[HN Gopher] Where Johnny Cash came from ___________________________________________________________________ Where Johnny Cash came from Author : tintinnabula Score : 75 points Date : 2023-12-16 17:14 UTC (1 days ago) (HTM) web link (www.neh.gov) (TXT) w3m dump (www.neh.gov) | AlbertCory wrote: | With love & respect to the Man in Black: | | I keep a close watch on this heart of mine | | I keep my eyes wide open all the time | | I hold my pants up with a piece of twine | | If you are mine, I'll pull the twine. | quantum_state wrote: | Very much indeed! | User23 wrote: | I highly recommend his autobiography. It gives some detail on his | time growing up picking cotton, among many other interesting | anecdotes. | lotsOstuf wrote: | Just seconding this as it was one of the most compelling | biographical books I've ever read. I binged it during a holiday | shopping trip to the mall 20-ish years ago. Couldn't put it | down, just followed along with the group as they went from | store to store with my face in a book. | | We sure don't live life like that anymore. | ronnier wrote: | > The Man in Black grew up in Dyess, Arkansas, in a community of | poor farmers working government land. | | Similar. I grew up in Arkansas for 6 years of my childhood | working on a turkey farm until I was 11~. Hard work ,7 days a | week for 6 years working with turkeys and cattle. Something is | lost today by most kids being removed from hard work, I think. | Defiantly brings a different perspective going from that to | working in the largest tech companies | ttymck wrote: | Can you elaborate on what is lost? What is the difference in | perspective? | DaveSchmindel wrote: | I can, from the other side of life. | | I was raised in middle-class suburbia, in the North East U.S. | My family wasn't wealthy, but wasn't hurting either. I did | well in school, but didn't have to try very hard to maintain | grades in Advanced Placement classes. Outside of school, I | worked easy lawn-care gigs with my neighbor and we made | decent cash with 20-30 hours of work per week. | | It afforded me a life of coasting, leisure, and throwing away | my downtime. | | I am nearing 30 years old and just realizing that I'd | consider my behavior to be bad habits I need to kick. I want | to work harder, and I have to teach myself what that means. | mcculley wrote: | I would hope that there is some optimal balance. A lot of | my childhood was spent doing manual labor for money. A lot | of that was wasted opportunity to learn more and get | experience that would have benefited me financially later | on. | ronnier wrote: | What was lost was hard work ethic and the perspective of how | good life is now, respect for others, and we've gained some | arrogance from never having to suffer. | | I had an odd life, I lived in the projects as a child until I | was sent to my grandfathers farm for 6~ years, and after | that, back to the violent city I had originally lived in. I | was at a huge disadvantage compared to my peers but from the | hard word I was subjected to in those 6 years (work ethic it | taught me), pure luck of getting into computer science | (thanks to John Carmack via doom/quake), and meeting the | right people, I was able to work much harder than those | around me and rise up quickly through the worlds biggest tech | companies, make a ton of money to the point where I was able | to retire at 40 (though I didn't and still work). | | To answer your question, in my view, that's what was lost -- | a connection to brutal hard work that keeps the world moving | forward. | jdewerd wrote: | My parents infected me with the same disease -- an intense | conviction in the nobility and virtue of individual hard | work -- and it led me to a terrible place, the physical | sciences, where I received a harsh lesson in the nature of | capitalism. It's not about creating value, it's about | capturing value. In a low-leverage situation, when everyone | works hard you are simply paid less. Surplus is captured | through ownership and ownership is concentrated at the top. | In low-leverage jobs, this system transforms hard work from | a noble individual value to a collective curse. | | The explosive growth of the software industry over the last | few decades has led to an abnormal situation where regular | employees have enough leverage to capture a substantial | fraction of their surplus. Most people are not so lucky. | For most people, the system looks more like: | You load sixteen tons, what do you get? Another day | older and deeper in debt Saint Peter don't you call | me, 'cause I can't go I owe my soul to the company | store | | and having experienced work environments that were low | leverage through no fault of the employees, I understand | this, I respect this, and I did not forget it when I left | for software, where we have it much easier not because we | work harder but because we are in a growth industry. | | I too found it easy to climb. I too enjoy the "free" money | from real estate investments and a stock portfolio. But I | know where it comes from. I do not pound my throne and | launch spittle as I demand for those beneath me to work | harder for my benefit. | | You shouldn't either. | diob wrote: | Thank god, I'm also well off and work hard. But I know | plenty who work hard and aren't. Luck is a big factor. | jackfoxy wrote: | Worked my way through college on semester breaks on farms | in Oregon and Germany. I can totally relate. The | camaraderie of showing up at the shop with the other hands | on a frigid morning, working until sunset, sometimes | longer. Watching crops grow. Harvesting. It also helps that | I grew up in the last great generation of feral children. | We were outdoors all the time. Rain or shine. I get | depressed if I'm not outdoors enough to this day. Outdoor | living (as well as hard work) seems lost on so many people | today. | itronitron wrote: | I don't think it's hard work that has been lost but rather | a connection to 'direct results' which are notably lacking | from a lot of jobs. | hereonout2 wrote: | It sounds like your saying from the age of 5-11 years old you | worked 7 days a week as a farm hand. | | Could you say more about what era this was and how many how's a | day? | ronnier wrote: | Yup, 7 days a week with my grandfather. I'm 44 now, he's 96 | and still going strong but without the farm since he got too | old to run it and simply retired. | | But yeah, 7 days a week I'd tend to the turkeys, cattle, dig | potatoes, pick tomatoes (we grew a lot of vegetables) , cut | hay, rake hay, fluff hay, etc. Being 7 years old on a tractor | cutting hay all day was extremely fun. We'd also make the | square bales of hay and being 7 or 8, I wasn't strong enough | to lift them, so I'd drive the truck with a trailer and my | grandfather would be behind loading the square bales. We'd do | this for hours in the heat (I had the easy part), he had pure | raw strength. We had almost 200 acres of land. | hereonout2 wrote: | Thanks, sounds different and would certainly instill a | certain work ethic. | | I'm similar age and have been in paid employment since the | age of 13, a lot of different things through farming, | manufacturing, retail and catering before I started in | tech. | | I was always grateful for the work ethic but also important | was the experience of being the most lowly employee being | made to do the grunt work. I think that gave me the | confidence to get on with the job without complaint or too | much assistance, I feel that especially helped me progress | early on in my tech career. | | Still, I'm not sure how I'd feel about my own kids working | so young. And in all honesty, don't really think those | opportunities would be there for them now anyway. | ekianjo wrote: | > And in all honesty, don't really think those | opportunities would be there for them now anyway. | | Modern governments actively endure that working before 18 | is like chilf exploitation or something which is | ridiculous as you learn much more by doing than by | watching videos or reading books | CapitalistCartr wrote: | My mom grew up in Appalachia, in the same time as Johnny Cash, | dirt farmers in a "holler". No indoor electric, plumbing, or | phone. Wood stove cooking and heat. A spring house for water. | Baths every Saturday night. Their livelihood was completely | dependant on growing food and lumber. I find it unimaginable. | Technically I know how it worked, but it's completely alien. In | one generation. | itronitron wrote: | My father had a similar childhood. Grew up in a 3 bedroom | cabin that his father built, shared a bedroom with his 3 | brothers, and spent a lot of his childhood running around the | woods with a rifle and trapping animals to sell furs. Despite | having a very successful career, he refers to this time in | his life as 'when we were wealthy'. | freedomben wrote: | Same, my grandfather grew up the same way. Horses were their | way of life, and the house was located in a spot where | electricity and other utilities would never make it, and | paving a road was unfeasible. The house was essentially | abandoned once the kids were raised and the parents wanted to | nice | dvngnt_ wrote: | the children yearn for the mines | itronitron wrote: | hence the popularity of minecraft? | bsder wrote: | > Something is lost today by most kids being removed from hard | work, I think. | | I'm not sure I agree. | | The work was hard _and you didn 't get anywhere_. | | You worked the farm, the mill, the mine, etc. just like your | father did and his father did. You didn't get rich. You didn't | even get comfortable. You were still poor, and your children | were going to remain poor. | | The window where labor unions made mill, mine, and factory jobs | something livable was quite short--1960 to 1980, roughly. | | Yeah, shitty, excruciating work was a good way to beat you kid | over the head with "go find _ANYTHING_ else to do as a career. | " Worked for my dad. Worked for Joe Namath's dad. etc. | | Not sure I count that as anything "being lost" though. | chrisco255 wrote: | > The window where labor unions made mill, mine, and factory | jobs something livable was quite short--1960 to 1980, | roughly. | | I'm sorry, what? What do you think 2023 mills, mines, and | factories look like in the United States? | | Here's a tour of a wheat mill: | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYP6AnNQjNo | | Here's a modern coal mine: | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vwo3slH1wsk | | And here's a modern factory: | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mr9kK0_7x08 | briHass wrote: | If nothing else, it should humble you and make you appreciate | how lucky 'you' are now to have found and be good at one of | few remaining white-collar jobs that pay well. That list of | high paying jobs is shrinking rapidly, and it's pretty | reasonable to think that in 20 years, software engineers are | going to be the miners/mill-workers of the previous | generation. | 6stringmerc wrote: | All that lovely prose and wonderful history and not a single | reference to the well known conditions of working poor musicians | who turned to stimulants like speed and cocaine to make it from | gig to gig rain or shine or you don't get paid. | | There is an even darker undercurrent from where Johnny Cash came | from - it's something I've been discussing often in 2023 with | other musicians - the US tries to kill us. It makes this the | worst and most dangerous job possible and yes that also means | Cops harass us. Because of that??? | | Our music is raw and real - Guns N Roses, Nirvana, Run the Jewels | - the biggest export is our culture of rebellion that won't quit. | You can take credit for the good stuff yeah put a song on the | playlist at the Bar in your Carhart stuff... | | Johnny Cash, Waylon, Willie, and the ongoing legacy of "I will do | this no matter what" and being exploited is no joke. I'm proud of | the Hendrix family. I'm sad to see this, this big wall of text, | just gloss over how Johnny Cash got out of where he came from. He | didn't do it with thoughts and prayers y'all. | tshirthoodie wrote: | > _the ongoing legacy of "I will do this no matter what" and | being exploited_ | | If you're willing to do it no matter what, you're begging to be | exploited. That's the entire history of the labor movement in a | sentence. | schneems wrote: | > you're begging to be exploited | | A "yes, and" pivot: you're going to be exploited, you | _should_ be begging for a union. | | I've been musing on what an open source (users/creators) | union would look like. The best of us write software in this | "no matter what" category. How could we collectively support | them while they support us and we support each other? | zakary wrote: | If you're only sellable skill is making music, and you have | to put food on the table, that isn't begging to be exploited; | it's grit | bequanna wrote: | It simply seems like supply and demand to me. | | There many, many people trying to be successful in arts and | entertainment. | | Why would someone overpay for something that may be seen as | a commodity because of the overwhelming supply? | jzb wrote: | Vulnerable. Not begging, vulnerable. This is prime blaming | the victim. People who have an innate drive to make music or | art are vulnerable to be exploited, but place the blame where | it belongs: on those who would exploit them. | | Most humans enjoy music and art. We want it to exist. It | makes life better. We shouldn't be looking down on those who | want to supply it. | bequanna wrote: | > People who have an innate drive to make music or art are | vulnerable to be exploited, but place the blame where it | belongs: on those who would exploit them. | | I don't understand this. | | Why are only people who make music or art special in this | regard? | | If I am someone who enjoys Software Engineering, am I also | ripe to be exploited? If not, please explain. | roflyear wrote: | > It makes this the worst and most dangerous job possible | | Then why do it? You know the answer to this, just like I do. | chrisco255 wrote: | > He didn't do it with thoughts and prayers y'all. | | Johnny Cash would probably argue otherwise, given his beliefs | and discography. | | Here is him singing "The Junkie's Prayer": | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OkDJt5GutqA | epiphanitus wrote: | Take us on the road with you. What's it like? | confd wrote: | > It makes this the worst and most dangerous job possible | | I'm sure the Wichita Lineman would disagree. | swader999 wrote: | I grew up with all those too but still found a lot of time for | Johnny Cash. Saw him live once too in a small venue. ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2023-12-17 23:00 UTC)