[HN Gopher] The stick shift might survive the electric revolution ___________________________________________________________________ The stick shift might survive the electric revolution Author : rntn Score : 24 points Date : 2022-11-18 22:02 UTC (57 minutes ago) (HTM) web link (robbreport.com) (TXT) w3m dump (robbreport.com) | vouaobrasil wrote: | I love driving stick and I've done so with all my cars...but I'm | okay seeing it go. I'd prefer the options to be more | environmental, and there are other joys in life. It's not good to | be attached to such things. | fhood wrote: | It's really stupid, but you can't tell me that the idea of a | manual electric doesn't appeal to the less rational parts of | your subconscious. | hinkley wrote: | I haven't driven stick in years, having bought a DSG car, but I | still prefer 'driving one-handed' the way you do with a stick | shift, and it's clear at this point that some people don't | remember being passengers in a manual transmission vehicle, let | alone driving them. | Karrot_Kream wrote: | I recently switched from 10 years of driving stick/standard to | an EV and the sensation of instant power dwarfs the fun of | selecting gear for me. I might just still be in the honeymoon | phase, and I barely drive preferring to bike around everywhere | instead. But having ample power in every situation from highway | acceleration to hill roads pretty much obsoletes everything I | used the stick for. I guess I do miss the habit of clutching | and heel-toeing but with an EV I get all the benefits with none | of the fiddliness. This was not the case when driving anything | but the top automatics. | aussiesnack wrote: | Seems like a nicely balanced perspective. I don't drive much, | but when I do, I much prefer 'manual' (translation of 'stick' | to non-US English), and take pleasure in smooth heel-and-toe | changes. I'm mostly a motorcyclist and similarly enjoy getting | better at smooth braking with changing down and rev-matching. | | But if electric motorbikes become usable and affordable to me | within my lifetime, they will offer different pleasures | (ubiquitous torque, quiet). And outside of driving/riding, | there will be enough pleasures to experience and skills to | learn for many lifetimes. | quantified wrote: | I have always seemed to get better mileage out of a stick than a | CV or automatic and definitely performance that matches my | desires, like engine braking on a downhill. But it really only | pertains to a combustion engine. A stick on a EV seems like a | rotary dial on my smart phone. | idiotsecant wrote: | There is absolutely a good reason for transmissions in an | electric vehicle, it's just that most EVs elect to remove them | for simplicity instead. | | I will leave the interpretation of this graph as an exercise | for the reader. | | https://i.stack.imgur.com/HRUva.gif | etaioinshrdlu wrote: | Manual transmissions are more efficient than automatic because | there is more energy lost to unproductive sloshing in the | torque converter in the automatic, whereas the manual has a | clutch that makes a near-lossless linkage. Nowadays, I'm sure | we could software-automate a mechanically manual transmission | to have the same driver experience as an automatic... | bbarnett wrote: | But was the rotary ever fun to use? | HideousKojima wrote: | My grandparents had a rotary phone and I always thought it | was fun/neat to play around with (they'd unplug it first, | obviously). I was about 8 years old when they got rid of it | so no idea if it's still "fun" to an adult. | bbarnett wrote: | I can very much see it as fun, when it is unusual. | | It isn't fun as a daily driver. | dottedmag wrote: | It definitely was. | bbarnett wrote: | Try saying that when using it in real life, making many | calls daily, with an exchange such as 908-. | | Then, the tone dialer appears. | | I was not interested in interacting with my telephone. I | just wanted it to place calls. | chinabot wrote: | Its basically petrol heads who prefer manual transmissions, I | doubt any of them have economy in mind, I have a manual | transmission on my hilux EV conversion unless I'm going uphill | or have a big load it stays in 3rd from start to finish | nimbius wrote: | as a heavy diesel mechanic the only application i can see is | heavy trucks. current slushbox automatics in the latest series of | long hauler over the road rigs is absolutely useless on grade and | costs triple to replace and service compared to existing manuals. | you dont want an unprovoked shift in the rain or snow when youre | dragging forty tons. | bombcar wrote: | Even those can likely be replaced with hybrids, after all a | locomotive pulls a lot more (900,000 tons of steel according to | the poet, but I think he's off a bit) and you can't build a | transmission for that. | Animats wrote: | Well, you can, but the history of locomotives with gearshifts | is not a happy one. British Rail in the 1950s had a Diesel | road locomotive (not just a railcar) with a manual | transmission. The shifting was powered, but not automatic. | Hitachi has built some switching locomotives with geared | transmissions and a really big 12-plate clutch. | | But no, you don't want to do that. | nimbius wrote: | i think youre right and i think the market will adjust, but | the current application is just trying to take what works on | local and regional beer haulers and ups vans and scale it up. | very myopic and leads to a lot of frustration when logistics | companies realize their drivers arent qualified to leave the | state with bigger loads because they never learned stick | Clent wrote: | I think this is why is would take off in trunks; probably | anything that hauls. | | As the article states in the article, there is no engine to | stall. This is more like vehicles with D, D1, D2. It's | optional efficiency. | | For an electric vehicle, switching between them doesn't | stall the vehicle, but it could be used to increase | distance between charges. | GnarfGnarf wrote: | I'm a big fan of manual transmissions, but if it adds more things | that need adjusting and that can break on an EV, I wouldn't want | one on my next (electric) car. | jmcphers wrote: | This went in a different direction than I'd guessed. As someone | who still drives a manual transmission car in the US, my guess is | that non-electric cars will eventually be a category for | enthusiasts. | | Those for whom a car is an appliance will gravitate towards | increasingly cheap, subsidized, low-maintenance electrics, but | there will probably always be a market for gas models for those | who can afford them, and my guess is those will increasingly | feature stick shifts since they're targeted at the enthusiast | crowd. | AlbertCory wrote: | I taught a 16-year-old (not my son) to drive a stick. It was | easy. I checked online and there's a place that will teach you | the basics for $295. I'd do it for half. There's not much demand | for that, unfortunately. | | The biggest magic tricks to teaching were (1) teaching him to | _think_ about gear changes before actually doing them, and (2) | being relaxed about mistakes. | | For (1) I would drive, and have _him_ tell me when to shift. This | gets over the intellectual hurdle of coordinating engine speed | with road speed. | | For (2), I just said, "OK, you're _going_ to stall the car, and | you 're _going_ to grind the gears. Everybody does. It 's no big | deal. Here, watch, I'll do it." Then I'd stall & grind the gears, | show him to get out of the grinding, and laugh about it. I think | anxiety is the biggest problem. | | I'm sure if it's your own son or daughter, it gets more | complicated :) | convolvatron wrote: | don't forget the first time you have to start on a hill. or | brake. first time I had to brake hard I forgot to put in the | clutch and that was the whole front end. | sprior wrote: | Correct me I'm wrong, but I was under the impression that EV's | like Tesla don't really have a transmission as in gears to | change, so as much as I'm a diehard manual transmission fan I | figured that was where it ends. Now a clutch pedal that simply | allows the vehicle to coast with regenerative breaking disabled | sounds like the best compromise to me. | idiotsecant wrote: | if your only use case is to disengage the regen braking you | should probably just have a regen braking disable function, a | clutch is an awfully complicated way to achieve that. You could | literally have a software 'clutch' pedal that did nothing other | than disable the regen if that was your goal. | | Although on the other hand the clutch does have a nice | property, which is that it works regardless of the state of the | control system of the vehicle. If my MCU decides it wants to | accelerate me at 500 mph into a wall a hardware clutch would be | a nice thing to have! | | W.r.t gearboxes in EVs: there is definitely a reason to have a | transmission in an EV, it's just that most manufacturers don't | include one for simplicity . | | https://i.stack.imgur.com/HRUva.gif | NegativeK wrote: | You're correct; Teslas (and most EVs) have a gear reduction but | no ability to change any gears, since they don't really need | to. Coasting comes by feathering the accelerator, similar to | how you can slowly decelerate in a manual transmission. | | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zsa-SxpiCU0 has Ken Block | talking about how different driving a high performance EV is, | though, since you have full wheel speed range without shifting. | On one hand, you don't need to work a clutch to keep turbos | spooled up; on the other, you have to be much more precise | because you can't let the clutch slip for additional control. | | In consumer EVs, though, the car won't really let your wheels | slip. | hinkley wrote: | If memory serves from the test drives, the new Hyundai/Kia | electric vehicles (built on a common platform) have paddle | shifters that only manage regenerative braking, similar to how | you would use engine braking. | | One of the subtler features of my DSG vehicle is that on most | downhills it will automatically downshift to maintain speed. On | a really steep hill it will start to race, but feathering the | brake for 5-10 seconds will convince it to downshift once more. | I haven't driven it in the mountains hardly ever, but that's | one area where manuals often win out - no melted brake pads, no | heat-warped calipers. | | In fact I put way more miles on the first set of brake shoes on | this car than I would have dreamed possible, to the point I | started having mechanics check their records to make sure we | didn't change them while it was in for something else. | Waterluvian wrote: | Like a record player, if there's demand, it'll get built. | gtvwill wrote: | I just wanna see racing ev's with straight cut dog boxes. | | Audio Volume Warning. Turn sound way down. | | https://youtu.be/dmJH84FnQa8 | seqastian wrote: | Will be pricey though. | zwieback wrote: | For a long time there was a perception that Europeans are real | drivers with their stick shifts and | | _" didn't everyone in the world think that American people were | babies--with their innocence, their Disney, their inability to | drive a stick shift?"_ (Elif Batuman) | | but maybe with EVs and modern automatic transmissions the day | really has come to say goodbye to manual transmission. Our family | cars have them and my daughter just bought a new manual Civic but | not for any real rational reason. | Gare wrote: | No, the reality is that we were (and still are, though a bit | less) poor compared to the Americans. I can afford myself a | nice automatic car and it is a blessing for me, but most of my | compatriots still can't. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-11-18 23:00 UTC)