[HN Gopher] How to use a watch as a compass ___________________________________________________________________ How to use a watch as a compass Author : jamesgill Score : 153 points Date : 2022-10-19 18:23 UTC (4 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.citizenwatch-global.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.citizenwatch-global.com) | frankus wrote: | Don't forget to subtract an hour if you're on daylight saving | time. | tejtm wrote: | and your offset within your time zone | quickthrower2 wrote: | cross reference with a reliable compass too! | tmtvl wrote: | Doesn't work quite as well with a digital watch. | marktolson wrote: | I hope this is a joke. | madcaptenor wrote: | Essentially this means approximating the bearing of the sun X | hours after midnight the sun as 15X degrees. This works better | the closer to the poles you are and the closer to the winter | solstice it is - see for example | https://possiblywrong.wordpress.com/2012/01/25/using-a-watch... | quickthrower2 wrote: | Fun but probably useless as an actual compass for navigation with | maps which requires higher accuracy. | [deleted] | praptak wrote: | Daylight saving messes this up a bit. | askvictor wrote: | Probably not any more than big timezones do. | ottoflux wrote: | You can do this (crudely but effective enough) with a any watch | if you take a second to make a simple sundial. Rotate it with the | stick (or whatever) until the shadow reflects the actual time and | you're pointing North (in the Northern hemisphere). It helps to | be familiar with the angle range of how time is broken up in the | day on a sundial but it works. | throwaway4837 wrote: | Isn't this just using the sun as a compass? You could easily just | look at the position of the sun knowing what time it is, or use | your hand and make a sun-dial. I believe the watch is only there | to tell us the time and cross reference that with the sun's | position. | rosywoozlechan wrote: | Right, if you can see the sun and know the time of the day why | do you need a watch for this. | Terr_ wrote: | Yeah, the strategy only really involves (A) knowing the current | time and (B) a protractor or a good sense of angles. | | Or in word-algorithm form: | | 1. When the sun rises that's usually at 6AM in the East, at | 12AM noon it's usually towards the South, and when it sets | that's usually 6PM in the west. (Valid for northern hemisphere | only.) | | 2. Use the current time to linearly interpolate between those | three values. | | 3. Once you know the heading of the sun, you can figure out | which way is north. | re wrote: | It would be fascinating to see a visualization of how the | accuracy of this method varies given parameters like latitude, | time of day, time of year. | quickthrower2 wrote: | And local/national government politics (aka stuffing around | with daylight savings and carving out new time zones) | madcaptenor wrote: | Don't tempt me, I have real work to do. | nevster wrote: | Don't forget to flip it if you're in Australia! Half-way between | 12 and hour hand is North. | kije wrote: | I love this trick. You can also do this using your hands if you | know roughly what time it is. | | For example, if it's sunny out, place your arm in your shadow, | parallel to the ground. Keep it there. This arm represents the | current time (say, 10 O'clock). Look at your shadow and point | your other arm out, parallel to the ground, and adjust it until | the arm's shadow points at "12 O'clock" relative to your first | arm (in your shadow). Clap your hands together, and you're | pointing north! | soperj wrote: | You'd be pointing South no? Or is this for the southern | hemisphere? | kije wrote: | Compare it to the parent article and you'll see what I mean. | If you are the center of the watch and you put your hand in | your shadow, it will face the direction opposite of the hour | hand in the article. If you adjust your other hand to face 12 | O'clock relative to that hand, it would be at 6 O'clock if | you're going by the article. So the direction is flipped. | When you clap your hands together, you'll be facing North | instead of South. | zmgsabst wrote: | Doesn't N or S reverse at noon? | | Imagine (for simplicity) that we have 6a to 6p with solar noon | at 12p. | | Then if I put my right arm in my shadow at 6am and my other arm | 180 degrees from it, then I'll be facing South. If I do the | same thing at 11 am, I form a big wedge with my right arm on | the NW side, again facing South. | | But at noon that changes: the sun is directly South from me, so | my right arm is North and my other arm is in the same spot, so | I turn around to face North. | | From there, my right arm is on the NE side, and my left arm | makes a widening wedge as I face North -- until at 6pm, I'm | standing with my right arm facing East and my left arm opposite | it, facing North. | HillRat wrote: | Yes -- the article doesn't explain this, but in the morning | you use the clockwise side of the hour hand to find south, | and in the afternoon the counter-clockwise side (IIRC). | mckeed wrote: | It doesn't work at 6:00 unless you know which way to face. At | 11am you should have a small wedge, and your left arm should | be in the shadow, in order to not point both arms straight | behind you. At 1pm your right arm will be in the shadow for | the same reason, so you're still facing north. | [deleted] | ww520 wrote: | Ah. This is the Boy Scout trick learned when was a kid. | pwillia7 wrote: | I'm more impressed with someone using it to determine the favored | starting line for their yacht race. https://www.citizenwatch- | global.com/support/exterior/yacht.h... | Kon-Peki wrote: | There are usually going to be too many other factors at play to | use this to your advantage at the start, but occasionally | you'll see someone start a race on a completely different tack | than the rest of the field and go on to finish far ahead of | everyone else. | | Edit - to be clear, almost everyone figures out and starts on | the favored tack - you don't really need a sailing watch to do | this. In races with heats or starting groups, you have to do | this 10-15 minutes before your start, because once the starting | sequences begin you don't get near the start line until it's | your groups turn. So the advantage comes from recognizing and | adjusting to any wind shifts that may have happened in the few | minutes before your race. | xcambar wrote: | If I know the time and see the sun or shadows, I approximate the | direction by estimating the course of the sun. | | It always works significantly well, meaning I never need it on | critical situations and the margin of error is bearable. | | But I'm mostly surprised not to see someone else comment the | technique before. Is it not a known technique? | uoaei wrote: | Of course what you describe is the main way people navigate by | the sun, when the margin of error is bearable. In more extreme | situations where precision is needed, decimating the margin of | error is pretty important, especially when used in conjunction | with a map or known landmarks. | Nition wrote: | Southern Hemisphere version: Instead of pointing the hour hand at | the sun, point the twelve o'clock at the sun. North is | approximately half way between the hour hand and the 12. | codeflo wrote: | From some of the comments, I'm not sure people fully get this. | It's basically doing a geometric construction of the sun's path | across the sky, using the distance between the hour hand and the | 12 on the watch face as one of the input angles in the | calculation. That's quick (important because you have to repeat | it while you're marching) and easy to remember (also important | because you might need it in a situation without access to | Wikipedia). Under the assumption that the sun rises at 06:00 in | the exact East and sets at 18:00 in the exact West, the | construction is almost perfect. Of course, that's never exactly | true in real life, but still a lot more accurate than "well I | know the sun is roughly South". | dheera wrote: | You'd also need a 24-hour watch, as the sun makes a full 360 in | 24 hours, not 12 hours. | fiddlerwoaroof wrote: | This just means you go halfway between the hour hand and the | 12 marker. | system2 wrote: | If I see the sun, why would I need a watch to tell me where south | is? | usrusr wrote: | Depends: are you the kind of person who considers it a good | idea to be aware of uncertainty? You'll be perfectly happy with | "I'm on the northern hemisphere, it's afternoon, so south must | be somewhere left of the sun". | | But if you are the kind of person who like to lose themselves | in point-something percentage point deltas in small (or | unknown) sample size market research, go on, pat yourself on | the shoulder for building that makeshift shadow observatory, it | will make you happy even if you don't really know where exactly | you are relative to the center and natural bounds of you time | zone. | certifiedloud wrote: | only because you'd need to know what time it is to know where | south is relative to the sun. | chasd00 wrote: | don't you only need to know if the sun is rising or setting? | or basically if it's morning or not? | dctoedt wrote: | An old Boy Scout trick. | b3morales wrote: | I had a watch with a bezel like this as a kid, but over the years | I'd forgotten how this technique worked. A nice refresher! | politelemon wrote: | Wouldn't this be messed up on longer days, like in summer when | the sun rises at about 4 AM and sets at 9PM? Or similarly, winter | when the days are really short | mckeed wrote: | Yes, at 6:00 you have to know which side to put north and | south, and from 6pm-6am it will be North instead of South | between the hour hand and 12. If you know the sun rises in the | east, though, you can account for that and the trick can still | be helpful. | kqr wrote: | No. Earth still makes a full rotation in 24 hours, at a fairly | constant angular velocity. | | The only thing that changes during longer days is the height of | the sun over the horizon, not its angle along the surface of | the planet. | TobTobXX wrote: | No, fo the same reasons sun dials still work: The sun rises at | a slightly different point on the horizon. The trick even works | north of the polar circle where there may be 24h days, as the | sun is always in another direction. | | The sun moves around, whether it is above or below the horizon, | so the trick works regardless of length of time the sun happens | to be above the horizon. | AdmiralAsshat wrote: | Is that what the rotating dial on my watch is for? | askvictor wrote: | For SCUBA diving, it is to tell you how long you've been | underwater for, so you can determine (among other things) your | nitrogen saturation. I'm not sure if the original design was | specifically for that purpose, but every (dial-based) diving | watch has such a ring. | tomjakubowski wrote: | Also for measuring durations. | Xylakant wrote: | > Positioning the rotating bezel so that it points south, will | then allow you to read other approximate compass directions. | owlninja wrote: | Likely more for this: | | https://www.citizenwatch-global.com/support/exterior/measure... | est wrote: | You don't need to remember the method, you can deduce it from two | simple facts: | | 1. In a perfect world, 12 o' clock is where sun at its highest | peak in the sky, 24 o' clock is where sun below the horizon at | its lowest. | | 2. If your are in northern hemisphere, the sun's trajectory is | slightly off to the south. | | Now try emulate the sun's rotation with your watch's hour hand. | TheRealPomax wrote: | The word "deduce" is doing _a lot of heavy lifting_ here. | vesinisa wrote: | This trick alone is why I think if daylight saving time is ever | abandoned we should switch to permanent winter (~natural) time. | gonzo wrote: | 1959 edition of the Boy Scout Manual "Time for North" | | https://mediafiles.scoutshop.org/m2pdf/BePrepared_Vol_3_No_9... | bigmattystyles wrote: | I learned this from Gallipoli (1981 Peter Weir movie about WW1). | In the movie they get totally screwed by this trick when it turns | out it's overcast. Tangent, that movie is great, the synthesizer | music is odd but to me it works and the whole movie is beautiful. | mordechai9000 wrote: | This is a good way to get a general idea, but unless your local | solar noon happens to coincide with noon on your watch, it's | going to be off. For instance, solar noon at my current location | is around 2:00 pm. | | As long as the sun is out, it's a good way to stay oriented and | keep to a general heading. It works well when combined with local | features and topography. So you can say something like "I'll keep | heading more or less south until I see the river, then I know I | can follow it upstream to the bridge and intersect the road back | to my car." | psychphysic wrote: | This is a great trick and with practice you don't even need a | watch, heck you don't even need an object to cast a shadow. | | The sun is over there, a shadow would be that way, it's about 5 | o'clock. That must be north! | | What I've always thought of as witchcraft is this. | | Jab a stick in the ground, mark the end of the shadow. Come back | some time later say 15-30mins. Mark the new end of the shadow. | | Draw a line between marks and that is an east-west line! | | In the Northern hemisphere the stick is south of that line, in | the southern hemisphere it's North! | | What!! | chrisseaton wrote: | > The sun is over there, a shadow would be that way, it's about | 5 o'clock. That must be north! | | That works for example if you have a path and you're trying to | find out which way goes north and which south, but a watch can | give you an actual quantifiable bearing that is actionable if | you have no other ground orientation. | CSSer wrote: | Normally an upvote is enough but I just have to say that your | enthusiasm about this made me smile so wide. This is great. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-10-19 23:00 UTC)