[HN Gopher] What's an obelisk, anyway? ___________________________________________________________________ What's an obelisk, anyway? Author : herodotus Score : 101 points Date : 2024-02-18 16:29 UTC (6 hours ago) (HTM) web link (www.science.org) (TXT) w3m dump (www.science.org) | bookofjoe wrote: | I honestly thought this was going to be a discussion of the | Washington Monument. | wkat4242 wrote: | It's a big French native from a tribe opposing the rule of Julius | Caesar of course | ithkuil wrote: | Celt. Franks came later from germany | bigmattystyles wrote: | Are Gaul and Celt the same? In any case, he also fell in the | magic potion when he was a kid. Loves wild boars. | sigzero wrote: | Yes - The Celts were the people spreading throughout Europe | during the late Bronze Age and the Iron Age. They spoke the | Celtic language and shared cultural and religious practices | and beliefs. The Gauls were the Celtic tribes that settled | in what the Romans called Gaul. | wkat4242 wrote: | I did not know that, thanks. And cool! | | That explains why they had some typical celtic things | like druids. | DylanSp wrote: | Sorta kinda; "Celt"/"Celtic" is a broad term that's been | applied to a lot of different peoples, languages, and | cultures. The history blog ACOUP has a good post on it [1]; | it's long, but only the first part is really relevant to | what you're asking (up through the table comparing | different regions). | | [1] https://acoup.blog/2023/05/12/collections-who-were-the- | celts... | ithkuil wrote: | The etymology of the word "gaul" is fascinating. | | It's an exonym, i.e. it's not how the celts living in | Gaul would call themselves. | | There are two origins of the word that are likely to cave | coexisted in a "convergent etymology" | | 1. The name of an ancient Celtic tribe (one of many) | sounded like "galatai" to ancient Greeks and it sounded | about right because of the the white skin (either fair | skin or white paint). So in this case it ultimately stems | from a Celtic word. | | 2. The old Germanic word "walhaz" meant something like | "foreign" or "Roman". That originated many names for | former roman territories when Germanic people encountered | them. (Similar word for Slavic). That left a lot of names | like "Wales/welch", "Wallachia", "vlachi". This word went | through a sound change when adopted in romance languages | similar to how other words like "werra" - > | "g(u)err(a|e)", "Ward" - "g(u)ard" ... | | The regular sound changes in languages betray the | coexistence of these two etymologies at different times | and phases of the Evolution of the romance languages and | french in particular. | | The latin "g" sound evolved into "j" (gamba -> jambe) so | one our think that if the word "Gallia" was available | from the latin substrate it would have transformed into | "Jallia" and in fact it was! As attested by place names | like La Jaille-Yvon and Saint-Mars-la-Jaille. | | This reveals how the modern french name "gaule" likely | stems from the second etymology (the German origin). | | That said, languages are rarely let evolve naturally. | There is plenty of people who studied languages and kept | latin alive for centuries and it's also quite possible | that the version with the "g" sound has been also kept | reinforced because of the relationship with the classic | texts (Gallia est omnis divisa in partes tres) | wkat4242 wrote: | OMG don't tell the French they have German heritage. You will | not survive it. | tharkun__ wrote: | Or the Germans that their ancestors also settled in the | Frankenreich and they should of course be on good terms | with them! | | Or Franken (i.e. parts of Bavaria) that they're Bavarian. | | Or English that many of them are part French nowadays | (think Normans). | | Or ... | | History is messy. People are messy. Mostly vengefully so | unfortunately. This is why we can't have nice things. | shermantanktop wrote: | The people most likely to threaten your borders are also | the people you're most likely to share culture and genes | with. So minor differences in language, culture, and | geography become important signs of essential distinction | from your historical enemy. | | Freud called this the "narcissism of small differences" ( | https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissism_of_small_diffe | ren...). | samatman wrote: | The French are largely of Celtic descent, with some Frankish | admixture in some regions, in others, practically none. | Except in Gascony and the Pyrenees where they're Basque in | descent, Gascon being of the same etymology as Basque. | | People of Frankish descent are mainly found in the | Rhinelands, which does include a bit of France, but is mostly | located in modern Germany. | | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franks | ithkuil wrote: | Yes, genetically and linguistically the Germanic rulers | haven't tipped the scale to their side in France. | | But OTOH the name "France" is unequivocally Frankish | (Germanic) and thus not something that Obelix, a Gaul from | ~2070 years, ago would identify with. | mgaunard wrote: | That's Obelix. | | An obelisk is a type of pillar from Ancient Egypt. | wkat4242 wrote: | I know. I was joking of course :) | | But Asterix and Obelix are of course named after asterisks | and obelisks. It's part of the joke. | yumraj wrote: | It makes me sad that you had to explain it. :( | southernplaces7 wrote: | An example of how some people on this site are about as rigid | as obelisks (lowercase) when it comes to understanding even | very obvious jokes... | amarant wrote: | Or *friend, to put it briefly. | crashmat wrote: | No, that's obelix. Obelisk is is a type of storage composed of | a thin and flexible disk of a magnetic storage medium in a | square plastic enclosure. | AlphaWeaver wrote: | No, that's a floppy disk. An obelisk is a mythological snake | that will turn you to stone if you look at it. | Andrex wrote: | It's an ancient Egyptian deity whose essence was trapped inside | a trading card, but not before driving the card's initial | artist to suicide[0]. | | https://youtu.be/-nab64DWEh8?t=268 | WirelessGigabit wrote: | Growing up in another language than English an Obelisk was the | NOD's main defensive structure. | lstodd wrote: | No, it's Gallente freighter from Eve Online. | ikari_pl wrote: | comparably desirable to a Tesla coil | frozenport wrote: | Where are the TEM images of the proposed structures? | NobleLie wrote: | Considering it's predicted shape is that of obelisk ("rod") one | is left to imagine that this finding has only metagenomics | behind it. | benjamin-lee wrote: | Not the author of this paper but am current PhD student focused | on viroid discovery. There's no TEM but there are good methods | such as RNAfold [0] for predicting their structures. In the | case of rod-shaped RNAs, the prediction methods are quite good | since it basically comes down to looking for substrings of | reverse complement sequences within the circular RNA. | | [0]: http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1748-7188-6-26 | frozenport wrote: | The actual item is required to understand where it occurs and | if these sequences have other explanations. | ProjectArcturis wrote: | If this turns out to be true, it's one of the most exciting basic | biology findings in years. To discover a new type of organism, | which seems to infect humans, or at least infects things that | infect humans -- it's just amazing. How many mysterious diseases | are caused by these things? | chasil wrote: | If you like that, then you will love gypsy transposons. | | https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LTR_retrotransposon ___________________________________________________________________ (page generated 2024-02-18 23:00 UTC)