[HN Gopher] The Great Unconformity: Research points to glaciers ... ___________________________________________________________________ The Great Unconformity: Research points to glaciers being the culprit Author : cbkeller Score : 38 points Date : 2022-01-30 19:52 UTC (3 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.vice.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.vice.com) | ruined wrote: | it's notable that the missing time period is longer than the | entire time period since, including basically all of known | evolution. immediately prior to the discontinuity, there is only | very simple life, and immediately after, life is significantly | more complex, but also highly constrained, as after a mass | extinction. | | i just like to think about this sometimes. it brings me a deep | sense of peace | codesnik wrote: | peace? why? | cbkeller wrote: | Geologist here -- happy to answer any questions about this! The | underlying paper [1] and the older one it builds on [2] are both | open access. The rj-MCMC for the time-temperature inversion used | an existing program from the thermochron community, but we made | most of the figures in Julia. | | [1] https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2118682119 | | [2] https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1804350116 | mynegation wrote: | Thank you! So I get it that glaciers eroded miles of rock from | the surface. But where is all that material? Was it moved to | the mounds elsewhere? (where?). Was it ground into gravel, dust | or silt and washed into the ocean? | cbkeller wrote: | Ground up and washed into the ocean -- and then ultimately | subducted and made into new magmas! | throwawaylinux wrote: | Noob question but are these layers in general built up from | sediments eroded mostly from higher ground, volcanic activity, | or both (or something else)? | | In any case, if glaciers rapidly eroded kilometers of rock on a | continent-wide or global scale, could evidence in similar | layers be found for all that sediment when it is deposited by | the glaciers? And if so, might that look different expected by | the other theory (tectonic activity)? | cbkeller wrote: | Ah yes, quite right on the first part! The catch is that to | be preserved, those sediments have to be deposited somewhere | else on the continental crust, say in epicratonic seas [1] or | in subsiding basins [2]. If the sediments wash all the way | off the continental shelf and onto the ocean crust, then | they'll ultimately get subducted into the mantle! | | The catch with glaciers is that putting a lot of big glacial | ice sheets onto the continents takes that water out of the | oceans, and lowers sea level -- meaning a bunch of places | where you could normally preserve sediments on the continents | will be above sea level during the glaciations (AKA above | "base level"), and more of those sediments will be washed off | the continents entirely. There still some places where you | can find the fossilized glacial till from these Cryogenian | glaciations (which is in part how we know they happened), but | it's basically only in the tectonic basins at the margins of | the continent that were subsiding fast enough to stay below | base level and not get eroded away. | | [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inland_sea_(geology) | | [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedimentary_basin | vrdabomb5717 wrote: | I'm curious if we see other unconformities related to other Ice | Ages. If receding glaciers scraped away the earth and led to | this big of a gap, shouldn't this have happened again when the | glaciers receded after more recent ice ages, like in the | Pleistocene? | cbkeller wrote: | Great question -- and yes! | | Pleistocene glaciation in the northern hemisphere has been a | lot shorter (so far) than the Cryogenian glaciations, but it | is probably not a coincidence that the outline of Canada's | "Precambrian shield" basically matches the outline of the | Laurentide ice sheet (check out Figure 5 of the 2019 paper | [1]). We're probably only talking about scraping off no more | than a couple hundred meters of sedimentary rock formerly | covering the shield, but that's about what you'd expect. | | More broadly, as one author noted long before us [2] it turns | out that most of the places on Earth where there is a lot of | Precambrian crystalline basement exposed at the surface today | (i.e., where later sedimentary rocks have been scraped off, | one way or another) were glaciated either recently or in the | Late Paleozoic Ice Age [3], which hit much of Gondwana (see | also Fig S16 here [4]). | | More recently, another group of researchers using | thermochronology in Antarctica [5] found evidence of several | kilometers of exhumation during the Late Paleozoic Ice Age, | as well as perhaps 1-2 km during the last ~35 Myr of Cenozoic | glaciation (n.b., Antarctica has been glaciated for a good | bit longer than we've been having ice ages in the northern | hemisphere). | | [1] https://www.pnas.org/content/116/4/1136/tab-figures-data | and see also Fig S16 in [4] | | [2] https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/article/ | 83/... | | [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Paleozoic_icehouse | | [4] https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/suppl/2018/12/26/180435 | 011... | | [5] https://doi.org/10.1016/j.epsl.2018.10.044 (see | especially Fig. 7) | h2odragon wrote: | Alternate theory: Earth was assembled by some subcontractor who | skimped on construction costs where they thought no one would | notice. | | This accounts for the absence of slood. | 74B5 wrote: | Let us thank the free market for his miraculous creation, amen. | neffy wrote: | But Slartibartfast designed every single one of those Glacial | Fjords personally! ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-01-30 23:00 UTC)