[HN Gopher] Why are plants green? To reduce the noise in photosy... ___________________________________________________________________ Why are plants green? To reduce the noise in photosynthesis Author : dnetesn Score : 53 points Date : 2022-10-01 19:27 UTC (3 hours ago) (HTM) web link (worldsensorium.com) (TXT) w3m dump (worldsensorium.com) | Yaa101 wrote: | Interesting, apart from more efficient solar panels it could hand | us a solution to better protect our skins with colored sunblock. | delecti wrote: | I'm not sure the same consideration applies to sunblock. The | article makes the case that plants always "want" to let through | the same quantity of light, but not necessarily the same | proportion, while we ideally want to block 100% of UV all the | time. | greenthrow wrote: | Solar panels are already much, much more efficient than | photosynthesis. | _alxk wrote: | That doesn't preclude that further optimisation of solar | panels could stem from research on photosynthesis. | akira2501 wrote: | Perhaps.. but part of the reason plants "lack efficiency" | compared to our solid state electronics is that they need | respiration to exchange input and output products with the | environment and the entire plant needs to be laid out in | such a way that it can maintain a root structure while | being advantaged with respect to competing vegetation. | | The two problem spaces are similar in that they use light, | but exceptionally different in almost every other respect. | dvh wrote: | Because sun is green. | VierScar wrote: | Sun white | kzrdude wrote: | After passing through the atmosphere, the sunlight is | strongest in the green (of the visible spectrum). | [deleted] | wyager wrote: | The sun barely looks different from an artificial blackbody | of the same temperature. The atmosphere is not a big | consideration here. | cdumler wrote: | The sun is classed as a green star[1]. As a black-body | object, it emits the most light in the green spectrum. We see | white because we evolved to distinguish color based on our | star; however, our ability to detect variance in brightness | in colors is far more limited. | | We, in fact, use this to our advantage. View screens transmit | exactly brightness in narrow red, green, and blue such to | fool our eyes into believing we see colors there that are not | in fact there, such as red and green light to simulate yellow | light. | | [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_star_(astronomy) | thehappypm wrote: | But chlorophyll doesn't absorb green, it absorbs other | colors ! | leeoniya wrote: | the explanation is actually quite difficult to google. | | "why are plants green?" -> because chlorophyl | | "why is chlorophyl green?" -> because it reflects green and | absorbs everything else | | okay, you have to search: | | "why did plants/chlorophyl evolve to be green" | marginalia_nu wrote: | This is tangentially related: https://youtu.be/36GT2zI8lVA | Silverback_VII wrote: | I always thought that it's because that they are descendants of a | bacterium that was forced to use the less profitable part of the | light spectrum(blue & red) because the main part was already | occupied by other bacteria. By reflecting green from the sun, | they reflect the strongest wavelength. | kzrdude wrote: | So, are there multiple competing explanations being offered for | this in general, and none of them have ever become entirely | settled? | kingkawn wrote: | Welcome to true science | fluoridation wrote: | The peak of the solar spectrum seems to be in the blueish zone, | though. | acdanger wrote: | I read - I think here[0] - that green light doesn't penetrate | water as well as other wavelengths. So there was no advantage to | evolving to absorb the full spectrum. | | [0] | https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/H/bo164656... | aaaaaaaaaaab wrote: | This doesn't explain why terrestrial plants didn't evolve some | way to utilize e.g. UV radiation. It should be possible in | theory, since we know of radiotrophic fungi: | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiotrophic_fungus | layer8 wrote: | The UV frequency range has much less energy in the solar | spectrum than visible light, see here: | https://sunwindsolar.com/solar-radiation-spectrum/ | moffkalast wrote: | > there was no advantage | | Well there is one disadvantage even: overheating. | leobg wrote: | I still don't understand. How does specializing on blue and red | remove the noise from flickering sunlight? After all, when it | flickers (say, because of shades or clouds), doesn't that affect | all wavelengths equally? Why should green light be more unstable | in that regard than blue and red? | layer8 wrote: | I didn't quite get that either. It seems to be based on the | fact that the intensity of sunlight varies with frequency: | https://sunwindsolar.com/wp- | content/uploads/2013/09/insolati.... Green in the middle of the | visible spectrum is the most intense, whereas blue and red fall | of towards the edges of the visible spectrum, so are less | intense. Maybe the noise is less for blue and red merely by | virtue of those frequency ranges having less intensity. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-10-01 23:00 UTC)