[HN Gopher] Black currants were banned in the USA (2017) ___________________________________________________________________ Black currants were banned in the USA (2017) Author : thunderbong Score : 112 points Date : 2023-09-12 06:55 UTC (16 hours ago) (HTM) web link (foodtolive.com) (TXT) w3m dump (foodtolive.com) | alexwasserman wrote: | Harvested raw berries in general don't travel well, and so there | are plenty of instances of berries existing in specific | countries. They need processing into something like jam to | travel. You don't miss what you've never heard of. | | As a Brit in the US losing currents is a shame, and an | interesting reason, but there others we get in the US that are | much rarer at home. | | For example several here aren't found in the UK (or used to be | hard to find): https://gizmodo.com/the-18-tastiest-berries-that- | grow-wild-i... | kwhitefoot wrote: | > raw berries in general don't travel well, | | A quick search for baer (berries) on the website of the biggest | online grocer here in Norway shows: blueberries from Poland, | Italy, and Spain, raspberries from Poland and Portugal, | blackberries from Belgium and Netherlands, redcurrants from | Norway. Perhaps they only travel well inside EFTA. | bombela wrote: | You find those modern thick skinned fat blueberries | everywhere it seems. But the more delicate berries not so | much. | | Blackcurrant (Cassis) and redcurrant (Groseille) taste quite | different, they are nice sprinkled atop fraisier cake for | example. | | One of my favorite little berry is the Myrtille. They are | tiny little balls, dark purple all the way through, and | lovely when cooked on a tart crust. Trader Joe has a frozen | berry tart from France that includes it. Yummy! | mytailorisrich wrote: | 'Myrtille' is blueberry. The thing is that there are | several cultivars and species, so it can be difficult to | know which one. | | You probably mean the 'European blueberry', _Vaccinium | myrtillus_. | bombela wrote: | "Vaccinium myrtillus" literally means the "common | Myrtille". Which is not blue and doesn't taste like a | blueberry. I understand that blueberry is the common | North American English word for Bleuet an and Myrtilles. | While it's the other way around in France. | | Blueberies are called Bleuet in Canadian French. And in | France today they are sold with the same two names on the | packaging (blueberies, bleuet), but often people will | call them myrtille anyways! A point of contention for me | as I am alwahs sad to hear Myrtille and be served Bleuet | :) | monkpit wrote: | Google says "myrtille" is the English "bilberry", not | blueberry. | mytailorisrich wrote: | Well not so strictly. It says bilberry or blueberry | because what is exactly meant is not so black and white, | and it may also depends on your flavour of English and | French. | | For instance, @bombela says that "North American" | blueberry is 'bleuet' in Canadian French. In France, | 'bleuet' is a flower. | mrguyorama wrote: | >But the more delicate berries not so much. | | I have a mountain of experience freezing wild maine | blueberries and wild strawberries. They both freeze just | fine and can be eaten as is after thawing, a little mushy | but still clearly the proper flavor profiles. | | My grocery has an entire section of frozen berries. | | Frozen berries will travel just fine and be delicious | anywhere. Most berries don't cross significant borders | because A HUNDRED YEARS AGO they couldn't travel well, and | so local tastes diverged. Consider, gooseberries are easy | to find here in new england when they are in season, but | you still wouldn't see something like a gooseberry soda, | because that's just not that popular of a flavor. | dylan604 wrote: | >Harvested raw berries in general don't travel well, | | Yes, that's why the majority of berries in the US are grown in | Mexico. The largest selection of blueberries, blackberries, and | raspberries in my local groceries are all from Mexico. There's | one specific store that has a really great produce department, | and from time to time, they will have local blueberries from a | farm in state, but that's only while they are in season. | LargoLasskhyfv wrote: | They travel and store very well if shock frozen, which enables | me to buy them all year in bags from 500g to 2000g. Spicing up | my Musli, Yoghurt, sometimes ice cream, and what not else. | LargoLasskhyfv wrote: | Btw. regarding preparation of Musli with Milk, have you ever | tried putting it in the fridge overnight? And wouldn't you | expect a soft sludge then? | | Not so if you put the frozen berries in! The low temperature | in the fridge lets the berries thaw up very slowly, turning | it all into a cool slush, which crumbles at the lightest | pressure. Can be varied by crushing/mushing the berries for | even more taste. Very pleasuring texture! | ginko wrote: | Meh, not a huge loss for Americans IMO. Blackcurrants are | probably the berry I could most easily do without. | | Redcurrants on the other hand.. | vmilner wrote: | You can still get UK blackcurrant yogurt (eg "Longley Farm") in | the same little pots I used to get from the milkman in the | mid-70s so not all is wrong with the world.... | pvaldes wrote: | Chokeberries would made an acceptable substitute. | SanchoPanda wrote: | If ever there were a food item that needed a "Chilean Sea | Bass" style marketing rebranding, its the Chokeberry. | nicolaslem wrote: | I didn't like it at first but as some grows in my garden I got | used to it. Now eating blackcurrant while working is one of the | highlights of summer for me. | scandox wrote: | Makes an amazing Jam. Surprisingly complex flavour. | tpm wrote: | And they have a naturally high content of pectin (a fibre | that is used as a thickener additive / gelling agent). | DrScientist wrote: | Yep - one of my favourite jams - that's how pretty much all | my black currents are used. | TRiG_Ireland wrote: | If you haven't had blackcurrant, seek it out. It's a distinctive | flavour, and I love it. Also, while articles on this always | highlight specifically blackcurrant, I believe that it also | applies to redcurrant (like blackcurrant but milder) and | gooseberry (like blackcurrant but tarter). | Lutger wrote: | Oh my, I don't care much for blackcurrent, but absolutely love | redcurrant and whitecurrant. The best one is a pink cultivar. | | I tell you, the pines aren't worth it. | blincoln wrote: | Agreed. It's my favourite fruit flavour. It's _very_ | distinctive, so I imagine it 's a love-it-or-hate-it taste. In | the US, there are few domestic products that incorporate | blackcurrant, but just about any European-import grocery will | likely be stocked with a wide variety. Jams, jellies, syrups, | soft drinks, instant oatmeal with freeze-dried blackcurrants, | etc. Larger liquor stores will often have (usually imported) | cassis (blackcurrant liqueur) as well. | | I'm still disappointed that Strongbow never brought their "Dark | Fruit" cider to the US. I first tasted blackcurrant by drinking | one in London about ten years ago. | adw wrote: | ... I somehow shouldn't be surprised that industrial | snakebite-and-black exists. The favourite drink of UK goths | everywhere. I can feel Andrew Eldritch sneaking up behind me. | He has a drum machine. | | (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snakebite_(drink)) | tpm wrote: | And there is also josta (or jostaberry), a hybrid of | JOhannisbeere (blackcurrant) x STAchelbeere (2 different | species of gooseberry). | goda90 wrote: | I've planted two Josta bushes that I hope will produce next | year. Haven't even tasted one yet. | helpfulContrib wrote: | Another good one of the Berries of Distinctive Flavour is The | Elderberry .. the flowers from which one can make a delightful | syrup that not only makes for a superb soda, or cocktail base, | but can be turned into a fruit-flavoured Liquor, which is .. if | you like such things .. probably one of the nicest little | schnapps you'll slurp. | | (Gotta cook 'em right though, well except the flowers, you just | harvest those before the ants do and make a delicious summer | soda for the kids ..) | skypanther wrote: | Elderberries make great jelly and pie. Unfortunately the | birds keep getting mine before they're ripe, it's hard to | find them in the wild on public land, and no one grows them | commercially around me. So I haven't had either in years. | TRiG_Ireland wrote: | The flowers, yes. I grew up on elderflower champaign. | Wonderful stuff. I have had elderberry cordial, but not | recently. Must seek it out again. | Arrath wrote: | There's also the salmonberry! | mortureb wrote: | Gooseberries are very different. Much more sour, very | firm/hard, crisp and very tannin-y. Pickled gooseberries made | in India are amazing if you're okay with it being hot. | tuukkah wrote: | Red gooseberry is somewhat less sour than the green one | though. | swores wrote: | Gooseberries don't taste anything like blackcurrant to me | (thankfully so, since I love gooseberries and don't like | blackcurrants) | SanchoPanda wrote: | Growing up outside the US, black currant was the third default | flavor of ice cream after vanilla and chocolate. Having | strawberry fill that role here still seems like a missed | opportunity for something slightly more bitter in the lineup of | your average tiny one cart ice cream vendor on a beach or | similar. | ravenstine wrote: | The "author" either recently learned English as a second language | or needs to upgrade from GPT-2. | grumblepeet wrote: | Such a coincidence. I rarely drink Ribena - which is the | concentrate made from Blackcurrants (other blackcurrant cordials | are available) - but the other day I bought a bottle. I had just | made myself a drink of it and sat down and opened Hacker News and | this is the first article I see. It's sad that that are banned | over there in the USA and I did know about the issue with pines | but the little berries are great in drinks and also for making | summer pudding. | jfrej wrote: | Oh, so there's no Ribena[1] in the US? Or is it imported? | | [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ribena | dghughes wrote: | Hit and miss for Ribena here in Canada I never even knew about | it until last year. The existence of it I mean not the | availability here. | | Here in Canada we tend to know more about UK stuff than people | in the US. We get imports the US doesn't of various products | Kinder chocolate/toy eggs for one. | OJFord wrote: | Probably (or its equivalent) 'grape' flavoured. | joncrocks wrote: | Cordial drinks aren't as much of a thing in the US anyway. | throwaway154 wrote: | I feel Ribena's so baked in to British psychology it's not | seen as a cordial. Orange, lime, and blackcurrant cordials | are cordials. | | Ribena's just Ribena. It's mixed with water almost | exclusively, lemonade at a push, but blackcurrant cordial | would be used for snakebites or rum+Guinness. Surely I'm not | alone on this? | justinclift wrote: | > blackcurrant cordial would be used for snakebites | | Of the actual snake variety, or are you meaning some kind | of drink? | dfawcus wrote: | A drink, larger and cider. | | One can have a 'snakebite and black' adding a dash of | black currant, also a 'black nasty' being a 'snakebite, | pernod and black currant'. | doloputer wrote: | In the UK, it's a 50-50 mix of larger and cider. I guess | some people mix in some cordial too. | drivers99 wrote: | Both replies mentioned "larger" (and cider) so I googled | it and it's just a typo for "lager" | vmilner wrote: | I am with you on this. | throwaway154 wrote: | To add to mixing... just the right amount of water. | Stronger or weaker for a cordial is simply stronger or | weaker. But more or less water for Ribena is a question | of _right_ or _wrong_ ; that's why it's never quite right | when going round a friend's house back in the day, or if | it is that's uncanny. | HeyLaughingBoy wrote: | Rum & Guinness sounds like an interesting combination. I | have to try it. | IntelMiner wrote: | I believe they refer to them as "Kool-Aid" drinks, despite | being prepared differently | red_trumpet wrote: | I'm not sure I understand the word "cordial" correctly, but | Ribena doesn't have alcohol. | wuiheerfoj wrote: | Cordial is a thick juicy syrup added to drinks, but is not | alcoholic itself. I think the GP means 'squash' or | 'diluting juice', which sometimes gets called cordial too | (though I associate cordial with the thicker stuff) | jfrej wrote: | It's worth noting that Ribena also comes ready made. If I | ever buy Ribena, that's what I go for. Especially the | carbonated version. | | There are alternative blackcurrant cordials for diluting | which are much cheaper and taste good. I think every | British supermarket has their own brand one. | arethuza wrote: | Also _creme de cassis_ - which is basically Ribena with | alcohol! | dinkleberg wrote: | I'm sure you can find them somewhere in the US, but it is | definitely not a usual item here. I've never encountered it and | have only heard of it from some British folk. | | I can't imagine many non-US soft drinks companies try to come | to the US and compete against Coke and Pepsi companies outside | of maybe niche stores. | alexwasserman wrote: | Basically not available outside of specialty stores, or the | occasional supermarket with an import aisle. | | Definitely not widely drunk. Nor is Robinson Orange Barley, | which is still my fav drink, despite being somewhat older than | the typical market. | | (Brit in US) | vmilner wrote: | I remember Annapolis MD used to have a store with lots of | British biscuits, Marmite, Bovril, marmalade, Ribena etc. - | an oasis to the Englishman abroad. | Tangurena2 wrote: | The nickname for them is "BritMart" and tend to be more | common in areas with large British expat communities. I | remember lots of them when I lived in Florida. | | There is a bit of difficulty getting Cadbury's chocolate | due to Hershey owning the trademark in the US. They shut | down most grey-market importers. | vmilner wrote: | Can you get other (ie non-Cadbury) brands of chocolate | that don't have the butyric acid that (I believe) makes | Hershey etc. so grim to most British palates? | masfuerte wrote: | Ribena has been ruined with artificial sweeteners. If this | tinkering actually worked I wouldn't mind but Britons continue | to get fatter. | swe_dima wrote: | Adding black currant leafs when brewing tea can add wondeful | taste! | | I'd say it's stronger and more nuanced than mint. | helpfulContrib wrote: | Here in central Europe, I have black and red variants in my | garden, from which I've been picking for my daily muesli on the | regular for years, and probably have a few bowls' worth in the | fridge, as their season is over but my collecting isn't .. they | are delightful plants, providing much in terms of vitamin C and | other things, such as sugars .. | | I think berries (and peas) are among the easier things to grow | locally, and I sure wish more people in the cities and things | did, we'd have more for the birds .. | | Of course, this story is a reason we can't just have | 'uncontrolled agriculture' but so, I'd just say let people grow | the native species of whatever they can eat and leave us all | alone, gardening is a human right .. | ofcrpls wrote: | The closest I get to experiencing Black Currants in the US has | been Black Currant Ice Cream in Indian Style Ice Cream shops and | Duerr's Black Currant Preserve in Cost Plus World Market. | mabbo wrote: | When I lived in Scotland (exchange program year in University) I | remember asking my roommates "what's blackcurrant?" And they | looked at me like I had asked what an apple was. | | We actually had to go search online and figure out why I'd never | heard of them. | Orlan wrote: | For me, it was Skittles! I traveled to the UK, bought some | Skittles, and almost spit them out (blackcurrant instead of | grape). Had to look up what it was. Still haven't tried the | real thing, only in candy form. | mattl wrote: | British food area of your local grocery store may have | Ribena, which is a blackcurrant cordial. | tj-teej wrote: | Squash! :) | oniony wrote: | I have literally never seen blackcurrant written as two words | before. Here in UK it's always a coined single word. | xbmcuser wrote: | If we are talking about unknown berries I would like to promote | phalsa it grows in India and Pakistan only available in some | cities in the month of May and June. | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grewia_asiatica | goda90 wrote: | This really should be titled "Why WERE Black Currants Banned in | the USA". They are no longer banned in the majority of states as | the article itself says. I can buy them at the farmers market in | Wisconsin when in season and my garden store sells bushes of | multiple varieties of currants. | UncleOxidant wrote: | The article says: "Therefore, some states start reversing the | federal ban on this berry" and goes on to say "Today, these | plants are successfully grown in New York, Connecticut, Oregon, | and Vermont." which would explain why I've been growing black | currants in Oregon for the last 15 years or so, I guess. | miah_ wrote: | And just across the lake here in Michigan I cannot grow without | permit, and am only allowed a few varieties that are known to | be resistant to WPBR. I may try to grow some next season, if I | can get seeds _and_ a permit. | | https://www.michigan.gov/-/media/Project/Websites/mdard/docu... | [deleted] | hillsboroughman wrote: | Awesome story. If black currants are so much richer than oranges | in Vitamin C, why didnt the long distance sailors of the Age of | Discovery, like the Portuguese going to India or the Spaniards | going to the New World, not carry them? They only carried | oranges. Puzzled. | crazygringo wrote: | Black currants don't keep fresh, the way citrus does. | | So you'd need to dry them, which loses something like 90% of | the vitamin C in the process. | | Seems like an awful lot of work when you can just haul a few | boxes of limes, which are a lot easier to harvest anyways then | tons of tiny berries. | | (Not to mention they didn't even know about vitamin C | specifically to begin with.) | lionkor wrote: | they are very difficult to store in large quantities, and | pretty much impossible to store for longer periods than a few | days | diogenes4 wrote: | [dead] | raverbashing wrote: | Probably because the ability to measure Vit C was not invented | yet, and you really need a small dose of Vit C to not get | scurvy | | (Not sure how blackcurrents keep over long distances compared | to oranges as well) | mrguyorama wrote: | The link between Scurvy and Vitamin C was not established until | the early 1900s. Before that, pretty much only experimental | evidence was able to establish what helped with scurvy, with | various things found to be useful, including certain animal | meats for arctic expeditions and sauerkraut, and lots of things | that definitely didn't cause scurvy were blamed for it, like | bad hygiene, tinned meats, alcoholism, etc. | | For the British, things were especially bad. Numerous captains | and sailors had personally demonstrated and convinced | themselves that scurvy could be prevented with fresh citrus, | but were unable to convince the "classically trained" | physicians who made Naval policy, who were still pushing things | like "you need more air in your tissue". One of captain Cook's | expeditions had good results with malt and wort preventing | scurvy, so that was official practice even as navy admirals | demanded lemons. | | The connection between citrus and Scurvy was finally proven in | an animal model in the early 1920s, before we even understood | what "Vitamins" where. | [deleted] | momirlan wrote: | or some Ribena bottles | netsharc wrote: | What an oddly written article. ChatGPT? SEO bot? High-schooler? | | These sentences don't seem to have a very strong connection with | each other: | | > Getting black currants banned has been deemed minimally | effective for disease prevention. Therefore, some states start | reversing the federal ban on this berry. However, Europe still | remains the producer of 99% of the world's black currants stock. | | "It is not so bad"? | | > Today, these plants are successfully grown in New York, | Connecticut, Oregon, and Vermont. Yet, the majority of Americans | can only enjoy processed or dried berries. It's not so bad | considering the benefits of eating dry fruits. | Mordisquitos wrote: | It's badly written, but more on the level of a bad human writer | than any AI. The connection between the three sentences in the | first example seems quite clear to me. Starting from the second | sentence: | | 1) "[...] _some states start reversing the federal ban on this | berry_ [because the ban has been deemed ineffective for disease | prevention] ". | | 2) "[Even though some US states are reversing the ban] _Europe | still remains the producer of 99% of the world's black currants | stock_ ". | | Regarding the second example, it is just an excuse to have an | internal link to another article on the same site praising | dried fruits. " _It 's not so bad_ [that Americans can only | enjoy processed or dried blackcurrants] _considering the | benefits of eating dry fruits._ ". The reasoning is quite | crappy, given that the linked article does not imply that dried | fruits are better than non-dried fruits, but it is to the level | of precision that one might expect from a filler blog on some | health-food online store. | [deleted] | sitzkrieg wrote: | the weird aff link in the middle for random berries is the | cherry on the top | NikkiA wrote: | Sounds like an ESL writer, 'It is not so bad' is a common | phrase I see written by native slavic speakers, it's probably a | direct translation of a language idiom. | OJFord wrote: | Why are we talking about it uncontracted, making it sound | weird, when the actual quote is 'it's not so bad' which | sounds perfectly fluent to me (native BrEng)? | hombre_fatal wrote: | It's definitely a common phrase but it's really poor | writing here. | OJFord wrote: | I agree, just only really because it's too | colloquial/informal/spoken for an article imo, wouldn't | be my choice. But not worth calling out, and certainly | not for not making sense or seeming like a robot or ESL | author wrote it. | pcrh wrote: | It reads like it was automatically translated from another | language. The grammar is all over the place. | nerdponx wrote: | It also answers the question directly in the first paragraph | with no fussing around, so I like it better than 99% of | articles. | radiorental wrote: | Definitely reads like AI. Short declarative statements. No | coherent narrative. | | (I see what I did there (o;) | Aulig wrote: | The publishing date of the article is 2017, so pre-ChatGPT. Of | course there were spintaxes back then, but those articles were | way worse. | | Either way, the article seems mostly fine to me. | aaron695 wrote: | > The publishing date of the article is 2017 | | I used to predate my blog posts in Wordpress by years. Why | would you use todays date? No one reads blogs in order, how | pedestrian to follow the old rules. | | You can also fool some of Googles date metadata, it's not | just the day it's first indexed. Reddit by incompetence | screws with it. | | But I've never seen a content farm do it.... yet. | | Webarchive first snapshot 8th Nov 2020 - http://web.archive.o | rg/web/20230000000000*/https://foodtoliv... | | The idea there is a pre-AI internet is not true. | | AI will go back and change the past. Not even Google/Web | Archive can record it all. Is it AI pre-dating or was it | missed on Web Archive here? (A: The Facebook comments seem | real, so missed by Web Archive, but if Facebook deletes/makes | private the data then we are back to not knowing) | jliptzin wrote: | Chatgpt wouldn't write crap like that | UncleOxidant wrote: | I've got black currant plants growing here in Oregon (the variety | is Crandall) - I've grown them for years. You can order them from | One Green World near Portland - I don't see anything on that | particular page that says they can't ship them: | https://onegreenworld.com/product-category/berries/currant/b... | HeyLaughingBoy wrote: | The leaves look a lot like raspberry leaves. | UncleOxidant wrote: | They look quite different from each other in person. | vjk800 wrote: | Pines and black currants both grow here in (Northern) Europe. How | come the fungus isn't a problem here? | bstpierre wrote: | > Some varieties of European and Asian pines have this innate | resistance because they evolved alongside the fungus. However, | American trees met this threat too late to develop a workable | defense. | masklinn wrote: | So similar to e.g. phylloxera, chestnut blight, "dutch" elm | disease, ... | timeon wrote: | Yes most European vineyards are now grafted on American | rootstock. | happymellon wrote: | As the article states, European pine has a natural resistance. | pmx wrote: | This is covered in the article. European pines evolved | alongside the fungus so they have a natural resistance to it. | Simulacra wrote: | _The US Department of Agriculture had no choice but to have black | currants banned because the plants became a vector for a disease | that threatened to annihilate all pines in America_ | DennisP wrote: | It sometimes startles me how disconnected some people are from | nature. I can't imagine all our pine trees dying off, it seems | utterly horrific. It would be devastating to biodiversity and I | would deeply miss the trees themselves. But to the author: | | > It might seem extreme, but this measure was necessary to save | the logging industry at that time. | | And later: | | > The situation has turned so serious that it threatened the | existence of US pines. As they are the main element of the | logging industry, it must have been dealt with as soon as | possible. | swyx wrote: | [flagged] | cout wrote: | I grew up (in US) thinking blackcurrant was a variety of black | tea. I had no idea until I got older that it is a berry. | | Similarly, I thought elderberry was just a silly word that Monty | Python made up to be funny. | Symbiote wrote: | I wonder if young Americans would make the association between | elder wood and elderberries, from reading Harry Potter -- the | Elder Wand is a significant object. | | Elderflowers are also used in drinks, both cordials and | liqueurs. | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sambucus | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elderflower_cordial | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St-Germain_(liqueur) | mahidol wrote: | Blackcurrants are no longer banned in the United States. | systems_glitch wrote: | Huh, we were wondering aloud at the farm the other day why | they're basically unknown in the USA anymore. TIL. | delfinom wrote: | My parents were growing it illegally for years in the US (now its | legal in NY) and they got the shoots from their relatives in | Jersey who have been quietly farming it for a few decades (going | back to the 1950s) for the Eastern European community in the | region. | | It wasn't really banned too well.... ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2023-09-12 23:01 UTC)