[HN Gopher] Charles Mingus Cat Toilet Training Program (1972) ___________________________________________________________________ Charles Mingus Cat Toilet Training Program (1972) Author : lightlyused Score : 274 points Date : 2022-01-09 14:08 UTC (8 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.charlesmingus.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.charlesmingus.com) | dang wrote: | Anybody want to take a shot at figuring out the year? | pvg wrote: | 1972 it looks like, from googling the better original title | _The Charles Mingus Cat-alog_ | | https://www.topospress.com/collections/prints-and-ephemera/p... | | https://www.schoolforthedogs.com/podcasts/episode-96-the-cha... | iainctduncan wrote: | For folks who are like "who is that guy again?".... Mingus was | one of the most important jazz bass players in 20th century and a | key figure in both bebop and free jazz. And quite a character. | This is but one of his legendary achievements! | AlbertCory wrote: | Indeed, and how could I resist reading an article with that | title? | tclancy wrote: | The poop of the jazzman's cat is some jive-ass shit. | iainctduncan wrote: | Winner. That's some inside baseball shit, lol. | kevinmchugh wrote: | I also like how he wrote his eggnog recipe, it's very much in | his voice | https://www.charlesmingus.com/blog/news/minguss-5-star-raptu... | | I've never actually made it | jbigelow76 wrote: | I saw the title and thought "you mean the Jazz musician, | Charles Mingus?" And sure enough, it is, which kind of makes | sense. A random person named Charles Mingus explaining cat | toilet training isn't interesting; it's the esoteric | intersection of a genius who helped shape an entire genre of | music and the mundane things people do in everyday life. | noman-land wrote: | Not just a bass player but a legendary composer. | | Here's one of my absolute faves, Pithecanthropus Erectus. | | https://youtu.be/p0H2G_W-O0I | drumttocs8 wrote: | Black Saint and the Sinner Lady is one of my top albums of | all time. | jbigelow76 wrote: | I got into Charles Mingus through "Mingus Plays Piano", I | particularly like piano jazz when working, but any bop | oriented jazz is good. Newcomers should give "Myself When I | Am Real" a listen, it's a lovely composition. | | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tk71dhCz7wM | noman-land wrote: | Absolutely beautiful album, and Myself When I Am Real is | one of the best tracks. | | The whole record has little bits of studio talk before and | after some of the recordings and you can hear Mingus | feeling really shy and vulnerable playing alone. You can | even hear it in his playing, I think. Pretty remarkable. | Love that guy. | amongwhales wrote: | Love Myself When I Am Real and Black Saint. But I had | trouble finding other songs as enjoyable. Is there | anything else similar in his catalog? | cushychicken wrote: | _Black Saint and The Sinner Lady_ | | !!!!!!! | jokoon wrote: | I wonder if animal trainers have tested this method again and | again. I suspect that not all cat will be able to be trained like | this. | pcj-github wrote: | Our cat spontaneously unlocked this achievement at about 5 years | of age... We heard a little noise in the bathroom for a couple | weeks and could not figure it out until we actually caught her in | the act. Hilarious, and quite convenient! | ubermonkey wrote: | Given that the strip is now (ouch) almost 19 years old, it occurs | to me that some folks may not have seen Nightlife Mingus' | appearance in the web comic Achewood: | | http://www.achewood.com/index.php?date=06202003 | boondaburrah wrote: | Man look at that early 2000s simple text-based web header & web | design. | ad404b8a372f2b9 wrote: | It often strikes me that nothing has aged as well as solid | colour backgrounds/widgets when it comes to user interfaces. | If you'd told me this site was made in 2021 I'd believe you. | Another example that comes to mind is the intro screen at the | start of The Running Man, crisp white text on a red | background. Looks as modern as the day it was made: | https://i.imgur.com/wCRSDK0.jpeg | | I wish I could extrapolate from this to figure out what else | will age well when designing UIs. | kevinmchugh wrote: | This is the strangest intersection of my interests I've ever | experienced. | password1 wrote: | Linus from LinusTechTips did a series of videos on how he trained | his cats to do this: | https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLiNYRHLggAj39fRHaUYE42D2v... | mthom wrote: | The cat that pamphlet is about, Nightlife Mingus: | http://achewood.com/?date=06202003 | subpar wrote: | While we're talking about Mingus, don't sleep on his mind-blowing | eggnog recipe. I try to make it every year... a beautifully | alcoholic act of improvisation: | https://www.charlesmingus.com/blog/news/minguss-5-star-raptu... | koalaman wrote: | I left my cat alone in the house for a few days with my | housekeeper popping in to feed and entertain him. He had a little | over 2 day spell on his own at the end when my housekeeper | couldn't come in. When I arrived home I discovered that our | housekeeper had accidentally closed off the door accessing his | litter box. I searched the house looking for the mess but | couldn't find anything.. until I went to the bathroom and found | that he had taken upon himself to use the toilet. He's definitely | gone up in my esteem since. | | All to say that some cats don't need any kind of training to use | the toilet. | JohnBooty wrote: | This is true. My cat definitely pees in the sinks and bathtubs | sometimes even when his litter is fresh. He poops in the litter | with no issues, so I don't think it's a location problem. My | best educated guess is that he simply finds the sinks more | convenient than hiking down to the basement. | | I have no doubts that he would pee in the toilet as well, but I | can't leave the toilets open because we have dogs around. | | (Although, now that I'm typing this, I suppose we could install | cat-doors on the bathroom doors to let the cat in, and keep the | dogs out...) | | The sink/bathtub peeing is definitely gross and not ideal. But, | not as gross as it sounds. He very very precisely pees directly | down the drain. The smell is almost unnoticeable. So | unnoticeable that it took us a _lot_ of time to figure out he | was even doing it, since he sometimes pees in the box as well. | The main danger to him peeing in the sinks is that it will make | it difficult for us to know if he has a blockage as we can not | monitor his urine output. | | (I am not "noseblind" to cat pee smell, as far as I can tell. | The litterbox is in the basement and if I neglect to clean it | on a given day and there is pee in there, I can smell it from | upstairs. I've also asked trusted people like my brother to | verify there's no cat pee smell in the house! He's not afraid | to give me harsh opinions...) | Nextgrid wrote: | > but I can't leave the toilets open because we have dogs | around. | | As someone who's never been a dog owner, what's the problem | with dogs and toilets? | sethammons wrote: | Dogs like to drink from toilet bowls. I've owned lots of | dogs and it has never been an issue aside from one dog as a | kid and we just accepted it | Nextgrid wrote: | If this is really a big problem I wonder if a brand could | come up with a mix of Bitrex | (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denatonium) and one of | those deodorizers/fresheners you put hanging on the edge | of the toilet bowl. | base698 wrote: | My cats also drink out of the toilets. | fullstop wrote: | My cats will use the sinks or tubs if they have a UTI. | jaxn wrote: | Did they continue using the toilet after that? | rectang wrote: | Cool cat. | | I love how Mingus is so in tune with how his cat (Nightlife) | thinks, sensing how to encourage him, how to avoid freaking him | out, how to lead him along. | | Some of Mingus's best known works (Mingus Ah Um, Black Saint and | The Sinner Lady, etc.) are organized group improvisations, with | multiple wind instruments playing improvised lines at once. It's | different from big bands like Ellington's where you have featured | soloists and everybody else playing charts (even if the rhythm | section does some improvising), and it's difficult to achieve | balance of the various elements under such circumstances. I get a | sense from this article how Mingus manages to get inside the | heads of his collaborators, to keep their trust, and lead them | towards a shared vision. | [deleted] | throwawayjd wrote: | I wonder if this is a joke or an actual technique. I'd be very | interested to see someone reproducing this. | ludamad wrote: | Cats exist that do this, and I haven't seen anything | implausible from a cat psychology standpoint. Seems legit. Dogs | can too | shimonabi wrote: | It's not a joke. | | I've never tried it, but I've seen plastic products selling on | the internet that replace the cardboard. | xtlyths wrote: | I successfully got 2 middle aged cats to do this. They have | both since passed and I have two new cats. I haven't bothered | to train them, but I think it's because my wife cleans their | box and I haven't thought about it. | | The first two cats did this almost effortlessly. They didn't | give us any trouble because we changed steps slowly. | chairmanmow wrote: | I believe you, sounds like a bit of a bother to train the new | cats as well. Makes me wonder though if once one cat was | trained, if you got a new kitten whether it could pick up the | behavior from the trained older cat. That'd be pretty great - | the gift that keeps on giving. | ratww wrote: | I have a friend who never trained their cats for that, yet the | two cats seem to prefer the toilet. The cats even have two | spacious litter boxes away from food and noise. Every time I go | to his house my friend reminds me to put the lid down after using | so the cats don't use it. | Nextgrid wrote: | Out of curiosity, why would he _not_ want them to do that? | Seems very convenient and saves on cleaning the litter box | manually. | shigawire wrote: | I've always been intrigued but the risk/reward seems too high. I | don't want to mess with the bathroom habits of my cat who has | never previously relieved himself outside his box. I scared to | try to fix what isn't broken at this time. | darksaints wrote: | I've seen this tutorial almost word for word before, and I even | know a few people who have trained their cats using this method. | It wasn't until today that I realized that this was method was | created by one of the most famous jazz musicians in the world | (and IMO the best bass player that ever lived). | LNSY wrote: | I love Mingus. | | The Watts Towers complex has a museum to Mingus attached, as well | as another museum of local artists attached. I'd highly recommend | a visit. It's a beautiful neighborhood full of very nice people. | xbar wrote: | As if I didn't have enough reasons to love Mingus. | | Thanks for the museum suggestion. I haven't been to the towers | since 1979 when I made my parents take me after they played in | a tennis tournament at USC while I hung out at the Boys and | Girls Club in the nearby park. | nani_o wrote: | hmahncke wrote: | Excellent use of adaptive learning, zone of proximal development, | etc. | foreigner wrote: | Has anybody managed to teach this to a dog? | wwwwewwww wrote: | I considered training our cat to do this, but there's a bunch of | advice out there saying that it may be harmful to your cat, and | may be difficult as the cat gets older. So please consult with | your vet before going this route. | metabagel wrote: | If you have a cat which uses the litter box without any problems, | count your blessings and call it a day. Having a cat use the | toilet is counter to their instincts to bury their business from | other animals. If they fall in, they'll be traumatized and start | doing their business in other unpleasant places. | | I've used the litter robot, and honestly I think a plain old | litter box is easier to keep clean, and in general better for all | parties. | WickyNilliams wrote: | Funny story: I knew someone who trained their cat to do this. It | was all going well, the cat had been using the toilet | successfully for a number of weeks. That is, until the cat fell | in the toilet one time. From then on it refused to use the | toilet, but had become accustomed to going in the bathroom... So | the cat started popping in the bath. And no matter what he tried | he couldn't stop the cat from doing this. At least the story is | funny from the outside perspective. Perhaps less so if it was | your bath and your cat haha. | | On a more serious note, I believe it is not advised to put cat | poop down the toilet, since our sewage treatment systems are not | capable of dealing with toxoplasmosis from cat faeces | intricatedetail wrote: | Then a cat does "business" in whatever that triggers similar | response as toilet e.g. your shoes, pots etc. It's also not fun | cleaning the cat that fallen into toilet bowl (and all the | splashings around). | viach wrote: | Similar to how one gets a backend developer working on "full- | stack" - by slowly moving tasks context. | SV_BubbleTime wrote: | I think I just realized that my wife has been doing this to me | for years. Eh, I respect her game. | kaashif wrote: | Appreciating the full stack rather than just focusing on the | backend is very important to a marriage. | ramy_d wrote: | Does toilet training your cat introduce a significant health | hazard through toxoplasma gondii into the surrounding | environment? It's so hard to tell if your local wastewater plant | takes care of this... | nickkell wrote: | I could have sworn I read something to this effect, that this | is ill advised because waste treatment plants aren't really | equipped to handle animal parasites | WickyNilliams wrote: | Yeah this is my understanding. Sewage treatment cannot | destroy toxoplasmosis | drakonka wrote: | There are even special litter boxes sold that are intended to go | on the toilet seat for this type of training. But as cool as this | is, I believe it can be dangerous, especially for owners of male | cats. | | Cats' urinary habits are important to keep an eye on. A change in | urination volume or frequency can be the sign of a critical issue | that requires veterinary attention. You just can't easily track | urine volume if the cat is going to the toilet, even if they | don't flush. | | With a litterbox, you can get an idea of what their normal clump | size is and notice if that changes. Regarding frequency, maybe | you can hear your cat jump on the toilet, but I'm not sure it's | as reliable as hearing them repeatedly scratching the litterbox. | If you are out during the day and come home, with a litterbox you | still notice the pee clumps to get an idea of how much they've | peed - unlike with a toilet. | | One aspect where the toilet may actually be better is that you | _might_ be able to spot blood easier in the water. | | I also wanted to train my first cat to use the toilet, until he | suffered from a urinary blockage as a kitten. If he'd been using | the toilet, I likely wouldn't have noticed that anything was | wrong until it was far too late. Blockage is more likely in male | cats, and it is _not_ an uncommon problem. It is already far too | easy to not notice if a cat is blocked if you're not careful, and | it doesn't take long at all to become life threatening. I believe | a toilet would only exacerbate this risk. | | If I see blood in the litter, no clumps, or clumps that are | smaller than usual (or heck, even much bigger than usual), I know | to pay extra attention to my cat and either book a vet | appointment or go to the emergency room. It's allowed me to catch | bouts of infection, crystals, and idiopathic cystitis early (all | of which he is now more prone to after his initial urinary | problems). A cat's kidneys and urinary system can also be | impacted by stress levels, with unexplained straining and bladder | inflammation thought to be in some cases caused by stress. Having | them pee in a toilet in my opinion decreases visibility of a very | important and sensitive health factor. | fhe wrote: | I'd just want to add that, I in general don't think it's a good | idea to train cats to learn behaviors that are unnatural for | them. One could say that, eating processed cat food and living | with humans are already unnatural, which is true. But to the | extent that's possible, I want to provide my cats the freedom | to act as naturally as possible. | | On this particular cat toilet training trick: cats are in fact | quite particular about litterbox -- where it's positioned, how | safe it feels inside it, how it smells. A human toilet is | decidedly an unnatural setup for cats, and who knows what can | happen. Maybe the cat learns to use it but constantly feels | anxious about it (e.g. slipper surface). Maybe it will avoid | pooping until it gets really uncomfortable. All of these can't | be good for its health. | yholio wrote: | The modern housecat is just about as natural as a naked human | living wild in the forest. It has been selectively bred to | perfection for cuteness and sociability with low aggression | and diminished survival abilities. Some can't even tolerate | the natural climate where their owners live. | | I totally support "healthy", but natural, what is natural for | a species that has evolved to use intelligence to prevail | over the natural world (in this case, the intelligence of | their owners, but still)? | | No my friend, our purpose on this earth is to co-evolve the | most unnatural cat to the point where they are ready to take | over as the dominant inteligent species of this side of the | galaxy. | wwwwewwww wrote: | "The modern housecat is just about as natural as a naked | human living wild in the forest. It has been selectively | bred..." | | I think it would be better to say "The modern housecat is | just about as natural as a modern human living in a modern | house". Both species adapted to modern human environment. | causality0 wrote: | I think you're ignoring the ways the toilet is better than | the litter box. For example, it's also unnatural for a cat to | have to smell its old poop and also touch it while burying | new poop. A toilet removes that source of stress and | potential disease. | garblegarble wrote: | Although it's worth noting that there are other non-toilet | alternatives as a middle-ground that also let the cat | perform natural burying behaviour without there being old | poop in there - like a self-cleaning litter box. | InvaderFizz wrote: | I have a cat genie, it's great, if you put it in a well | ventilated outdoor space, have it run automatically after | every time the cat uses it, and toss in a handful of | citric acid every week to let it clean itself. Then every | three months, take the whole thing apart and pressure | wash everything. | | It's better than scooping litter every day, by a factor | of 3-5x. But it's not magical and wonderful. | hedora wrote: | The failure mode on self cleaning litterboxes is worse | than normal litterboxes or toilets. | | We had one, and, as usual, got busy and forgot to clean | it. The end result was a spotless, odor free and empty | self-cleaning litterbox (all the litter had been auto- | removed) and a male cat with a urinary tract infection. | metabagel wrote: | You're exactly right. Cats have an instinctual urge to bury | their poop so other animals won't smell it. The toilet is | counter to their instincts. | | Also, if a cat falls in the toilet, it's traumatizing, and | they may start pooping and peeing in other places which you | don't want. | ModernMech wrote: | > One aspect where the toilet may actually be better is that | you _might_ be able to spot blood easier in the water. | | One thing that's cool is there are special cat litters now that | change color when blood is present. | oneplane wrote: | This is one of those things I thought of as well. A pet | generally won't know how healthy it is or if it feels unwell | why it does so. What you can do as a pet owner is monitor | behaviour and check what goes in (food, water) and comes out | (poop, urine, vomit) as a basic indication of health. | dawnerd wrote: | And if you have a male cat it's important to also make sure | they're getting enough liquid, especially if they're on a dry | food diet. My cat almost died while I was out of town because | he stopped drinking from stress I guess and was only on a dry | diet. Now they're on a can diet and healthy. | drakonka wrote: | Very good point. My cats get wet only. The male I mentioned | in my other comment is underweight since he never regained | his full appetite after his urinary issues, so at some point | I started allowing him to snack on a bit of dry food at night | to get his weight up. A month or two later he developed | urinary problems. This ended up being caused by crystals in | his bladder, which are associated with not taking in enough | liquids. Now, I'd rather he be a little skinny than risk that | again. Water fountains help, but aren't enough. | | There is an issue of Royal Canin Veterinary Focus that | focuses on lower urinary tract disease in cats and dogs: | https://vetfocus.royalcanin.com/en/-/media/vet-focus/en- | us-p... | | There are interesting sections on Feline Idiopathic Cystitis | and blockage, which talk about water management as well. On | page 23, there is a table called "Table 1. Clinical features | of cats diagnosed with cystitis with (n = 8,220) or without | (7,862) concurrent pyuria in 2012." | | At the bottom of the table are a few rows on diet. ~3.5% of | cats in the sample were on a canned-only diet. ~19.2% were on | a mix of dry and canned food. 77.3% were on a dry-only diet | (percentages slightly varied for those with pyuria). | xivzgrev wrote: | Yep. My cat was dry only, and almost died from a blockage. | He's been wet only, and no issues, since | | When I hear other cat owners feeding only dry I tell them | this. They don't usually want to change, likely believing | that wouldnt happen to their cat, but at least they're | informed. | xivzgrev wrote: | My cat got blocked one time. It just happened one day. Came | home from work and he was meowing painfully, and kept doing it. | So I took him to ER. | | Did you notice warning signs in days prior? I typically don't | check litter every day so possible I missed subtle signs | earlier | drakonka wrote: | Sorry to hear about your cat. I hope he's OK now. | | It was really unfortunate because mine was blocked after an | otherwise routine surgery, after which the vet warned us that | it might take him longer to go to the litter box! So at first | we thought nothing of it and thought him not having peed yet | was normal post-surgery recovery. | | But I did learn to recognize the signs after that, since they | kept sending him home while he was still blocked. In general, | the potential signs of a blockage are pretty much the same as | potential signs of infection or other urinary issues. I | suggest watching/listening for the following: | | * Frequent trips to the box. If a cat keeps going in | repeatedly, something might be up. They either can't get pee | out, or have some irritation that is making them need like | they need to keep going to the box. This can start with just | going a bit more frequently than you're used to and escalate | to stepping in and out of the box every few minutes. Note | that this can also be a sign of constipation, which can also | be bad (but tends to be less critical than urinary blockage | in the beginning). Usually cats have a different stance when | they pee vs poop, so you can kind of tell what they're trying | to do if you pay attention. Sometimes, if they keep straining | to pee and can't, they might actually resort to trying to | poop instead, which won't help and just keep them coming back | to the box. | | * Low or no volume. These frequent trips, in case of | blockage, will result in no pee coming out, or maybe just | drops. This _could_ also mean that the cat simply has no pee | left in them and it is some other urinary tract irritation | causing them to feel like they keep having to go, but that is | really only safe to assume if you've _seen_ them pee a good | amount recently. Usually when they are just irritated, | they'll still get _something_ out when they go back in. If | when you get home all you find is abnormally tiny clumps or | drops, it can be a sign that something is off. | | * Vocalization. If they are vocalizing more than usual, | especially in or around the box. It can be a sign of pain | (this sounds like what you used to catch it, which is great). | | * Blood in the urine. I know it can be hard to see with many | litters, but sometimes you can spot blood either in the | urine, drops on or around the box, or even on the cat's fur | after they go. This is more a sign of bladder irritation than | blockage, but the two often go hand in hand, and one can | progress to the other, so it's time to see a vet. | | * Trying to go outside of the box. If they are in pain or | unable to pee in the box, they may resort to trying to find | another spot. If you find your cat peeing or trying to pee | outside of the box when they're otherwise litter trained, | something might be wrong. | | * Repeated licking of nether regions, especially coupled with | one or more of the above. If they are in pain or irritated, | they may keep licking and fussing with the area. | | * Eventually, not going to the box at all. The bladder gets | distended, and nerves are damaged. This is very dangerous. | The bladder is full, but the cat loses the ability to feel | when they need to pee. My vets have said that as a rule of | thumb, if a cat does not pee at least once in 24 hours, to | get to the emergency vet asap. | | There can also be cat-specific, individual signs of | irritation or pain that you'd know best as the owner. For | example, I noticed when my cat has trouble comfortably peeing | he will start drinking a lot more water. I am not sure if | this is common for all cats, but it's one thing I keep an eye | on: if he keeps going between the box and the water bowl, I | know something is up. | | In general, a lot of it is quite individual. Cats do | sometimes just change up their pee schedule. I might come | home and find that mine hasn't peed at all when he normally | would, but that doesn't mean I need to rush to the emergency | just based on that one thing. I judge by how he looks, how | he's acting, and just keep an extra eye out for any | additional signs (and pay attention for when he pees next). | | We can also learn to feel the fullness of the bladder through | the abdomen, and many cat owners (especially those dealing | with disabled cats) do. Apparently it's quite easy, and my | vet would do this pretty regularly when needed, but I | unfortunately never managed to get the hang of it myself | (though I still try sometimes if I suspect something is | wrong). | fullstop wrote: | Prior to this there were likely signs. * | Frequent litter box visits * Excessively grooming "down | there" * And finally the yowling that you heard | | Sometimes they will attempt to pee in sinks or hidden places | which are not the litter box. One of mine reacts poorly to | stress and can't eat kibble or she gets a UTI, and I've | gotten very good at identifying when something is going to be | a problem before it gets out of control. | zwilliamson wrote: | When it comes to cat health and preventative care a lot can be | gleaned from the book The Forever Dog (https://foreverdog.com). | There is a lot we can do as care takers to prevent health | issues and not just monitor for them. | | The summary of the book is "Eat less, eat fresher, and move | more and more often" | | Perhaps with cats the movement part maybe not be as applicable, | but the eating fresher (no processed foods) and eating less | would make a huge difference it a cats life. Maybe someone will | write Forever Cat? | drakonka wrote: | I think that largely makes sense, but also think the | _biggest_ jump in cat food quality isn't so much the jump to | freshness but the jump away from dry. Cats who eat primarily | dry food are at risk of chronic dehydration. They simply do | not end up drinking enough water to compensate for the low | moisture content in their food[0]. Water fountains help | entice some cats to drink more, but in the end it's usually | not enough to compensate. | | For my cats, I usually opt for variety. I try to pick high | protein wet food of different types, including nutritionally | balanced raw, within their individual requirements and | tastes. At the same time, I follow my vet's advice and always | have urinary wet food handy. Usually they get one pouch of | urinary food that helps prevent and dissolve a certain type | of bladder crystal in addition to normal wet food each day. | | [0] https://www.waltham.com/news-events/nutrition/cats-can- | benef... | praptak wrote: | OTOH it might be easier to take a urine sample from a toilet | trained cat. For litter trained cats you need to use special | non absorbent litter or leave the cat at the vet so that they | collect the sample themselves. | drakonka wrote: | That can be true, but I think you can also get the cat used | to sample collection by hand as they go into the box. | | I've had to collect so many samples over the years, and the | easiest way is to hold a measuring cup/spoon under the cat | when he/she goes into the box and squats. When I hear mine go | to the box, I just walk over slowly and chill in the area | (act casual). Then, when he looks committed and gets into | position, I squat next to the box and hold the cup under him. | You can collect a good amount of very clean urine this way | (of course not sterile like cystocentesis, but for most | purposes it is perfectly fine). It takes some practice to | find the right place to hold the spoon depending on your | cat's anatomy, as you have to estimate where the pee will end | up going. | | In another part of this thread I mentioned having a Litter | Robot, which this technique is not really possible with. I | bring out a backup open litterbox when I need to collect a | sample, for easy access. | ricardobeat wrote: | My extended family has always had a ton of cats, and I don't | remember the last one that was seriously ill without it being | due to old age. Most of them were "outdoor cats" in a small | country town. | | Is there something in modern cats' diet / habits that makes | them more susceptible to disease? These concerns read like | hypochondria, coming from this background. | trhway wrote: | >Is there something in modern cats' diet / habits that makes | them more susceptible to disease? | | The cheap supermarket dog/cat food can hardly be called a | food. It is an epitome of bottom line optimization. Grain and | the "by-products" - frequently the 1st/2nd ingredients - | which is hides/hooves/beaks/horns/etc. flooded with | industrial chemicals back at the China's giga-meat-factories | and powdered. | JohnBooty wrote: | I don't know about the indoor/outdoor thing w.r.t. UTI | incidence in particular. But for those of us not living in | small country towns, outdoor cats are not generally a viable | option so it's all about giving them the best indoor life. | | Generally speaking, indoor cats tend to live much longer. | Generally they make it well into their teens. Of course it | all depends I guess. Indoor/outdoor cats living in an ideal | rural situation probably have the happiest and healthiest | lives of all. (Although, of course, depending on local fauna | they may eat a lot of birds, so there's that cost to consider | too...) | reaperducer wrote: | Since we're trading anecdotes... | | My experience with six cats over the last 25 years is that | the outdoor cats lived much longer and got sick less than my | inside cats. | | I have no idea why, but i don't think it's diet, because | they've all eaten the same food. | 3np wrote: | Just like with humans, exercise is a major factor in | health. Outdoor cats generally get way more. | | Another factor for this observation (that I also made) | could be genetics - generally "pure-bred" (aka more likely | to suffer from disease linked to genetic factors) are more | likely to be strictly-indoors while outdoor cats are more | often "mongrels". | reaperducer wrote: | In my case, they were all mongrels, except for the | current one, who is an indoor cat. Fingers crossed! | mdpye wrote: | > they've all eaten the same food | | Heh, that's what you think... | | Ever watched one of those lighthearted documentaries where | they GPS tag and attach cameras to a whole neighbourhood's | cats? They mostly wandered around eating each other's food | :D | drakonka wrote: | I wouldn't call something hypochondria just because I | personally haven't had to deal with it. It's really great | that you've never had this issue and I hope you never have | to, but if we're going by anecdotes, there are several in | this very thread from people who have. | | Diet can be a contributing factor, yes. I mention it a bit in | this comment, with a link to a journal issue that talks about | these issues in dogs and cats, including some information on | frequency and contributing factors: | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29864189 | mancerayder wrote: | Doesn't a urinary infection cause that? | | For an indoor cat, I strongly suspect there's a problem with | canned food sometimes. When I had a cat a long while back, | every so often you'd open a can of cat food and it'd have | worms, or the cat would (after being extremely excited as you | were opening the can), sniff and propel himself away from the | food. You'd look and notice it was off (like it had something | crawling in it). | 2muchcoffeeman wrote: | Wait, cat food is not pasteurised and sealed in the tin? | aaaaaaaaaaab wrote: | Lol! Wholesome tutorial! | | Reminded me of how we tend to forget that even the most | outstanding people are just as ordinary as we are. When at home, | legendary jazz musician Charles Mingus is just an ordinary guy, | training his cat to use the toilet. | dbreunig wrote: | The tone and approach here is exactly what I'd expect from a man | whose chief complaint as a band leader is that jazz musicians | interpret his music too much and classical musicians follow it | too literally. | jelling wrote: | That's cat's balance is the key here. I tried this with a | hairless cat - whom also have very little in the way of whiskers | - and the poor thing just didn't have the balance to handle the | final steps. | saluki wrote: | Our neighbor when I was growing up had a cat that would use the | toilet and flush. I was amazed as a kid. | | Not sure I want to share the bathroom with our cats. | | We just got a litter robot last week it's pretty amazing. We set | it up in a hall closet to get the two litter boxes out of the | laundry room. It should pay for itself in 3-4 months by using | less litter than our two traditional litter boxes (yesterdays | news litter). | jakebasile wrote: | I've been looking at getting an automatic cleaning litter box | for a while now. Would you mind recommending the type that you | bought if you are so happy with it? | Zircom wrote: | Just make sure you're cats never see it turn itself on, two | of my three cats refuse to use it after watching it cycle and | I'm back to having a separate box for them that I clean | everyday, honestly thinking it selling it if I can talk | anybody into buying a used poopbox | | For the one cat though it is definitely great, he's kinda | fearless though so your cats may not quite be brave enough to | face the beast everytime they go to the bathroom. | | Edit - my name is Zircom, I have a litter robot 3 for the | record, and I recommend it as long as you don't have scaredy | cats. | drakonka wrote: | I've had a Litter Robot for nearly a year and also really | like it (wrote a more detailed review here[0]), although it's | definitely not perfect. Mine is the Litter Robot 3 with the | WiFi functionality (lets me keep an eye on how often they go | even when I'm not home). I do believe the price isn't worth | it for _most_ people, but do not regret the purchase. | | [0] https://liza.io/litter-robot-3-review/ | jakebasile wrote: | Thanks for the review. Would you say it cuts down on smell? | That is my biggest issue with cat ownership and I've been | looking for ways to further reduce it (beyond better | litter, baking soda, etc.). | | Edit: Thanks for all the replies. I am still on the fence | about it, and may try further options to reduce the smell | (at least enough so that a cat-person like myself can live | with it ;)) | jeromegv wrote: | My air purifier is next to our cat litter and there's no | smell at all. I strongly recommend one (on top of helping | with allergies, dust, covid, etc..) | SV_BubbleTime wrote: | I wonder if you mean "no smell to a cat person" or if you | mean no smell to everyone else. Because I've been in | enough cat people's places to know the former is a real | thing. | natdempk wrote: | I've done the air purifier thing as well, paired with | some unscented litter like Dr. Elsey's Ultra Litter and | it genuinely doesn't smell most of the time, unless | they've recently used the box or its not cycling due to | being full. | drakonka wrote: | Would you mind sharing what air purifier model you use | next to your Litter Robot? | natdempk wrote: | Sure, I use a Coway Airmega AP-1512HH set to low | permanently. It doesn't move a ton of air on the low | setting, but it is very quiet and the size fits pretty | well next to the robot. I think getting something quiet | is key as to not spook your cats, as one of mine hates | the sound of loud white-noise-ish sounds. | | I will say I think this one works well, but you could | likely find something cheaper because you don't need to | much air circulation for a litter box. I just happened to | already have this one. | drakonka wrote: | Thanks. I have read good things about that model, but | don't think it's available in my country. But I was | looking into a Coway Storm AP-1516D last year, and didn't | end up pulling the trigger since there were just too many | options to choose from. This reminds me to look into them | again. | Nursie wrote: | We use a system called ezi lockodour here in Australia. I | believe the US name is Purina TidyCats. | | Made a huge difference to the smell when we switched. | dotBen wrote: | Another Litter Robot owner here (we are onto our second | one) and I feel it does cut down on the smell. | | The litter won't stay in the open part for more than | 10-25 minutes and then it is cycled into the drawer which | is relatively contained and has a charcoal filter on it. | | We have two cats and end up changing the drawer every 2-3 | days. I have a friend who manages not to change the | drawer for a week and I do think it starts to smell then. | | The main benefits are that we don't have to tend to the | litter tray that often and when we do we only need to | pull out the plastic trash bag, tie it up and replace | with a new one. I also think it uses a lot less litter as | we never have to fully change it out like you do with | normal cat boxes. | | It's an expensive item but I think it's definitely worth | it. Get a reconditioned one for $50-100 less as they are | perfectly clean and they will get messy pretty quickly | anyway. | | We pair ours with Nature's Miracle cat litter which has | baking soda and other deodorizer in it. | mey wrote: | It does not cut down more on the smell. Since the waste | is basically sifted out quickly to the lower try and not | left buried by the cat, it can get smelly. Litter type, | cat, and how often you chant the lower tray will change | that, but overall, I would not put it in a living space. | drakonka wrote: | I wouldn't say it cuts down on smell, unfortunately. In | fact, it has the potential to make it worse, since the | waste is gathered in a bin for longer periods of time (as | opposed to flushable litter in a normal box). | | There is a carbon filter that sits on one end of the tray | to help minimize scent, but it's not very effective in my | experience. I'm currently experimenting with putting | various nicely-scented objects in that tray, in front of | the filter (like those little scent blocks you can hang | on the side of your toilet bowl, for example). | | The scent will also largely depend on the cat's digestive | system. My cats tend to not have very smelly or soft | feces so it's not bad at all, but if one of them gets | diarrhea you bet I'm emptying that litter bin right away. | Likewise, if a guest is coming over I'd probably suggest | emptying the litter bin beforehand just in case. | | I know you already know of better litter and baking soda | tricks, but there is a powder you can purchase and | sprinkle into litter, which gives off a fresh scent. I | found using it also helps, as does sprinkling some of it | into the bottom of the litter tray itself (into the | litter waste bin). I don't have the name of it on hand, | but I think there are a few brands out there that are | pretty common. | | Edit: the _majority_ of the time there is no smell I can | easily detect until I open the tray to remove the | garbage. But as someone else mentioned, no smell to a cat | person may not be a reliable gauge. | natdempk wrote: | One thing I've done to help with the smell is put a | smaller air purifier on low next to it running | continuously. This really helps a lot in my experience | compared to having nothing. It can still smell a bit if | the robot is full and nothing is cycling or one of the | cats has just used it, but other than that there is | largely no smell. The other thing that helps a lot is | changing the carbon filter on the robot on a regular | basis, maybe every couple or few months, since once that | goes a lot more smell leaks out. | garblegarble wrote: | I'm not the person you're asking but we use the same brand, | the Litter Robot 3 (without wifi) and think it's great. Both | our cats took to it very quickly. | | It does require a small amount of maintenance to keep it | running smoothly. Separating and cleaning the main pieces | every 2-3 months is all I do (nothing that requires tools to | disassemble, but a good 15 minutes of cleaning+vacuuming) | | Our cats were always very stinky with traditional litter | boxes (even on different diets) and the litter robot did cut | that down significantly... but what made a huge difference | was using a litter that was a combination of clay, activated | carbon and silica granules (we use Biokat's Diamond Care | Classic - it is expensive, previously I manually mixed in | carbon+silica into cheaper clay litter with moderate | success). | | We only have one cat now, and only need to replace the bag | once every 10 days, but even so I can't detect any cat smell | in the house (and am quite sensitive to it) nor can any of my | friends/family -- but they all have cats so there may well | still be some base level of smell that all our noses are | innured to. | | To a sibling commentor's warning, neither of our cats are | worried about it cycling (in fact, our sphynx races over to | watch it cycle any time she hears the motor start up). It has | a weight sensor as well as a pinch sensor to prevent the cat | being injured in case they jump in while it's running -- so | far nobody's tried to, but good to know it's there. | | I found it quite good for our older cat, too: one of our cats | had a bit of arthritis in later life and needed the set of | steps to comfortably get up and into the litter box which | does increase the already pretty significant footprint of the | device. It also has an automatic low light that comes on when | it gets dark that helped her get around when her eyesight was | failing. | | A sibling comment noted that it's pretty expensive and may | not be worth the cost - I think that's probably true, | although I've no regrets (and even bought a second one) | because of the amount of scooping it's saved me. | JohnBooty wrote: | Our cats were always very stinky with traditional litter | boxes | | As a compromise solution I've had pretty good luck placing | air filters next to the litter box. The commonly | recommended ones (Coway, Winix) are $100-$150 on sale and | have both particulate filters and charcoal odor filters. | Filter costs are ~$25/year and electricity cost is ~$5-10 | per month. | | That's probably more expensive over a large enough number | of years relative to a robo litter box, but you're also | removing other indoor allergy causes as well, so it's doing | other work which may be beneficial. | | Also the fan noise from the filters is very gentle; | actually a plus for many. | mey wrote: | I have a litter robot. Takes normal kitchen trash bags and is | able to keep up with two adult male cats. Very happy with it, | had it for over two years. I think the cats would mutiny if | they went back to a normal box. | | It does take a little learning. You have to learn how to not | overfill it. How to do a full break down clean of it (not | hard just more involved). It doesn't keep the smell down | significantly more than a traditional litter box imo. | | Pretty sure ours paid for itself in litter savings in about a | year. | xattt wrote: | Who does the flushing? | analog31 wrote: | I've heard that if the cat learns to flush, it will flush your | toilet all day because it's fun. | swader999 wrote: | Kids do this and cats are smarter. | Nextgrid wrote: | You could technically automate it. Training the cat is the hard | part. Detecting that a cat (or frankly, anything else) is on | the toilet is easy with some electronics. | ratww wrote: | Some cats learn to flush, which is absolutely nuts, but it | happens. | donkarma wrote: | apparently the cat can learn to flush if the cat hits it by | accident | swader999 wrote: | My cat learned how to turn on the tap nearly wrecking the | well. Now he's an outdoor cat. Seems happier too. | Pixelbrick wrote: | http://achewood.com/index.php?date=06232003 | k__ wrote: | I'm so happy my cat goes outside to do her business. | | My last cat used a litter box and when she got old and demented, | she would sometimes sleep in the box, so I had to clean her | regularly. | JohnBooty wrote: | Poor baby! Thank you for taking such good care of her into her | old age. | k__ wrote: | Yes, her last year was heartb breaking. But at least she had | a few good days every week until the end. | | Seeing that she was able to steal some food from a table when | I was out of a room when she was already blind and deaf | warmed my heart. | | 20 years I had her, good times. | sesellis wrote: | There are commercially available kits to do this that are | concentric rings that work very well. The kit coupled with | flushable litter makes it very easy to toilet train a cat. | | However, I can confirm you will get into a bathroom stare down | with your cat every once in a while. | ratww wrote: | You have to teach the cat to close the door. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-01-09 23:00 UTC)