[HN Gopher] Endurance: Shackleton's lost ship is found in Antarctic ___________________________________________________________________ Endurance: Shackleton's lost ship is found in Antarctic Author : 0xedb Score : 227 points Date : 2022-03-09 07:30 UTC (15 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.bbc.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.bbc.com) | pg_bot wrote: | "For scientific discovery give me Scott; for speed and efficiency | of travel give me Amundsen; but when disaster strikes and all | hope is gone, get down on your knees and pray for Shackleton." - | Sir Raymond Priestly, Antarctic Explorer and Geologist. | | For those who don't know about this expedition, NatGeo has a good | video about it on youtube. | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgh_77TtX5I | belter wrote: | It's incredibly well preserved: https://youtu.be/eB7ApbS2P7o | Naga wrote: | This has been an exciting few years for exploration fans, between | the discovery of the Franklin Expedition's ships and this! | aborsy wrote: | The name Endurance is apt, given that it's so well preserved | after over a century! | ygra wrote: | From Wikipedia about the ship: | | > Every detail of her construction had been scrupulously | planned to ensure maximum durability: for example, every joint | and fitting was cross-braced for maximum strength. | | > ... | | > Though her hull looked from the outside like that of any | other vessel of a comparable size, it was not. She was designed | for polar conditions with a very sturdy construction. Her keel | members were four pieces of solid oak, one above the other, | adding up to a thickness of 85 inches (2,200 mm), while its | sides were between 30 inches (760 mm) and 18 inches (460 mm) | thick, with twice as many frames as normal and the frames being | of double thickness. She was built of planks of oak and | Norwegian fir up to 30 inches (760 mm) thick, sheathed in | greenheart, an exceptionally strong and heavy wood. The bow, | which would meet the ice head-on, had been given special | attention. Each timber had been made from a single oak tree | chosen for its shape so that its natural shape followed the | curve of the ship's design. When put together, these pieces had | a thickness of 52 inches (1,300 mm). | | So I guess if you build a ship that way for that purpose, it | probably will survive for quite a while relatively unscathed | (apart from that it has been crushed a bit by the ice). | KarlKemp wrote: | I believe what really matters in cases like this is that wood | doesn't degrade underwater, and that there is very little | movement of water at the spot. | ygra wrote: | Maybe the initial picture most of us have regarding ship | wrecks is ships built from metal, which rust and fall apart | significantly easier when submerged. | DougMellon wrote: | > The wreck itself is a designated monument under the | international Antarctic Treaty and must not be disturbed in any | way. | | Does this prevent them from entering Shackleton's cabin? With the | amazing condition this ship has remained in, I wonder what | interesting things they would find in there. | kitd wrote: | IIRC all the interesting stuff had been removed from the ship | already before it went down. But yes, a peek around inside | would be interesting anyway. | EdwardDiego wrote: | I dunno, I know that people have been preserving relics from | polar expedition huts, Scott's and Shackleton's for example. | | (You can even buy a whisky based on the whisky they found | stashed at Shackleton's Hut): https://nzaht.org/shackletons- | whisky/ | hef19898 wrote: | Apparently some of the gas canisters and canned food from | Scotts expedition are still good, and lying around in the ice | and snow. | cconcepts wrote: | Interesting to me that Shackelton and the Endurance keep popping | up on HN. I happened to read "South" some years ago and it had a | big impact on me as someone who loves the outdoors. | | I just didn't expect it to keep popping up in a technology | focussed community. Yet I can see the appeal. The sheer | determination of Shackelton and crew should be inspiring to all | people. | EdwardDiego wrote: | Shackleton is the polar explorer I respect the most, mainly for | the fact that no-one had to walk heroically to their deaths in a | blizzard on any of his expeditions. | | Even if you think Erebus shouldn't have been there, the efforts | to keep everyone alive get a big thumps up from me. | | (Also, his ponies did way better than Scott's, Scott rejected | what worked for Shackleton: | https://captainantarctica.com.au/meat-eating-horses-of-antar...) | sendfoods wrote: | any books you can recommend on historical polar expeditions? | troyvit wrote: | Another fiction is The Terror: | https://www.librarything.com/work/1499548 | rjsw wrote: | Try "The Worst Journey in the World" [1], there are eBook | links from the wiki page. | | [1] | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Worst_Journey_in_the_World | Bayart wrote: | Although it's a fictional novel, I really like _The | Adventures of Captain Hatteras_. | EdwardDiego wrote: | I've just purchased Ranulph Fiennes' biography of Shackleton | and definitely recommend that one, also I really enjoyed | Endurance by Alfred Lansing, also about Shackleton's | expedition. | | Fiennes' also wrote a good book about Amundsen and Scott, | Race to the Pole. | | I've heard good things about "Mawson's Will" by Lennard | Bickel. | | (I tend to focus on Antarctica due to its proximity and the | historical connections to Antarctic exploration in my area) | eitland wrote: | > Shackleton is the polar explorer I respect the most, mainly | for the fact that no-one had to walk heroically to their deaths | in a blizzard on any of his expeditions. | | Isn't this true for Nansen as well? | hef19898 wrote: | Shackleton is right up there with Nansen and Amundsen. | Zickzack wrote: | Amundsen lost his life trying to help Umberto Nobile and | Nobile's crew. | mellosouls wrote: | For those who can access it, the Channel 4 drama with Kenneth | Branagh is still available for free: | | https://www.channel4.com/programmes/shackleton/on-demand/308... | | https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0272839/ | s_dev wrote: | The Liam Neeson narrated documentary is the best one covering | this story. | | It's on YouTube and well worth a watch on a slow Sunday. | aliswe wrote: | link? | Tronno wrote: | The Endurance (2000): | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kr5r3qV78hI | dang wrote: | Also https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/09/climate/endurance- | wreck-f... | | (via https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30613319, but no | comments there) | [deleted] | iammiles wrote: | For anyone who hasn't read it, Endurance: Shackleton's Incredible | Voyage, by Alfred Lansing is a well-written account of the | expedition story. | telesilla wrote: | Also in Spanish a very lovely, ambitious undertaking in graphic | novel form: | | https://www.luisbustos.es/Endurance | martopix wrote: | I came here to say the same. Wonderful book, historically | accurate but reads like an adventure novel. | davidjohnstone wrote: | I read this a month ago. Excellent book. Incredible story. | nbap wrote: | I second that. | ls65536 wrote: | Two more I would recommend in addition to Lansing's that focus | more on different specific aspects of that expedition are | "Shackleton's Boat Journey" by Frank Worsley (who served as | captain of Endurance) and "Shackleton's Heroes: The Epic Story | of the Men Who Kept the Endurance Expedition Alive" by Wilson | McOrist. | | I think anyone with an interest in sailing or maritime | navigation will appreciate Worsley's first-hand account of the | crossing from Elephant Island to South Georgia in a modified | lifeboat[0]. Worsley covers the subsequent crossing of South | Georgia's mountainous interior in great detail as well. | | And often left out from popular accounts is mention of the Ross | Sea Party[1], who endured terrible conditions on the other side | of the Antarctic continent to ensure that Shackleton and his | crew would have had enough supplies to survive the final | stretches coming from the other side of the continent. | | [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyage_of_the_James_Caird | | [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ross_Sea_party | bacon_waffle wrote: | "Shackleton's Forgotten Men" is a good book on the Ross Sea | Party. I've spent a bit of time on the Ice and done some | Southern Ocean sailing (neither in the same league as these | early explorers, obviously), and think their story is at | least on par with the Endurance side's. | | "Shackleton's Argonauts" by Frank Hurley (photographer of | Endurance) is another good one if you can find a copy. | robin_reala wrote: | There's also _South!_ , an account of his voyage written by the | man himself. It's public domain now: | https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/ernest-shackleton/south | telesilla wrote: | I recommend the 15 hour audio book for long travels | https://naxosaudiobooks.com/south-unabridged/ | sandgiant wrote: | The audiobook edition read by Simon Prebble is one of the best | I've heard. | noufalibrahim wrote: | I'm glad someone mentioned this. It's an excellent narration | of an excellent book. | | I've been reading it to my son. It's got so many lessons on | leadership, grit, foresight, courage etc. Very inspiring. | | One thing that struck me was how sharp a judge of character | Shackleton was. He picked the members of his crew after short | or no interviews and was vindicated in his all his | selections. That must have been a skill learned from time in | the real world. Something which might be scorned on today for | being biased or something else like that. | nerfhammer wrote: | And if you don't have the appetite for a whole book yet, the | wikipedia article on the subject is quite well done | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_Trans-Antarctic_Exped... | raverbashing wrote: | > "Men wanted for hazardous journey. Low wages, bitter cold, | long hours of complete darkness. Safe return doubtful. Honour | and recognition in event of success." | | Well, he wasn't wrong. Reminds me of some job openings. | PedroBatista wrote: | Minus the last phrase. | hef19898 wrote: | It shows that "radical" endeavors and orgs have an easier | way to find the right set of peoples. And I like the total | bluntness of the job offering. | eesmith wrote: | Followed by: "Searches for the original advertisement have | proved unsuccessful, and the story is generally regarded as | apocryphal." | jupp0r wrote: | Maximum age: 25. 10 years of direct polar exploration | experience required, 20 years of direct polar exploration | experience strongly preferred. | ankaAr wrote: | I come from a sailors family (every male in the family served | some years in the Navy, not my uncle, not me -IT Manager). I | remember my grandpha telling me the Endurance story, how | Shackleton keep being THE Captain, saving his people from a | clearly death. | | I still have in my mind the marvelous pictures taken by Frank | Hurley, the night ones are impressive. | | I still have the book from Alfred Lansing, Endurance. It shows | you how hard was the life after the Endurance was trapped in ice, | and how they manage to survive in one of the worst climates. | | Good thing the endurance will be there, protected and resting | from the hard journey. | belorn wrote: | It is pretty amazing how they managed to locate the wreck. | Searching by sonar is a very time consuming activity and takes | ages just to scan a very small area, with the added issues of | interpreting the readings. I wonder what clues they had to narrow | down the search area. | ls65536 wrote: | "Endurance was found just over four nautical miles (7.5km) and | roughly southward of Frank Worsley's famous sinking position | (68deg39'30" South; 52deg26'30" West)." [0] | | Truly a testament to the skill of Frank Worsley, Endurance's | captain, whose navigation was also essential in successfully | reaching South Georgia in a modified lifeboat [1], returning | themselves to civilization and calling for help to rescue the | rest of Shackleton's men waiting on Elephant Island. | | [0] https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-60654016 | | [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyage_of_the_James_Caird ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-03-09 23:00 UTC)