[HN Gopher] macOS Keeps a Huge Wallpapers Cache
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       macOS Keeps a Huge Wallpapers Cache
        
       Author : giuliomagnifico
       Score  : 62 points
       Date   : 2022-09-26 08:29 UTC (1 days ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (giuliomagnifico.blog)
 (TXT) w3m dump (giuliomagnifico.blog)
        
       | dimitar wrote:
       | I got a MacBook Air 2020 with 128GB storage to use mostly for
       | browsing and light dev and that quickly filled up. It's like the
       | OS tries to obsolete the machine as quickly as possible. The
       | biggest annoyance is Finder telling me most of the storage is
       | used by "Other".
        
         | keyle wrote:
         | Try something like disk inventory X. It's a life saver.
        
           | tehwebguy wrote:
           | Put my vote in for `ncdu` (just skip your iCloud folders)
        
           | kitsunesoba wrote:
           | My longstanding favorite for this has been
           | OmniDiskSweeper[0]. It's dead simple and I've been using it
           | for just about the entirety of OS X's existence.
           | 
           | [0]: https://www.omnigroup.com/more/
        
           | moralestapia wrote:
           | Disk Inventory X is great and that's how I found out the
           | speech folder on my OS X was taking like 12GB.
        
           | gtm1260 wrote:
           | Gotta put a word in for daisy disk! Maybe you're paying for
           | some fancy animations, but by golly are they nice LOL.
        
             | arthurcolle wrote:
             | DaisyDisk is great. Best $10 on an app I've ever spent
             | (circa 2015)
        
             | erwinh wrote:
             | Some of the best functional data vis out there. For those
             | wondering the chart type used by daisy disk is called a
             | zoomable sunburst.
        
             | boopmaster wrote:
             | I second Daisy Disk. When I made the leap from Windows to
             | mac in the early 00s I wanted something to replace the
             | freeware "scanner" I had found so entirely useful.
             | 
             | http://www.steffengerlach.de/freeware/
        
         | wzyoi wrote:
         | The iPhone is doing the same. The unremovable caches will kill
         | your space with time.
         | 
         | I remember the Apple Music app caching and never removing any
         | songs you've listened to and not showing any space it uses in
         | settings.
         | 
         | But this behavior is not specific to the Apple Music app - any
         | other can do it too. Any caches from social apps you use have a
         | high chance of being untraceable - it all goes into "Other".
         | 
         | Why? Try buying a model with a higher capacity to get an
         | answer.
         | 
         | I also saw this behavior with an Android device - where
         | removing a messenger on my grandfather's phone freed up 20+ GB
         | of space.
        
           | jimvdv wrote:
           | I once found 15gb+ of Spotify cache from my 256gb MacBook.
           | Deleted the app and use the web player now.
        
             | ReactiveJelly wrote:
             | People ask why everything is web apps and there's the
             | answer - It's a layer of sandboxing that users have _at
             | least some_ control over.
        
           | Wowfunhappy wrote:
           | > I remember the Apple Music app caching and never removing
           | any songs you've listened to and not showing any space it
           | uses in settings.
           | 
           | Wait--really? I don't use Apple Music, but surely with heavy
           | use, you could easily end up with a cache that's hundreds and
           | hundreds of gigabytes large...
        
       | justinator wrote:
       | > The folder path is: Macintosh SSD/Users/[yourHome]/Library/Cont
       | ainers/Photos/Data/Library/Application Support/Photos Desktop
       | 
       | Certainly isn't a
       | ~/Library/Containers/Photos/Data/Library/Application
       | Support/Photos Desktop in my home.
        
         | pulvinar wrote:
         | The actual folder is "/System/Library/Desktop\ Pictures", but
         | it's protected on newer systems. It consumes 414MB on my
         | machine, which is 0.3% of a 128GB drive. Doesn't seem worth the
         | trouble to me.
         | 
         | BTW, I found the path by double-clicking the folder as seen in
         | Desktop & Screen Saver, then dragged that selected Finder
         | folder to a terminal window.
        
           | giuliomagnifico wrote:
           | > "/System/Library/Desktop\ Pictures"
           | 
           | No, this is the wallpapers folder used to store all the
           | default macOS wallpapers, not a cache folder, don't delete it
           | (if you don't want to delete all the macOS stock wallpapers).
        
           | saagarjha wrote:
           | That's the desktop pictures folder. This is talking about
           | some sort of cache for photos you use as your wallpaper.
        
         | ChrisMarshallNY wrote:
         | I don't have one, either.
         | 
         | I suspect it gets formed, when we use the Photos App to set the
         | desktop.
         | 
         | I have always used the PrefPane.
        
           | giuliomagnifico wrote:
           | Yes if you don't use Photos to set the wallpapers, then you
           | don't have it.
        
       | ryandrake wrote:
       | I really wish OSes would stop using my filesystem as a dumping
       | ground for rando metadata their developers keep generating and
       | finding no other place for. Between .DS_Store, .Trash,
       | desktop.ini (on Windows), and all these various "caches" garbage
       | heaps they randomly dump into my directories, I feel I have less
       | and less control over what I'm keeping on my own hard drive by
       | default. A hard drive that _I_ purchased, not some developer in
       | Cupertino.
       | 
       | Yes, I know some of these can be turned off if you dig deep
       | enough in settings, but the behavior should not be on by default.
        
         | [deleted]
        
         | hcarvalhoalves wrote:
         | To disable .DS_Store files:                   defaults write
         | com.apple.desktopservices DSDontWriteNetworkStores true
        
           | saagarjha wrote:
           | ...of course, only on external disks.
        
             | yjftsjthsd-h wrote:
             | Are internal disks likely to use a non-mac-native
             | filesystem?
        
       | unethical_ban wrote:
       | "Delete cached wallpapers" should be art of a disk cleanup
       | wizard, but I understand why they do it.
        
       | Legion wrote:
       | In one of those random coincidences, I recognize OP's username
       | because just last night I was reading their forum comments on the
       | OpenWRT forum about the Netgear WAX202. Was trying to decide if
       | picking one up at a $30 sale price would make sense as a
       | replacement for an older device, the R7800.
       | 
       | OP did not find it to be so after their testing, and as such, my
       | $30 remained in my pocket.
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2022-09-27 23:00 UTC)