[HN Gopher] Long-term benzodiazepine use causes synapse loss and... ___________________________________________________________________ Long-term benzodiazepine use causes synapse loss and cognitive deficits in mice Author : sternmere Score : 147 points Date : 2022-05-14 20:37 UTC (2 hours ago) (HTM) web link (scitechdaily.com) (TXT) w3m dump (scitechdaily.com) | pizza wrote: | Much of the brain is about error correction of information | transfer, bc two neurons have a typical *less than ten percent* | chance of a message from A reaching B. | | So if I were to put on my speculator's hat for a second, having | something that destroys neural connections at a local scale would | probably be compensated with increased volume of noisy | communication at a global scale. | | And having heard ex-benzo addicts describe the withdrawal as like | having your brain lit on fire, well, that tracks.. | johntfella wrote: | be interesting to study someone, or a mouse I guess with said | damages and doses of ambien for repair | (https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamaneurology/article-abstr...) | foolfoolz wrote: | i think mental health medication has been borderline fraudulent | for over 50 years. the drugs rarely beat placebos. when they work | the methodologies of study are rarely replicated. this is just | hanging some giant exit sign in front of desperate people saying | we can get out out of this mess all the while knowing it's a | gamble. a gamble you're paying with your health and someone else | is winning by taking the money. | | the "mental health movement" ignores this and is mostly lip | service. clean your room. take a walk. | | no one really cares about you but you and learning how to care | for yourself is so hard. i hope we can train people in proper | self care so we don't need to prescribe their life away | andrewinardeer wrote: | > Long-term use of benzodiazepines has been linked to cognitive | | Like, no shit? | ppg677 wrote: | I take a half tablet (10mg) of Xanax every once in awhile. (Maybe | once a month on average). | | It makes me feel so relaxed. | | I knew it was too good to be true. | b0tch7 wrote: | I take 5mg about once a week which I thought was pretty | harmless :( | kayodelycaon wrote: | You're not taking high doses every day, which is what the | article is about. | randomopining wrote: | Was just in Mexico and took them 3-4 days in a row (0.5mg - 2mg) | to sleep after drinking or the next morning. Slept amazing those | few nights. Felt terrible 2 days after the last one, and even now | close to a week later I don't even feel that good. Pretty sure | they are terrible for you. | s5300 wrote: | Thank you for informing us of the fact that you take benzos | with alcohol in your system. | | Self PSA that probably nobody should take your opinions | seriously. | aaaaaaaaaaab wrote: | Benzo after drinking? Jesus... | colechristensen wrote: | That's quite a lot, especially mixed with alcohol. | jimmar wrote: | I took 1 benzodiazepine bill once about 15 years ago and I still | remember the effect--instant total relaxation. I remember | thinking that it felt _too_ good and that it 's something I | shouldn't let myself have again. Hearing about its long term | effects, I feel somewhat lucky. | op00to wrote: | When I am having a bad panic attack and take 1 Ativan, if I am | lucky I go from being convinced I am dying to able to function | with some difficulty. Lotsa brains, lots of different reactions | to the drug. | ad404b8a372f2b9 wrote: | I was prescribed some after a severe accident and it really | helped me, both during while dealing with the pain and stress, | and after to get over the trauma and anxiety attacks. | | I've always been fervently anti-meds but sometimes when you're | in a tough spot they are magical and going without is the worse | alternative. | | For what it's worth after 2 years of occasional use, I have no | addiction at all. I've been tracking my use daily for the past | year and as my anxiety has waned I've stopped taking them | entirely. | colechristensen wrote: | The first time I took Xanax I cleaned my kitchen and it went | from mildly embarrassing to quite presentable in an hour or | two. I could actually execute the things I wanted to do without | fighting though ridiculous feelings. | | I am treated like an addict or ridiculous when I tell doctors | I'd rather not "try SSRIs" or a series of strange sedating | substances because they're all so afraid of prescribing | something with addiction potential (and the regulators trying | to stop them). | codeulike wrote: | In mice | | https://twitter.com/justsaysinmice?s=09 | dang wrote: | Ok, we've inmiced the title above. | | I had to add the c-word, though ("causes"). The article uses it | several times, so I suppose it's ok for the title. Please let's | not repeat the usual "C is not C" business. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | anyone knows wether ghb is neurotoxic? | Commodore63 wrote: | Jordan Peterson had a horrible time with these drugs and resorted | to extreme measures to get off them (eight days in an induced | coma!) Even today he might still be on them - he is pretty cagey | about his present pharma situation when asked about it on | podcasts. | | https://nationalpost.com/health/jordan-peterson-benzodiazepi... | | Horrible drug. | seattle_spring wrote: | It's also pretty obvious that he is cognitively impaired. | s5300 wrote: | Peterson is a verified idiot with nonexistent self-control. Not | the slightest modicum of it. | | Basing anything off of his antics is asinine. So weird to see | people who put him on a pedestal on HN. | | & benzos aren't "horrible drugs" | | People who don't know how to manage themselves and their usage | of them are horrible people though, especially when they try to | cut down others who have no issues using them responsibly, | which sometimes literally saves their entire lives. | 77pt77 wrote: | He claimed he had no idea what they were. | | Someone that identifies as a neuroscientist. | | He knew very well but thought he was special. | | The only thing special is that he went cold turkey (extremely | dangerous) and had to be placed into an induced coma in Russia | because no one else would do it. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | few people know it but you can fight a benzo addiction with | flumazenil injections. You can even do it yourself if you have to | avoid multiyear waiting lists.. (e.g. OTC on indiamart) however | you must be extremely extremely careful to take the minimum | needed dose, if you take too much you risk passing out/epilepsy. | but at the medical dose, it is safe and will accelerate recovery | time and quality dramatically. | cosmiccatnap wrote: | I thought this was well known as Peterson effect. | listless wrote: | I take .5 mg Klonopin for sleep every night. | anonuser123456 wrote: | Not a great idea in the long run. | tinyhouse wrote: | Why there aren't more studies on humans? It's not difficult to | find people who have been taking benzos or other related drugs | for years. | colechristensen wrote: | I researched long term impairment in humans for benzos and was | only able to find very mild (i.e. on the edge of measurability) | cognitive impairment which was mostly recoverable after a | period of abstinence. | sedeki wrote: | Is it reasonable to assume that the same thing applies to the | Z-drugs too, specifically Zolpidem? | | I have a family member that I'm worried about, that has taken | Zolpidem for several years straight (apart from minor breaks in | between prescription refills because of overconsumption during | the previous refill...). | mtlmtlmtlmtl wrote: | From skimming the article, it seems they've linked this effect | to benzos interacting with a specific protein in microglia. | This is not the interaction benzos share with Z-drugs, which is | modulation of the GABA-A receptor. So it seems unclear whether | this can be extrapolated to Zolpidem. | | However, Z-drugs(and benzos as a sleep aid) generally should | not be used daily for longer than a few weeks until a better | solution is found. Unfortunately, doctors often do this anyway, | following the path of least resistance, I suppose. | | I wouldn't worry about any kind of brain damage, but I would | recommend reviewing their options, maybe seeing another doctor. | Lots of people can manage just fine with something like | extended release melatonin, or indeed nothing. | gzer0 wrote: | As zolpidem is associated with drug tolerance and substance | dependence, its prescription guidelines are only for severe | insomnia and short periods of use at the lowest effective dose | [1]. | | Zolpidem increases risk of depression, falls and bone fracture, | poor driving, suppressed respiration, and has been associated | with an increased risk of death [2]. | | I would recommend you to seek a second opinion from another | medical professional about whether this family member should | perhaps slowly taper off of the Zolpidem. | | [1] https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ta77/chapter/1-Guidance | | [2] | https://escholarship.org/content/qt08d9f3d5/qt08d9f3d5.pdf?t... | smithmayowa wrote: | Just came off benzos withdrawal those things are insanely | horrible, delirium, depersonalization, derealization, muscle | tremors, and persistent headaches were some of the symptoms I | experienced. Thank God I did not have seizures. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | take magnesium lthreonate for an effective synapse recovery | symlinkk wrote: | You know what else causes brain damage? Anxiety | SemanticStrengh wrote: | The world of medecine is degenerate. Sustainable, non addictive | and non neurotoxic anxiolytics exists: the #1 being opipramol the | sigmaergic. emoxypine (which btw cure hangover) and guanfacine | are worth mentioning. Maybe beta blockers to some extent. NMDA | antagonists such as memantine have side effects but are not | neurotoxic to my knowledge and there are milder ones such as mg- | lthreonate. afobazole is interesting but its pharmacology is too | weird to be sure. Etifoxine is revolutionnary, it double axon | length growth rate so ironically a great cure to benzo | neurodamage. its acts on the _mitochondria_ benzodiazepine | receptor. It 's unclear to me wether it is subject to a tolerance | effect and if so if it is lower. Also etifoxine can interact | badly with other drugs on the liver. Note that there exists | ultra-atypical mechanisms, such as inositol megadose or tofisopam | but they are not firstline. | | So yeah, basically opipramol and guanfacine should be what humans | take as first line. Glycine is a nice obvious augmentation (kinda | absurd that people forget about the second inhibitor | neurotransmitter in the brain, especially since the effect feel | nice and doesn't really lead to tolerance). if you have benzo | neurodamage, take magnesium lthreonate which is a very potent | synaptotrophic. | | also fun fact: the benzo cartel was so strong it was the most | prescribed drug in the world, all classes, in the 70s | sph wrote: | I have a hard time believing that while the current status quo | is suboptimal, there's some little known compounds that are, as | you say, revolutionary and with little side effects. | Pharmacological research is a constantly moving target, there | is no scientific nor economic reason that a supposedly | "perfect" remedy remains unknown. Sounds too much like thinly | veiled conspiracy, or perhaps they're not as perfect as you're | suggesting. | | That said, it's not my area of competence, so if you know _why_ | opipramol and guanfacine are ignored compared to benzos and | other anxiolytic, you should probably explain that. | | EDIT: re: guanfacine, I know it's a second-line treatment for | ADHD, it was previously used to treat hypertension, but this is | the first time I hear it might be applicable as an anxiolytic. | It does certainly have side effects, though not as bad as being | neurodegenerative like benzodiazepines. | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guanfacine | gavinray wrote: | I have personal experience with Guanfacine (and Clonidine), | beta blockers (Propanolol/Labetalol), Etifoxine, Phenibut, | and a myriad of benzos. | | Long history of RX for anxiety disorders, which I eventually | tapered off of and quit due to dependence. | | Can attest to Etifoxine being effective without side effects, | guanfacine and clonidine being mildly effective. Beta | blockers never did much for me but YMMV. | retrac wrote: | Anecdotally, I can attest to the surprising efficacy of alpha | blockers. I have used prazosin as a sleep aid for the last | decade, a few times a month. | | There were some limited studies that suggest it is effective in | helping sleep quality in people with nightmares and PTSD. Now, | I don't have PTSD, but I do have a mind that will not shut off | at night, running in useless circles that jolt me back awake. | It does nothing for the racing mind, but my body's | physiological reaction to my emotional state is lessened. I | _physically_ relax, quite literally in smooth muscle activation | terms, and apparently that lets me get to sleep. | | Beta blockers are probably a bit more heavy duty, but they do | appear to be quite effective at treating performance-related | anxieties from another small study. Shakes? Chills? Dizziness | and blood pressure spikes? From the discussion I had with my | psychiatrist, I think the working hypothesis is that treating | the physical symptoms of anxiety is an effective intervention | here, as the discomforting experiences that the initial anxiety | triggers, creates a feedback cycle. (Oh god, now I'm sweating | and flushed, everyone's gonna notice...!) | | It's interesting when I explain it to new physicians when they | take a history. Like my current GP. Initial surprise. A | psychiatrist prescribed that? For... anxiety? A pause. Yes, | that actually does makes sense. Just never thought of it | before. | kayodelycaon wrote: | High blood pressure and anxiety can both cause similar | symptoms. Tightness in the chest, for example. Your body | tends to mistake one for the other. | | Treating high-blood pressure with an ACE inhibitor (which | does not treat anxiety) can reduce anxiety simply by | relieving symptoms that feel like anxiety. | | Beta blockers have the nice effect of directly treating both | anxiety and high blood pressure. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | Good to hear! Glycine 3 gram before sleep can be useful as a | combination. it relaxes the body too and relaxe the mind | also. There are interesting studies showing positive effects | on sleep and no tolerance. | | magnesium l threonate before sleep, the lthreonate variant | penetarte the brain far more than regular magnesium, and it | acts as a mild NMDA antagonist, which means it decrease | maximal excitation. it is also a great synaptotrophic. | cameronh90 wrote: | Propranolol is very commonly prescribed for anxiety in the | UK. I take it as needed and it works wonders, but it does | make me a bit lethargic. It doesn't completely eliminate the | low level anxiety but it stops it ending up in a viscous | panic cycle. | matheusmoreira wrote: | Widely used for anxiety in my country as well but not an | optimal choice due to the cardiovascular effects. As you | noted, it can cause fatigue. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | there exists beta blockers that mostly do not cross the | blood brain barrier, and therefore have less effect on | fatigue | blantonl wrote: | _also fun fact: the benzo cartel was so strong it was the most | prescribed drug in the world, all classes, in the 70s_ | | "Mother's little helper" was a term coined during the 60s and | 70s (Diazepam - aka Valium) | [deleted] | gavinray wrote: | Etifoxine can be purchased from other countries and has studies | showing comparable effects to classic benzodiazepines for acute | panic attacks, but without being addictive. | | Personal experience, it doesn't have noticeable psychoactive | effects like benzos do but does block stress response + panic. | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Etifoxine | rhexs wrote: | Emoxypine doesn't seem to have any English studies, or has | incredibly few. So it may or may not be useful, but I sure as | heck can't tell. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | here's 438 studies for you | https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=Emoxypine&sort=date the | marketing name is mexidol. Emoxypine is a wonder drug for | health, it is one of the most potent superoxide antioxidant | and has an incredible range of body protective effetcs see | e.g. | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emoxypine#Mechanism_of_action | | look at the pictures and admire the amount of saved brain | volume https://www.researchgate.net/publication/221738761_Eva | luatio... | rhexs wrote: | Interesting. What's the quality of Russian medical research | versus western? What journals are considered prestigious? | (Not trying to troll -- I honestly have no idea and can't | judge it accurately). | SemanticStrengh wrote: | I have much more respect for russian papers in | pharmacology in general than for your average american | study. There are many reasons to this: 1) a lot of their | research is public. They don't have broken incentives, | e.g. they can study the tech that the body use, such as | peptides. Big pharma can't leverage endogenous peptides | because they're not patentable, a true tragedy that | considerably sets back medecine progress. 2) they study | outside of the boxe things, they are not afraid to do | human trials, they have expertise in gerontology | (oxidative stress, bioenergetics, etc) which are often | very lacking in american studies. | | also, those russian researches are generally validated by | non-russian working groups. | | as an example, many of the favorites nootropics people | experience have been discovered in russia (racetams, | bromantane, etc) | rhexs wrote: | Thanks, interesting to get this perspective. I have seen | a lot of interesting research chemicals and nootropics | redditors are using, most of which are prescription drugs | in Russia (semax, selank, probably others). Shame there | doesn't seem to be any pharmaceutical crossover, would | love to see some studies done in the West. I'd be too | scared to experiment on myself. | tunnuz wrote: | I was prescribed Diazepam some time ago (and loved it). But as | far as I know you're not supposed to be on benzodiazepines for | very long? | meowface wrote: | >Experiments conducted by the researchers revealed that synapse | loss in mice that were given a daily sleep-inducing dosage of the | benzodiazepine diazepam for several weeks resulted in cognitive | deficits. | | I know it's only in mice, but it's pretty scary if it also has | this effect in humans even when only taking it for a few weeks. | Based on the title, I was initially kind of expecting something | like daily use for years. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | xan not workib | sibeliuss wrote: | As someone with a few family members addicted to Xanax (long | term) and have repeatedly bore witness to the destruction, I can | say with certainty that it's an evil drug. It's like the person | crawls inside a space where they can safely project all of their | anxieties onto others. Their problems becomes _your_ problems, a | fully projected virtual experience. It 's definitely psychosis- | like, and I've always wondered if there was some brain damage | involved. Well, here's the answer to that. | jmcgough wrote: | Daily use of benzos is extremely bad in general - the physical | addiction is not pleasant to withdraw from, and it significantly | increases the risk of dementia in old age. | trevorishere wrote: | > dementia in old age. | | Spoke to a psychiatrist on this one. He was saying The Lancet | longitudinal study was bunk and that Xanax use was not one of | concern. | | I'm not saying he's correct, but he literally laughed at my | objection to Xanax, including it's now very long history of use | with an average dose of 6mg/day. | twstdzppr wrote: | Xanax use is cause for concern in general. Acutely it is | safe, but chronic administration is definitively not, and not | something to laugh about or take lightly. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | doctors often laugh at their own ignorance and pride | mistrial9 wrote: | this man laughed at you for suggesting this? Xanax is a | "benzo" wikipedia tells me.. Consider the source | fermentation wrote: | Had some anxiety issues in France and a doctor that I met with | (who I had trouble speaking to) prescribed daily benzos for a | month. Towards the end of the month it felt like my body NEEDED | the pills. It was scary. | jmcgough wrote: | Your brain chemistry acclimates to using a GABA agonist every | day and will get out of whack if you stop taking it :( like | anxiety will be WAY WORSE when going through withdrawal. | | I still use a benzo (lowest dose lamictal) but only about | once a month when I need hit the panic button. It's really | not meant to be a daily use drug, scared me when a friend was | prescribed it as a daily medication. | trevorishere wrote: | Lamictal is not a benzo and must be used consistently | (daily) to prevent SJS as it requires titration. Generally, | those who need it (epileptic patients or those with bipolar | disorder) must use it for the duration of their life. | kayodelycaon wrote: | Lamictal is an anticonvulsant, not a benzo. I take it daily | as a mood stabilizer for bipolar disorder. | cameronh90 wrote: | Daily use of benzos gave me sleep paralysis, false awakenings | and made me sleep walk. | | Not saying that proves anything, but it was _scary_. | [deleted] | kayodelycaon wrote: | This doesn't surprise me. I have Klonopin for as needed use. | (Since early 2019, I've used 106 0.5mg pills, so not a | significant amount.) | | Being bipolar, I find they are necessary for suitations my | regular medication and coping mechanisms can't handle. Without | them, living a normal life would be difficult. | | That said... benzos scare me. Taking one pill will calm me today, | but at the expense for increased anxiety the next two. | | If I go to a convention, I'll have ramped up to my max dose | around the second or third day. After that, it becomes less | effective because I can't (and won't) increase it more. I've only | gone five days at most and by the fifth day, my anxiety is the | same it would be without medication. Coming off that afterwards | is brutal. | | If I had another effective option, I would use it. I've tried | very hard to "power through" my symptoms or find alternatives | during my first year being diagnosed. My psychiatrist, therapist, | and friends had to just about physically slap me to use them. | zosima wrote: | This is quite interesting as for a long time there has been some | evidence that Benzodiazepine usage can increase the risk of | Alzheimer's diseases and it has often shown up as a risk factor | when doing large-scale database studies. Summary here: | | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6960222/ | | I won't jump to the conclusion that this is the mechanism, or be | certain that the we are talking about causation rather than | correlation, but evidence like this certainly tilts the weight | towards causation. | glerk wrote: | Benzos are pretty terrible drugs in general. The physical | addiction potential and withdrawal people are going through are | enough to dissuade me from touching them. For folks dealing with | anxiety, I recommend trying propranolol. It is not as powerful, | but sometimes it is enough to achieve the desired effect and the | side effects are way less severe. | leach wrote: | I take a benzo ICE as needed, but was on them for a while and | never really noticed degenerative affects though I'm young | though. Should I be worried? | kayodelycaon wrote: | From the article: | | > When diazepam medication was stopped, the effects lingered | for a while but were eventually reversed. | | I think you'll be okay. | leach wrote: | That's good, I'm conflicted because they've helped me but | they are nasty little drugs. I've only ever been prescribed | would never take them recreationally. | | I was on them daily for a while and eventually, even though | I never really worried or got anxious, other emotions where | muted as well. I felt like I didn't need it anymore and my | doctor didn't tapper me off them correctly so for two weeks | strait I barely slept and had terrible withdrawal symptoms. | Having them ICE is nice but I would never recommend them to | people to take daily they are just to intense. | kayodelycaon wrote: | Just a warning to anyone who has asthma, propranolol is a older | beta blocker from the 1960s and has made asthma worse in | various trials. | | My doctor and psychiatrist recommended I use other classes of | medications. | matheusmoreira wrote: | Yes. Asthma is treated with beta agonists. Beta blockers will | block the effect of the asthma medication. | colechristensen wrote: | Propranolol does almost, but not quite nothing for me. It does, | however, put me on a daily(!) withdrawl cycle where when I'm on | it, it does a small amount which is right up near the level of | noticing, and when it wears off amplifies my normal symptoms. | | Xanax was the only thing I ever took that did more than took | the edge off (or some things which just made me loopy, sleepy, | and/or high), it could at appropriate dosages simply turn my | symptoms off and I went about doing normal productive human | things that I wanted to. | | But the state that I live in, and every doctor that I've met | since I moved across the country has wanted to try every other | drug in the book (again) before even considering, and none have | thought raising the dosage beyond the literal smallest dose | (despite me being 6'2" >200lbs). It is extremely frustrating. | jotm wrote: | Most drugs that actually work are terrible. If you're gonna | abuse stimulants for relaxation, it's obvious to everyone but | you that it will be a very bad time, for example. | | That said, the recommended dosages are basically bullshit. For | anything, I'd say take 1/2 or 1/3 of what they recommend in the | first few days/weeks and taper up. | | But please use your own brain when taking advice from | strangers. | natly wrote: | I recommend working out, it helped me a ton with anxiety. It | basically cured it (I don't work out much anymore but a short | intense few months of hard workouts seems to have almost | removed it from my system years afterwards). | blagie wrote: | There are sources of anxiety without clear solutions. I have | a stalker. There's low-level harassment continuously, but | every few months, she does something crazy, and my life is | completely disrupted. I have no idea what to do about it. | | It's nearing a decade.... | Nextgrid wrote: | Can police help? | | Alternatively, (non-violent) retaliation? Seems like | there's no downside for this person to be harassing you. | Creating a downside might make her think twice next time. | cameronh90 wrote: | Assuming GP is male, he probably doesn't want to do | something that might be seen as being aggressive, | harassing or upsetting to her, even if not violent. | | Threatening to involve the police is a common way women | abuse men. You can of course involve the police yourself | but they often won't listen. | | I had an ex try to create a situation where I would be | framed for rape by creating fake social media accounts | purporting to be me. Luckily she wasn't smart and the | police saw that all the accounts were obviously created | by her. Yet they still didn't help protect me from | further harassment or do anything to her for trying to | frame me and making false police reports. | | Sad as it is, probably best to just try and ignore her | and consider going by an alias online and moving house. | Dma54rhs wrote: | I had similar experiences and police are pretty much | useless in that case, flat out said since you're | physically stronger than the stalker there's no threat to | your life. Oh well... Its a constant torture. | blagie wrote: | My ex is smart, wealthy, and devotes most of her life to | this. She smart enough that she rarely leave evidence, | and when it's there, it's convoluted enough that you | can't really act on it. For example, a drone fly-by | leaves no evidence. A story about some convoluted 9-month | scheme to frame me isn't something anyone will listen to, | let alone pursue. If you walk in with a big pile of | documentation, you look crazy, not them. | | The court system is a big hole to throw money into: | | 1) It is surprisingly impervious to actual evidence. A | woman crying on the stand, with a bunch of fabrications, | will be believed. A man showing documents won't be. | | 2) It's influenced by preparation and money. If the other | party is willing to devote their whole life into this, | and you want to live anything resembling a normal life, | you're basically SOL. | | There isn't a magic fairy government agency who cares | about this sort of thing. | | I don't think there's a solution. | | I was modestly famous before this, but I haven't done | anything public in a half-decade because of this !@#$%. | natly wrote: | Sounds awful. My cause was definitely more caused by | developmental period weird wiring, so definitely different. | Hope you find some way to resolve it one day somehow. | cameronh90 wrote: | Interestingly working out is a trigger for my anxiety. I'm | currently trying graded exposure therapy for exercise, but so | far it's not working. | fb03 wrote: | Was about to say this. | | Do you also trigger while trying to exercise? I have had | pretty intense panic attacks while trying to work. to the | point of having dizziness, weakness, closing throat | feelings, the works! Pretty shitty stuff. 15 minutes later, | you are absolutely normal and feeling bummed and sometimes | embarrassed as well. | | I would also not wish a panic attack to my worst enemy. | | What I'm trying to do now is short walks and getting more | 'confidence'. I think what gets us/me is the "what if I | trigger" thing. | | So, going slow helps build a little of confidence. That's | my current plan, at least. I know an attack is bound to | happen, and I will not win every time, but I'm not gonna be | deterred by it. I know exercise helps a ton. | | Thank you for this reply and wish you well! | orangepurple wrote: | I had those exact symptoms from not eating sufficients | amounts of salt combined with not drinking enough water. | Now I aim for 7 grams of table salt per day. Low sodium | symptoms are indistinguishable from "feeling like you are | dying." | natly wrote: | This was the case for me too! :) I really hated running at | the start because it triggered anxiety. In the end it | turned out to be a blessing because it provided me with | basically a safe (not socially connected etc) way to | activate it at my own comfort and degree I was comfortable | with and basically feel like my twisted up brain | connections got smoothed out by doing it for a while. | (Basically exposure therapy as you mention.) Lions mane may | have been part of helping too but idk. | fb03 wrote: | That's my current plan as well. Just getting back to my | exercise routine and work my fitness levels and also | 'exposure'/'desensitization'. | | Wish you well! | cycomanic wrote: | Yes, it's unfortunate that exercise is not prescribed more | for these issues as there are tons of studies showing the | benefits of working out against depression, anxiety etc.. I | think we should really be seeing a mechanism where doctors | can prescribe time off for exercise to deal with mental or | physical issues, without repercussions for the employee. | Maybe it's too much of a hope to see that in the US, but at | least in Europe. | ilikeitdark wrote: | Doctor gave me for anxiety in the day and sleeping at night. On | it for way too long,and horrible. Definitely not worth it. | transfire wrote: | Benzos disrupt REM sleep. Eventually you will go mad. | ldjkfkdsjnv wrote: | The reality is many drugs have long term effects, we just can't | see them yet. But if you are close to someone who is a user, over | the long run you will notice differences. Sometimes its just that | they don't have the same spark. Regardless, 100 years down the | line we will look back in horror at the state of pharmaceutical | drugs. All it takes is going to a doctor, saying you have | anxiety, and the doctor pops out a script. His "medical degree" | and insurance demands that he "treats" his patient. | wit22145 wrote: | > His "medical degree" and insurance demands that he "treats" | his patient. | | Completely lost me here. Why does the doctor have air quotes | around their medical degree? And what's wrong with treating | disease? Or are you saying insurance requires unnecessary | prescriptions? Because that's definitely not the case, | insurance would prefer no prescriptions financially at least | and the doc is paid the same either way. Overall I think you | just have an axe to grind against medicine for some reason. | It's not a perfect system but I don't think you really know | what you're talking about and are concerned with the wrong | things. | heavyset_go wrote: | SSRI-like drugs and drugs like buspirone are considered the | gold standard for anxiety disorders now. They do not act like | benzodiazepines at all in the brain. | symlinkk wrote: | How do they act? I just started taking buspirone for | crippling social anxiety and I'm not sure if it's helping or | not. | [deleted] | swayvil wrote: | You are speaking beside his point. | ZanyProgrammer wrote: | You're taking a very specific article about benzos and making | unsubstantiated leaps about medicine in general. | matheusmoreira wrote: | Benzodiazepines are not even first line treatments for anxiety | though. More like a last resort. They are very useful in | aborting panic attacks and that says a lot about the intensity | of symptoms necessary to justify their use. | | SSRIs and SNRIs have a much better risk/benefit profile. | Sertraline in particular is a really effective drug. I don't | really understand why other doctors prescribe benzodiazepines | so frequently but I'm not doing it. | jotm wrote: | If you look closer at others, you'll notice they have a new | spark. But "new medication" won't be your first thought. | bcook wrote: | You've got a dangerous level of confidence. | openknot wrote: | >"But if you are close to someone who is a user, over the long | run you will notice differences. Sometimes its just that they | don't have the same spark." | | The loss of a spark can happen regardless of drug use. Work in | an unsupportive environment over a long period of time, a | breakup, or the failure to achieve a long-sought goal can cause | a person to change over time. In addition, the underlying | condition that the medication is treating may cause the effect, | which could have been worse had the medication not been | prescribed. | | It's plausible that medications may have understudied long-term | effects, but there are too many confounding causes to attribute | a behavioral change to long-term medication use. | mikercampbell wrote: | As someone who has had a long time relationship with Xanax, | it quite literally saved my life. I was prescribed it for | chronic nausea, and was 40lbs below my ideal weight. | | I've never been tempted to take any more than my prescribed | dose, and so it's been a "healthy" relationship, but I'm | working to discontinue my prescription for reasons other than | this article. | | Not to be one of those "well, I use it and I'm fine and | aren't tempted", on the contrary - I understand fully why | people would feel the tugs of addiction. | | It's hard because I know I have an uphill battle to go. I use | therapy and have seen benefits from psychedelics and | medicinal cannabis, but it's literally a "pick your poison" | battle. | | But also, it's hard to have a spark when you're not able to | live a normal life without assistance. | | But in hindsight, I can see that this route has had it's | costs and I'm excited to see who I am independent of it. | ZanyProgrammer wrote: | The reality is that many doctors these days will not prescribe | large amounts of benzos, certainly not just willy nilly. | ldjkfkdsjnv wrote: | I'm not just talking about benzos, but also anti psychotics, | amphetamines, statins, and basically the whole gamut. My | brother is a pharmacist, and is constantly shocked by the | prescriptions that healthy people bring in to get filled. The | medical field has been unjustly given too much prestige. | cstejerean wrote: | And how does he know they are healthy? | anonymoushn wrote: | maybe my pharmacist can tell that I don't need | methylphenidate because I have all my documents in order | while I'm already on methylphenidate :) | sascha_sl wrote: | "You can't have ADHD, if you had ADHD, you could not have | driven here for an hour" -- real thing that happened to | someone I know. | throwaway284534 wrote: | This is a exactly the kind of puritanical catch-22 that | entrenches every corner ADHD treatment. "Oh, your | justification for access to the _high-inducing_ , party | drug of amphetamine is that it'll cure your lack of | focus? Well, if these dangerously addictive drugs so | effective, then surely you can handle 30 day | prescriptions with no refills." | | God forbid your prescription runs out on a weekend or | holiday when your doctor's office is closed. And don't | even think about shopping around for multiple scripts | because that'll just label you as a drug addict. The only | winning move is to take half-doses on down days and build | up a small stash of emergency medication. | opportune wrote: | 100% this. The worst part about ADHD treatment is all the | disruptions of care to prevent people trying to abuse it. | I personally don't give a rat's ass if people want to | take adderall to go out and party or masturbate either. | They'd probably have fun with less negative health | effects or risk of fights/belligerence compared to | alcohol... | | But for some reason the government (the FDA) and medical | field in general cares about abuse a lot. In the past few | weeks, Cerebral got labelled a pill mill by the FDA/execs | and as a result almost all ADHD telemedicine patients are | having a hard time getting prescriptions filled. Sending | a prescription to multiple places sequentially (because | they keep refusing to fill it) or calling a pharmacy in | advance to ask if they'd fill the prescription runs the | risk of being labelled a drug seeker, and any power- | tripping retail pharmacist - who doesn't know anything | about you at all - can just refuse to fill your | prescription if they want. Asking your provider for a | higher dose is also anxiety-inducing for similar reasons. | | The worst part is, people with ADHD still build a | dependence/tolerance on amphetamines/methylphenidate. So | running out of your medicine is really disruptive - not | only do your symptoms go untreated, but they become worse | than they'd be if you were unmedicated for a long | interval, plus you have to deal with things like not | feeling fully awake, being hungrier, lethargic, sleeping | more while your body adjusts back to being unmedicated. | But for some reason that's acceptable as long as we | prevent people from taking amphetamines for fun. | sascha_sl wrote: | I found it really useful to cycle single doses between | 5mg/10mg and ocasionally skip it entirely, when I know it | wouldn't be essential. (Usually the skip sorts itself out | when I forget I have them. You'd think lingering | processing deficiencies would be obvious enough to remind | me, but apparently not.) | | I've been avoiding higher doses because this setup works | well enough that I don't want to disrupt the status quo | and I keep hearing from friends that build a dependence | and even one who went off them entirely after adverse | reactions on very high doses. | | Fortunately I have a doctor who agreed this was a good | idea and writes me prescriptions for different strengths. | cwzwarich wrote: | > My brother is a pharmacist, and is constantly shocked by | the prescriptions that healthy people bring in to get | filled. | | While I definitely agree with your general point, how does | your brother know that they're healthy or don't need to | take the medication? I've never had any discussion with a | pharmacist (in the US or Canada) where I've revealed this | information. | ldjkfkdsjnv wrote: | What I mean is a mother of 4, with no medical history, is | feeling stressed and worn out. Maybe she has trouble | focussing. All of a sudden she comes in with an | amphetamine prescription. A year later, she's a full | blown dependent on a serious drug. She was actually just | burned out and probably just needed a break from her kids | and a vacation. Very common. There's no transparency, no | public understanding of doctors who are prescribing like | this. It's only in a pharmacy do you get a birds eye | view. | sascha_sl wrote: | You're making a lot of assumptions here, "maybe", | "probably". | | "No medical history" doesn't mean shit either, it just | means you have not yet seeked help. Most don't see mental | health professionals at the first sign of issues, often | they only do when things are starting to crumble. And | that's my experience in a country with socialized | healthcare, now translate that to the US where therapy is | unaffordable to a large number of people. | anonymoushn wrote: | I sort of expect that the psychiatrist spends more time | with the patient each month than the pharmacist. | rhexs wrote: | It's sort of a sad indictment of our system, but odds are | the pharmacist sees the patient far more than the | psychiatrist does. | tptacek wrote: | I have literally never had a discussion with a | pharmacist. I drive up, hand them my script through the | drawer thingy, and they hand me back my drugs. In fact, | in the last couple years, I barely even do that anymore; | our doctors just call in our scripts, and we get a text | message when it's time to pick them up, and that's that. | | The idea that pharmacists have any meaningful diagnostic | role in the US is risible. | yata69420 wrote: | I always hear about these community pharmacists that | consult with patients about medical issues, but I'm yet | to meet one myself. | | I suspect pharmacists are the _only_ people that some | class of Americans can speak to about medical issues | because they have an open storefront. | | I don't know what pharmacists know about drugs, but | they're useful people to speak to about insurance issues. | They know the rules around age cutoffs for optional | vaccines, which generics are in stock, when something | will be denied by insurance, etc. | wickoff wrote: | 15-ish years ago, when I was twenty, I was foolish enough | to see a psychiatrist. I walked away with a prescription | for an SSRI, a typical antipsychotic, a mood stabilizer | and some Xanax to take as needed. | | What I really needed was my father not being dead when it | mattered. | ZanyProgrammer wrote: | Your brother is not a clinician, definitely not those | people's clinician. | opportune wrote: | If they're healthy, couldn't that be because of the | medicine? | | A lot of people have conditions that medicine treats so | well you wouldn't even know they had a condition at all. | | I know many people who have taken antipsychotics, | amphetamines, and statins for decades and it was perfectly | fine for them. I also personally know some judgmental | pharmacists too. All I'll say is, there's a reason | pharmacists and doctors are distinct professions. | matheusmoreira wrote: | > If they're healthy, couldn't that be because of the | medicine? | | It's very likely. This actually has to be explained to a | lot of people with chronic diseases like hypertension and | type 2 diabetes. Way too many of them just stop taking | their medication after their condition improves. | cycomanic wrote: | I believe blaming this on doctors only is way to easy. I | believe many people demand medication when they go to the | doctor. If they go because of a cold they don't accept | being told to rest for a week, but demand antibiotics, if | they feel depressed they don't want to be told to exercise, | but want a quick medication etc.. I definitely see this | since coming to Sweden, where it's difficult for doctors to | prescribe antibiotics and lots of expats complain that they | went to the doctor and were told to rest for a week. They | feel they are not taken seriously if they don't get | medication (that is not to say that there are no problems | with how healthcare is done here, but restrictive | prescriptions of antibiotics is not one of them). | anonymoushn wrote: | antipsychotics are horrifying. do therapeutic doses of | stimulants cause problems other than heart disease over the | long term? | maleldil wrote: | Antipsychotics are terrifying, but I'd rather deal with | the physical side-effects than the disorder, and they're | pretty effective at treating that. | [deleted] | matheusmoreira wrote: | Depends on how you define "problem". Amphetamines may | cause a lot of side effects: lower appetite, agitation, | insomnia, irritability, bruxism... The list goes on. | Whether these risks are acceptable or not is an | individualized choice. Some side effects may even be | beneficial: lower appetite for weight loss, insomnia for | narcolepsy. | aaaaaaaaaaab wrote: | No, long-term stimulant use is totally A-ok! /s | mtlmtlmtlmtl wrote: | Actually, at therapeutic doses, it is. | sascha_sl wrote: | If your brother told you that with this exact framing, he's | in the wrong industry. | | Health, and especially not mental health is very much not | visible or even obvious. Just ask any disabled person that | is not bound to a wheelchair 100 percent of the time. | twstdzppr wrote: | They are easily one of the most harmful classes of medications. | Sure, they combat anxiety acutely, but wreck ones cognitive | abilities in the process. This has been readily observable for a | long time. | | Plus, the anxiolytic effect quickly turns into a dependency, as | when the withdrawal starts kicking in you're inclined to start | having anxiety attacks. | | Suppose you want to get off them. Now you have a significant | problem. Can't quit cold turkey -- you're likely to have a | seizure. | shepardrtc wrote: | I was prescribed benzos because of sleeping issues, but I was | also taking phenibut at the same time. After about 3 weeks of | using large doses of the benzos every night, I stopped taking | them, but a year later I still feel pangs of withdrawal sometimes | when I get stressed. It took me another 4 months to get off the | phenibut and a month or so after that before my sleep returned to | normal. There were months where I maybe got an hour or two of | sleep a night. If I got stressed, I simply wouldn't sleep at all. | I once went three days without sleep. The torment of that | combined with the withdrawal from the drugs showed me what hell | was like. I tell everyone to never take benzos for any reasons. I | don't care how safe the doctors say they are; they aren't. | Period. There are repercussions - as this study shows - and they | will not help the underlying cause of your issues. Treat the | cause, not the symptoms. | jlmorton wrote: | It's much the same with chronic alcohol usage, and a very | similar pathway. Both alcohol and benzodiazepines bind to GABA | receptors, and through several difference mechanisms | (desensitization, downregulation through gene expression, | degradation), these receptors become less sensitive. | | GABA receptors are critical to sleep. After prolonged usage of | alcohol, or benzos, sleep often becomes impossible without an | ever-larger dosage. | | These sleeping difficulties sometimes persist for quite a | while, and sleep disturbances are one of the primary causes of | relapse in alcoholics. People learn that alcohol helps them to | fall asleep. Even if the quality of sleep is poor, it's | substantially better than no sleep at all, as anyone who has | gone through what you did surely knows. | bsimpson wrote: | Someone close to me has long been addicted to both alcohol | and Ambien (sleeping pills). | | I'd never considered that alcohol could trigger the need for | Ambien. I'd presumed it was a lifestyle thing for someone who | was used to being out all night. | yodsanklai wrote: | > I tell everyone to never take benzos for any reasons | | You can't generalise your experience. Everybody is different | and that's the doctor's job to assess whether the benefits | outweigh the cost, considering the patient and their problems. | | Personally, I've been taking benzos very occasionally for 20 | years (never more than a few days at a time) and they helped me | overcome difficult times. Never had the slightest addiction or | side effects. | | > Treat the cause, not the symptoms. | | Easier said than done | sva_ wrote: | I have friend who was at nursing school, and she'd get them | prescribed for the few occasions where she had to do a | presentation, as she would get extremely nervous. She never | took them after. Maybe she could've addressed the issue | differently, but it worked for her, and she never got hooked. | But milage varies, and so on. She also told me that at the | hospital, benzos are readily available and they kinda hand | then out like candy to manage patients (there doesn't seem to | be any rigorous bookkeeping about them). | | I also tried a few many years ago, but they didn't really do | anything for me. I think they only work if you got anxiety or | something, so some underlying issue which -if chronic- is | probably not a good fit. Never had any cravings since. | kayodelycaon wrote: | I've reacted differently to different benzos. One did | nothing. Another triggered one hell of a mood swing (I'm | bipolar). Finally settled on Klonopin, which has a long | half-life. It seems to be less.. harsh? | | Psychoactive medications are fun... | pirate787 wrote: | My family was addicted to benzos by a quack doctor who hands | them out like candy. He has many seniors on it long term for | "anxiety" and though seniors are at particular risk and are | not supposed to use more than 6 months. | r3trohack3r wrote: | I got to see this side of American medicine while in high | school. My great aunt unofficially overdosed on a cocktail | of drugs prescribed by a group of loosely coordinating | doctors. | | When she passed, her cocktail included 12 prescriptions. | One of her doctors had prescribed her medication to lower | her blood pressure while another had her on medication to | raise it. | ada1981 wrote: | I think literally everything from learning to play tic tac | toe to quantum computing is easier said than done... | | It's harder to clear trauma, teach emotional regulation and | to build a life that is healthy, yes. And, it's a path worth | walking down. | mikepurvis wrote: | This whole discussion is making me feel better than ever for | choosing cannabis edibles (legal in Canada) to address | stress-induced insomnia and other sleep issues for which the | root cause was not something I was in a position to | immediately address. | | I take it a few times a week as needed, small doses (2-5mg) | and I feel that I am in control of it and could go off any | time. | opportune wrote: | Did you tell your doctor you were taking phenibut when they | prescribed you benzos? It seems like something you definitely | shouldn't mix. | | I completely agree that benzos are bad news unless you truly | need them. In my relatively uneducated opinion, I don't think | they should be a first-line treatment and it's kind of a joke | that they're considered schedule 4 (at least compared to things | that are schedule 2 - I don't think really anything should be | "scheduled"). Benzos and other gaba-ergics may not be as | pleasurable as other drugs, but they're very addicting and have | the most harmful withdrawal process of any class of drugs. | | Phenibut and the prevalence of RC benzos (which aren't subject | to the federal analogue act since benzos are schedule 4) are | another phenomenon. I think people underestimate the risks of | this stuff due to how easy it is to get them - especially | phenibut which is sold in a lot of more "legit" websites. | 77pt77 wrote: | Of the common legal drugs, benzos are by far the most dangerous | to quit. | | And you get addicted in like a week. | | Be very careful. | bsimpson wrote: | There was a tea bar in my neighborhood that would put kratom | in one of the teas. | | It didn't make me feel particularly euphoric, but I did find | myself craving it the next day. Shit is fucking weird and | scary. | tinyhouse wrote: | I took it for two months for sleep and had no issues quitting | it besides a few nights of taking longer to fall asleep. | entropie wrote: | > Of the common legal drugs, benzos are by far the most | dangerous to quit. | | Not sure if that's right. Alcohol withdraw can actually kill | you. | kevin_thibedeau wrote: | By the time you've developed alcohol dependence you've most | likely gained more than a few comorbidities. That doesn't | happen in a week. | ikiris wrote: | They're the same withdrawal... Benzos are just far more | potent, so the dependence can happen MUCH faster, in like | days. | hibern8 wrote: | Benzo withdrawal can as well. | entropie wrote: | Oh, I didn't know. | 77pt77 wrote: | And again, you get to that state in as little as a week. | | Alcohol takes much longer. | RGamma wrote: | Doctors prescribe benzos for sleep issues and tell you they are | safe? Do you live in the US? | shepardrtc wrote: | Yes. Some doctors do; some don't. My new doctor was horrified | when I told her what I was prescribed. She's young, and she | said the first thing they say in medical school nowadays is, | "Benzos are bad." My first doctor was much older and clearly | from a different era of medical school. | jolux wrote: | My doctor is young and gave me a limited prescription for | ten doses of lorazepam while I was adjusting to duloxetine, | which often exacerbates anxiety in the first couple weeks. | I was experiencing regular panic attacks before starting so | he wanted to be sure they didn't become disabling. Benzos | are safe when the amount and duration are carefully | controlled. The problem is chronic usage, which is more or | less contraindicated these days. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | is that a question? Benzos are not safe despite what many | doctor believe. I'm in EU. | whimsicalism wrote: | they're saying they wouldn't be so easily prescribed in the | US | SemanticStrengh wrote: | is that a joke? I'd be very surprised if doctors were'nt | abusing benzo prescriptions for GAD | RGamma wrote: | Weird this can happen in the EU to be honest. | | In Germany these things are really difficult to come by for | these minor reasons (it's probably different for the | critically ill but I wouldn't know). | | Briefly, doctors have to have special permissions to | prescribe potentially addictive or mentally altering | substances and it's only with a special, bureaucratic kind | of prescription ("BtM-Rezept"). | | That's why I always wonder how this can happen so casually. | If I'd ask my GP for benzos for sleep problems I'd most | certainly not get them even if he'd be allowed to prescribe | them and reckless prescription in this case could lose him | his license. | jotm wrote: | Wow, 1. who tf gave you phenibut before gabapentin/pregabalin? | Phenibut is notoriously hard to quit. It takes at least a few | weeks of gradual tapering down. 2. Together with a | benzodiazepine? Wew, lad. Should've also taken a few shots of | vodka before sleep for the insanity trifecta. | | Edit: sorry, I always assume _other_ people have access to | medication. I don 't so I shouldn't have laughed. | | Yeah, so there are a few gabapentinoids/gabaergics out there, | and they can help a lot. | | But please read everything you can before deciding on | something. | | Just a couple of pages of Phenibut experiences have convinced | me to not try it because there are better alternatives with | fewer side effects. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | it's less frequent but people can get addicted to pregabalin | too. | Fargoan wrote: | He probably gave himself phenibut. It's not a prescription | drug. You can just buy it online. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | there can be legitimate uses for acute exceptional benzo use | for e.g. panic attacks but yeah for anxiety or sleep they are a | slippery slope that ruin lives. As I said in my other comment, | there exist effective, saner solutions. | cameronh90 wrote: | I have a small pack of prescribed diazepam in my backpack in | case I have a panic attack. Haven't used any of them so far, | but just having them there makes me a lot less anxious. | throwaway23324 wrote: | azinman2 wrote: | That's a classic strategy. I had a brief period of panic | attacks that benzos really helped with that helped me | gradually have less and less. I don't particular like the | feeling of the benzo, luckily, so it wasn't appealing to | take outside of acute need. My doctor did seem to want to | monitor refills and asks me how often I take them (almost | never now), so he was aware of the dependence issue. I do | carry one around just in case, and very rarely, do in fact | need it. | shepardrtc wrote: | My eventual treatment for my underlying anxiety was Lexapro. | It's worked wonders. I can't say enough good things about it | - as long as you stick with it. Old SSRI's are terrible, but | newer ones work like they're supposed to. At least in my | opinion. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | SSRIs do not work for everyone. It's good that they work | great for you. | phenthrowAway wrote: | To anyone curious about phenibut: | | Don't. Just don't. Please. | | Just a few weeks of usage can cause dependence. It is notorious | for causing compulsive redosing. Withdrawal can make you unable | to sleep for days, with lingering effects like panic attacks | and anhedonia for weeks and weeks. Withdrawal from larger | quantities can cause auditory and visual hallucinations and | seizures and can even KILL you. Avoiding serious symptoms | requires an excruciating taper that can take months. The | effects of long term abuse are poorly understood. | | "But it's totally legal, and with responsible dosing can be a | potent nootropic. I'm not a drug addict, I'm a biohacker. I'm | not after a high." | | Yeah, That was my thinking too, and in hindsight that was | immensely stupid. Please just look at r/quittingphenibut before | doing anything. | | Be kind to your GABA receptors. | capitalsigma wrote: | I take phenibut about 1x/week, I have been for about 2 years | now. I think it's generally pretty OK for me, though I've | started to worry that it impacts my memory a touch, at the | edges. | | Do not take drugs every day. For real. I don't want to | victim-blame but it is wild that you expected to be able to | be able to take drugs daily for _weeks_ without withdrawals. | As a rule of thumb, unless you intend to be on it forever | (e.g. caffeine), you should never take anything more than | maybe 2 days out of 7 in the week. Psychoactive drugs are not | like aspirin, where you dabble a bit as necessary. | | Phenibut is serious stuff. Nobody would say "I had only been | drinking a pint of vodka every day for a few weeks before I | realized I might have to deal with withdrawals." | c7DJTLrn wrote: | Well that's frightening. I tried it out recently and didn't | really feel anything that would get me hooked on it but maybe | that's naive. | mckirk wrote: | My advice: Don't underestimate the substance, but also | don't give too much importance to stories of people that | overdid it and had a terrible time. People have been using | Phenibut for long periods of time without getting dependent | -- provided they space out the "Phenibut days" enough. Of | course that requires some self-knowledge: If you are the | kind of person who would have trouble keeping it to "not | more than twice a week maximum (ideally not more than once | a week) at reasonable dosages", then Phenibut can easily | turn into a slippery slope to physical dependence, with | horrible withdrawals. | | If you know yourself enough not to overdo it, it's not | _that_ terrible a thing; though your individual response to | it will of course vary, which is where the "self-knowledge" | comes in again. | heavyset_go wrote: | I've heard of people going through withdrawals after just a | single week of use. Nuts that it's sold as a supplement at | all. | | Interestingly enough, a suspected GABA prodrug that | supposedly passes the blood-brain barrier called picamilon | has been banned by the FDA, yet phenibut is still on shelves. | SemanticStrengh wrote: | picamilon is banned? That's dumb, soon they will ban | l-theanine and taurine? I really don't think you can get | addicted to picamillon like phen or benz | kayodelycaon wrote: | Some supplements are basically unregulated medications. | | I found out the hard way that L-Theanine does not mix | well with bipolar disorder. I suspect it inactivated the | mood stabilizer I was on. | heavyset_go wrote: | The FDA's argument is that it isn't a naturally occurring | substance like an amino acid: | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Picamilon#Regulation | SemanticStrengh wrote: | insane hypocrisy from the Federal Death Agency, a prodrug | is functionally the exact same thing as the endogenously | occuring substance | shepardrtc wrote: | Phenibut is horrific and should be banned. I thought I could | control it, but I couldn't. | s5300 wrote: | Because you have no self control a substance should be | banned. | | Cool world that would be to live in. | sshine wrote: | I tried it once years ago. | | Amazingly potent. I considered finding applications for it, | but alas, I had no use for it. | | Seems like a WW2 drug like amphetamines: Sure works wonders | if you're patching up people, going through horrors like a | breeze. But it ain't a peace-time nootropic with minimal | downside. | throwaway23324 wrote: | loeg wrote: | > I tell everyone to never take benzos for any reasons. I don't | care how safe the doctors say they are; they aren't. Period. | | Do you ever wondered if maybe something about your situation | might be different from most other people prescribed benzos? | For example, the concurrent phenibut use. | tinyhouse wrote: | Benzo got a terrible rep because of addicts. People who have | addiction problems shouldn't be prescribed benzos. I can tell | only my own experience working with a psychiatrist. I started on | SSRI and the first month was horrible. They gave me benzo to help | with anxiety and sleep. It really did the job, my sleep improved | a lot. I used a low dose (1/2 of what I was prescribed) and had | no symptoms besides being a bit more sleepy when walking up in | the morning. I stopped taking it after two months of taking it | daily, when things started to stabilize. I had no bad symptoms | stopping it besides a hard time falling a sleep in the first few | nights. About 4 days after I went back to normal and never had | issues since. | | I also know that in many countries benzos are the more common | sleep drugs, unlike the US where z-drugs are more common. I know | at least one person in my family that is now 90 who has been | taking benzos for sleep for about 40 years. He is doing well | cognitively. This is of course very anecdotal. | holly76 wrote: ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-05-14 23:00 UTC)