[HN Gopher] The persistent and pervasive impact of bullying in c... ___________________________________________________________________ The persistent and pervasive impact of bullying in childhood and adolescence Author : PaulHoule Score : 154 points Date : 2022-11-30 14:30 UTC (8 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) (TXT) w3m dump (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) | CalRobert wrote: | Of course, in some places huge multinational organisations were | found to be protecting child rapists and by and large got to keep | running schools. Not sure governments are about to start caring | about child welfare. | carabiner wrote: | Cue HN "it's just words" refrain. | boeingUH60 wrote: | I attended high school in a not-well-known country (Nigeria) and | the amount of bullying I witnessed was unfathomable. I'm talking | outright beatings from seniors, and it was legalized (reporting | to the school authorities will get you more beatings). | | I transferred from a chill private school to a public school | because, well, my Dad wanted me to have some | "experience"...needless to say, the experience I got was that | even teens can be extremely cruel to each other...the funny part | is that most people here see it as normal and laugh about it, | like they don't realize they're living the equivalent of a wild | animal farm...but for some reason, I got over the horrific | bullying real quick...or maybe I'm scarred and don't know it. | ilaksh wrote: | That's just a gang that has taken over a school and the adults | are afraid of them. | boeingUH60 wrote: | Haha, yes, unfortunately that's how it is at virtually all | government-run schools in my country...pure cruelty is the | order of the day, and I'm not exaggerating. | [deleted] | kingofheroes wrote: | When I was coming up, especially in middle school, we were always | told that you should just ignore bullies and they would go away. | This, of course, never actually worked. And anyone who did fight | back against their bullies were punished just as severely, if not | moreso if they swung first, as the bully. This entire approach | was complete BS and only served to enable bullies because they | now know that their victims either won't fight back or, if they | do, the victim will receive most of the consequence. | | With the benefit of hindsight, I think its vitally important that | all children learn some form of self-defense (boxing, karate, | BJJ, it doesn't matter). I only realized this way later in life | when I started training in Muay Thai and found I had way more | confidence standing up to other men, both because I knew how to | handle myself and because I wasn't as afraid of getting punched | in the face. Bullies only go away if you make them go away. | Fighting back is the only real solution victims have in the | absence of adult supervision (which is often the situation). You | may be punished, but the sense of catharsis more than makes up | for that. | pengaru wrote: | > You may be punished, but the sense of catharsis more than | makes up for that. | | The kind of punishment doled out by law-abiding adults to | children isn't even a blip on the radar vs. suffering a vicious | bully. It isn't even worth mentioning, punishment for violence | is a total farce until adulthood. That's basically the whole | source of the problem; bullys have realized there are no | consequences. | | The best response to a bully is an immediate and vigorous | aggression resembling that of a honey badger, full stop. I | agree it's important to teach children self-defense and get | them familiar enough with conflict to not piss themselves when | faced with it. It's the children who can get away with fighting | back without negative consequence, and substantial upside | potential. | P5fRxh5kUvp2th wrote: | 100%, the way to avoid being bullied is to not be an easy | target. | | I once had a kid bullying me in middle school. I spoke with my | mother about it, who recommended I say something to the | teachers, which I did. | | When that didn't work I knocked the shit out of him the next | time he tried to bully me, to the point that he was running | around the edges of the classroom trying to get away from me | while I chased him down to beat on him some more. | | He stopped fucking with me after that. | | To your point, we both got suspended, but my mother made it | clear I wasn't being punished and made sure I had fun during | that suspension. | | It's a lifelong skill that will be used as an adult too. | bsnnkv wrote: | I've written before that as I get older (as a male), I appreciate | the importance of physical prowess more and more, and definitely | infinitely more than I did as a teenager. | | With regards to taking steps to insulate yourself and | particularly your male children from physical bullying (= | assault): | | The first stop should be developing a body and a physical | demeanor that naturally makes any bullies think twice about | trying to assault you- the perceived cost should outweigh any | potential benefit for them. | | If that fails, and it probably will at some point, because there | is always someone bigger and stronger, you need to be proficient | in some kind of striking sport. Boxing is great for this. You | don't need to be able to go to the final bell with Mayweather, | but again, you need to be able to hurt the bully enough that in | the future they'll know that the cost will outweigh any potential | benefit. | photochemsyn wrote: | The article has a rather convoluted definition of 'bullying': | | > "Bullying, a form of peer victimisation, can take place between | children, between adolescents or between adults. It is not | bullying when a parent or a teacher is abusive towards a child. | While the terms peer victimisation and bullying are often used | interchangeably, peer victimisation is not equivalent to | bullying. For example, it is not bullying when two people of | about the same strength quarrel or fight, but it is peer | victimisation. An especially important feature of bullying is the | power imbalance between those who perpetrate bullying behaviours | and their victims..." | | The notion that parental or teacher abuse can't be called | bullying is nonsensical, as it produces the same kind of behavior | in children (fearful, submissive, avoidance, etc.). The general | psychological concept is 'operant conditioning', essentially | brainwashing by authority figures enforced by violence, | humiliation, and so on. It's a key feature of all authoritarian | systems. There's little doubt that schoolyard bullies are merely | aping the behavior of adult authoritarian figures: | | https://www.thoughtco.com/operant-conditioning-definition-ex... | | The best literature on bullying (and also a criticism of the | British school system) IMO is "Lord of the Flies" (William | Golding, 1954). Note it was _not_ a critique of so-called 'human | nature' in general but of a particular societal construct. | | https://crookedtimber.org/2019/11/07/englands-ruling-patholo... | | > "Virginia Woolf drew a very clear line between the | brutalisation of little boys in a loveless environment and their | assumption as adults into the brutal institutions of colonialism. | It's long been clear to many that the UK is ruled by many people | who think their damage is a strength, and who seek to perpetuate | it." | | People are often reluctant to discuss this, because it exposes | the fact that "free Western democracies" employ these | authoritarian tactics (perhaps with heavier emphasis on | psychological control vs. physical control) just as often as | communist or theocratic states do. | corobo wrote: | Heh, decent timing. My last CBT session ended with me realising | one of my issues may be a lasting effect of bullying. | | Essentially I was trying to find out why I procrastinate, beyond | "it's just the ADHD lol" | | Boiled it down and down and down until we hit the core of the | issue and realised I don't want to poke my head up and ship | code/sites/ideas/etc because I believe I'll be bullied for it. In | school doing anything that lifted you up (e.g. good grades) made | you a target. | | The realisation was that that will probably not to happen now. If | I do something exceptional at 34 I probably wont be bullied by my | peers (or heck, even if I actually was bullied for it.. who cares | lol, my peers don't understand the market I work in) | | I'd never reevaluated the internalised rule "If I excel, I will | be bullied" until the other day. | | -- | | On a slightly more positive spin the whole thing made me quite | sensitive to deception. If someone is trying to deceive or | manipulate me my subconscious might as well be flashing up a | Metal Gear Solid exclaim noise for how obvious it seems. | | MGS Exclaim for reference: | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qbeEO58Hlfo | standardUser wrote: | I strongly relate. I've noticed a lot of my bad habits or odd | approaches to things are actually simple pain avoidance. Bad | things happen to us and we unconsciously develop methods of | avoiding or lessening those bad things. No different than a | beaten dog flinching at a raised hand. For me, a lot of these | behaviors have been easy to unlearn, but it took half a | lifetime to notice them in the first place. And who knows what | other subtle pain avoidance behaviors I engage in that I've yet | to see or understand. | frodetb wrote: | It' uplifting to hear that these things can be managed and | unlearned. I hate knowing that I am my own biggest obstacle | in certain respects. | a1pulley wrote: | Does anyone have experience with going to a "school within a | school" for "gifted and talented" kids? I was trying to figure | out why I don't remember any bullying from my middle school or | high school, when it dawned on me that I might have been | insulated from it by taking classes exclusively with gifted and | talented kids --i.e., kids from stable/whole/educated | households. I went to a high school where kids came from a mix | of blue collar and lower-earning white collar families; does | bullying still happen at public high schools in wealthy areas? | | There's a lot of discussion here about how private school kids | are insulated from bullying. Does anyone have first-hand | experience or hard evidence of this? Based on books and movies | about boarding school, it's hard to believe this. | jvm___ wrote: | "If I excel, I will be bullied" or "I need to bring things with | me to parties/events because people don't value me for just | being me" | SoftTalker wrote: | What? Bringing beer/wine/snacks to parties is just polite. | projectazorian wrote: | There are degrees. | | Bringing a reasonably priced bottle of wine from a winery | you like - nice and thoughtful. Bringing a bottle of Opus | One - you're overcompensating. | jrgoff wrote: | There is a difference between choosing to do something like | that because it is polite (or whatever other reason you | find compelling) and feeling like you _have_ to do it to be | acceptable. | garbanz0 wrote: | Can you elaborate on how the deception part is related to the | bullying? I don't see the connection | PaulHoule wrote: | I wonder if private schools are a way that rich kids can afford | to be different but poor kids can't. See | | https://sfstandard.com/business/inside-ftx-founder-sam-bankm... | | Would rich kids be facing much more competition for elite spots | from poor but smart kids if bullying wasn't part of the | curriculum in the public schools? Given that only 10% of kids | get to go to a school where dignity is assured, it could be | that 90% of the smart kids are being kneecapped and don't reach | their full potential. One more thing that makes a mockery of | "meritocracy". | | I was glad to see though that New Hampshire (where I grew up) | finally passed a law making it possible to sue schools for | bullying like the other 49 states. | | https://newhampshirebulletin.com/2021/05/26/families-deserve... | | I wonder also how many Enrons and Challenger Disasters we've | had because many of what could have been our best people had it | beat into them that self-assertion is not allowed for them. | beezlebroxxxxxx wrote: | Private schools are an instance of opportunity hoarding, and | "opportunity" should be understood in a number of ways. The | opportunity to buy a certain level of freedom from bullying | in favour of a "selective" crowd, for instance. Though I | doubt there is _less_ bullying in private schools, more that | it manifests in different ways; if I had to hypothesize, I | might suppose the bullying is of a different intensity | though. | PaulHoule wrote: | I was bullied intensely in the public schools. My parents | were able to get me into a private school for just one year | and the difference was night and day. For the first time in | my life I was able to go to school and get respect. They | sent me back to the public schools for the fourth grade and | it was war all the time all over again. | | Someone I know used to brag about the stunt he pulled to | embarrass the private high school he went to and I shut him | up pretty harshly about it because I had suffered so much | in the public schools and how I would have appreciated the | privilege that he got more than he did. | | Of course he had his own problems including a struggle with | alcoholism, getting beaten up by the cops, etc. and today | he is a tenant and I am his landlord so it's not like I | didn't catch some breaks. | savryn wrote: | yeah, when I was trying to figure out 'What is the moment | before the split second "my fingers just opened a new tab" | effect, I realized so much of adhd is really consciously or | subconsciously: | | emotional flinching | | distraction is just running away from a feeling. I don't | actually care about the content of the new tab, i'm not | addicted to the internet, blah blah | | ---------- | | BTW, The old book Focusing by Eugene Gendlin really helped me | here-- it's on libgen or you can youtube the authors name to | see some of his one on one sessions he did with people before | he died. (You can do it yourself without a person tho, it's | just having a kind listener helps you stick with it) | | it's NOT about adhd or focusing on stuff lol, it's the name for | his diy technique of 'figuring out what the feeling is' and | unlocks all other therapy stuff that you may do after | AppleBananaPie wrote: | Thanks for sharing 'distraction is just running away from a | feeling.' It puts my experience into words succinctly without | giving a root cause to why I might feel that feeling. | Separately sometimes I can find a period of my life that | seems to explain why I act the way I do but I'm also not | confident in my memory to know if it was happening before | hand or if I'm just associating two things that are only | slightly related. | | For example: I tend to be a very self deprecating individual | because I like to laugh and hang out with people who say | silly things but I also use it as a crutch to avoid | accidentally offending people. I went to a very bad college | and so was considered very good at academics while there and | may have developed this then to fit in. I could also have | developed it growing up because it was a way to laugh off | mistakes. I could also just like the sense of humor. Heck | even this statement I'm replying to that I like so much I'm | certain I've heard it and resonated with it before but have | just lost focus of it over time. | | Anyway thanks again for sharing, it has helped refined my | thinking. | corobo wrote: | Yeah the whole "ok but _why_ do I respond like that? " is a | massive focus now that I've realised there are all these | internal rules I've been following since early teens and | possibly even younger. | | I'll absolutely give that a look into, thank you! | | Also for nerds who have yet to consider it: CBT is like | debugging code, except the code is your brain. I'd highly | recommend looking into it where possible, especially if you | are opposed or wary of the "and how does that make you feel?" | style of therapy. Fascinating field, and quite helpful for me | so far. | [deleted] | 4qz wrote: | IX-103 wrote: | Right. That's why I have my 3 year old scheduled for a nose | job. I'll probably wait a couple years on the boob job. | | /s | 4qz wrote: | thewebcount wrote: | I sometimes feel like I'm in some alternate universe when I read | stuff like this: | | > These new findings indicate that interventions should also | focus on supporting victims of bullying and helping them build | resilience; | | ... | | > These studies suggest that public health interventions could | aim at preventing children from becoming the target of bullying | behaviours from an early age. | | Have we considered ways to make bullies not want to bully? That | seems way more productive to me. I'm mean, I'm all for teaching | kids resilience and self-reliance, but at some point, we have to | get to the root of the problem, which is the bullies and why they | want to bully other kids and stop trying to just fix the kids who | get bullied. | s1artibartfast wrote: | >Have we considered ways to make bullies not want to bully? | That seems way more productive to me. | | It is entirely possible that the want to bully can be reduced | but cannot be prevented. Of course people should do what they | can to prevent it on the bully side, but it is reasonable to | also consider other factors. | hateful wrote: | There's a term for this: Victim Blaming. | | It's one thing to not be so sensitive when it comes to jokes or | teasing, but this requires a maturity that a child does not yet | have. | | A feel as though a lot of people that say those things haven't | been victims of bullying, or maybe, at least, not the a certain | extent that others were (I know I'm treading very close to a No | True Scotsman with that statement). | | I was bullied when I was a child and it was BAD. I can't really | express how EVIL the bullies were. Like something out of a | horror film. | | Edit: I'm a little confused by the replies - I re-read my | comment to see if anything was ambiguous. I'm saying that | bulling is way worse than people think. Maybe it was unclear | that I am agreeing with the comment I was replying to, not | opposing it? | s1artibartfast wrote: | If there was something that you could have done yourself to | prevent or stop it, would you refuse to do it? | | If there are skills that could be taught to children to | prevent their own bullying, would you deny them? | P5fRxh5kUvp2th wrote: | I would take it 1 step farther, if you're not teaching your | children how to deal with bullies themselves then you're | harming them for life. | | There's a point at which the child cannot possibly deal | with it and you as the parent must step in to protect them, | but most of the time if a child learns how to deal with | bullies you don't need to. | hateful wrote: | Of course I would. I feel as though this is a false | dichotomy. It isn't either/or. I wish I got the help that I | needed and that adults took it more seriously - not going | into detail, but I ended up almost dying because of it. | Jensson wrote: | The study literally says that you should ALSO help the | victim build resilience, it never says that we should | stop preventing bullies from bullying. | P5fRxh5kUvp2th wrote: | > A feel as though a lot of people that say those things | haven't been victims of bullying, or maybe, at least, not the | a certain extent that others were | | I say those things and my stepfather was abusive to the point | of choking me unconcious and kicking me in the face with a | steel-toed boot. | | Please, do tell about how I know nothing about dealing with | abuse at the hands of others. | jacooper wrote: | But that's not bullying, that's just straight up Abuse. | Teever wrote: | I'd go so far as to suspect that anyone calling this victim | blaming is a bully themselves and is attempting to make | people at large less resilient to bullying by advocating | positions that don't promote resiliency and self control in | these kinds of situations. | P5fRxh5kUvp2th wrote: | > Have we considered ways to make bullies not want to bully? | That seems way more productive to me. | | At over 40 years of age I've had to deal with people attempting | to bully me, most of them are completely shocked when they | realize they can't. | | My point here is that if you think bullying is something that | stops at graduation then sure, that sounds like a reasonable | position, but the premise itself is wrong. | | One of my favorite lines: | | > Bullies don't stop being bullies when they graduate, they | just get lawyers. | onemoresoop wrote: | This is a good point. Policing bullying in school (when | young) may work if one can catch it in the act but this bully | behavior never stops in adulthood, it starts taking different | forms. Being aware of bullies and not being affected by their | actions helps but they will only find a different target. | thewebcount wrote: | Do you think that if bullies were stopped when young, they | might be able to turn into adults that don't bully? | | Regardless, as others have said here, I have way more avenues | for dealing with bullies as an adult, including but not | limited to getting my own lawyers. | barbariangrunge wrote: | A lot of bullies were bullied when they were younger. It's a | chicken-and-egg problem | olau wrote: | I read somewhere that to be successful you need to focus on the | environment people are in, as in instead of trying to figure | out who the bullies are, you need to figure out why a certain | environment leads to bullying behaviour. | thewebcount wrote: | That sounds productive to me. | dionidium wrote: | This presupposes that bullying is always explained by something | environmental or that it's learned behavior. But what if | bullying is just fun for some people? What if human beings have | differing innate levels of aggression, empathy, and tolerance? | What if some people see bullying and feel a little pit in their | stomach -- fear, disgust, anger -- and what if others simply | don't? | | "The blank slate" conception of the world continues to mislead | us about the domain of effective interventions. | MrVandemar wrote: | >But what if bullying is just fun for some people? | | We have a word for those people: "sociopath" | thewebcount wrote: | I don't understand what point you are trying to make here. If | some people find bullying fun, they should be taught why it | isn't fun for others and dealt with if they continue. I mean | I'm sure rapist think that their rape is fun or empowering or | something, but that doesn't mean it should be allowed. | wutheringh wrote: | The scientific consensus is that more commonly aggressive | disorders that involve violating others' rights like BPD and | ASPD are less treatable than anxiety and depression. | | Stop trying to apply feels-right reasoning to complex medical | topics. You're out of your wheelhouse. | thewebcount wrote: | I'm not sure how getting to the root of the problem instead | of treating the symptoms is "trying to apply feels-right | reasoning to complex medical topics." If the topics are more | complex, let's address those complexities. I feel like when | they say, "We should teach kids how to survive bullying | better," they're the ones trying to apply feels-right | reasoning to a complex situation. That's a short-term | solution. If the real, long-term solution is medical | intervention of some sort, then do that! But don't let the | bullying continue and put all of the work on the victim of | the bullying. Sure, we can help them be more resilient, as I | said above. But the actual problem needs to be addressed no | matter how hard or complex it is. | PaulHoule wrote: | Bullying is the social destruction of self not because it is | the act of one "crazy" person but because bullies have the | support of the entire community including teachers, other | students, and school administration. | | If it was just one violent person doing one thing it would be | a minor act. It is everyone being complicit in this act that | demonstrates to you how worthless you are that destroys you. | | I recently wrote a letter to the alumni development office of | the undergraduate school I went to about why I don't give | money to them when I was re-traumatized by receiving the | first alumni newsletter I had received in a long time. | | We had a student who waged a war against gays but this was | the 1980s and people like that were so afraid of AIDS that | instead they'd bash straight people who showed the slightest | amount of support for gays. I couldn't leave my room without | the risk of being assaulted. It only ended when he hit a | resident assistant in the face with a rock from a catapult at | point blank range. A gay man and a lesbian woman committed | suicide because of this nonsense. | | This person had support from many groups of people at tech | including religious people, drug users (this guy was the drug | dealer who would take the biggest chances to get supply) and | the school administration. What I found was so wounding was | that I lost many of my friends over this. | | The person I blame most of all was the very popular dean of | students who told me repeatedly that his "hands were tied" | but I am sure he would have found something he could have | done if his daughter was the victim. | | The ringleader of this group went to prison a few years later | because he was caught on tape selling 3 kilos of cocaine to | an undercover cop. If I heard he was still alive and had gone | straight I would would forgive him and actually celebrate him | because he has paid for his crimes and it is such a hard | thing to go straight. | | I would have a very hard time forgiving the dean of students | because he has received so many accolades from people and is | seen as a hero (for many good reasons), I grieve more for the | people who were victims of suicide than I do for my own | suffering which was minor in comparison. I wonder how many | other victims there are from before and after I was there. It | is all the more wounding for me because otherwise college | would have been a respite and chance to heal from the abuse I | received in the public schools. | somethoughts wrote: | I would say in an ideal world yes, but the fact is that in the | real world a lot of generalizable anti-bullying | messaging/curriculum can start from a good place but can easily | be mis-construed or willfully and purposefully construed or in | fact morph into such things like critical race theory, etc. | | Society will probably need a lot of time to collectively figure | out where to draw the line between the spectrum ranging from | "let's not bully a distinct subgroup of people" and "why are we | unnecessarily over-empowering a distinct subgroup over all | other groups". | | In the meantime, those people in the subgroups need support. | spicyramen_ wrote: | I used to help classmates that were bullied by defending them | either by stopping other kids hitting them or hurting them | verbally. Kids can be evil. Some people are unaware what can | cause to other peoples lives. Now I have 2 boys, I teach them how | to box and good manners. Reality is that they can face bullies | and they should be ready to engage in physical fight, words | sometimes don't matter | aurizon wrote: | One of the huge problems in schools, as well as in cyberspace is | bullying in social ostracism (shunning etc) as well as beating. | It trains people to 'shed water' in their actions. Surrender to | bullies, yield to their demands and otherwise 'toady' to them. | Anyone who objects or fights back feels the weight of the online | or schoolyard pack members. This is, I feel, exacerbated by the | relentless increase in the cost of teacher oversight. The use of | teachers is an abuse of their role as teachers. They need a class | of staff - watchers etc. There were often student monitors when I | was young to supplement the misuse of teachers in lieu of | employed as watchers. What is the solution? There is a need for | the halls/stairwells/yards to have a watcher present on each | landing, hall segment, entry, exit and all corners of | yards/approaches. This is a lot of people to add to the budget = | it is neglected, this is why they stopped using teachers $$. The | only solution is remote watching with a central operating room. | Sounds like China? - not so much. China has a hated government, | as recent riots show. There is an old adage, 'In loco parentis' | https://www.lawnow.org/search/?q=loco | | We have all read/seen Lord of the Flies - | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_of_the_Flies | | What we see in unfolding in schools (and in our neighborhoods) is | the same sort of structure engendered by a lack of supervision by | 'Parentis' over various groups. So we must assert control in | schools/yards/neighborhoods/online to the degree needed to limit | the levels of oppression exerted by peers/cliques/gangs so people | are free to go about without some one/gang/clique wanting to | exert control. | | So if we put 4K cams in schools/yards/halls with a watch room - | is that OK, what if we have 'true Parentis' watching this stream | as well as staff members? If Johnny bullies Lenny and one of the | parents tells Johnnie's parents - who looks at this later and | chastises Johhny - will this work? Will he not care = it's a | jungle, he has to 'man up' a Lord of the Flies response? | | The same thing plays out in many schools/cities, the hordes of | students and gangs and street people are a large LOTF experiment. | This HAS to be solved. To what degree do other countries have | this problem? | roel_v wrote: | Lord of the Flies was fiction though, not only that, it was | bullshit. when it happened in reality, the exact opposite of | the book happened: https://medium.com/illumination- | curated/real-life-lord-of-th... . | aurizon wrote: | I can see that being how it would go down with a bunch of | peers from similar strata. Sadly the public school milieu in | the USA/UK is a bully-archy....that more closely parallels a | LOTF scenario - absent supervision. | gatane wrote: | You have 40 or more kids on a room, all day. What could go | wrong? | | Welcome to the school system. | b800h wrote: | Being rather contrary here, but is there any evidence that | bullying actually _improves_ some people 's lives? As a victim of | childhood bullying, the experience was awful, but I learned a | thing or two as well. | goda90 wrote: | Bullying encompasses such a broad range of actions, it's | possible some cases can be a strengthening/educating experience | in hindsight, but others can be absolutely life destroying. My | experiences with bullying were pretty mild. I'd say they taught | me patience and standing up for myself when it's the right | time. But they were mild experiences. I can't imagine the | impact of what I've seen in some videos taken by high | schoolers. | janef0421 wrote: | The same could thing could be said of almost any experience. | dsfyu404ed wrote: | I doubt there is any more upside to bullying than there is to | any other bad experience that teaches healthy skepticism. | dboreham wrote: | Builds character. | themitigating wrote: | For everyone and are all the traits that it builds positive? | maire wrote: | My experience gave me tenacity and resilience. | | My experience was not as bad as some others on this list. I | believe that is because girls are psychological bullies, and | boys are physical bullies. My husband was chased and beaten up | until he the beat up the lead bully. | | I met my lead bully as an adult. I was surprised to find out | that she did not realize she was a bully. She acted as if we | were childhood friends. One of her friends apologized to me, so | others certainly realized. | | Her life did not go as well as my life. I suspect it was | because the traits that made her a bully as a child did not | work for her as an adult. | skippyboxedhero wrote: | If you look at countries that have large private and | comprehensive education systems (and which aren't well- | segregated like the US), it is very obvious that you are | permanently ruining the lives of hundreds of thousands of kids | every year. | | Whether you learn something from it or not, the purpose of | school is to learn. If you went into work every day and had | someone beating you up every day, would you be productive? | Probably not (and btw, the only reason we have systems where | this happens at all is because of what adults want, not what | kids want). | ryanklee wrote: | Every experience has something to teach, but that just means | all experiences are alike in this one regard. It's an | absolutely horrible way to justify the various strains of hell | that run through the world. | | Please replace the word bullying in your question with the word | rape or mutilation or imprisonment or starvation and see how | horrible that line of thinking is. | oifjsidjf wrote: | "School is the only place where modern humans will experience | violence". | jxramos wrote: | why is that exactly, there is some weird | purification/concentration of social things that only happen at | school. Is it the spike of age cohorts (+/-6mo) all thrown | together without any regulating factors that would occur with | older wiser children (say +6 years) being able to correct the | misbehaving individuals? Is it a factor of the sheer | outnumbering encountered from high student to adult ratios? Is | bullying less likely to occur when the adult count increases? | lotsofpulp wrote: | In the US, probably a combination of reduced birthrates means | there is less density of children, in conjunction with real | estate development that requires cars to travel point to | point, effectively filtering out situations where children | get together without adults. | yamtaddle wrote: | Teachers/admin can't long-term isolate the shitheads unless | they go _really_ far--notably, it 's very hard to be kicked | out for bullying that's short of repeated cases of extreme | outright violence. A teacher and even school admin can't | "fire" a chronically disruptive and/or bullying student. | Other students can't vote with their feet and flee the | classes with the worst bullies. They're stuck and no-one has | the power to fix the situation. | | That's why it's so bad. One employee starts pulling dumb shit | and several employees report it to the manager, good chance | that employee's not going to be able to keep it up much | longer or they'll be gone. Yes, abuse happens at workplaces, | but school-type bullying doesn't have the same kind of cover | it does in a school. Several students report a bully, that | bully will still be there next week. And next quarter. And | maybe in their class next year. Still being a bully. | | Selection bias during admissions gets talked about a lot when | it comes to private schools, but they also have the | superpower of being able to tell a kid who won't shape up to | GTFO permanently. One family's tuition isn't worth risking | several other students leaving. This can and does happen, and | it doesn't solve all the problems, but it means the worst of | the worst don't stick around like they do at public schools, | poisoning the whole school atmosphere. | themitigating wrote: | If an adult attacks someone they can go to jail or at the | minimum are arrested for assault. In school the consequences | are much less serious | skorpeon87 wrote: | That's nothing to do with school though, just youth. Kids | who get into fights in the summer months away from school | aren't sent to jail for it like adults. Being at or away | from a school isn't a factor in that difference. | skorpeon87 wrote: | Nah, that doesn't ring true to me. I got into plenty of scraps | during the summer when I was a kid. Nothing that rose to the | asymmetry I would describe as bullying, but certainly it was | violence. And besides the overt fights, many of the games we | played were essentially organized fights. | | Maybe things are different now, with kids spending too much | time indoors playing video games instead of running around in | the woods. But I think violence is generally an outcome from | boys being together and relatively unsupervised. The insidious | part about violence in schools is the double-jeopardy you face | from administration; first you get your ass kicked by the | bully, then you get your ass kicked again by the bureaucracy | putting you through the wringer. | SapporoChris wrote: | A number of military personal might beg to differ with you. But | I'm willing to hear justification for your comment. | pegasus wrote: | Only in the military? Wouldn't it be easier to steelman the | argument by inserting the missing "most"? | SapporoChris wrote: | Certainly not only the military. I was countering an | absolute statement, I don't need to list all exceptions to | prove the statement wrong. I only need to list one. | AtlasBarfed wrote: | Is that some manipulative jingoistic pro-military shaming? | | A boxer obviously will see violence, so will a pigskin | football player. Those are things they signed up for and the | violence is part of the voluntary activity. | | A soldier (or policeman) signs up to be in war, either an | active one or one that might happen. | | A high school student, a cube worker, a barista, a fireman, | they do not sign up for violence. | | The difference is that children have no choice but to go to | school. They are sent to the slaughter. | [deleted] | badcppdev wrote: | But they will witness violence all the time through media of | different types. Which affects you in a different way. | BetaDeltaAlpha wrote: | FYI: The full quote is "Public Schools are prisions for | children, and are one of the only places where many people will | experience physical violence." | [deleted] | black_13 wrote: | HPsquared wrote: | Reminder that this study is only showing a correlation. | | It could also be the well-known effect that "weaker" (physically | or mentally) people are more likely to be bullied. | | The way to test causation is to have a "control" group with | normal environmental bullying levels, and a second group which is | otherwise identical to the first, randomly targeted by the | scientists for extra bullying. This would of course be unethical. | It also wouldn't be double-blind, and also wouldn't be the same | process anyway. In short, it's impossible to prove empirically. | civopsec wrote: | > It could also be the well-known effect that "weaker" | (physically or mentally) people are more likely to be bullied. | | Dang, I was going to post this suggestion as a joke (because | "proof that weak people deserve it"--get it?). | lukas099 wrote: | I don't think anyone said anything about 'deserving it'. | [deleted] | [deleted] | giantg2 wrote: | "It could be that "weak" (physically and/or mentally) people | tend to get bullied more." | | This is absolutely true in my experience. It's the same way | that many criminals prey on the smaller/older/weaker in | society. Why pick a target that has a good chance of winning in | a fight? I'm sure plenty of others have anecdotes, but I fought | a bully, won, and they were always friendly after that. | paradox242 wrote: | This is why I am going to emphasize to my son that if someone | begins to bully him, the sooner he corrects the bully's | assessment of him the sooner it will likely stop. This may | include violence (with many caveats) if necessary, as | frankly, it's the only language they often understand and | respect. I am not happy that this is the case, but this | behavior appears to be a universal part of the human | condition. Based on my experience, adult intervention or even | supervision cannot be counted on, so it will be something | that eventually he will need to learn to handle himself. | | Bullying in it's most common and less extreme forms appears | to be a way of reinforcing group conformity and norms, as | it's often directed at those who are different in appearance | or behavior. By calling attention to this with name calling | or teasing, they publicly demonstrate their own in-group | status and as a side-effect also pressure the target to | conform to group expectations. Over time, this can be just as | insidious and damaging even though violence may not be always | involved. | | In the most pathological form, you have a person that has a | lot of internal uncertainty around their own position in the | social hierarchy (which actually may be quite high already | and part of what makes this pathological) for which bullying | is a way to assert their dominance over another. These are | the bullies that we all know and which seem to fixate on a | particular target or group, and are the type I alluded to in | my opening paragraph. They are not necessarily spoiling for a | fight (that is something else entirely and distinguishing the | two can be difficult) but rather have identified their target | as being someone weak or low status enough that they will not | fight back nor will anyone rise to defend them. However, if | the target does fight back and even if they lose, if this | happens consistently then that is often enough to update the | calculation on their end about whether the benefits outweigh | the costs (after all, they could eventually lose the fight or | at least it could be close enough that they don't win | convincingly which is almost as bad) and their attention will | shift elsewhere. | | There is also a greater likelihood that others may stand up | for you if you stand up for yourself. It is another tendency | of human psychology that I have observed that those who do | nothing and essentially "take it" are viewed with contempt | even if those observers also disapprove of the bullying. | There seems to be some general undercurrent of disgust with | perceived weakness, but this is perhaps rooted in some sense | that the risk of intervention is less likely to be | reciprocated. After all, if the victim doesn't appear willing | or able to do this for themselves, why would they be expected | to do so for someone else? | scythe wrote: | This isn't a study, it's a review of studies. You will also see | this: | | >Establishing temporal priority - what come first, bullying | victimisation or poor mental health - is an essential first | step. Indeed, one important alternative hypothesis that must be | ruled out is that early mental health symptoms account for both | an increased risk for being targeted by bullying behaviours and | also for later psychopathology. Findings so far have shown that | over and above early signs of poor mental health prior to | bullying victimisation, being bullied in childhood or in | adolescence is associated with new symptoms/diagnoses of mental | health problems, and especially with later symptoms of anxiety | and depression (Arseneault et al., 2006; Bowes, Joinson, Wolke, | & Lewis, 2015; Kim, Leventhal, Koh, Hubbard, & Boyce, 2006; | Stapinski et al., 2014; Zwierzynska, Wolke, & Leraya, 2013). | These studies are robust not only because they controlled for | symptoms prior to being bullied but they also controlled for a | range of other potential confounders, including gender, | parental socioeconomic status and low IQ. | civopsec wrote: | Nah, people aren't interested in the studies anymore after | they get to do their correlation-not-causation mic-drop. | blue039 wrote: | I was bullied pretty severely as a kid. So bad in fact I was put | on medication just to deal with it. I was a weaker kid when I was | younger owing to the fact I was sick a lot. | | In America there is a concept of "zero tolerance" that keeps the | bullied compliant and the bullies in charge. It was not until I | started to get very violent that the bullying stopped. I would | fight at a moments notice even sometimes in classrooms. Spent a | lot of time suspended and my parents had conferences. I never | lashed out at anyone. Though if someone tried to insult me, push | me around, etc I would immediately switch modes and start | swinging. As I got bigger and stronger it became less of an | attack of weak punches to full blown knockouts. | | The only way we can solve bullying is by teaching our kids that | violence is not only necessary but expected. Teach them to be | violent, and teach them to control it. You must defend yourself | from these people. Enrolling your kids in an actual martial art | (some combination of boxing, bjj, muay thai, etc) will help. When | they break a bullies nose/arm/etc and get suspended you should | not only encourage them to continue you should celebrate the | victory. You can't win with bullies by "being the better person". | Bullies aren't beat enough at home, so it's your job to bring the | beatings to them. School systems are DESIGNED to protect bullies | and subjugate the bullied. In America, they are prisons. The | sooner children realize this the sooner they realize the methods | to staying alive aren't much different. | | "If you are not capable of violence you are not peaceful, you are | harmless." | skorpeon87 wrote: | > _In America there is a concept of "zero tolerance" that keeps | the bullied compliant and the bullies in charge. It was not | until I started to get very violent that the bullying stopped._ | | Exactly my experience as well. Fighting back is the only thing | that ever made the bullying stop. I fought back once in the | locker room against a boy two years and two feet older and | taller than me, basically lost the fight immediately, but | because I fought and wouldn't submit, everybody else stopped | the fight and after that day I was never bullied in school | again. | | The reason I never fought back sooner is because I was scared | of the rules even more than the bullies. The "Zero tolerance" | rules made clear that if I fought back I would be just as bad | as the bullies, and in just as much trouble (except I'd | actually be in more trouble, because my parents would be livid | at me for getting suspended while the bullies' parents wouldn't | give a shit.) "Zero tolerance" means zero due process. It's the | school administrators essentially siding with bullies by | default because it makes the paperwork easier. Absolutely | immoral. It should be their responsibility to figure out who | actually started the fight and punish the perpetrator but not | the victim. | | In the end I didn't get in trouble after all, because locker | room fights were beyond the eyes of adults and nobody ratted | anybody out. I resent the teachers and the administration the | most, for making me afraid to stick up for myself. The kids who | bullied me were psychos or broken people, and I find it easy to | forgive them. But the administration did harm to me by being | lazy bureaucrats. | tristor wrote: | Absolutely agree. The law I ran afoul of was called the "Safe | Schools Act" and predictably did nothing of the sort. Zero- | tolerance is zero-accountability and zero-sense. It does | nothing to address or resolve problems, just makes the lives | of petty bureaucrats easier. | cnity wrote: | Attaching glowing review and positive outcome to a violent | action in childhood is dangerous (though it did serve you, | yes). The reason is obvious: it can lead to being drawn to | situations likely to lead to the same result and praise. | phkahler wrote: | >> Bullies aren't beat enough at home | | This I have to disagree with. Some of them I believe have a | terrible home life and are handing down the abuse to whomever | is a weak target. | | You may be right in other cases though, and that had never | occurred to me. Lack of respect and self control may stem from | neglect or lack of parenting rather than abuse. | Der_Einzige wrote: | The problem is that they need to be beat for the right | reasons. | | The violence rate of east Asians who were spanked at home | hard by their parents is likely astronomically lower than | Americans who weren't spanked. | | It's not about being spanked, it's about why you were | spanked. Be just. | MagicMoonlight wrote: | >Muh bullyocaust | | Sweetie, that's a cope. Bullying is a choice. It's this kind | of pro-crime, pro-rape thinking that lets all the bad things | happen to people. It's always a choice. Plenty of people | happen to go through much worse things without hurting other | people. Like for example, the victims of the bullies. So it's | clear that there's no inherent reason for the bullies to do | it, they just want to. | JackFr wrote: | A famous American college basketball coach once said "A | basketball fight generally lasts two punches. Make sure you | throw both of them." | kneebonian wrote: | I was bullied quite a bit in school, now my boys are starting | school and I have them enrolled in BJJ, and the first time my | kids comes home upset because someone was picking on him I'll | tell him to put that kid in guard and don't let go until the | teachers physical remove him. | conductr wrote: | What age did you start them with BJJ? I've been considering | for my 4 year old but not sure if that's too early. It seems | too early to tell him to punch the bully in the face (what I | did as a kid) but I like the idea of equipping him with the | ability to subdue a bully until an adult can take control. | kneebonian wrote: | So the gym I train at (they grabbed me after I saw my kids | doing it) has a rule that they need to be at least 3 and | potty trained, so our youngest started a little bit ago and | is more working on the skill of listening and paying | attention than some of the techniques but my 5 yo is | learning some good stuff and is soon going to move from the | young children's class to the youth class where the | emphasis moves from holding still and paying attention to | actual BJJ. | | So I'd say 4 is a good age to start, if you need to find a | good gym I'd recommend going over to old.reddit.com/r/bjj | and asking for advice on there, you'll probably get some | good advice. | | Also it makes wrestling with the kids way more fun when | they try and practice their BJJ at the same time. | conductr wrote: | Great thanks for the feedback and resources! This led me | down a path to discover we have a dojo in our | neighborhood I was unaware of and they have an age 3-5 | class. Just in time for winter break too! Thanks again- I | would have just assumed he was too young for BJJ but this | is pretty exciting actually. I probably won't do it | myself but he can practice on me at home :) | yourapostasy wrote: | _> School systems are DESIGNED to protect bullies and subjugate | the bullied. In America, they are prisons._ | | Most US public schools and low-rate private schools are like | this. If your children are in an ultra-competitive public or | private school however, the bullies are tossed out, the schools | confident in the 100% ironclad certainty there is another | family literally grateful for the opportunity to place their | child in the new opening within 24 hours. The student body goes | through cycles of forgetting this until a new bully is | expelled, then the bullying simmers down to much more subtle | forms. | | In the ultra-competitive private boarding schools, the kind of | over the top physical bullying you hear about in public schools | is nearly non-existent because they will expel on far lower | thresholds for bullying. | | But yes, if your children are in US public school or you are a | child in a US public school, generally speaking fighting back | regardless of the zero tolerance consequences tends to stop the | bullying better than going through toothless school policies. | Bullies tend to prefer soft targets over porcupines. If you are | being bullied and choose to fight back though, then go in at a | location with adults to intervene quickly nearby expecting to | get hurt and lose (in the sense the bully has the physical | upper hand), but never defeated (in the sense you and the bully | have to be separated before you stop). If it is a group doing | the bullying, go for the leader. | | The US public school systems' bullying problem won't stop until | the bullies' parents know that they have a no-recourse, no- | litigation-overturning consequence to bullying that sees their | precious no-fault snowflake expelled to "lower class" schooling | if they run out their options. | JamesBarney wrote: | While this will stop the bullying there is a serious risk of | this affecting your ability to get into a competitive high | school or college. My cousin defended a friend from a bully in | middle school and the bully's parents called the cops on him. | The charges were eventually dropped but the record stayed | around and almost kept him out of the highschool he wanted to | go to. | troon-lover wrote: | racked wrote: | Fully agree. I unfortunately never had the balls to fight back, | but every time I think back about it, I wish I'd just fucking | punched someone. Even now, 20 years after the fact. | dboreham wrote: | > keeps the bullied compliant and the bullies in charge | | I've seen some of this in our local schools: meetings held with | the head teacher to "hear both sides" when one side is a bully | asserting their right to bully the other side. | | > kids in an actual martial art | | I had this idea, based on my experience as a kid, but never | actually got around to enrolling them. They're in college now | and so I guess it wasn't necessary. | Sakos wrote: | > I've seen some of this in our local schools: meetings held | with the head teacher to "hear both sides" when one side is a | bully asserting their right to bully the other side. | | This is endemic in modern culture. The need to treat two | opposing opinions as equally valid and balance them against | each other as if there's some sane middle-ground to be found. | There's no middle-ground between slavery and non-slavery. Or | between the earth is flat and science. | trgn wrote: | Yes 100%, there's a reason for this. Distinguishing right | from wrong is an absolute act, and we have been conditioned | to associate that with religious zealotry or raving lunacy. | By hearing both sides, people are shying away from taking | responsibility. Also, by holding up an ethos (e.g. bullying | is categorically wrong) to others, we hold up a mirror to | ourselves. Hypocrisy is instantly revealed then. (Note for | example that the religious right has no problem being | hypocrites ). | kneebonian wrote: | > They're in college now and so I guess it wasn't necessary. | | Just saying man if you are looking for a Christmas present | for them get them a membership to train at a BJJ gym, if you | have a daughter it will keep her safe, if you have a son it | will give him the opportunity to interact and build | relationships with people he doesn't know, and may not | normally associate with. BJJ is all about technique over | physicality and carries a low risk of injury. | | For both of them it will give them the confidence that if | they end up in a bad situation they know they have the skills | to respond calmly. In addition if the gym is any good they'll | have them do some rolling so they'll be able to learn to stay | calm under pressure, which is a very transferable skill. | | Just a suggestion. | voski wrote: | I was also bullied a lot. Especially between first and eight | grade. I was much bigger than everyone else but I would never | fight back. I always felt bad about potentially hurting someone | else so I would just take it. | | The kids couldn't actually physically damage me since I was so | much bigger. They did cause a lot of psychological harm. I had | a very negative predisposition towards anyone that I met. I | just assumed everyone would be hostile towards me and would | want to make fun of me. I still struggle with this mindset and | I am in my thirties. I will usually be very shut off from | people I do not know. | | There were a couple of times that I did stand up for myself. | Each time the bullying completely stopped. | | I thought I was being the better person by not fighting back | but that was not true. I was being harmless. That harmlessness | invited more violence. | s1artibartfast wrote: | I think the key term here is learned helplessness. Children | and to a lesser extent adults push boundaries. Establishing | strong boundaries is a key part of developing a sense of | control over one's life. | leto_ii wrote: | Based on your virulent tone I suspect you still harbor strong | resentment against your childhood bullies. I somewhat get that, | I was bullied too and I still hate those kids. | | As an adult however I realize that my bullies were actually | abused children who had a rough time at home and took it out on | me at school. | | > When they break a bullies nose/arm/etc and get suspended you | should not only encourage them to continue you should celebrate | the victory. | | Sorry, but this is completely sociopathic insanity. Celebrating | one child maiming another? What is this, the hunger games? | | > Bullies aren't beat enough at home, so it's your job to bring | the beatings to them. | | Do you think it's ever ok for an adult to beat a child? You | have it all wrong, it's the kids who are beat who become | bullies. | | > If you are not capable of violence you are not peaceful, you | are harmless. | | Capable of violence is one thing, systemically encouraging it | as part of normal upbringing is however strictly antisocial. | troon-lover wrote: | tristor wrote: | I pretty much concur. The worst part of being bullied for me | was that I was punished for defending myself by the adults | around me. I got charged with assault in middle school after | winning a fight with a kid who chased me to the bus stop with a | metal pallet strap whipping me, as soon as we were off school | grounds I turned on him and beat him down with a textbook. | | We both were arrested and charged, and I was told to my face by | a judge that "there is no such thing as self-defense in | schools." Which is not only a bald-faced lie, it's | unconstitutional. You have a right to be secure in your person, | and a right to self-defense, well established by the Supreme | Court in case law and described in the Declaration of | Independence. | | I also didn't get bullied again at that school after that | incident. Self-defense is not just a right, it's an imperative. | 0xfeba wrote: | I think you go a bit far, but I agree somewhat. | | I was picked on a fair bit in school. The nature of "zero- | tolerance" meant that fights were quick. I recall one day just | being shoved into a a door threshold unexpectedly. I had had it | at that point from this person, so I took my heaviest book out | of my bag and slammed him in the head with it as he was already | walking away triumphantly. Looking back, he could have been | seriously injured. Many people witnesses and laughed at him. | | He never bothered me again. | | But how can you know someone will leave you alone or just | escalate things? | kneebonian wrote: | > But how can you know someone will leave you alone or just | escalate things? | | You don't but in the animal kingdom most animals haven't | evolved to be able to overcome their predator, they've just | evolved to make it difficult enough for their predator to | decided to look elsewhere for food. Make sure they know if | they pick on you their going to have trouble and they'll go | somewhere else. | [deleted] | [deleted] | 2devnull wrote: | " studies suggest that public health interventions could aim at | preventing children from becoming the target of bullying | behaviours from an early age." | | Sounds almost like victim blaming. If true, if there's something | about the bullied that causes them to be bullied, perhaps | bullying is actually a form of social correction. Not that nature | should be our guide, but often harsh social behavior is | functional from an evolutionary standpoint. That said, | | What huge imago made A psychopathic god: I and the public know | What all schoolchildren learn, Those to whom evil is done Do evil | in return. | trillic wrote: | Who's laughing now? | | https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/WhosLaughingNow | themitigating wrote: | Who determines what is socially correct? | 2devnull wrote: | The bullies. From an evolutionary perspective it would | ultimately come down to those who get to choose their mate. | DFHippie wrote: | > " studies suggest that public health interventions could aim | at preventing children from becoming the target of bullying | behaviours from an early age." | | > Sounds almost like victim blaming. | | The public health measures could be directed at the bullies, | no? | hristov wrote: | Bullying as social correction is a very bad type of social | correction. This way the social correction is done by the | dumbest and most violent members of society in order to conform | society to their vision. And then society grows up to become | dumb and violent. Well lets not kid ourselves, this is exactly | what has been happening in human history, and that why humanity | continues to be mired in suffering and conflict and is | intentionally destroying its environment. But this is something | we have to change. Social correction should be done by trained | adults that know exactly which traits are bad and to be | corrected. | | I think when the article says "that public health interventions | could aim at preventing children from becoming the target of | bullying" they refer to more health based intervention. Such as | helping kids to be healthy and not malnourished, or overweight | from eating bad food. | tablespoon wrote: | > " studies suggest that public health interventions could aim | at preventing children from becoming the target of bullying | behaviours from an early age." | | > Sounds almost like victim blaming. If true, if there's | something about the bullied that causes them to be bullied, | perhaps bullying is actually a form of social correction. Not | that nature should be our guide, but often harsh social | behavior is functional from an evolutionary standpoint. That | said, | | A distinction needs to be made between post-facto "victim | blaming" and prevention that involves potential victims. | Conflating the two leads one to oppose good measures out of an | allegiance to an unrealistically perfect, ideologically- | motivated fantasy (that social problems can and should be | solved _only_ by authorities applying pressure to the "guilty" | people"). | lukas099 wrote: | > Sounds almost like victim blaming. | | I disagree. They are not suggesting that the interventions | specifically target the victims. | 2devnull wrote: | I didn't do a close read. My comment was in response to this: | | " research has identified some factors that predispose | children to be targeted by bullying behaviours. These studies | suggest that public health interventions could aim at | preventing children from becoming the target of bullying | behaviours from an early age." | | To be clear I said nature shouldn't be our guide. Nature | often means that life is nasty brutish and short. I even | quoted the famous Auden poem as support. Sheesh! | licebmi__at__ wrote: | > Sounds almost like victim blaming. If true, if there's | something about the bullied that causes them to be bullied, | perhaps bullying is actually a form of social correction. | | This is only true if bullying actually corrects something which | is a big logical leap to just leave to an appeal to nature. | ilaksh wrote: | It's actually a different problem than most people realize. What | happens is that you have criminal assault and abuse being | tolerated by adults and then blaming the victims. To try to | understand, take the behavior of the "bullies" and imagine it is | being done by adults. | | It really comes down to a lack of responsibility and | accountability for managing the behavior of children in schools. | Instead of dealing with children who are totally out of control, | they blame the victims and compartmentalize the assaults as being | somehow different since they involve children. | | These assaults are actually even more critical to address in | childhood because as they are allowed to form patterns that | persist in criminal assaults and fraud in adulthood. | | This type of failure is one reason that we don't truly have a | civil society. There is this facade of order, but really at the | heart it's just the animal kingdom. There is some aspiration by | those with the responsibility, but on average the teachers etc. | have little real resolve, courage, or capability to actually deal | with the broken and dangerous children that are common in | schools. So they blame the victims. | thegrimmest wrote: | It seems to be very hard to distinguish between bullying and | rough play. Rough play is a developmental requirement | (particularly for young boys) across the hominoid clade (and | likely wider). Being denied it also has real and lifelong | consequences. For further reading, Frans de Waal has done a lot | of work in this area. | | Educational policy informed by this research usually looks not | to intervene in physical conflict between equally matched (by | size/age) peers. It also looks at conflict management and | resolution as a primary responsibility of the peer group, | rather than the adults/teachers, with the escalation path being | to older peers before adults. | ilaksh wrote: | Humans have physical games with rules. "Bullying" is nothing | like that. | agumonkey wrote: | Depends, if it becomes chronic rough play you know something | might be wrong. If you're close enough and can see that it's | asymmetrical and the victim is always the same, someone | should intervene. | TylerE wrote: | An interesting approach I read - I think it was a novel, | honestly, but may have been an autobiography - was that | fights were not just tolerated but sanctioned, with one big | proviso: In the gym, with boxing gloves and headgear on, and | fists only. Going down or taking a knee ends the fight. | | Let 'em work out the tension, but with very minimal chance of | hurting anything. | bentley wrote: | I was a peaceful kid and no good at gym class, which played | some part in why I was bullied. What benefit would I have | received from officially sanctioning my regular physical | humiliation? | TylerE wrote: | Well, for one it forces the school to scknowledge thst'd | it's happening, which is at least half the battle. | | And of course both sides must agree, you can't be forced | in to it. | ilaksh wrote: | This is completely unrelated to the harassment, abuse and | assaults labelled as "bullying". | macinjosh wrote: | I am here for safe and supervised middle school duels. It | would have helped me a lot. | | I went to a strict religious school and a kid who bullied | me over years pushed me too far one day and I started after | him, got maybe one kick to his leg in. Teachers stopped me | immediately, but never did the same for the years of verbal | abuse mocking me for my weight though. I ended up getting | spanked by the principal with a thick wooden paddle in | front of my teacher that day. This was the mid to late 90s. | I heard once the kid who bullied me is in prison now. | erdos4d wrote: | You should get the straight facts on that kid and what he | did and confront the school over it. They obviously | failed across the board with him and probably someone got | hurt for him to get time. They could have done things to | correct his behavior, instead they punished you for | lashing out against his abuse. This needs to show up when | people search that school so other parents know how they | really are and avoid sending their kids there. | dpkirchner wrote: | I wonder how many people would be still willing to fight if | they were forced to delay for some amount of time (hours?). | My hunch is it'd be very few, which would be a win. | mc32 wrote: | There is also "rough teasing" which isn't quite bullying | --but can turn into bullying sometimes. It often calls for | take but give. This typically can happen within your in- | group. | anonym29 wrote: | Rough play is voluntary, being a victim of bullying isn't. I | say this as someone who engaged in rough play, got bullied, | and was a bully, at different times. | thegrimmest wrote: | Learning how to respond to antisocial behaviour by a peer, | and being able to resolve conflict independently, are two | very important skills that it's critical to learn. Being | seen as someone who needs adult help to resolve peer | conflict is socially disastrous for young people. We do | children no favours by intervening in this developmental | process. | anonym29 wrote: | There seems to be a disconnect between what you think | bullying is and how it actually manifests. Between | adults, the behavior would be classified as unprovoked | assault & battery. Someone punching you in the back of | your head while you weren't looking, without a word being | said between either of you, because the other person's | peer group dared them to is not a failure of the victim's | conflict resolution skills. | | To be clear, as a victim, I was subject to unprovoled | physical battery like this more time than I can count | between the start of middle school and my second year of | high school. As a bully, in my senior year, I never | engaged in any kind of physical violence, just name | calling and verbally provoking someone prone to emotional | outbursts. | s1artibartfast wrote: | I think this post speaks to the problem of broadly | discussing "bullying". | | As you point out unprovoked battery and name calling fall | under the same terminology, but the appropriate responses | are obviously not the same. | Dudeman112 wrote: | >being able to resolve conflict, independently | | A shame sometimes the best way to resolve a conflict is | eye gouging the aggressor before they permanently break a | part of your body | | The thing that stuck with me the most by getting the | "resolve your conflicts by yourself" treatment was that | no matter how much someone is being a piece of shit, the | only one you can count on is yourself | | Everyone else will watch as you break, and only intervene | if you fight back. And punishment is only ever dished out | in equal measures between aggressor and victim | | Noticing that was probably the start of considering | people to be rotten by default, reasons are needed to | assume someone isn't | cannaceo wrote: | "Solve the problem yourself". Yeah, you've never had to | deal with being chased by bullies and having the shit | kicked out of you for no reason. Bullying is not a | conflict between peers anymore than a woman getting raped | is a conflict between peers. | | As an adult these problems are solved for you by either | human resources, the police, or being able to avoid the | situation. Maybe that's why you don't walk around the | rough part of town alone at night. As a kid you have no | control over your environment. | thegrimmest wrote: | Well, bullying is many things, and I think the exact | issue is that the conversation lacks nuance. As I | mentioned in my first post, conflict which is evenly | matched should not be regarded the same way as conflict | which is not. If you are attacked by a group of people, | or someone substantially larger than you, then | intervention is warranted. Ideally this intervention is | carried out by older peers. If you're being bullied by | one of your peers, you need to learn the skills to | resolve that conflict. Sometimes escalation is the best | tool, sometimes avoidance is. There's no panacea, but | it's something we all need to learn. | [deleted] | cannaceo wrote: | Can you give an example of what being bullied by a peer | would look like and what skills would be required to | resolve that conflict? | thegrimmest wrote: | If one of your classmates takes to pushing you around, | taking your stuff, embarrassing you, calling you names, | etc. This is normal behaviour in apes who are trying to | establish a dominance hierarchy. The bully likely sees | you as a soft target who is easy to dominate. The best | course is to correct that assumption - escalate conflict | - fight back, fight dirty. It's the same rationale as in | prison - you don't want to end up at the bottom of the | dominance hierarchy. The best way to avoid that is to | make friends and be more trouble than you are worth. | bentley wrote: | In adulthood I've never had to resolve a problematic | interaction through physical violence, and I hope to | never have to. The methods I _have_ used--distancing | myself from the bully, reporting to management | /HR/oversight agencies--are quite like the methods I used | to avoid bullying in childhood. I never used violence | back then either. | | The only meaningful difference between now and then is | that in adulthood I have more such avenues and they are | much more effective. The fact that they were less | effective in childhood is an indictment of the | administrative and social structure we have constructed | schools to have, not of nonviolent methods themselves. I | reject your assertion that it's helpful for a bullied | child to model behavior on chimpanzees in the jungle or | criminals in prison. Becoming violent in childhood would | have had negative long-term effects on me, and I'm glad | nobody back then gave me the "advice" you're sharing now. | thegrimmest wrote: | Or perhaps the conclusion here is that administrative | intervention is not effective on children the same way as | it is on adults. | bentley wrote: | Given that my interactions with adults outside of school | (and later, when I was pulled out of public school to be | homeschooled) were almost always positive, I'm willing to | specifically blame school administration and/or their | techniques. | s1artibartfast wrote: | I think you problably have some sampling bias in your | adult interactions. | | Im guessing most of them don't involve the lowest | functioning portion of the population, eg, people who | regularly comment violence, rape, and beat their wives, | or are currently incarcerated. Public schools cut across | the entire population spectrum and include children with | legitimate social and cognitive deficiencies. | | Adults also have more developed brains and better | incentives to obey. a hostile worker might still care | about losing their income, car, or house. It is hard to | find comparable incentives for children and young adults. | Biologist123 wrote: | Good response. Toxic organisations (at whatever scale) | fail to maintain an atmosphere where bullying is rejected | and people are helped to be their best. Children should | be taught to recognise toxic organisations and be given | courage to exit them. And internalize that you do this as | an adult too. There are situations where assault or | battery could arise, and it is good to have some training | in how to deal with those situations. Bullying, assault, | battery are all abusive: it's just bullying is legal and | the others are not. | leto_ii wrote: | > It's the same rationale as in prison - you don't want | to end up at the bottom of the dominance hierarchy. | | The simple fact that you think it's not a problem to | somewhat approvingly compare schools to prisons is | already a bad sign. Schools shouldn't be like prisons. | Prisons shouldn't be like prisons either, but that's | another story... | thegrimmest wrote: | Approval has nothing to do with it - we are apes living | in dominance hierarchies, children even more so. | leto_ii wrote: | That's just not true. There are many kinds of social | relations, dominance being just one particularity nasty | one. Other apes also exhibit a whole range of social | relations. It doesn't have to be a dog eat dog world out | there, and most of the time it actually isn't. | MrJohz wrote: | I'm not the person you're replying to, but I was bullied | as a child, and honestly, the problem is hard to deal | with. I was not good at socialising, I found it difficult | to read social cues, and I was kind of irritating a lot | of the time. None of that excuses bullying, of course, | but ultimately a large part of what caused that bullying | was my own behaviour. If I'd have been more socially | adept, if I'd realised that the social group I'd found | wasn't supporting me and if I'd put more effort into | making worthwhile friends, I wouldn't have been in that | situation. | | In the end, I needed to change for the issue to be | resolved - which I did, and, along with moving to a new | environment which helped reset a lot of my social | interactions, that helped a lot. Obviously that's not | some instant magic wand solution - I went through five | long years of this experience, with various teachers and | other adults trying to help me before things started | clicking and I started being able to move on - but in my | experience there aren't really many better solutions. | | So, while I can't reiterate enough how unacceptable | bullying is, and what a negative impact it had on those | years of my life, I do agree with the previous poster: | the ultimate solution to being bullied often lies in the | hands of victim (n.b. not literally: I never found | violence helped me), and trying to resolve the situation | via visible external intervention may well have little | impact. For me at least, a better social education would | have made me much more prepared to deal with the issues | that I faced. | cannaceo wrote: | "The ultimate solution to being bullied often lies in the | hands of the victim" is the reality that people who are | pushing for anti-bullying measures are trying to change. | thewebcount wrote: | But isn't one really useful way to learn by having people | older and wiser than you step in and explain the | situation to everyone involved? You don't just throw a | bunch of math symbols at a child and say, "learn how to | do arithmetic." You teach them what numbers and numerals | are and how to manipulate them. You teach them easier | concepts first, and then build on them. That needs to be | done for both bullies and their victims, too. Most people | will not "just figure it out." That's abusive in itself. | david-gpu wrote: | _> We do children no favours by intervening in this | developmental process._ | | Will you do the same when your child is being bullied? | How do you think that may affect them and their | relationship with you? How do you think a child feels | when they realize that the adults around them do not have | their back? What does it do to their sense of safety and | their self-esteem? | | I have lived through this and have my personal take on | these questions, but I'd love to learn about yours. | thegrimmest wrote: | Like with most things, I think the right move for an | adult is to help the child solve the problem themselves, | rather than do it for them. As other posts have | mentioned, learning when and how to apply violence is a | critical skill. We (particularly children) do not live in | a post-violence society. Children should of course not | feel abandoned by those closest to them, but being | overprotective can have its own negative consequences for | development. | | It's clearly a fine line to walk, but if you're being | bullied then what you need is to _learn_ how to address | /discourage that behaviour - not an intervention. | Otherwise all you're doing is deferring the learning | experience until next time. Past a certain window it's | _very hard_ to learn this skill, and you can be stuck | with a helpless mentality for your whole life. | [deleted] | oblib wrote: | I got pretty good at avoiding fights with bullies and | dumbasses. And I never started a fight. I always made an | effort to avoid fighting. | | But I did become a "fan" of boxing at a very early age | and studied how boxers fought. How they setup opponents, | threw punches, and especially how they avoided getting | hit. Most kids don't do that so it's pretty easy to gain | an advantage. And bullies tend to leave kids alone who | they know will fight back. | | I grew up in some pretty rough neighborhoods so I was | motivated to learn. | mcguire wrote: | Homicide and suicide are the second and third leading | causes of death for teens and young adults following | accidents (primarily motor vehicle). (If it matters to | you, males are much more likely to die and females are | more likely to report bullying.) | thegrimmest wrote: | well of course - how else are the healthiest members of | our population going to die? | Nasrudith wrote: | Putting aside outliers like kids wity cancer, there is | what is diplomatically called "death by misadventure". Or | less diplomatically winning a Darwin award. | oblib wrote: | My advice is teach your kids how to fight. | | I grew up with 2 brothers and lots of cousins and learned | how to fight by watching boxing on TV. | | I fought my 2 year older brother to a draw when I was 6 | years old. I dropped a 15 year old kid who was way bigger | than me and bullying me by kicking him in the balls that | same year and then stood over him while he was on the | ground writhing and crying in pain and told him he was | lucky I wasn't kicking his face in. He never came near me | again. | | By the time I started school kids in my neighborhood knew | I would fight and when I started Jr. High kids in school | already knew I would fight, and I was not a big kid, I | was pretty small compared to most kids my age. | | When I was 14 a kid I didn't know and was way bigger than | me hit me in the head with a hockey stick at a city park | and knocked me out cold. When I came to he was skating | away from me. I skated as fast as I could, caught up to | him and jumped on his back and knocked him down and I | started wailing on him. I really don't remember how but I | ended up sitting on his chest slugging him in the face as | hard and fast as I could when I started hearing people | yelling "Stop! Stop!" and realized there was a crowd of | people watching me. | | When I was in my late teens I started taking MMA classes. | That taught me how to use an opponent's force against | them and when I was 21 I literally bounced a guy who'd | been pestering me for years to "wrestle" off his bedroom | ceiling. He was in my face pestering me again so I gave | him and little shove and he came back trying to shove me | as hard as he could, so it was mostly his energy, I just | redirected it. He was in shock because it happened so | fast. I was stunned at how well it worked. | | When people know you will fight back they tend to not | mess with you and getting hit is not the worst thing that | can happen to you. You'll heal up. Not fighting back | sticks with you and hurts forever. | | Bullies will only keep bullying kids who don't fight | back. I taught my 5 kids this and none of them were | bullied in school. | P5fRxh5kUvp2th wrote: | > When people know you will fight back they tend to not | mess with you and getting hit is not the worst thing that | can happen to you. You'll heal up. Not fighting back | sticks with you and hurts forever. | | 100% | | I once had a kid walk up to me and tell me he had to show | me something out in the recess yard. We get out to a | certain spot, he bends down and picks up a screwdriver | and throws it at me, slammed into the side of my head. To | this day I have no idea why, didn't know the kid. | | I chased him back into the school building, he turned a | corner and the principal was standing there talking to a | teacher. I remember very clearly he drew up next to the | principal and had a shit eating grin on his face. | | I removed that grin from his face very quickly, he | thought I was afraid of the consequences of beating him | in front of the principal. He learned otherwise. | | To the principals credit, once I told him the story, saw | the knot on my head, AND the screwdriver I got away with | absolutely no punishment. | | I've never been one to start things, and in fact often | times I let them go too far, but I've never actually been | afraid of a fight. I used to move a lot as a kid and at | some point I just got used to having to fight atleast 1 | person at a new school, once people realized you wouldn't | take their shit, they didn't give it. | soco wrote: | As we all read stories about bullied kids, or even this | study above, not having help to resolve peer conflict | isn't especially useful to kids' development either. So, | how exactly should they handle it by themselves? Gang up? | Outgun the bullies? I'm sorry but I can't even imagine a | good way, any good way, how a bullied nerd kid can get | out of bullying by themselves. | thegrimmest wrote: | My understanding is as follows: | | 1) If you're roughly evenly matched, you should fight | | 2) If you're not, your peers should intervene - "pick on | someone your own size" | | 3) If this doesn't work, escalate to older peers | | 4) If that doesn't work, escalate to adults | | This relies on children being taught and encouraged to | intervene in unfair conflict, which the research | indicates they are naturally inclined to do. | soco wrote: | So basically you advocate not only educating the own kid, | but also educating their peers to intervene, and also | educating the older ones to police the area, and | educating the adults in the end. Do you really think this | is a realistic policy, over the lifetime of your school | kid? In an ideal world, no idea, but in this real world | Id say zero chance. However I can tell you how it works | around here (Switzerland, by no means perfect either) | where school personal will usually intervene - and | somehow the bullied kids manage to learn their social | skills as well. Yes we might be apes but even among apes | the social structures are so different that the | comparison is mostly meaningless. | thegrimmest wrote: | This was basically how things have worked and continue to | work in (particularly rural) areas where policymaking is | lacking and people are left to their own devices. | "Bullied" kids seek help from their immediate peers, from | their/their peers older siblings, and from adults, | roughly in that order. Parents typically do not hesitate | to suggest aggressive escalation as a conflict resolution | strategy. This strategy is often applied successfully. | | I'm suggesting that the current "zero tolerance" approach | practiced in North America does more harm than good by | halting this process before it can resolve conflict - | thus harming both the bullied and the bully. | anotherman554 wrote: | "This was basically how things have worked and continue | to work in (particularly rural) areas where policymaking | is lacking and people are left to their own devices." | | So in rural areas if a child in school grabs another | child, throws them on the ground, and starts beating them | in the middle of math class, the teacher will not attempt | to intervene? | | Sorry but I don't believe this. | mcguire wrote: | One notes that rural teens and young adults die of | suicide at nearly twice the rate of those in urban areas. | (https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarti | cle/...) | bentley wrote: | The problem with American zero tolerance policies is not | that they attempt to stop violence, but that they find | the bullied to be as culpable as the bully, because | "participating" in violence is what's considered wrong, | not instigating it. | bentley wrote: | My own experience growing up in rural America is not so | romantic. Bullies were sometimes those who had a numeric | advantage when it came to having relatives who were peers | and adults at the school. Their victims, often, outsiders | who were not physically strong, had no big siblings to | protect them, and were not "favorites" of the teachers. | Such children would not benefit from your strategy. | zadler wrote: | There isn't one of these steps that bullied children are | not doing that they could do to resolve their issue. If | your point is that their issue could be solved with | education; well maybe, maybe they need parenting also... | thegrimmest wrote: | I think the point is that the education system has to | embrace this strategy rather than fight it with zero | tolerance policies. | zmgsabst wrote: | Do you hold this same view about adults and police? | | Are we denying women a chance at personal development by | having police arrest rapists rather than forcing women to | develop the necessary skills of interpersonal violence to | defend themselves? | | ...where is the line? | thegrimmest wrote: | I'm simply pointing to a body of research that shows we | have this area of development in common with our ape | relations, and that the strategies juvenile apes use to | resolve conflict largely apply to children too. | | With regards to sexual assault - we surely should teach | vulnerable people the necessary skills to avoid violence. | It (used to be) common sense not to drink in the company | of strangers, especially if you are physically vulnerable | (regardless of your sex). None of this is exclusive to | punishing perpetrators, which we should of course | continue doing. | mcguire wrote: | You might wish to examine the statistics on the | relationships between rapists and their victims. | thegrimmest wrote: | And you might want to examine those on alcohol | consumption and sexual assault. | mcguire wrote: | Problem: " _Existing research indicates that (a) being | bullied in childhood is associated with distress and | symptoms of mental health problems...; (b) the | consequences of childhood bullying victimisation can | persist up to midlife and, in addition to mental health, | can impact physical and socioeconomic outcomes._ " | | Solution: Let 'em work it out themselves. | WarOnPrivacy wrote: | > Solution: Let 'em work it out themselves. | | Working-it-out is an effective approach for two people | who want to solve an issue - an issue that they're both | fairly responsible for. | | But where you have one child experiencing long-term and | unearned mistreatment at the hands of many peers - | attempts at working-it-out are such a mismatched response | that more mistreatment seems likely. | thegrimmest wrote: | I don't see how this research controls for the zero | tolerance policies which have been in place for a long | time, and which lots of research suggests serve to | prolong and escalate conflict. | mcguire wrote: | Source? | | I have a pretty low opinion of the zero tolerance | policies because they seem to primarily operate to the | benefit of the bullies in this case: the bullying is not | readily visible as a problem to the adults and when it | is, many of them think as you do, that kids will be kids | and they should work out their problems themselves. | However, a fight is an immediate problem and the obvious | instigator is the victim of the bullying. | Teever wrote: | They are very important skills to learn, and they're ones | we as a society haven't really learned because we're | still dealing with this problem. | granshaw wrote: | I'm not sure if there's data/studies on this, but I feel that | bullying is a bigger problem in the US than in eg Europe and | Asia. If so, would like to see more discussion on why that is | and how we could improve things by comparing | DontchaKnowit wrote: | I dont buy it. Ill bet bullying is way more normalized in the | UK. | loandbehold wrote: | Not sure about Asia, but in Europe bullying is as common as | in US. | granshaw wrote: | Interesting, good to know | skippyboxedhero wrote: | The US compares relatively well because, despite having | comprehensive education, the system is also designed to | segregate schooling areas. | | In Europe, bullying is worst in countries with comprehensive | systems (UK/Nordics/Eastern Europe, unsurprisingly they are | countries that have left-wing education systems built for the | social justice goals of adults, not learning outcomes of | kids). I believe it is as bad or worse in Asia although for | different reasons. | | Btw, there are also quite good stats about sexual violence | against girls and, unfortunately, you actually see these | levels are highest in comprehensive systems in Europe. This | is likely due to under-reporting elsewhere but it is very | strange to see somewhere like the UK come out worse than | Afghanistan in violence against girls. I think people should | also ask why this kind of stuff isn't known (again, it is | because schools are designed for social justice for adults, | not for kids...it is an unfortunate reality of our world). | wwweston wrote: | > UK/Nordics/Eastern Europe, unsurprisingly they are | countries that have left-wing education systems built for | the social justice goals of adults, not learning outcomes | of kid | | Learning outcome rankings are commonly pretty high for UK | and the Nordics -- there's a number of metrics, and some | asian countries come out outlier strong depending on the | test, but it's pretty common to find Finland, Sweden, and | the UK in the top, and Finland in particular seems pretty | enviable by a number of standards. | | Also, learning outcomes for kids _are_ social justice goals | -- people who think of their social values /goals in those | terms (vs people who use "social justice" as a drive-by | disparaging/othering term to signal their own ideological | allegiances) are almost always concerned with broadening | positive educational outcomes. Perhaps you don't share | those goals, or perhaps you believe that some social | movements are promoting policy that isn't well-optimized | for those goals, but it's _entirely false_ to state that | they 're mutually exclusive. | | And as they say, "citation needed" for stats about bullying | or sexual violence. | myth_drannon wrote: | I came to similar conclusion. My children go to an elementary | school in Canada and there is bullying even in good schools. | The things that these little kids do is incomprehensible to | me. I went to elementary school in USSR and I never saw what | my children experience in Canada(at least I don't remember | it, but I do know that the schools in USSR had bullying | issues with teenagers). | | Is it because children have too much freedom in school, | innatentive/overworked teachers? My wife tends to think it's | the food(sugars) and TV/computer games (even first graders | spend significant chunks of their free time playing Minecraft | and other games). Is it because of playdates culture and not | being free to play on the street with neighbours after school | which helps socializing kids? | [deleted] | Der_Einzige wrote: | Let's be honest, playing Minecraft is more likely to be the | reason you're bullied, instead of being the source of | bullying. | | Well, unless you count getting griefed on MC as bullying... | quacked wrote: | > Is it because of playdates culture and not being free to | play on the street with neighbours after school which helps | socializing kids? | | All children need to be "socialized", which means "taught | the local method of the art of civilization". Currently in | the western world there IS no "local method of the art of | civilization". There's barely even a "local people". Most | people grow up around transplants and whirling hodgepodge | of rapidly-evolving ethno-social practices that never comes | close to stabilizing on a single, repeatable way of life. | | The US's and Canada's failures to raise up kids to behave a | certain way is due to the fact that the modern western | world is in a local period of flux/chaos. Children rarely | see their full-time working parents and live in | environments where they have little freedom and few | trustworthy allies that will remain with them throughout | their whole lives. The several people I know who grew up in | the USSR did not experience this, and while they | experienced shortages, authoritarianism, and poverty, they | also experienced very intensely local community with people | who they understood and expected to live the same way. | (This broke down across ethnic lines, of course.) The | necessary fixes are far more pervasive and difficult than | many people realize, and mostly start with "fixing the | adults" rather than "fixing the kids". | | Bullying is a deeply primal instinct, with the end result | of establishing a social hierarchy with the most powerful | and violent on top and people who will listen to them and | provide goods and services on the bottom. The reason that | adults who commit crimes end up in prison is that modern | western governments keep a really well-armed and nasty gang | on a leash (police) and have a system to deal with the | bullies who don't learn how to keep their bullying in line | with social acceptability. (For instance, you can | emotionally torture an employee into depression, but you | can't punch them in the face.) I believe that the bullying | we're seeing children do now is closer to status-jockeying | in a post-civilization world than as a consequence of our | current society's setup. They're trying to establish | hierarchies and social norms for themselves, because | they've never observed or been taught any. | trgn wrote: | Play dates really create needless friction because they | don't allow children to click organically. The restoration | of the public realm, making it safe for children, is the | most pressing challenge for america. | yamtaddle wrote: | Dunno about Canada, but in the US schools have _very_ | limited options for dealing with problem kids, and class | sizes are way bigger than they 'd be if we really wanted | every kid to have a great education (we would be aiming for | about half what they are now, in that case)--more social | problems is one consequence of that. | | If we could "sacrifice" the top ~10% most-disruptive | students--just keep them out of the ordinary classrooms-- | it'd improve everyone else's experience and ultimate | educational attainment immensely. My wife used to be a | teacher and days when the _right_ couple kids both happened | to be sick, all the lessons got done faster than the time | she 'd allotted, giving time to cover bonus material, and | she said you could just _feel_ how much more relaxed and | jovial the atmosphere was, and could see it on the kids ' | faces. Consider how much benefit it would convey if that | were _every_ day and those effects could compound over | years. First person who figures out a way to do that that | doesn 't condemn the 10%ers who actually have a chance of | reforming, and that's palatable to constituents, will have | done more for US education than anyone else has in a | century, probably. | dotnet00 wrote: | My personal experience was that Western schooling was much | kinder than Asian (Indian) schooling (parent's job had me | moving countries every 3 years). Having been a bit of an | outsider in both systems (didn't have the years of shared | history in Western circles and accent was too American in | Asian circles) and extremely timid, while I did initially get | bullied in Western schools, it was nowhere near as pervasive, | underhanded or nasty as it was in the Asian schools I | attended. | | In the Western system I could more often rely on just | ignoring or complaining to a teacher to result in some | action, in the Asian schools I went to, many of the teachers | and other parents seemed almost complicit in the bullying | (somewhat unsurprisingly, especially the English teachers). | | I still remember that on my first day in an Indian school in | 4th grade after having gone to school for ~3 years in NY, I | had been mocked and called stupid in front of the class by | the math teacher for writing out how I answered a problem | differently from what had been taught to the rest of the | class. Completely ruined me on math for several years because | it made me too hesitant to ask questions about fundamental | things I didn't understand and as a result I had terrible | fundamentals. I only really managed to get over that by | spending the entirety of 8th grade self-teaching myself math | after school. | | The way I like to think of it these days is that Western | education made me enjoy learning and helped build up my | confidence, while Asian education made me cynical and better | at reading people (which isn't a bad thing to me now, but I'd | still rather never go through that again). | | Of course this is just anecdotal so it doesn't say a lot | overall. | cliquecover wrote: | As someone who went through the Indian education system, | teachers were some of the worst bullies who would | frequently abuse their power. | | - A teacher posed a question to the class and I and another | boy answered immediately. The teacher was upset and said | "cliquecover and boy are always putting themselves forward" | | - A few senior students demo'ed a cool robotics toy they'd | built. Our science teacher mocked our class for not being | as intelligent as them, instead of explaining how we could | build one (doubt he knew anything about it). | | - A university lecturer openly ridiculed all the female CS | students as "useless" | | - A tendency to obscure their incompetence and lack of | understanding by focussing on petty details: eg a math | teacher ridiculing us for not knowing our multiplication | tables and forcing us to memorize them, instead of teaching | useful skills, English teachers being obsessed with | spelling and handwriting instead of general reading and | composition skills | | - Universities engaging in extortion by refusing to release | student's personal documents unless they would take up the | first job offer they obtained via university placements. | | Very few intelligent people in India would become teachers | in the kind of school I went to. They would rather take up | software/IT/private sector jobs, so you get mediocre non- | entities who have free rein to treat students as they | please. | kingofheroes wrote: | Not to downplay the severity of the problem in America, but | bullying is pretty damn severe in East Asia. The "nail that | sticks up gets hammered down" quote often used to describe | the situation there. Search "japan bullying" in Youtube and | you'll find a long list of videos talking about the issue in | Japan in particular. | yamtaddle wrote: | I know it's not exactly a reliable record, but Japanese | high school anime are a popular genre and pretty | consistently depict a fairly intense atmosphere of | bullying. It's often not the focus so you have to read | between the lines a bit in some of them, but it's usually | there. Not sure how much of that's true and how much is | fictional trope. | anotherman554 wrote: | I'm not sure what you mean by Japanese high school anime? | Some anime, particularly in the slice of life genre, | depict a idealized version of high school where there is | no bullying. | AndrewKemendo wrote: | I'd offer that the problem is compounded (and actually really | the root) by anti-social parents who are unable or unwilling to | parent appropriately, then raising hell when teachers attempt | to cajole the student into being pro-social | zadler wrote: | As well as that the parents of the victim are easier to deal | with even when the child is damaged than the parents of the | bullies. And the parents of the victim may also be complicit | in the victim blaming. It's absurd to think it's something | that could be fixed in a generation also. | devwastaken wrote: | >These assaults are actually even more critical to address in | childhood because as they are allowed to form patterns that | persist in criminal assaults and fraud in adulthood. | | It's this kind of logic that creates it actually. Trying to | create Uber safe environments for hypothetical outcomes results | in those behaviors being suppressed and mutated later. Children | are designed to bully, the same as every other mammal species | plays when young. If they were not, you wouldn't find it in | every place where children are throughout the planet. | | We can only mitigate severe effects. Smaller schools is the | most significant step, but it will never happen. | agumonkey wrote: | What's usually blamed on bullying victims ? Is that a lack of | assertiveness ? | | In society there's often a reflex to blame girls from trying to | hitch hike, like stepping in risky activities.. but for | bullying it seems completely passive and unwarranted. | ricktdotorg wrote: | i was bullied for a number of years at a local school in my home | town (northern UK) from the age of 5 until 10 by the son of my | school's headmaster (!!). i was even caned by that headmaster for | "telling stories" that his son was bullying me. | | i learned most of this much, much later as an adult, but TL;dr my | parents met many times with the headmaster, who simply refused to | believe his son would bully anyone. my father and the headmaster | apparently almost came to blows (but didn't, my dad is a good | man) and the upshot was that i was withdrawn from that school and | sent to a very austere Georgian quaker boarding school for the | remaining 8 years of schooling. the change of school of course | removed the headmaster's son's bullying, but introduced other | [boarding school type] issues which likely scarred me in other | ways. but at least the bully was gone from my life! | | n.b. some ~25 years later i did actually meet the | bully/headmaster's son at a random event back in the UK; he had | no memory of the bullying and i was heartened to observe that his | life was a disaster and he was desperately unhappy. | | that made the ~5 years of bullying feel at least like it got me | _something_. | creativeideas wrote: | I'm always concerned when I see these types of studies that the | conclusions drawn from them will lead to "cures" that are worse | than the disease. God help us should we ever succeed in | eliminating all the challenges of life - we'll evolve into | spineless blobs. | WarOnPrivacy wrote: | Many arguments here against bulling prevention seem to conflate | two different issues. | | They lump squabbles between similarly weighted peers with the | situation where individual children get systemically singled out | for mistreatment. | pharmakom wrote: | Bullying seems to be a human universal. This is really sad and it | makes me wonder what come be done? | | Lord of the Flies is the most realistic book about children that | I know. | mixmastamyk wrote: | There was an example more recently of kids being shipwrecked | and working cooperatively. Not a refutation but food for | thought. | | https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/09/the-real-lord-... | Cupertino95014 wrote: | I completely agree about the problem, and some of this thread has | the answer: fight back. Being adults, we naturally focus on what | the adults can do. Of course if someone in authority sees bad | behavior, they should stop it. | | The problem is all the bad behavior they _don 't_ see. The | bullies just learn to do it when no adults are watching. Teaching | the kid how to fight back is a great solution and several answers | have said that. | | But suppose he or she just can't (sick, handicapped, | uncoordinated, tiny, etc.)? | | This is where the kids who are _not_ being bullied can step in. | Teach your big strong kid it 's not cool to just watch it happen; | confront the bully yourself. Protect the kids who can't protect | themselves. | AtlasBarfed wrote: | The advocacy of violence implies the ability to succeed in | doing it. Perhaps you don't recall the vast difference in size | and strength in adolescence. | | Couple that with GROUPS of bullies, what do you advocate? | | Well, the modern solution to war is more firepower, and that is | the firearm. So essentially, the end state of advocating | violence is school shootings. | Cupertino95014 wrote: | So now it's _groups_ of bullies, not just one? That wasn 't | part of the problem statement. | | Also firearms: that wasn't part of it until you brought it | up, either. | AtlasBarfed wrote: | So bullies are people that stress the societal boundaries | of acceptable behavior. | | The advocacy of violence in response is a further stepping | over of a societal boundary, essentially the same one used | by bullies. | | So the boundaries are crossed, both legal, institutional, | and societal. | | But you want to be pedantic about "problem statements"? | That firearms and school shootings are some boundary that | is fantastical and doesn't get crossed in the real world | (that is, the USA conception of the real world)? | | You want boundaries on the problem statement, which is | about using violent extralegal means to address violent | extralegal threats? | | What a bizarre comment. Like, you don't think gangs exist? | You don't think bullies who crave power and strength don't | crave strength in numbers? You don't think gun violence | exists, exists at schools? | | Are you in some fantasy land where BJJ is the solution for | world peace? Are you some gun nut scared that this will | cross into gun control? Are you just some spectrum resident | pendant/troll? | | Weird. | Cupertino95014 wrote: | Lots of people on this thread advocate for fighting back. | I don't know why you have a problem with it. | | "Bullying" on the original article had nothing to do with | firearms & school shootings, as you would know if you | read it. It has to do with one nasty kid picking on | another one. It very rarely makes the news. | | If you need to have the last word, go ahead. I'm not | replying any further. | bentley wrote: | Not that it holds much scientific value, but my impression | from reading news stories about school shootings is that the | perpetrators usually were already known in their social | circles as bullies, not bullying victims. | anonreeeeplor wrote: | I have ADHD and Aspergers. Which results in extremely high | anxiety. I did not get along with other children or people. In | fact; I found them completely boring and had no desire to | interact with anyone. My instinct at school was just to avoid | them all. Eat alone, hang out in the school library. | | I have run into parents who homeschooled their children and let | them follow their curiosity. Some of the results I saw them get | were completely out of this world. The kids taught themselves | multiple languages and instruments. | | I'm going to be faced with a similar choice with my kids. I will | likely put them through public elementary school. Junior high I | feel is abusive to children. | | They are going through very complex hormonal and emotional | changes and on top of this you dunk them in a tank surrounded by | parasites who are garaunteed to act like savages. | | With mobile phones and cameras. | | I think I could see a strong argument to skip junior high and | high school altogether and explore home school. | | If anything like what happened to me happens to them (and I | honestly didn't have it that bad), I will seriously consider | pulling them out. | | The damage that was done to me lasted 15 years. That is | unacceptable. | | I personally had severe acne. Putting me in junior high to get | taunted - irreparable self esteem damage. | | Parents need to understand. | | Let's be honest. The elephant in the room is human beings get | ahead by bullying Eachother and forming mobs and cliques. | | This behavior has shown up at every job I have ever had. The | dumber the people are the more likely they will use this | "strategy" to get ahead. It is the go to dumb person strategy. | | You can only avoid it often by working at smaller companies or | developing much better social skills. | sokoloff wrote: | > [guaranteed] to act like savages. | | While assigning them to read and discuss Lord of the Flies... | AtlasBarfed wrote: | One of the things that happens is similar to the group | psychology of hazing. | | A person perceives abuse as much worse than the person that | deals it out. Hazing is the person being abused then delivering | worse punishment than they received to the next round of | people, again because their perception of the original hazing | abuse was worse than what their abusers perceived. | | School tolerance of abuse/bullying is essentially this hazing | cycle occurring over generations, more slowly. | | That's not the only fucked up human psychology loop in play. | Denial, stockholm syndrome, and of course, laziness all come | into play. | theonething wrote: | We're strongly considering homeschooling our kid. We have | reservations (read are scared of how hard it sounds compared to | sending them off to school) but hearing about experiences like | this move us in that direction. | | It sounds like a best of both worlds. Avoid bullies and other | bs associated with institutional education and instead have a | customized, curiosity driven education. | poisonborz wrote: | ...and also to keep the kid in an associal bubble. | Socialisation and experiencing/handling all kinds of people | in life is the most important skill to be learned in school. | I woulnt want to give this up for comfort. | theonething wrote: | > and also to keep the kid in an associal bubble. | | There are other ways to socialize kids besides school. As I | understand it, things like field trips and social | gatherings are an important part of a well balanced | homeschool experience. | | E.g. instead of just studying about government from books, | take a field trip to city hall, observe a public meeting | and talk to people there. Homeschooling gives you that | freedom. | | Anecdotally, I personally know homeschooled young adults | that are confident, have great social and communication | skills and are doing very well in life thus far. | dandanua wrote: | The problem with bullies will never be solved if we don't solve | the problem with teacher first. | | Teachers, in essence, is the most bullied class in social | hierarchy. They have low wages, huge overtimes, tremendous | responsibility of upbringing children, yet almost no real | authority over them. It just doesn't make any sense. | | Because of this I'd bet that most teachers nowadays are either | spineless, or bullies themselves. Teachers that can display a | real leadership are miracles. | kreelman wrote: | Great that this has made it to the front page of Hacker News. | | So sad that this happens. I changed schools 5 times and only 2 of | them had no bullying. It's true that it changes you. There are | some good resilience changes that happen, but there are bad | changes too. | | ...Unfortunately I think it is the human condition to want to | have power over others. It would be awesome if there was some way | to fix this, but we are all a bit broken I think. | hristov wrote: | This is very important to talk about. I think I still have issues | from being bullied and I am in my 40s now. My issues are anger, | but more importantly social anxiety and much worse social skills | than I wish to have at this age. | | Just in case any psychologist are reading this, I would like to | point out a type of bullying that I experienced but it is never | talked about. It is basically sexual harassment by closeted | homosexuals. One kind of assumes that homosexuals are these fey, | thin mild mannered and fashionable kids, but in reality a lot of | the fat nasty bullies were self hating closet homosexuals. I was | always a target for them because I had this childhood disease | that made me very thin and tall and pale, and apparently that is | very attractive to those scumbags. | | And they bullied me verbally and physically and always made me | feel like shit. The worst part is I did not know what was | happening to me because I did not know much about homosexuality | (I grew up in a communist regime that preferred to sweep that | stuff under the rug). So I grew up thinking there was something | seriously wrong with me. | | There is a lot of talk about bullying of gays in school, but | there is also the problem of bullying of heterosexuals by | homosexuals. To solve this, schools should teach their kids about | homosexuality early. Probably as soon as puberty because by then | these kids will be confronted by it. And while schools do teach | that sexual harassments is wrong they should make it clear that | the same holds true for homosexuals. I have a feeling that a lot | of gays think they are special and above the general society | rules about sexual harassment. Even in my forties I still get my | drinks spiked from time to time! And most importantly teachers | should be taught to recognize and prevent sexual harassment in | the homosexual context as well as the hetero one. | onemoresoop wrote: | I was moderately bullied, there was actually this one guy who | gave me panic attacks and I'd go at great length to avoid him: eg | was crossing the street or avoiding certain neighborhoods where | we could've run into each-other. It didn't last too long and | luckily I didn't get physically harmed too much, so I consider it | didn't have a deep impact at the time but from time to time I | still have a nightmare, something like once every 10 years or so, | I guess it left some scars on my subconscious. Luckily I'm not | easily bullied and nobody can affect me much except for people I | really care about. | mihaic wrote: | One aspect of today's society that would have seemed strange to | anyone 100 years ago is that any verbal/psychological abuse of | any kind is bundled as more ok than minor violence. | | Violence is almost never the answer, but modern bullies seem to | be artificially building situations where it's the only answer, | since they know they'd get their way otherwise. | | It's true that many abusers become this way due to violence at | home, but abandoning any option in responding to force with force | seems absurd. | scohesc wrote: | I was bullied both in school and by my own father (who has | Asperger's and a mean streak of narcissism) growing up - | definitely suffering the long-term and forever consequences in my | life because of it. Low self-esteem, no confidence in myself, | can't talk to anybody without second guessing everything. | | I'm trying to pull myself out of the slump but after living on my | own for 3 years I still have troubles with relationships - not | trusting anybody, etc. | | The sooner we can identify children who are being abused at | school, at home, and adopt corrective measures (ideally keeping | the child at home instead of throwing them into the foster | system), the better off society will be. | germinalphrase wrote: | FWIW, someone very close to me experienced a similar childhood | and found CBT and Internal Family Systems therapy really | helpful. | scohesc wrote: | Thanks for acknowledging and supporting - mental illness is | such a hidden "we don't talk about this" thing in society and | people don't pay a lot of attention to it because they can't | easily directly observe it in others. | | Only recently I've been able to actually talk or mention my | upbringing - I was always shamed and threatened never to tell | anybody about what was going on or else "I'd rip the family | apart". It's hard to fully realize the scale of the abuse | until you metaphorically swim to the surface and stick your | head out of the water to see the world around you with a | different lens for the first time. | | I've been using a combination of strategies to try and find | my way out of the mess I was thrown into - I've been seeing a | psychiatrist for CBT sessions every 2-3 weeks for almost 10 | years and have found it helpful, along with attempting to | make daily entries in a journal (the ADHD gets in the way | sometimes heh). | | I'll definitely look into IFS therapy as well. I did some | cursory reading and it seems like that's something that would | help me. | bored-econ wrote: | I really wonder how many americans and asians here think, that | schools in Europe are inherently less affected by bullying. I | went to a public school in germany. I attended school from around | 2000s-2010s, so i had a mixed bag young teachers affected by | modern pedagogics, middle aged teachers and teachers who clearly | showed influence of nazi like pedagogy (it's called ,,schwarze | padagogik" (black pedagogy) in german an was popular until the | late 70s. | | At least one girl and three boys dropped out of my high school | year (we had 3 classes with around 20-30 students) explicitly | because they had been bullied! Then there was at least one | student, who repeated a year because of bullying. Then there were | like two female and male students who got heavily bullied, but | made it through high school without disturbances. | codazoda wrote: | This reminds me that I should write down the experiences I | remember as a child, including being chased over three miles by | half a dozen kids. I finally crossed into an older woman's yard, | she recognized what was happening and asked me inside. I'll never | forget the beautiful polar bear rug in her living room. She got | her keys and drove me home. | | Lucky for me I sprouted between elementary and junior high, I | also got meaner, and the problems stopped. | | I turned out okay but I'm sure it shaped me in various ways. | CalRobert wrote: | I wish we could be honest with our kids that sometimes you need | to be mean in order to not be destroyed by mean people. | zmgsabst wrote: | I consider people who aren't honest with children about this | to be bad people: | | They're helping the abuse by lying to those children in their | role as a trusted adult. | haswell wrote: | I hear what you're saying, but I think it's important to | take a more nuanced viewpoint rather than reducing such | parents to "bad people". | | I think it's fair to criticize such people, or point out | why it's a problematic approach, but many parents are just | trying to do what they believe is the right thing, | misguided though it may be. | | Education and correcting misconceptions is important, and | applying a binary mindset to anyone who shields their kids | in this way is not going to move the needle, nor is it | likely a fair representation of these individuals. | P5fRxh5kUvp2th wrote: | If a parent were to ask a known pedophile to babysit you | wouldn't blink at calling them bad people. | | It's the same thing, this is clearly harmful. If you're | uncomfortable with calling them bad people, then call | them bad parents. | zmgsabst wrote: | Everyone is trying to do what they think is right -- you | can read the pro-social statements of many dictators. | | I think teaching your kids not to defend themselves is | obviously bad parenting -- and the people who do that, to | the result of their own children getting hurt, are bad | people. | david422 wrote: | This is a difficult lesson to learn and also can be a | difficult lesson to act upon (unfortunately). | CalRobert wrote: | Unfortunately what I mostly learned is that money allows | you to shield yourself to some extent. The true appeal of a | "nice" neighbourhood isn't the fancy houses, it's that the | police might care about you. The appeal of a private school | (aside from hobnobbing with kids of rich parents) is that | bullies can get kicked out of a private school much more | easily than a public one. | p0pcult wrote: | Similarly, to have a tolerant society, intolerance can't be | tolerated. | p0pcult wrote: | For the downvoters: | https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance | ilaksh wrote: | This illustrates the core problem: victim blaming. | evancox100 wrote: | Where is any blame being assigned to anyone? | solumunus wrote: | I think you're replying to the wrong comment. | progrus wrote: | My parents basically said "If you keep getting bullied, assault | the bully, try to draw blood, and we'll take you out for ice | cream if you get suspended." | | Highly recommended for any parents of boys out there - it is the | best way to address this problem. | bradlys wrote: | I mean - great advice if you're as big as the bully. As a kid | who was often smaller than kids 2-3 younger than him all the | way to his senior year in high school... Can't say that advice | would go over well. | troon-lover wrote: | SoftTalker wrote: | > we'll take you out for ice cream if you get suspended. | | Is that before or after their arrest, incarceration and | juvenile court hearing? | dsego wrote: | It can also backfire, depending on the kid's psyche. A troubled | child could imaginably interpret that as carte blanche and | overreact to a perceived threat or retaliate and get into | serious trouble. | P5fRxh5kUvp2th wrote: | Well shit I guess they should just do nothing and die then. | | My decision to cross the street could result in me getting | hit by a car, I'm still going to do so. Life is risk, these | types of comments are useless. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2022-11-30 23:00 UTC)