[HN Gopher] A massive oil spill in the Pacific Ocean reached the... ___________________________________________________________________ A massive oil spill in the Pacific Ocean reached the Southern California coast Author : amelius Score : 143 points Date : 2021-10-03 18:53 UTC (4 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.npr.org) (TXT) w3m dump (www.npr.org) | spicyramen wrote: | Yes, was very disappointed as they closed the airshow. | lefrenchy wrote: | This comment is just too on the nose, chef's kiss. | userbinator wrote: | It'll just slowly go back into the ground where it came... I find | it funny that a lot of self-proclaimed "environmentalists" who | love to espouse the benefits of using "natural" stuff get | outraged by things like this, as if oil wasn't a naturally | occurring substance. | foxhop wrote: | It floats on top of water and kills life. | Zamicol wrote: | Tragic. | | I hope in the future humanity is better with mycoremediation. | bigdict wrote: | I first parsed this as my-core-mediation. | mch82 wrote: | @SupervisorFoley on Twitter is a member of the Orange County | Board of Supervisors & providing useful updates for anyone living | in the area. | labster wrote: | Couldn't happen to a more appropriate group of people. It's just | deserts for decades of opposing environmental policy. I hope the | residents of Huntington Beach are so inconvenienced that they | have to relocate to their second homes in Texas. | throwaway0a5e wrote: | This will reconsider nothing and just find a way to rob state | coffers to pay for cleanup. Basically every calamity that | befalls rich coastal residents is handled like I described. Why | will this one be different? | labster wrote: | Of course it won't be different. But I'd rather it happened | in Huntington Beach than Venice or San Pedro, because the | people there actually deserve it. | pine390 wrote: | Perhaps you should seek out a therapist in order to process | your violent tendencies and the subconscious traumas that | could be leading towards such behavior. | sva_ wrote: | Some video of oil at the beach | | https://twitter.com/alschaben/status/1444664303269728257 | anoplus wrote: | It is deemed to be repeated, as long as most people are too | indifferent to push this kind of unjustified environmental damage | to the headlines | gruez wrote: | But oil spills have been trending down over the past few | decades, even as oil shipments have increased: | https://ourworldindata.org/oil-spills. | | You're right it won't go to zero, in the same sense that | airplane crashes won't ever go to zero. however that's because | it's really hard to prevent all airplane crashes/oil spills, | not because people are "too indifferent". | belorn wrote: | Airplane crashes will continue as long as people use air | travel, which is unlikely to ever change. The best we can do | to prevent airplane crashes would be to build in enough | security in airplanes so that enough amount of systems has to | fail before a crash can occur, including eliminating human | failure and cascading failures. | | Oil spills will also continue as long we extract oil from the | bottom of the ocean (and to a degree land). In contrast to | airplanes however, we should have a future where we stop | extracting it from the earth. In order prevent climate change | we need to stop today, and every day we continue to pump it | up we are stepping further into catastrophe. | | We can have a future were electric planes flies in the sky. | We can't have a future were we continue pumping up more oil. | The oil need to stay where it is. | burkaman wrote: | This spill was from an oil rig, not a tanker. Do rig and | pipeline spills follow the same trend? Haven't found data on | rigs yet, but pipeline spills do not. | | Pipeline incidents have been roughly constant over time: http | s://portal.phmsa.dot.gov/analytics/saw.dll?Portalpages&P... | | Edit: Also, the data you referenced comes from an | organization that's run by oil companies and tanker operators | (https://www.itopf.org/about-us/the-board/). I doubt they'd | just fabricate data, but they are incentivized to massage the | definition of what counts as an "oil spill from a tanker". If | I were relying on this data I'd probably want to find an | independent source. | | Edit 2: NOAA data of all spills does not show a downward | trend: https://incidentnews.noaa.gov/raw/index | gruez wrote: | >Pipeline incidents have been roughly constant over time: h | ttps://portal.phmsa.dot.gov/analytics/saw.dll?Portalpages&P | ... | | I couldn't get the link to work. If it's flat, but the | amount of oil being transported is up, isn't that still a | decline? | | >Edit 2: NOAA data of all spills does not show a downward | trend: https://incidentnews.noaa.gov/raw/index | | I fed the chart into excel and generated a graph: | https://i.imgur.com/QKu2Yly.png | | looks like even though incidents (orange line) is up, the | amount spilled (blue) is down. | burkaman wrote: | Sorry about the pipeline link, it's ALL REPORTED INCIDENT | 20 YEAR TREND on this page: | https://www.phmsa.dot.gov/data-and- | statistics/pipeline/pipel.... I don't know if amount | transported by pipeline is going up. | | I appreciate your optimism. The downward trend in amount | spilled is nice to see, but that value is unknown for | nearly half the entries, so I wouldn't read too much into | it. I'm not saying it's impossible that things are | getting better, I even think it's likely, but it's | certainly not at the same level as airplane safety, where | everything that can be done is being done and crashes are | incredibly rare. It is trivial to find examples of the | oil industry failing to do the bare minimum (here's one | recent report, the first thing I found: | https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-21-293). I'm very | comfortable stepping on a plane, but I would not be | comfortable living next to a pipeline or making a living | fishing next to an oil rig, and I think the statistics | back up my feelings. | cptskippy wrote: | Southern California has considerable oil and natural gas | seepage off shore. Many of the oil rigs aren't drilling but | simply harvesting the seeps. | | They passively collect 100-150 barrels a day from the Coal Oil | Point Seep Field. | | https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_Oil_Point_seep_field | | The oil in question was not from a seep however. It came from | the processing platform Elly that supports two other drilling | rigs in the Beta field. | xyzzyz wrote: | Seems like the "massive oil spill" from the link is | equivalent to half a year of natural seepage from this single | seep field. | dmckeon wrote: | More like a month, at 42 gallons per barrel. | cptskippy wrote: | I have no idea how a surface spill compares deep water | seeps but the seeps have been happening for hundreds of | thousands of years. | | Not sure where I am going with this but I just thought it | was interesting. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2021-10-03 23:00 UTC)