[HN Gopher] Things you are allowed to do, academic edition ___________________________________________________________________ Things you are allowed to do, academic edition Author : Topolomancer Score : 73 points Date : 2021-11-18 17:25 UTC (5 hours ago) (HTM) web link (bastian.rieck.me) (TXT) w3m dump (bastian.rieck.me) | jarenmf wrote: | I've had great luck with cold emailing scientists with | interesting questions or asking for code, I almost always got | interesting and lengthy answers even from famous scientists in | the field whom you'd expect to be super busy. | decsser wrote: | This is often the case but I would never expect a response. I | used to work with some PhD CS / MD / IITians / TED speakers. | By-and-large, top people tend to skew towards celebrity-like | personalities: bifurcating into highly-socialized or | misanthropic. Most are highly-socialized as it's academia. | | My general rule-set is "impose as least as possible, ask | something only they would know, and don't waste anyone's time." | btrettel wrote: | I recall once that I emailed someone who wrote a paper I liked | very much congratulating them on the excellent paper. I didn't | get a response until probably around a month later. They thanked | me, said that my email made them very happy, and apologized for | the delay, saying something along the lines of "Your email was so | positive that I didn't know what to say in response." | dhosek wrote: | I make a point of sending complimentary emails whenever I read | a story or poem I really enjoy. As a writer of fiction and | poetry, I know that most of the time, there's no indication | that anybody ever reads our stuff, so it's always nice to find | out that someone does. | j7ake wrote: | Are there any success stories of people becoming a mentor to | someone because of a cold email? That sounds like a lot to ask | for considering how much time it takes to mentor. | Topolomancer wrote: | I am mentoring at least one researcher because they reached out | to me like this. But it's a good point; I'm not sure how | successful the strategy is overall | Cd00d wrote: | 8 months after graduating college, I realized I missed solving | physics problems. | | I drove to the nearest university, walked into the physics | department office, and asked to speak to the chair. The chair | was busy, but the vice-chair was more than happy to chat for 20 | minutes. | | The vice-chair then took me to a researcher's office, and we | chatted for half an hour. That researcher then introduced me to | a group professor, who offered my an unpaid-technician job a | few days a week. | | After a couple months happily toiling in the lab, often | alongside the PI, I was asked to change to a full-time paid | position. | | A year into that the PI asked me to join the graduate college. | I earned a PhD from the group 6 years later. | | It all worked very nicely for me, and every person was lovely | and encouraging through the whole process - regardless of my | audacity in asking for the chair! | JackOfCrows wrote: | I haven't been formally mentored but at work and in school I | have had a lot of luck with "what you do sounds interesting and | I would love to know more about it," including with the Dean of | my department who (I assume) is pretty busy. | | I imagine there are jerks out there but honestly for a lot of | people this is something they have poured a lot of themselves | into (especially in academia) and its nice when someone is new | but actually really interested. | ISL wrote: | If you're an undergraduate at a research institution, the odds | are extremely high (>>20%). Similar if you're a graduate | student/postdoc. Almost every undergraduate I've taken on has | been the result of a cold email with clear intent/interest. | | If you're coming in from outside academia, be prepared to have | useful skills/knowledge to bring to the collaboration and a | clear ability to commit enough time to be valuable. Expect a | much lower conversion-rate. Most people that academics | encounter with cold emails (at least in physics) from the | outside are insufficiently prepared or advancing a pet (usually | demonstrably-incorrect) theory. | | If you email the right person with, | | "Hi, ISL! | | I'm j7ake, and have a ton of experience with X (link to resume) | and am really interested in learning more about experimental | gravitational physics. I've read several of your papers | [1,2,3], and your work is really interesting. | | It looks like you might be able to use X to improve your | results with Y -- might you have a little time to answer some | questions about your group's work and see if there's a way I | might be able to help you put X to good use? | | Thank you! | | j7ake" | | you'll get replies. | dorchadas wrote: | I hope. I'm waiting for replies from two professors I emailed | asking about advice for a PhD and how to pursue it. I even | included my proposal and how I'd go about it. One of them, at | least, mentioned taking PhD students and the other is at the | school that'd be best for it (due to proximity to where I'd | be doing field work). Both mentioned a research interest in | the topic too. I even emailed from another university in the | country's account. | | I've also emailed another academic over a month ago about an | article he wrote abiut a type of non-profit I'd love to set | up, and haven't heard back. Though when I emailed him last | year it did take 6 weeks to respond. I just wrote this to say | I feel it's very hit or miss, depending on the academic in | question. | decsser wrote: | This correlates with my experience. I hustled my way into a | only paid undergrad research assistant role that didn't | previously exist at a top-tier infosec lab doing IPS/IDS work | and helping grad students fix their code. It was necessary as | there were too many applicants for too few menial campus | jobs. | bachmeier wrote: | > Ask someone for a potential collaboration. | | I have received many cold emails asking for this over the years | (many more after becoming an editor for obvious reasons). Given | my schedule and my research backlog, I'm unlikely to accept such | an offer. What I find odd is that the requests almost always | involve topics nowhere near my research expertise. | | The worst ones include something like, "After going through your | publication record, I see that you are an expert on this | topic...". You should not expect a response. I create a new email | filter to be sure I never spend time on your messages again. | mmmmpancakes wrote: | This matches my experience. Collaboration is a serious | undertaking and commitment. It is very unlikely that a | collaboration formed out of thin air will be productive enough | to justify the investment of time and effort. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2021-11-18 23:01 UTC)