[HN Gopher] Run Your Home on a Raspberry Pi ___________________________________________________________________ Run Your Home on a Raspberry Pi Author : CapitalistCartr Score : 290 points Date : 2022-02-02 13:43 UTC (9 hours ago) (HTM) web link (pragprog.com) (TXT) w3m dump (pragprog.com) | swayvil wrote: | It's like that scene out of Brazil. The wall panel is removed to | reveal a greasy maze of tightly-packed houseguts. A dizzying | complexity of convolving and cryptic organs for... turning on the | lamp. | boringg wrote: | Am I the only one who still has yet to understand the value | proposition of a smart home [outside wifi + sonos]? | | The trade off isn't a clear win to me for me to automate | everything else. If it was I would try a raspberry pi set up. | xconverge wrote: | I approach it like this. As you go through the next week, try | and see if you can identify something that you do every day, | almost like a habit, and think if automation could remove that | task from your life. A few of my favorite examples: | | 1. Checking front/backdoor is locked every single night, now I | have an automation that turns on the front hall light and sends | my phone a notification that the door is unlocked. | | 2. The "did I close the garage thoughts", just being able to | check your phone from the airport or wherever you are and see | "yep its closed" is "nice" but not necessary of course | | 3. Everytime I open the garage door, the light turns on with a | timer and some logic so that I never touch that light switch | | 4. auto turn off air purifier in bedroom in the morning (and on | at night too) | | 5. Anytime the doorbell rings and I am not home, I get a phone | notification with a picture of who is at the door. Helpful when | worried about missing packages, deliveries, etc. Doesn't | necessarily "help" solve the problem, but does do something | mentally | | 6. Recently I added one that nudges the volume on the tv up a | few clicks and down a few clicks based on the HVAC turning | on/off, it was something I found myself doing habitually and | now that it works it is extremely seamless and has been great | | I have way more complicated scenarios of course, all of which I | find compelling, but I really like the automations where you | dont know they are doing something necessarily, your brain just | forgets they are even automations. | brimble wrote: | What's kept me from trying this stuff out is a few | interrelated factors: | | 1) There's no possible way setting up and managing this stuff | manually is going to be worth it if it only controls a couple | things. | | 2) Doing enough to overcome point 1 seems to begin with "step | 1: spend lots of money and time to replace tons of stuff that | already works completely OK" and/or a bunch of research (I've | used enough AirBnB IoT "actuate the existing deadbolt" add- | ons to know that a bunch of them are time-wasting crap that | barely works, plus I've never seen one that didn't look bad) | | 3) Taking a "just do it as you replace things" approach still | results in spending more money (IoT will be more expensive | than dumb, just about every time), plus lots of things will | probably never need to be replaced while I own this house, | plus that means potentially _years_ before I hit any kind of | reasonable pay-off period. | | 4) I have a feeling I could solve several of the problems | faster and cheaper with a dumb approach of low-voltage LEDs | hooked to the right things and run to the right places, or | outlet timers, or whatever, if I were so inclined--which I'm | clearly not, because I haven't. | | Every time I get the urge, I think back to that automation | effort/payoff chart from XKCD and then... don't, because I | can't see how I'll _ever_ get on the good side of the line. | Doubly so if _any_ part of it can 't go years without any | kind of attention or maintenance related to the IoT aspect of | it. | | [EDIT] The calculation would change if I enjoyed that kind of | thing as a hobby, of course. | moffkalast wrote: | Yeah, I've installed a bunch of PIR controlled LED strips | around the apartment to light up as people walk into rooms | automatically, and aside from that there really isn't anything | else I see I would need. | | The "smart" approach would be having all of them wifi enabled, | and then being able to change colour, intensity, duration, etc. | via web or app. You know what also works just as well for that | though? One or two push buttons on each detector lol. | tov247 wrote: | I concur. I take a Battlestar Galactica inspired approach to | appliances in my house. It's fine if they have computers in | them, I just don't want them to be able to communicate. | moffkalast wrote: | So say we all. | amelius wrote: | How much convenience does this bring? Is it life-changing, or is | it more like nice to have? | rcarmo wrote: | It's very handy to get off work, grab a mug of barley coffee, | sit on the couch, say "Siri, let's watch Movies" to your watch, | and have the TV turn itself on, the audio routed to the AV | system, and the Apple TV set as input. | | All the above is done by Siri talking to the Apple TV (which is | the home hub) and homebridge nudging the TV and inputs via | plugins. | | And _nearly_ all the above happens solely inside your LAN, | except for the speech recognition (which may or may not happen | on-device if you have a recent iPhone nearby). | haunter wrote: | I have a home system and tried RaspberryPi several times but in | the end I went with an older Mac Mini. Old ones are quite cheap | on the used market and also significantly more powerful than the | RaspberryPi, that was one of the main reason in the end I rather | chose that. | ramses0 wrote: | Also of note is their recent kickstarter / crowd-supply: | https://www.crowdsupply.com/nabu-casa/home-assistant-yellow | | It's basically an enclosure + some extra integrated hardware for | zigbee (and supposedly "easy-to-add" z-wave). | | The ecosystem is heavily "run it on a rasb-pi" anyway, so you're | 99% of the way there just purchasing or repurposing a PI, but it | wasn't that expensive to back their crowd-funding and I'm happy | to support an attempt at an "official" configuration that can be | purchased. | | I use it slightly for its own capabilities, but mostly as a | bridge to bring more devices to HomeKit compatibility. | | eg: I was able to add my wifi-controllable pool pump to | homeASSISTANT and it creates corresponding devices in homeKIT so | I can make an iOS shortcut accessible to siri: "Hey Siri, clean | the pool" which turns on the pool cleaner. It's kindof like | living in the future. :-P | | I also found recently a "chromecast => airplay" extension/addon | which... bam... now the few chromecast devices I have show up as | airplay sinks for audio (not airplay2, but airplay1 is convenient | for where I've got them put). | | ...and I just got some Samba-mount thing so I can rip my DVD's | and copy them over to `/Media/*.m4v` which I can then blast out | via chromecast (nice b/c both my chromecast and home-assistant PI | are wired, so it shouldn't be sucking up wifi bandwidth, and | keeps me from having to set up a real ). | | It _really_ needs a complete overhaul of how it's thought about | (ie: configuration via yaml, confusing organization of | extensions, addons, configs, better update management) ... I'm a | developer and I still get lost in the mental model they expose | via the UI, but it gets the job done and it's got a good | ecosystem and community to help figure out how to get done what | you're trying to do. | daill wrote: | Am I the only one who uses Fhem? From my point of view it's | extremely robust which increases the wife acceptance factor . I'm | running Hue, Z-Wave sensors, Shelly's, Homematic and an Echo | connection. Sooooo much potential. | hatware wrote: | Getting into home automation beyond Google/Apple/Smart things can | be a boon, you really have to devote a chunk of time to it. | Running useful services at home is one of the fastest ways to | learn. | YaBomm wrote: | I'd rather use a few ESP8266... at $3 bucks each, they include | WiFi... and support micropython. | rootusrootus wrote: | I think a Pi is great to start with. Then you graduate to a real | computer when your HA gets too big and laggy for the Pi to keep | up with. I use a NUC. But my brother repurposed an old laptop | with good results (built in UPS, and quiet!). | nomel wrote: | At what point does HA get too laggy? Are you doing audio/video | transcoding? | rootusrootus wrote: | Nope, nothing heavy like that. I don't know what the | threshold is for every use case, but for me once I got more | than maybe 50 devices, HA started to struggle on the Pi. The | NUC is lightning fast, however, and I've grown my HA | considerably since. Plus it's nice to be able to run ESXi on | the NUC and have VMs for other things too, e.g. Grafana, etc. | brodouevencode wrote: | This would be nice if you could find one. Supply it terribly | short these days. | micromacrofoot wrote: | Exactly... I have an order in place that _might_ arrive by mid- | summer. | destitude wrote: | Yeah.. not sure where there is ANY Pi 3/4s available for sale | in USA unless you pay way above MSRP price. | llbeansandrice wrote: | Anyone have success with remote cameras? Services like Arlo and | Ring seem straight up awful but also rolling my own seems like | more effort and headache than it's worth. | rcarmo wrote: | I have ESP32 cameras that (mostly) work with HomeKit (there are | a few memory issues on the ESP32 side), and a full blown | HomeKit camera that "just works". | johnl1479 wrote: | I have had success integrate Ring and Wyze cameras through Home | Assistant. If you'd rather not go that route, there is a | project that publishes Ring cameras over MQTT and RTSP links: | https://github.com/tsightler/ring-mqtt | rabuse wrote: | I've been wanting to create something for awhile that monitors my | driveway, and when there's motion detected (through camera or IR) | near my vehicle, it turns on a red light in my room, and possibly | include a sound. | urig wrote: | From the contents page this looks like a very cool book indeed. | Is there a webpage somewhere that explains what the projects are? | For example, what do Photo Hook and Hue Fan do? | melenaos wrote: | I just implemented the foundation of my home automation. | | I installed NodeRED on a raspberry pi and it communicates with | arduino through MQTT. | | The good thing with this is that i control the hardware parts | woth arduino and the automation logic with NodeRED. | | NodeRED is much easier to use than HomeAssistant because of the | extensibility and the use of NodeJs. | | I have implemented an arduino library that makes the development | on that an easy task. | | I wanted to have everything on the local network and dont depend | on the internet. We had some internet outage the past years and i | dont want to lose the control of my house for that. Also, | everything is much faster. | | Every arduino can run on its own, that way even if the raspberry | pi is out of order, i can open and close the lights using a | button or a switch. | rcarmo wrote: | I second this approach. My home automation is 98% HomeKit (via | homebridge) and 2% Node-RED (for a few custom MQTT message | translations and a dinky little dashboard with metrics). | m4tthumphrey wrote: | Slightly OT: | | > Run Your Home on a Raspberry Pi | | If you can get hold of one! | | I've been looking for a Pi4 for ages to use with PiHole but sold | out everywhere, some have back orders for 2023 O_O | | Anyone got any recommendations of other devices that work well | with PiHole? I have a Mac Mini acting as a home server but from | what I've read, PiHole does not run great on it via Docker... | ComradePhil wrote: | I tried running PiHole on a Windows box using Docker Desktop. | It worked for a bit but it stopped working at some point... and | I didn't bother fixing. It had been working fine for so long on | my RPi. | | You can buy fanless celeron mini-computers from Aliexpress for | $100-$150. You can also get i5/i7 if you are willing to pay a | lot more. Most of them come with pirated Windows (some sellers | even say that they'll send it with Ubuntu pre-installed) but | you can simply remove it and install Ubuntu Server and then | install PiHole, Home Assistant or whatever you want. | arcbyte wrote: | They only made 150k in all of 2021, so we're seeing the result | of that right now. Good news is they're expecting to make 250k | in Q1 2022 with 500k planned for Q2. | squarefoot wrote: | > If you can get hold of one! | | You don't need any in fact. It's Python so it runs on any | powerful enough Linux platform, and there's a boatload of them | out there; the Raspberry Pi is just the 1st one to become | popular and it's the most advertised. Hoarders depleted all | stocks to sell them overpriced? Well, screw them, we're going | to the competition instead. | | Here's a list, updated yearly, of the most known Linux boards | available with data and prices. | https://linuxgizmos.com/catalog-of-136-open-spec-community-b... | | Take a look also at the devices supported by Armbian and | DietPi. | | https://www.armbian.com/download/?device_support=Supported | | https://dietpi.com/#download | | Also worth visiting is the Linux-sunxi site, where you can find | a huge load of open documentation about hardware and software | for Allwinner CPUs used in some of these boards. | | https://linux-sunxi.org/Main_Page | | Also available are Amlogic CPUs docs at the Hardkernel site. | | https://dn.odroid.com/ | | Example: here's the over 1000 pages long S905x3 full data | sheet. | | https://dn.odroid.com/S905X3/ODROID-C4/Docs/S905X3_Public_Da... | | The public Raspberry Pi CPU data sheet is 166 pages long. | moffkalast wrote: | It's probably not worth going much past something that's also | super popular like an ODroid. Otherwise you'll just be | spending an inordinate amount of hours trying to figure out | obscure bugs that the non-existent community hasn't yet fixed | for you. | | I once made the mistake of buying a Banana Pi M2 Zero. Specs | were great, support looked decent, I thought I'll be getting | a Pi 3 in a Zero form factor. What I instead got was a thing | nobody uses on which barely anything runs properly with such | flaky wifi that it's practically useless. Never again. | driverdan wrote: | Pihole will run on anything and works fine in Docker. I'm | currently running it via docker on a Pi but will eventually | move it to a more standard server with other services. | nerdjon wrote: | I have to ask others, have people had good luck with this? | | I have tried to do this multiple times, with multiple models of | Pi and every time after 6ish months it just seems to completely | stop working. I can't get it to boot even off of a new sd card. | | Am I doing something wrong or does the hardware really not want | to be run consistently in this manner? | | I have since decided to just run some home automation VM's on my | media server which has worked flawlessly (minus networking being | weird sometimes). | aulin wrote: | The only time I've bricked a Pi ever was when I shorted 5V and | 3.3V rails in a 3B+. A friend always talks about one bricked | with an apt upgrade by a broken firmware or something, never | seen anything like that. Saw plenty of dead or corrupted | sdcards but that can be fixed with a new one, which doesn't | seem to be your case. Maybe a bad power supply? Pi is a bit | picky, you need one with 5.1V to prevent low voltage warnings. | wjdp wrote: | Have had the same problems, though it's always the Pi chewing | up the SD card, a new card solves it. These guides really need | a warning saying "If you find this useful, switch to using a | server that doesn't rely on an SD card after ~6 months" | | The Pi is fantastic for getting a taste of self-hosting / home | automation as it's so cheap but by no means should it be relied | on. | | I moved our Home Assistant install to a docker container on | basic PC and it's been rock solid after several SD cards were | eaten by the Pi. Though I still have DNS (via PiHole) running | on a Pi and that's starting to act up. | | Only time I've found Pis reliable is when they either don't | write much or are running a read-only disk most of the time. | We've a network audio player using piCorePlayer[1] on a Pi | running for years and never had an issue, it's running tiny | core linux and only makes the disk r/w when you're upgrading or | changing settings. | | I'm tempted to move my MQTT server to a Pi using tiny core as | that'd keep messaging up while I'm rebooting or doing some | other task on my single server. Something like | http://akeil.net/posts/mosquitto-mqtt-on-tinycore.html | | [1]: https://www.picoreplayer.org/ | nerdjon wrote: | I have a TV PI that seems to so far be running just fine | after about 6 months. But I also have it reboot once a day so | maybe that may be some magic. | | I have PiHole running myself, my original plan was to use a | Pi but the last thing I wanted for that thing to die and my | internet stop working. An easy enough fix, but a frustrating | one. | | Mine is also running on the my media server. Which... is fun. | When I reboot it I have to start things VM's in a certain | order or things get really unhappy. | | I agree that a warning like that should be in place, I am | surprised though that a new card worked for you. I have a | drawer of Pi's that I never managed to salvage. | wjdp wrote: | Mix of things mean I haven't changed it (yet) - As you | point out having on a shared server isn't great. I do want | a separate device for DNS, I don't want the network down | because the 'everything server' needs a reboot. - aand when | it breaks I don't tend to be in the mood to fix it. Usually | late in the evening when watching telly. It usually needs a | reboot or `pihole-FTL.db` has gotten to several GB in size | and needs deleting. But I'm sure it's getting closer to | being unrecoverable. | | I've also got it doing DHCP so every device gets a | <hostname>.<network>.uk domain, plus it handles some static | records as well. Means it's not just a quick swapout, need | to find and migrate the custom stuff I've done to it. Most | of this should be in a git repo but unsure if all of it is. | | The joys of overcomplicating home networking! | Semaphor wrote: | I have my PI running off a USB-SSD instead. It works very | well, though initial set up can be a bit of a hassle. | paulmd wrote: | I used to boot my fileserver (not a Pi) like that and it | worked fine for a number of years until the USB-SATA | adapter died. Not sure if you meant an actual purpose-built | external SSD but I don't know that I'd trust a home-brewed | solution in the long term. | not1ofU wrote: | If you dont mind, do you have some link to hand that you | used to set that up? | | Edit: - sorry, nevermind, I should have read the rest of | the comments, there is a link below this comment (at time | of writing) | paulmd wrote: | Be sure to move /var/log and other write-heavy directories to | a tmpfs so they're not constantly chewing up writes. | | The long-term solution for this (if you're up for it) is to | PXE boot from your fileserver, so you don't need a SD card at | all. | h2odragon wrote: | I've got "TV Pis" that idle LibreELEC/Kodi most of the time and | have been running for 4+ years on the same SD cards (updated | them a couple times in that time, not recently). | | My "server Pi" is >3yo old, only turns off when the power | fails, and doesn't _do_ a lot with its SD card but the OS, but | has never had an issue. | | What kind of power are you using? I've got these on little 2.5a | wall warts; the "server" has a scrounged 20 year old PSU pulled | from a Cisco 2500 router running it and some other stuff. No | UPS tho and we get power outages and weirdness as usual for a | rural area. | nerdjon wrote: | Maybe the power supply is the issue. Every time I have setup | I pi I would get the Canakit sets so maybe it is just not | suitable? | h2odragon wrote: | My wall warts are mostly from canakit sets, i can't | complain about them. | magicalhippo wrote: | Make sure to check the USB cable you use. I have a few | which has ~1 Ohm resistance, and given that the Pi can use | 1-1.5A under load that translates to a 1-1.5V cable drop. | | This can cause the Pi to shut down, and SD cards are not | happy losing power while writing AFAIK. | | I've had multiple Pi's run for years off the same SD card | without issue. My Home Assistant install has a 3GB database | with updates every few seconds due to some chatty Z-Wave | modules. Been running just fine since 2018. | | I also had a few with issues, and _all_ of them were down | to cables with too high resistance. Some were sold as | charging cables, yet were rubbish. | | I got a USB cable tester from AliExpress, alternatively buy | some known good ones. | | For SD cards, make sure they're class A1 or A2. | | [1]: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32973869742.html | paulmd wrote: | Not only are SD cards not happy with losing power during | writing, but they are very sensitive to "brownout" | undervoltage conditions. In this case writes may appear | to succeed but actually fail to commit, which is | obviously problematic for the integrity of your data. | | (if people were using a checksumming filesystem like ZFS, | this of course would be immediately apparent when it was | occurring!) | | Samsung sells "high endurance" SD cards - I would | strongly recommend these for RPi usage, and they are also | very useful for dash cams since those are always | continuously writing as well. Sandisk sells high- | endurance cards as well but frankly Samsung is a cut | above the rest of the SD card market - my SD card | failures have essentially gone away since I stopped | buying other brands. I think I have had one SD card | failure since then and it wasn't related to write | endurance, just didn't use it for a couple years and it | was dead when I tried it again. | | But yes, in general, power quality is a massive problem | for RPis, and people don't really consider it because | it's one of those "it works 99.9% of the time" | situations. It's like a race condition that you only | rarely ever hit, it _looks_ correct and people will die | on the hill of "it's worked perfectly fine for months | now, the power can't be a problem" and then you hit a | weak flash cell when the CPU is heavily loaded and the | voltage is starting to droop and it happens to be a | critical file rather than just some log or a chunk in an | audiovisual file somewhere, and _then_ you notice it. | | I'd say >95% of all Pi failures come down to either power | problems or SD card wearout. They're certainly not | otherwise flawless, it's a janky cheapass SOC in general, | but that is the _overwhelming_ cause of Pi system | failures. | | If you can swing it, network booting from a fileserver is | a much more reliable option in the long run. I haven't | really experimented with it, and performance will | probably be worse, but it gets the SD card out of the | equation entirely, which mitigates both of these | problems. You're not writing to flash, so brownout | doesn't matter in terms of the potential for failed | writes, and you aren't writing to a physical SD card so | there's no wear. | Nextgrid wrote: | I have 2 and they've been running for years on the same SD | cards. Maybe power or cooling is an issue? Mine use reputable | USB-C adapters (the official Raspberry Pi one just because it's | small, but alternatively I'd go for an Apple or Anker one) and | cases with a little heatsink you can stick onto the processor. | wyager wrote: | Pis are horrendously unreliable. Even if you pull out all the | stops to make them work reliably (like disabling SD card | writes), they don't. | | The broadcom chips they use are complete garbage. I was hopeful | I could use the watchdog timer to make a pi more reliable (by | restarting it when it inevitably crashed). Guess what? The | internal watchdog timer doesn't f*cking work! You'll notice | that every project using pi hardware that needs a WDT uses an | external one. | | Total junk! I don't use them for anything anymore, and I used | to have like 6 automating various things. | paulmd wrote: | I played around with Pis a lot in the OG Pi 1B era and yeah, | I got tired of fixing it every couple months (I attribute | this to power quality and SD card failures) and just moved to | using various x86 based systems. I used surplus SFF | optiplexes from surplus sales (paid as little as $5 for | some), AM1-based mITX (mobo+CPU for $50!), or Atom-based NUCs | (used to get "surplus" J5005 NUCs with the plastic still on | for $125). | | I'm looking to get back into it with some Pi4s for a few | things - but I'm planning to PXE boot this time around to try | and sidestep the SD card/power problems. Basically just stuff | like LibreElec to free up some of my J5005 NUCs for actual | stuff. | aulin wrote: | I've used the internal watchdog without any issue. I mean the | one you enable from systemd with RuntimeWatchdogSec=10 (where | 10 iirc is a number less than 14 which is the number of | seconds where the timer overflows). Not really much to | configure or customize but it works reliably. | wyager wrote: | Interesting. Perhaps they fixed the driver/hardware since I | last looked at this a couple years ago. At the time, no one | had got it working successfully (the special device was | there; it just didn't seem to do anything). | rcarmo wrote: | Modern Pis have effectively zero (pun intended) relationship | to the original ones. The kernel issues were fixed, and as | long as you keep them cool, you can go a long way even on SD | cards. | andylynch wrote: | For this kind of application, my own experience and others | using home assistant seems to be your much better of plugging | an SSD into the pi's USB 3 and using that. It's also really | important to use a good power supply. | spookthesunset wrote: | Bingo. Booting from an SSD is much better. Yeah it is a | dongle dangling off the side of the Pi but it is much more | reliable. | creeble wrote: | I've had good luck running pi's for years between (power fail) | reboots. | | One thing though - I don't think any of my pi's run x windows, | I think they're all console mode. I get the feeling that they | do fewer writes in general this way, but I don't really know. | Anecdotally, I had a pi that ran x that I was experimenting | with, and after a couple of months found it locked up/dead to | the network. A reboot brought it back fine, but I unplugged it | a few days after that and haven't been using it. | cpascal wrote: | It might be the Pi wearing out the SD card. The Raspberry Pi | Compute Module 4 [1] actually has a PCIe Gen 2 x1 socket. | | Jeff Geerling (who's active on HN) has actually gotten SATA | working [2] through the Compute Module 4 and the Compute Module | 4 IO Board [3]. | | If you go his route you could potentially set up a Pi with more | durable storage. Although, if you watch Jeff's video its a PITA | getting SATA working as he had to recompile the kernel with | SATA support. Also its pretty hard to get the Compute Module 4 | and the IO board at the moment. | | [1]: https://www.raspberrypi.com/products/compute-module-4-io- | boa... | | [2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZSx1BRwz1bs | | [3]: https://www.raspberrypi.com/products/compute-module-4/ | rkangel wrote: | Alternatively you go PXE boot and network storage but then | _that_ assumes that you 've got something else running to | provide it. It's a nice solution when you've got half a dozen | Pis around though (we use it in labs for our hardware test | setups). | Saris wrote: | Yeah it's better to spend $80 or so on an off lease small form | factor desktop. They don't really use that much more energy | than a Pi but are much faster and more stable with real SATA | storage. | ldiracdelta wrote: | I ran 20 pi's at work for years and had one failure. I've run | my irrigation system off a pi for 4 years without a problem. I | may be the anomaly and I don't live in Death Valley. | | When you have an image that you're happy with, back it up. | Using a USB<->SD card reader on a linux machine, run gparted to | slim the image down to the minimum, then run something like | this sudo dd if=/dev/sda of=my-pi-v1.img | bs=1M count=7000 status=progress | | Where `/dev/sda` is the sd card and `7000 `is the number of MB | the pi disk takes after you gparted it down to the minimum | size. | | Next, flash the image on a new disk and make sure it works with | the pi. | scottlamb wrote: | You have bad luck or are doing something wrong. I've had a Pi2 | running for years and a Pi4 running since they were released in | 2019. I had to replace a SD card once (and now am using a SATA | SSD on a USB bridge instead). Otherwise, no hardware failures. | | > I can't get it to boot even off of a new sd card. | | Best guess: power adapter problems. Either the power adapter | itself is dead or it misbehaved, killing the Pi. | fernovus wrote: | It's super doable, especially if you store your root in a HDD | partition. Using an USB flash drive would be the same as | relying on a MicroSD, not the ideal for 24/7/365 usage | hotpotamus wrote: | I'm with the others who have been running pi's for years with | no issue. I did however go back into the office awhile back and | stumbled across a pi display setup that had gone into read only | at some point - most likely an sd card failure. | | I would think if you want to take it up a step, you could look | at something like an Intel NUC. | hinkley wrote: | I still have this dream that some day everyone will have a little | stack of SBCs running home services from tracking energy use to | running pinhole to running persistent game servers (eg, | Minecraft). | | Every year you pop out the oldest one and pop in a newer one and | speed the whole thing up. | kkielhofner wrote: | Home Assistant[1] is the best approach I've found for this. It's | pretty amazing but has a pretty steep learning curve (although | they're getting better and better at this). The real power of HA | is the rich integration ecosystem[2], the Community Store[3], and | that it runs locally (more reliable and much faster for things | like motion sensors, etc). | | It expresses everything from every integration as an entity in | various device classes so as long as some random tech is | supported by an integration you can group them seamlessly. For | example - I have Z-wave based motion detectors but I can control | Hue lights and Wemo switches for motion detection - but only if | I'm home as reported by the zone feature in their iOS companion | application. | | Their supervisor/docker based install for Raspberry Pi is pretty | slick[4]. Write an image to disk as you usually would and you get | a bare-bones OS with Home Assistant running in docker. Then there | are additional docker-based add-ons you can install for stuff | like MQTT, Z-Wave, Let's Encrypt, SSH access, nginx, and more. | All managed in the web ui. Pretty cool. | | [1] https://www.home-assistant.io/ | | [2] https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/ | | [3] https://hacs.xyz/ | | [4] https://www.home-assistant.io/installation/raspberrypi | phreeza wrote: | Does anyone have some experience to share with integrating home | assistant with Homematic devices? I'm stuck with those for | controlling my heating but really dislike the interface. | Inversechi wrote: | They have a really welcoming community from my experience. | Try either their forum or discord. | aivisol wrote: | +1 for Home Assistant. Have it running on RPi4 for almost two | years already without single glitch. It has tons of | integrations, and besides that you can always build your own | Arduino modules to connect with it over MQTT if you have your | special use case. Web UI is really nice, you can even access | and edit config files with it without going ssh. Android/IOS | app also works pretty well. | ornornor wrote: | Not to mention that, with the help of appdaemon[0], you can | write Python code to implement all the logic you can dream of. | | I found this much more powerful than the base GUI, and much | more expressive (and less clunky) than Nodered or the yaml | automations. | | [0]: https://appdaemon.readthedocs.io/en/latest/ | m0ngr31 wrote: | I setup Home Assistant to be able to talk to my solar inverters | and see my battery voltage without walking out into the garage | (over modbus). | | Since then I started adding in door sensors and my thermostat. | I just need to find a way to see how much propane I'm using and | I'll be set. | davemtl wrote: | I recently set-up HA on a Raspberry Pi, integrating my lights, | security system and other devices. You're right about it having | a steep learning curve but once it's up and running it's pretty | much set and forget. With HA I'm able to use my Hue switches to | toggle a TP-Link Kasa smart power outlet. It also has the added | benefit of only requiring ONE application on my phone instead | of nine. | xxpor wrote: | I'd also suggest to everyone looking into HA to take the time | to learn Node-RED. After running HA for a year and a half, | but only ever creating basic integrations, NR has really | unlocked the power of HA for me. Part of it is the tutorials | for NR explained the internal data model of HA in a way that | I finally get it. Plus just ergonomically, I find NR MUCH | easier to deal with than HA's native automation UI. | iamspoilt wrote: | I spend my last weekend setting up Home Assistant using VMWare | on my spare machine. To say that it has been very rewarding is | understatement. I am completely blown away by the possibilities | that it enables. For instance, I have all my unsupported | devices magically supported in HomeKit via the HomeKit Bridge | integration in HA. | contravariant wrote: | Does anyone know how Home Assistant compares to node-red? As | far as I can tell Home Assistant is better at building a | dashboard of things, but node-red is better at actually | automating specific actions (unless you want to grapple with | HA's YAML based scripting language). | | Is this about right? Is it possible to combine Home Assistant | and node-red, or has Home Assistant outgrown the need for | something like node-red? | OJFord wrote: | It is possible, and a few years ago seemed quite a trend | (just going by /r/homeassistant spectating) - | https://github.com/hassio-addons/addon-node-red - but I | gather HA's own automation scripting has at least | visualisation if not GUI programming now. | avel wrote: | They are not comparable because node-red is a generic low- | code programming tool while HA is home automation software. | | If you mean how they compare when you plug in node-red to HA | and use it for automations, rather than use HA's "native" | automations... I believe the consensus is that node-red is | more user-friendly in that way, and because it can plug to | other things on its own it can provide more flexibility. On | the other hand, HA has recently worked on the UI of their | automations, and it is already pretty good for simple flows. | In the end both of these approaches are great, each with its | own pros and cons. | Semaphor wrote: | IME: For simple automations, HA UI is far easier. For complex | ones, if you want a GUI, node-red, if you want to handwrite | scripts, HA. If you don't care it really depends, in some | cases coding them is easier, in some cases node-red is | easier. | | But then this is about Node-Red integrated into HA. | seanw444 wrote: | I was thinking about getting started with HA, and then I saw | the YAML. Dear God. May just be the ugliest scripting | language I've ever seen. | entropie wrote: | For me node-red is more of an addition to homeassistant. | There is node-red-contrib-home-assistant-websocket [1] to let | node-red speak with homeassistant, you can watch state | changes etc. I use ha for like two years now and at the start | there was no inbuild automation-backend like it is now so we | did everything with node-red. | | https://flows.nodered.org/node/node-red-contrib-home- | assista... | rcarmo wrote: | I've settled on homebridge to talk to the Home app on my | iPhone (which is where all the automation is done, and then | executed on an Apple TV) and a little Node-RED for custom | flows. | | I have zero YAML to maintain, and I'm happier for it. | acidburnNSA wrote: | Same. I've been a huge Home Assistant fan and minor contributor | for many years. My house is among the smartest houses I've ever | heard of. HVAC control, security system, air quality | monitoring, multi-site IT systems monitoring, lighting controls | (including LED strips that update to the right color scheme for | the next holiday), whole-house networked audio (including | streaming off-site if connected to the VPN), on and on. All | self-hosted, on-prem, zero cloud, coordinated by Home | Assistant. Offsite notifications via email, offsite control and | monitoring via my Openwrt router's VPN server. | bredren wrote: | Have your written up your implementation? What type of air | quality sensors have you used and how are they integrated | into the home's behavior? | scottlamb wrote: | I'm still figuring out Home Assistant. I love that it has a | real ecosystem and that it seems to have a decent | HTTP/WebSocket API (that I just started playing with). | | Some things I don't love: | | * A lot of the integrations seem half-baked or to not quite fit | the generic Lovelace cards. I think to some extent this is an | inherent problem in supporting a lot of devices that have | crappy, non-standardized APIs. Example: if I bump up the low | temp on my Venstar thermostat on the Home Assistant dashboard, | Home Assistant will immediately set it back. If I dig through | logs, I see the thermostat complained that in auto mode | (heating or cooling as needed), the low set point and the high | set point have to be (at least) six degrees apart. When I | adjust the thermostat through its own touch screen, the high | set point automatically raises to meet that constraint. Home | Assistant should do the same. I've been meaning to look into | fixing it myself, but there seem to be weird things like this | on every integration. | | * You need multiple automation rules to do almost anything. I | think it's common to want the state of one thing to match | another (for example, garage door open => sticky notification | on my phone, person in driveway after sunset within last 5 | minutes or switch on => driveway light on). You need a rule in | their YAML DSL to for the off->on transition and another for | the on->off. It'd be nice to set a rule that defines a level | rather than an edge and have it internally do the | transformation. It'd also be nice to define the actions of a | notification's buttons inline, rather than as a separate | automation. | | * The companion Android app's notifications seem to be flaky. | At least, they're sometimes slow. I think they can be delivered | out of order and possibly are lossy, which aggravates the | problem with not having something that just sets the state | reliably. I assume it's pretty hopeless to have it reliably be | in the right state if your phone was off when a notification | was supposed to be delivered or Home Assistant was down on | state transition or the like. | | * Some things seem to be only checked at startup, so my house | has race conditions after power outages. For example, if Home | Assistant starts up more quickly than my Yamaha AV receiver (+ | network switch + DHCP server), I can't control my home theater | setup until I restart Home Assistant. | dheera wrote: | I also hate that you have to install it as an OS or VM to be | fully featured. | | If you use the docker version it is crippled with no | "supervisor" mode. | | Also every now and then a light or switch will go greyed out | in HA, their official apps still work, and I have to restart | HA to be able to use it in HA again. Pretty annoying when you | get home after a long day, soaked in rain, fumbling in the | dark to turn on lights and now you have to fumble more to | restart the damn server before you can use your lights. | janitha wrote: | How is the container version crippled? | | An anecdotal data point, but I've been running the home- | assistant container image on k8s without any issue, and I | have a lot of integrations. | dheera wrote: | You can't run HACS, supervisor mode, Kelvin-sun matching | plugin ... | giobox wrote: | I'm running HACS in the container release right now, it's | worked for a long time. So long as you have your HA | configuration folder as a volume etc it will preserve | across restarts/upgrades. | | I'd go as far as to argue the (officially supported!) | container release is the best way to get a production | quality install of HA - containers are a great way to | package and release complex web apps like HA. Mines | automatically updates itself every time new container | image released, has done so with no intervention from me | for over a year. With the container lifecycle/config, you | don't really need Supervisor mode either. | | To say it is crippled is nonsense, it is literally one of | the two officially recommended install paths: | | > https://www.home-assistant.io/installation/ | | Official support for Docker release in HACS: | | > https://hacs.xyz/docs/setup/download#home-assistant- | containe... | lookingsideways wrote: | HACS works in a container, or is there specific | functionality of it that doesn't work? I've been using it | inside a Docker HA container on a Pi without issue. | easton wrote: | Supervisor mode is basically operating system configuration | stuff (DNS, audio, etc.) telemetry for the dev team, and | health checking: https://www.home- | assistant.io/blog/2020/09/16/supervisor-joi.... (Unless I'm | missing something?) | | It seems fine that this isn't available in docker, since | you can do all of this via docker and your host's | configuration system. It would be nice to have a GUI for | it, but if you need a GUI then you probably aren't running | HA via docker, you used their image. | nomel wrote: | > ... for the off->on transition and another for the on->off. | It'd be nice to set a rule that defines a level rather than | an edge and have it internally do the transformation | | The "solution" I found was to poll, and use "choose", and | sometimes some helper switches for state, to do what is | needed. But, I think at any reasonable level of complexity, | you're better off using one of the three python components: | the one built into Home Assistant, pyscript, or AppDaemon. | | Home Assistant Python: https://www.home- | assistant.io/integrations/python_script/ No imports. | | pyscript: https://github.com/custom-components/pyscript Full | python. Supports Jupyter. Straightforward. | | AppDaemon: https://appdaemon.readthedocs.io/en/latest/HASS_TU | TORIAL.htm... Full python. A little lower level. Allows the | creation of dashboards. | | Related, the Matter protocol is on its way. I'm waiting for | these devices before I redo my house, or put much more effort | into any of this: | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matter_(standard) | antsar wrote: | Matter is interesting. But... | | > The project group was launched and introduced by Amazon, | Apple, Google, Comcast and the Zigbee Alliance, now | Connectivity Standards Alliance (CSA). | | I'm having a real hard time believing that anything user- | beneficial will come of this, unless you're willing to sell | out your smarthome and privacy to big tech. | heurisko wrote: | > I'm having a real hard time believing that anything | user-beneficial will come of this, unless you're willing | to sell out your smarthome and privacy to big tech. | | At this level, the way data is handled is vendor | agnostic. | | I see Matter as more akin to USB, or indeed, the | internet, as the idea is that devices are supposed to be | able to communicate via IP, not just by ZigBee. | lazide wrote: | Another way to look at this - maybe this is a way to give | a pressure relief valve for all the privacy conscious so | they stop harassing them so much for the 90% of consumer | case that doesn't care? | rcarmo wrote: | I gave up on it solely because of the GUI. It's confusing as | heck and very far from Apple's Home app, which is the preferred | UX of the CFO (Chief Family Officer), even for fairly complex | automations. | | So I just used homebridge for everything, with a smattering of | Node-RED for (very few) device shims (it is _very_ easy to do | MQTT handling with it). | | Also, I now have zero YAML to maintain, which is also a boon. | | Kudos, though, for Home Assistant auto-discovery, which I use | with my Tasmota-reflashed devices (there is a homebridge plugin | that transparently adds them to HomeKit as soon as they're set | up). | gregable wrote: | For folks here I strongly recommend installing the appdaemon | integration and just writing python scripts. The downside is | there is a good bit of learning curve and time investment | just to get the hello world going (turn on a light at | sunset?). | | Once you are there, you can write shared libraries, abstract | away whatever you want, have legit tests, and just do | anything you would normally want in your coding environment | (vscode, auto-formatters, source control, etc). Obviously not | the right recommendation for a consumer system, but if you | are like me and feel more comfortable with a programming | language, it's the way to go. | ornornor wrote: | Fully agree. | | Interested about the tests though. I'm not a professional | python developer but would love automated tests for my | appdaemon code. How did you set it up, and how do you run | the tests? | rcarmo wrote: | I can do that with homebridge-mqtt (I just stopped doing it | in Python because Node-RED did what I needed and gave me a | dead easy chart for temperature sensors). | iandanforth wrote: | How do you handle network security? I wouldn't trust an IoT | device on the same network as any of my family's computers or | phones for example. | syshum wrote: | For me I mainly use Zigbee and Zwave Devices not WiFi | Devices. | | I am sadden that wifi seems to be taking over and ZigBee and | Zwave are starting to lose favor. | nomel wrote: | I like to believe that it's because matter protocol is on | its way, so hardware isn't being developed: | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matter_(standard) | | But, I think it's actually because wifi is easier for the | average person to get working. With Zigbee, you need a | Zigbee hub, but sometimes you need a brand specific Zigbee | hub, sometimes you don't (even though it's advertised that | you do), and sometimes the Zigbee compliance is so bad that | adding a device from another vendor break your whole Zigbee | network (looking at you Aquara). Zwave throws more | incompatible hubs to the mix. And, even within these, it's | rare to have devices work with each other in a way that | makes sense. | | Hopefully matter saves us, so I don't have to install 5 | integrations in Home Assistant to remind me that my car | isn't plugged in at night or my back window is open, while | the heater is on, and then another to make any of it | accessible to HomeKit. | syshum wrote: | I must be lucky then because I have lot of Zigbee and | Zwave devices all running Transmitting to Nortek | GoControl USB stick attached to a rPI running Home | Assistant. | | I have several vendors of both Zwave and Zigbee Sensors, | HVAC thermostat, Bulbs, Switches, etc.. All of them play | nice with each other, and FAR FAR simpler to setup than | WiFi which often requires the use of some weird mobile | app, and play hopsotch with the networks.. | | Zigbee I just pair them to the GoControl and it is done | | hell I even bought some no name used Door Sensors off | ebay that were Zigbee, I mainly use them for Temp | monitoring in various places.. They had no problem | connecting to my network either | xxpor wrote: | In addition to all of the "use Z-Wave/Zigbee as much as | possible" comments (which I personally do), for stuff where | there's no choice like Roombas, I have a separate SSID on a | VLAN that can only talk to the internet, my DNS server | running Adguard, and HA (which is on the main network). I | also have stateful rules that allow connections to be | initiated from the main network to the IOT network, but not | vice versa. I also try to find things with ESP* controllers, | as mentioned. | | I've really been trying to move away from cloud based stuff | not only because of data privacy, but concerns about services | going away and (most importantly) latency. | | My old wifi smart plugs had 2+ seconds of latency from when | I'd hit the button in HA to actually turning on. | Zigbee/Z-wave stuff is (from my meatsack perspective) | instant. I have a zigbee door sensor on the door to get into | my garage, and a zigbee smart plug connected to the overhead | florescent lights. By the time the door opens enough for me | to actually see inside the garage, the lights are on. | Sometimes I think they never turned off. It's fantastic. | vladgur wrote: | How do you setup a separate VLAN and SSID? None of the | "pro-sumer" wifi mesh setups under $500 support VLANs | xxpor wrote: | I use Unifi for wifi gear, which supports it out of the | box. | | https://www.ui.com/unifi/unifi-ap-ac-pro/ for the wired | AP, https://store.ui.com/products/uap-beaconhd for the | extension into the back of the house. Pricy, but not | completely outrageous IMO. | | For an actual router, I run OPNsense in a VM (on the same | box as HA, funnily enough). My server has dual 10 gig | ports, so I pass through one of them to OPNsense and run | it as a "router on a stick", where the basic internal | network is the untagged VLAN, and the public side is VLAN | 99. My switch then strips the VLAN 99 tag from the packet | before sending it to the cable modem, and vice-versa. My | switch is https://mikrotik.com/product/crs328_24p_4s_rm, | which was $379 in 2018. However, you can get similar | functionality from MUCH cheaper microtik or | unifi/ubiquity switches if you don't need 10 gig support. | | If you're starting from scratch I might get something | like https://store.ui.com/collections/unifi-network- | unifi-os-cons..., and an el cheapo dumb switch, as long | as it'd pass through vlan tagged traffic. You want | anything that's crossing a vlan boundary to end up on the | router anyway, so you can apply firewall rules to it. | zrail wrote: | Do you feel that using a virtualized router with other | things on the box puts you at greater risk? I.e. you're | putting an awful lot of eggs in that one basket. I've | considered setting that up before but shied away from it. | xxpor wrote: | Availability risk? Sure, but that's 99.9% my own doing | (constant experiments, etc) | | Security risk? Not in the slightest. I'm running an up to | date proxmox which is just KVM+QEMU with some scripting | and a website on top, basically. I know how to setup | IOMMU groups and such. If it's good enough for the big | cloud providers, it's good enough for me. | zrail wrote: | Yeah primarily I'm concerned with availability. I have a | "production" hypervisor now with all of the household | services running on it that I've promised my spouse I | wouldn't mess around with which cuts off one avenue of | experiments. | vladgur wrote: | Do you know if Dreammachine can work with another | ubiquity Access point in a mesh fashion? | nybble41 wrote: | The Ubiquiti Access Point AC Mesh Pro[0] (~$200) appears | to support multiple SSIDs and VLANs. Of course you'd need | at least two of them to count as a "mesh", which is | $400... was your $500 budget _per access point_ or for | the whole system (and if so, for how many APs)? | | [0] https://store.ui.com/products/unifi-ac-mesh-pro-ap | wyager wrote: | Not OP, but I make extensive use of VLANs to isolate off | security cameras, IoT devices, etc. etc. into their own | mutually isolated network environments. | | I also don't use Wifi for any of these devices anymore. It's | usually a bad experience. Either use ethernet or a dedicated | IoT-oriented wireless protocol. Z-wave seems OK but not very | flexible, Zigbee is a pain in the rear (but the only option | for many device classes), and I'm hopeful that Thread will | actually be good. | rcarmo wrote: | I just don't use Google or Alexa (devices from those | ecosystems punch holes through my home gateway for a bunch of | server-side glue that is extremely ill-advised, and a bigger | risk than LAN security IMHO), moved most things (sensors, | typically) to ZigBee, and reflashed everything I could with | Tasmota. | | It's extremely inconvenient to have IoT devices segregated | from, say, TVs and media devices, especially if you rely on | AirPlay or Chromecast to get audio around the place, so I | just secure my Macs (and PCs) properly as if we were still | traveling and visiting clients. | | I keep tabs on Apple security bulletins (HomeKit has | relatively few issues, and works mostly inside the LAN except | if you're outside the house - it then switches to a variation | of the old iCloud "back to my X" tunneling). | alufers wrote: | I personally just flash everything possible with open-source | software. All my light switches and Wi-Fi lightbulbs run | Tasmota, which I password protect and semi- regularly update. | The one odball is my Gree AC unit, which is on a separate | WiFi network and subnet (I just run hostapd on my RPi since | it's close-by). But it's more to protect it from the outside, | not the other way, because it's controlled with JSON sent | over UDP, and if you send a malformed packet the | microcontroller inside crashes. When this happens and the | compressor is engaged it will freeze up, possibly destroying | itself and start flooding the floor, because the condensation | pump won't turn on. | artificialLimbs wrote: | >> When this happens and the compressor is engaged it will | freeze up, possibly destroying itself and start flooding | the floor, because the condensation pump won't turn on. | | Do not buy Gree. Check. | rcarmo wrote: | Or maybe not automate destructive devices. Might be | simpler and more responsible anyway, since equivalent | harm can be had if your kids ask Siri to warm up the | house... | bliteben wrote: | What lightbulbs do you find are best for running tasmota? | I'd prefer not to have to setup a zigbee setup in addition | to my zwave. | slingnow wrote: | > But it's more to protect it from the outside, not the | other way, because it's controlled with JSON sent over UDP, | and if you send a malformed packet the microcontroller | inside crashes. When this happens and the compressor is | engaged it will freeze up, possibly destroying itself and | start flooding the floor, because the condensation pump | won't turn on. | | Wow, the future is truly here folks! | jve wrote: | How did you find that out? You mean random UDP packet can | destroy AC? | | /me having a Gree unit that is to be installed | clownpenis_fart wrote: | tragictrash wrote: | if you flash openwrt/ddwrt to your router, you can create an | isolated subnet with its own DHCP server and enter your own | firewall rules (iptables) blocking all traffic from your | local subnet to your IOT subnet. You can then bind that to a | wifi ssid (the guest one). Its kind of a PITA to setup, but | it works great once you get it. Netgear Nighthawk routers | have worked great for me in the past. | | Don't forget to set up a reverse proxy with ssl and automatic | cert renewsl, even in your home network. Wifi can be hacked | with trivial ease. Caddy or nginx/certbot will do you well | there. If you also run a pi-hole you can have the pi on your | local network pass ssl checks by overriding some DNS entries. | rhinoceraptor wrote: | One, I avoid WiFi products entirely if there is a good | alternative. Zigbee and ZWave are two good ecosystems, you | get a USB radio, plug it Home Assistant machine and you're up | and running. | | A second option is finding devices that can be flashed with | Tasmota or ESPHome. This could also mean putting together | your own devices with an ESP8266, ESPHome is basically plug | and play for simple things like temperature sensors. You | assemble the device, configure which pins to use via YAML, | and then flash it to the ESP. | | You don't even need to download a local build toolchain, the | ESPHome add-on to Home Assistant can flash devices plugged | into your computer just from the web interface, and then do | OTA firmware updates. | clownpenis_fart wrote: | mindslight wrote: | I prohibit IoT devices from connecting to the Internet at | all, and only use devices that can be controlled by the local | network [0]. Thus firmware updates don't matter (as long as | the manufacturer hasn't included any logic bombs), as the | trust model is that devices are just an extension of the | network segment. | | The least-involved way to set this up would be to set up an | old wifi router to create a second network, don't connect | this router to your existing network or uplink, and then set | up your home automation server with two ethernet ports. | | [0] eg TP-Link Kasa, although I heard this may have changed | for recent ones? Either way, with this setup you'll be | immediately aware of whether local control functionality | works, so you're well within the return window. FWIW I stay | away from Amazon's GENSYM brands, even though they'd be easy | to flash with Tasmota etc, because I don't trust them to get | line voltage design considerations right and I don't feel | like QAing every single device. | slothtrop wrote: | I'm aiming to use a supervised installation to free up the pi | for other tasks, but concerned about performance. Will be | booting from SATA to help to this end, and to avoid degradation | from writing to microSD often (this may be the case when I | start recording security footage) | Nextgrid wrote: | I haven't had any issues just using the stock image on an SD | card - it seems to be fast enough. YMMV especially if you | plan to run other things on the Pi, though in this case I'd | recommend going for a mini-PC instead and just installing a | standard Linux distribution on it. | slothtrop wrote: | I see. Really it was just going to be something like pihole | which is supposedly light. Maybe better not to use the | supervised if this is focused on running HA? | | In the future I'll consider the mini-PC, thanks. This will | have to do for now. | vorpalhex wrote: | You will probably not have a great experience running cctv | from a pi. You may want something a bit beefier unless your | cams are low res, mostly due to transcode/copying costs. | | In terms of disk, you want multiple disks as either | raid/zfs/btrfs/lvm. It will probably be better to do this on | a separate machine and mount it via nfs. | | For your boot volume, you can also use a usb thumb drive to | help avoid sd card fatigue. | paulmd wrote: | I've really wanted to get into this to some extent but it's | such a complex (and expensive!) topic that I really would like | some distilled knowledge from someone who's been through it and | figured out what works and what doesn't, the pitfalls, etc. | This is probably a good place to ask - does anyone know of a | reliable guide (or ideally blog) to get started? Or maybe would | be a good topic for a future HN submission. | | My personal focus would be on cloud-free/self-hosted systems. | Looping through the cloud as a convenience is fine but I don't | really want to rely on cloudshit 100% for the operation of my | house. | | Also I've heard really good things about the Lutreon stuff? Not | open, and not cheap, but it works, and I've heard the z-wave | stuff isn't always 100%. | belthasar wrote: | I've used Home Assistant on a Pi 3B+ for about a year now. My | main objective is like yours, I want as few devices as | possible connected to the internet and generally only buy | devices that have a local API (local polling in HA terms). I | do pay for Nabu Casa, HA's cloud service for convenient | access to everything but nothing I use requires it. This also | help support a project that I really enjoy using and rely on. | | I have most devices connected to an old wireless router that | is completely disconnected from the internet. The raspberry | pi is connected to my main network through ethernet and is | connected to my "smart network" over wifi. I like to think of | the HA instance as a two way mirror since it can reach the | internet and see the devices but the devices themselves can't | phone home or access the internet in anyway. | | For bulbs, light switches, and smart plugs I generally stick | with TP-Link Kasa. The local API works great with HA though I | believe they are removing this in future firmware updates | [0]. This appears to be for the UK only but I'm not 100% sure | on that. I purchased a plug a few months ago that still | works. | | My thermostat is a Venstar color touch with the local API. I | have it connected to the internet but I could disconnect it | and everything would still work how I want. | | You can flash Wyze v2 cameras with the official RTSP firmware | to view them locally. You lose some of the features of the | Wyze cams but I think this is a fine trade off. While this | works with the Pi, streaming video taxes it a lot. It isn't a | perfect experience by any means. | | I also use Zigbee devices instead of Z-Wave (no real reason | other than the first device I wanted was Zigbee). I have a | Sonoff Zigbee bridge flashed with Tasmota that allows me to | use any compliant (or quasi compliant in the case of Xiaomi | Aqara) plug, motion sensor, temp sensor, etc across brands. | The Zigbee bridge is also has access to the internet because | it needs to connect to an NTP server. This means that these | devices work fine when the internet goes out but if for some | reason the hub gets power cycled while having an internet | outage they stop working. | | You can get Zigbee antennas that connect directly to the Pi | but I avoided this because the USB ports can cause | interference. You can fix this by getting a USB cable | extender. | | Feel free to ask any other questions about my setup. | | [0] https://alerts.home-assistant.io/#tplink.markdown | Macha wrote: | They've also been pretty hostile to OS packagers trying to let | you run it without dedicating an entire device to it, most | publicly NixOS but they indicated they planned to insist the | same against Fedora and Gentoo too: | https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/pull/126326 | | That behaviour kind of makes it hard to trust that it won't | lead to the next Marak situation. | asveikau wrote: | I run it in a VM and don't mind it; it's got the updater, it | feels pretty self contained. | | I even do USB passthrough to give it access to my z-wave | stick. | bmicraft wrote: | I've been running homeassistant installed by pip3 for years | now (before they even had a os) and that has always worked | fine. | kkielhofner wrote: | For what it's worth frenck does not represent Home Assistant | and the first sentence of his profile is "Slightly assholic | at first sight"... | | That said you have a point but in my usage of Home Assistant | almost since birth when it was a single pip install command I | can tell you the sheer functionality, integrations, etc make | getting it fully running a nightmare. Not to mention from | their perspective actually supporting it almost impossible. | Maybe this speaks to a wider problem but I'm very happy to | install it with docker on the distro and hardware of my | choice and have everything more-or-less just work. | | I referenced the operating system approach here because it's | the quickest and easiest path to get up and running on a | Raspberry Pi and therefore relevant to the article. | bpye wrote: | This kind of pushed me away from HA. I've ended up using | integrations built using hc [0] to bridge devices to HomeKit, | either existing or ones I've built, and then using Promtheus | to collect metrics. It's not something that 'just works', but | I feel much happier with how it works than HA. | | [0] - https://github.com/brutella/hc | billfor wrote: | If you don't have any need for bleeding edge devices, Openhab | still works on a rpi4 as an alternative to HA. I like that I | can just install it as an apt package onto an existing rpi with | other things and java just does its stuff, rather than | dedicating the entire rpi4 to it or running in a container. | scottlamb wrote: | > I like that I can just install it as an apt package onto an | existing rpi with other things and java just does its stuff, | rather than dedicating the entire rpi4 to it or running in a | container. | | If you try Home Assistant again, you'll probably like Home | Assistant Core. No separate OS or container needed, just a | Python virtual environment. That's how I have it installed. I | have to do the updates and backups manually (rather than it | self-updating automatically / through the UI) but I find that | preferable to dealing with an extra machine, VM, or | container. | mr_person wrote: | +1 for OpenHab. I have tried HA several times, but always | cone back to OH for its super simple ui and app layout | editors. Apt install is also nice. | | Also, plugging in a half-decent zigbee controller usb dongle | and receive native zigbee controls in the system, no need for | a bridge like mqtt | wyager wrote: | I had a terrible experience with Home Assistant. Slow, buggy, | unreasonably difficult to implement non-trivial automations. | | My heuristic since then has been to minimize the amount of | node.js in my home automation codebase and this has worked | wonders for its reliability and usability; currently the only | component I still have that's node-based is zigbee2mqtt, which | (possibly not) incidentally gives me more issues than any other | component. | | The best approach I've found has been to have (in isolated | jails/containers) zigbee2mqtt dealing with zigbee network stuff | (you must use CC2652 based coordinators and routers for any | kind of reliability), mosquitto acting as an MQTT broker, and a | custom program (write it in whatever you like) talking to | mosquitto, with Pushover for push notifications. | bonzini wrote: | I do the same for the automation part | (mosquitto+zigbee2mqtt+custom scripts), but I do have Home | Assistant for GUI and logging. For example I have a card in | Home Assistant that shows whether any system at home doesn't | ping. | | Here is an example of an automation script, turning a zigbee | plug on/off depending on solar roof output: https://gist.gith | ubusercontent.com/bonzini/c705bdd47fd5cd16a... | kkielhofner wrote: | I'm not understanding how node.js relates to Home Assistant | (written in python)? | late_groomer wrote: | Home Assistant has been nothing short of amazing. I started out | just wanting to control my Christmas lights back in early | December; tried going the HomeKit with HomeBridge route, only | to realize I needed an iHub or some other (i) device on my | network to have it work remotely. It was a bad experience even | while on my network, luckily stumbled upon Home Assistant | looking for better options a week or so into the journey. Now | I'm controlling everything, even watching my security cameras, | through HA. | | The one caveat in my experience has been trying to run Pi-Hole | on the same server as HA Supervised or using Adguard Home. | Trying to run HA and PiH, even though they were both in docker | containers, caused the Pi 3B+ to freeze every few hours. HA | makes it clear running anything else is a bad idea, and that | proved correct. I deleted PiH and tried the Adguard Home addon | for my DNS for awhile, it was really slick and had a lot of | features, but I found myself missing the PiH for several | reasons. For one, it really sucked to be tinkering with HA | while other people on the network were on the web; every time I | needed to restart HA (which was often setting up the cameras), | I'd get constant groaning and moaning about the internet being | out. I also found it harder to control white/black lists; | adding individual sites here and there was not as simple as it | is in PiH. It also lacked the simple "disable for X | minutes/seconds" feature I used so much. | | I ended up installing just PiH on the Pi 3B+ and grabbing a | cheap Chromebox off ebay to run HA. All the things I was doing | on HA really pushed the Pi at times and I read one too many | stories about SD cards dying from heavy use. Now everything is | zippy and I feel _safer_ with HA installed on the internal M.2 | SSD. | jrm4 wrote: | I'm curious about other people's experiences with this stuff, | especially if you're someone who likes simple scripting and found | Home Assistant to be too clunky. | | Basically, I've bought a lot of these little devices, and am much | more interested in doing this in a more "Unix Way" way; give me | text streams/web APIs and let me figure it out. I think there are | things like Huginn and there's a like a Perl one or something? | | Frankly, I'd really like to do it in Bash or similar? Anyone gone | their own way like this? | | (I end up not getting far because the use cases aren't compelling | enough for me to put the time in? I don't know.) | rustyminnow wrote: | You can do both! I run HA for the web gui, but I have a few | shell scripts for more automated things. Actually, now that I'm | looking at them, they call to an HA api to make changes. So you | could run HA to provide a web API for things and script around | that? | piceas wrote: | I did. I haven't sorted out proper ventilation for my laundry | room yet. Using a pi zero with a dht22 to control a | dehumidifier via a tradfri power switch when needed was quick, | fun, functional, and offline with no vms or GUIs needed. | | Logging the data elsewhere to influxdb was a fun little | addition for a few pretty graphs. | | I'm a fan of nats.io but it isn't necessary. A private network | via zerotier makes life easy but is also completely optional. | djanogo wrote: | Better yet, run your home on Dell/HP micro computers that get | decommissioned by enterprises/hospitals/big-orgs every 3 years. | Find them on Offerup or FB or Craigslist market place for | $100-$200. | | These are built solid with metal enclosures, fan cooled, UL | certified PSU, ~7k CPUbenchmark.net. Usually i5 6thGen Intel CPU, | 8GB-16GB RAM and have REAL storage(SSD) and M.2 NVMe. If you are | lucky you might find vPro version with remote management. | | Currently running a HP G2 bought on Offerup for $70 with | i5-6600T, 16GB RAM, 256GB SSD running Ubuntu server with | HomeAssistant VM and few containers. It idles at 7w, with <2% CPU | for my work load. | | I tried Raspberry Pi with HomeAssistant with it's piss poor | antique storage solution, it idled at 5W, it went straight back | to store. | Fiahil wrote: | > [...] Currently running a HP G2 [...] | | Great, except it's fucking huge and noisy. | | I'm running a kubernetes cluster on a pair of raspberry pi and | a 4-bay NAS as storage. What kind of lunatic would store data | on a single, non-redondant, disk or an SD card ? | bduerst wrote: | Pi's don't have SATA or PCI - what's the I/O of the drives? | Is it noticeable? | 29083011397778 wrote: | Perhaps late, but I'm using PXE to boot and run my pihole | at home. Works quite well IMO | djanogo wrote: | It's the twice the size of Pi with case, not sure what's | "massive" about it. | rnestler wrote: | I currently run a home server on a librem laptop where I broke | the lid and can't be opened anymore without breaking it further | (I tried to repair it, but since some parts broke mechanically | I couldn't really fix it) | | Works kinda nice and is completely silent most of the time. | mindslight wrote: | WHAT STORE DID YOU BRING THE PI TO? IS IT STILL THERE? | | I'll second the recommendation for real PC hardware. Tinkering | is fun up until it's not. When it becomes not fun is when | something breaks, takes down a system you have come to rely on, | and now it becomes _work_ to recreate the functionality you | used to take for granted. Seeing people go for the RPi for | something they 're going to put a lot of hours into makes me | cringe a bit, having had several SD card filesystems get | corrupt. If that's what it takes to get you started with self | hosting, by all means go for it. But there is much nicer | hardware for running servers on. | | Having said that, I still use RPis for edge devices and the | like. | | PS I really like that idle power figure on your server. I wish | there were a list of power consumption figures for integrated | hardware, it seems quite hit or miss. | spookthesunset wrote: | You can fix that SD problem by booting off a USB SSD instead. | Much faster and more reliable. | mindslight wrote: | I want to use a Pi4 8GB as an arm64 build host so I'm going | the USB SSD route there. But adding on additional hardware | ultimately seems like the "stone soup" | (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stone_Soup) version of | setting up a server. | | Furthermore I'm hesitant to rely too much on the arm | ecosystem in general. If one pops a drive with a Linux | installation into any amd64 machine, it straightforwardly | boots. Whereas just making an arm device boot can be its | own tinkering session of figuring out its own bespoke | partitioning scheme, firmware files, and U-boot image. Many | times you're stuck using a non-mainline kernel since that's | what the embedded developers hacked on to get something | running. Devicetree compiler what? And sure, using a | purpose-built distro can hide much of the complexity, until | that distro decides your device is too old and drops | support. | | Heck, I've even moved my wifi AP's over to low power amd64 | machines instead of the popular answer of OpenWRT/DD-WRT. | When I want to upgrade to a new wifi standard, I'll just | pop in a new wireless card. The same machines also run Kodi | for the TVs (which used to be separate RPis). | spookthesunset wrote: | That is not a half bad idea. How loud are those things? | zrail wrote: | When my G3 (newer version of parent's machine) is booting up | all of the VMs it's running it can get kind of noisy but it | settles down quickly to basically silent. | some-guy wrote: | I have an SFF Dell Optiplex I bought for $100 many years ago | that's still my main "homelab" machine. It's fairly quiet | besides the two 12TB spinning hard drives inside but the fan | isn't noticing. | | A rack mount server would be out of the question as I live in | a small condo, both for size and noise. | djanogo wrote: | Barely audible, you have to have your ear <1ft from it to | hear the hum. | rubatuga wrote: | Same for my HP Z230. Literally have to be within a foot or | two to hear it. | afavour wrote: | I did that too but those PCs are just stupidly massive for the | purpose. Raspberry Pi 4s don't require SD cards any more so the | storage issue is moot. My RPi sits next to my router now, you | wouldn't even know it's there unless you looked closely. | nomel wrote: | > My RPi sits next to my router now | | Some brave souls have installed Home Assistant on their | routers: https://www.snbforums.com/threads/home-assistant- | entware-gt-... | djanogo wrote: | Did you read the part which says "micro", these are about | 2-3x the size of Pi with those cheap plastic cases. I had | mine beside the router before I moved it inside TV console. | | Pi will be single purpose device, the "micro" can be full | blown server and comes with ALL parts required, no need to | hunt for good PSU, case, cooling, storage. Some of them come | with 1 Sata and 2x M.2 NVMe, so you can literally pass those | NVMe to TrueNAS in proxmox and run full blown NAS with | encryption/encoding/decoding in VM. | KolenCh wrote: | May be you mean 2-3x in every linear dimension but that | still seem to be smaller than those in my mind. (While Mac | mini is not known to be the smallest, it definitely exceeds | 2-3x in some linear dimension already.) What kind you have | in mind? | rubatuga wrote: | Using my HP Z230 with 16GB ECC RAM, multiple VMs, 2 NVMe SSDs, | and 2x3TB HDD. | justin66 wrote: | > fan cooled | | As if that is a benefit. | | Putting a server in a corner of my home and forgetting about it | is an application where I want the machine to be powerful | enough to work without active cooling, as small as possible, | and with no moving parts. None of these constraints is | difficult to accomodate in this day and age. | djanogo wrote: | Ya it's possible to build a fanless system, but Apple or any | OEM with those parts is not going to sell you that system | <$100. Not with out of the box compatibility with every x86 | software out there. | | The fan ramps based on usage, as I said, Ubuntu server with | HASS OS, VS Code Server, Netdata monitoring, NodeRed, Sonos | Airplay, InfluxDB and few other containers, it's barely gets | to 2% CPU usage and CPU temp at 25C. | | Look at Pi, they have been at it for SO many years and that | shit is slow with no real storage interface, they are only | faster compared to their own previous generation. | justin66 wrote: | > and that shit is slow with no real storage interface | | We were talking about using it for a home automation | system, which is just a very low traffic web server with | some odds and ends. We are not talking about competing in | the TOP500 or something. It's _easily_ doable with a newer | Pi. | YaBomm wrote: | zrail wrote: | I just migrated all of my "production" home things to an HP | Elitedesk 800 G3. It's great! Maxed out the ram and threw a 1TB | SSD in. I'm using Proxmox and have: | | * home assistant VM | | * pi-hole primary LXC | | * UniFi controller LXC | | * media stack LXC (jellyfin is installed directly on the host | to minimize hardware transcoding issues) | | * a VM running various docker containers with dokku, including | AppDaemon | | It's barely ticking over most of the time and using very little | energy. | | We use zwave devices around the house and due to issues making | zwave complex (RF + brick = bad, plus it's a very long house), | I actually have a handful of Raspberry Pis with zwave sticks | running zwavejs2mqtt scattered around. Yesterday I decided that | I'm tired of dealing with the rPi-zero-W being so slow so I | ordered a bunch of Dell Wyse 3040 thin clients off of eBay to | replace them. Still trying to decide how I'm going to run them | but probably it'll look something like Alpine diskless running | docker and zwavejs2mqtt in a container. | djanogo wrote: | Cool, and your elitedesk I believe comes with remote BIOS | access with Intel vPro, that's even cooler, never have to | plugin display. | amanzi wrote: | I have three Dell Optiplex micro PCs with vPro running | Proxmox. It's so nice having full remote access to them, | makes life so much easier. | zrail wrote: | Yeah. I haven't set that up yet after getting Proxmox up | and running, but it's something that I should probably work | on. | | I've had such a good experience with this one that I keep | trying to figure out if I can replace my Dell T20 minitower | router running VyOS with one. The blocker is that the Dell | actually has standard PCIe slots, whereas if I were to use | a USFF I'd have to either go way up market to something | like a Lenovo M920Q or accept USB ethernet adapters. | bpye wrote: | I'm still running an 8th gen HP micro server, but I would run | something else if I could get >=8GB memory and 4 SATA ports for | relatively cheap. I haven't seen anything that gets me there | yet though. | djanogo wrote: | Nope, no OEM wants to make that, not enough market for it. | However you can buy NVMe to 6xSATA adapter, but your case | might not fit those drives, | | I planned on buying NVMe extension cable, cut a slit in case, | run the cable outsidde, plug in NVMe to 6xSATA adapter | outside of the case and keep the SSD's outside, this would | need reliable external power supply for SSD (Amazon sells | them for ~$30, but I don't trust them). | | I believe you will get to ~10-15w with this setup, at which | rate you could build regular ITX/MATX case to hold all SSD's | with i3-10100 and be at ~16w idle. | hedora wrote: | It sounds like you want a Synology, at least hardware-wise. | This one supports up to 6 GB of RAM, four SATA ports, and | idles with low wattage and low noise. | | Built-in virtualization and docker. It's $500 at Newegg. | | https://www.synology.com/en-us/products/DS420+#specs | | They make bigger ones, of course. | wyager wrote: | I've been doing a bunch of home automation work recently. Here | are some observations I've made: | | 1. Most extant home automation software is totally unreliable | garbage. Buggy, slow, poorly designed. You want to reduce the | amount of code you pull in as much as possible. | | 2. Raspberry pis are totally unreliable garbage. The hardware is | just bad. There's no way to make them reliably operate for long | periods of time without crashing, and there's no way to make them | automatically recover from a crash (because the watchdog timer, | or its driver, in the crappy broadcom chips they use is broken). | | 3. Most of this home automation software is optimized for users | who don't know how to code at all, and is extremely poorly | optimized for people who can write basic scripts or whatever. | | 4. Most of the radio protocols for wireless IoT devices are | totally unreliable garbage. | | After messing around with this on and off for a few years, the | best setup I've found is: | | 1. Use a normal computer or server, not a raspberry pi. It | doesn't need to be expensive or anything; just use a decent | machine with an x86 processor. There are tons of great industrial | PCs for cheap on ebay. | | 2. Use some kind of containerization setup for separating | components. I strongly recommend using jails on FreeBSD, since | you can treat jails as physically separate machines for | networking/firewalling purposes (using vnets). | | 3. Make liberal use of VLANs to isolate IoT things from the | internet and from each other. | | 4. Don't use any IoT devices that operate over WiFi. Ethernet is | great, and dedicated wireless protocols (zigbee, z-wave, etc.) | can be OK with a bunch of work. | | 5. If you want non-trivial automations, don't try to use some | existing "user-friendly" or "low-code" or whatever home | automation software. Just write a normal computer program that | does the automations. | | The specific stack I have for most of my automations in my | current house is zigbee2mqtt running in one jail (this is by far | the most problematic component), mosquitto running in another, | and then my program which does the automations running in a | third. My program can also do things like send me push messages | via pushover. | | I've managed to get a seemingly stable zigbee network with a not- | totally-trivial number of devices (around 25 now) by using CC2652 | radios and plenty of zigbee routers, and also turning off all | lightbulbs before adding more devices to the network. | | It's a shit show, and I can't really recommend getting into it | right now unless you _want_ to spend a bunch of time doing | sysadmin tasks, or you only want very simple automations (in | which case maybe use HomeKit or something). | rcarmo wrote: | I would like to challenge that assertion that Pis are garbage. | If you use a recent hardware revision you should not have any | issues, mine have outlasted the ODROID I had running homebridge | for a few years off an EMMC. | | Also, I git push my automation services to a server using | https://github.com/piku, which isolates them in (simple) | sandboxes. Zero issues for a long time now, and with Docker | pull restrictions coming up soon, I can certainly put up with | npm taking a while to update Node-RED... | zrail wrote: | I agree with all of your recommendations. I use Home Assistant | running in a VM on a normal machine as a sensor fusion platform | and for dashboards. Every non-trivial thing is then an | AppDaemon[1] app running in a separate VM on the same machine. | I have zwave devices rather than zignee so I use zwavejs2mqtt | on raspberry pi's in various locations around the house (soon | to be replaced with tiny Atom machines). | sleepingadmin wrote: | An upcoming project of mine is to setup magic mirror: | https://magicmirror.builders/ | | Then start moving my other stuff onto the rpi as well like pihole | for example. | | I wonder if RPI has a zigbee module or similar for automation. It | doesn't seem like it? Anyone ever find anything like that? | atsmyles wrote: | Jeff has it covered (It's coming soon): | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gJFsZL5CTgM | jvlier wrote: | Take a look at Zigbee2MQTT. Works on Pi with Zigbee USB sticks. | Integrates with Home Assistant. | Donckele wrote: | I have the ARP1600 board which has an xbee slot plus a bunch of | other useful stuff. | | https://www.waveshare.com/arpi600.htm | sirtaj wrote: | You can use a USB module, or wifi-zigbee bridge devices from | vendors like Sonoff are also supported. | cryo wrote: | Beside several USB dongle options there is the RaspBee II | module for the io header https://phoscon.de/en/raspbee2 | klft wrote: | The Book "Control Your Home with Raspberry Pi" by Koen Vervloesem | is excellent imho. His approach centers around mqtt and he shows | how to connect ZigBee, Z-Wave, Bluetooth and 433.92 MHz devices. | He is very into security, showing how all communication is | secured via TLS. He also shows how to setup VPN so you can access | your home automation system securely from outside. | krnlpnc wrote: | I find running my home servers on USFF x86_64 systems to be much | more reliable. You can find them used for the same price as a | kitted out raspberry pi, and they are faster, have more ram, and | more durable disks. | | I like USFF because it's essentially laptop components in a mini | desktop case. With power saving features turned on (currently I | force all power saving features on using powertop) they don't use | many watts. | | I don't rely on raspberry pi for anything that needs to run 24x7 | because of sd card wear and the hassle of downtime and | replacing/reflashing/reconfiguring a new card causes. | justin66 wrote: | > I don't rely on raspberry pi for anything that needs to run | 24x7 because of sd card wear and the hassle of downtime and | replacing/reflashing/reconfiguring a new card causes. | | One can always use an SSD. They work great. | krnlpnc wrote: | Indeed, my USFF has an m.2 :) ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-02-02 23:00 UTC)