[HN Gopher] The harrowing journey to Elephant Island by Ernest S... ___________________________________________________________________ The harrowing journey to Elephant Island by Ernest Shackleton and Endurance crew Author : CapitalistCartr Score : 46 points Date : 2022-01-19 12:48 UTC (1 days ago) (HTM) web link (www.atlasobscura.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.atlasobscura.com) | dhbradshaw wrote: | One of my favorite quotes is by Amundsen, who led the group that | first reached the South pole: | | "Adventure is just bad planning." | jfk13 wrote: | While it's a cute saying, it's not entirely fair. Luck also | plays a large role. | | The Antarctic could perfectly well have killed Amundsen, too, | just like it killed Scott. It's true his journey was better | planned and prepared, but that didn't mean his success -- or | indeed survival -- was guaranteed. | Dowwie wrote: | Scott brought machines and ponies to Antarctica. He brought | an additional crew member without having sufficient resources | for him. He also had the men sled-haul supplies. Amundsen | brought dogs and just enough crew. The dogs pulled the sleds | and the crew ate the dogs as they went along, and as | according to plan. Amundsen earned his victory. | hcrisp wrote: | "For scientific discovery give me Scott; for speed and | efficiency of travel give me Amundsen; but when disaster | strikes and all hope is gone, get down on your knees and pray | for Shackleton." - Antarctic explorer, Sir Raymond Priestly | sec400 wrote: | If you like history and stories like this you'll probably also | enjoy "Madhouse at the End of the Earth: The Belgica's Journey | into the Dark Antarctic Night" | (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/54900051-madhouse-at-the...) | | A 1897 expedition that ends up wintering (stuck floating in the | ice) in a time just before radio communication. | hcrisp wrote: | I just finished reading "Endurance", Alfred Lansing's classic | account of Shackleton's doomed quest. Harrowing is exactly the | word to describe it. And even more harrowing than the trip to | Elephant Island was the 800-mile voyage Shackleton took with five | other crewmen from Elephant Island back to civilization in South | Georgia. To navigate it he had to cross the dreaded Drake Passage | (the latitudes between Antarctica and South America where winds | swirl unimpeded by large landmasses) in an open lifeboat relying | only on a compass and occasional stars in life threatening | weather. Upon arriving in South Georgia they ditched on the | uninhabited South shore and had to cross mountains by foot to | reach the whaling station. All survived. | Someone wrote: | And then, Shackleton not only organized the rescue party for | the three crewmen he had left behind on the other side of the | island, but also organized and led all four attempts to rescue | the crew left on Elephant Island. | | And no, he didn't take time to recover from the journey to | South Georgia before doing that. | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_Trans- | Antarctic_Exped...: _"He first left South Georgia a mere three | days after he had arrived in Stromness"_ | | 3 days to organize a ship, a crew and supplies. | | And of course, once back in England, he and most of his crew | volunteered to serve in World War One. He was denied that, but | several of his crew died in that war. They already had offered | to do that when, IIRC in Buenos Aires they heard war had broken | out, but had been told by the king to continue the expedition. | ftkftk wrote: | Excellent book - came here to recommend it as well. | gwintrob wrote: | Ditto. One of my favorite books ever. Shackleton was a master | at maintaining a positive mental attitude. | aborsy wrote: | The drake passage open boat voyage is considered a great | achievement to this date. I recommend reading it. | | Shackleton died some 7 years later in a subsequent expedition. | anjbe wrote: | The journey of Shackleton and his crew is one of the most | exciting stories of survival and leadership I've ever | encountered. Shackleton himself wrote an autobiographical | account, and its copyright has expired, so it's now in the public | domain: | | https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/ernest-shackleton/south | | https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/ernest-shackleton/south/te... | spaetzleesser wrote: | "survival and leadership " | | And loads of luck. There were so many occasions where if | something had gone only slightly wrong they would all have | died. But you have to admire their persistence to never give | up. Not giving up is all you can do. | [deleted] | cconcepts wrote: | The Book "South" which is something like an edited version of | Shackelton's diary, has this journey in reasonable detail. It had | a profound impact on me; that people could be that tough and | resilient against massive odds. I think about it often when I am | feeling stressed - how would someone like Shackelton handle this | so the fear didn't impair their judgement. | gherkinnn wrote: | The ordeal he and his men went through is truly outlandish. | | A memorable element was the mens' reaction to WW1. Them asking | "who won?" felt awfully like one would ask about a football | game. | | But I found Ernest endlessly describing every depth measurement | and the stomach contents of every penguin they killed hard to | get through. | grumblepeet wrote: | My partner's great uncle Perce was on that expedition, he was a | stowaway and eventually became carpenter and cook. He adopted the | ships cat who was called 'Mrs Chippy' because it followed him | everywhere (chippy being slang for carpenter). Lost most of his | toes to frostbite but survived to make it back to Britain. His | first cousin was still alive until a few years ago and she | recounted him saying that he would never leave Newport again. | d_silin wrote: | "Wooden ships and iron men". What an adventure! | | Great that there is another age of exploration coming up - the | interplanetary one. | [deleted] | SOMA_BOFH wrote: | "Shackleton's Boat Journey" by F. A. Worsley is a first hand | account of the journey, written by the Captain of the Endurance. | | No fluff in this book, it gets directly to the action. Worsley | has a very direct writing style which is easy to read. | Dowwie wrote: | seems to go by another title, "Endurance: an epic of polar | adventure" | anjbe wrote: | I concur, Worsley's account of the voyage is excellent and | highly worth reading. | jfk13 wrote: | Most definitely agreed; I read it many years ago as a | youngster, and have never forgotten it. | | For a different telling of the expedition more generally, | _Mrs Chippy 's Last Expedition_ is worth a look: | | https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/128731.Mrs_Chippy_s_Last. | .. | evan_ wrote: | Immortalized in song by Beastie Boys: Like Ernest | Shackleton said to Orde-Lees: "I'll have dog pemmican with | my tea" | | https://genius.com/1510527 | ajwingert wrote: | Does anyone else only know about Ernest Shackleton from Atypical? ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-01-20 23:01 UTC)