[HN Gopher] GNU Radio ___________________________________________________________________ GNU Radio Author : tosh Score : 246 points Date : 2022-01-15 09:50 UTC (13 hours ago) (HTM) web link (github.com) (TXT) w3m dump (github.com) | idealmedtech wrote: | Our satellite team in college used GNURadio to modulate and | demodulate our radio signals, and to automate the entire pass (in | conjunction with our mission operations team). I remember at that | time (2016-2018), there was an absolute dearth of information on | something as simple as demodulating GMSK, much less OQPSK. The | given blocks for these modulation types never worked, so we had | to build out custom blocks in C++ to have a chance at interacting | with an actual spacecraft in flight (with all the goodies like | active Doppler compensation etc) | CapricornNoble wrote: | I did my masters thesis with GNURadio 2013-2016 (a frequency- | hopping implementation). I often thought my struggles were 100% | my own incompetence, but eventually realized it was possibly | 50% buggy GNURadio blocks. So much potential in SDRs but damn | was this software an opaque mess to use. | idealmedtech wrote: | There was a time where I could point to specific | implementations in GNURadios source that were very buggy | (lots of uninitialized memory assumed to be zeroed), but | alas, it's been lost from my memory. | teleforce wrote: | This is an excellent book on learning DSP for modern wireless | communications and it should get you over the fundamentals [1]. | | There is an interesting project for open source LoRa physical | layer implementation in GNU Radio. The authors had to reverse | engineer the LoRa physical layer for the implementation because | it is proprietary unlike the data link layer LoRaWAN part of it | [2]. | | [1]Digital Signal Processing in Modern Communication Systems: | | https://www.amazon.com/Digital-Signal-Processing-Communicati... | | [2]LoRa PHY based on GNU Radio: | | https://www.epfl.ch/labs/tcl/resources-and-sw/lora-phy/ | punnerud wrote: | Could GNU Radio work as a Python alternative to NodeRED? | (Node.js/JavaScript) | nereye wrote: | A more generic equivalent seems to be PyFlow: | https://wonderworks-software.github.io/PyFlow/. | | GNU Radio is targeted to a specific domain and the collection | of existing nodes reflects that, similar tools exist for other | domains, e.g. for CAD there is Sverchok which works with | Blender: https://nortikin.github.io/sverchok/. | [deleted] | vkoskiv wrote: | This reminds me of a fun story. A few years ago at a cool lan + | demoparty event called Instanssi they had a local FM radio | station dedicated to the event. It was then revealed that hidden | in that FM transmission was the private key to a litecoin wallet | containing some coin. I set about to try and extract the hidden | message, but didn't succeed before someone else armed with GNU | radio had already decoded the SSTV image from the sideband | broadcast. It was a fun challenge, and the person who won taught | me a bit about GNU Radio. An amazing piece of software, and a fun | memory! | mikewarot wrote: | Have they fixed the incredible loss of features from the WX GUI | yet, the QT widgets just didn't have anywhere near the same | functionality last time I looked? | | [Edit]The WX versions of FFT and Oscilloscopes were far, FAR | better than their QT replacements. | minimilian wrote: | You're probably talking about something else, but it took me a | while to realize that many features are hidden behind a right | (or is it middle) click. | beaugunderson wrote: | This is a big deal when running on e.g. a MacBook that has no | middle click--it is very worthwhile to use software that | emulates a middle click when a modifier key is held down to | gain back this functionality. | mikewarot wrote: | If you want to learn DSP, GNU Radio is the way to go. It has | audio sources and sinks, so you can try out things and hear / see | (using the scope sink) the results in real time. | | It was really interesting to play with negative frequencies and | get a better handle on it than the math alone would have ever | given me. | pajko wrote: | Usually there's little documentation about SDR, but Analog | Devices has "recently" released a book, which is available for | free: https://www.analog.com/en/education/education- | library/softwa... | | Also can be bought, but has a quite hefty price tag: | https://www.amazon.com/Software-Defined-Radio-Engineers-Trav... | | Other good resources are the books and courses on WirelessPi: | https://wirelesspi.com/book/ | doom2 wrote: | Does GNU Radio have any utility for amateur radio operators? For | example, tx/rx of FT8 or PSK31 (or any other digital modes)? | BenjiWiebe wrote: | Yes, but why not use the existing software? Building flowgraphs | in GNU Radio is not simple. | sh4un wrote: | Weird. Was looking at this program yesterday and the website was | all over the place. | dang wrote: | Some past threads: | | _FM Reception with the GNU Radio Companion_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25976599 - Jan 2021 (18 | comments) | | _GNU Radio 3.9_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25823359 | - Jan 2021 (53 comments) | | _Software Defined Radios with GNU Radio Companion_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24208497 - Aug 2020 (1 | comment) | | _Decoding radio telemetry heard on news helicopter video footage | with GNU Radio_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23417891 - | June 2020 (36 comments) | | _An Implementation of Tempest in GNU Radio_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23151880 - May 2020 (35 | comments) | | _GNU Radio first steps: a FM receiver_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21613988 - Nov 2019 (38 | comments) | | _GNU Radio 3.8_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20681316 | - Aug 2019 (67 comments) | | _Shinysdr - Software-defined radio receiver application built on | GNU Radio_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14170516 - | April 2017 (19 comments) | | _A Peek at GNU Radio's Buffer Architecture_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13406505 - Jan 2017 (15 | comments) | | _Digital Video Transmission using LimeSDR and GNU Radio_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11856912 - June 2016 (8 | comments) | | _Public safety radio systems decoding with GNU-radio OP25 | project_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11696507 - May | 2016 (1 comment) | | _GNU Radio Tools for Radio Wrangling and Spectrum Domination | [video]_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10843175 - Jan | 2016 (22 comments) | | _Taking control of a 36 year old NASA spacecraft using GNU | radio_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9476853 - May 2015 | (7 comments) | | _Taking the Raspberry Pi 2 for a Test Drive with GNU Radio_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9420427 - April 2015 (46 | comments) | | _How to talk to a 36-year-old space probe with GNU Radio, a USRP | and a big dish_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8028773 - | July 2014 (18 comments) | | _Exciting developments in GNU Radio_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2279758 - March 2011 (2 | comments) | | _GNU Radio - create your own software-defined radio device_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=622035 - May 2009 (6 | comments) | cebert wrote: | SDR and GNU radio has always sounded interesting to me ever since | I heard it mentioned on the Security Now podcast years ago. Does | anyone know of good resources on how to get started? This is | something I'd love to tinker with one day. I also don't know a | great deal about RF communication in general. | ericbarrett wrote: | I looked into this last year, and the process seems to be "get | at least half an undergrad degree in signal processing and then | read the code." GNU Radio is _really_ powerful, but most of the | tutorials out there are "rest of the fucking owl" style[0]. | Which I then realized makes sense, given the complexity of the | domain. So be aware it's a deep subject and you won't be | decoding new satellites in a few clicks unless you're copying | somebody else's homework. | | [0] https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/how-to-draw-an-owl | wavewalkerdsp wrote: | I've put together new introductory tutorials here: | https://wiki.gnuradio.org/index.php/NewTutorialReview | | Using a virtual machine with Ubuntu 21.04 and installing using | the PPA is a good way to test it out: | https://wiki.gnuradio.org/index.php/InstallingGR#Ubuntu_PPA_... | | More background information on the tutorials, future plans, | etc. https://www.wavewalkerdsp.com/2022/01/13/gnu-radio- | tutorials... | weberer wrote: | This wiki page is pretty good for getting started. | | https://wiki.installgentoo.com/wiki/Software-defined_radio | pajko wrote: | Buy a dongle and antenna from here: https://www.rtl- | sdr.com/buy-rtl-sdr-dvb-t-dongles/ | | Install GNURadio, start playing with gqrx and FM reception. | | Buy a cheap radio controlled thingy, install SDR# with the | plugins package and RTL_433 plugin for it and start playing. | ngcc_hk wrote: | Got some fortran (0.3%) there? | oolonthegreat wrote: | I especially appreciate the "Simulink-like" block based visual | coding style, I think it's a more intuitive alternative than | textual coding in the context of systems and blocks etc. | | also love the convenience of simply "adding a slider" whereas in | matlab for example you have to build an "app" and add callback | functions and do weird stuff to change the block parameters | RF_Savage wrote: | I just wish GNU Radio did not brake compability between versions. | | 3.6 --> 3.7 --> 3.8 all ware breaking. | | So no older example or block you find will work in the current | version. This is infuriating when trying to learn and following | tutorials. All my friends seem to have migrated to building their | prototypes in C using something like liquid-dsp instead of | gnuradio. As that will compile and work next year. | superkuh wrote: | It is frustrating. What I do is keep computers from a given | time era in their natural state of software. So now I have a | physical computer for running GR 3.6 stuff, one for 3.7 stuff, | and soon I'll have one for 3.8 stuff. Trying to constantly | upgrade and getting rid of old installs is counterproductive. | | This applies in general to _all_ software. It 's really nice to | have old OSes use applications that can't run on newer distros. | ggm wrote: | Has always done a terrible job of selling itself. A $25 dtv | receiver and a chickenwire antenna parabola and code your own | satellite TV decoder, learn what radar guns emit, emulate a | modem... maybe even shift to IR and do TV controls.. it's, latent | in this stuff. | | But the frontpage doesn't take you there. | galangalalgol wrote: | that $25 dtv receiver only goes up to 2ghz so you can't get | satellite tv without building a downconverter which isn't | trivial or as cheap. Radar guns are even higher in frequency. | It can only receive so you can emulate only the demodulation | part of a modem. IR sounds like fun though. You could listen to | tire pressure monitors too. | TheDesolate0 wrote: | n00p wrote: | an LNB (the thing that goes in the focus of a parabolic | antena) is really cheap and easy to power | | the probem would be that the cheap dtv (RTL-SDR) only gets up | to 2.4MHz of spectrum bandwith, a typical DVB-S mux can be | around 20MHz or the DVB-T terrestrial standard, 8MHz | wdfx wrote: | How can the DVB-T signal bandwidth be larger than what the | 'dtv' receiver is capable of if that device was actually | originally designed to receive exactly that class of | signal? | mimanning wrote: | The 2.8 MHz limitation comes from shipping raw RF samples | off the device over USB 2. When operating as a DVB-T | receiver the device decodes the signals before sending | them over USB so it uses less bandwidth. | | The device was originally intended only as a dtv receiver | and not a general purpose software defined radio. The | hobbyist/ hacker community discovered the hidden debug | mode that allows raw data acquisition and wrote drivers | for it. | galangalalgol wrote: | The LNBs on ebay are pretty cheap but the intermediate | frequency some of them use use is a bit too high. And as | you say. You'd just be finding some slice of the signal | without any hope of demodulation. I still think a | microphone or rtl are a great way to play with gnuradio | companion. Lime sdr is probably the next step up in price. | superkuh wrote: | Sure. That's because GNU Radio is for making the | applications/flowgraphs. It is not an application you "use". It | is an application for making applications. Give a newbie even | the friendly GUI gnuradio-companion and they're not going to be | able to do much without some serious time learning or existing | DSP background. | BenjiWiebe wrote: | Right. There isn't any way of making it easy or beginner | friendly, because DSP and RF aren't simple topics. | ganzuul wrote: | For a little more investment you can get hacked version with a | TCXO and it is able to receive almost 0 to IIRC 28MHz. It is a | 2.8MHz spectrum analyzer although energy readings are not a | feature. | | However cities are terribly noisy environments so loop antennas | should work better for most people. Most amateur radio guides | assume you are at least a homeowner but that is not realistic | among people interested in a 20 eurodollar receiver. | wdfx wrote: | For about the same cost you can buy an sdrplay rsp clone | which can receive from 0-2GHz with 10MHz bandwidth. | brightball wrote: | I am always shocked that radio isn't core science curriculum in | high school at this point. | yeetaccount4 wrote: | Have you driven around town at noon? That's when kids were | getting out of school pre-pandemic. I just read this morning | Kansas is so desperate for substitute teachers that they'll | take on teenagers without a single college credit. The public | school system in many parts of the country is basically state | funded daycare. | spacecadet wrote: | 100% | aatharuv wrote: | Any chance this is at least partially deliberate? If more | people were to use GNU Radio, the manufacturers of said | hardware would get sued until they were forced to lock down | their hardware. | syedkarim wrote: | Do you mean manufacturers of RTLSDR devices? Those don't need | to be locked down (in the US), as they are receive-only | devices. | szopa wrote: | What are some good resources to start playing with SD add an | amateur? | nereye wrote: | https://pysdr.org/ is a good introduction to DSP/SDR using | Python. | | Previous discussion on HN: | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24750588. | | Ham Radio Workbench podcast on GNU Radio: | https://www.hamradioworkbench.com/podcast/GNU-Radio. | | In terms of hardware, there is a large spectrum, from | inexpensive RTL-SDR (receive only, ~$25), PlutoSDR (transmit | and receive, $229, which PySDR covers) all the way to $x000+ | for USRP etc. | octagons wrote: | Check out the Field Expedient SDR series. They offer a decent | introduction for beginners. | masto wrote: | I'm reasonably good at computers, and I even have a small | understanding of electronics and radio, but I bought a HackRF | One about 6 years ago, and every time I try to use this stuff I | get hopelessly lost. Most of the time I can't even get the | software running, or figure out which software I need to get | running, and when I do I'm hopelessly lost. The only thing I | ever managed was to listen to an FM radio station with a | program that simplified the interface down to a frequency | slider. | | I would love to do things like investigate how my water meter | broadcasts its readings, but "latent" doesn't even begin to | cover how inaccessible this stuff is. There are "tutorials", | but they just say "Stick these parts together. There, now you | have stuck these parts together!" (https://wiki.gnuradio.org/in | dex.php/Simulation_example:_Narr...) | | I know, open source, I should learn everything and then write | better documentation. | MrQuincle wrote: | I reverse engineered a so called social alarm a bit ago. You | can find it here: https://github.com/mrquincle/social_alarm | | Gnuradio was also new to me. However with two HackRFs I could | do the entire thing. First replay attacks. Then trying to get | the code by building up a set of processing blocks. Last | synthesis of the complete signal. | | Very nice to do! Felt great! | jancsika wrote: | You should consider this a real treat-- it's like you're | getting to travel back to the 90s open source scene _for | free_. | | -Tom Sawyer | geenew wrote: | Is it possible to use a laptop's built-in wifi antenna / wifi | card as the hardware side of a gnu radio setup? | | That seems like it would be a nice cheap one-two punch for | getting started. AFAIR wifi uses the public (unregulated) bands | so there should be lots of interesting stuff on those | frequencies beyond wifi signals. | jcrawfordor wrote: | WiFi adapters don't really expose this type of interface. | WiFi adapters interact with the host computer by sending and | receiving packets, the 802.11 framing and radio de/modulation | is performed internally by the adapter. In other words, the | host computer sees IP packets, not radio data. Some adapters | (or really most adapters) provide some ability for the host | to send and receive raw 802.11 frames but it's an | infrequently used feature and tends to have a lot of caveats | and limitations... you'll see a lot of discussion of this if | you read into security/exploitation use-cases for WiFi that | involve monitoring or generating 802.11 management traffic. | | This is somewhat related to the old difference between a | "modem" and a "winmodem": proper telephone modems performed | the de/modulation internally, winmodems did not and relied on | the host processor to do so, resulting in generally lower | performance but a much cheaper device. At modern network data | rates it is not really feasible to do this and the general | direction is towards offloading more and more of the work to | the network adapter, outside of the host's control or view. | | For gnuradio you need raw radio samples, often referred to as | IQ data due to the nomenclature for amplitude and phase. Few | devices that aren't specifically designed for software- | defined radio use expose this data because it requires extra | complexity in the device and tends to be rather high- | bandwidth. The "RTL SDR" TV tuner dongles are so well known | precisely because they contain an undocumented feature that | allows a host to request raw IQ data, although at a poor | sample rate and bandwidth since these devices were not really | intended for it. | lsllc wrote: | You can use a paperclip or a piece of wire if you have access | to a GPIO port: | | https://www.rtl-sdr.com/receiving-ads-b-jetliner-traffic- | wit... | | https://www.theverge.com/2019/11/26/20981630/raspberry-pi- | pi... | noasaservice wrote: | > Is it possible to use a laptop's built-in wifi antenna / | wifi card as the hardware side of a gnu radio setup? | | No. There's a LOT of stuff the wifi chip does to convert EM | to data, including despreading and other computationally | expensive operations. | | Using an expensive SDR, you can follow this paper from 2013 | to see the block diagram of what decoding wifi looks like: | | https://conferences.sigcomm.org/sigcomm/2013/papers/srif/p9.. | .. | RF_Savage wrote: | Due to it being a radio licenced by rule, the firmware in | wifi devices is locked down tight. If it ware wide open FCC | would revoke it's type acceptance. | | The only project that so far has managed to even partially | use wifi hardware as a more generic SDR is nexmon[1] and even | that is rather involved. Really cool project but not much | heard since 2018. | | For just experimenting with modems across a noisy path one | could just use the built in microphone and speakers. | | 1. https://github.com/seemoo- | lab/mobisys2018_nexmon_software_de... | throway453sde wrote: | If i run linux can i modify the firmware? Also the | regulations differ from country to country so this should | be legal in some of the country. | Shared404 wrote: | Firmware is typically loaded directly onto the hardware, | so you would have to have a way to flash your custom | firmware to the wifi antenna/card. | | In the US and other countries, it is to the best of my | knowledge legal to modify firmware for hardware you own. | The illegal part is broadcasting, most bandwidths are | highly regulated. Listening on the other hand is mostly | legal, or at the very least extremely likely to fly under | the radar. | RF_Savage wrote: | You will not be able to modify the firmware blob just by | running linux. | | Few years back there was danger of FCC de facto banning | alternative router firmwares like openwrt to prevent | tampering with the wifi cards firmware. | | This was the "only manufacturer signed firmware allowed" | thing that thankfully was avoided. | | FCC's motivation in this is to prevent people from using | too much power or certain frequencies. | | And as most manufacturers want to be able to sell in USA, | it would have likely affected all versions. Kainda like | how many wifi devices sold in Europe only go up to | channel 11 on 2.4GHz, when the EU band goes up to channel | 13. But ch12 and ch13 are not legal in usa, so they are | blocked. | colechristensen wrote: | It has been done because wifi/bluetooth chipsets are mostly | software defined radios but the software is in proprietary | pretty well locked down firmware environments. The hardware | of the radios will also usually be specified for very | specific bands and will have less general purpose uses. | | Also note that it's easy to break FCC regulations and | generally be disruptive if you mess around with this stuff | and don't know what you're doing, and the FCC happily hands | out five digit fines. | | https://github.com/seemoo- | lab/mobisys2018_nexmon_software_de... | erikbye wrote: | Not the github frontpage, no. But the actual homepage points | you here: | https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLbBQHMnVMR41zZUZGF0bJ... | wildzzz wrote: | There's a similar SDR toolkit out there called RedHawk. Its open | source but heavily funded by the NSA so you can imagine that it | has specific SIGINT applications in mind. However, you can still | connect it to an RTL-SDR and play around with the components in a | similar manner. | | https://github.com/RedhawkSDR/redhawk | spacecadet wrote: | I love gnuradio, been messing around with it on raspberry pi for | some time. Making antennas from scrap is particularly fun. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-01-15 23:00 UTC)