[HN Gopher] From Burned Out Tech CEO to Amazon Warehouse Associate ___________________________________________________________________ From Burned Out Tech CEO to Amazon Warehouse Associate Author : jasonshen Score : 171 points Date : 2022-10-03 18:58 UTC (4 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.jasonshen.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.jasonshen.com) | selimnairb wrote: | Guy who doesn't need to work slums it with the poors to self | actualize. Fuck this guy. | betwixthewires wrote: | As someone who's worked almost the full gamut of work types, from | warehouse to sales to manufacturing to software development, even | service and call center work, I can say that there's something | rewarding about physically demanding work, taxing though it may | be, that you just don't get sitting at a desk. And there's | something you get building an abstract machine with your mind at | a keyboard that you can't get in a warehouse or a factory. These | days I try to balance those things, I make sure I do things that | are very tactile and physical and alsp sit at my workstation at | least a few hours a week to make progress on my projects. I'd say | having a bit of both feels pretty good. | imwillofficial wrote: | This is kind of awesome | [deleted] | [deleted] | throwie_wayward wrote: | you will own nothing and be happy. oh, an a computer will tell | you what to do every step of the way. | wnolens wrote: | Similar story with me. Except I ended up in AWS! | | Worked in different big tech for 7y, and took a sabbatical | because I could, and so why not? | | Well after a year of travelling and working on my own ideas and a | bit of contract work, I entered a complete pit of depression. I | mean contemplating ending it all to stop the pain. Instead big | daddy Bezos was handing out tech jobs like candy so I took one | begrudgingly just to have someone else to be accountable to, | because I found it completely impossible to live with only my own | expectations. | | It helped. I'm halfway good again (or perhaps just a different, | darker normal), with a different outlook on what and why I do | things. But goodness.. I will never retire again. Not without | kids to raise, or something/someone else to be accountable to. | hnuser847 wrote: | Can you help me understand this perspective? Was there really | nothing you wanted to do with your life that you had to resort | to getting a corporate job to keep yourself sane? A guy a used | to work with went through the same thing recently after his | startup was acquired. I'm not sure how much he made, but I'm | pretty sure he's set for life. He stayed retired for about six | months before getting bored and getting another job. It's just | completely baffling to me. | | I want to sail the world. That is my one and only dream in this | life. If I made enough money to retire, that's what I would do. | I would never dream of getting another job just to fill the | time. | | Granted, I've never been retired and probably won't be for a | very long time, so I don't know for sure what it would feel | like. But this perspective that retirement is boring and/or | soul crushing just doesn't compute with me. Maybe I'm missing | something. | strangattractor wrote: | What this really shows is that it is a lot harder to do most | anything other than being a CEO. Steve Jobs held CEO positions at | Apple and Pixar simultaneously. Seriously doubt that either was a | 20 hour a week job. | jasonshen wrote: | OP here. Decided to share this on HN because it seemed relevant | given the earlier article on seeking structure. A lot of folks | responded to my comment about Philip sharing that they too have | experienced a yearning for physical labor. | | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33070986 | | Life takes all of us in different directions, I thought HN | readers would find this path instructive. | WesternWind wrote: | It's interesting that he developed tendonitis. | | I've read that the rate of injury at amazon jobs is incredibly | high _, which is not good practice in my view. | | _ Article says amazon rate of serious injury 80% higher than | competitors https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-57332390 | mikrl wrote: | When I was in a warehouse slugging cast iron and black steel | all day I could barely walk by the time I got home. | | Spending all day on your feet, loaded with a large mass going | up and down, and wearing the least shitty boots you can afford | does a number on you. I still feel it in my foot and calf to | this day and it's been years. | | The old guy I worked with must have been going on 65 and | slugged harder and faster than me with less bitching. He hated | the company, but not the work he did. Absolute trooper. | missedthecue wrote: | The other way to look at this is that Amazon actually reports | injuries. My brother worked at a "mom & pop" carpet warehouse | and they wouldn't report anything unless it resulted in a | hospital visit i.e. broken bones, high blood loss, concussion, | etc... | hemloc_io wrote: | yeah I always found the public, but especially tech's | industries interest in Amazon's warehouse conditions somewhat | dubious. | | Where I used to live there were tons of people who worked at | normal warehouses and switched over to Amazon b/c the pay was | better and things were basically the same. | | Amazon gets tons of, at least somewhat deserved, heat for | what they do, but compared to the truly horrific things done | by something like the meatpacking industry? idk if the amount | of shit they get is equal to the actual on the ground | conditions. | | Working for a mom and pop manual labor gig generally sucks | wayyyy more than a big corporate one. (Lower pay, shittier if | any benefits, longer hours, much more nepotism, no recourse | for issues etc.) | | EDIT: for context on the meatpacking thing. | | Meatpackers will illegally import immigrants, pay them much | cheaper under the table and if there's an inkling of dissent | get ice to round them up and deport them. e.g. | https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/jun/29/ohio- | ice... | | Also meatpacking is basically a monopoly, that the feds are | trying to fight. | | https://missouriindependent.com/briefs/joe-biden- | debuts-1-bi.... | WesternWind wrote: | Perhaps that's true, though I tend to think OSHA and | equivalent bodies actually know what they are doing. | | Still even if they are the same, if more than 1 in 20 workers | gets a serious injury at work at any job, I think that's an | issue. | renewiltord wrote: | Qantas has for decades been one of the safest airlines. During | this period, it was also the airline with some of the highest | minor incident rates. I believe I read this in _The Field Guide | to Understanding Human Error_ by Sidney Dekker. | | You may find it a useful thing to consult on the subject. | samstave wrote: | Amazon will be the first to adopt the exo-skeleton-assist for | factory/warehouse workers, which the unit is registered to you | and any damage will result in a docking of your medical | coverage/pay. | scrlk wrote: | > "Alexa, open the exo-skeleton, I need to go to the | bathroom" | | > "I'm sorry, your exo-skeleton has already been opened for | the allotted 15 minute break, it will not open again until | the end of your shift" | renewiltord wrote: | Imagine doing all this and not installing a condom cath at | least. | foobarian wrote: | Heh if you go through the trouble of building an exo- | skeleton might as well build in the toilet facilities. | scrlk wrote: | > "Warning: Your exo-skeleton waste container is full." | | > "Warning: You have ran out of your free waste container | quota for this shift. If you require a new waste | container, it will be deducted from your pay" | | > "Alert: High stress levels detected. You are required | to report to an AmaZen(TM) Mindfulness Practice Room [0] | for 30 minutes after your shift" | | [0] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-57287151 | purplezooey wrote: | This sounds nice, but the guy is already rich. That makes it a | lot less interesting. | themitigating wrote: | Why? | svnt wrote: | William Shatner answered this in 2009: | https://youtu.be/ainyK6fXku0 | artylerzysta wrote: | I found physical work very relaxing for mind. | curiousDog wrote: | Hey Peter Gibbons already did this. Time to burn the whole damn | warehouse down, Milton. | asim wrote: | Whoa that really sucks. I met Philip Su a really long time ago | when he was at Facebook. I think he came to our office in London | to give a talk. Sad to hear he's been through such a difficult | time. Hope life continues to improve for him and maybe he makes | his way back to tech at some point. | barbariangrunge wrote: | I sometimes miss my old job hauling around boxes. It's great | exercise and you never have to take stress home with you. Good | coworkers often times too | | It just doesn't pay enough to retire off of. Can't easily build | savings. Can't easily pay for the dentist or other emergencies | | Being a lead programmer pays a ton better. I just wish I wasn't | as stressful as it is | fn-mote wrote: | > Can't easily pay for the dentist or other emergencies | | Work a union job, not Amazon? | | UPS benefits will easily cover your medical and dental | problems. (Once you qualify.) I don't know anything about | Amazon's worker coverage. | xedeon wrote: | From a quick Google search: | | - https://m.media-amazon.com/images/G/01/employer- | brand/AMZ_20... | | - https://www.amazon.jobs/en/landing_pages/benefitsoverview- | us | | - https://www.amazon.jobs/en/landing_pages/benefitsoverview- | us... | pxx wrote: | Amazon's medical coverage is no UPS but it is extremely | competitive against plans that union members try to tout as | better. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26753455 as | an old discussion where the thread creator thinks their plan | is a lot better "due to unions" but it's actually a lot | worse. | notesinthefield wrote: | I left devops behind to go back to an IT help desk. Around a | 20% paycut but I never even have to have email on my phones, no | on call, no weekends, I barely have to think much. Good | benefits and still above average pay for my area and I can | return to grad school part time. I realized I just dont deal | well with stress and it easily spills over into my personal | life, my stress started effecting my spouse so I _had_ to go. | jdwithit wrote: | I have a friend who works in finance at a huge bank. He makes a | killing, but absolutely despises his job. His stated goal is to | make enough to retire early (we're ~40 now, so soon-ish) and | then work part time at a hardware store just for something to | do. Pretty much for the reasons you said, meet people, low | responsibility and stress, the job ends when you punch out. | | I think I'd get bored pretty quick, but I do understand where | you're coming from. | sharkweek wrote: | Graduated in 07, was working middle office for a bank, economy | tanked so I left to go travel in a low cost of living area | (Central America) for a bit. | | Came back, couldn't find a job so worked at a grocery store for | two years throwing freight. | | Honestly kinda loved it. No stress besides the occasional surly | coworker, but it felt very peaceful making a customer-ravaged | shelf look whole again. Couldn't afford the low wages now but | at the time not sure I would have traded it for much. | htrp wrote: | You're getting paid for the extra stress .... markets in | everything. | moonchrome wrote: | Often the tradeoff is not worth it (as in I've seen | situations where people were working way more stressful | situations for like 20%-30% pay bump), not just talking | values, but if it's really high stress it better be paying | enough to be able to retire in 10 years because constant | stress will kill you faster than repetitive physical labor. | SevenNation wrote: | > I had what I would stereotype as a traditional Chinese | upbringing in America, which meant my parents very much expected | straight A's. Anytime a B happened, something had gone wrong. The | explanation was never like you lack the talent or whatever, but | that you didn't work hard enough. | | It sounds like the author never got a chance to figure out the | intersection between what he liked to do and what he was actually | good at. Instead, he was trained to respond to the approval of | authority figures. So the true north of his internal compass | pointed to whatever the person in charge at the time thought of | him. | | Fast forward to 2021: | | > I think most people who dream of retirement think that it's | going to be awesome. And it was--for about a month. I skied on | weekdays, shopped at Target at 11am with nobody there, and played | video games. But after several months of pursuing various hobbies | as my whims and interests--all the things which people who aspire | to retire young might look upon with envy--I felt unfulfilled. I | became unmoored, set adrift in a sea of theoretical possibility | only to drown in unbounded optionality. Novelty and excitement | turned into a spiraling vortex of depression as I began to wake | up sometimes at noon, sometimes 2pm, and on the rare occasion | even getting out of bed at 6pm. | | With no authority figure to send the positive vibes he craved, | the author felt adrift. This is where the gig at Amazon comes in. | Authority figures galore and a clear sense of what a job well | done meant. | | Some are chalking this up to poverty tourism. Maybe it's | something else. | jarek83 wrote: | I did the other way round. After 5 years in Tesco warehouse | somewhere in the UK, I went back to Poland to learn web | development. Picking jobs are cruel, I'd advise anyone against | taking it and trying hardest they can to avoid it. It gives you | problems with your back, your legs, gets you bored about life. | You get back home physically tired and mentally numb each | freaking day, that's because you wear your arse out there forced | to ignore any safety rules just to get on time with all tasks and | you still get some angry manager calling you every now and then | because his managers always push him to achieve more | 'picks/hour'. If you see warehouse job ad - run. | 0xbadcafebee wrote: | I heard the higher-level positions around the Warehouse (like | Operations Manager) are often 16 hour days. | gnrlst wrote: | I have a sense of guilt when I compare myself to my high school | friends who have to work longer, work harder, and get paid | significantly less. They are just as smart, they just made | different choices. And this sense of guilt and of feeling like I | don't deserve it just compounds the imposter syndrome to the | point I can't even enjoy what I have because I think that at any | moment I'll be "discovered" and lose everything. I think it stems | from my inability to appreciate what I have because I have this | instinctive belief that if I let myself, then something will | happen for whatever reason. | | Now that I wrote this I realize it has little to do with the | original article (which I read, both parts actually), but | hopefully someone has some good advice, so I don't have to resort | to quitting and going to an Amazon FC to feel better about | myself. | theteapot wrote: | > hopefully someone has some good advice, so I don't have to | resort to quitting and going to an Amazon FC to feel better | about myself. | | Go work on a farm or as a gardener. You'll feel much better | outdoors closer to nature. | germinalphrase wrote: | This may not feel like a serious enough problem, but paying | someone (like a therapist) to listen and advise can really help | clarify one's thinking. Lots of therapists meet virtually now | too. | orev wrote: | > They are just as smart, they just made different choices. | | Most people fall within a similar range of intelligence, and | where they end up in life is far more a result of the choices | they made than how smart they are. So you made a bunch of | choices, like learning tech, etc, and they made a bunch of | choices, like maybe partying instead of studying, and now you | get to enjoy the rewards. | | You shouldn't feel guilty about that, you earned it by making | better choices. | theteapot wrote: | Or maybe he was just lucky. Just saying. | Bakary wrote: | I don't think guilt is helpful, but this logic has some | issues. You obviously cannot have everyone be a coder. And | becoming a coder takes many intervening steps of which | choices are only one factor. Being born in a developed | country (heck only the US has those truly insane salaries), | having a natural interest for it, having universities and the | means to study, living in a safe home etc. these are all | unearned yet make up 90% of the end result. | gamechangr wrote: | I have had this experience. Sometimes its important to remember | that money is just a proxy. For example, I have paid for 10 | friends from High School to spend a week in a 3,000 SQ FT cabin | in Colorado and just relax. | | I'm going to say a few things that I normally wouldn't, just to | better illustrate my point. A few of my friends make less than | $30k a year. One is 1st grade teacher (male) and one is a full | time math tutor. They are great people who go to work and make | a difference. I wouldn't feel the same if they just laid on | their couch and drank everyday...but still. | | Remember money is really for experiences. I paid for the Cabin, | 10 sking passes and sent each of them $2,000 for the trip to | cover air fairs and transportation. The whole thing was maybe | $30,000 and it's one of my better memories. | | I would say -- be intentionally generous and look for ways to | help your life long friends. Yes, it helps them. Yes, it helps | you too. You would be shocked how much purpose it brings to | your life. | | Most 40 year olds have less than 2 people in their life that | would lend them $10k. Be that friend and never keep track. | | This is the reason you work hard and are paid more than you | should be - to be a better friend than you otherwise would be | able to be. | | Blow someone away with your generosity | fffobar wrote: | BTW, a highly disturbed sleep like he is describing is a common | sign of burnout/depression/anxiety disorder. Do not ignore it! | There are drugs and therapy, it is worth it. It is double worth | it if you have the money to stay unemployed or have other ways of | getting some extended rest, at least 3 months. BTW, there is even | some chemical signalling pathway explanation for that connection. | Or maybe it is hypothesized? IDK, it's above my knowledge level. | But the correlation surely is real and strong. | kirbys-memeteam wrote: | avgDev wrote: | "The experience was physically taxing, he was diagnosed with | tendonitis after moving hundreds of boxes a day, but it pulled | him out of his depression and helped him gain perspective and a | deeper sense of meaning"....... | | I have mixed feelings about this. What this has proven is working | at amazon warehouse sucks, and is not sustainable. | | I've had many physical shitty jobs in my 20's. Then, I had some | health issue and could no longer keep doing that to my body, so I | went back to school and got a CS degree. | | I sometimes get depressed and miss physical work, but then I | remember how shit it was and how an injury would prevent me from | working. As a dev I think I'm going to be able to earn money as | long as I'm alive and have a functioning brain. | | I guess once you have enough money then maybe someone might find | that work fun? Obviously it helped the writer with depression. | However, if he ever gets permanently hurt and it affects his | daily life I have a feeling depression will come back in full | swing. Office work is much much safer. | | There are ways to help people through tech and have much bigger | affect then moving boxes for a shitty company. | | Edit: What helps my depression is connecting with people outside | of work, helping people in my community, doing projects around my | house and spending time with my son. Additionally, I try to make | good choices when spending my money and limit my spending on | stuff I don't need, as I dislike excessive spending. | | Edit2: Some great comments below. This is very much poverty/shit | job tourism, which the writer can escape at any moment. This is | some BlackMirror type of content. Guy makes it big in tech, | retires, now works shit job people are trying to escape to cure | his depression. He then writes about it on a blog. Now, other | non-aware devs might be reading it contemplating leaving their | jobs to do a REAL job. | behaveEc0n00 wrote: | The public is catching on to how sucky it is: | https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/jun/22/amazon-wo... | theteapot wrote: | Experienced both sides too. Some physical jobs suck and some | bosses _really_ suck, but some are also great and massively | rewarding even though pay may not reflect that. Really depends | on the company, the match of body+job, and importantly the | _Country_ - worker protection laws. | madrox wrote: | I don't think the author is recommending their experience. He's | merely talking about what he did and what happened. We've known | for millennia that physical work sucks. That's why the lowest | echelons of society always end up doing the worst of it. This, | I think, is why previous generations were so emphatic about | college education. In their experience, it was a ticket out of | doing physically taxing work. | aswanson wrote: | Definitely. My dad always recalled working on the Navy Ship | yard and how cold it was before saying to himself, "F--- | this" and going to college to become an accountant. | nsxwolf wrote: | Overly taxing and dangerous physical work sucks. Working in a | professional kitchen is some of the most fun and (non- | monetary) rewarding work I've ever done. | symlinkk wrote: | Software development is taxing on your brain the same way | physical labor is taxing on your body. It's depressing, soul | sucking work. You're stuck inside, staring at a screen for 8+ | hours a day. | ericmcer wrote: | Not to mention the perverse association you develop with the | computer being a requirement for getting work done. My | dopamine is so tied to ticking off boxes by finishing | computer work that tasks like cleaning the kitchen have an | empty feeling. | [deleted] | avgDev wrote: | Working at amazon as an order picker is depressing, soul | sucking and can wreck your body for the remainder of your | life. | | Devs can get by working few hours a day, some barely do any | work at all. | | I refuse to stare at a screen 8+ hours a day. I take healthy | breaks and create boundaries. | | I rarely have to solve puzzles at work. The grunt of the work | is almost the same thing over and over. | logisticpeach wrote: | _Devs can get by working few hours a day, some barely do | any work at all_ | | Not sure how others here feel, but I have to say that when | I've found myself in situations where there isn't much work | to be done I find it utterly soul destroying. | | Always feel guilty doing anything else in down-time when | I'm billing a client and so sometimes end up sitting in a | weird stand by mode, feeling like I'm somehow being lazy. | knicholes wrote: | You can always add metrics to your functions, refactor | your code, improve your deploy process, write more tests, | etc. | aswanson wrote: | Exactly. Not all forms of development require deep | thought mode, and a lot of them add value to your overall | productivity and code quality. | avgDev wrote: | It's not lazy. If I go for a walk I'm actively thinking | about projects. I have solved many problem by just | clearing my mind and taking breaks. | | Building software should not be paid by the hour. It's a | weird thing. | | If I can build a piece of software in 10 hours, and | another dev needs 40 hours....it seems kind of odd to pay | the slower less resourceful dev MORE for a slower | delivery? | nunobrito wrote: | Yep. Same here, at my level of experience can deliver | work in high-quality at a fraction of time required for a | junior. Instead of burn-out, use the extra time to enjoy | other things and keep learning/improving. | jrochkind1 wrote: | So I consider taking a walk to clear your mind part of | work for sure. I also consider reading HN or other | engineering news/continued education sites to be part of | work. And taking a coffee break to chat with co-workers | about whatever (back when we worked in an office), | including big-picture stuff and non-work related stuff, | sure, that too. | | That's all part of work when you do this kind of work. | You can not just write code 8 hours a day, indeed, it's | impossible, and if an employer tries to make you work | that kind of sweat-shop environment (sometimes it seems | like that's the actual goal of some Scrum | implementations), it won't actually get them your best or | even most productive work. | | But there are people on HN who say that they literally | spend the majority of their day the majority of days just | doing things that are not work at all. I dunno, watching | TV, running errands, riding their bike, mindlessly social | media'ing, playing video games. Like they only spend a | few hours a week on anything related to work at all. | | I agree with GP that for me that's utterly soul- | destroying, I end up feeling useless and unmoored. (The | other day on the radio I heard someone reference a study | that busy-ness to life satisfaction graphed as an upside | down U, if you have too little free/leisure time you are | unhappy, but people with _too much_ are unhappy too, | there 's a sweet spot in the middle. Perhaps that's what | we're talking about here). | | But maybe different people are different. | | Or maybe in new remote world, if you spend that time on | projects you find rewarding (writing poetry, I dunno) | instead of just goofing off, then it's not really | "leisure" anymore, and you won't have that problem. If | also you don't have any ethical problems with it (maybe | your employer is awful and deserves to be drained of | money), or just worry about getting caught. | tobyjsullivan wrote: | You might be surprised to learn that for every dev working | "few hours a day" or barely doing anything at all, there is | another engineer doing all their work for them - usually in | a constant state of fending off burnout due to having to do | other peoples' work in addition to their own. | nsxwolf wrote: | The trick is to avoid becoming _that_ developer. | tobyjsullivan wrote: | I think the trick is to give and take. And maintain teams | that give and take. | | Sometimes I need to take my foot of the gas. But I also | appreciate that, when I do, someone else has to pick up | the slack. | | When I encounter teammates who only take, take, take, and | never give, either they leave or I do (depending how much | influence I have over their employment) | avgDev wrote: | That other engineer is actually a problem. He is | accomplishing nothing by grinding 8+ hours a day and will | burn out, most deadlines are bullshit. | | Nobody can sustain that much work for a long period of | time. | | I would much rather be a good well rounded reasonable dev | than someone doing others work. That is a huge red flag. | Every dev should be responsible for THEIR work, not their | team mates. Unless of course they are doing code reviews. | humanistbot wrote: | If all jobs had the same salary, benefits, career path, etc, | there is no way I'd trade software development for a job | involving strenuous physical labor. | zmgsabst wrote: | If being a security guard paid half instead of a tenth what | I made as $BIGCO software developer, I'd switch back | immediately. | symlinkk wrote: | I would. Imagine getting paid to be outdoors in the sun | getting exercise. Imagine not having to spend an extra hour | each day in a crowded gym doing boring repetitive movements | because your sedentary job would ruin your body otherwise. | Imagine not having posture and back problems at age 30. | Imagine having the output of a hard days work be a physical | object you can point to your son and say "see? I made | that". | [deleted] | Fomite wrote: | A lot of physical jobs will happily ruin your body, and | give you posture, back and knee problems at age 30. | Bakary wrote: | If you are an American SWE or have a corresponding | salary, you pretty much only have to work for 10 or so | years before retiring, assuming you learn how personal | finance works and learn to live without a fancy car or | any status-related possessions. | | Heck you could do it in 5 years if you are a FAANG | employee. | SantalBlush wrote: | You just described what a weekend home project is like, | not a real blue-collar job. | AlotOfReading wrote: | Man, I'd go back to being an archaeologist in a heartbeat. | I like software, but the whole corporate thing gets old | real fast. | the_only_law wrote: | Archeology sounds awesome, but I imagine it's one of | those highly academic fields where barely anyone makes | it. | AlotOfReading wrote: | There's a surprisingly large number of jobs, but making | even middle class income is difficult unless you're one | of the dozens of people that get a staff job with the | government or win the academic lottery and get a tenure | track position. | sillyquiet wrote: | My mother-in-law was a nurse at an orthopedic surgery center. | She always said the major classes of patients she saw were: | | 1. old folks getting joint replacements 2. young athletes 3. | middle aged construction workers or laborers | twstdzppr wrote: | Physical work is great in a controlled environment. Hence, the | gym. No need to destroy ones body doing physical labor, if it | can be avoided. | markdown wrote: | > This is very much poverty/shit job tourism | | Reminds me of Mike Rowe's "it's righteous to destroy your body | for low pay" capitalist propaganda. | Manuel_D wrote: | Better than destroying your body for no pay in a command | economy. | kjeetgill wrote: | It's not propaganda, it's a perspective. He's pretty involved | in activism on the behalf of trades work, not just the | mouthpiece of some think tank ad campaign. | antiterra wrote: | The dude is literally bankrolled by the Koch Industries. | | I will grant the Koch family is more than one person and | more than one foundation/company, and they've bankrolled | amazing museums etcetc (billionaire philanthropy is better | than billionaire non-philanthropy.) | | But, this is unquestionably calculated corporate advocacy. | bliteben wrote: | What a hot take, I may have spent too much time on the | internet myself today. | antiterra wrote: | The most sinister thing about it is that we do need to honor | those people who work incredibly hard and undesirable jobs, | but by _compensating_ them, not just worshipping them like | heroes. Mike Rowe and the cabal that funded his character | attempt to make the viewer feel self-righteous satisfaction | merely from empty recognition of merit. | | He argues against a minimum wage because some jobs are | 'stepping stones,' but this runs counter to his whole | narrative. Further, a proper trade skill training | infrastructure a la unions or guilds would allow for | experience ranked compensation. I get that people are wary of | corruption and protectionism in unions, but it seems | relatively fair in an adversarial market system. | | (I'm also aware that simply expressing the need for higher | compensation/benefits here is going to sound like bootlicking | to smug leftists, but I would respect the dirty job of | literal bootlicking.) | avgDev wrote: | The reason I as a dev earn a lot more than our order picker | where I work is that the software I have built is speeding | up everything. I created massive improvements in | efficiency. My high salary is justified because my work has | a much bigger impact on the finances. | | It is that simple. I interview often to get a true market | rate. Nobody would pay me what I'm making if the market for | devs wasn't this good. | nradov wrote: | I met a young software developer who got a night job loading | UPS trucks instead of joining a gym. It seemed to work for him, | although it's probably not sustainable. | PragmaticPulp wrote: | > What this has proven is working at amazon warehouse sucks, | and is not sustainable. | | This person went from a 23-year career sitting at a desk to | doing physical labor all day. Any physical labor is going to | take a toll on someone in their 40s who hasn't been doing | physical labor. | | I have a lot of people in my extended social circle who are in | physical labor jobs. Amazon Warehouse jobs are always viewed as | the "easy" fallback option: Doesn't pay as well as the hard | physical labor jobs, but it's also viewed as the safe, | comfortable option. Obviously, someone coming from a 20-year | desk job is going to have a different perspective when thrust | into a job with any physical demands. | jrochkind1 wrote: | I also have people in my extended social circle who are in | jobs that involve a lot of physical labor. As we all enter | our late 30s-early 40s give or take, and they realize what a | toll it's taking on their bodies, most of them are trying to | get out of it, or have gotten out of it. They realize they | aren't going to be physically able to do it another 25 years, | and their bodies are going to get increasingly wrecked. | | From what I've heard (including from acquaintances who have | worked there), a job at an Amazon Warehouse takes a toll on | your body for sure. For sure it's hardly alone in being like | that. | | (The people in my extended social circle who are in jobs | involving physical labor are perhaps more likely than most | physical laborers to have people in _their_ social circle who | sit at desks, and to be able to access networks and resources | to shift out of physical labor to make a living). | BurningFrog wrote: | You can also write a very similar rant about how sedentary | desk jobs are not sustainable with all the obesity related | life shortening conditions it leads to :) | kQq9oHeAz6wLLS wrote: | I think the takeaway is none of us is getting out of this | alive. | tomcam wrote: | Written like someone whose knees have never been blown out | on the job | subsubzero wrote: | I too had many shitty jobs in my early 20's and reading this | article kinda triggered those job's bad memories and how much I | hated working at those places. I remember even after getting | into tech many years later I would sometimes have dreams where | I would be back in one of those jobs having a minor case of | PTSD. | | That being said there are other ways to do the type of career | shift that the author wants. My Wife's cousin who worked as a | electrician near SF mentioned to me one of his co-workers was a | former sr. director at Oracle who got burned out and wanted to | try something new. I asked him how they liked the new career | and he said she loved it. That job payed well and didn't | require the forced degradation seen at amazon warehouses, plus | you get to interact with interesting people and travel to | different locations frequently. | NaturalPhallacy wrote: | > _I have mixed feelings about this. What this has proven is | working at amazon warehouse sucks, and is not sustainable._ | | Sure it is, as soon as you realize employees are replaceable | commodities that get used up like break pads. | | Sustainable for the individual? Obviously not. Sustainable for | amazon. Of course, which is why it won't be changing. | lesuorac wrote: | It's not sustainable for amazon-ish [1]. They offer higher | wages than competitors because they need to keep accumulating | new employees or convincing old ones to come back. | | [1]: https://www.google.com/search?q=amazon+run+out+employees | +to+... | NaturalPhallacy wrote: | 8.1% inflation to Amazon's rescue! Just in time. Whew, that | was a close one. | skadamat wrote: | I can empathize to be honest. There's something awesome about | doing physical work. You get to use your body to think and move, | and feel concrete progress. | | However, I think being a Tech CEO is at the opposite end of the | spectrum from being an Amazon Warehouse Associate. Being | somewhere in the middle seems very compelling. | | In essence, Crawford talks about this feeling extensively in his | book (Shop Class as Soulcraft). Here's the essay that started it | all: https://www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/shop-class-as- | so... | | He used to be a manager at a political think tank but went back | to the trades because he found the latter not only more | satisfying, concrete, and tangible, but also more mentally | taxing, creative, philosophical, etc. | rgrieselhuber wrote: | Fuckin A | spacemadness wrote: | This person seems like they are suffering from typical tech | bubble non-awareness disease. They always strive to make the | world a better place as... a director of Facebook. Debatable. | Early retirement is such a nightmare for me that.. I became an | Amazon Warehouse Associate out of boredom? I'm not sure how any | of this narcissism is making the world a better place. | jbm wrote: | He's a stranger sharing his experience, people obviously found | it to be interesting. | | Re-contextualizing into a class struggle style comment, just | because he shared his experience, is not very interesting. | | All blogging is narcissism if you redefine narcissism to be the | most bland shade of the word's meaning. | avgDev wrote: | This is what I felt but could not put it into words. Non- | awareness disease is the PERFECT word to describe what I felt | reading this. | quickthrower2 wrote: | > strive to make the world a better place | | Are you sure that is the motive? | gamblor956 wrote: | Yes, the entire thing was cringe. | | But it's not just a tech bubble thing; it's more of a 6-figure | yuppie thing. I knew a doctor making $500k/year in L.A. who | insisted on taking vacations in disaster zones, etc., as a | tourist (not with Doctors w/o Borders) so he could "experience | human suffering" and "become empathetic" to his fellow men | through their "shared suffering" of being in the same | approximate location as people who were starving or seriously | wounded. | | He doesn't actually do anything with this "increased empathy." | He just feels like it makes his EQ super high or something | silly like that. | yuliyp wrote: | How dare he find meaning in things that are different from you. | Congratulations on figuring out how to find fulfillment and a | balanced life before the rest of us. Philip's journey toward | that is clearly different from yours. | margalabargala wrote: | He describes exactly what things he finds meaning in: | | > For me, a lot of my meaning comes from two things. One is | doing something in the world that feels like it's actually | making things a little better somehow. And so contributing to | society in some meaningful way. | | The parent is commenting on how Philip's previous (and new!) | work positions apparently fulfilled those criteria in no | small way, in Philip's view. They are noting that it is | striking that this is the case, as from the perspective of an | outsider looking in, it does not appear that a director at | facebook, nor an amazon warehouse worker, fulfills the stated | criteria. | jcheng wrote: | From his LinkedIn: | | > Launched a global health software nonprofit, funded by | the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, focused on using | smartphones to improve rapid testing in low-income | countries. | | Granted that is 3 years out of a 20-odd year career, but | it's the stint immediately preceding the events of the blog | post. | FiberBundle wrote: | I just find it kind of worrisome that he finds meaning in | work that other people are exploited for for a lack of better | options. Why would a financially independent person choose to | help enrich a large corporation over, say, voluntary work to | help underprivileged people, animals or whatever else you can | think of? | bobthepanda wrote: | A lot of feel-good jobs have an unfortunate public facing | component. There are segments of the population that treat | service workers with contempt or sometimes even violence. | | Retail workers and social workers dealt with the worst of | it, teachers deal with this behind the scenes, and nurses | and doctors became (more) exposed to this over the | pandemic. People don't put up with emotional, verbal and | sometimes physical abuse, and they shouldn't. | akira2501 wrote: | > I just find it kind of worrisome that he finds meaning in | work that other people are exploited for for a lack of | better options. | | I think viewing every warehouse worker as a member of a | lower labor caste who is merely being exploited is not a | warranted view. The fact that people can easily find | meaning in this labor is further indication it is | incorrect. | | You're also presuming a rather tyrannical existence for | these people.. wherein their path through life must be | dictated to them by their "best options." People make | suboptimal choices for all kinds of reasons, and they don't | view their circumstances as being "exploited." Probably | because the companies they work for didn't _create_ the | suboptimal choices for them in the first place, their | employer is a matter of circumstance, not conspiracy. | | > Why would a financially independent person choose to help | enrich a large corporation over, say, voluntary work to | help underprivileged people, animals or whatever else you | can think of? | | Again.. people make suboptimal choices intentionally. The | explanation here is "this is a very low risk option that | can be exited immediately if such a whim arises." And in | all likelihood, exiting in this way wouldn't prevent you | from being hired back later if your fortunes or whims | reverse. | | Forgive me, but you seem to be a little too comfortable | looking down your nose at these people. | hkon wrote: | There is a difference between enduring hardships because you | want to for fun, and enduring it because you must to earn | money. | | It reads like a slap in the face | A4ET8a8uTh0 wrote: | Something about what you said triggered a memory in me. I | remember a story about how westerners embraced meditation | and how monks described how they ( westerners allowed into | the monastery ) completely missed its point by enjoying | staring into sand, when it was in theory supposed to induce | boredom. | | I will admit that I am not sure how I feel about the | article. I might be still processing it. | spacemadness wrote: | Yes, Philip's journey was an extremely privileged one | apparently and required a blog post or it didn't happen. | CoffeeOnWrite wrote: | Yep, the guy never reflects on his privilege not _needing_ this | job. Bad on the blogger too for not prompting them on this - it | could have been an interesting article.. | jasonshen wrote: | I would encourage you to listen to the podcast, because he | definitely does reflect on this, but it wasn't the focus of | my interview, because this was focused on ways in which | burned out tech workers try to find meaning in their life, | not an analysis of low paid jobs. | [deleted] | carlosdp wrote: | Did you actually read the article? He's probably the one person | in tech that is directly aware of what it's like to work at a | warehouse _because_ he actually did it for real. He 's not | claiming to be "making the world a better place" by working at | Facebook. He's telling the story of how he got burned out from | that world and sought out a real "honest labor" job that he'd | heard a ton about in the media to snap out of it and get real. | | What more could someone possibly do to wave off the label of | "tech bubble non-awareness disease," in your opinion? | spacemadness wrote: | "For me, a lot of my meaning comes from two things. One is | doing something in the world that feels like it's actually | making things a little better somehow. And so contributing to | society in some meaningful way." | | Yes, I read the article. | LtWorf wrote: | I loved the "silicon valley" show, where every single | shitty startup was saying that they'd make the world a | better place. | themitigating wrote: | " He's probably the one person in tech that is directly aware | of what it's like to work at a warehouse because he actually | did it for real." | | I work in tech but previously did overnight stock at Walmart | so I guess that's two people. | | What's the point of using this kind of hyperbole in your | comment unless you wanted to make others hate people in tech? | SketchySeaBeast wrote: | > What more could someone possibly do to wave off the label | of "tech bubble non-awareness disease," in your opinion? | | Going from rich to working in a warehouse until you feel like | leaving is not the same experience as working a warehouse | because you feel like eating. | et-al wrote: | > He's probably the one person in tech that is directly aware | of what it's like to work at a warehouse because he actually | did it for real. | | There are plenty of people in tech who didn't have the | traditional four years of uni -> FAANG route. They just don't | blog about it. | bobthepanda wrote: | Also, people who worked through college. | Bakary wrote: | He learned what a grueling job was for a few weeks. He did | not learn what it means when that grueling job is your past, | present, and/or future. The part about the takeout food seals | that impression | didgetmaster wrote: | There were many times in my programming career when I wanted to | take a mental break and just do some kind of menial job for a few | months. There are many routine jobs that don't require much | training so it should be easy to do one for 6 months. The problem | is generally that most people's career paths do not allow for | this kind of thing. It looks bad on your resume to have 'truck | driver' or 'shelf stocker' in-between tech jobs. | ryandrake wrote: | I solved this by simply getting hobbies that involve manual | labor. You get the physical exertion and the ability to see the | results of the work of your hands--without the drudgery of a | job and the pressure of having your livelihood depend on not | wrecking your body. If you're not feeling up to it today, just | don't go out to the garage. Need extra zen time to forget your | JIRA queue? Spend a few extra hours hobbying. | | Started with auto mechanics, learned basic maintenance, moved | on to minor, then major auto repairs. Then tried woodworking, | built a few pieces of furniture for the house, then moved on to | sheet metal. Finally ended up building a two-seat airplane. | Physical hobbies are both satisfying AND low-pressure. Plus, | you shouldn't have to quit your tech job to get a hobby. | jdwithit wrote: | I got deep into homebrewing beer for a while for this reason. | It was extremely satisfying to make something tangible and | physically taxing after spending all week tapping on a | keyboard. Not to say that software isn't "real", but having a | physical thing you can show off and share and enjoy hits | differently. | | Unfortunately having dozens of gallons of good beer on hand | at all times led to some pretty bad habits so I had to get | out of that game (plus I had kids, so RIP to both hobby time | and frequent drinking). Still looking for the next hobby that | really clicks with me, the intersection of science and | creativity and engineering and socializing that is brewing | was pretty perfect. | octodog wrote: | Genuine question, why does it look bad? I don't think this | would be a problem at all where I live (Australia). Worst case | you could just leave it off your resume. | [deleted] | omega3 wrote: | He could have just played Farming Simulator. | vukadinovic wrote: | When you're so rich and bored so you start doing regular jobs lol | tristor wrote: | I read the article, and... I get it. But something about this | just seems weird to me. I grew up mostly on a family farm, worked | every day of my life in some capacity since I was 9 or 10 years | old, and did shit jobs to pay for college (which I eventually | dropped out of right before graduation). I don't think my route | into tech is that different from many of the other folks I've | worked with... this guy lived a /very/ charmed and privileged | existence compared to the average American tech worker, and going | to work at an Amazon warehouse to get a reality check seems... | patronizing somehow. I am glad he got a reality check, but I feel | like there's another way to do this, or at least how to write | about it. | nathanaldensr wrote: | Why deny his experience, though? Not everything needs to be | viewed through a lens of privilege. I hope the author gained an | appreciation for those less fortunate or less ambitious. At | least they have experienced the "other side," so to speak. | brushfoot wrote: | > this guy lived a /very/ charmed and privileged existence | | His experience in tech doesn't sound so charmed to me. He was | obsessed with climbing the corporate ladder. He slept in the | office and woke up early every morning to start grinding again. | He worked so much he didn't even have time to play a game with | his son. | | He tried another kind of work to see how it compared, and he | learned stuff. There's nothing patronizing about that. | thrown_22 wrote: | Life is fundamentally unpleasant and once you have your basic | daily needs met you have time to develop mental issues. In the | west basically everyone including the homeless don't have to | worry about being eaten, murdered, starving or dying from | exposure. This leaves a lot of leeway for everyone to think how | bad they have it while historically being in the top 1%. | | It's rather hard to have empathy for someone who has it better | than you. But I've found it helps to also remind yourself that | the majority of people who ever lived will feel the same way | about you. | dnissley wrote: | I think part of that feeling is coming from how we've been | socialized in the middle/upper classes to perceive people with | lower incomes working more physical jobs than us. | | It's no longer acceptable to be snooty towards people in these | positions, but we haven't dropped the stigma totally, and now | the acceptable way to view + interact with them is to act (in | the performative sense, because many of us don't actually know) | with deference, assuming that their lives are truly miserable | and their dignity is on the line every day they work such jobs. | The expectation is that we must feel sorry for them and treat | them better than other people because of it, or treat them with | kid gloves. | | When you adopt such a stance, the idea of someone willingly | going and doing one of these terrible no good jobs does seem | patronizing -- it's masochistic even, and so is viewed as | suspect and "touristy". When someone does such a thing they are | "disrespecting themselves" by people with this view. If anyone | ever tries to provide and alternative view and tell us that | most people's lives in these positions aren't so bad by going | and experiencing it themselves, however partially, we heap | scorn on them. "They don't know what it's really like, it's | horrible what these people have to do." "They have millions of | dollars in the bank so their experience can be dismissed." Etc. | cheeze wrote: | It almost feels like... tourism? to me? | | Hard to explain, but I get what you mean. | solraph wrote: | Maybe it's less patronising, and more just blindingly obvious | to those of us who have had crap jobs in the past? | | Having grown up adjacent to upper-middle class people (I'm | arguably entering that sphere now, but I definitely didn't | start there), I think a bunch of them could benefit from | hearing this story from one of their peers. | carabiner wrote: | Sell your back, or sell your brain. There is no other way. | NaturalPhallacy wrote: | Be born to rich parents.* | | *Restrictions apply. | smallerfish wrote: | I think this is partly a story of retiring without having enough | in your life to replace work. I understand how that's possible, | as full days of work leave me not wanting to do much in the | evenings (I don't have kids, so I can't imagine where parents | find the energy) - that said, it's probably important for your | mental health post-retirement to find things outside of work to | engage in well before your retirement date comes. | EricE wrote: | Traditional jobs are often referred to as honest work for good | reason. | 77pt77 wrote: | No. For no good reason. | djhworld wrote: | Working in a warehouse for 6 weeks is gruelling, and from the | interview it sounds like he got a taste of that experience, but I | think there's a marked difference between working for the novelty | of it and working because you're living paycheck to paycheck. | | Saying that though I think he's right in the sense that having | experience of working in an environment like that _does_ give you | the appreciation for the relative comforts of a tech job. | | I've worked retail jobs when younger, and sitting on your butt | all day writing code is way easier... | virtuous_signal wrote: | I agree absolutely. One of these people can stop whenever the | experience stops being fun and the other has few other options. | It's about as inspiring as poverty tourism or an episode of | Undercover Boss. | spoonjim wrote: | Working in an Amazon warehouse can be refreshing and restorative | when you can quit after 10 weeks and have millions of dollars in | the bank. Not so much when you get tendonitis after 6 weeks but | have to stare down another 30 years of this and still won't have | any savings. | themitigating wrote: | Yes and we are all aware of that. Are you saying that his | experience and blog cause harm to those people who have to do | it? There's been countless posts about Amazon warehouse | conditions on Hackernews and other news sources. | Bakary wrote: | The takeaway is more that one of the contributing reasons the | world is so dystopian is that people at the top literally | have no awareness or understanding or what life is like at | the bottom. | giantg2 wrote: | Ostensibly he could just retire. | Bakary wrote: | I'm perhaps repeating myself from the other thread but this post | angered me more than I expected it to. Other commenters have | picked up on it too, but many others seem not to see it. This | sort of poverty tourism is actually really twisted and indicative | of some very grim aspects of our world. I'm curious as to what | the author thinks or whether they are aware of this. | nipponese wrote: | Why does someone trying to understand something through first- | hand experience get an -ism? I wish every white-collar role, | especially c-suite and director level person at Amazon took the | time to work on the warehouse floor, first-hand. | Bakary wrote: | But there is no actual understanding. The person in question | thinks it's a quaint little experience. The part about the | food takeout illustrates this well: no comprehension about | actually having to do this sort of labor your entire life. If | this article does not seem like parody straight out of HBO's | Silicon Valley I am not sure what to say | helen___keller wrote: | > For me, a lot of my meaning comes from two things. One is doing | something in the world that feels like it's actually making | things a little better somehow. And so contributing to society in | some meaningful way. | | > But the other thing is socialization with my coworkers is a | huge part of my daily satisfaction in a job. You might be free | Monday through Friday but all of your friends are working when | you want to grab coffee. | | I can't relate to many of the author's life experiences, but this | quote really hit home. I think we're all wired to want to (a) | make something better and (b) share our life and experiences with | other people. | | How (a) and (b) manifest varies greatly depending on life | background and opportunities, but I can say most of the mental | healthy difficulties I've had previously in life can be related | to those two points. | fjfbsufhdvfy wrote: | There are a lot of people who have given up on a) and instead | spend all their time trying to tear the stuff other people | build down because they got bored. | jjmorrison wrote: | For those judging this guy - let's remember most of us are pretty | similar. Might be an opportunity to look inwards. | kvee wrote: | I thought it was pretty interesting to read from the guy himself | on his own site. | | This one is quite well done: | https://peaksalvation.com/socioeconomic-bends | [deleted] | vadym909 wrote: | If physical work is too hard, you can try being an Amazon | contract recruiter- mundane work, a bit easier on the body and | higher pay. | ravedave5 wrote: | Has this dude never heard of hobbies? | elzbardico wrote: | There's something strangely satisfying in hard physical labor. | When I do stuff at home, like renovations, installing stuff, | gardening, or doing car stuff, even house cleaning, I get a | strange kind of euphoria that I don't get even when doing stuff | like working out in a gym or cycling, at least, not at the same | degree. | darod wrote: | interesting that he's so programmed to work that just relaxing | for a bit made him depressed. hard to see how working 11 hours a | day is going to make it easier for him to still not have to put | his kids on the calendar. | | on a side note, i wonder if the actual therapy was just doing | something physical. sitting down not moving for hours and hours | is not what we were built to do. i always found working out, | brazilian jiu jitsu, hiking, anything physical to be very | therapeutic if i've been inside an office all day. | dfxm12 wrote: | More than just doing something physical, something | group/team/class based like BJJ would also give the camaraderie | and socialization that satisfied him. | | I hear a lot of retired people _say_ "I miss working", but when | probed, they'll say things like "I miss the routine", "I miss | the people I saw all the time", "I miss the structure". Work is | not the only place you get these! Going to BJJ, kickboxing, | clay studios, adult sports leagues, walking groups, some | volunteer opportunities, etc., all fit the bill. I think some | people put so much of their life/identity into work that they | can't even imagine something else... | germinalphrase wrote: | If anyone is interested in trying Brazilian jiu jitsu, just | know it's common to be completely confused for a while before | the different positions/techniques start to click. It's like | a huge flowchart, and you're randomly jumping into the middle | somewhere. | darod wrote: | yup, baby steps (black belt 2nd degree) | tpmx wrote: | I wonder what this guy's blood pressure level is. | | Advice: Make an effort to slow down by 10-20%, and then take it | from there. | princevegeta89 wrote: | Interesting story. I can easily see how the responsibilities of | being in charge of a decent-sized company can wear you | down..however I do not personally believe there would be so much | fatigue though. | | I am curious to hear stories from HN folks here who have been | through similar trajectories | oldsklgdfth wrote: | I work in FAANG and enjoy Costco. Sometimes in the food court I | day-dream of working there. You know what you are doing, you use | your body, you go home and don't think about it. | | I told my friend. He thought it sounded a lot like larping. | Bakary wrote: | If you work in a FAANG (presumably as some sort of knowledge | worker) you have a unique opportunity to never have to work | again within just a few years of saving. | oldsklgdfth wrote: | I could do that and then go work at the Costco food court. | Somehow that doesn't feel any less like larping. | | On a serious note, how does one do that? It doesn't "feel" | that way, but I know that's lifestyle inflation. | antiterra wrote: | The worst of poverty tourism is when it is done impersonally | without recognition of the inescapable circumstances of others. | Do see how real people live and work, connect with them to their | faces. Recount your difficult escape from a low-income origin. | | But: don't think that you are one of them and able to advocate as | a representative if you aren't, a la Pulp's Common People. | | We should encourage resilience, but be sympathetic about its | absence. Everyone _should_ choose to learn to shake off a punch | to the face, but that doesn't negate the real trauma of someone | getting assaulted who didn't have that lesson. | odysseus wrote: | Wonder if this guy was influenced by the ending of the movie | Office Space. | carimura wrote: | Ya Peter Gibbons figured this out (modulo the podcast) a long | time ago. So did Lawrence. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-10-03 23:00 UTC)