[HN Gopher] Neuropsychiatric researchers rethink what depression... ___________________________________________________________________ Neuropsychiatric researchers rethink what depression might be Author : theafh Score : 165 points Date : 2023-01-26 15:31 UTC (7 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.quantamagazine.org) (TXT) w3m dump (www.quantamagazine.org) | ErikVandeWater wrote: | > Our knowledge of the genetics, however, is incomplete. Krystal | noted that studies of twins suggest that genetics may account for | 40% of the risk of depression. Yet the currently identified genes | seem to explain only about 5%. | | I see the value in analyzing genetics for depressive genes, but I | also consider that how the genes interact with our environment | that play a role. For example, if the state of women's rights | around the world returned to where it was 200 years ago, it would | likely appear a genetic cause of depression is related to having | two X chromosomes. To wit - is the issue with the genes | themselves, or is it that those with the genes are somehow | repressed by the way society works? | zeroonetwothree wrote: | Women have 2x the rates of depression as men. But is there any | reason to think that 200 years ago it was even more so? | | I think we overestimate the impact of external factors on our | internal mental states. That's why the typical treatment for | depression is CBT (literally changing your thoughts and | behaviors) and not "improve your external situation". | ErikVandeWater wrote: | > Women have 2x the rates of depression as men. But is there | any reason to think that 200 years ago it was even more so? | | That's interesting. I would have thought men would have it | more since it's an abnormality, and with only 1 X chromosome, | men are much more frequently abnormal. | | When I said "If the state of women's rights around the world | returned to where it was 200 years ago," I meant if women who | currently had normal human rights lost them. In that case we | would see a major increase in depression among women, the | point being that depression would be explained much more | clearly by genetic factors, even though the genes didn't | change; the interaction between the genes and the world | changed. | | > I think we overestimate the impact of external factors on | our internal mental states. | | We definitely do. And the external factors that affect our | happiness the most are often the least controllable. | asdff wrote: | I think that's in part due to the fact that women are an | oppressed group in this world. Even in this country, the | rhetoric used against women by certain politicians is | abhorrant, and startlingly accepted by a huge swath of the | population. There are politicians who want teenagers to | carry their rapists baby to term; we've had a rapist | president and now there's a rapist sitting on the supreme | court bench. Then you have a huge swath of people who still | believe in the patriarchal mid century views towards women, | or who have raised sons who continue to believe that crap | and saddle that behavior on their partners, perpetuating | mistreatment just like how racism continues to be | perpetuated. Minorities are similarly at higher risk for | chronic depression than whites. | asdff wrote: | At the same time, there's only so much to improve your | external situation, especially if you are dealing with hard | facts sort of situations (e.g. chronic health problems or | terminal illness, poverty). If your source of depression is | something external you can do something to improve, your | therapist will definitely recommend you moving away from | whatever that is (e.g. a toxic work environment or an abusive | partner). The reason why we encourage cbt is that it gives | you some tools in the mean time, as sometimes the external | factors driving your depression are going to be difficult or | impossible to change. | asdff wrote: | Gene by environment interactions are super important for | understanding how genotypes affect fitness in context. Change | your environment to the open ocean instead of on land, for | example, and you can readily see how your genes now hurt your | chances for survival instead of improve them. | | That being said, there's a lot to the genetic compotent of | disease risk beyond just changes to the sequence of protein | coding genes. How much protein that gene produces can be | affected by a number of factors, such as the presence of singe | nucleotide polymorphisms (changes to one site in the DNA) that | may be well outside the gene region in the genome, but are a | binding region for a transcription factor or an enhancer that | drives expression of that gene and therefore dramatically | lowers (or increases) the protein produced. You can also have | epigenetic changes that similarly effect gene expression, but | these are not reflected anywhere in the genomic sequence since | these represent changes to the proteins that package DNA in the | nucleus, not to the DNA itself. | tus666 wrote: | Move psychology and psychiatry into the Astrology department | please. It ain't science. | elil17 wrote: | I'd tend to agree that psychology can be unscientific at times. | Certainly a lot in that field is derived from very abstract | theories (e.g. psychodynamics) that are not as falsifiable as | one might hope. | | Yet, the comparison to astrology is also unfair. Scientific | studies have repeatedly shown that many psychological | treatments (e.g. CBT, DBT, interpersonal therapy) are | effective. A lot of early medicine worked this way: we knew a | treatment was useful before we understood the fundamental | biology of how it worked (e.g., rudimentary vaccines came | before germ theory). | tus666 wrote: | You are making a false equivalence between clearly | identifiable physical disease (e.g. shingles), and this | questionable concept called "mental illness" or "depression", | and this false equivalence is at the root of the problem. | | This is one of the problems of how the scientific revolution | has been carried out in western society. The scientific | method which was so successful in application to certain | problems (mainly in the physical realm), has been assumed to | be just as effective in other areas as well. | | Then we see false inferences being drawn and faulty | conclusions being reached based on philosophically | questionable assumptions being drawn - "hey, it looks like we | are applying the scientific method, therefore we must be | right!". Badly applied science is just as bad a non-science | like astrology. | | Guess what - if you lock a chimpanzee in a cage it will | become "depressed". Maybe just let it out and return it to | the jungle? That ain't science, it's just common sense. | elil17 wrote: | If you run a bunch of people who are unhappy through a | standardized psychology program (e.g. CBT), they get | happier compared to the people who didn't get that program. | That's just a fact. | | Maybe that's not the scientific method by your definition, | but I'm not sure it matters. | | And yes, I get that a lot of mental health problems are | caused by problems in society. To extend your analogy, | we're not the zookeepers, we're other chimpanzees. We're a | lot smarter than monkeys so we even perhaps have a shot of | escaping. But it is absolutely reasonable to try to help | each other make the most of our lot. | | So who care's what you call it, therapy is a way to help | people have more fulfilling lives. Medications can be too. | tus666 wrote: | Again you run face first into the brick wall of | questionable assumptions and get a bloody nose. | | What's happiness? How do we measure it? How long does | this feeling last? Was it measured again 10 and 20 and 30 | years later? And what was the "control measure"? People | who did not go through any program at all? Was it simply | the opportunity to think through their life issues rather | than the "CBT" itself the main driver to improve their | mood? Did the study attempt to identify different causal | factors? Did the participants actually make substantive | changes to their lives or did they simply start to "feel | better"? Did different people with different backgrounds | respond differently to different kinds of treatment? | (rhetorical question obviously). | | Are you now starting to get a taste of the absurdity of | psychology and psychiatry? Sure getting people into a | room to simply start _talking and thinking about their | lives_ is a good thing. It probably helps, in different | ways for different people. But again, this is not | science, just common sense. | | The attempt to "sciencify" and pathologize lived human | experience is like a kind of mental corruption by the | scientific establishment that refuses to believe anything | is beyond it's scope. But again, just because you run | what looks like a "scientific study" and write a fancy | "scientific paper" does _not_ validate the corrupt and | invalid assumptions and beliefs it is attempting to | demostrate. | | It's a bit like the cognitive failure that led to | "software engineering". Engineering was created to | formalize the manipulation of the physical world. | Applying it to information synthesis was always wrong, | yet people did it anyway, and it led to spectacular | failure. We now have agile development as a result. Maybe | the same thing needs to happen to psych "sciences". | igammarays wrote: | Depression, and almost all mental disorders, can't even be | defined or reliably identified by any diagnosis test, leave alone | finding a biological cause. | | Found a book recently on the topic, "Cracked: The Unhappy Truth | about Psychiatry" by James Davies, an expert who worked as a | clinical psychiatrist, and was himself present at meetings when | organizations like the NHS worked on standardizing definitions | for mental disorders (DSM and ICD). | | My notes: | | * Naming mental disorders is like naming constellations in the | sky: the phenomena are real, but finding a pattern is completely | subjective and arbitrary. | | * There is a growing movement of professional psychiatrists | calling for the abandonment of the DSM and ICD and other newly | created terms for mental disorders. | | * There is no scientific evidence whatsoever for the existence of | ANY of the "mental disorders" described in the DSM or ICD, yet | these mental health manuals are taken as bibles in the West. The | authors of the manuals themselves are publicly quoted to have | said that these manuals are simply subjective guidelines, with | absolutely no biologically-identified cause for these "diseases". | | * Most of these "disorders" are simply describing normal | variations in personality found among people at different periods | of life. Identifying behavioural patterns and assigning a name to | it is a purely subjective matter. | endorphine wrote: | I was hoping to see Finasteride mentioned in the article. I've | read that it was found to trigger suicidal thoughts in patients. | I'm curious why that is. | [deleted] | rhinoceraptor wrote: | The most common reason I've seen speculated is the | neurosteroids that 5-alpha reductase is involved in, | allopregnanole and isopregnanolone. | asdff wrote: | I'm really curious what the long term effects of finasteride | use will be or if there are side effects from withdrawl. So | many people I know use it and this is the first I've read of | this side effect, so it must be relatively understudied. I | guess the silver lining with so many people testing out a drug | like this is that it makes it easier to look at more rare side | effects with a larger sample size. Sometimes I think if there's | an actual perfectly safe cure for baldness out there, you'd at | least see rich people like the British Royal Family or LeBron | James using it. | [deleted] | benibela wrote: | Pet theory: It is a protection from negative emotions | | Someone experiences too much sadness and other negative emotions, | so the brain tries to stop the negative emotions by shutting down | all emotion processing. Then you do not feel so many negative | emotions anymore, but also no more positive emotions. You just do | not feel anything. Since motivation comes from emotions, you also | lose all motivation to do stuff | elil17 wrote: | Sounds like psychodynamics. A core part of that theory is that | unbearable emotions/thoughts are relegated to the "unconscious | mind." | super256 wrote: | Maybe it's different across cultures, but to me it was | communicated that more serotonin makes you more risk-taking and | removes anxiety from you. The anti-depressant effect is coming | from the rewards of taking risk (e.g. asking someone out, | applying for a new job, asking for extra ketchup on your fries). | | There was a funny study about crayfish changing behaviour when | exposed to SSRI, where they became bolder to the point of | endangering their life. | | https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/jun/15/crayfish... | alienalp wrote: | Chronic inflammation is also result of many other health problem. | Depression is ultimately a natural process. It is known that | depression caused by health issues probably big portion of cases. | Nothing new. I realized that bluntly interfering with a mechanism | built-in in our body is ridicules. People should be focusing in | root causes. However i doubt that SSRIs really interfere with | depression anyway. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTDPV1XOIPY I | think what happens is SSRIs make recovery faster for people who | are at the stage of recovery by giving false hope. There are ones | that really interfere with depression and result is drastically | increased mortality. Which is really what should happen if you | surpress a natural mechanism solely exists to increase survival. | ogwh wrote: | There is literally no useful information in this article. | | It could be summed up as "everything people have been told is | bullshit and we don't know what isn't". | | What a waste of time. | NickM wrote: | It's really bizarre to me how fixated people are on viewing | depression solely through the "disease with a biological cause" | lens. Even in this article, which acknowledges the serious flaws | in the serotonin hypothesis, all the alternatives they explore | are around other biological things like other neurotransmitters, | inflammation, etc. | | Maybe more people are anxious and depressed than in the past | because modern life really sucks for a lot of people. I'm not | saying that's a simple thing to fix, and certainly there is a | biological component for _some_ people...but the idea that | societal changes are increasing rates of anxiety and depression | seems _way_ more plausible than there being some sudden and | mysterious shift in the biology of a significant percentage of | the population that needs correcting via medication. | mhardcastle wrote: | Here is a lecture by Robert Sapolsky, an extremely well- | regarded researcher, that goes over some evidence on depression | being a disease: https://youtu.be/NOAgplgTxfc | | It's been a while since I've seen it, but I recall his evidence | including some rather striking non-behavioral symptoms, like | changes in sleep cycles. | | To address your specific thoughts on it, his position | (paraphrased from memory) is that social stressors like you | describe cause elevated cortisol, which causes depression - | such that your position that "modern life really sucks" is not | incompatible with a biological cause. | | It's extraordinarily interesting in a lot of other ways - | definitely worth a watch in spite of the length. | NickM wrote: | Oh yeah, certainly, being depressed is correlated with all | kinds of changes in biology. I'm not saying it's like "just | in your head", but the question is, do those changes lead to | being depressed or does being depressed lead to biological | changes? | | Of course that question is an oversimplification since the | answer is certainly some of both; but the prevailing wisdom | seems to be that it's mostly/all biological changes leading | to feeling depressed, whereas I'm not convinced the scales | don't lean more in the other direction, at least on average. | | EDIT: but as to your point about stress leading to elevated | cortisol levels, to me that's clearly _not_ a biological | cause. The cause is stress, and the elevated cortisol levels | are an effect of the stress. It 's not like the hormone | levels just went up all by themselves due to some genetic | abnormality or something; if they did, then yeah maybe that's | a biological disease that warrants some kind of chemical | correction, but that's not at all what we're talking about. | alexfromapex wrote: | Not disagreeing with you I think depression is a constellation | of things but anhedonia in my opinion definitely has a | biological cause because it comes and goes. | johnthealy3 wrote: | Correct me if I'm wrong, but this could be the first real | acknowledgement in science that RA, lupus, and autoimmune disease | in general could be CAUSED by mental health issues? FTA: | | "It's also unclear whether simply treating inflammation could be | enough to alleviate depression. Clinicians are still trying to | parse whether depression causes inflammation or inflammation | leads to depression. "It's a sort of chicken-and-egg phenomenon," | Nemeroff said." | [deleted] | untech wrote: | ...because literally nobody really knows what causes the | depression. | cpncrunch wrote: | We do actually have a lot of research into factors that can | cause depression, which the article mentions: | | "Different genetic variations can affect whether individuals | respond to certain types of stress, such as sleep deprivation, | physical or emotional abuse, and lack of social contact, by | becoming depressed." | [deleted] | LatteLazy wrote: | We really have no idea what "the" cause is. It maybe have one | cause or many (it almost certainly has many...). | | We don't even really know what depression is. Is it a disease or | a symptom or both? Is it actually multiple different diseases all | presenting similarly? | | One look at how regularly professionals change the | name/definition/diagnostic criteria for this shows you we are | still in very early days for mental health... | zeroonetwothree wrote: | Right, depression isn't just one thing. It's a general term we | give for a family of related symptoms. Sometimes it can be | caused by obvious external factors (your loved one dies or you | lose your job), in which case it's not considered a "disorder", | just a normal response of your brain. Other times there is no | obvious external cause and you just have those symptoms for no | apparent reason. In such cases we call it "depressive disorder" | and treat it with therapy or drugs (which are at best only | moderately effective). | | Of course there are many things in medicine that have no known | cause so it's not exactly unique to depression or even mental | illness. For example some large % of chronic pain is idiopathic | (no known cause), and there are a host of physical conditions | that we similarly have no idea about (fibromyalgia, IBS, etc.). | LatteLazy wrote: | Of course, before it was called "depressive disorder" it was | called clinical depression and defined slightly differently. | Before that it was just (unipolar) depression. Before that it | was Melancholy. I think it is actually now called something | else but I cannot for the life of me remember what... | | It's like in the dark ages when people just had "fever" and | died. | [deleted] | dbg31415 wrote: | Not that I've had extensive conversations with licensed | professionals about this topic for the last 25+ years... but oh, | wait. | | It's a tripod, and you need all 3 to be aligned or else you can | be susceptible to falling back into the shit. You don't have to | have problems with all 3, problems with just 1 will do it. But | you do need to aware that sometimes you do need to fix all 3. | | Circumstances. | | Biology. | | Behavior. | | And it's complicated. | | Circumstances. If you have a ton of shit going on that isn't | making you happy, you can be depressed. You'll need to work to | avoid circumstances that get you down. But... we're seldom able | to control our lives. | | Biology. There can be unbalances. Lack of exercise, for me, is | the most common way to feel shitty. If I didn't have my health, | I'd feel shitty. Brain health, body health, just health. Also | just physical comfort. You have to make sure you're physically | OK. | | Behavior. You have to want to be happy. You have to be open to | it. You have to strive for it. You have to respond and interact | with people in a way that doesn't make them feel shitty, or else | you'll drive them away. And... you have to avoid people looking | to just be shitty and drag others down. | | If a friend tells me that they're depressed, my go to is to take | them for a hike. Get them out of their surroundings, get some | sunshine, fresh air, and get them moving. I like small tasks, | small goals that can build into bigger ones. "We don't have to | climb the mountain, let's just go a mile and see how we feel." | And it's nice to just have someone there, in the moment with you, | doing the same thing. And when I'm down, and I know I'm doing the | same thing someone else is, and they're able to enjoy it, I am | reminded to let myself enjoy it too. | | For me personally... it's hard. We all live our own mistakes. | Finding a way to forgive myself, while still learning how to | improve. Finding ways to keep my step count up. Finding ways to | cross off to-dos at work. I have a little consequence / reward | system in my head... if I am late to a meeting, I have to do 10 | pushups. If I do my chores (stuff like cleaning up, doing the | dishes, and yard, and laundry), I get to play a video game at the | end of the day... and not beat myself up for being lazy. You get | to set your own. | | It's important to reflect on why you do things. I get down when I | feel like I'm just floating between things that are expected of | me. | | Anyway I don't know, if there were cures, if this shit were | simple, it wouldn't just constantly be in the background. | Routines, friendships, and small goals... staying active, try not | to eat pure garbage, try to be thankful and show appreciation to | others. I don't know, no real punchline here. Just that life is a | struggle to keep decay at bay. | rcarr wrote: | What is currently called "depression" needs splitting up into | finer grained categories because it's become a useless catch all | term at this point. I would argue that the people who are really | truly rendered catatonic (and so likely have something seriously | wrong in the brain that needs addressing with drugs) should be in | one category and I would argue this is quite a small minority. I | personally believe that the "depression" the majority are | experiencing is more akin to what Johan Hari talks about in Lost | Connections and it's root causes are absurd societal structures | and political failures which are deeply harming people. If | someone feels trapped in a hopeless situation and this drags on | for years because society is not providing any means to help them | escape and improve their lives then depresssion is a pretty | inevitable outcome. | | In a modern day society it really isn't acceptable. Give people | access to low cost housing. Reduce the cost of education so no | one is priced out of it or forced into massive debts. Subsidise | healthy food and tax junk. Subsidise gym memberships and sports | clubs for the poorest. Increase the amount of therapists being | trained and make them more accessible. Pay people proper wages. | Watch depression plummet. The solutions are there - why is there | no political will to enact them? | | Edit: | | I have no idea why but people are reading "subsidise" and seeing | "free". That is not what I said. Subsidise the things you want to | encourage so it is cheaper for the consumer at the point of sale | and do the opposite for the things you want to discourage. The | cost you pay as a society ends up being less in the long run. | Less people ill and ending up in hospital means more people | working and paying taxes etc. | davidn20 wrote: | I would argue we live in an era with the most access to | everything you listed out ever. There are more programs to help | the poor than any other period in history. The internet and | YouTube give you access to the world's knowledge. You can get a | membership to Planet Fitness for $10/month. | | Also, I realize all of this is great, but the opposite side is | true too. We also live in an era with the most amount of | obstacles and vices people can fall into. Yes, there are | amazing lectures on YouTube, but there are also millions of | addicting cute cat videos. | | I state all this to say depression and improving people lives | is not as easy as providing them access. They need to want to | put in the work themselves. | rcarr wrote: | I agree that people do need to put the effort in themselves. | I just think that they put the effort in when they have | breathing space and hope. If people can't see a way out of | their situation then they won't put any effort in, they've | become hopeless and therefore depressed. You could argue that | the disease in that case may be one of perception, and that | you need to enrich the person's life by opening up to new | possibilities and ways of perceiving the world. But you can | also build more visible progression paths into the system so | people never feel that way in the first place and can always | see a route out if they choose to take it. | | I'd also argue that there are some social programs but: | | - we're drowning in information overload so people don't | necessarily know how to access them. For example, a lot of | the poorest households in the Uk did not claim the money they | were entitled to from the government for energy payments this | winter. | | - We don't really have policies that are addressing the root | causes of poverty which are unaffordable housing, | unaffordable and/or poor quality education and low wages. | landemva wrote: | > political failures | | If politics is being blamed for depression, it is because | people voluntarily consume media about politics. Just say no. | Refuse to be sucked in to that pattern. | rcarr wrote: | Second and third order effects. | | If the main cause of poverty is unaffordable housing and low | wages and poverty is one of the leading causes of depression | then the people who have the ability to tackle the housing | crisis and low wages but instead choose to do nothing are | also responsible for the causation of a lot of depression. | The people who are able to do something about the housing | crisis are politicians. I do agree with you though if you | think political media is pretty toxic. | s1artibartfast wrote: | I would argue that most depression is something more | philosophical and behavioral then simple material conditions. | | It is a state of disconnect from one's own life and the World | At Large. This is symptomatic of a loss of individual agency | and ability to interact with their environment in a personally | meaningful way. | | All the free gym memberships and free food in the world is | useless if individuals don't want to go to the gym or cook the | food. In reality, there are opportunities for free recreation | and cheap healthy food readily available, but that isn't the | bottleneck. | | Bottleneck is trained helplessness which leads people to self | medicate and watch an average of 40 plus hours of Television a | week instead of doing something that actually Sparks Joy. | DrThunder wrote: | I agree with your first paragraph. However, I don't think your | 2nd paragraph is a fix that'll help very many people at all. | | This idea that just throwing free things at people will give | them any amount of deeper happiness is typically proven false. | I also don't find therapists all that useful but I guess that's | a personal subjective take... maybe for the right people they | can be. The healthy food thing is a cultural issue and no | amount of subsidizing it to make it cheaper will get people to | eat healthier. The percentage of obese people is too high to | place all the obesity blame on food pricing. | | The issue is simply that modern day life is typically TOO easy | for most people and gives back very little deep meaning. We've | created a culture that gives zero meaning to anyone and | promotes nihilism. You will not fix that with welfare. Some of | the most depressed mentally ill people you find will be very | well off financially. | landemva wrote: | > modern day life is typically TOO easy for most people and | gives back very little deep meaning. | | That is about accurate for USA. People can start a garden or | put a pepper plant under a CFL bulb. Grow some food to get | some appreciation for how life has become easier. | juve1996 wrote: | > Some of the most depressed mentally ill people you find | will be very well off financially. | | Is this statistically true? otherwise this is worthless. | | See: Study Finds Strong Relation Between Income and | Happiness, Does Not Max Out at $75k. Turns out that famous | study that everyone loved to quote isn't exactly truth. | https://www.nysscpa.org/news/publications/nextgen/nextgen- | ar... | digdugdirk wrote: | I believe you're interpreting the OP's second paragraph | differently to how it was intended. | | The idea isn't that you're "giving" or "providing" or | "subsidizing" with welfare - the point is that the | subsidization has already occurred, just in a non-human | focused way. Factory farming has been subsidized so processed | sugars and unhealthy food are the norm. Companies are | effectively subsidized by allowing minimum wage scheduling | without providing healthcare. | | This all has knock on effects. Healthy food isn't just a | cultural issue, many people simply don't have the time or | access to be able to cook healthy natural food. For the vast | majority of people, they have no possible access to a | therapist, even if they wanted to or were able to afford it | (unlikely in the case of the US healthcare system). And of | course, since there's minimal insurance support for general | therapy, there's a much smaller market for people to go into | it. The negative feedback loop continues. | | I agree with your general point that life gives back very | little meaning in our society, but its important to | understand that this doesn't just occur because life is too | easy. For many people, life is hard. And there isn't a | visible path out of the situation they're currently in. | Checking out/dropping out/giving up is honestly a reasonable | response. | | TLDR: Try not to think of Welfare as a handout. See it as a | signal of a broken society that needs fixing. | rcarr wrote: | I didn't say free, I said subsidised. | | You need to reduce friction for good habits and increase | friction for bad ones. At the minute, our societies do the | exact opposite. Unhealthy food and Netflix and cheap. Healthy | food and education are expensive. | | It doesn't matter how it happened, once someone is in the | hole, the negative feedback loop makes it very hard for them | to escape. If you are worked to the bone on minimum wage to | keep an overpriced roof over your head you will likely fall | into the trap of eating shit food and binging on Netflix | because summoning the energy to cook, teach yourself skills | and exercise is going to be difficult. And the more you give | in to doing that the deeper into the hole you fall. People at | the bottom need breathing space. Reduce the amount of money | they have to spend to survive which means they don't have to | work themselves to the bone to survive and they can actually | focus on improving themselves. I've literally seen it happen | with my own eyes. | | And yes, for some people life can be too easy and that can | also cause depression. Which is why I believe we need finer | grained categories to narrows down the root causes and | provide more tailored solutions than just handing out happy | pills willy nilly to everyone. | s1artibartfast wrote: | >You need to reduce friction for good habits and increase | friction for bad ones. At the minute, our societies do the | exact opposite. Unhealthy food and Netflix and cheap. | Healthy food and education are expensive | | I would argue the opposite. healthy food is already dirt | cheap, and education is free. | | One hour at minimum wage can buy enough clean healthy food | to last an adult most of a week.[1] Free education as | available at online and at libraries, ranging all the way | from simple tasks to Phd courses from Stanford. | | My point isn't to minimize the hardship of the depressed, | but point out that friction isn't the issue. If 5 minutes | of cooking, picking up a book, or typing an educational | topic into youtube is too much effort, there is a | _different_ problem. | | Why does reading a book, cooking, or learning seem like | work, and not fun? It certainly isn't because it is too | hard in reality, especially when the same depressed person | found pleasure and relaxation in doing these things before | they were depressed. | | [1] I was at the store yesterday and pork was 88 cents/lb, | frozen vegetables ~ $1/lb, and rice and beans ~$1/lb. | rcarr wrote: | I agree with some of your points but not all of it. | Healthy food can be affordable if you know what to buy | and how to cook it. But I disagree that it is cheaper | than junk food and it is certainly less convenient to | cook and purchase. In the UK at least, there are also | 'food deserts'[1] which means it is difficult to access | healthy food. | | I also agree that you can teach yourself stuff online for | free. However it doesn't change the fact that you don't | have the piece of paper saying you've got a degree which | is one of the societal structures that holds a lot of | people back. If you want the certification for an online | program, you have to pay a similar amount of money to | what you would have if you'd attended in person. There | are lots of immigrants working in Western countries as | taxi drivers who are scientists, doctors and the like | back in their home countries but can't practice here for | whatever reason, normally to do with the paperwork. | IT/Dev is an outlier in that they will hire people | without degrees in ways that don't happen in other | industries. Something like 'Good Will Hunting' where a | self taught janitor makes it into a white collar career | is pretty rare. | | > My point isn't to minimize the hardship of the | depressed, but point out that friction isn't the issue. | If 5 minutes of cooking, picking up a book, or typing an | educational topic into youtube is too much effort, there | is a different problem. | | I still believe friction is a key component. Say you're | on the minimum wage and you have to work as many hours as | you possibly can to keep a roof over your head. Plus you | have a lengthy commute. When you return home you are | physically and mentally depleted, particularly if you are | an ill fit for whatever job you've had to take on to | survive. You want to turn your life around, but you've | only got limited time available outside of work to do it. | So you start looking for ways to save time. Maybe you'll | cut back on exercise, or start eating more junk food so | you don't have to cook as much and you can study. Or | maybe you'll cut back on sleep. You keep this up for a | while but eventually the physical and mental effects | start to become overwhelming and you become more and more | ill and eventually you burn out. You've worked hard, | you've studied and you've still gotten nowhere. And your | body and mind are a mess. Maybe you end up losing your | job as a result. You lose faith that anything will ever | pay off and you stop studying. You fall into depression | and the cycle gets even worse. Maybe you even turn to | alcohol and drugs to numb the pain. What that person | needs is less friction in their life and a bit of help. | Maybe it's work from home, maybe it's cheap and healthy | takeaway food and probably a higher wage. | | > Why does reading a book, cooking, or learning seem like | work, and not fun? It certainly isn't because it is too | hard in reality, especially when the same depressed | person found pleasure and relaxation in doing these | things before they were depressed. | | Because the person is engaged in a fight for survival. | They are not necessarily studying a topic because they | want to but because it's the only thing that will help | them get a job in their current location. They can't move | away because they have no savings. Whatever they have to | learn becomes high stakes. You can't afford to mess up or | fail because if you do then you're toast. And learning | requires failure so it's a stressful experience on top of | your already stressful life. You've got society telling | you you're worthless due to paying you barely enough to | survive and now you've got a compiler error or a textbook | you can't decipher saying the same thing. It takes a | large amount of strength to hold fast and have faith that | you will eventually come out the other side victorious, | especially if this kind of thing goes on for years. | | [1] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/oct/12/more- | than-a-... | s1artibartfast wrote: | I think we are talking past eachother. | | When I talk about access to learning, I am not talking | about obtaining a piece of paper increasing economic | mobility. I am talking about learning for the sake of | personal enjoyment. | | Most poor people are not depressed, so you have to ask | what sets the depressed apart from the rest. Why can one | person find joy in learning, and not another? | | I think this points to something greater than money= | happiness. Im not saying it doesnt matter, just that I | don't think is accurate simplification. | | You constructed an elaborate and plausible narrative why | someone is depressed because of their economic situation. | However, it ignores the person in identical situation who | is happy. What is different between them? | rcarr wrote: | > I think we are talking past eachother. | | I think we are too. | | > You constructed an elaborate and plausible narrative | why someone is depressed because of their economic | situation. However, it ignores the person in identical | situation who is happy. What is different between them? | | From my viewpoint, there are four components: | | - Personality | | - Expectation | | - Perception | | - Resilience | | Starting with the first, imagine you're really, really | into the arts. Maybe you're really into musical theatre | or something like that because you saw them on TV. Now | imagine you're stuck living in an isolated town in | Alaska. | | Now we can move on to expectation. Maybe you grew up as | kid and thought one day I'll make it out of this town and | move to a city where I can work in musical theatre. Or | maybe you don't even have that high expectations, you | just want to live in a city where you can watch musical | theatre. You think you'll grow up and earn the money and | get out of the town. But it doesn't go to plan. Maybe you | struggle to find a job because you don't have the skills | needed in the area. You're working as a bartender and | don't seem to have any money left over at the end of the | week to put towards your new life. Years go by and you've | not made any progress. Your dream is fading further and | further into the distance. | | Which moves on to perception. So many years have gone by | that you no longer see any possible way of achieving your | expectations and living somewhere that matches your | personality. You know what you're doing isn't working but | you can't think of anything that will. You fall into a | depression. You let your body and mind go to shit. | | A year or two goes by and maybe your perception changes | and you think "maybe if I train as a lumberjack then I | can earn more money and then I'll be able to save and get | out of here." So you go to college to train as a | lumberjack. But you've been out of school for a while and | you've forgotten how long it takes to learn a new skill. | You fuck up a lot. You're not really a lumberjack type so | the other students take the piss out of you and you | become the butt of the jokes. You try and start running | for your mental health but you're that out of shape that | you can't even run a mile. You give up on both because | you haven't built up enough resilience through previous | challenges to make it through. | | That last part is absolute key. When you're exercising, | the total stress the body endures needs to be appropriate | for it to have the intended effect. If you push someone | too hard who is out of shape you risk injuring them. Even | if you're a seasoned athlete and overtrain, your fitness | decreases. Similarly if you don't work hard enough to | trigger growth, your fitness won't increase. | | It is the exact same thing with depression and why some | people on here are saying depression is caused because | life is too hard and others are saying it's caused | because life is too easy. The stress stimulus needs to be | tailored for the individual. For a lot of people the | stress is either too high or too low and it is causing | major, major problems. We're calling both of these polar | opposite cause and effects "depression" and it means | everyone is shouting at each other rather than coming | together and helping each other. | | Going back to our original scenario, you might have | another poor person who lives in that small Alaska town. | Maybe he loved musical theatre too. But maybe his | personality extended to other interests so he was happy. | Or maybe he never expected much out of life so he was | happy. Or maybe he could perceive different opportunities | to escape. Or maybe he took the same lumberjack and | running route but he knew that it was going to take a | long, long time to get good at either and he was going to | have suffer and persevere for a long long time. | | It doesn't matter how someone got in the hole, when they | decide that they're ready to get out, society needs to | rally around them to offer support. That doesn't mean to | completely molly coddle them but it means that, just like | a good coach or physio, you've got to realistically | evaluate how much stress and damages they've endured and | how much they can currently tolerate and then gradually | increase their ability to handle more over time until | they're back on their feet again. At the minute, in my | opinion, society is far too much Led Tasso and not enough | Ted Lasso. | D-Coder wrote: | > The issue is simply that modern day life is typically TOO | easy for most people and gives back very little deep meaning. | | Any references that people were less depressed when things | were more difficult? | PuppyTailWags wrote: | I disagree that modern day life is too easy for most people | and that's why people are depressed. Specifically, I don't | think there's any evidence that lives with more adversity are | less prone to mental illness. By this logic, PTSD shouldn't | exist, neither should the myriad of studies that prove | beating your children statistically results in a whole host | of negative outcomes. | | I think you personally just might not be engaging with people | who aren't well off financially. The rate of mental illness | among the homeless and the jailed populations is way, way | higher than the rate of mental illness among the wealthy. | starkd wrote: | Way to completely ignore the point. It is also addressing a | spiritual problem with material concerns. Just throw more money | at it and the problem goes away? | | It is also founded on the premise that the government is in a | position to remove any and all risk from people's lives. | Indeed, it would be obligated to do this. It is extending a | guarantee it has no way of fulfilling. | jaywalk wrote: | So only poor people suffer from depression? | re-actor wrote: | Poor not in wealth but in quality of life, which is almost | everyone. | rcarr wrote: | No not at all. Rich people who benefit from the system can | also be victim to it in other ways. Not all managers are | sociopaths and I'm sure a lot of them feel shit about some of | the things they have to do in order to maintain their jobs. | And everyone, regardless of wealth and status, is subject to | the "slings and arrows of outrageous fortune" and whatever | personal tragedies they may bring. As I said we need finer | grained diagnoses. You might have for example: | | - Catatonic depression, likely physical in nature | | - Shit Life Syndrome [1], likely societal cause, possibly | other issues are play | | - Privilege Pathos, likely caused by past trauma, loss or | existential issues | | These are obviously exaggerated groupings to make the point. | At the end of the day, at the receiving end of every | diagnosis is an individual with a unique biology and | backstory that lead to their depression. But if you want to | have the most impact on reducing the ever skyrocketing amount | of depression cases, you would be best to focus on the | societal issues and that, in my opinion, is what is causing | the most symptoms in the most amount of people. The people in | the other two categories (the catatonic and the rich) are the | people most likely to be currently receiving treatment | anyway, the first because they can no longer look after | themselves and so wind up in the system and the second | because they have the means to access therapies. | | [1] - | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shit_life_syndrome?wprov=sfti1 | Buttons840 wrote: | You really missed the point. He's saying "depression" means a | lot of different things[0], and that many people are unhappy | simply because their societal (economic and social) situation | sucks and thus their life sucks. | | [0]: It would be interesting to have a discussion about | "depression" without actually using the word, since it's so | overloaded. | DrThunder wrote: | I think OP is referring to the 2nd paragraph. | ex3xu wrote: | I am a subscriber to the microbiome inflammasome hypothesis for | major depression [0], so I wouldn't be surprised if a treatment | course for depression in many people could be as simple as better | dental hygiene + magnesium orotate + probiotic supplements. I've | had my eye on studies linking schizophrenia with inflammatory | cytokine markers, and it follows that other psychological | conditions could have similar etiology and pathogenesis. Research | on the influence of gut bacteria and intestinal dysbiosis on | anxiety and depression has been coming out since at least 2013 | [1]. | | After reading Robert Whitaker's 2010 _Anatomy of an Epidemic_ | [2], I 'm convinced that future generations will look back on | this era of psychiatric treatment with the same critical eye that | our generation points at Moliere's 17th-century leeches or George | Washington's personal doctor treating his strep throat with | several blood-letting phlebotomies -- an absolute iatrogenic | travesty. The overprescription of potentially mania-inducing | antidepressants in children and teenagers is especially egregious | to me. Add in the perverse incentives of profit-driven | pharmaceutical companies, and you get issues like Zyprexa's 2009 | class action lawsuit, for example [3]. | | For those looking for a readable introduction to the potential | link between chronic inflammation and depression, there is _The | Inflamed Mind_ by Edward Bullmore from 2018 which did some rounds | on talk shows and the like. | | [0] https://sci-hub.st/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30004130/ | | [1] https://sci- | hub.st/https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/art... | | [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anatomy_of_an_Epidemic | | [3] | https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2009/January/09-civ-0... | dennis_jeeves1 wrote: | I have not specifically dug into depression, but I think I can | overall agree with the line of thought. As far as modern | medicine goes, it is almost undoubtedly primitive but puts | forth a facade of sophistication. | standardly wrote: | The fact that healthy people still get depression makes me | skeptical of hypotheses like this. If it were as simple as | taking probiotics, x and y supplements, and eating healthier, | (and brushing teeth more), I think a lot more people would have | beaten major depression by now. | | Someone else in the thread suggested it's just exercise, sleep, | and diet. Yet there are plenty of folks who do these things | perfectly and still get depression. | hot_gril wrote: | I like how the website puts a progress bar at the top to | compensate for browsers increasingly hiding the regular scroll | bar on the right. | [deleted] | MuffinFlavored wrote: | What are some good ways to get a bunch of serotonin when | seemingly nothing really excites you/brings you joy and you view | almost everything in the form of "pros/cons" (aka everything is | not without its downsides)? | googlryas wrote: | Change your thought patterns to be less cynical. | MuffinFlavored wrote: | How does one control their own mind? | googlryas wrote: | Read philosophy, go to therapy(maybe CBT), generally change | your inputs. | zeroonetwothree wrote: | I encourage you to look into CBT. The best version of it | I've seen is in the David Burns book "Feeling Good: The New | Mood Therapy". Although you can also try a therapist (but | they might be more hit/miss). | | The basic idea of CBT is that our thoughts are a result of | our actions, and by changing our actions we can change our | thoughts. I'm not going to say it's super easy, but it | definitely does work. | barrysteve wrote: | It works for six months to mask problems. | lhuser123 wrote: | Some ideas: Signup for classes of some hobby you really like. | Read good books about something that can help you see life from | a different perspective. Learn from Dr Andrew Hubberman on | YouTube | MuffinFlavored wrote: | Hobbies I like: incessantly refreshing HackerNews/Reddit. | Distracting myself with random coding projects. I feel like | my attention span has been fried from TikTok/being a | "computer kid" for the past 20 years or so. Books don't | "capture" my attention I guess. | lhuser123 wrote: | Lol. I guess I was referring to try something different. | Not that I'm an expert but have tried many things & one of | the best was taking classes for a hobby I enjoy. You met | people with similar interest & have something to talk | about. The mere fact of interacting with people & see life | from a different perspective can have a real impact. Of | course this is just the beginning. | asdff wrote: | I've struggled with this. In the end the solution was to just | ignore my pros and cons list, and go with the flow. There's | been plenty of times I've gone into something thinking not much | of it, and being pleasantly surprised after. There's also a | book that really helps me which I periodically reread every few | years: _Siddartha_ by Herman Hesse. Its a short read, ~150 | pages. It reminds me how important the fullness of life is, the | good and the bad. | [deleted] | mikrl wrote: | I've been taking the precursor as a supplement (5-HTP) but I'm | not sure of it's efficacy as I'm not a nutritionist. | ajkjk wrote: | This whole article about how "getting a bunch of serotonin" | isn't the problem. | ajkjk wrote: | *is | bt4u wrote: | [dead] | rcarr wrote: | "If exercise could be packaged in a pill, it would be the | single most widely prescribed and beneficial medicine in the | nation." | | Robert Butler | MuffinFlavored wrote: | I go for a 3 mile walk every now and then. Doesn't really do | much to be honest. I guess you could be referring to the kind | of exercise where you need to at least get sweaty. | rcarr wrote: | Put a backpack on with some weight in it and go for the | same walk. You'll get a much better workout, you'll feel | better and it doesn't even feel all that different to | walking without it. If you want more information on this | have a read through this: | | https://blog.goruck.com/rucking-training/the-rucking- | white-p... | | It helped me get through a depressing period in my life. | asdff wrote: | If you do this though I wouldn't use a jansport, I would | use a dedicated hiking backpack with a waist and chest | strap that is designed to support your back. | rcarr wrote: | Haha yeah absolutely don't use something with unpadded | straps! | zeroonetwothree wrote: | Yes, unfortunately walking isn't really sufficient. You | need to get your heart rate up sufficiently, so something | like running, biking, weightlifting, dance, etc. work. I've | long suffered from depression, and while I find it very | hard to exercise regularly, when I do I definitely feels | significant improvement to my mood. It's unfortunate that | it's so hard to do it consistently. | rcarr wrote: | For what it's worth, try bringing the exercise to you. If | you like cycling, set up a turbo trainer or exercise bike | in your house. If you like weightlifting, get some | dumbbells or a sandbag or a squat rack. Reduce the | friction and set yourself a goal of doing 1 repetition or | 1 minute of exercise a day. It's such a trivial amount | and you've reduced the friction of doing the task to such | an amount that it makes it much easier to get a | consistent habit going. | asdff wrote: | You can also bake in exercise into your daily life. | Rather than drive 5 mins to the grocery store and put the | groceries in your trunk, walk for 15 and carry them by | hand. You can even do curls, squats, deadlifts, and | overhead presses with your grocery bags along the way (in | college I'd do this with beer cases, they are about a | pound per can). It's also easy to add few more steps to | your day you wouldn't normally do, like taking a lap | around your house before you leave and when you get back. | Take the scenic route to the neighborhood mailbox when | you drop off a letter. Go up and down your stairs twice. | asdff wrote: | Give yourself some credit here. Walking 3 miles is an | accomplishment especially if you do it regularly. We | evolved to walk, not to sit around all day. Simulate being | the hunter gatherer ('modern' ones e.g. in Africa walk 3-8 | miles a day), its good for your health to use your body for | what its supposed to do. It's like driving the car every | now and then so you don't get flat spots on the tires. | asdff wrote: | I feel like you can get pretty close with a | steroid+amphetamine cocktail. | beedeebeedee wrote: | Really surprised no one here has made the connection between | depression and the fight-flight-freeze response. Depression is | just the freeze response, just like we see in our animal | relatives. Only difference is we can be triggered by thoughts and | not only the presence of danger. Freezing is when you are so | powerless, you cannot fight and you cannot fly away. You freeze. | That response can be reinforced, and sadly, reinforced by thought | alone. | tjpnz wrote: | I wonder to what degree medicine would be "solved" if in the | future chronic inflammation could be removed from the equation. | Based on my own consumption of pop-medical articles it's the | biggest recurring villain. | david_draco wrote: | "The Cause of Depression" assumes there is a single cause, which | may not be the case. | mettamage wrote: | I agree with this idea. I personally think there isn't. There | are more parts of the system that can be attacked in order to | cause depression | cpncrunch wrote: | I wouldn't say attack is the right word. Depression seems to | be an evolved mechanism that has developed in the brain, as a | way to change the organism's behaviour, e.g. resting while | sick (sickness behaviour depression), getting more sleep, | getting out of a stressful situation, etc. The problem is, | it's more like a generic "check engine" light, but without | having access to an OBD, so you kinda have to look at your | lifestyle and try to figure out what's causing the | depression, which isn't always easy. | debacle wrote: | HN has seen a steep rise in mental health related posts in the | last year. Am I the only one who has noticed? | digitalsankhara wrote: | No. I see an increase in mental health awareness in general | across most media. Which is a good thing. | debacle wrote: | Unless it's symptomatic of a sharp increase in mental health | difficulties. Most MH folks I know are completely booked | months out at this point. | DenisM wrote: | Booked? What do you mean? | harvey9 wrote: | Those bookings could be increased willingness to seek | treatment rather than increased difficulties. | trgn wrote: | Is that increased exposure making us healthier (ie. mindful, | tolerant, understanding, patient, ...) or more neurotic (ie. | ruminative, paranoid, self-absorbed, defensive, ...)? | fahadkhan wrote: | No doubt the correct answer is "it requires research." But | I guess the answer is going to be "it depends, on the | individual and the circumstances" | digitalsankhara wrote: | This is a good question and one that must vex most mental | health practitioners. You list both states of mind and some | potential mitigations. | | I'm a bit uncomfortable with the term neurotic myself as it | can have dismissive connotations. | DrThunder wrote: | Ehhh it can be a good thing to an extent. Over-indulging | yourself with mental health discussion is bad though imo. | There's TOO MUCH talk about it nowadays. To the point where | people with normal negative thoughts and emotions are | diagnosing themselves with severe mental illnesses and | running to the doctor for prescription meds. | | From personal experience with anxiety it's also not great to | continue discussing your issues 24/7 because you get to the | point where you're only forcing yourself to stay in that | mindset. You need to get out and live at some point or you'll | never recover. | asdff wrote: | IMO people have historically been not talking nearly enough | about mental health. I think everyone should be seeing a | therapist regularly, mentally ill or not. The demands of | society are stressful and people are expected to just put | up with it and not ever have room to be anxious or sad. | Most psychologists I've spoken with also have poor views of | the psychiatric approach to a lot of mental health issues. | Psychologists favor actually working with you and | developing internal strategies to protect yourself long | term such as cognitive behavioral therapy, whereas | psychiatrists have a tendency to talk little and send you | home with a prescription versus leaving that as an option | of last resort. | digitalsankhara wrote: | Please accept an upvote for this wonderful comment. My | experience bears out your view. Whilst there is good | stress - the sort that can make us feel alive, the | majority is harmful to a lot of people. | | I've long felt there is an epidemic of stress which I | think accounts for a host of poor outcomes for many, many | people and society in general. I wish I had the ability | to describe it more fully myself but my thinking on this | is not fully formed given it must involve sociology, | culture, politics, work, family, education and philosophy | etc. In fact the whole fabric on the way we live our | lives and why. | | I think the foundations for possible solutions have been | set by many cultures. Chinese, Japanese and Greek | philosophies in particular are, of course, practised by a | lot of people, myself included. Ultimately, I feel human | evolution will be through the mind and perhaps | generations, hundreds of years in the future, will look | back at this time in horror the same way we may look back | to when leg amputations were carried out with no | anaesthetics. | alar44 wrote: | Yeah I agree. I had an ex that listened to mental health | podcasts 8+ hours a day. It's all she'd talk about. It | became pretty clear that she was addicted to mental health | in a way. Her entire life revolved around grief and trauma. | It's good for us to work on ourselves, but you have to | actually BE yourself at some point. | digitalsankhara wrote: | I would say that too much mis-informed talk is probably not | a good idea. The balanced view would be to acknowledge | those normal negative thoughts and emotions. And that is | the crux of the issue. Knowing when those thoughts become | abnormal is, hopefully, helped though a broader public | education and acceptance of mental health. | | Knowing that, if you do in fact need to seek help whether | from a friend, professional or even a stranger, you will | not made to feel neurotic or told to "snap out of it" is | where I hope the end game for increased mental health goes. | | Mental and physical health are so closely related - mind | and body. It's taken decades to start to get a foothold of | acceptance for this type of thinking in the mainstream. | | I hear what you are saying about not overdoing it, but | lives have been lost because people were too afraid to | talk. I don't know what the longer impact of more social | acceptance of mental health issues will be but it is my | wish it leads to a more compassionate world. | petesergeant wrote: | Very anecdotal, but I've noticed on HN that people taking the | SSRI Lexapro for GAD seem to think it's incredible, and people | taking it for depression seem to be underwhelmed | tylermac1 wrote: | Also anecdotal, but everyone metabolizes these classes of drugs | differently. I'm an "ultra-rapid metabolizer" of a slew of | SSRIs, so they're next to worthless for me compared to other | medications. | lhuser123 wrote: | Also anecdotal. And some people are ultra-slow metabolizers, | which can cause the drugs to stay in the body longer than | anyone could have anticipated. So the effects of 1 pill daily | can feel like twice that amount since previous day dosis is | still in the blood. | edgyquant wrote: | SSRIs affect me strangely. I feel mentally like I'm not | depressed but then I have all of the symptoms of depression | amplified. Oversleep, no motivation etc but hey I feel like | I'm not sad internally. | thenerdhead wrote: | I've always thought depression to be a symptom to a larger cause. | There's many books that talk about why such as everyday stress, | childhood trauma, genetics, spirituality/meaning, and even lack | of quality human basics(foods, sleep, air, etc). So many factors | and even all those can be wrong. | | This article is promising that it seems science is rethinking | this challenge one small step at a time. I've always been | fascinated with stories where previously depressed people found | the right combination of change to turn their lives around. | Sometimes it feels like it is cyclical in life. Being able to | treat it with a kitchen sink of tools could really help outside | of a single drug solution. | marosgrego wrote: | They seem to look for causes on the hardware level, but maybe | it's a software issue many times. | syntaxfree wrote: | This is a little unfair to _Listening to Prozac_, which was | raising speculation about SSRIs effect on trophic and atrophic | factors back in the 90s. In fact it's unclear whether anyone ever | believed in the catecholamine hypothesis (excepting simplified | accounts for marketing or doctor-patient communication), and it's | been for decades now a cottage industry to disprove it in favor | of something ele. | | It's on the other hand disturbing that there's talk of broadening | the term "depression", when it really needs narrowing. There's | such a thing as a medical condition "depression" that one might | as well define as "responds to antidepressants" and then there's | everything else -- the invisible boundary accounting for how | little effectiveness antidepressants have at large. It's a damn | shame that we don't have the means of diagnosing it (whereasw | Kraepelin developed the bipolar/schizophrenia differential | diagnosis before Freud even arrived on the scene). | | Overall this article does nothing to inform or educate. | opportune wrote: | Depression and anxiety may as well be the cough and fever of | the mental health world. We can certainly treat cough and fever | symptoms but that is quite different from treating the | underlying condition. | | I think the big problem is we probably have a lot of recent | societal/cultural changes which at least contribute to | depression and anxiety, but are very hard to detect because of | near universal adoption + too many confounding variables when | examining holdout populations. Thinking of things like diet | (and trace chemicals, pesticides), sleep habits, screen usage | (internet, social media, porn, passive media, games), caffeine, | etc. Somewhere in those areas, IMO, likely lie very large | causal contributors to all of the reportedly increasing mental | health problems we are seeing. | | I can also speak from personal experience that I had very | debilitating depression/anxiety as an adolescent which has | since greatly leveled off but not quite cleared. While I could | likely still be diagnosed with depression now, to me the two | states comparing now vs then are so wildly, qualitatively | different that I am convinced they represent different | underlying pathologies. What I have now feels more like the | same thing that most other malcontents seem to have. | anonreeeeplor wrote: | I hate articles like this. They are part of an entire genre of | pseudo intellectual nonsense that seems to be this genius insight | but directly ignores obvious causes. | | They treat depression like it is some mystery of science when it | is directly caused by...everything about modern society, | institutions and lifestyles. | | People in Africa living in villages don't get depressed. People | living in suburbs eating shitty food with no hope due to | capitalism and crappy prison schools do. | | The cause of depression is so obvious only a PHD would be able to | write and publish a BS article like this, and it is total horse | shit, and pretend it's a mystery. | | It's not a mystery, they just want to try to solve it with crappy | drugs that you don't actually need rather than target the root | problems, which they can't target. | | I hate these articles and think they are promoting an | intellectual culture of pretending not to understand the obvious | by drenching it in overly intellectualized nonsense. | | This is a media coverup. We know what causes it. | gverrilla wrote: | Agreed. I had an introduction to this perspective long ago by | reading what Karl Marx wrote about suicide [0]. | | 0: https://www.amazon.com/Marx-Suicide-Psychosocial-Issues- | Karl... | ako wrote: | > People in Africa living in villages don't get depressed. | | Any data or studies on this? | fragmede wrote: | > People in Africa living in villages don't get depresse | | Holy shit yes they do, I don't know where this myth comes from! | | https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S266724212... | rgbrenner wrote: | It's an old myth... like here's an article in American | Anthropologist from 1934 talking about it: https://anthrosour | ce.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1525... | | There's a lot of data showing it isn't true, but it's one of | those "facts" that feels true because there's a lot of | stressors and unhealthy things about modern life. | bannedbybros wrote: | [dead] | ding_dang wrote: | I've yet to see someone qualified on HN discussing this. It's all | vapid anecdotes and unfounded/untested beliefs and subscriptions | to various pet theories. | rpastuszak wrote: | > Reject the bad, false, negativity, darkness and move toward | the love, true, light and goodness. When I was depressed, only | spiritual teachings, love and God moved me nearer good feelings | and comfort. | | I have no idea what you're talking about. | avgcorrection wrote: | Oh, so what is it? | | > To treat depression effectively, medical researchers may | therefore need to develop a nuanced understanding of the ways it | can arise. [...] | | > That prediction may frustrate some physicians and drug | developers, since it's much easier to prescribe a one-size-fits- | all solution. | | But it will not frustrate headline writers. | sys32768 wrote: | If I drink to a very buzzed state three nights in a row, I become | palpably depressed, irritable, and anxious. If something bad | happens during this time, it cuts deep and feels overwhelming. | All of the negative things in my life become tormenting devils. | | It takes about 24 hours of sobriety for me to begin to feel | normal again, and at least 48 to feel I am at my normal baseline. | | I always assumed the alcohol was depleting my serotonin. | | Beyond that, most of my depression seems to be due to my heroic | and idealistic self raging and wallowing in the chasm between my | ideals and hard realities that I cannot defeat. | jobs_throwaway wrote: | > Experiments in which researchers artificially lowered the | serotonin levels of volunteers didn't consistently cause | depression | | Jesus...hard to imagine volunteering for that study | likeabbas wrote: | There's no single cause and no single cure which is why it's so | hard. | | I moved cities at 10 years old, and was bullied and isolated | during the entirety of Middle School. Ever since then, I've | always had negative and depressive thoughts lurking around. It's | just my normal. | | A psychiatrist helped me understand that those formative years | are when your cortex is developing. The cortex learns through | repetition, and during those years I was having constant sadness | and suffering events. So, my emotional intelligence learned to be | that way and that's why I've suffered ever since. | | If I'm not pro active in thinking about being happy or doing | active things, I default to being depressed. After almost 20 | years, I'm still suffering. | | A side effect of being isolated during those years is my social | skills have taken longer to develop. I didn't have a true batch | of friends until college, but now I've lost all of them. | RobotToaster wrote: | I've read early life adversity can cause epigenetic changes. | exo-pla-net wrote: | Your brain cannot "learn" to be sad. You can, however, learn | maladaptive schemata: fundamental ways of viewing the world and | oneself that can help a child get through adverse periods (like | bullying and ostracization), but which are ultimately | maladaptive and inaccurate in adulthood. | | You might have come to believe, for instance, that you're | fundamentally "different" or "unlovable", and that you can't | expect to be socially accepted or loved. | | These core beliefs, these schemata, are difficult but possible | to change. Schema Therapy has had empirical success at doing | so. | | The subjective experience of changing a maladaptive schema is | like teleporting from a miserable planet to a strange but much | happier, more loving planet. You can be (much) happier than you | think; you're just stranded on a miserable planet, one that | would make anybody sad. | | I'd suggest checking out Reinventing Your Life by Jeffrey | Young: it provides the tools you need to get to that happier | planet, where you can feel safer and loved and accepted. | likeabbas wrote: | > Your brain cannot "learn" to be sad. | | This is ~equivocally~ unequivocally false. The portion of the | brain that develops emotional intelligence forms during your | formative years and can learn to be put in a depressive | mindset. | | * https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5984129/ | | * https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6132040/ | | > Humans are likely the most emotionally regulated creatures | on earth. Compared to other animal species, we can modulate | and modify emotional reactions and experiences, even very | intense ones, through a large and sophisticated emotion | regulation repertoire that includes skills of distraction, | reappraisal, language, prediction, social interaction, | suppression, and more.1-5 At times, these skills require | effort, and at other times, they seem reflexive and | automatic. But what are some of the variables in this | sophisticated emotion regulation repertoire? The parent of | any toddler or even adolescent can attest to the very slow | development of emotion regulation processes. This slow | development has been documented in empirical research, which | also notes the large individual differences from one person's | ability or style of emotion regulation to another's. | Evolutionarily speaking, this slow development of emotion | regulation ability in childhood that culminates in an | exquisite ability in adulthood points to the benefits of a | slow-maturing emotion regulation system. Indeed, humans are | not only a highly emotionally regulated species, but they are | slowly developing in general, relative to other species, 6 | with a prolonged period of immaturity. Phylogenetically, slow | development may confer benefits through an extended period of | neural plasticity--a feature of a developing neural system | that heightens its ability to learn from the environment. If | so, then humans may owe their sophisticated emotion | regulation skills to the "extension" of childhood that has | evolved in us. The nature, chronicity, and quality of | environmental inputs during these periods of plasticity, in | particular those from close relationships (e.g., parents, | friends, teachers), in large part determine emotion | regulation functioning in adulthood.7 Thus, adult brain and | behavioral function in this regard can be conceptualized as a | historical reflection of what was experienced during | development. To fully appreciate individual differences in | adult emotion regulation skills, then, it is helpful to | understand how the brain develops. | ASalazarMX wrote: | > during your formidable years | | I had to lookup "formidable" in case it was a specialized | term, but I think it's a typo. Nevertheless, I like it | better this way. | likeabbas wrote: | Definitely a typo. Thanks | yowlingcat wrote: | First of all, the phrase "emotional intelligence" is a pop- | psychology invention created by Daniel Goleman which has no | clinically meaningful use. There's a big difference between | emotional intelligence and emotional regulation. | | There's also a difference between traumatic experiences | (such as you moving somewhere new at 10 and struggling with | isolation and being bullied) and how you may have | psychologically adapted to these situations. But nothing | you've mentioned implies that your brain can "learn to be | put into a depressive mindset" -- it's more the case that | strenuous challenges that haven't been addressed, or moved | past, or evolved from, will continue to cause problems | until work is gradually done to address them. | | I have always felt it's similar to musculoskeletal issues. | You can do a lot of damage to your lower back by sitting at | a desk all day, or to your wrists by typing at an angle | that causes repetitive strain. That damage can be | "mitigated" in different ways -- medication, surgery, | physical rehabilitation. While the last one is most | difficult, it's also the most effective because you're | training the mind-muscle connection at the point where it's | fragility is causing and compounding structural damage. | | Even as people get older, until they reach very old age, | it's rare for these kinds of MSK problems to occur in ways | that cannot be unwound by adherence to physical therapy and | a good exercise regimen. I think the same is true for our | minds. As you mention in an earlier comment, if you do | something that makes you happy, you feel happy for that | time before drifting back to depression. But that in and of | itself may be the point -- if you are constantly doing | things which make you happy, it may not be immediate, but | eventually you can re-orient your brain you being default- | happy with depressive episodes rather than the other way | around. That doesn't make it easy, of course, nor is there | a one time fix. | likeabbas wrote: | > But nothing you've mentioned implies that your brain | can "learn to be put into a depressive mindset" -- it's | more the case that strenuous challenges that haven't been | addressed, or moved past, or evolved from, will continue | to cause problems until work is gradually done to address | them. | | What is the practical difference between saying "learnt | to be put in a depressive mindset" and "psychologically | adapted to these situations"? Psychiatrists don't need to | be so technical when explaining the differences to | people. I'm only framing the conversation in a colloquial | manner such that non-psych majors will understand them. | In some manner I've "learned" to be in a depressive | mindset. And, through repetition, I can "un-learn" it. | | > Even as people get older, until they reach very old | age, it's rare for these kinds of MSK problems to occur | in ways that cannot be unwound by adherence to physical | therapy and a good exercise regimen... if you are | constantly doing things which make you happy, it may not | be immediate, but eventually you can re-orient your brain | you being default-happy with depressive episodes rather | than the other way around. | | I'm not disputing this. The times where I am the happiest | is when I'm in my routine of working out and playing | tennis. But when I get out of my routine, I fall back | into the depressive habits. It's hard to stay consistent. | Maybe if I stay consistent for long enough, my default | will not be depressed. But I have yet to be consistent | for long enough to reach that point. | mensetmanusman wrote: | Emotional intelligence is another way of saying that you | have the ability to read the room, which clearly many | people (and very many of the technical people I interact | with) did not have great ability for (which results in a | lot of cringe-worthy moments). | exo-pla-net wrote: | [flagged] | likeabbas wrote: | Practically, what is the difference between emotional | state and consistently emotionally regulating into a | depressive mindset? I'm not a psychiatrist and I don't | care what the precise terminology is. In layman's terms, | what I've stated is correct. | exo-pla-net wrote: | [flagged] | JimtheCoder wrote: | [flagged] | likeabbas wrote: | Nothing I've said is incorrect. I'm just using colloquial | language to describe the issue. | | You are just being an asshole by trying to show off your | technical knowledge in the subject, which is not helping | anyone. | vervez wrote: | Thanks for sharing and i'm happy to be your friend :) | Pigo wrote: | This reminds me of how long it took me to notice a pattern in | my relationships. When I look back, it's so obvious that I was | picking a certain kind of person, and behaving in a certain | kind of way, that would lead to the same conclusion. But it | didn't feel like I was repeating the same story over and over | again just to satisfy some malformed part of my psyche. I can't | rewire something so deep in me that even effects who I'm | attracted to. All I can do is be aware of it, and course | correct. | agumonkey wrote: | It would be interesting to know what phases our brains go | through that 'settle' emotional / social reflexes. | | I had a strange life due to pre-wired issues, until 30 when a | few traumatic event (including a first relationship that was as | positive as negative) completely altered my reality. I was very | surprising to say the least how one day you cannot exist | socially (total shut-in with obsessive painful thoughts on a | daily basis), and the next one you see colors and friendliness | everywhere. Deep in your guts, something that really lifts your | mind, imagination and heart solidly, not just a philosophical | understanding. | | I had a year of socially vibrant emotions but gradually went | back to my old self (avoidant) but I still remember that my | reality is somehow altered and very far from what others can | experience or what is healthy. | | If anybody has resources to read or places to monitor I'll be | glad to know. | | ps: I have a ton of questions regarding the neurology of the | perception of "the self" and others for the lack of better | terms. if any neuroscientist has time to waste, my email is in | my profile, feel free to spam. | incognito_robot wrote: | It is uncanny how much this mimics my own experience. | | Was bullied between ages 11-16. Grew a a social circle in high | school, which started fragmenting once everyone went off to | university. I rarely if ever see any of them anymore. | | Before the bullying, I was aparently happy and excited for most | things (according to siblings). After it I have always been the | low energy serious guy. | | 20 years on I feel an intense need for human connection, but no | matter how much I try I never seem to be able to cultivate any | kind of lasting relationship with others. | Traubenfuchs wrote: | > It is uncanny how much this mimics my own experience. | | A significant amount of people damaged exactly like that run | around. It's nothing noteworthy nor exceptional. And there is | no recognized cure for us. | | My pet theory is that through either nature or nurture, we | are permanently damaged individuals that won't ever | experience what we perceive as the normal, healthy social | life and mental states. Our brains are permanently altered to | our detriment. | | Connecting to your anecdote: I am 30 and my mom still | mentions what a lively and happy child I was. I wish she | wouldn't, because it hurts to hear about the potential I | squandered, lost or had stolen. | ryanwaggoner wrote: | There are no magic bullets, but the research on | psychedelics and depression are encouraging. | Traubenfuchs wrote: | The only time I managed to acquire psylocobin was on an | island where a big rave was happening. A hippie guy sold | me magic mushroom pills. I was too scared to take it in | this atmosphere and wanted to take the pills home. To | leave the island, one had to walk through nipple-high | water. The pills in my wallet melted away in the water. | | Maybe some other day. | imiric wrote: | > I wish she wouldn't, because it hurts to hear about the | potential I squandered, lost or had stolen. | | I think this negative mentality doesn't help. The sooner | you try to live life to the best of your abilities with the | cards you've been dealt, the sooner you'll feel better | about your present and future. We can't change the past, | but we can choose to accept it and move on. | jvm___ wrote: | Same. Insulting nicknames from elementary into highschool. | Same 15 boys due to small classes at private Christian | school. | | Married the first girl who showed me positive attention. I | didn't know what a friend for me was, so we're married but | not friends. | | The hope for you is that I found a group through a local | running group. They posted on Facebook and we run weekly. | They added me to the group chat last year and it's been | amazing having people to chat with and go on runs with. | | Going home to someone who you can't have a conversation with | is hard though. | | Trite advice that worked for me. Find a group of people who | do the thing you like as a way to make friends. This group | was started by someone just looking to not run alone in town. | | I can picture in my head walking up to the running group | meetup for the first time, it honestly feels like a new birth | after being friendless from grade 7 til age 40+. | ryanwaggoner wrote: | I wasn't bullied, but I was a homeschool kid who ended up | at a private Christian school and then married the first | girl who showed me any interest. We finally divorced after | two decades of struggle. The entire 3-4 year period of my | marriage finally collapsing under its own weight came with | several beautiful bright spots: I went to therapy, I had | several life-changing experiences with psychedelics, and I | found a group of incredibly good friends in similar | situations. It's mindblowing the difference that a few good | friends can make. | theGnuMe wrote: | People develop a set of psychological defense mechanisms to | the bullying that work at the time but can be maladaptive | later. Maybe you were bullied because the bullies found your | happy excitement upsetting to their feelings and wanted you | to feel the way they feel. This is not uncommon. I'm sorry | that happened to you. But it sounds like you are finding the | time to reflect on your past. | | As for relationships, the "one simple trick" for human | connection and relationships is that there is no trick, you | have to continuously put the work in. It helps if you find | activities that you want to do and make friends there. A lot | of people find satisfaction in helping other people, so | volunteering can be one way to meet new people. | | You might face constant rejection at first but you are not | unlovable. But if you are nice and kind to others and help | others people will value that and think of you in the future. | | At some point you will reach critical mass and things will | get easier. | zeroonetwothree wrote: | Depression often develops in adolescence so I think we should | be a bit skeptical with the 'correlation is not causation' | going on with these examples. | vbezhenar wrote: | I'm in a similar situation. Best friends I've found are when | I actively played WoW and attended raids. I didn't kept them | though but that was nice time and probably I had best | interactions at that time. I'm trying to replicate that time | but WoW changed and its audience changed, I don't feel like I | fit there anymore. | PuppyTailWags wrote: | I found out that part of the issue with creating lasting | relationships with others is that it actually takes a lot of | effort to maintain relationships. It's not like a dating game | where if you have a good dialogue on day 1 and then another | good dialogue on day 2 their disposition changes. It's much | more nuanced and much more specific on individual-to- | individual interactions over months or years. Remembering | common events to talk about regularly, responding and being | responded to, birthdays, holiday celebrations, mutual | activities, organizing intimate setting (think "potluck at | X's house") socialization, the list goes on and on about the | wide variety of behaviors. | | If you're struggling, I found graythorn's various assessment | resources super helpful, as it systematizes aspects of | relationship building that most people find intuitive. Things | like "what level of friendship am I with this person" and | "assessment on expressing needs and support" were helpful to | me. Although these guides are specifically towards autistics, | so keep that in mind when you try them. | com2kid wrote: | > but no matter how much I try I never seem to be able to | cultivate any kind of lasting relationship with others. | | I used to run a startup focused on this, here is what I | learned: | | Time. The answer is time. Research shows there are two ways | long term bonds are formed, shared adversity[1], or lots of | time spent together. General rule of thumb for relationship | building: | | 1. 10 hours together is someone you know 2. 100 hours | together is a good acquittance. 3. 1000 hours together is a | good friend and a relationship that can now last a long time | | This is why activities such as football watching (3*18, 54 | hours a year, 2 years and you now have the beginnings of a | good friends circle), or weekly poker matches (2 hours, | almost 100 hours in a year) are so effective at building | relationships. | | Interpersonal hobbies with lots of down time, like rock | climbing or playing in a band, accelerate this process | greatly. | | For people with kids, weekly play dates, or a weekly rotated | dinner hosting. | | Friendship is literally grinding hours, when we are young it | is easy, studying and hanging out get those hours in, but | when we get older, we have to be purposeful about it. | | [1] Military boot camps are an example of this, so are the | various culture wars. If you make people feel they are part | of an oppressed group, preferably while isolating them from | society at large, you will forms a cohesive group that acts | together and one where everyone feels connected to each | other. "Both sides" of the political spectrum do this, once | you learn to spot it you start seeing it everywhere. | citilife wrote: | I recommend people try to go to Church -- even if you're | not exceptionally religious (you can even tell them that, | I've never seen anyone mind; though they may try to | convince you). | | It's an easy place to meet 30-40 people in a day, everyone | there has different interests and comes from different | walks of life. If you attend for a few weeks you'll often | start attending lunch together, meeting out at some | activities, etc. Plus, all you have to do is show up. | People at a church tend to be outgoing, at least some of | them are. Someone is bound to reach out to you if you sit | there and drink a coffee. | spidersouris wrote: | > Research shows... | | Do you have any references in mind? | com2kid wrote: | When running my startup I did a deep dive into the | psychology behind friendship and relationship building, | but I haven't kept track of any of the references since | then. | takk309 wrote: | I can't agree more on the shared adversity. My three main | hobbies are rock climbing, hockey, and cycling. With | climbing you have to battle against yourself and your | limits. Good partners will support you in those pursuits. | Add in the fact that your life is literally in someone | else's hands when they belay you, it is a quick path to | trust. Add in the down time, as stated above, and you will | make true friends. Going on a week long climbing trip with | a small group will stack up quality hours fast. | | Hockey is different but you still have a team working | towards a goal, literally! With a good group of people, | good as in nice people, not skilled, you win and lose as a | team. Plus the on bench and locker room time means you get | to know one another over time. | | Cycling is different for me, it is a solo experience and as | a result I don't have any friends in that world. | geph2021 wrote: | Cycling is different for me, it is a solo experience and | as a result I don't have any friends in that world. | | I guess it depends where you live, but usually there are | cycling clubs or bike stores that have organized group | rides. Riding with a group is an incredible way to enjoy | longer rides while socializing, and it's safer. | | I started cycling and was amazed at how social it was | (albeit living in a town with a sizable cycling | community). In my youth I was a swimmer, and although | there is a lot of shared experience/adversity and | friendship on any sports team, there's a lot less | socializing that can be done while your head is | underwater! | likeabbas wrote: | I believe we find it hard to keep relationships because we | take criticism/rejection harder than others. My (former) | friends would say that I have no trouble burning bridges with | anyone. Any time I've found myself embarrassed or hurt by | someone else, I've pushed them out of my life. This | definitely comes from how I handled people in my formative | years | waboremo wrote: | For me this was Rejection Sensitivity Dysphoria, linked to | ADHD but of course that itself has a lot of overlap with | the anxiety/depression realm. | | It's a pretty messed up condition to deal with, especially | because even the mere perception of potentially being | rejected can cause disproportionate reactions. | UncleOxidant wrote: | Yep, because we have very negative associations with | criticism. In addition to being bullied, we tended to move | a lot when I was a kid. So it became easy to just leave and | start over somewhere else - I think I even started to look | forward to being able to start over. I remember as a kid | playing with other kids and after a bit just disappearing | and hearing them in the distance say "hey, where did he | go?" - I'd often do this. Much later I came to realize that | this was some kind of avoidance and that it wasn't the | norm. I think that I expected even amicable play situations | to eventually lead to being bullied and I think that's why | I'd just ghost people. | citilife wrote: | Probably wont be taken well, but IMO depression is an illness | in the spiritual sense. Depression is described as being sad, | alone and without hope. That's quite literally what | spirituality is for. | | I think it's probably impossible to treat with drugs because | what people really need are friends, hope and a good outlook on | life (which often comes from hope). I'm sure drugs can improve | people with imbalances and I'm also sure it's not just one | thing that causes depression. That said, it seems like it can | often be solved with more traditional means -- finding | community and purpose. | csours wrote: | It seems likely that depression is also not a single disease. | UncleOxidant wrote: | Bullying is such a detrimental thing to experience. It has | lifelong consequences. It's good to see that schools in the US | are taking it more seriously than they used to. In the past the | attitude from adults seemed to be that experiencing bullying | would make you tougher. Now we know better. | | I know that I personally still suffer the effects of bullying | some 40 to 50 years later - for example, I tend to withdraw | from any conflict/confrontation in the work setting | misinterpreting even constructive conflict/criticism as being | directed at me personally. When I was a kid playing with other | kids I tended to withdraw and disappear even in situations | where there was no bullying because I came to expect it would | happen. And I see that I withdraw similarly in the workplace. | In that sense the bullying from many years ago has negatively | impacted my career and mental health (anxiety, panic attacks | and a bit of paranoia as I'm always expecting the worst from | other people). | mathematicaster wrote: | Thank you for sharing this. | likeabbas wrote: | Any time. I wish every child could have rich formative years | so they can avoid long lasting emotional pain. | ASalazarMX wrote: | > I didn't have a true batch of friends until college, but now | I've lost all of them. | | I think losing college friends is inevitable. People get jobs, | move, marry, change, etc. Clutching to the friends when life | was much simpler might not work now. | | The solution would be making more social ties with neighbors, | family, acquaintances, hobbyists, etc., and try to find new | friendships/relationships within them. | hi41 wrote: | I can relate to your comment a lot. I went through many years | of isolation during my childhood resulting in poor social | skills. After so many years my thoughts are continually | negative. Like you, I too don't have any friends. I am unable | to break the cycle of loneliness. When I try my interactions | are awkward which makes me self-conscious and I withdraw. | kodah wrote: | Same thing, ish, here. I don't know if my experience is | anecdotal but this gets easier with age. I can hypothesize that | I did a lot of unpacking and that my experiences today are much | more net positive, thus drifting my "default state" farther | from a depressive mindset. Mushrooms helped, but I'd recommend | anyone looking into mushrooms, or psychedelics in general, to | be cognizant that dealing with trauma in a trip can either be | really great or really terrifying. You also are largely not in | the driver's seat when dealing with trauma in a trip and | fighting it will make things worse. The latter being a lesson | I've learned many times over at this point. | dmd wrote: | > There's no single cause and no single cure which is why it's | so hard. | | My neurologist once said to me "any time you see the phrase | 'multiple mechanisms of X' in a medical journal, that's code | for 'we have no fucking clue'". | spiffytech wrote: | > There's no single cause and no single cure which is why it's | so hard. | | This is exactly right. I'm at the tail end of a long depressive | journey that wasn't caused by self-beliefs, distorted thoughts, | trauma, etc. Nearly every depression treatment I sought had | zero effect. | | My problems came about because I had undiagnosed and | unappreciated neurological + genetic conditions that created | stacking debuffs that made ordinary SWE jobs tax my executive | function and deplete my neurotransmitters, eventually leaving | me personally and professionally debilitated. | | Because I suffered the symptoms for so long before identifying | the causes, neurologically I seemed to have entered a new | attractor (in dynamical systems terms). I couldn't recover by | just discontinuing what brought me there; my neurology kept | gravitating towards the new steady-state. (A good chunk of this | is black-box reverse engineering what helped me recover) | | I've only gotten better by radically changing my circumstances, | identifying a crucial supplement, and undergoing a medical | procedure. | | The eye-opening part of the journey was understanding that | because depression is defined by a set of symptoms, receiving a | diagnosis doesn't tell you anything at all about what's wrong | with you. It only confirms you have a problem at all. | TurkishPoptart wrote: | >My problems came about because I had undiagnosed and | unappreciated neurological + genetic conditions that created | stacking debuffs that made ordinary SWE jobs tax my executive | function and deplete my neurotransmitters, eventually leaving | me personally and professionally debilitated. | | I love how you used "stacking debuffs" here. That made me | smile. | smn1234 wrote: | which supplement helped you most ? | spiffytech wrote: | I have a genetic mutation called MTHFR C677T, which means | my body doesn't process vitamin B9 with the necessary | efficiency. B9 is upstream of regulating the quantities of | monoamine neurotransmitters the brain synthesizes | (serotonin, dopamine, and norepinepherine). | | (Not everyone with an MTHFR mutation experiences symptoms. | For a long time I didn't. Best guess is my body changed | after a period of intense stress.) | | I take L-Methylfolate 15mg, which bypasses my digestion and | provides my body with the processed materials directly. | | The brand name for this is Deplin, which requires a | prescription. I just switched to over-the-counter | L-Methylfolate - it remains to be seen if it's as | effective. | | Fun fact: once I started taking Deplin, I had to come off | of all my traditional antidepressants. They were at max | dosage and having no effect, but once my brain was flooded | with neurotransmitters, all the antidepressant side effects | kicked in, including (perversely) amplifying depression | symptoms. | bnjms wrote: | How did you find out about the MTHFR mutation? How was it | tested for? | spiffytech wrote: | I took a mail-in genetic test from Genomind. I didn't | understand the significance of the result until I was | coincidentally prescribed Deplin and mentioned the mood | change to my ADHD coach, who connected the dots. | | Having a concrete scientific explanation for the | empirical result I was seeing was a great confidence | booster, bolstered some hypotheses I had, and helped me | identify next steps in my journey. | trevwilson wrote: | > identifying a crucial supplement, and undergoing a medical | procedure | | Would you feel comfortable sharing some specifics on what | these were for you? | spiffytech wrote: | I remarked on the supplement in another comment. | | The medical procedure was TMS - I spent ~6 weeks coming in | every weekday, had my head strapped into a magnet helmet, | and the magnets stimulate the parts of the brain associated | with depression. I understand it to be vaguely like jump- | starting an engine with a dead battery. | | I just had my last session yesterday, and I see huge | changes from December. | | Crucially, I underwent TMS in 2019 and saw almost no | change. At that time, I was still in the abrasive career | situation, and wasn't on the supplement, so my hypothesis | is TMS had very limited benefit because I didn't have | sufficient quantities of neurotransmitters for stimulation | to do anything, and any possible benefit was being | immediately eroded by the circumstances that created my | problems in the first place. | | I also had undiagnosed autism (which came with hardcoded | limitations I'd been treating as personal preferences or | bad attitude), and ADHD (which I was diagnosed with as a | kid, but didn't understand how it manifests as an adult). | Both of these tax executive function (neurotransmitters) | heavily, and the MTHFR mutation handicapped how much | executive function I had to go around in the first place. | My particular neurodiverse needs appear to be at odds with | the typical SWE work environment, so every day I was | powering through my special needs, until my brain couldn't | take it anymore and simply gave out. | golemotron wrote: | It's amazing how far we go to avoid seeing depression in the | context of a person's social interactions. | tifik wrote: | I made it a principle to never click a title (or a thumbnail in | case of e.g. youtube) that is intentionally this click-baity. | | If it's a topic I genuinely am interested in, I just look the | information up somewhere else. | spacemadness wrote: | Or titles in the form of a question that ultimately is either | answered "no" or "we have no idea. keep clicking each week to | find out more!" | tifik wrote: | Just for the record, the original title was 'The real cause | of depression is not what you think it is', or sth very close | to that. | | I am happy to see it was changed. | joescharf wrote: | Everyone wants a pill as a quick effortless fix, but IMO it seems | a lot of our modern afflictions come down to an gross imbalance | of exercise, diet, sleep, and social connection. Most likely the | way society (see disclaimer) currently functions - how we work, | how we consume our limited leisure time is sort of an | occupational hazard to peak health. | | Not to mention, exercise is "too hard" for most, the food supply | is weaponized with sugar and FUD, everyone is so tired at the end | of their "BS job" workday, so hit the couch and stream the | streams. And now you have a vicious flywheel that quickly turns | people into candidates for the latest big-pharma "cure" | | HN Disclaimer: I'm in the US and making generalizations based on | my observations. Not saying that there aren't needs for pharma / | pills / afflictions that aren't solvable by the above, etc... | stronglikedan wrote: | I'd lump those pill into that list of the cause of modern | afflictions. I got off them, because they made things worse, | just in different ways than the depression itself. I cured | myself with diet and exercise. | com2kid wrote: | I know the serotonin theory of depression is pretty much dead, | but it is a fact that being around people raises serotonin | levels. For introverts it is _tiring_ , but it is better than | not being around people. | | Being around people reduces cognitive decline in old age. | | Being around people reduces depression levels. | | Being in a supportive community _reduces the severity of | symptoms from schizophrenia_. | | The 2+2 nuclear family concept is an abomination, we are | supposed to live in a multigenerational community, surrounded | by friends and family. | | The modern American lifestyle destroys psychological health. | Without large social circles, finding romantic partners is | hard, which leads to all sorts of negative life outcomes. | | Raising kids is hard, friends of mine who have nearby extended | family have a much easier time raising kids (and are more | likely to have more kids!) Heck my sister had kids 20 years | before I did (bit of an age difference), 2 sets of grand | parents, lots of free baby sitting, and aunts and uncles to | help out with homework. It was also useful for me, I got to | learn a lot about babies early on. | | > gross imbalance of exercise, diet, sleep, and social | connection | | Yeah lots of these are solved with a large social group. I have | some good friends (who sadly now live a bit aways from me) who | host dinner parties 3 or 4 nights a week. People come over and | help cook and clean up, so everyone eats healthy meals all the | time. | | Friends who have lots of family nearby, just rotate whose house | they go to on different nights, all the kids and adults after | school/work get together to do child care and cooking. Healthy | food for everyone, less work. | | Lots of modern life scales up really well. 2 parents will get | exhausted taking care of 1 baby, between cooking, cleaning, and | watching the child. | | 4 parents, 3 kids? Much easier. Seriously, piece of cake. | | 3 grand parents, 4 parents, a young auntie, 5 kids? No problem | at all. | | Society has seriously screwed the pooch. | | If I had some insane amount of capitol I'd try to start some | sort of shared housing for families, do intense interviews to | match people up (see: My last failed startup) people cook | together, raise kids together, support each other. Put 3-5 | new/young families in a mid size housing complex with a shared | yard. Put a support network in place, house chaperone ( _cough_ | RA _cough_ ) to help out now and then. | | Extended Family as a Service. Dystopian, maybe, but possibly | it'd do a lot of good in the world. | | (If any investors want to get in touch, please do, :-D ) | thowaway959125 wrote: | To me, this is undoubatedly a huge part of the problem. | | I noticed that my depression spiked when I started to become | more isolated. I was getting older, long time friends are now | scattered about the country/world, difficult to make new | ones. Family members are isolated and scattered doing their | own thing in their nuclear units. Parents are divoced and | fending for themselves too. Finding a romantic partner under | these circumstances is difficult ... having no friends can be | seen as a "red flag". It snowballs. | | I have also thought of the concept of shared housing for | adults. I LOVE this idea. | | They share the responsibilities much like a multi- | generational family would, they just happen to be strangers. | AnIdiotOnTheNet wrote: | > Society has seriously screwed the pooch. | | Pretty much all available data says as much, but we refuse to | do anything about it. Hell, most refuse to recognize there's | even a problem. | elric wrote: | > gross imbalance of exercise, diet, sleep, and social | connection | | Indeed. What's worse is that we, as individuals, know this. But | we, as in the western society at large, seem to be utterly | unwilling or incapable of addressing this. | | Long working hours to make ends meet. The shittiest food is the | most convenient option. There's a metric fuckton of light- and | sound pollution which messes with our sleep. 10% of folks | suffer from sleep apnea for a variety of reasons. So many | things are messing with us. At some point, we're going to have | to start dealing with these things. | gatonegro wrote: | > _it seems a lot of our modern afflictions come down to an | gross imbalance of exercise, diet, sleep, and social | connection_ | | If you think about it in an evolutionary timescale, the way | most of us live in the West these days is horrendously | incompatible with the sort of life we evolved to live. | Thousands and thousands of years were spent out in nature, in | small communities, eating certain types of foods, engaging in | physical activities, etc. | | The sit-on-a-chair-all-day, look-at-screens-all-day lifestyle | is a comparatively new development, and neither our minds nor | our bodies are suited for such an existence. That's enough to | cause us a fair amount of trouble. Add all the socioeconomic | issues you mention into the mix, and it all starts to make | perfect sense to me. | 2OEH8eoCRo0 wrote: | I think so too. 9 times out of 10 a person has horrible eating, | sleeping, or drug habits and a sedentary lifestyle. | robocat wrote: | I'll add situational-depression to your list: an ongoing | sadness due to being stuck in a bad circumstance (bad | relationship, terrible job, etcetera). The defining factor is | that once the bad circumstance is "fixed", the long-term | sadness is quickly gone (replaced with ongoing contentment) and | symptoms don't reappear. This is not an academic definition, | just a personal observation, although perhaps you have seen the | effect happen to others in your life. | | I've had situational-depression badly enough that I would | easily have been diagnosed as clinically depressed (more than | one person said so, and if I had gone to a doctor I am sure I | would have been given a label and some pills). When the cause | was resolved, I immediately switched out of the funk and all | symptoms of "depression" were gone. I don't believe it was | correlation, that is I don't believe depression lifting caused | me to fix my bad circumstance: I don't think I had any | influence over the actual date the underlying cause was | "fixed". Chronic clinical depression is not usually fixed in a | day. | chasil wrote: | _Serotonin syndrome_ is also a real risk. | | SSRIs are extremely dangerous if tryptophan intake is also | increased (with supplements, for example), even moreso if | niacin is also consumed to encourage the tryptophan -> | serotonin pathway. | | https://selfhacked.com/blog/serotonin-syndrome/ | | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6184959/ | PragmaticPulp wrote: | > Everyone wants a pill as a quick effortless fix, but IMO it | seems a lot of our modern afflictions come down to an gross | imbalance of exercise, diet, sleep, and social connection. | | For what it's worth, exercise, diet, sleep, social engagement, | and lifestyle changes _are_ well-known inputs to addressing | depression. Therapists will explore and encourage improvements | in all of these areas. Good psychiatrists will as well, given | enough time and a patient who is open to listening. | | One of the difficult issues is that many depressed patients | often don't want to hear any suggestions that depression might | be due to anything other than external factors. This is why the | pop-science version of the "chemical imbalance" theory became | so popular in the mainstream: It gives a plausible explanation | that depression is just something that happens to you due to no | fault of your own, which is weirdly easier to accept for many | people. | | There are similar treatment problems with a host of health | issues, such as obesity. The trend on social media and pop | culture is to explain obesity away as a chemical or societal | problem, minimizing the input of personal choice and actions. | It's very popular to propose theories that "counting calories | doesn't work" or hear anecdotes about people who claim to only | eat less than 1000 calories per day but never lose weight | (which isn't possible, even 100% sedentary coma patients need | more calories than that). | AnIdiotOnTheNet wrote: | But Obesity isn't very much about personal choice, as | evidenced by most people being able to keep a reasonable | weight without counting calories or putting in any effort | whatsoever, while people like me have to obsess over | everything because if we ate the way we "naturally" feel like | we should then we'd be blimps. | | Or rather, it is about choice, but the choice for some is | "obsess over it and suffer a lot more than the people around | you for the rest of your life", not to mention generally | being treated like not being able to fight your body's | compulsions is a personal failing by people who _don 't have | to fucking do that_. | | P.S.: And before you go shoving your fad bullshit advice of | the week at me, it should be noted that at one point I had | lost half my body weight and am still over 100lbs down. I | have been doing this for over a decade, I have tried every | trick anyone has yet devised to make this easier and none of | the work for this kind of weight. | | Any diet will work for 10-15lbs. Like, literally _any_ diet. | This has been shown multiple times. Losing real, serious, | obesity-level weight takes significant effort and suffering | _continuously_ and anyone who says differently is full of | shit. | | ...unless there 's a drug involved. Amphetamines and the new | class of diabetes drugs seem to actually work wonders. The | former is obviously problematic and ill-advised. | elric wrote: | I think the folks on HN are generally aware that weight | loss is incredibly hard, I'd be surprised to see anyone | here trying to shove fad advice down your gullet. | kar5pt wrote: | I could flip this around and say that focusing on internal | causes of depression is a way for those in power to avoid the | social responsibility of having to change it. We can kick the | responsibility ball back and forth all day. | | _Why_ is it so hard for people to get adequate sleep, | exercise, a good diet and social interaction? Even most non- | depressed people I know don 't do these things well (except | maybe the last one), so this isn't something unique to | depression. | ryanwaggoner wrote: | Exactly this. We throw people into a sick society and then | blame them for their lack of personal responsibility when | they get sick themselves. | | As an individual, yes, do what you can (which might mean | changing to a less "sick" culture or subculture so you're | not fighting a sisyphean battle). _And also_ , we should do | better as a society. | elric wrote: | Same with drugs. There's a bit of cocaine-epidemic where I | live. With lots of gung-ho politicians clamoring for a "war | on drugs" and "zero tolerance" and "hold the addicts | accountable", etc. But I don't hear any politicians talking | about _why_ so many people want to snort cocaine... | joescharf wrote: | > This is why the pop-science version of the "chemical | imbalance" theory became so popular in the mainstream: It | gives a plausible explanation that depression is just | something that happens to you due to no fault of your own, | which is weirdly easier to accept for many people. | | Yes, and "chemical imbalance" is totally legit but not like | its predominantly being marketed. The chemicals (dopamine, | seratonin, whatever) are already present in our bodies - they | just aren't consistently expressed across the population. For | many people, these chemicals aren't released as regularly or | in sufficient quantities for a given time period. Often due | to lifestyle, but also just differs from person to person. | But hey, put in 45 minutes of Z2-Z3 cardio and it can be | amazing how the cobwebs get cleared. | | > The trend on social media and pop culture is to explain | obesity away as a chemical or societal problem | | The somewhat recent corporate opportunism targeting obesity | and marketing it as completely normal and healthy, almost | something to strive for, is incredibly concerning. | 2OEH8eoCRo0 wrote: | > One of the difficult issues is that many depressed patients | often don't want to hear any suggestions that depression | might be due to anything other than external factors. | | I knew someone like this. She'd get new therapists until one | of them tells her what she wants to hear. | | You're nailing it IMO. If you get to blame society, genetics, | or external factors then you don't have to take | responsibility. You get a pass. (people think) | PuppyTailWags wrote: | To counterpoint your anecdote: I know a girl who is fit, | eats great, gets good sleep, regularly goes on long trips | with friends, still clinically depressed and struggles to | experience any sort of joy which is why she puts in so much | effort into trying to improve her life. Still got | depression, baybee. | whstl wrote: | Funny thing. I actually got depression/burnout when I was | preparing to run a half-marathon (I do it yearly). | | It pissed me to no end that the couple people who got to | know about it basically told me to "exercise more and do | volunteer work", even when I told them that it was caused | by work-related stress. | rconti wrote: | Telling a depressed person to just start exercising, eating | well, and sleeping sufficiently is really not significantly | more helpful than telling them to just be happier. | Dma54rhs wrote: | Telling them they can fix their problems without doing | any of those is not working either. | pojzon wrote: | I dont like myself and I have no way to change myself as the | issues I face are of a genetic cause. | | I wont be happy till I accept myself, but I wont accept myself | like Im not accepted by others. | | Simple as that. This is the burden Ill carry till the end of my | days. Hopefully sooner than later. | theGnuMe wrote: | I think it is the gut microbiome and chemicals. Basically drink | too much alcohol, get depressed or inferred from the hangover. | It's a negative feedback look b/c usually drinking relieves | depression at first. Then fail to eat properly for what you and | your microbiome need, you get depressed. Tryptophan depletion for | example. Take a serious course of antibiotics get depressed since | your microbiome is out of whack. | | There's probably genetics involved as well. Sun light exposure | modulates hormones and Vit D. | | I wonder if there's a correlation with caesarean section births | and depression as well. The hypothesis would be that the infant | is born into a sterile environment and does not get populated by | the moms microbiome. | | Exercise probably plays a role as well since it boosts resilence. | PaulHoule wrote: | "Serotonin" is itself a complex entity. | | There are 14 known serotonin receptors in 7 families | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5-HT_receptor | | not to mention other targets such as the serotonin transporter | which is a target of many antidepressants. | | Serotonin pharmacology includes antidepressant and antianxiety | medication, psychedelic drugs such as LSD and mescaline, the | nearly unique drug MDMA (aka Ecstacy), drugs to suppress | vomiting, part of the action of some antipsychotic drugs, anti- | migraine, and drugs that increase gastric and intestinal | motility. | | Platelets, your gut, and heart valves are just a few tissues that | are full of serotonin receptors: some serotonin-active drugs can | seriously damage your heart valves, see | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fenfluramine/phentermine | | ---- | | The conclusions that people made about free serotonin in spinal | taps of psychiatric patients in the 1960s have been long used in | a facile manner in psych med marketing and the chickens seem to | finally be coming home to roost on that one. | | I'd almost call the SSRIs "antineurotic" drugs in that they are | helpful for both anxiety and depression in many people. There has | been a lot of negativity about them in the news in the last | months or so, particularly reports of bad efficacy which I think | draw the wrong conclusion. | | Basically if you try "X mg of fluoxetine vs a placebo" you are | going to have poor response and a lot of side effects. In good | clinical practice you see your doc, fill a script, talk to your | doc in three weeks, maybe increase the dose, maybe try a | different med if you don't get a response or if you are bothered | by side effects. If you do that you get much better results that | the average clinical trial of a single antidepressant but you are | going to talk to your doc (maybe sometimes to the nurse over the | phone) several times over 6 months or so. | zttg wrote: | [dead] | ThinkBeat wrote: | We dont understand the brain nearly enough to form a cohesive | understaning of depression. (or many other brain related things). | | Now, some are saying that gut flora might also be involved. And | possible genetic markers. This would create a gigantic number of | permutations. | | I doubt we can ever "fix" depression with just drugs / chemical | imbalance. We may help it along. | | Current treatment for depression, in so far as drugs are | concerned, is a doctor throwing an "anti depression" pill at you | and askinf you to try it for a while and see how you feel. | | If you feel worse, or no better, you get to try another. | | The loop repeats until something works better or until you are | out of alternatives. | | In which case, if you have severe depression, options like | electrocution of the brain (forget proper English term) becomes | an option. | | It is often successful, but usually must be repeated and it is | not a good thing for the brains other functionality. | edgyquant wrote: | I definitely get the "we don't understand the brain" aspect. | This applies to a ton of things in psychology which I can't say | I'm a fan of. For instance my sister (a psych major) spent | thanksgiving arguing with me that babies can be born | sociopaths. This is something we definitely can't state for | sure and seems like predetermination with a fancy name. | [deleted] | nobody9999 wrote: | >I definitely get the "we don't understand the brain" aspect. | This applies to a ton of things in psychology which I can't | say I'm a fan of. For instance my sister (a psych major) | spent thanksgiving arguing with me that babies can be born | sociopaths. This is something we definitely can't state for | sure and seems like predetermination with a fancy name. | | I'd go further and say that most things we class as "mental | illness" is just a way of categorizing our ignorance. | | Even drugs that purport to help with "mental illness" at best | treat some of the symptoms of the _unknown_ causes of such | symptoms often have side effects that can be worse than the | symptoms. | | While significant advances in neuroscience have given us more | knowledge about how our brains/mental states work, most | attempts at treatment are at the level of trepanning[0] to | release evil spirits. | | Hopefully that will change as we learn more. I'm not holding | my breath. | | [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trepanning | robotburrito wrote: | I can't help but imagine the principal Skinner meme in this case. | "Am I out of touch? Is society causing depression? No... It's the | chemicals that are wrong." | [deleted] | samsquire wrote: | When you cannot find something inside something you can try | looking outside where you were looking for answers. | | In my experience, my spiritual health, acceptances, lack of | rejecting bad (and source of) things is the direct cause of all | negative thoughts, feelings. | | Reject the bad, false, negativity, darkness and move toward the | love, true, light and goodness. When I was depressed, only | spiritual teachings, love and God moved me nearer good feelings | and comfort. | nobody9999 wrote: | >Reject the bad, false, negativity, darkness and move toward | the love, true, light and goodness. When I was depressed, only | spiritual teachings, love and God moved me nearer good feelings | and comfort. | | I'm glad that works for you, and I encourage you to do those | things that make your life better. | | As an empiricist, for me "spirituality" is just a trope that | many use as a crutch (which can be _very_ useful to some). | There is only the _natural_ (nothing "super" about it) world. | There is no "spirit" or "soul" that defines us separately from | our physical existence (i.e., I reject the concept of Mind-Body | Dualism[0]) | | And the "God" you mention is just an _imaginary_ sky daddy, | whose inscrutable "motives" are generally co-opted[1] by the | opportunistic to gain acceptance from those who have such | beliefs. | | I prefer to create meaning from the _natural_ world and take | great comfort in the vastness and incredible beauty, variety | and complexity of the universe as it actually is, rather than | the, unsupported by evidence and often manipulative, ideas | around the existence of supernatural beings /causes/effects. | | All that said, what's most important is (by one's individual | estimation) living a happy, satisfying life. If others require | beliefs I reject to do so, I have no issue with that. | | We all need to make our own (whether good or bad) decisions | about what constitutes a "happy, satisfying life." And while | expressing opinions about that is certainly reasonable and | expected, attempting to force[2][3] those opinions on others is | _wrong_. | | [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind%E2%80%93body_dualism | | [1] https://www.encyclopedia.com/history/applied-and-social- | scie... | | [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostasy_in_Islam | | [3] | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dobbs_v._Jackson_Women%27s_Hea... | mx24 wrote: | >I prefer to create meaning from the natural world and take | great comfort in the vastness and incredible beauty, variety | and complexity of the universe as it actually is, rather than | the, unsupported by evidence and often manipulative, ideas | around the existence of supernatural beings/causes/effects. | | If your life is so meaningful why are you taking so much time | to prove how rational and knowledgeable you are? I mean are | the references linked above really necessary? You sound like | a teenager that just discovered Atheism. | rpastuszak wrote: | For the love of God and all that is holy, please stop. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2023-01-26 23:00 UTC)