[HN Gopher] What We Gain from a Good Bookstore ___________________________________________________________________ What We Gain from a Good Bookstore Author : pseudolus Score : 163 points Date : 2022-08-06 11:56 UTC (11 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.newyorker.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.newyorker.com) | tomhoward wrote: | There's a great story [1] of how established Australian | independent bookstore Readings survived the entrance of Borders | into the market in the early 2000s. | | Borders opened a huge store directly over the street from | Readings' flagship store and tried to wage a price war, whilst | Readings kept its prices up and redoubled its efforts at | providing a great experience to customers. | | Since Borders shut down in Australia in 2011, Readings has | continued to expand and thrive, now operating seven stores in key | locations around Melbourne, but still retaining its small- | business, community-focused charm, and still just selling good | books to book lovers, as it did when it first opened in the late | 1960s. | | [1] https://rosshoneywill.com/articles/how-mark-rubbo-killed- | bor... | PaulDavisThe1st wrote: | Sorry, everyone. | TedDoesntTalk wrote: | I wonder if Gen Z will know book stores that aren't Barnes & | Noble or independents who sell everything from books to socks to | chocolate, but still call themselves bookstores. | reaperducer wrote: | Don't worry too much about Gen Z. They seem to be correcting | the mistakes of the Millennial generation, and behave much more | like Gen X than their immediate predecessors. | TedDoesntTalk wrote: | Great to hear. In what categories have you noticed that? | pessimizer wrote: | They'll know nothing about the mildew-stinking catacombs I used | to explore. Never know the feeling of finding a bargain, or a | book that you couldn't find any information about. Everything | is coffee-comfortable, tastefully decorated, and overpriced. | Every indie bookstore a chain-in-waiting. | satiric wrote: | We'll I do and I'm gen z, although I've inherited that from my | mom. If not for her I don't think I would care about bookstores | at all. Not a lot of the people I know read books these days, | it's been replaced by TV, YouTube, and video games. Not that | that's inherently a bad thing (there's plenty of good, | thoughtful content and plenty of mediocre, dopamine filled | content - just like with books) but it will be interesting to | see how it plays out. | | Ultimately I think I spend too much time on these kinds of | things anyway, and would rather spend time making something. I | tend to find more enjoyment from actively creating rather than | passively absorbing. | TedDoesntTalk wrote: | Thanks for the perspective. | gmiller123456 wrote: | ... you can't adjust your glasses without hitting some Strand- | branded merch | | The irony of this statement is all of the ads, plus a pop-up on | the website making the criticism. The exact percentage is going | to change based on window size, but on my desktop it's about 40% | content, 60% ads at best. At worst, disregarding the popup, when | the inline ads are shown, 100% of the window is ads. | gz5 wrote: | Work from home / hybrid shift may help? Anecdotally, folks seem | to seek more in-person or in-community experiences when they lose | some of what they used to get from the in-office experience. | | For some folks, there also seems to be a slight shift from | prioritizing destination to prioritizing journey, and from | efficiency to experience. | | These shifts may not be enough to make the business models work | for most, but bookstores with good locations and experiences can | sell plenty of high-margin food and beverages, and can possibly | find new business model edges (subscription?, joint subscriptions | w/ other businesses?, event hosting?, classes?). | throwaway0x7E6 wrote: | nothing. physical bookstores and libraries are obsolete. they | don't serve a purpose anymore. | | the electronic format is superior in every way - full text | search, fully customizable/accessible reading experience. ebooks | cost nothing to "print", transfer and store, and they don't | degrade. | | a 500 GB SD card fits 25000 rather large 20 MB pdfs/epubs. a 16 | TB HDD fits 800000. | | it's over. and that's a good thing. | ryanobjc wrote: | There's a few areas where paper is vastly superior: | | Doesn't require power to operate | | The tactile experience is top notch, and makes for fast seeking | in the book | | You can sell or lend the book without permission from someone | else | | Edit: also books don't have dynamic tracking or affiliate links | or scams for getting you to buy something - this is more | apropos to websites. Still though, I hear people say that long | form is dead and internet video/short form, or even blogs is | the way real knowledge is passed on. | throwaway0x7E6 wrote: | >You can sell or lend the book without permission from | someone else | | I can give you a copy of any book I own for free | jakewalters wrote: | Victerius wrote: | If you want to find more secondhand books, check your local | colleges and universities. Some have annual book fairs where | books are sold at heavy discounts. I found some gems at such a | fair when I went a few years ago. You need to go early though, | because others will snatch the best titles if you don't. I also | went there a few weeks ago to drop a load of my old textbooks, | some of which are like new. Hopefully, they make their way into | hands that will find a use for them. | | Anecdotally, I currently have an outstanding book order on Amazon | for a title I'm convinced I wouldn't find anywhere in store. The | title is 20+ years old and a little niche. | wrycoder wrote: | Try Abebooks.com, which is also owned by Amazon. | montefischer wrote: | Also biblio.com, which is not. | reaperducer wrote: | _check your local colleges and universities. Some have annual | book fairs where books are sold at heavy discounts._ | | In Chicago, and many other cities, larger library branches have | a little room where the books the library doesn't want anymore | end up. | | In the case of Chicago, the Harold Washington Library has a | room with a table and stacks of books. You grab what you want | and put a suggested donation into the box on the wall. Usually | about 25C/ a book. | | In other cities, I've seen this expanded into entire miniature | bookstores. But in those cases, they end up charging second- | hand retail prices, which is a shame. | akudha wrote: | Curious, what book did you order at Amazon? | goldcd wrote: | I don't really think that's what the article was getting at. | (although I'm not quite sure what it was trying to do) | TedDoesntTalk wrote: | > I'm convinced I wouldn't find anywhere in store | | In the "old days" before Amazon, you would place a custom | order at the book store (Not a second-hand book store) and | it'd arrive a while later. | mattkrause wrote: | You still can! | | I was interested in a book that went for $120 on Amazon; a | local shop ordered for me at $80 instead. It took about a | week, so maybe a hair longer than Amazon. Oddly, I found | the link directly from the publisher. | jonhohle wrote: | In my teens I nearly wore out my local library's copy of | the Terminator 2 Illustrated Screenplay. In the late 90s, | on a whim, I went into a B&N that had just been added to | the mall where I worked and placed an order, even though I | knew it had been long out of print and the likelihood of it | ever showing up was near zero. | | Around a year later I got a call that my book was in and I | could go pick it up. When I arrived, a pristine, new, old- | stock copy was waiting for me as if it were still 1991. I | still have that book proudly displayed - both the joy of | its contents and its discovery will accompany it for the | rest of my life. | | eBay, Amazon, Shop Goodwill have made this process | immensely easier, but I still find joy and thrill in the | random second hand store finds. | TedDoesntTalk wrote: | Now I want that book :) | sideway wrote: | I'm intrigued by all these comments praising second-hand | bookstores as I've never been in one myself. My discovery methods | are pretty simple and quite targeted. | | Could you name some interesting, non-fiction books you've | discovered that would be impossible or hard to find in online | bookstores? | thundergolfer wrote: | I have come to value 2nd hand bookstores so much in day to day | life that I maintain it as an almost 'must have' when assessing | living locations. Great coffee shops are a dime a dozen in | reasonably affluent areas, but a good 2nd hand bookshop adds so | much warmth and charm to an area. | | I don't have any in walking distance from where I live right now, | but I'm moving to NYC soon and will aim to correct that. | (Shouldn't be too hard, right?) | | > Think of what's happened at the Strand, where a coffee shop | recently joined some ground-floor bookshelves and where you can't | adjust your glasses without hitting some Strand-branded merch. | | I did notice that when I was there in May. They place was | overstuffed and too commercial. I also didn't get a sense of what | Deutsch calls the "slow time of the browse" because I was too | caught up keeping polite distance from the too-crowded aisles. | waspight wrote: | Just curious, why is second hand book stores that important? I | imagine that everything worth reading is available on Amazon | and rated in Goodreads. I am just curious and hopefully I am | totally wrong as well. | yojo wrote: | I'll offer another perspective: human interaction. Good book | stores have good staff, helpful other humans that will engage | with you and guide you to something you would like. | | Computers can fill some, but not all of this role. We are | social animals. We are hard wired to feel good when we are in | community with other humans, and to (in cases) develop | psychosis when deprived of that contact[1]. | | The price of a book is trivially easy to compare, while the | value of social interaction is hard to quantify. Replacing | in-person commerce with online shopping because it is less | expensive or more convenient may not be as good a deal as it | seems. | | 1: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8131183/#abs0 | 00... | fritztastic wrote: | Having visited many second hand bookstores in different | cities, there are absolutely books out there worth reading | not available online- soke will never be available online. | There are a lot of obscure books out there- old, self- | published, or just really niche subjects- which will never be | popular or wanted enough to find reproduced digitally. | | Besides being an experience in and of themselves (used | bookstores are often very unique and individual, sometimes | operated by interesting people who do it out of a love of | books or history), you can find some real gems and sometimes | even terrible unbelievable books of decades past that would | never be something you could find in a regular | commercial/corporate book shop selling for profit and | catering to whatever is on the bestseller list, what critics | recommend, and what publishers want to sell. | | Besides the experience and obscure books, used bookstores | often are the best places to meet interesting people. Some | people, myself included, love the atmisphere of these shops- | the smell of old books, the piles of otherwise discarded | tomes, shelves where you can find books that were once part | of collections curated by bibliophiles- some of these books | have annotations on them, some of them are on very niche | subjects not easily found elsewhere, some so old if you look | for information online you won't find anything. I've had and | heard some really fascinating conversations in second hand | bookshops I don't think I would ever have experienced | otherwise. Some of these shops are a place of community, | where people post business cards and event posters for things | you wouldn't readily find out about easily- some host events | in the store itself (discussion groups, games, book clubs, | etc). Some have very comfortable atmosphere and welcome | people coming to just hang out, no pressure to spend money. | Additionally there is the possibility there for you to build | a bond with the owners/keepers, who sometimes will bring out | books they keep off the shelves just for you. | | Some old book shops are absolutely packed with everything | from textbooks to catalogues to literature- unsorted | treasures waiting to be found. Books with no ISBN, no online | presence whatsoever, items that cannot be found otherwise | (unless you were looking for them specifically, and even then | they would be really difficult to procure). There is a charm | to be found in these shops that just cannot be replicated in | common bookstores. | BuyMyBitcoins wrote: | For me personally, it's the experience and atmosphere rather | than the availability. There's also the charm of browsing | without looking for anything specific in mind. I know it is | possible to be shown a random assortment of books online, but | it doesn't compare with simply walking down the aisles and | just scanning over all the titles for what looks interesting. | tomc1985 wrote: | And supporting them is supporting a faceless corporation run | by young, ageist technocrats, where all your rights are | squashed under DRM | Swizec wrote: | You can't browse Amazon, it's too in your face trying to make | a quick buck. | | I just tried browsing Goodreads and it slapped me in the face | with a gigantic Please Login Right Now You Terrible Person | modal. Not very browsing friendly either, I guess. | | There is a charm to browsing a small bookstore. 2nd hand or | otherwise. You dawdle in the aisles, meander between sections | you'd never think to look at, catch your eye on interesting | covers, try the heft of a book, see which ones are long and | which are short, the design and the font give you a sense of | character, tell you a little about what this book is like to | read. You turn it around, read the back to learn more ... | there is a spatial component to your search. When you stumble | into a book that draws your attention, you're likely | surrounded by similar books you might also enjoy. | | The experience is distinctly _in_ efficient. Good for when | you don't know what you want. Might not even realize what | you're in the mood for until you find it. | | And somehow you never walk out with fewer than 3 books. | simion314 wrote: | Just IMO, but with physical books you can open them and | inspect the content, this might not be important for | literature books but for more technical books you want to see | examples. I am not from US and our online book stores do not | allow you to electronically browse the books. Review might | help, I wanted to buy a programming book for my son (Roblox | sutff) and a review told me that the code listings are | garbage and there is no actual care in the type setting of | the book, now imagine I buy this book at the moment there is | no such a reivew(and if the review was wrong then I avoided a | good book), with a real store you can see for yourself, the | downsides that the book selection might be limited for niche | subjects. | | Also I think is faster to evaluate the book if you have it in | your hands, you can immediately notice if the quality is bad | or good, if the fonts are maybe too small so it would be hard | to read, if the content feels padded with tons of irrelevant | stuff, if you like the art style or language of the author. | Is the same like when you want to buy a phone or monitor, if | you have it in your face you can imediatly spot things you | don't like and see the real dimensions where if you have just | some pictures and numbers in your face it is harder.(I bought | a watch as gift for someone and when it arrived I was shocked | how small it is in reality, there were numbers in the | description but numbers felt ok for me at that time) | milesvp wrote: | It's the type of people they attract. It's the owners who are | often very avid readers. It's the collection of books you | find, most of which have had some amount of curation, if only | because of limited shelving. They are often very low margin | so often they add charm in the same way artists do to a low | rent neighborhood. | anigbrowl wrote: | Because you don't know what you don't know, and neither does | Buy'n'Large. In a second hand bookstore you'll come across | things in the same category that are useful and important but | don't come up in a recommendation engine because they're not | popular. The deeper into a field you go, the more noticeable | this is. | | Also, the second hand bookstore isn't maintaining a secret | police file on every micro-action and momentary impulse you | exhibit while inside their property. | shever73 wrote: | This is a thoughtful question. For me, it's the personal | contact and supporting a local business. Amazon actively (and | knowingly) harms the book trade and ignores the fact that its | third-party sellers sell counterfeit items. | | Browsing a second-hand book store is just one surprise after | another. I've found books I never knew existed, but instantly | fell in love with. I whiled away many hours in second hand | bookshops when I visited Edinburgh. | | When it comes to new books, making a purchase at a local book | store can really make a difference. Last year, I wanted to | upgrade my ebooks of The Art Of Programming to the print | editions. I could buy it from Amazon, but asking my local | book store to order in the items was a wonderful experience | on so many levels. The cost was a little, but not a | significant amount, higher, but it allowed for some great | interactions in the shop. Now, I pop in every couple of | weeks, have a chat with the owner and get fantastic | recommendations. | reaperducer wrote: | _I imagine that everything worth reading is available on | Amazon and rated in Goodreads._ | | Then you should broaden your imagination. | | Amazon and Goodreads have barely a fraction of one percent of | the books that were published. And that's just in English. | | It's like saying "Anything worth watching is on streaming," | even though less than 5% of the world's video content ever | made the translation from film to VHS to DVD to streaming. Or | paper to records to tape to CD to streaming. | | There's a whole vast world of content out there beyond the | internet. Once you discover this, it's like taking a pill in | The Matrix. | | (My metaphor might be off there, as I've never seen The | Matrix, but from what I understand from other people's | conversations, that should work.) | dredmorbius wrote: | Where are you getting your count of books available on | Amazon? | | I'd be curious how this compares with LibGen / ZLibrary | (about 4--5 million titles). | fritztastic wrote: | I understand your metaphor in the sense that The Matrix is | a scifi adaptation of the allegory of the cave. The concept | that commercial/online bookstores are where items worth | finding will be found is like thinking the shadows of the | cave are the only thing worth seeing. You are correct, | there is so much content there be found, which isn't | limited/controlled by what the big market values. | | Additionally those are very good points about English and | streaming. There are books out there which are not | translated and not digitized, which are absolutely worth | reading, and will not be found anywhere besides private | collections, used bookstores, flea markets, estate sales. | Some of these books were originally purchased long ago | and/or far away, just because they are not popular enough | to be easily found does not mean they are not worh finding. | bombcar wrote: | A friend of my dad is a professional book hound, and he | says it amuses him when he sees others who can't | understand what to do with a book that doesn't have an | isbn. | MikusR wrote: | > Amazon and Goodreads have barely a fraction of one | percent of the books that were published. And that's just | in English. | | Source? | [deleted] | bananamerica wrote: | Used bookstores are great for discovery, you often end up | with something random and unexpected that you would never buy | on a digital storefront. | NegativeLatency wrote: | Aside from other stuff listed: Local businesses enrich the | local economy, while buying from amazon does not | | Also I'd suggest checking out a good local bookstore, it's a | whole different and IMO a more wholesome and relaxing | experience. | pradn wrote: | The Strand is only worth going to as a tourist attraction (if | you're fully aware of its status as such), or if you need big | art books (they're unmatched in that category). | | In NY, I'd say take a look at Left Bank books (rare, old | literature, photography, art books - some are even early | editions of classics), Codex (little used shop with a fantastic | selection), Mercer St Books and Records (basement hole in the | wall), Westsider Rare and Used books (an UWS classic), | Unnameable Books (good events and a literary selection). | | For new books, McNally Jackson is the preferred one for the | reading public. Their staff selections are useful and they have | a dedicated poetry and chapbook section. | sthu11182 wrote: | I agree on Westsider. However, I always liked the Strand for | its collection of history, science, and math books. While | Strand can be crowded and touristy, it still has a good | collection of books. | euroderf wrote: | They have the books, but be prepared for life on a ladder | if you really want to dig in. | ghaff wrote: | The Strand is one of the places/attractions/etc. that it's | easy for locals to dump on a bit because it's something | popular with tourists. But the reality is that they can be | a lot of fun. | | The last time I was in NYC, I was really hurting because of | not one but two bad hamstrings cause by hockey. I could | barely walk--which is not a great combination with NYC. I | had some time and took a Circle Line cruise. It was | delightful and I hadn't done it since I was a child! | sidpatil wrote: | My favorite is East Village Books. I've had luck finding | interesting books there. | kingkawn wrote: | The one true bookstore in nyc is Book Thug Nation in | Williamsburg. The best curated selection of used literature | I've ever come across and a smattering of other stuff too. | integrale wrote: | If you end up in Manhattan: Mercer Street Books, Alabaster | Bookshop, and Joanne Hendricks Cookbooks are some of my | favorites. The latter two aren't necessarily cheap but have | some really cool stuff. | sircastor wrote: | > I don't have any in walking distance from where I live right | now, but I'm moving to NYC soon and will aim to correct that. | (Shouldn't be too hard, right?) | | Unfortunately, Fox Books put all the small, independent stores | out of business. | [deleted] | jhbadger wrote: | I know you are making a reference to 1998's "You've Got | Mail!", but that movie was (besides being based on the | earlier movie 1940's "The Shop Around The Corner" hence Meg | Ryan's store, and the Hungarian play _that_ movie was based | on), inspired by the story of how NYC 's Shakespeare & Co. | bookstore was driven out of business by a new Barnes & Noble | nearby. That Barnes & Noble has since closed itself. | SeanLuke wrote: | Wait wait wait. I had to look this up myself: there exists | a bookstore chain in New York City and Philly called | _Shakespeare & Co_? And it appears to have no relationship | at all with the uberfamous Shakespeare and Company | bookstore in Paris? This is a bit like naming your new | restaurant chain "The French Laundry". How could they be | allowed to do this? | jhbadger wrote: | To be fair, even the current Paris-based bookstore of the | name isn't the "real" one founded by Sylvia Beach in 1919 | (that closed in 1941). I think the various bookstores of | the name today do so in honor of Beach's store so they | don't really claim ownership of the name. | SeanLuke wrote: | No, that is _not at all_ fair. This wasn 't a cold | business decision. | | George Whitman, who founded the current Paris bookstore, | and Sylvia Beach, who founded the original, were very | close friends. She even toyed with reopening her original | shop with him, again under the name Shakespeare and | Company. Two years after she died, he renamed his | bookstore (Le Mistral) to Shakespeare and Company _in her | memory_ in 1964, as he thought that 's what she would | have liked. He also named his only daughter after her. As | it happens, the second Shakespeare and Company also | became a hub for authors like Langston Hughes, Richard | Wright, James Baldwin, and many of the Beats. It's the | sister shop of City Lights in San Francisco, with a | similar author history. Whitman was awarded the _Officier | de l 'Ordre des Arts et des Lettres._ His daughter now | runs the store. | | So in Paris there were two Shakespeare and Company | bookstores, both extremely famous at different critical | times in literary history, whose respective owners were | very close, and which were both basically set up the same | way. I think it's reasonable to say that they're both the | "real" Shakespeare and Company. That's a far cry from the | NYC situation. | timst4 wrote: | When you walk down the quai along the Seine in Paris, there are | used book kiosks for kilometers. The bouquinistes have been there | for many years and maybe they are the true enduring heart of | French values. Americans consume TV like the French read books, | at least in the capital. It is no surprise the overall awareness | of the population is far more attuned to the realities of a | modern world. America has outsourced their perception of the | world to megacorporations hell bent on profit. Reading is an | ethical act, and it is also a necessary one (we are finding out) | for Democracy. | pseudolus wrote: | The bouquinistes might conjure up romantic notions of a book- | loving French population but the reality is a little more | complex. Bouquinistes are regulated and apparently are required | to allocate three out of every four boxes of merchandise to | books. This apparently is causing them some financial hardship | as many are located in areas frequented by non-francophone | tourists and, given the choice, many would prefer to sell | postcards and the omnipresent models of the Eiffel Tower that | everyone takes home with them. [0]. | | [0] https://publishingperspectives.com/2010/10/paris-seine- | side-... | throwaway821909 wrote: | That the problem is apparently only in tourist areas is | further evidence that the French love books, if anything | vonnik wrote: | One of the great thing about the physical sites of used-book | stores, which I've never seen replicated in an online store, is | their ability to surface books you'd never know to look for. It's | not just curation, but the accumulation of curation over many | years, and the willingness to leave interesting books on the | shelves to wait for the right reader. | | Great second-hand book stores are riddled with wormholes into | past civilizations and cultures, maybe just a few decades old, | that no one ever bothered to name or remember, outside the | wormhole of the book. So I guess they make the past more | discoverable. And by discovering those lost cultures we can | understand the trajectory of our culture, its effervescence and | loose ends and lost causes. Which is great for understanding our | own time. | | Rant: American culture seems fascinated with time travel and | alien intelligence, as though they were things just out of reach, | when in fact, we're surrounded with time travel and alien | intelligence that we manage to ignore. The books are the time | travel. The ravens/dolphins/dogs/elephants are the alien | intelligence. | ryanobjc wrote: | It's really interesting - we've seemingly given up on curation | and discovery on the internet. There's just too much spam and | scam to really make it work. Take your average recipe website: | it includes multiple paragraphs of irrelevant "background | story" to delay you seeing the recipe for more ad views. | | Whereas books and libraries have none of that cruft. If you | want to learn something the library (or bookstore) is a much | better place - the books don't come with dynamic ads and | affiliate links to encourage you to buy something. | elliekelly wrote: | It's not just with books, either. I think the deliberate | inefficiency is a selling point for a lot of brick & mortar | stores now. In second hand stores and stores like Home Goods | or Five Below you have to sift through a bunch of | disorganized crap to maybe find something you didn't even | know you wanted. It's like loot box shopping, I guess. | me_smith wrote: | I absolutely enjoy finding a used bookstore while exploring a new | town or city. I can't help but meander through the dusty, over | stocked aisles overflowing with old and new books. The | personality of the store is not just built from the owner but | also the surrounding community and the books they read. Some | stores have large science fiction sections; some have larger | history sections; and some may even have an actual engineering or | computer science section. | | During one of my meanderings, I found "Structure and | Interpretation of Computer Programming" (SICP) lying under | computer reference books on the top shelf. I got the old rickety | foot stool, pulled the book down and found it was in decent | shape, so I had to buy it. And yes, I know I can read it for free | online. | | If anyone is in the San Jose, CA area, check out the Recycle | Bookstore. One of my favorites. | rr808 wrote: | Meh, I really dont miss bookstores, and I suspect most people who | claim to love them are exaggerating. I dont read as much as I | used to, my local library is good and online is much cheaper and | convenient. What is cool is second hand books if you can get | browse for something interesting cheap that you didn't know you | wanted. | wrycoder wrote: | It's also true in new bookstores that by browsing the stacks, | you find books you didn't know existed and are interesting. | Amazon does a very poor job of that - even the top 100 in a | category are not as interesting as the selection in my local | small bookstore in the same category. That's because the local | bookstore is curated. Amazon is sorted by "popularity". | | The Harvard Coop was about the last good technical bookstore in | my area, but it's been dumbed down, and now just mostly carries | the pop science stuff, like other bookstores. | | I haven't been in the MIT Coop since they moved for the second | time. They used to be right in the middle of the campus. | bwanab wrote: | I read a lot and every day. 90% of my reading has been on my | iPad in the last several years because I agree it's just much | more convenient. Despite that, I still love the ambiance of a | good bookstore. | wrycoder wrote: | I'm a constant reader, and I'm doing more reading on my | devices, using Kindle and Libby for books that I'm only going | to read once. I have way too many books in my house, and I | actually don't have enough time left to finish reading them | all! | sudobash1 wrote: | I'm glad that these other venues work for you, but don't assume | that everyone else values the same experiences as you. Speaking | personally, I find that a physical used book store has many | practical and aesthetic advantages over an online store. (An | example of a practical benefit for me is discovering new | writers.) | | I know many people who in actuality love and prefer a physical | bookstore. This is evinced by many profitable bookstores in my | area (both new and used). | WolfeReader wrote: | "I suspect most people who claim to love them are | exaggerating." | | I can't imagine why a person would either think, or write, this | sentence. Most people are being honest when they say they enjoy | a thing. | fritztastic wrote: | I'd chalk it up to an egocentric assumption, because it's not | hard to accept people love things. I don't care much for old | cars but I understand that for some people it's a huge | passion they have a lot of love for and they're not | exaggerating when they mention how much it means to them. | | Some people (myself included) genuinely love bookstores in | general and used bookstores specifically. It's not an | exaggeration, if I lived near a good bookstore I would be | there regularly. | rr808 wrote: | My reasoning is that loads of people I meet say they love | books and bookstores - but when I go to one of the few | bookstores left in my area they're mostly empty, or usually | mostly families looking for kids books. | padolsey wrote: | I'm probably one of those people who waxes lyrical about | bookstores but don't really find myself in them nowadays. | To me it's a special experience tho. I experience them like | museums and there are very few left (!!) that are imbued | with that character of poetic chaos and serendipity. The | only book shops left may indeed only be frequented by the | demographics that keep the margins nice and fat. So I | suppose there's a hidden bias in your observation. | reaperducer wrote: | Because it reinforces his own assumptions and prejudices. | It's a way of justifying a thought that is easily disproven. | | By portraying someone who doesn't think the way you do as a | bad person (in this case, a liar), this person elevates | themselves, in their own mind. | | It's pretty much seventh-grade logic. | mattkrause wrote: | A (good) public library may also scratch a lot of the same | itches: you can browse the stacks, they sometimes have | events and "staff picks", etc. | closedloop129 wrote: | >What an unparalleled activity it is to browse a bookstore in a | state of curiosity and receptivity, chewing one's intellectual | cud!" This isn't the cheap, fast-food browse of the scroll but, | rather, something more meditative, more nutritious. | | >Deutsch's bookseller is a cross between a curator, rabbi | (Deutsch comes from an Orthodox Jewish background), and gardener. | "Our work is to select and assemble, making the discordant wilds | of bookish inquiry manageable," he writes. | | In other words, a better link aggregator. What does it take to | create that depth online? | swayvil wrote: | Have you ever thought that this whole "dream evocation and | amplification via text-consumption" thing might be a dead end? I | mean, 99.999% of the meaning is coming from your own head anyway. | And there is this powerful and toxic illusion of "knowing", which | ain't good. | | It's basically solipsism-opium. Might be a bad trade. | ryanobjc wrote: | Isn't this argument a fancier version of "civilization is | dumb"? | widowlark wrote: | Amazon proved that it takes more than low price to sell a good | book. Thats why their physical stores are gone | selimthegrim wrote: | I am enraged that the local anarchist secondhand bookstore and | lending library was replaced right before I moved here by condos | and a brunch place. | bombomdifgity wrote: | solmanac wrote: | Make an anarchist zine and distribute it at that brunch place. | abdullahkhalids wrote: | For anyone else wondering, the one in Montreal on St Laurent is | still there according to Google Maps. | mattkrause wrote: | I thought it had turned into a spa or some such. | | Will report back later--it's hot out now! | selimthegrim wrote: | There was a makerspace I went to in Montreal which I wonder | if it's still active. | | E: it was Foulab, so looks like it still is. | selimthegrim wrote: | Wrong New World French city ;) | JasonFruit wrote: | There are several good independent bookstores in Madison, WI, the | medium-sized college town near which I live, and I'm happy to say | that most seem to be well-supplied with customers who actually | buy books, and have not resorted to the shenanigans this article | describes. | | One of my favorites, Leopold's, does have a small coffee shop | that serves the best coffee in town. That's not what makes me | love it, though: its small collection is arranged by country (or | in some cases region), and it's exquisitely selected. Every time | I go in, I find several books that I would never have noticed or | thought to search for in a more traditionally-arranged bookstore: | Turkish religious wisdom stories, a history of the Russian | revolution, a volume of Sholom Aleichem's stories, the | autobiography of a woman who lost her family to the Khmer Rouge | -- it's a treasure of a collection. I expect to keep going back | there for a long time. | | I wonder if other bookstores could stand out like that by | structuring their collections in a way that helps their customers | find interesting things they might not otherwise look for. I | think -- though I'm no expert -- that most people go into a | bookstore thinking not, "I need to find a copy of _X_ ," but "I | hope I find something good to read!" A bookstore that solves the | second problem connects better with actual customers. | | A quibble with the article: | | > "Browsing" itself is an agricultural term, he points out, in | one of his book's many divagations, often entertaining but | sometimes a bit twee, on the culture and language of | bibliophilia: it's what cows do in a field, and only started to | be used to describe reading habits in the nineteenth century. | | Cows don't browse; they graze, evenly cutting the omnipresent | grass. Goats are browsers, picking bits of what they believe are | the tastiest, most nourishing plants, and leaving the ones they | don't care for. | blockwriter wrote: | Madison has a great small business community in general. I am | always really impressed by the number of small, independent | establishments of good quality when I go. | bee_rider wrote: | The analogy seems to fit goats a little better anyway. And we'd | all like to be goats, right? Nobody wants to be a cow. I wonder | if the specification of the ruminant was an addition by author | of the article, and not really what was originally intended. | | > "Books, like the leaves and shrubs known as the browsage, | provide ruminant-readers with their nutrients," Deutsch opines, | at his purplest. "What an unparalleled activity it is to browse | a bookstore in a state of curiosity and receptivity, chewing | one's intellectual cud!" | JasonFruit wrote: | I agree that it's a quibble with the article, not Deutsch. | BurritoAlPastor wrote: | Ironic that this review of a memoir about bookstores starts off | by linking to it on Amazon. | neovive wrote: | Just noticed that as well :). It also looks like an affiliate | link. | O__________O wrote: | Yes, the "tag" parameter in an Amazon.com URL means it is an | affiliate link. | charcircuit wrote: | Amazon is a bookstore. | BurritoAlPastor wrote: | Fine, you pedant, it's ironic that a textually sympathetic | review of a memoir lionizing the virtues of secondhand brick- | and-mortar bookstores, while fretting about their continuing | viability as a business model, would link to the book on | Amazon, a online-only store commonly considered to be the | primary disruptor to that business model. Happy? | egypturnash wrote: | Amazon is a huge e-commerce site that operates with brutal | efficiency. It started out as a book seller but it is now a | place you can buy pretty much anything, with zillions of | third parties selling merchandise of dubious provenance | through them. | | As it grew from a book seller to what it is now, Amazon took | a huge amount of business away from both the small | booksellers that this book discussed in this article is | mostly talking about, and the larger chain bookstores that | were crushing a lot of those small booksellers underfoot at | the time. | | Hence, the irony: the first link is to buy a copy of this | book about the virtues of small bookstores _on Amazon_ , the | company that ate a huge percentage of American retail stores, | starting with books. | pessimizer wrote: | Like a catalog is a bookstore. | dymk wrote: | RIP Amazon Four Star stores (which were brick and mortar | stores that sold, among much else, books) | [deleted] | prepend wrote: | I love bookstores (like most people in this thread, I assume) and | notice the mtv-ization where they sell more stuff that book | people like than actually books (puzzles, games, journals, art | supplies). | | I wonder if this is a spiral to try to stave off eventual closure | or the future where there will be one shelf of books and the rest | "book culture." | | Nothing makes me happier than going into a book store and seeing | a huge stack of outbound internet sales to be mailed out. | erickhill wrote: | Plus, small local bookstores have no idea who you are (in | general) when you walk in the front door. No tracking codes, no | "browsing history" in your back pocket. | | You get to have full and total anonymity (even if you're a | regular, your path through the store will be yours and yours | alone). You can browse the aisles and look at any old book's | spine you please, pull it off the shelf and read the inside cover | or maybe some employee notes on a card if there are any. | | And the next time you come in, that book won't be in the front | window since you touched it. You can start the whole process over | again. | teddyh wrote: | This is overwhelmingly the reason why I prefer to shop local | instead of buying anything online. | redelbee wrote: | I love used bookstores and my retail business is right next door | to one that I mostly despise. The shelves are literally | overflowing and there is no rhyme or reason to shelf | organization. The prices are high, which I normally wouldn't mind | because usually it comes with great curation or presentation or a | point of view. But this shop has none of those redeeming | qualities. The employees also don't seem to care about reading or | books, other than to point out how quickly some categories of | books fly off the shelves. It's all very transactional. | | It's the weirdest experience because I want so badly for it to be | like other shops I've browsed and loved. I've even considered | opening my own bookshop down the street to fulfill my desire for | a great used book shop in my city. Maybe someday. | carvking wrote: | You can pickup your favorite "Pocket folding folding tool for | outdoor camping." ? | | https://www.amazon.com//dp/B0B5ZRBGWP ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-08-06 23:00 UTC)