[HN Gopher] Productivity porn ___________________________________________________________________ Productivity porn Author : triplechill Score : 278 points Date : 2022-08-03 18:21 UTC (4 hours ago) (HTM) web link (calebschoepp.com) (TXT) w3m dump (calebschoepp.com) | FredPret wrote: | I recently read The Focal Point and The One Thing. While these | are tangentially related to productivity porn, they finally | allowed me to let go of optimizing my work methods and focus on | the one or two important things every | day/week/month/year/lifetime. | | Stress levels: plummeting. | | Output (& happiness) much, much higher, far more than 10x before | | Optimized work methods: I now print out a very short to-do list | for each business I work in. A literal printout from Notepad or | Apple Notes. | | "Productivity": trending towards zero | sdoering wrote: | Have these books on my list. I feel you would recommend them? | FredPret wrote: | 10/10, yes. | hahnbee wrote: | It's the lesser of 2 evils. At least I'm learning when I'm | consuming content that surrounds my work/lifestyle goals rather | than just mindlessly scrolling through content that doesn't help | me at all. | Syntonicles wrote: | Agreed. This thread is filled with people who are confusing | "consuming productivity content" with "actively being | productive". It is one thing to discount reading blogs about | time-tracking, efficiency and scheduling _instead of_ | implementing it in your daily life. It is quite another to | discount the habits of productive people. To write those off en | masse is to ignore the very real and obvious gradation of | effectiveness we see in those around us. | | There are two counter-points that are often dismissed. The | first is that if you haven't encountered the concepts, you | aren't likely to stumble upon them without searching. Learning | to plan and organize your behavior is no different from | learning the fundamentals of any other skill. | | The second is precisely your point. Our thoughts and behaviors | are driven by context. Given a person reading a blog about | time-tracking and a person who-knows-where on an infinite | social media scroll, who is more likely to close their browser | and do whatever they feel is most important? I know who I would | bet on. | Apocryphon wrote: | I think there is truth to the idea that someone who is | actually implementing these systems, even half-heartedly, is | at least putting in some effort towards whatever their goals | is. However, I don't think the following is so clear-cut. | | > who is more likely to close their browser and do whatever | they feel is most important? I know who I would bet on. | | Immersing oneself in productivity lifehacks is often a good | way to _feel_ productive without actually being so. So I | don't think either person stands to have a greater chance | than the other towards getting back to work. | Kosirich wrote: | I wonder if people with (adult) ADD are more susceptible to this. | Same as the author, I would like to hear the story of someone | breaking the cycle for good. | Ensorceled wrote: | I think the cure is to find a couple of systems that work and | "settle" on them and stick to them. | | I have settled on the idea of "Minimal Viable Day" and "Minimal | Viable Week" ... what are things that, if I did those things | AND NOTHING ELSE, I would consider the day and week a success. | | Friday afternoon, I create a MVW todo item with 2-3 important | things in it for the next week. Every morning I create MVD todo | item with several things in it (often a bunch of smaller items | and one or two largish items). | | Everything else goes into the todo list and is ignored until | the next MVD/MVW checkpoint. | | Now I ignore all other "productivity hacks" and focus on doing | this one. | Kosirich wrote: | Thanks for sharing. I understand what you mean and I'm | currently doing something similar...again. What I (often) | lack is the steps needed to go from a more complex long term | project to MVW/MVD tasks and then sustaining that in the long | run. I'm currently looking into ways of hacking this, this | being the dopamine cycle. | Ensorceled wrote: | I've been doing SCRUM for a long time ... it's pretty | natural for me to break down projects into smaller pieces | that fit into a 1 week or 2 week cycle. | alexalx666 wrote: | my ADD is coupled with being obsessive, this combo works | kstrauser wrote: | I know I am. The catch is that I _have_ to do at least a little | bit of this if I want to not be homeless. I 've settled on the | Things app with something that looks vaguely like GTD if you | squint: | | - I have an inbox. _Everything_ I agree to do that I can 't do | in the next couple of minutes goes in there. "Buy dogfood". | "Paint the house". "Do a thing for work". Everything. | | - I triage the inbox and put starting dates on everything I | can't do right now (like "buy a Christmas ornament") so that | they'll show up on my daily to-do list when the time comes. | | - I review everything weekly, add stuff I've forgotten, and | delete things I've finished or abandoned. | | And that's about it. Thing is, without this system, I can't and | won't remember to do any of the things I need to. It doesn't | matter how important it is to me to make sure I buy an | anniversary card for my wife: I'll forget until it's too late. | The above is how I walk the line between "letting my life fall | apart due to disorganization and forgetfulness" and "wasting | time optimizing a fancy process". | thenerdhead wrote: | I'm writing a book on this(in my bio). I don't claim to have | broke the cycle, but I discuss the challenges of my generation | in it. | petecooper wrote: | _adds to Safari reading list, later files to `to read` bookmarks_ | zeroonetwothree wrote: | I think it's equally unhealthy to be obsessed with being | productive 100% of the time. | triplechill wrote: | Agreed, the trick is finding the balance. Personally still | figuring how to do that. | nicbou wrote: | Here is a really pleasant video with a similar message: | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sz4YqwH_6D0 | | A writer writes. A painter paints. You are not defined by what | you want or prepare for, but by what you _do_. | | On the other hand, you don't have to spend every waking hour | being productive. You can go on a bicycle ride without measuring | speed and distance. You can work on things that won't develop | into income streams. Not everything has to be about the hustle | and the grind. | BolexNOLA wrote: | >You can go on a bicycle ride without measuring speed and | distance. | | It's kind of wild how people need metrics - myself included - | in order to feel like they _did_ something. I have been really | trying to address that in my own life after I found it had | creeped so far into my daily life that it was influencing _what | video games I play_. I mean...what? | | I blame it on the fitbit I got years ago haha | rr888 wrote: | I wonder how many "successful" people actually read this stuff. | owow123 wrote: | "im not productive" === "im not happy / socially isolated and my | self esteem is low" this statement probably holds true for 99% | who "relate" to this shite. | | Stop lying to yourself, more work wont make you happy - It didnt | the first time. | | There is no easy fix, disabling social media wont fix it. Most | gains of that nature are short lived. | | For real results its long term work on yourself and changes to | your environment (I'm just getting started on my journey of | solving this dont take it from me, talk to people > 10 years old | than you or read a philosophy book > 500 years old) | therealasdf wrote: | I unsubscribed from Ali Abdal's youtube channel for this same | reason. I have the utmost respect for him and I'm amazed at how | well he manages his life. However, i always felt anxious after | watching his videos. This video to be exact made me feel like | shit and made me decide I should unsubscribe | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tQSKyvjsUuI | travisgriggs wrote: | I'm gonna go read an article about how to be a better stoic now. | [deleted] | jedberg wrote: | I disagree with the premise. I think the things you learn reading | that tweet or that medium post can be useful. There were | definitely times when I ran into a problem and thought to myself, | "Hey I remember reading about this on Hacker News, how did they | solve it?" and then going back and finding the post and finding a | solution to my problem. | | There is also the notion of being able to make better decisions | with more "connection material" in your mind. The more you know, | the more likely you are to make a novel connection. | | I consider reading HN and the like part of building up that | library. | epolanski wrote: | The point isn't expanding your knowledge, but doing so when | there's other priorities. | jedberg wrote: | But priorities are just a personal preference and ever | shifting. Sure sometimes there are external forces driving | our priorities, like needing to finish a work project to get | paid, bur once you've taken care of those, it's totally | reasonable for "knowledge acquisition" to be at the top. | a9h74j wrote: | The article itself explores the analogy to porn more deeply than | the usual offhand reference to productivity porn, particularly | with reference to energy-sapping and demotivating effects. | redanddead wrote: | While reading this story it felt like we are subscriber() | functions to social media's eventemitters. Like we're all hooked | up to this larger system | ericmcer wrote: | If you peruse instagram accounts that post tutorials of how to do | things (cooking, art, engineering, etc.) you will quickly realize | that there are thousands of positive comments and likes on | instructional videos that teach things completely wrong. Anyone | attempting to follow the video would be baffled. This article | definitely comes up with a good term for the phenomenon behind | the success of those videos. | Barrin92 wrote: | The biggest issue with the whole productivity porn thing is that | it's fundamentally 'midwit' activity. Genuinely novel work, by | definition cuts through existing things, brushes them away and | produces something that is new. Tending to your knowledge gardens | and note taking tools and reading blogs and whatnot is just | busywork. | | People who built real things generally do so because they have | the will to do it, not because they have 500 pages of investment | advice collected on Notion. | 999900000999 wrote: | Life advice, self help, etc, all of it is too general to be | helpful to anyone. | | What works for a 46 year old married mother of 3 probably won't | be what works for a 23 year old tech nerd. | | You have this obsession with becoming some type of super human | who can do things vastly beyond your peers. | | Sure the average 30 year old living in LA will never buy a home. | | That doesn't concern you super elite hustle bro. Hustle so hard | you have 3 houses, 2 lifted trucks, and a dog who can speak basic | French. | | Most of us are by definition average. Actual life advice for our | above character would be to move somewhere with affordable | housing, only buy a lifted truck if you have cash, etc. | | No body wants to read. | | "Fix your life over 18 to 24 months by making difficult choices" | | People want. | | "Fix your life in 3 weeks, only takes 30 minutes a day" | notsapiensatall wrote: | You keep saying "lifted truck" like it's something to aspire | to, but aren't pickups dirt cheap in the US? | trebbble wrote: | God no. Even before the recent huge bump in car prices. | | They're very _common_ , but not cheap. | | They're either actual work trucks built to do real work (so, | not cheap) or are status symbols (so burning cash is part of | the point--also not cheap). | | Like with anything, you can save buying used, but I don't see | very many older trucks around these days. Dunno if a lot got | taken off the roads with Cash for Clunkers, or if rising gas | prices made older trucks less appealing so a bunch got | scrapped, or what. Seems like _most_ trucks I used to see | were older, but since they got more popular for normal | drivers, even one visibly 7-8 model years old is pretty | unusual. Less so out in the sticks, but near the city, it 's | almost all fairly-new trucks. | | The people who really want to show off can get trucks that | approach six figures, retail. Not some custom job, that's in- | demand enough that it's a normal trim level they make. | | Any extra stuff done to a truck after purchase is _sometimes_ | about functionality but _most cases you see_ will be | conspicuous consumption instead, including lift kits. Tons of | them are on trucks that 'll rarely leave pavement--they're | the same as fancy, expensive rims or whatever. | | [EDIT] Cheap (relatively cheap, anyway) light trucks _used | to_ be a thing, like in the 90s and earlier, but are damn | near not made at all, anymore. | jjice wrote: | New pick ups are pretty expensive, at least from my | perspective. A baseline F150 starts at 40k-ish. A decked out | one could run you near double that I believe. | | Compare to a baseline Civic at around 23k. | notsapiensatall wrote: | Wow. People are really paying $80k for an F-150? | | Every time I think I can't get any more cynical, life | throws a curveball like that. | BolexNOLA wrote: | Many pickup trucks in the US are basically luxury | vehicles akin to a high end Mercedes or BMW. | philk10 wrote: | wait til you hear about the waitlist for the F-150 | Lightning... | pugets wrote: | I worked with a guy who spent $55k on a new truck. We | were both making $18 an hour. He was in his early 20s | living with his parents. | | That was in 2017... I wonder if he's still paying it off. | mustafabisic1 wrote: | Love it, and totally felt this myself. That's why I created a | newsletter for remote working parents. To be on the creation side | and as least as possible on the consuming side. | | https://thursdaydigest.com/ | ChildOfChaos wrote: | Your solution to productivity porn is to create more | productivity porn? | mustafabisic1 wrote: | Everything about this post seems to be like that lol There is | something to it for sure. Thanks for the comment, you cracked | me up :D | aaaaaaaaaaab wrote: | Cool! Added this to my Notion board! | [deleted] | LordHeini wrote: | I really don't get any of those "be more productive", book, | video, course and so on. | | Every single person I know just wastes their time with that. | Usualy they work long hours and still don't get much done. | | But hey, they have Zettelkasten with things the never read. A to | do list with stuff they never do. And they go out in the morning | at 5 for jogging, while gulping down a liter of coffe or energy | drinks which results in them being groggy the whole day. | | If you ever think you need to adhere to what is preached in any | self improvement thing, just don't. | | Habe your shit in order, avoid working mor than 7 hours day and | take your weekends and vacations seriously. | | Especially in IT nothing will get you further than being smartly | lazy. | tamsaraas wrote: | You don't understand how the trick works. I am a person who | fell for the bait thrown by info / "guides" sellers.2010-2015 - | peak in my life of productivity. I was able to do damn a lot of | things altogether. Fix challenging and complex bugs, implement | modern and crazy stuff, etc. | | And my hobby project (game) became popular. Unfortunately, I | did not use any GTD / todolists, etc. Maybe a tiny todo program | like qtodotxt because it's small, and I am too greedy to pay | for todoist. | | But since the end of 2015 - I have noticed how slowly I was | starting to do smaller and smaller amounts of work. I was just | sitting and can't push myself to continue with the previous | speed of results. Not because things become more complex, but | because I can't explain to myself what is going on. | | More tasks on the todo, more things to do, more promises | freaked off, etc. And after googling for a better todo tools, | ads networks got my interest and started to offer through | youtube and ads different promoted videos about GTD, matrix | Gunzenhauser or how it is called, and other stuff. | | Tons of really nice made videos, which work like popcorn for | brains. Do X to get the Y result. Extremely easily explained | things and procedures. I followed this bullshit and dug in | because someone else was thinking for me, not me myself. I did | not realize that at that point in time. | | I think this is extremely important to bold: I was not ready to | even try to think or understand that I want to job done not by | me but by someone else. This is an important thing, please try | to remember it, I will get back to it later. | | In 2016 -> I started to learn different methodologies, follow | different literature and books which do the same, and around | the end of 2016, I got a strict understanding that this is | business. Literally structured business which makes by | themselves via tricks and manipulations with information and | reasons <-> results relations which force idiots like me follow | it, purchase more to get something that never will work. But | you are forced to purchase and learn more because you can't | make the thing work because it's impossible to make the | thing/methodology work. Because the methodology sucks. Because | it's made for business more. Like drugs -> while you read all | of that bullshit and believe in that -> you feel good, when you | trying to do something - you feel pissed off. And you face some | kind of addiction. | | God bless, I met some girl in 2019, which was suicidal, and was | hospitalized and treated by psychiatrists. She told me -> "man, | the thing that you have this is typical symptoms of depression, | try to visit doctor." | | I was denying that thing for damn a long time, maybe two years | for sure. The problem with depression - is that the thing you | can't beat alone. You will always go deeper and deeper to | darker and more problematic things which impossible to cure | yourself. That does not work like that. | | Anyway, finally, when I worked in 2020 for only two weeks in | the whole year, I strongly realized something extremely bad | with me. I tried damn everything, just imagine everything that | you can or who suggest you something: nothing helped. Literally | everything (relax, changing work, changing friends circle, | restriction of something X, doing something Y, whatever). Does | not matter. | | Just save your time and nerves - do not listen to anybody like | me. So, in 2021, I slowly got a strong wish, like when you are | hungry or want water, but that wish is about to die. This | feeling follows you every single day, every single thing. If | somehow you got a conflict / emotional problem -> boom, you | wanna die. No, this is not a "pissed off" thing. This thing is | about 3,2,1 - jump from a window. No jokes here. Crazy shit. | | Anyway. Somehow after one of such days when I almost committed | suicide -> I visited a doctor. Diagnosed with the latest stage | of depression (it's when people kill themselves), and got | offered to be hospitalized, and so on. I refused that, and I | got pills to drink and talked with psychiatrists for a few | months (until the war started). | | So. What do I want to say to you? After starting to visit | doctors who treat depression with pills + I tried to fix my | problems with professional specialists in a clinic -> I started | to feel better. | | My libido because of pills -> goes down. But my intellectual | potential -> go up in 2016-2015 years. I was able again, for | almost a month, non-stop work, work great, did tons of a good | job, and be productive. | | I did not follow any tools, methodology, etc. I just had an | inner power to do that. I got it back. Some kind of will. | | So why do I write all of that? I hope my post helps many IT | specialists like me (who feel burned) to understand those head | problems -> it's common problems, and these problems are | treated and help damn a lot to return back the previous level | of productivity of your nature. | | It will not boost you over your limits, but correct treatment | will help you cure the source of your wasted will. | | Just stop jerking for GTD / kanban / scrum / other bullshit. | All of that shit does not work and should not work. Just | abstraction, which will make life harder. If you feel extremely | overwhelmed, can't do things in time, or lose your focus, or | can't force yourself to work as you worked before ->, visit | your doctor. | | Pills are not costly, and treatment in the early stages too. | And results - damn awesome. | doix wrote: | > Especially in IT nothing will get you further than being | smartly lazy. | | One day I'll finish my "self-help" book which is all about | doing as little as possible and leaving everything until the | last minute in case it resolves itself. Unfortunately, I listen | to my own advise and will probably never finish the book. | barking_biscuit wrote: | Reminds me of that line from that movie "you and your stupid | mate" where the guy ignores the letter and doesn't open and | he says something like "If I wait 5 days and then open it, if | it's bad news then that's 5 extra days of happiness that I | got that I wouldn't have got if I opened it now". | | Can't fault that logic. | lkschubert8 wrote: | The JIT Productivity Method. You'll have it written just as | soon as someone goes to read it. | JacobThreeThree wrote: | Schrodinger's productivity. | paulryanrogers wrote: | You jest but didn't the guy who wrote "The Martian" do it | one blog post at a time? | Sinidir wrote: | What the hell. Why are you stealing my idea? I've been | working on this for 30 years. Its about 10% done. I'll do the | rest next weekend. | ozim wrote: | There is a joke: | | Boss is stepping outside of brand new BMW - good morning Joe, | you see that brand new BMW, if you keep working hard and make | more hours I will get new one next year! | stingraycharles wrote: | Being more productive rarely leads to a happy and fulfilled | life. It's often precisely those moments in life when I'm on my | least productive, that I look back on as if I really lived. | | Of course, be mindful of your time, but learn how to use it | wisely, rather than optimizing for "productivity" as observed | by others. | SoftTalker wrote: | Always needing to be "productive" or busy can be a sign that | you're avoiding something else in your life. The classic | example is the workaholic who is hiding from the reality that | he doesn't like spending time with his spouse or family. | Instead of confronting and solving that problem, he runs away | from it by working 60 hour weeks. | [deleted] | bobthechef wrote: | baby wrote: | I wouldn't put it this way. I think sometimes life gets into | the way of my work, and that's not a bad thing, and sometimes | work gets into the way of my life, and I get shit done and | feel good about it as well. | lmm wrote: | > Being more productive rarely leads to a happy and fulfilled | life. It's often precisely those moments in life when I'm on | my least productive, that I look back on as if I really | lived. | | Hmm, I've had the opposite experience. | throw149102 wrote: | I think we might just have different definitions of | productive. To me, writing code or reading a paper can be | productive, but so can a conversation with my dad or a nice | meal out. Basically I see "Productivity" and replace it with | "Productivity towards producing more personal utility" where | that utility can be anything - happiness, relaxation, actual | goods and services, etc. | | Furthermore, I think putting on the hat of "productivity" can | sometimes reveal unusual things. Like how a conversation with | a friend is just repeating the same old dreary boring stuff, | and if you put a little effort in you can have a more | "productive" conversation. | xkcd1963 wrote: | It's nice to be able to live ones potential through. This | desire seems to stem from observing others "oh, could I | eventually accomplish the same, or reach the same level?". It | seems to me though genuine happiness can also be found through | other means. | nvch wrote: | It's like fishing or hunting for somebody. Only a few pieces of | information will be today's catch (if I'll be lucky today), but | the hunting time is well spent anyway. | TrackerFF wrote: | Hustle and grind. Create 7 streams of income. Work 18 hour days - | anything less and you're a loser destined for mediocrity. Read 5 | books a week. Start trading stocks and crypto. Take cold showers, | hit the gym. Optimize your schedule, log every minute spent. | Ditch your loser friends and only hang out with likeminded - | success breeds success. Sigma grindset. Moon or bust. If you're | not worth $1 million liquid before 30, cut off your finger and | work even harder. Analyze your productivity and always look for | places to cut fat. | fastbenz wrote: | that's why I'm Doraemon now | bryanrasmussen wrote: | I believe the last line is supposed to be 'A pig in a cage on | antibiotics.' | Yajirobe wrote: | Reminds me of this awesome video - The Hustle: | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_o7qjN3KF8U | weakfish wrote: | This is my all time favorite video to show people | | > "Check robinhood. All red, just as I expected." | Trasmatta wrote: | The videos on that channel are so good that they're painful | to watch, when you realize how closely it matches the life | you're living. | | This one is my favorite (or "least favorite" depending on how | hard it hits on any given day): | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DYvhC_RdIwQ | | I feel like the people doing that channel could write a very | effective modern Office Space. | omginternets wrote: | The last minute of him stammering on the zoom call makes me | want to hide under the bed. | willcipriano wrote: | My favorite: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FDoH15ylAeo | easton wrote: | The most recent one, "Leadership Sync", pops into my head | in pretty much every meeting I've had in the last two | weeks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1RAMRukKqQg | the_af wrote: | This video is hilarious (like many on that channel). What | cracks me up is the little jokes you can miss unless you | pause some frames, like | | "...but not before I read my blogs" --> "What Ancient | Mayans Can Teach You About Living Your Best Life" | | "and journal about creativity" --> "sleep retrospective, | epiphanies: 0" | colpabar wrote: | it is insane to me that this channel is being discussed | today because literally 2 days ago it was recommended to me | on youtube. | | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y8OnoxKotPQ | cercatrova wrote: | The one about microservices is incredible: | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y8OnoxKotPQ | wizofaus wrote: | Gold! | jamil7 wrote: | 2 Years later I still have trouble watching this one, hits | too close to home for an old job I had. | epolanski wrote: | Reminds me when I had to sort some payments FE-wise which | was a very trivial array sort (there was at most 50 | payments per page, nothing impactful performance-wise) on | a json array which had a timestamp value, but CTO got | involved with this triviality for some reason and started | blabbering of how business logic had to be on the | backend. | | I literally had a working feature branch in 10 minutes, | but it ended up being a 6 weeks job involving architects, | devops, 3 backend engineers to have a microservice | implemented in GO (which basically no backender knew) to | handle those payments sorting. I'm not kidding. | | I didn't got a promotion to staff engineer or architect | few months later because CTO was fixated with "micro | services experts" which basically consisted of anyone | putting Go on their CV and having an AWS certification. | | The guys hired were so sweet, they would spend like | months repeating in the daily every day they were doing | analysis and understanding our architecture, just to | produce after 8 weeks a pdf of few pages with their in- | depth analysis of Kafka vs RabbitMQ which was basically a | summary of their landing pages lol. | | I love the information economy. | [deleted] | WelcomeShorty wrote: | So... that's me. FCUK. I really need to listen to these | "work life balance" types more. | xivzgrev wrote: | "Read Marcus Aurelius - meditations. didn't understand shit" | | LOL | jkereako wrote: | Thank you for this. | TrackerFF wrote: | The real deal folks | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjfwxZcsKoI | t00ny wrote: | Ouch | badpun wrote: | Wow. This is literally poison for the mind and soul. | jedberg wrote: | I honestly can't tell if this is satire or not. | Apocryphon wrote: | When I read "24 year old CEO" I think of Hinton: | | http://www.smashcompany.com/business/what-happens-when- | the-b... | BolexNOLA wrote: | The real Patrick Batemen folks | BbzzbB wrote: | The funniest part about this video is how he gets | absolutely nothing done professionally except read two | emails. Driving around to flash his expensive (leased) car | doesn't count. | omega3 wrote: | Isn't this a satire? | BbzzbB wrote: | Not intentionally anyway. If it was intentional, it was | to grab attention (like include a mistake in a tweet), | but it seems serious and on-brand for an | influencerpreneur. | trebbble wrote: | These kinds of windows into a life explain how some | entrepreneur/CEO types can be owner and/or CEO of like | three businesses, on the board of a couple others, in | some kind of advisory role on a couple startups, and so | on, and still always seem to be starting or trying to get | a hand in some new thing: it's because they don't really | do jack shit. | | Meanwhile the peons get an anti-moonlighting clause and | absurd claims over any work done in off-hours. | 8f2ab37a-ed6c wrote: | Nothing says you're a successful high-impact CEO like | having a camera crew following you around all day as you | work out twice and eat salad. | neilv wrote: | Finally, an innovation in dating site profiles! | dominotw wrote: | kept waiting for the punchline that never dropped. | shepherdjerred wrote: | I stumbled upon these guys in NYC! They've got the most | relatable videos. | grudg3 wrote: | I read this in my head like the intro to Trainspotting. | R0b0t1 wrote: | Fitting, overwork is a coping behavior for some people. Just | like taking drugs is for others. | owow123 wrote: | 18 hours a day? Telsa ran on 4 hours sleep, stop slacking. | | Putting you on PIP for this attitude, not very "big org" | mindset. | the_af wrote: | You can shave some slacking off time by skipping lunch and | dinner and instead chugging some Silicon Valley energy drink | mix, marketed with a fancy name. | | Wasting time with meals is for unsuccessful losers! | dvfjsdhgfv wrote: | Sounds like the beginning of a Radiohead song. | Suro wrote: | Fitter happier | | More productive | | Comfortable | | Not drinking too much | | Regular exercise at the gym (3 days a week) | | Getting on better with your associate employee contemporaries | | At ease | | Eating well (no more microwave dinners and saturated fats) | | A patient, better driver | | ... | codyZ wrote: | I think that I actually 'L - O - L' at most three times a year | when reading on my computer. "cut off your finger and work even | harder." is the best one yet! | MuffinFlavored wrote: | I get that this is satire but could you expand on why people | who want to be healthy + productive "have it wrong" (which I | feel your satirical comment alludes to?) | | You're "taking the piss" at people who value working hard/long | hours, reading, trying to be successful financially, taking | care of their health/fitness, cutting ties with loser friends | (drug addicts? bums?) | matsemann wrote: | It's not that any one of them is wrong. It's overdoing them, | or doing them all at once to the detriment of the others. | | Or more likely: the image being put forward isn't even real, | because it's not enough hours in a day to do them all. | MuffinFlavored wrote: | > doing them all at once to the detriment of the others. | | a situation comes to mind | | a father who has to ignore his wife + children because he's | addicted to "the grind/hustle" of working 12+ hour days and | traveling... so he can make money... for his wife + | children | | is there true net detriment in that case? i'm sure the wife | + children appreciate the extra income? | 0xFF0123 wrote: | It depends, there's obviously a happy medium between the | two extremes. Optimising for family happiness, sure. | Optimising for making money and expecting that to return | family happiness, probably not. | Swizec wrote: | It's like people who spend so much time optimizing their | perfect productivity system that it doesn't leave any time | for doing the things. Their entire life is about managing the | productivity system. | | Talking about the work !== doing the work. 9 times out of 10 | you're better off doing something, anything, than worrying | about productivity. Go _do_ stuff. | | Doing every productivity hack and good habit in something | like Ferris's Tools of Titans is literally a full time job if | not more. | | I have the same critique for note taking porn. | epolanski wrote: | There's nothing wrong in it, if taken lightly and in a | healthy positive manner. | | I think he's parodying the extreme fixation with one's | productivity. | ravenstine wrote: | Not who you're replying to, but the problem I see with | productivity porn is that it completely ignores the luck | involved in success. We all have agency, but some people will | work more hours and take more ice baths than everyone else | and still end up poor and irrelevant. Some people are better | off realizing they don't have "it" and taking a more relaxed | approach to life. | eptcyka wrote: | Valuing hard work, reading and trying to be financially | successful is something completely unrelated to trying to do | 18 hour work days, skimming several books a day, and running | the hamster wheel off the peg and into the frying pan. Hard | work is often what is required to be successful, but just | mindlessly toiling away is not the key ingredient to success. | | Also, what good is a friend who wouldn't come to your aid in | the hardest of times? | MuffinFlavored wrote: | > Valuing hard work, reading and trying to be financially | successful is something completely unrelated to trying to | do 18 hour work days | | Are you trying to say "it's easy to be financially | successful by working 8 hours a day instead of 18 hours"? | | like... it's "overstated" that people think they need to | "work more/work harder" to become successful? | lmm wrote: | Easy, no. Easier, yes. People absolutely overvalue | putting in more time/effort, which actually has pretty | poor returns. | CSMastermind wrote: | Some people who push these values on social media care way | more about the image of being a "successful person" than | actually doing what it takes to achieve success (which rarely | involves bragging about how hard you work on social media). | | They're at best untrustworthy sources and at worst snakeoil | salesmen. | | Speaking of the latter there's a special brand of cognitive | dissonance being shown here. | | If there were some surefire way to be rich and happy, etc. in | a very short period of time. A system so simple that anyone | could follow it then why doesn't everyone? | | If you really believe that these habits would make anyone | successful then you have to explain why everyone isn't doing | it. | | And they convince others and themselves that it's because | most people aren't willing to do what it takes. They won't | sacrifice their comfort or friends or whatever to the point | that it takes to be successful. | | If you do all these things are still aren't rich and retired? | Well it must mean you haven't sacrificed enough or worked | hard enough or whatever! | | The real answer is that none of these habits are a guarantee | of success. Are they good ideas? Sure! Like for sure eat | healthy, get enough sleep, read books, and work out. | | Like everything though there are tradeoffs, often on your | time, and moderation can be the key for most people. There | are other inputs into your success and there's no one size | fits all plan that works for everyone. | MuffinFlavored wrote: | > Some people who push these values on social media care | way more about the image of being a "successful person" | than actually doing what it takes to achieve success (which | rarely involves bragging about how hard you work on social | media). | | Devil's advocate but | | you can measurably tell if you are financially successful | (from working hard/long hours) and our healthy fitness wise | (from going to the gym/eating clean/going for a run/etc.) | | you can also measurably tell if you are in a good headspace | from meditation/yoga/reading | | I'm the first person to poop on people who "do it for the | Gram" but... | | Most people I know who post about being successful are the | same people who wouldn't want their image hurt by being | caught in a lie. | | aka... they aren't really "fronting", they are really | "about it" when it comes to living a "let's talk about it" | lifestyle | Retric wrote: | It's really tempting to assuming the things you think are | important are what actually result in success. Nobody | sees all the possible lives they could have had. | | Daily jogging seems like a healthy choice when you | wheren't hit by a car etc etc. | | Add in all the actual lying and it's easy to get an | incredibly distorted view of reality. | MuffinFlavored wrote: | Avoiding jogging (in lieu of gaining obesity/any various | degree of issues that come from lack of exercise) in fear | of getting hit by a car seems irrational, wouldn't you | agree? | | You should strive for "perfect". If "perfect" is healthy | and healthy means go for a run (with risks), you have to | weigh it against the alternative (don't run, be | unhealthy). | BolexNOLA wrote: | The guy spends so much time optimizing every minute of his | day that he's functionally not "living." | | Also notice he has literally _no_ human interaction. | MuffinFlavored wrote: | what do we define as living? | | i have many friends who swear it is more fun to work than | to "sit around watching netflix/hang out with friends | passing time/drinking alcohol" | [deleted] | ziddoap wrote: | Parent poster is referring to the people that take "healthy | and productive", condense it, distill it, then shoot it into | their veins. | | At some threshold it becomes an obsession, which is not | great. | MuffinFlavored wrote: | why would anybody want to be unhealthy and unproductive? | what is to be gained from those two characteristics? | gedy wrote: | The opposite of these people is not necessarily | "unhealthy and unproductive". | the_af wrote: | I don't think that's a reasonable take on the comment | you're replying to. | | The answer to mindless obsession with health, | productivity and success fads for entrepreneurs is not to | become unhealthy and unproductive. | | Though, on that note, what do these "productivity" and | "success" even mean? Why is being extremely productive a | worthy goal? Leisure is good, too. | maximus-decimus wrote: | Fun. The answer is fun. | | But obviously, it's not that you have fun eating because | you're unhealthy, it's that you're unhealthy because you | eat stuff for enjoyment. | | Similarly, being unproductive isn't fun in itself, but | having fun means almost by definition not being | productive. If a hobby is productive, it's not really a | hobby. | samatman wrote: | There is a whole world of lucrative fun out there. | | One thing about a livelihood though: it's never fun all | the time. | | The same is true of many serious hobbies however. | | Fun certainly doesn't have to be productive, nor is it an | antonym. | smiddereens wrote: | leokennis wrote: | I'm not qualified to comment on the health factor. In general | striving to be healthy is good, no contest there. | | But regarding working those long and hard hours (which then | cannot be spent on other things) maybe we should heed the | advice of the dying: | | https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2012/feb/01/top- | fiv... | | > 2. I wish I hadn't worked so hard. > > "This came from | every male patient that I nursed. They missed their | children's youth and their partner's companionship. Women | also spoke of this regret, but as most were from an older | generation, many of the female patients had not been | breadwinners. All of the men I nursed deeply regretted | spending so much of their lives on the treadmill of a work | existence." | MuffinFlavored wrote: | For anybody who is just scrolling by and not clicking any | links: | | Top five regrets of the dying | | 1. I wish I'd had the courage to live a life true to | myself, not the life others expected of me. | | 2. I wish I hadn't worked so hard. | | 3. I wish I'd had the courage to express my feelings. | | 4. I wish I had stayed in touch with my friends. | | 5. I wish that I had let myself be happier. | borroka wrote: | This list has been circulating forever, following the | publication of the book, and I believe they should be | called "top five very theoretical and after the fact and | with no empirical evidence they are regrets and they | would do something different if in the same position of | the dying". | | Now, think of those who like to eat until they are full, | those 7k calorie meals. There are many such cases, | especially in the United States. After such a large meal, | which would frighten weaker stomachs, if they were asked, | "Do you regret eating like that?" they would almost | certainly say yes. But they would do it again tomorrow, | some would say because they have a medical condition, | others because they love to eat and don't mind having | problems with walking, diabetes, and all the assorted | ailments that go hand in hand with overeating, or | alcohol, or any combination of the two. | | In a moment of tremendous weakness, of fear of crossing | the Acheron, when asked "do you regret working so hard?" | even the laziest worker the world has ever seen, the | anti-Stakanov, would say, "yes, I do, it's one of my | biggest regrets." | | Some of my friends did not continue studying after middle | school and sometimes say, "I would have/should have | continued studying," regardless of the fact that at that | time they were not inclined to open a textbook even with | a gun pointed at their head. But in their minds, if they | had a chance to go back in time and armed with motivation | that they did not have at the time, they would study, of | course they would. But they only like the idea, not the | action. They are the same people. And it's the same for | those five regrets, the "if I had $10 million, I would | give $9.5 million to charity." But they don't have that | $10 million. | lupire wrote: | throw149102 wrote: | I mean this is funny but this isn't at all what the post is | about. What it means by "productivity porn" is only | tangentially related with the hustle sigma male trillionaire | grindset stuff. | baal80spam wrote: | > Work 18 hour days | | ...and meditate the other 6. | ourmandave wrote: | Ultimate life hack: | | 1. Dude, move to Venus where a day is 5,832 hours. | | 2. Become a 10,000 hour expert in less than a weekend bro! | | 3. Profit! | mellosouls wrote: | You are Andrew Tate and I claim my five pounds. | | Or Russ Hanneman. | abledon wrote: | dont forget to use discountcode huberman at athetlic greens | ghostbrainalpha wrote: | I really like Athletic Greens though.... | nickstinemates wrote: | I don't. Tastes like shit. | mise_en_place wrote: | I guess I take a different approach than the author does. I waste | several hours a day on such social media consumption, but I don't | delude myself into thinking I was productive. If anything, it | lights a fire under me because I wasted so much time, and that | gives me a productivity boost to finish the things I was supposed | to do. | quickthrower2 wrote: | He seems to conflate learning with productivity porn. Doing a | course or even a short gym video is fine if (a) you sought it out | to solve a problem and (b) you apply what you have learned. | | Even serendipitous "I will learn that interesting thing on HN" if | done with purpose and diligence is fine. | [deleted] | thenerdhead wrote: | While this term gets overused, I think what we're really saying | is that we're addicted to success. Or the idea that we will be | successful if we are overly productive. | | If you watch many of the people on social media who are | "productivity gurus", you will notice that their philosophy of | how to stay productive will shift as the content gets stale and | they need something more novel to talk about with their growing | audience. Many of them are just like you and me and cover the | latest bestseller book or popular tweet that has merit to it, but | then gets discarded after we realize it doesn't work in our | lives. | | In turn, they also become wildly successful by providing you | surface level tips on how to be a little more productive each | day. | | While I used to be obsessed about this topic or what others call | "hustle culture", I think you have to go through it before you | realize how finite one's life really is. The overworking, the | "always on"-ness, the comparison to others who happened to reach | success earlier than us. | | It all doesn't matter at the end of the day. The simplistic | perspective is that you can take common occasions and make them | great and you'll find success or at least a better understanding | of your definition of "success". | googlryas wrote: | > Or the idea that we will be successful if we are overly | productive. | | I find this one the most fascinating. It implies a supreme | confidence in the correctness of one's beliefs, which I simply | have never had. As if to say, the only thing stopping my | success is my ability to drive faster, but without any doubt | that you're actually on the right road, heading the right | direction, etc... | truncate wrote: | I've come to realize that there is some kind of wisdom on not | caring too much about outcomes, being in present and keeping | things simple. For a long time, I believed in exactly opposite, | success, over-optimize - whatever I do do it right way. Until | during COVID, I found myself doing so many things, music, | fitness, coding, photography, and later dating -- and you can | constantly find endless amount of advise and new ways to do | things on YouTube, while not realizing you are getting mentally | exhausted. Trying to stay more in present, and keeping things | simple now -- not to succumb to the mass-marketing campaign of | whatever that something on internet usually is (most times it | is marketing something, be it some product or themselves). | thenerdhead wrote: | Exactly. I firmly believe that there's even a paradox to all | this. The less you care, the more successful you can be. | Almost like Office Space. | | Doing a few things very well is what separates you from | someone who does a hundred things not well at all. | | Attention is your most previous resource and it's stolen from | us everyday by others when we should reclaim it for ourselves | and those few things that we're passionate for. | bilater wrote: | Meta point: Reading this article was productivity porn. | wizofaus wrote: | But reading the comments has made my day, some zingers and | great references to other resources of genuine comedic value I | hadn't seen before. | sdoering wrote: | > Meta point | | Meta porn | redanddead wrote: | I was listening to Zuckerberg's internal Facebook memo to | employees and they're really going all out on VR, they think | it'll go big, trying to generate monopolistic effects by | subsidizing their VR hardware so that more people buy in, and | buying VR studios. | | Porn. Just give people meta porn | notsapiensatall wrote: | They can't. The money is in ads, and advertisers won't | touch anything that isn't family-friendly. | | A startup might be able to do a decent job, but they would | get booted off the app store faster than you can say a | four-letter word. | | Too bad there's no good way for users to write and run | arbitrary code on their devices. | ChildOfChaos wrote: | Yet they just increased the cost of the quest by $100 | redanddead wrote: | Just checked, yeah you're right! Wonder why | [deleted] | ketzo wrote: | Only if you don't follow its advice! | triplechill wrote: | I love this :D | atmosx wrote: | busted | [deleted] | personjerry wrote: | I think for content like this there's a scale between mostly | "feel good" fluff (i.e. Gary V stuff, imo) to mostly "useful" | stuff (i.e. Atomic Habits, imo). But everything has a mixture of | actionability and story-based fluff thrown in there | entertainment/inspirational value. | | In my opinion, the fluff gets you through the drier parts of the | reads. But what you decide to actually take out of the book and | action on - that's up to you. | | You turned it into mere entertainment when you read but didn't | take action, for example, clean up your desk to enable your | habits to begin, as clearly described in the Atomic Habits book. | | The good reads you'll probably need to note down and return to a | few times to extract all the useful, concrete advice. | jbjbjbjb wrote: | That's an interesting distinction. I think the in-between is | the worst. At least with Gary V you know you're getting energy | and motivation. Another YouTube video skimming over lessons | from Atomic Habits for the hundredth time is the mindless faux | learning to avoid. | bckr wrote: | Darn, this is completely true. I feel like such a techie when I | scroll HN and hoard links for later perusal. In fact I feel so | much better than I did about the same time spent on FB or Reddit. | But I'm still not putting that time into constructive pursuits. | alexalx666 wrote: | what helped me is having a filing system I can trust and tinker | with, check out linkding on github | amelius wrote: | Perhaps we should write down the things we _really_ learned | from reading HN, so we can decide later if it was worth the | time. | macrael wrote: | I can't find an online article where Merlin Mann discusses this | but I remember very vividly him talking about why he stopped | posting on 43Folders.com a decade ago. 43Folders was a GTD | productivity porn site and after while Merlin decided that he | didn't want to be "giving drugs to addicts" and stopped posting | little "5 ways to write a better task title" articles for all the | same reasons OP is writing about here. | dougskinner wrote: | Here ya go, one of my all time favorites of his: | https://www.43folders.com/2011/04/22/cranking | macrael wrote: | A beautiful piece, thank you. But this is more about him | prioritizing family over his book. It must have been on a | podcast I remember him talking about how he kind of had a | crisis of faith over running 43folders and stopped doing | little "life hack" posts. | Oarch wrote: | You've discovered the motivational industrial complex. I think | this nicely sums up the content of many magazines. | goatcode wrote: | I was disheartened when I read about all these successful | people and their lofty advice. I was more disheartened when I | realized their advice is just the random stuff they happened to | do that on their path to success, and that equivalent advice of | the myriad failures that complement them would never be heard | (and that both were of approximately equal value). Despite how | in the overmind the notion of "correlation is not causation," | this snake oil is surprisingly only beginning to go out of | fashion. | thenerdhead wrote: | I like to read self-help. I think it can actually change your | life. | | The problem is finding actual good self-help. Most stuff is | garbage or dives too deep into a specific topic. | | One of my favorite authors is Orison Swett Marden | (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orison_Swett_Marden) who | writes well-rounded self-help and founded a magazine | ironically called "Success". There's also Samuel Smiles who | wrote the original title called "Self-Help". | | If you go back in time far enough, you will come to the | conclusion that most self-help stems back to certain | influences at the time. You can go as far back as to the tao | te ching, meditations, or even the bible. Not much of this | stuff changes, but is repackaged with modern examples of | successful people into bestsellers. | robocat wrote: | One friend calls them "self harm books" because the vast | majority are harmful overall - sold as part of the self- | harm-industrial-complex. | WastingMyTime89 wrote: | > You can go as far back as to the tao te ching, | meditations, or even the bible. | | The Tao Te Ching with the adjonction of its commentaries is | a book on Confucian moral and ethic. The Meditations is a | journal and also mostly a book about ethics. I think | linking them to modern self-help books is somewhat | disingenuous. | | I deeply believe that if people actually stopped reading | self-help books and read books about ethics instead the | world would definitely be a far better place. "How to live | a life worth living?" is after all a far more interesting | question than "How to do the most of your life?". | [deleted] | heavyset_go wrote: | Most of the "advice" is just stuff some ghostwriters came up | with that sound good and fit into whatever image those people | want to publicly project. | prometheus76 wrote: | Goes back to Think and Grow Rich by Napoleon Hill. That | book really started the "self-improvement" movement. | ozim wrote: | You say you were disheartened. | | I bought and read Robert Kiyosaki - Rich Dad Poor Dad | followed with Donald Trump - The Art of the Deal. | | After reading these I felt worse than at the time I was | actually mugged on the street. I think I paid like $20 for | both books and muggers got something like $15 I had on me. | swyx wrote: | the irony is that they are just giving the audience what it | wants - a causal formula for success. a guy just saying "i | got really lucky" over and over would get no readership. | smiddereens wrote: | 8f2ab37a-ed6c wrote: | I would recommend | https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/54785515-four-thousand-w... | as an interesting counter-argument to all of the productivity | literature out there. | emadabdulrahim wrote: | I listened to his short lectures on the Waking Up app. Really | enjoyed them and clicked for me. I wonder if it's still worth | reading the book. | someweirdperson wrote: | > "Whether you are doom-scrolling on Instagram" [...] | | This most likely isn't intended to be reading a never-ending | stream of bad news (on instagram?), but simply an endlessly | scrolling site that keeps loading content before reaching the end | of the page. The wiktionary definition [0] seems wrong. | | [0] https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/doomscrolling#English | californical wrote: | I think that people use it hyperbolically rather than literally | in that context -- the original meaning is correct, but people | use the word in an exaggerated context to make a point | [deleted] | biztos wrote: | One of the original, and most effective, competition hacks is to | convince people that you sleep less than they do. | | When someone tells you they sleep 5 hours a night then run two | miles and take a 15-minute cold shower then start their work day, | 85% of the time they are lying, 10% of the time you will have | already noticed the effects of chronic sleep deprivation, and 5% | of the time it's drugs. | | But this has been a surefire way to put your competitors on the | back foot for hundreds, probably thousands of years. | the__alchemist wrote: | Where's the line? Watching self-help content is described in the | article as productivity porn. What about reading a self-help | book? A (let's say good quality) non-fiction book? A scientific | paper? A text book? Taking a class? Working on a project that is | likely to fail? Writing code? Writing an article? Writing a book? | | > When I look for solutions to this problem I only come up with | half-baked ideas and more questions. | | It sounds like the author's talking about science. | Ensorceled wrote: | If you are spending all your time "sharpening your saw" and no | time "cutting wood" ... you are probable over the line. | sdoering wrote: | I think in the end the question is what the result is. Does the | self help content prompt action, ideally sustainable action. Or | is it porn as described. | | Like porn could be a tool for people to engage in | (re)productive action. Or just porn. | ketzo wrote: | I think the easy rule of thumb is "do you ever actually _do_ | the thing you read about?" | cpach wrote: | I like to read about lots of things. Urban planning, | manufacturing, arts, culture, movies, politics, etc etc. | | Am I a manufacturer? Do I make oil paintings? Do I direct | movies? Am I an elected officiel? No. I'm in tech, doing | programming and sysadmin things. I'm a small cog in the whole | scheme of things. Still interesting to read about what's | going on in other fields. Nothing wrong with that IMHO. | ketzo wrote: | Agreed - but by the same token, I don't think you would | call any of that reading "productivity-related," right? | | Whereas if I, a software engineer, read 100 articles about | micro services and make a bunch of grand plans without ever | actually implementing anything... pornography. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-08-03 23:00 UTC)