[HN Gopher] Google to pay $29M settling location tracking with D... ___________________________________________________________________ Google to pay $29M settling location tracking with DC, IN; -$392M to 40 states Author : Terretta Score : 31 points Date : 2023-01-01 21:21 UTC (1 hours ago) (HTM) web link (events.in.gov) (TXT) w3m dump (events.in.gov) | leereeves wrote: | That's about $3 per person in Indiana. They must not have been | able to demonstrate much harm if they're willing to settle for so | little. | | Which I personally find unfortunate. I loathe location tracking | and wish these penalties had real teeth. | dsfyu404ed wrote: | > They must not have been able to demonstrate much harm if | they're willing to settle for so little. | | They probably had the cops put in a good word for how useful | they find the tracking. I'm sure that didn't hurt. | User23 wrote: | No monetary penalty has teeth. Unless the corporate veil is | pierced and executives go to prison it's just one more ordinary | business expense. | dmix wrote: | I suspect that would result in low level employees getting | scapegoated. | | It's important to evaluate the realities of how laws will | work in practice, not just what we want ideally to happen. A | corporation is a legal and tax framework, it might be | difficult to tack on such a law without fundamentally | changing how corporations operate. | | But this has been debate to death on HN, which is why I | suspect you're being downvoted. | INeedMoreRam wrote: | [dead] | westonmyers wrote: | Article and agreement say $20,000,000. Am I missing something? | blamazon wrote: | I think OP article is about a subset of a larger federal-level | settlement mentioned that was announced in November 2022: | | > NOVEMBER 14, 2022: Attorney General Josh Shapiro Announces | $391 Million Settlement with Google Over Location Tracking | Practices [1] | | [1]: https://www.attorneygeneral.gov/taking-action/attorney- | gener... | [deleted] | sigmonsays wrote: | i've started researching my next phone without google services | (Or strictly limited). Probably going with grapheneOS. | | Googles entire business is to track us and sell ads. So they're | never going to change. | NayamAmarshe wrote: | They're also a useful tool for NSA and the likes, which makes | me distrust them even more. | | A corporation so evil that you forget how evil they are. Don't | know if it's any better than any other form of evil, but it | definitely is a highly unethical company pushing towards a | highly unethical tech future. | LarryMullins wrote: | Banality of evil. | [deleted] | rdxm wrote: | [dead] | LarryMullins wrote: | I think this headline gave me a stroke. They're settling for 29M | with DC and Indiana, but -392M with other states? What does | settling for negative money mean, the states pay Google? | | Also the details in the headline aren't in the article. The | article doesn't mention "392M", nor DC. | [deleted] ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2023-01-01 23:00 UTC)