[HN Gopher] Appalachian Apple hunter who rescued 1k 'lost' varie... ___________________________________________________________________ Appalachian Apple hunter who rescued 1k 'lost' varieties (2021) Author : mooreds Score : 222 points Date : 2023-01-22 12:42 UTC (10 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.atlasobscura.com) (TXT) w3m dump (www.atlasobscura.com) | pfdietz wrote: | So, what is your favorite apple variety? | | The one I'm currently liking is the King David. | pvaldes wrote: | That would need to add a month time axis. | | My favorite apple for January is Perpetu "Everest", a crab | apple that is small, hard and edible only in the strict sense, | but oh, the birds that it attracts in the middle of the | winter... Is unique in that sense. Unless the other apple | trees, It keeps the fruits from Dec until March when the birds | need it most. In your climate the mileage may vary. | | For eating, Mingan, Golden or Rubinette are very tasty if | picked in their moment, but my favorite apple is any resistant | to the most diseases possible. This means a thick skin. | leipert wrote: | Kind of related: in former Eastern Germany they bred all kinds of | new Pear varieties. | | Pears are a little more finicky than apples and the fruit bruise | more easily. Furthermore a lot of the varieties will go bad | really quickly, so you basically have to eat them from the tree. | | Because of those reasons there are just one or two varieties | available in stores and there is not a lot of commercial interest | in Pears. With the end of the GDR, also came the end of Pear | breeding and there are barely any new breeds in the last 30 | years. | | To end on an Apple related note: my favorite GDR breed is the | ,,Schweizer Orange", ,,Swiss Orange". Which is so ironic because | there was no access to Switzerland nor good Oranges. | ranit wrote: | > Swiss Orange". Which is so ironic because there was no access | to Switzerland nor good Oranges. | | Perhaps this is what made it desirable. | leipert wrote: | It's a pretty good Apple as well. Very crisp and more fresh- | sour after harvest and becomes more sweet when stored for a | few weeks. | | And I stand corrected, it actually is Swiss and was created | in 1935: | https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schweizer_Orangenapfel | 6177c40f wrote: | I hope some of those trees are still around somewhere waiting | for someone to find them. | leipert wrote: | Ah yeah, there are still cultivars of the old breeds, but the | problem is that without new breeds being created, we are not | combatting the challenges of climate change and diseases | changing. | genocidicbunny wrote: | Serendipitous seeing this mentioned here after my father very | recently mentioned how much he missed the variety of pears that | he could get when he went on komandirovkas to the GDR. | _a_a_a_ wrote: | As you seem to know something about this, what's an apple/pear | hybrid like? I assume they do hybridise. How about pear/quince? | That should be an interesting one. | seszett wrote: | They don't hybridise as far as I know, or don't give anything | long-lived. | | An interesting hybrid though is x Sorbopyrus, a cross between | a pear and sorb tree. | _a_a_a_ wrote: | Never heard of it so for others | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shipova | | Can't cross with an apple but can with a whitebeam, I | wouldn't have believed it. Amazing, thanks. | nkurz wrote: | There are some apple-pear hybrids that produce fruit. | Development work seems ongoing in Germany. Unfortunately | for me as (mostly) an English speaker, most of the papers | describing it are in German. Here's a summary of an | abstract in English, though: https://agris.fao.org/agris- | search/search.do?recordID=US2014.... If you search for the | primary author plus some keywords (Thilo Fischer Apfel | Birne) you can find articles that give more details. | | I'm guessing the Sorbopyrus you are describing is the | Shipova: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shipova. It's a | surprisingly old hybrid. I've got one growing, but haven't | gotten any fruit yet. Have you eaten it? | seszett wrote: | I have never eaten it, but it's at the top of my list of | trees to grow once I have enough space for it. | leipert wrote: | Not that knowledgeable. We just wanted to plant a pear tree | when our kid was born. The tree seller was very chatty and | knowledgeable. | | You also need to plant pears in pairs in order for them to | pollinate each other. There are tables with which varieties | go well with each other. | pvaldes wrote: | If you can, try comice. A diva to culture, but the fruit is | fantastic. | | Pears are not the easiest fruit to culture and in some | areas is a doomed project from the start. --Don't-- buy | trees in the supermarket without a sanitary tag. Go to a | professional. Fireblight is a real pain | agtech_andy wrote: | Quince is able to hybridize with apples and pears. | | https://cornusmas.eu/catalogue/intergeneric-hybrids | | has some information about some interesting mixes (and he | sends out great plants if you are in Europe). | | Palms also form fascinating hybrids and there is an active | community of people around the world doing this and sharing | information. | pvaldes wrote: | apple and pear don't hybridize. They don't even can be | grafted one in the other. The tissues are rejected. There are | round species of pears naturally shaped as an apple but they | are not "pears" (common pears) neither apples. Are from Japan | and are called nashis or sand pears. Tasty and crunchy, very | good in salads | | Pear and quince can hybridize producing a fruit called | Pyronia (= Pyrus x Cydonia). Is not better than any of the | parents, so it remains basically unknown and unavailable. | _a_a_a_ wrote: | If anyone interested I stumbled on this | https://www.agroforestry.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/site- | files... "Rosaceae family intergeneric hybrids" which covers | a number including those mentioned here, plus hawthorn, | medlar and rowan mashups | blamazon wrote: | I recently caught an apple-centric episode of 'Gastropod' and | definitely recommend it. [1] | | I like podcasts that have transcripts, and invite you to this | moment where a few layers were added to my understanding of well | known American figure 'Johnny Appleseed'[2]: | | > TWILLEY: Johnny would get a mush of seeds and apple cores | thrown out by a cider mill, and he would stick it in a dugout | canoe, and tie that to another canoe and then float down the Ohio | River to find a promising new patch of land. | | > POLLAN: So like a real estate developer, he would make a kind | of judgment as to where the next wave of settlement was likely to | be. He'd buy or squat on a piece of land and he'd cultivate it | and plant his apple trees and they would be ready when the | settlers got there. And he would sell them for a couple pennies | apiece. | | [1]: https://gastropod.com/transcript-the-big-apple-episode/ | | [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnny_Appleseed | Waterluvian wrote: | I kind of like this version better than the altruistic fantasy. | It's a capitalism-driven win-win for Johnny and the settlers. | Alex3917 wrote: | > I kind of like this version better than the altruistic | fantasy. | | Same, although to be fair, in this day and age the altruistic | version is the more realistic one; it's a lot easier to | guerrilla garden some fruit trees than it is to run a | commercial nursery. Which is why most of the people who run | small independent nurseries do it as a second career, and | don't start until their 60s or so. | walnutclosefarm wrote: | Although I appreciate the work folks like Tom Brown do, the | notion that he has actually rescued 1000 varieties is a bit of a | stretch. An apple variety is only really rescued when it has | found a home in commerce and some significant consumer base wants | it. Otherwise it's just on life support in a museum, and maybe in | a few home orchardists' little collections of trees - it's | perpetuation still hanging by a thread. In particular, trees | grafted, as Brown's are, onto dwarf roootstock, sometimes mutiple | varieties per tree, and maintained by an 80 year old retiree, | could all be gone again in a decade or two, even if his records | are meticulous. Dwarf apple trees don't live long, and a single | ice storm or hurricane could kill hundreds of varieties in a | single pass. | | This is not to dis Tom's work, only to say, the actual rescue is | very tenuous. | hahamrfunnyguy wrote: | Many fruit collectors like Tom also make their collection | available to other collectors. | ForOldHack wrote: | In 1920, there were 23,000 varieties of Apples in the U.S. On | U.S.D.A. land, they grow less than 3,500. There are less than | 7,600 in the world. The article is misleading. The claim is Mr | Brown has rescued more than 1,200 varieties. | | The ONLY variety of Apple native to the U.S. is the Crab Apple. | | Apples are a $22B industry. | walnutclosefarm wrote: | The Crab Apple you refer to is a species, not a variety. And, | to be clear, while there were many, many varieties of apples | named and propagated in North America in the eighteenth, | nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, almost all of them | were of the same, single species. | marmetio wrote: | What you're describing sounds more like "revive" or "sustain". | Interesting and important next steps, for sure. Saving a | variety from imminent destruction is still a "rescue", though. | walnutclosefarm wrote: | That's a fair and good correction. My only point is that they | are still extremely vulnerable to extinction, unless there is | demand for them in the market. | floatrock wrote: | > An apple variety is only really rescued when it has found a | home in commerce and some significant consumer base wants it. | | This is such a sad viewpoint on the world when biodiversity is | valued only if it is commercially exploitable. See other | threads on what "home in commerce" really means: optimizing for | transportability and uniformity at the expense of flavor and | nutrition. | | Late to the heirloom party, but this summer a friend offered me | a cheese and tomato sandwich from her garden. I originally | wasn't interested because tomatoes were always kinda meh for | me. But after some encouragement I went for it and after the | first bite, I realized I just never actually had a truly juicy | and flavorful tomato in my life. | | When you say something needs to be commercially successful to | be viable, be careful what you're optimizing for. Our | commercial agriculture systems don't always optimize for the | things you're sold in the slick marketing commercials. There's | alternative commerce systems out there, but they look like a | farmer's market where you might be surprised by a variety | you've never tasted before and might have a few blemishes | rather than the scale of a national supermarket where both | coasts and everyone in between always gets the same consistent | but bland red delicious. | walnutclosefarm wrote: | > When you say something needs to be commercially successful | to be viable, be careful what you're optimizing for. | | I'm optimizing for survival. If an apple variety has no | market, it won't be eaten or enjoyed (so it becomes at best a | museum accession), and in the longer term, it won't be grown, | propagated or maintained, and because these things don't live | forever, and don't propagate themselves, it will disappear. | It doesn't have to have a huge market, it can be regional, or | highly specialized; it can even be for nursery trees so | people can try to grow it in their back yards. But just like | anything that has to be produced (that is, that doesn't just | persist on its own), it will disappear if no one is willing | to pay for it to be produced. | | So, I'm not making a value judgment about commercial vs | other, I'm just saying what it takes to keep something alive. | bbojan wrote: | Or as my former colleague put it: I didn't know I liked | tomatoes until the first time I traveled to Europe. | throwawaygal7 wrote: | Saving heirloom apples has zero biodiversity value, or near | two it. All domestic apples are extremely inbred and from a | one or two cultivars brought to Europe a few hundred years | back. The reservoir of apple biodiversity , at least for | sylvestris is in its native range where domestic apple | cultivation is actively polluting the genome. I think that's | like khazakhastan and western china. | RosanaAnaDana wrote: | To add to this, any seeds from wild pollination will result | in new 'varieties'my | | It's trivial to regain diversity from this species, and | it's not like apple is on the edge of survival. | pvaldes wrote: | Common apple is still genetically very close to the true | native species from Kazajahstan forests. This was a | surprise for everybody. | | There are other species from Japan to Siberia that can act | as pollen donors. | RosanaAnaDana wrote: | To add to this, any seeds from wild pollination will result | in new 'varieties'. | | It's trivial to regain diversity from this species, and | it's not like apple is on the edge of survival. | bagels wrote: | Are apples one of those plants that require grafting to be | true to type? | walnutclosefarm wrote: | Yes. | threadweaver34 wrote: | Tomatoes are the extreme of what's better from a home garden. | PragmaticPulp wrote: | > Although I appreciate the work folks like Tom Brown do, the | notion that he has actually rescued 1000 varieties is a bit of | a stretch. An apple variety is only really rescued when it has | found a home in commerce and some significant consumer base | wants it. | | This was a great article about someone putting in a lot of work | to collect and sustain old apple varieties. I didn't expect to | come into the comments and find people gatekeeping the concept | of rescuing old apple varieties, especially not on the basis of | a lack of consumer demand. He _has_ made these available to | others who want them, per the article. | | Come on, this guy rescued varieties from extinction. He's not | on a mission to restore their popularity among the general | public. Heirloom varieties are fun and rare and unique. Let's | enjoy and appreciate this for what it is. | ominous_prime wrote: | I think their point is that apple seeds don't grow true to | their parent, so every single sprout from a seed is | essentially a new variety, and they are continually created | and lost -- the genetic line is not extinct, these are all | the same plant. Capturing a large collection of palatable | apples is fun, but framing this as some sort of historical | preservation is kind of tenuous. | justinzollars wrote: | The red pippin apple looks amazing | Moksha108 wrote: | Sitting by my bed is a copy of Michael Pollan's book "The botany | of desire" he discusses Johny Appleseed in depth well worth the | read. | GnarfGnarf wrote: | Ironically, you will never find the best-tasting apples in your | local grocery store. The tastiest apples are often smaller, brown | or dark skin, not the big red 'juicy' apples the uninformed | consumer thinks are the best. Viz. the Red "Delicious", whose | flavor was bred out in favor of color and appearance. It is now | insipid and flavorless. | | In the Annapolis Valley of Nova Scotia, the humble-looking Cox | Orange is sweet as candy, with a hint of pear. You can only get | it from local suppliers. | swayvil wrote: | We're seeing a similar "optimization" on the internet. In this | case it's _information_ that 's being optimized. | | We're getting information that's less useful and nourishing, | more clickbaity, pandering and addictive. | | We could say that the internet is turning Red Delicious. | Waterluvian wrote: | I heard the same thing about the American fig tree being | basically candy compared to what we've got today. | | It explains why carollers wanted figgy pudding so badly. | masklinn wrote: | It's the case of pretty much every grown food product. As a | comment above it comes down to the incentives / optimisations | of a grocery store. | Waterluvian wrote: | In this case I think the American fig fell victim to | disease more than optimization. But perhaps those are | related too. | masklinn wrote: | Disease is definitely a good point, some varieties have | disappeared or severely contracted in range due to | diseases and pests. | Waterluvian wrote: | I'll have to read up if the fig was a monoculture like | bananas and therefore disease is kind of a consequence of | what you're pointing out. | walnutclosefarm wrote: | "Bred out" is a bit of a misnomer here. Apples varieties are | propagated clonally through grafting. However, each new cloned | tree originates from a single twig of a previous tree, and that | twig originates from a single cell of the donor tree. Since | cell division is not a perfect process, point mutations can | accumulate over the generations from this process. In the case | of Red Delicious, selections of point mutations (known as | "sports") for storage life, color, and conical shape have | resulted in the uninspiring, insipid thing we call a Red | Delicious apple. | | I have a tree of the original Delicious apple, which was a | seedling found in an orchard near Sumner, Iowa, not far from | where I live in NE Iowa. Preservationists have propagated this | tree for minimal mutation. It is a slightly larger apple than | commercial Red Delicious, ripens green with red blush, very | firm, sweet with mild acidity, and moderate storage potential. | Not my favorite apple of the 30 or so in my orchard, but one | well worth growing. | | Where you grow an apple also matters a great deal. Cox Orange | Pippen may be great in Nova Scotia, which is not unlike it's | Northern England home range, but it's a crappy apple in the | mid-South, and can't be ripened reliably at all where I live. | nkurz wrote: | > Not my favorite apple of the 30 or so in my orchard | | Great answers throughout this thread. But this comment raises | the obvious question: then which one is your favorite? | | (my answer is usually Wickson Crab: | https://www.orangepippin.com/varieties/crab- | apples/wickson-c...) | walnutclosefarm wrote: | Depends of course on the use to which I'm putting the | apple. If I had to reduce to a single variety in the | orchard, I'd probably grow Liberty (not an heirloom, but | rather a university-bred disease resistant variety created | in the 1950s). Great eating fresh off the tree (if, like | me, you like a tart, but not overly tannic, crisp eater), | makes great dried apples, and decent unfermented juice. I | would choose Honeycrisp (an even younger variety) over | Liberty, if it weren't so damned hard to grow well. For | keepers, I'd go with Black Oxford. For pies, it's hard to | beat Beacon or Charlamoff (which is known by at least a | dozen different names that are all somehow or other derived | from Charlemagne, or Carolingian). I also like Calville | Blanc for pies. | kdazzle wrote: | I actually bought a box of Cox Orange online from this orchard | in VT. They were good, but the descriptions are always better. | | https://www.scottfarmvermont.com/coxs-orange-pippin | | Salt Spring Island, BC also seems to have a big heirloom apple | thing going on, for any Van folks. (ex: I bought a couple of | trees from this orchard | https://www.saltspringapplecompany.com/) | pvaldes wrote: | Cox Orange is a mythical cultivar. In part because the | marketing but yep, is known as royalty. Sadly is known also to | pick any fungus disease in the list. There are probably best | new varieties. As a rule, the better taste a variety, the | faster it spoils (unless you cheat). | mooreds wrote: | > Ironically, you will never find the best-tasting apples in | your local grocery store. | | I'm not sure it's "ironic". I think it is a case of "you get | what you optimize for". | | Grocery stores optimize for: | | * cost | | * transportability | | * shelf life | | * appearance | | And all for good reason! That's what makes money. | | Doesn't matter if you have the best tasting apple in the world | if shipping it on a truck destroys 90% of them and you can't | sell the others before they go off. | masklinn wrote: | And for chains don't forget uniformity / repeatability. | | There can be local variations but the chain usually wants a | baseline for staples. | thatfrenchguy wrote: | To be fair, to someone who was not born in the US and grew up | eating apples from u-pick orchards, grocery store apples in | CA have an awful apparence and shelf life and way too sugary | taste, but this is likely a case of people buying what they | are used to :) | selimthegrim wrote: | Any thoughts on the Arkansas black? | pvaldes wrote: | All "black" apples and red flesh apples are a little acidic. | Arkansas black (is not really black) improves after storing | it for some months. Not so good to eat directly from the | tree. | | There are apples to eat from the tree and apples to store for | winter. Both groups are desirable to have. | threlfall wrote: | I have some trees from this place, as well as trees from 'Century | Farms' - another meticulously kept apple and pear orchard | archive. | | Their tasting and usage notes on heirloom apples is worth a read. | Learning how to take care of these trees has been a rewarding | journey so far, their status can be so tenuous as you learn about | the impacts of cedar tree rust, fire blight, and dozens of | bacteria out to quickly ruin the trees! | | https://www.centuryfarmorchards.com/descripts/osadescripts.h... | sbuccini wrote: | See also "NC Tomato Man": https://www.craiglehoullier.com/ | pancrufty wrote: | Surely there oughta be better fruits to save. As a generic "fruit | hunter" I hate all apples and oranges now, it's like there's no | other fruit in the world. Go spread the seed of the _ice cream | bean fruit_ and _tabo fruit_ instead. | macintux wrote: | I remember reading about someone whose passion (perhaps | obsession) was rescuing stray dogs in a big city. | | People would often ask him why he didn't apply that energy to | the homeless. His response, roughly: why don't _you_? Dogs are | his passion. | | Volunteer for the activities you're passionate about. And stop | sniping at people who are making the world a better place just | because you think you know better than they do what's worth | saving. | pvaldes wrote: | Those don't grow in temperate areas. | hahamrfunnyguy wrote: | This comment is as silly as saying you shouldn't grow walnuts | because there is watermelon. The fruits you mentioned are not | even comparable to apples they are tropical fruits and wouldn't | even grow in most parts of the United States. Apples from the | grocery store are generally lack-luster compared to varieties | that have been grown for flavor instead of shelf life. | | Apples have many more purposes than eating out of hand, this is | why they are the world's most popular fruit. There are cider | apples, pie apples and sauce apples. You can also make pectin, | jam and apple butter. What else is done with ice cream bean | besides just eating it? | thatfrenchguy wrote: | Yup, for the first years of so I lived in the US, I never | understood why American (hard) cider tastes so different from | French cider, even when you get fancy no-sugar added cider. | | The answer was that cider is mostly made from table apples | instead of cider apples, and they taste completely different! | hahamrfunnyguy wrote: | I've not had French cider, but cider is getting more | popular here and there are quite a few styles available. | One local cidery has a full range of ciders from sweet to | dry and they use a variety of different cider apples. There | are even a few cideries that are growing their own seedling | apples to use in their cider blends. | threadweaver34 wrote: | At long as there are wild, native apples growing somewhere, would | that be enough genetic diversity to recreate similar varieties to | anything that's lost? | maxerickson wrote: | Probably, but whether the particular combinations occurred | again would be a more complicated matter. They don't breed | true, so every new tree is pretty much a random experiment. | | (a given variety is propagated by cutting and grafting) | ForOldHack wrote: | I stumbled on this fine gentleman, while writing an article about | a type of apple. His work is legend. | mdturnerphys wrote: | Here's a nice Wyoming PBS piece on rescuing Wyomingian varieties: | https://youtu.be/KZyD74vNdcc | JoeAltmaier wrote: | Used to walk a neighborhood near where we used to live near | downtown. Go down a side street, at the end was a hayfield and a | pond! In the middle of town. | | And by the pond, an apple tree. With apples the size of | cannonballs. Big as your head. Somebody would stack the ones that | fell into tripods. It was surreal. | | Anyway the place is developed now, the pond gone, the apple tree | just a memory. | jacquesm wrote: | There is a strain of Golden Reinette that makes enormous | apples, very tasty and great to make applesauce from. A bit on | the sour side for many people but I love them. | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Reinette | dang wrote: | Related: | | _Tom Brown Is on a Mission to Restore Appalachia 's Rare and | Lost Apples (2021)_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31457804 - May 2022 (18 | comments) | | _7k varieties of apples and the 18 you need to know about | (2013)_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29761351 - Jan | 2022 (60 comments) | | _New variety of apple discovered by Wiltshire runner_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25236672 - Nov 2020 (37 | comments) | | _Pioneer-era apple types thought extinct found in US West_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22963226 - April 2020 (54 | comments) | | _Lost Apple Project_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22918261 - April 2020 (5 | comments) | | _Documenting every apple variety in North America_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20324355 - July 2019 (5 | comments) | | Also related (i.e. about apples -computer): | | _Apple Rankings_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33639206 | - Nov 2022 (462 comments) | | _The best apples for apple pie_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32966751 - Sept 2022 (60 | comments) | | _Red delicious apples weren't always horrible_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28032226 - Aug 2021 (250 | comments) | | _The Awful Reign of the Red Delicious (2014)_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26055724 - Feb 2021 (84 | comments) | | _Around the World in Rare and Beautiful Apples_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21977622 - Jan 2020 (48 | comments) | | _Cosmic Crisp Apple Launch_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20481026 - July 2019 (97 | comments) | | _The Curse of the Honeycrisp Apple_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18415216 - Nov 2018 (96 | comments) | | _7,000 varieties of apples and the 18 you actually need to know | about_ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16511886 - March | 2018 (5 comments) | | _250 varieties of apple on one tree (2013)_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15274944 - Sept 2017 (4 | comments) | | _How we got apples that taste delicious (2015) [audio]_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14527798 - June 2017 (18 | comments) | | _The Awful Reign of the Red Delicious (2014)_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14349964 - May 2017 (169 | comments) | | _The Awful Reign of the Red Delicious_ - | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8300619 - Sept 2014 (142 | comments) | | Did I miss any? I used some search tricks to find these so it | would be interestined if there are others. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2023-01-22 23:00 UTC)