[HN Gopher] A visual book recommender ___________________________________________________________________ A visual book recommender Author : squidhunter Score : 321 points Date : 2023-04-27 11:40 UTC (11 hours ago) (HTM) web link (nathanrooy.github.io) (TXT) w3m dump (nathanrooy.github.io) | FreeHugs wrote: | Reminds me of https://www.literature-map.com | | Which is a map of all authors in the world sorted by overlap in | readership. I found some of my favorite writers by browsing it. | | I wonder which approach is better suited to find something that | is spot on to my interests. | | When I think of my favorite books, they usually are the most | popular books of their authors. | | Are there any counterexamples, where an author wrote a book that | is more profound than their biggest hit but got overlooked for | some reason? | Tyr42 wrote: | I wish it was easier to see some of their books, or even copy | and search the author from each page. | lkbm wrote: | Oh man, Literature Map looks really great for finding recs. | | That said, I do think book-level might be much more valuable. | My first thought for this was _Night in the Lonesome October_ | by Roger Zelazny. I haven 't read anything else by him yet | because my brother informs me his other stuff is entirely | different. Looking at Goodreads, I think that qualifies as far | from his biggest hit. Is it "more profound?"? Doubtful, but | seems likely that you shouldn't group it with his others. I | want recommendations based on the book I like, not the author I | mostly might-not. | | A better example might be how Stephenie Meyer wrote the | _extremely_ popular Twilight books, and also _The Host_ which | is much less well-known, and better in many respects. Probably | qualifies as more profound, too--it 's told from the | perspective of a parasitic alien. Picture the Yeerks from | Animorphs if you read those.) | Zufriedenheit wrote: | Impressive Tool. I would love to have the same for movies. | stared wrote: | For post-t-SNE processing to get non-overlapping items, see also: | https://github.com/Quasimondo/RasterFairy | | I also used more crude algorithms that sort by X, group elements | in buckets, and within each, sort by Y. Then we get a grid of | elements. The result is less high-quality than with iterative | algorithms (and depends on if we sort by X or Y first), but it is | hard to beat its simplicity. | igaloly wrote: | Nice! Is there a github repo? | vrglvrglvrgl wrote: | [dead] | eshnil wrote: | > Only include reviews which came from users who had at least 10 | reviews. | | Not sure if that's a good idea. It shrinks the set of genuine | readers and overweights the set of professional spammers. | mxfh wrote: | similiar t-SNE visualisation, just for papers: | | https://static.nomic.ai/pubmed.html | | running on their deepscatter visualization engine: | | https://github.com/nomic-ai/deepscatter | | that keeps things dynamic for rendering | jvanderbot wrote: | Id love to have https://same.energy for book contents. | etra0 wrote: | woah, didn't know about this site! it is super cool! | | It feels like what Pinterest would be without the annoying | bits. | jvanderbot wrote: | Be careful, it'll become your defacto image search, and then | you'll be really disappointed when you realize it hasn't been | updated in ages | internetter wrote: | This is awesome. I only wish the author haden't waited years | after scrapping! Many books I've loved have been released in the | past couple years | paweladamczuk wrote: | This is really cool! | | I wish the accompanying article was longer. I can't fully grasp | how it was done because I don't know enough about the concepts | mentioned. | aroc wrote: | This is great. I think visual tools like this are under utilized. | They're fun to use and can often reveal interesting insights. | CSMastermind wrote: | I'm surprised there are enough books published under the category | of "Reverse-harem" to make it its own category along with things | like "Horror", "Fantasy", "Business", etc. | motoboi wrote: | Really interesting that my favorite sci-fi book, Pandora's Star | is in the middle of a void in the center of a large sci-fi | cluster. | | It explains why I couldn't find anything like it. | | Also very explanatory the fact the Tolkien's The Two Towers is | right by its side, because I also love that book. | | And now I'm already downloading the other "outliers" close to | Pandora's Star. | nycdatasci wrote: | Cool visualization, but the model needs work. The closest book to | "Harry Potter and The Chamber of Secrets" is "The Victorian | Lady's Guide to Sex, Marriage, and Manners". | rossdavidh wrote: | Hypothesis: the sort of person who reads "The Victorian...", is | likely to both like Harry Potter books, and also to review them | enthusiastically online. The typical HP child reader, does not | review books online. Just an hypothesis. | badcppdev wrote: | I have a theory (after having searched for The Diamond Age) | that certain very popular books are ironically not going to be | close to similar books because they appear on so many varied | reading lists. | | There's probably a graph theory phenomena that describes what | I'm thinking. | twosdai wrote: | Yeah basically what I think you're saying is that in a | weighted graph, if there are edge weights which are orders of | magnitude larger then the average it throws off certain | models. Like nearest neighbor. | | Basically just prune the top and bottom %1 of weighted edges | to get an appropriate average. Would be my guess for a fix. | bwb wrote: | Yep this is 100% true (i run shepherd.com). | | Within our data books like lord of the rings and harry potter | are nearly impossible to map for "books like" because they | are connected to so many other things. I am working now to | fine tune our model, but it has been an interesting | challenge. | narcraft wrote: | Sounds about right to me! | gnewton77 wrote: | The visualizations remind me of those in a paper I co-authored a | while ago (2009) visualizing ~2400 scientific journal / ~5.7M | full-text articles: "Semantic Journal Mapping for Search | Visualization in a Large Scale Article Digital Library" | https://nrc-publications.canada.ca/eng/view/accepted/?id=63e... | mhb wrote: | I also like https://shepherd.com/. One of its interesting | features is that authors list their five favorite books and say | why they like them. | cainxinth wrote: | Lol, I tried it out and put in one of my favorite books, | "Liar's Poker" by Michael Lewis and it suggested me a list of | "The best novels to help you understand the rich and | dysfunctional." | | Spot on! Bookmarked! | pedrosbmartins wrote: | Which reminds me of https://fivebooks.com/, where people from a | particular field are asked their top five book recommendations | for a given theme. The interview format is great, and I've | picked up a few recommended books along the way. | scotty79 wrote: | > The Best Apocalyptic Fiction, recommended by Elliot | Ackerman | | > 1. The King James Bible | bwb wrote: | Thanks for the nice mention :) | | I am about a week away from launching genre pages, age pages, | and filters for all those things. So on the hard-science- | fiction page, you can filter to see books in a variety of fun | ways and keep following your curiosity: | | Image showing how it works: | https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_pr... | | Hit me up at ben@shepherd.com if you want to try the early | preview, just tell me your fav genre and ill send you a link. | Rediscover wrote: | Nice article. Not what I was expecting... | | I was really hoping this would address "Visual Book" like in | hushiginoHai nonadeia, Fushigi no Umi no Nadia/The Secret of Blue | Water. The LaserDiscs used to say "Visual Book" in every episode. | | Great animated series (to me), a mix of 20,000 Leagues Under the | Sea and the Illuminati. | | Do NOT watch it with the english subs. Suffer with the Japanese, | even if You don't speak it. You don't need the junk verbal | translation, You will still get the main concepts. And Hanson's | driving is so much more manaical in Japanese. | qumpis wrote: | This looks super cool, but why not use this tool as a non-visual | tool to show similar books given a title? As far as I know there | aren't many tools for this | | Also it would be super cool if we could import out goodreads | reading lists and see them on the cluster | skuxxlife wrote: | This is super cool! I actually have been working on a new book | recommendation site (https://braincandy.com) that has a similar- | ish (but much smaller scale) visualization for book similarity. | It is really interesting how certain genres tend to be much more | insular than others and it can be a real challenge to break out | of genre boxes when making recommendations. There's so many books | out there on the edges and in-betweens that get lost when they | don't fit neatly into an existing popular genre, and those indeed | can be some of the most interesting. | thadk wrote: | Anvaka's YASIV was an extremely strong tool in this space until | Amazon discontinued the API it relied on. | | https://twitter.com/anvaka https://twitter.com/yasivcom | bwb wrote: | This is an awesome visualization, I am so impressed :). I've been | working on (shepherd.com) with a similar goal to try to bring in | human groupings to try to determine book connections via the many | angles humans bring to the table. And more serendipity like | wandering a local bookstore. I really love how you have done | this. | | Dropping you an email in a few hours :) | archydeb wrote: | Love this. Bought a couple of books similar to "Midnight's | Children' - author should definitely think about adding affiliate | links! | tpttt wrote: | Made an account just to comment on this. Look incredible. | scotty79 wrote: | Funny that most remote and isolated clusters ended up being m-m- | romance and ... manga. | brubsby wrote: | The gang of four design patterns book being two away from a MAGA | book is funny. | jasonshen wrote: | Did I miss how we are supposed to get recommendations from what | OP built? | _dwt wrote: | Find something on the map that you know you like. Now look | around it to see similar (i.e. if you like this, you're likely | to like that) books. | camjohnson26 wrote: | Kind of hacky but I built something similar to apply the page | rank algorithm to the authors referenced between books of various | topics, here's the result for science: | | https://camjohnson26.github.io/author-graph/science/ | | https://github.com/CamJohnson26/author-graph | | Clearly needs a lot of data clean up but still was very helpful | for discovering important scientists and their approximate | relative impact | butterNaN wrote: | Something's wrong here. I was very excited to explore this, until | I searched for "Getting Things Done" by David Allen. A nearby | book - "Crippled America: How to Make America Great Again" by | Donald J. Trump. | WaitWaitWha wrote: | Have you presented this to LibraryThing? ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2023-04-27 23:00 UTC)