | hadlock wrote: | > the components for this project cost between $60-80 | | Purple air sells a turn key indoor air quality device for $200, | is very reliable, also comes in a (clear) 3d printed case, comes | with power supply. Not as DIY as this guy's solution, but with | limited time on my hands the $100 was worth the cost of | admission. It also works with Purple Air's map which provides | nationwide air quality, temp and humidity, etc which is really | nice. | | It's worked flawlessly for me now for about five months. The | light turns from green to yellow when I open the window in my | south facing condo, but turns green again when I close the window | and turn on the air filter. I was surprised at how bad the air | quality gets when cooking food on the stove. | goodpoint wrote: | I wish there was a credible, volunteer run indoor/outdoor | pollution map. | | With cheap probes and peer-review software (properly packaged in | Linux distributions). | gruez wrote: | FYI to the author: you can get tiny screws off ebay/aliexpress. | They're under $2 for 50-100, including shipping. | geerlingguy wrote: | True, I just don't have any that small on hand. I have a few | boxes of M2.5 and M3, but none smaller. | jvanderbot wrote: | I did a similar thing -- set up AQ sensors in the house. | | I used the sps30 from sparkfun, CAD'd up a panel mount, 3d | printed it, built a wooden box for it + a pi, set up all the | networking and hosting, and packaged my utils for debian. | | Anyway, the AQ is fine, HEPA filters work when in-line with the | A/C, and there's nothing much to monitor even when AQ is mod/bad | outside. Boring, but nice to know, and fun to learn all those new | skills. | | Just don't burn incense. | sneak wrote: | Or standard paraffin candles! The soot (even when they burn | normally/"clean") is killer. | | I have some beeswax ones coming soon which are supposed to be | better; my PM25 meter is standing by for their arrival. | jvanderbot wrote: | I bought some electric candles. They can go months on a AA | nimh battery, and if you pay enough for them, they are | actually good / realistic enough for the wife's relaxation. | Great for power outages as well. | throwawaysea wrote: | Is there a particular "expensive" model you would recommend | for realism? | jvanderbot wrote: | These work really well, and seem to actually be made of | wax so the candle looks quite good. Note the "wick" is | sunk in an inch or two so there's nothing to really | suspend disbelief. | | Also they have an optional 24-hour timer so they'll | remember to turn on the same time you turned them on | yesterday. | | https://www.potterybarn.com/products/flameless-outdoor- | candl... | sneak wrote: | I like fire, and I like dripping wax, and I have really | nice sterling candelabras that look quite spiffy on my big | table bedecked with a half dozen long black taper candles. | eulers_secret wrote: | I feel the same way. Electrics are neat, though - | especially if you make your own: | https://cpldcpu.wordpress.com/2016/01/05/reverse- | engineering... | | But I just like the 'ambiance' too much. There are always | different levels of risk adverseness: if I was | considering candles a pollution health hazard I should | also stop riding motorcycles, vaping various things, and | stop eating like I do... | blacksmith_tb wrote: | That has been my experience too - unless you put your monitor | in your kitchen, in which case frying or baking will usually | cause a pretty significant spike... | Scene_Cast2 wrote: | I'm currently building an adapter to mate furnace filters to | quiet, high static pressure fans. This should keep the same | volume of filtration as a box fan, but lower the noise | significantly. I'll probably be ordering a batch of 5-10, if | interested, email me (link in profile). Or comment, as long as | you have an email in your profile, I suppose. | smiley1437 wrote: | I'm interested | Scene_Cast2 wrote: | Do you have an email or a way to reach out? I didn't find one | in your profile. | smiley1437 wrote: | updated my profile thanks | fotta wrote: | Probably worth noting that the South Coast AQMD tests various PM | sensors from consumer-grade to lab-grade and publishes results | [0]. Lots of cheaper consumer-grade sensors outperform the | expensive lab-grade sensors. | | [0] http://www.aqmd.gov/aq-spec/evaluations/summary-pm ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2021-09-08 23:00 UTC)