[HN Gopher] How I came to write "Tidy First?" tl;dr it took 18 y... ___________________________________________________________________ How I came to write "Tidy First?" tl;dr it took 18 years Author : KentBeck Score : 84 points Date : 2023-03-21 14:49 UTC (1 days ago) (HTM) web link (tidyfirst.substack.com) (TXT) w3m dump (tidyfirst.substack.com) | chmod600 wrote: | Off-topic, but the writing style seems to use "&" excessively. | Did anyone else find that disruptive? | dang wrote: | Some people like it. I would find it annoying except they used | to do it all the time in the 18th century and it's kind of fun | that an old convention came back. | codetrotter wrote: | > Some people like it & I would find it annoying except they | used to do it all the time in the 18th century & it's kind of | fun that an old convention came back. | | FT&FY | plorkyeran wrote: | Obviously it's fallen out of fashion, but it is/was just a | shorthand way of writing "and" & it used to be pretty normal to | just use it every time. It's not really something you can use | "excessively"; either you write "and" as "&" or you don't. | einpoklum wrote: | [flagged] | topaz0 wrote: | Others have refuted the "--someone not famous" part of your | shallow dismissal so I won't go there, but also my | understanding from the post is that "few people know about" is | because the book isn't published yet. | belfalas wrote: | Just to pile on - Kent Beck was one of the authors of JUnit. | His credentials are pretty solid. | neilv wrote: | Kent Beck's work is important to the field of software, | starting since before techbros were a thing, and ongoing. | | When a field becomes known as a "get rich quick" career, and | there's a massive influx people into the field... it's a little | sadly-funny to realize that more people in the field know the | names of people who got the most rich, than know the names of | people who helped get the field itself to that point (through | craft/avocation/research/etc.). | scrame wrote: | See also: Alan Kays comment on software engineering pop | culture. | neilv wrote: | HN comment thread from 2012: | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4956430 | dang wrote: | " _Please don 't post shallow dismissals, especially of other | people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something._" | | https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html | UK-Al05 wrote: | Kent beck is an incredibly famous software engineer. | | Invented XP, and the wrote the most well known book on TDD. | PaulHoule wrote: | His own writings aren't that bad but he's the Dr. Oz to the | agile-charlatans. (e.g. Dr. Oz had to explain to Congress | that he had no idea whatsoever why his face was on so many | ads for scam weight loss products.) | UK-Al05 wrote: | XP at the time was pretty good. A lot of people started | doing CI of the back of XP. | | I'd say he's pretty sad about how agile turned out. Its | pretty different to what XP advocated for in a lot of | organisations. | PaulHoule wrote: | The thing is the agile-charlatans copied his style for | talking about how programming teams should be organized. | blast wrote: | That's the charlatans' fault, not Kent's. | neilv wrote: | I managed to attend a few book-signings of great authors (Salman | Rushdie, Richard Dawkins, and, long ago, Beverly Cleary), but | would kill for this Yourdon-Constantine one, as well as the story | behind it. | | I actually worked for a CASE vendor that started by building | tools to apply Yourdon et al.'s Structured Analysis and | Structured Design to important systems, in mil/aerospace/datacom. | (I was lucky to be the teen mascot on our full-lifecycle | evolution of those tools, in the Portland division, and then on | an R&D team at HQ for next-gen OO CASE.) | | Yourdon also collaborated with Peter Coad on a pair of books for | OO development. | | To this day, I still find Yourdon et al.'s DFDs (from Structured | Analysis) to be one of the first and most powerful tools for | eliciting process/system understanding, from business people and | techies alike, even if they've never seen it. Put loosely, it | seems half of all business/org problems lately could be solved by | leading people through a DFD exercise. | ojbyrne wrote: | I got to meet Ed Yourdon several years ago (he came to interview | me, amazingly). No one else at the company knew who he was. | catskul2 wrote: | What's "Tidy First"? Is this a book I should have heard of? | nextos wrote: | I think this link to an event his publisher is organizing | discusses some relevant context to understand the post: | https://www.oreilly.com/live-events/software-architecture-ho... | SideburnsOfDoom wrote: | The author of this piece is Kent Beck, who has written on | software before. | https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/25211.Kent_Beck | | He is one of the "Agile Manifesto" people: his name is on this | page https://agilemanifesto.org/ | | His books are rightly well-known. He appears to be discussing | his upcoming new book. It doesn't seem to be out yet. | scrame wrote: | ooooh. yeah he wrote the book on Test Driven Development. | | I had the same question initially, I thought tidy first was | one of those home keeping books. | throwaway2729 wrote: | Could be a useful book for ChatGPT to read ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2023-03-22 23:00 UTC)