[HN Gopher] Trapped in Silicon Valley's hidden caste system ___________________________________________________________________ Trapped in Silicon Valley's hidden caste system Author : Brajeshwar Score : 113 points Date : 2022-03-01 15:12 UTC (7 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.wired.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.wired.com) | vmception wrote: | One day it occurred to me that I can tell if someone is from | India, but that I'd never considered to notice more nuances than | that, for such a big country with so many groups of people. | | I have just begun to notice, but I have no idea about the | identity politics. I recall in college that some of my friends | from India would fawn over certain last names, and I felt it was | something to do with the caste system, but I had concluded that | the people I was around in Universities and in the workforce were | mostly from a level of privilege that it wouldn't be possible to | learn more. I always found Indian nationalism to be strange, | where so many people would interject that everything is perfect. | Makes it easier for me to avoid my own US nationalism, because it | must be just as comical to others. | | In this article it mentions Dalit. How many people from that | group would be in Silicon Valley, is it impossible to know since | it is insensitive to ask and disastrous for them if people did | know? | | Seems like there is a potential for solidarity amongst more vocal | groups pushing for representation. | [deleted] | dang wrote: | Past related threads. I think there have been others. | | _How Big Tech Is Importing India's Caste Legacy to Silicon | Valley_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26435117 - March | 2021 (195 comments) | | _Caste discrimination in some of Silicon Valley 's richest tech | companies_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24952698 - Oct | 2020 (322 comments) | | _How India 's ancient caste system is ruining lives in Silicon | Valley_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24555492 - Sept | 2020 (47 comments) | | _Over 90% of Indian techies in the US are upper-caste Indians_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24552047 - Sept 2020 (613 | comments) | | _Silicon Valley Has a Caste Discrimination Problem_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24065132 - Aug 2020 (14 | comments) | | _California sues Cisco alleging discrimination based on India's | caste system_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23798922 - | July 2020 (56 comments) | | _California accuses Cisco of job discrimination based on Indian | employee 's caste_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23697083 - July 2020 (592 | comments) | bishamsingh wrote: | birdyrooster wrote: | A bit off topic but, separate from Indian culture, the United | States has a hidden caste system too that flows from antiquity | and is given texture through American slavery. If your family was | a slave or you look like a slave you are, unconscious in the | minds of most, systemically bottom caste here. | | Sorry if it is an unsatisfying critique of America but its | obvious. Go look at the wealth data, look who is thriving and has | net worth or success in business. | gerdesj wrote: | This is waaaay off topic. | | Carry down that line of thought and you might fall into all | sorts of nonsense. Note things like Pope Gregory (n?) saw a | pair of slaves in a market in Rome in the n00s. These two were | picked up from somewhere that would eventually become part of | England/GB. He was told they were Angles. The story goes he | quipped that they were "surely Angels" due to their physique | and long blonde hair. Part of England is known as Anglia still | and of course England itself is "Angleland". | | It seems a bit odd that, that anecdote and play on words | survives a good 1500 years during which time English has gone | through three major stages (old/middle/modern). However you can | easily posit from that story that Britons were also enslaved, | if you very carefully define "Briton"! | | Anyway, my point is that you can't really use terms like | american slavery. History can't be stuffed into boxes like that | with pejorative terms scattered like confetti. | | The caste system being discussed here is nominally an indian | sub continent thing and way older in origin than the slavery | employed around C17th onwards with the horrendous triangle of | trade. | birdyrooster wrote: | Yes off topic, and I edited my comment to reflect this. | American slavery is a distinct type of slavery because of the | geography and people involved. That is all I was saying. | johntiger1 wrote: | from my understanding, the caste system is thousands of years | old (in fact one of the reason islam was welcomed and later | sikh religion developed). are you sure that american slavery | was the origin? | vmception wrote: | They are talking about the US distinctly. The US caste | system, which has morphed primarily into a class system as | the laws no longer explicitly single groups out, despite the | correlations of effects that remain. | Sebguer wrote: | They're not implying that the Indian caste system originated | in American slavery, they're stating that America also has a | caste system. | gerdesj wrote: | Perhaps class system is a better term. The terms nearly | mean the same thing but not quite. I think the caste system | is closer in origin to the societal structure in the feudal | system that was common in medieval Europe, than the modern | class system. | [deleted] | pinephoneguy wrote: | Has vs had. I suppose you could say the races that were former | slaves are now given an artificial advantage but I wouldn't go | so far as to call it a caste system. | simmanian wrote: | I am not from India but I would like to be connected to these | groups. Any idea how I can reach out? | | edit: I guess this is as good as it gets | https://ambedkarinternationalcenter.org/join-the-mission/aic... | rhapsodic wrote: | yrgulation wrote: | The caste system is so deeply entrenched in the culture of those | abused by it that even centuries after leaving india they cant | leave it behind. | | Romania has a considerable group of such people. The Gipsy (also | know as Romani) are an Indian people that are thought to have | been part of a caste and fled India hundreds of years ago. To | this day they cant lift themselves up, and frankly the government | of Romania is not doing much at all. To call it an injustice it | would he an understatement. | zxienin wrote: | I am from "upper caste". My experience might not be commonly | heard perspective. In 10th grade of schooling, my parents changed | my lastname to avoid that folks figure out the caste. Due to | affirmative action (aka reservation) on steroids, upper caste | were losing opportunities. My parents wanted to avoid that I lose | out on selection, promotions.., where subjective discretion was | involved. | | I do not recall ever seeing casteism at workplace. So reading | these reports have been surprising to me, since these are not | subtle, but rampant. I can only attribute it to my privilege | driven echo chamber. Or the fact that I never worked in US. (only | briefly in India). | | What I read in media disgusts me. I am very motivated to make | sure nothing like this happens in my zone of control / influence, | at work. | | I know casteism is deeply rooted in Indian society. I do not | relate with it. Many folks I know, don't either. On optimistic | side, I hope that means with newer generations, casteism will | dilute and wither away. | johntiger1 wrote: | as a complete outsider to the caste system, say i was american- | born or otherwise "white-washed". would I still be subject to | this system? | sparky_ wrote: | Fellow outsider here. Got curious and did some searching; would | love to hear from some real Indian folks to confirm or deny | this line of reasoning. | | As non-Indians, it seems we exist outside the system, which | could be ambiguously interpreted to either have no connotation | at all, or to exist at the bottom of the social strata. [1] | | Anecdotally, the kind of treatment you'll get in practice | depends a lot more on your race and national origin. [2] | | 1: https://hinduism.stackexchange.com/questions/3898/what- | caste... 2: https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/let-s- | talk-about-r... | akvadrako wrote: | So, assuming there is a hierarchy and Indian are not better | than all other races, it seems the conclusion must be all | societies have some kind of caste system, it's just we don't | see it since we don't look for that sort of thing? | UltraViolence wrote: | It took hundreds of years for the tribal system to become fully | abolished in North-Western Europe and I suspect it will take a | similar amount of time before the caste system is eradicated. | throwaway_dcnt wrote: | The reason for my current user name here at hn was this exact | form of racism. It is the first post I made when I created this | throwaway. I was assured that my experience was unique and not | widespread. I am both sad and happy to see this, sad because it | exists, happy because it is getting some attention here at HN. | | I would like to take this opportunity to point out that everyone | of us needs to be vigilant about this type of racism. One thing I | recommend to my hiring managers is to not allow people from | frictioned backgrounds to manage and interview people from the | other side. Example problematic pairs for candidates/interviewers | (not including the cast situation) include: Indians and | Pakistanis, Serbians and Bosnians, Greeks and Turks, Chinese and | Japanese. | | One way I solve this is by introducing an independent | observer/participant when situations like this emerge. This is | costly but it has really worked to not only address this problem | but also created an amazing diversity in my teams because it | takes care of some of the implicit bias we all have to some | degree. | winterplace wrote: | Is there a way to privately message you? | aletzo wrote: | I'm sorry, but can you please elaborate a bit more on Greeks | and Turks? | | I happen to be Greek and have worked with 2 Turkish colleagues | without any issues. On top of that, during my many travels | across Europe, Turks (along with other Balkan nationalities) | are by far the most welcoming people I meet once they learn | that I come from Greece and I befriended a few of them. | | Do you have any different experiences to share? | User23 wrote: | I'm under the impression some people are still upset over | Cypress. | franklampard wrote: | > Chinese and Japanese | | When I interviewed last time; the only company i did not make | through phone screen was by a Japanese interviewer. I gave a | three viable solutions to an easy question. Had no idea why I | failed but probably because of racism | simmanian wrote: | It's definitely possible that there were other factors in | play. I hope you see the danger or irony of automatically | assuming that the Japanese interviewer rejected you because | of their racial bias. | jewayne wrote: | I hope you see the danger or irony of stigmatizing the | discussion of bias. | avalys wrote: | The solution you propose is arguably just as bad and I suspect | it might be illegal in the US. If I am a qualified manager or | tech lead, and there is an opportunity to lead a new project, I | would be furious to learn that I was passed over for the | opportunity because someone believed I was ethnically | incompatible with one of the people on the team. | rednerrus wrote: | The comment was about not allowing them in the interviewing | process. | avalys wrote: | ...it says "manage and interview"? | oh_sigh wrote: | If interviewing is considered a normal job function, isn't | not allowing certain people to interview certain people a | violation of EEO laws by discriminating based on a | protected class(national origin)? Unless you have some | specific knowledge that an employee just can't handle | people of nationality X, I would be very hesitant to | institute OP's advice, at least in the US. | [deleted] | bob66 wrote: | txcan wrote: | Only to be bogged down by a level higher "country-of-birth" based | discrimination system for GreenCards in the US. | pinephoneguy wrote: | Countries have borders, we invest a lot of money in our | children and people and would like a return on that investment. | In order for that to be possible we have to reject the people | who would abuse the system. | hemantv wrote: | This is all made up, news article created to make you angry. | Click bait. | | I have been in valley for 9 years. Never experienced any of it. | | Does Indian have higher standards for other Indian sure, but it's | never about caste. | pinephoneguy wrote: | Having different standards for different races (especially your | own race) is racist. | jonny_eh wrote: | Nobody in America has ever been racist to me, therefore racism | doesn't exist. | mdns33 wrote: | zozbot234 wrote: | It's so disappointing to see in the article that caste | discrimination is still being blamed by some on the religion of | Hinduism. There's no dharmic status whatsoever for "caste" in the | commonplace sense. The Vedas occasionally talk about something | that gets misinterpreted as caste, but it's very clear from the | texts that they're talking about individual callings and | aptitudes, and not any sort of immutable status. The latter were | merely a historically contingent development within Indian | society, very similar to those that were leading towards | feudalism and serfdom in the West. | simmanian wrote: | I think it's fair to say that the caste system is greatly | influenced by the flavor of reincarnation in hinduism. the | buddha himself set out to seek enlightenment and free himself | from suffering when he saw that so many people from the lower | castes are suffering. it eventually led him to reject hinduism | and teach that nobody suffers in this life because of something | that happened in "past" lives (in fact, he almost categorically | rejected reincarnation as a process where individuals are born | again and again, something many buddhists today do not | understand), that everyone can attain true freedom and | happiness. I assume this teaching is why Ambedkar came to | reject hinduism and embrace buddhism as shown in the article. | fdgsdfogijq wrote: | In a well known big tech company (FAANG), I have seen many many | examples of a whole layer of management from the same caste. So | like under one director, every senior manager will have been from | the same part of India. Sometimes this will extend to another | layer of managers below them. Behind the scenes, there is a | strong communication network that is often not caught or shown in | org charts. This will include high ranking engineers and managers | from sister organizations. | | It usually doesnt extend beyond that, since HR will be all over | it. Often they will even go out of their way not to hire Indians | as their directs, so as to deny any discrimination based hiring. | But its rampant. | Bhilai wrote: | Let me guess, its Amazon? | nraynaud wrote: | I can't imagine the crazy headache for management, like are you | going to ask your Indian teamates their cast when you suspect | there is foul play in the team? | rootusrootus wrote: | In my experience, the answer is always some form of "there are | no castes any more." They know that most non-Indians lack the | ability to prove otherwise, we can't even detect it. | jmyeet wrote: | It's crazy to me to see people saying "this doesn't exist because | I've never seen it". Here's a good rule to live by: privilege is | invisible to those who have it. Just think about that. | | I'm not Indian so can't speak to that experience but | discrimination masquerading as "culture fit" is just as rampant | in Silicon Valley as it is in the rest of the US. This includes | racism, ageism, misogyny and classism. If you don't think | MIT/Stanford grads in their mid 20s at Big Tech companies have | more doors open to them you're crazy. | | There is a tendency in the West to view all minorities as somehow | being the same. Like all Africans are somehow viewed the same in | many ways despite their being significant cultural, religious and | language differences that go back centuries. The same is true in | Asia (eg a lot of Chinese in Malaysia face significant | discrimination such that they end up going to university overseas | because they can't locally). | | So a deeply ingrained caste system like India's I can totally | believe doesn't magically disappear because those raised in that | system now happen to live and work in the United States. | belval wrote: | To Indian commenters on HN, how much of that is true? Do you feel | threatened when a coworker asks about where you are from? It's | something I do ask from time to time (not during interviews | obviously, but during lunch for example) out of pure curiosity. | Should I stop? | | I guess that I should explicitly add that I am not from India. | Cross-cultural communications can be a bit difficult at times and | I'd rather not make blunders like that. | cscurmudgeon wrote: | A lot of it is FUD. | | California withdrew it's Cisco case but you wont' see any | coverage of that here. | | https://thewire.in/caste/california-drops-caste-discriminati... | | I am from India and have been in the US for more than a decade. | | I come from a low caste. The only folks who have asked about my | caste and asked if I am from a higher caste are white Americans | due to my vegetarianism (voluntary for ethical reasons). | | > Do you feel threatened when a coworker asks about where you | are from? | | No, not at all. | | But I did get upset when my PhD advisor (a white American) | wanted to know if I was from the priestly class. | | There is definitely casteism in India, but I have not seen it | in Silicon Valley. | | Casteism is there in India and is unfortunately widespread but | steadily disappearing. India's PM and President are from lower | castes but you won't see coverage of that in Western news. | Bhilai wrote: | Who is spreading the FUD and why? | dhanvantharim1 wrote: | Its possible some of it is true, I know well educated brahmin | acquaintances who have outright said they are superior. I look | like a brahmin person and they tend to let their guard down | around me, But no one has ever asked me about my caste (Maybe | because they assume my caste based on how I look). At the same | time there are lots frivolous lawsuits from the groups | mentioned in this article so its hard to say. | fhrow4484 wrote: | > I look like a brahmin person | | > they assume my caste based on how I look | | I'm curious in this comment, are you dressing up a certain | way that is typical of brahmin, or are there some other | characteristics that makes you look brahmin? | Bhilai wrote: | A lot of stuff mentioned in the article is true. I would even | go ahead (at peril being downvoted by Indian patriots) that | India is a deeply racist country. My parents, educated upper | middle class working folks use to 'educate' me to not get | married outside our caste and such. Caste system is deeply | rooted in India and you can pretty much read about it from lots | of sources online. India has a lot of right provisions (like | the reservation system for SC/ST/OBC akin to affirmative action | type of stuff in US if I am not mistaken) but in a typical | fashion those provisions are either not applied properly or are | abused by people in such categories. India is also a deeply | poor country with a history of systemic racism so its not | surprising some of the beliefs have landed in silicon valley | too. | | > Do you feel threatened when a coworker asks about where you | are from? It's something I do ask from time to time (not during | interviews obviously, but during lunch for example) out of pure | curiosity. Should I stop? | | I think its a fair question. Its not as much about where a | person is from but "what caste they belong to" type of stuff | that might be offensive. | wincy wrote: | Okay so curious, I have a South Indian neighbor who is | Muslim. I assume Muslims are just a different thing outside | of the caste system, despite people saying caste is not | rooted in Hinduism? (I'm not saying it is, just curious how | an Indian might view their Muslim neighbors). | belval wrote: | Seems to exist for Indian muslims as well: https://en.wikip | edia.org/wiki/Caste_system_among_South_Asian... | lisper wrote: | It would never even occur to me to ask someone what caste | they were from, not just in Silicon Valley where I happen to | live, but anywhere in the U.S. Seriously, who does that? | belval wrote: | Someone who doesn't understand that it's taboo and is | curious of a system that existed for 3000 years? I | understand that it's a painful heritage for some but to an | outsider this seems akin to genealogy for example. | [deleted] | samizdette wrote: | I grew up around a lot of Indian people, and I have | definitely had the curiosity to know how to ask, but at the | same time known that it would be taboo. I can only guess | from their wealth or their last names. | AdmiralAsshat wrote: | It actually _does_ occur to me, mostly because I 'm curious | if all of my coworkers are of Brahmin caste. It doesn't | matter to me personally, but obviously it would be of | interest if all of the people in the Managerial or Lead | roles are from a certain caste, while all of the lower- | level Devs are in another. | JoeAltmaier wrote: | Couldn't that be a follow-on effect from a lifetime of | advantages in education and opportunity costs? It's not | necessary to imagine a special Brahmin-loving company | administration. | AdmiralAsshat wrote: | Oh, definitely. It could be neither intentional nor | malicious. But it would still be interesting to know. | User23 wrote: | It's also a general pattern that follows from human | assortative mating. Then add to that inheritance laws and | over the centuries the upper classes can acquire serious | cumulative advantages. Of course it occasionally | backfires, such as in the case of Habsburg inbreeding. | User23 wrote: | I worked at a big tech company where you could, with rare | exceptions, reliably estimate a South Asian employee's | place in the org chart from skin tone. I don't know how | well that correlates to caste, but I imagine it does to | at least some degree. | rajeshp1986 wrote: | I don't find any truth in it at all not especially in Silicon | Valley. These articles are a coerced effort to bring up the | caste divide from India into US and divide the Indian diaspora. | simmanian wrote: | The article mentions there were hundreds of people who joined | a Zoom call to give testimonies. In your view, is the author | exaggerating? | crate_barre wrote: | It could be possible they are projecting the home grown | issue of India onto America. Racism is traumatic, and can | lead to ptsd. If you dealt with it, you will amplify it | wherever you even think it could exist, eg 'I already know | what you think about me' as an internal thought. Imagine if | your whole life you were looked at as X, you will feel like | X even if you are in an environment that may not be doing | this to you. | | Severe defensiveness. Not trying to undermine testimony, | but life is a spectrum. On the spectrum of all testimonies, | there is without a doubt corroborating testimonies that are | the result of trauma. | | I'll give an example. I'm an alcoholic. There are times my | shame is so great that even in random stores where I go to | buy some beer, I can feel eyes on me as if the whole world | knows I'm an alcoholic. It's an intense feeling of guilt | and shame. Other examples of this are imposter syndrome | arising from being doubted. If you ever been doubted in any | meaningful way, you can palpably feel the doubt on your | skin in new situations - all from past trauma. But in | reality, no one may be doubting you in these new | situations. | 12ian34 wrote: | I'm Indian born with British nationality and I look Indian. It | doesn't bother me if people ask me where I'm from - I am often | curious about where others are from. It does, however, start to | slightly grate if upon me responding with "I'm British", I am | quizzed further with "But... where are you really from?" I hear | this less nowadays, but it used to be common enough to | "slightly grate", particularly from older, Caucasian Brits. Not | everyone that is British/American is also Caucasian. | | I don't think you should stop asking people where they are | from. But perhaps don't interrogate them (we get enough of that | at airports), implying that they're obstructing their true | origin from you. Also, tone matters, whether you like it or | not. Saying "where are you from" can sound genuinely curious, | but it can easily sound disgusted and derogatory. | | On any implied caste system, I can speak for the London tech | startup world in which I've worked for several years. I've | probably had dozens of (South) Asian colleagues and have never | noticed the slightest hint of intra-Asian racism or classism. | pinephoneguy wrote: | Obviously your ancestors aren't British so there's something | to the "where are you really from" question. I've been asked | similar things even as a White American. | 12ian34 wrote: | Sure, but imagine the scenario that you're one of about 5 | non-white people in your entire school life, and the area | you lived in has a similar demographic. You might feel | generally more alienated from society. It might make it | slightly harder to accept/understand your own identity, and | being quizzed about it further (at times when you've | already mentioned your nationality) is unlikely to help. | camtarn wrote: | It has rather different connotations in Britain. | | As far as I understand it from Americans I know, quite a | few people in the US have a fascination with where their, | and others', ancestors came from, so it _could_ be a fairly | innocuous question. Pretty much any American I know would | happily rattle off an answer of 'oh, I'm half Irish, a | quarter French, and a quarter Spanish' or something | similar. | | Here in the UK, even though we're also a nation of | immigrants and invaders throughout history, there is much | more of an attitude of 'people whose ancestors have always | been here' ('British') versus 'immigrants' ('not really | British') - even if the 'immigrants' are from families who | have also been here for generations. | | So yeah. Generally 'but where are you _really_ from? ' | means something a little like 'I don't believe that you're | one of us people who have always been here'. Whether that's | malicious or just naive depends on the person, but I can | imagine it gets pretty tiring. | | (I'm the son of a Chinese immigrant, but due to my other | parent being Scottish I pass for white and thus I've never | actually been asked the question!) | User23 wrote: | Ancestry is pretty common small talk for White Americans. | | I like learning more about people and the world so I like | to ask people about where they're from. The immigrants I've | spoken to are proud of their heritage and don't take | offense. I have noticed though that their descendants can | take offense, perhaps because they take it as implying | they're somehow inauthentic. All that's required is a | little delicacy. Instead of asking "where are you really | from" instead ask something like "it sounds like your | family has a really interesting story, would you like to | tell me about it?" ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-03-01 23:00 UTC)